News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898053
Total Topics: 90354
Most Online Today: 4569
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 2995
Total: 2995
Google

Roman Catholic Church Would Suppress Religious Freedom

Started by mistergus, Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 20:54:59

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mistergus

I have come into possession of a tract by Batsell Barrett Baxter (a huge figure among churches of Christ) regarding the Roman Catholic Church.  Brother Baxter lays out in this tract that if the Roman Catholic Church were ever to become a majority in this country, the rest of us would lose our religious freedom.  This comes not from accusations from non-Catholics, but from statements from authorities within the Catholic Church.

From this tract...


Francis J. Connell, Associate Professor of Moral Theology at the Catholic University of America, writing in the American Ecclesiastical Review, January 1946, on "Preserving the Faith Inviolate," said: "We believe that the rulers of a Catholic country have the right to restrict the activities of those who would lead the people away from their alligience to the Catholic Church...They possess the right to prevent propaganda against the Church."  The same author, in his book "Freedom of Worship, the Catholic Position", added: "In a country that is distinctly Catholic...the civil rulers can consider themselves justified in restricting and preventing denominational activities hostile to the [Roman] Catholic religion."

"A Dangerous Doctrine" - Batsell Barrett Baxter - -page 2



Believe me, this is the tip of the iceberg.  Bro. Baxter has a lot more to say in this tract.

We've already seen this in the world.  Everywhere the Roman Catholioc Church is dominate, other faiths are persecuted, even forbidden.  This is not an accident.  This is in keeping with the policies of the Vatican.

Remember, the Roman Catholic Church is not simply a religion.  It is a state.  And it is determined to achieve world domination.

The last time the Roman Catholic Church had world domination, we call it the "Dark Ages".  They suppressed  knowledge and science, burned heretics at the stake, denounced Galileo, etc..

It could happen again.

I am in the process of copying this tract word for word.  I give this board my word:  I will not start another thread until I have posted this tract, in its entirity.

Robert G


broach972

I cannot believe what I am reading here.  Gus, is this really a debate you want.  How dare you accuse the Roman Catholic Church of this while the Religious Right in this country, made up mostly of Evangelical Protestants, are chipping away at our freedoms on a daily basis.  What hypocrisy!!!

This is just another example of the hostility that many on this board have shown towards Catholicism.  While I do not expect many here to agree with Catholic dotrines or to be "pro-Catholic," every Catholic on this board has shown decency, graciousness, and a desire to present Catholicism in its true form.  We welcome open debate and discussion but this opening post is pure junk.  As a history teacher, I can tell you that Gus is way off on the historical merits of this tract.  What a joke!!

yogi bear

OH NO here we go again. Why don't we just talk about Jesus and what he has done for us and commissioned us to do with him.

broach972

Quote from: bvaug on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 21:21:00
OH NO here we go again. Why don't we just talk about Jesus and what he has done for us and commissioned us to do with him.

Bvaug, I would agree.  I welcome civilized and constructive debate and discussion over the differences that seem to separate us.  I have no problem educating those that have a warped or misguided view of Catholicism.  However, junk like this does not add to much of the discussion.

yogi bear

I agree that this kind of junk does no good to Christ followers and am sorry we have to endure those that wish to keep this an ongoing mess. If there is any convictions to be made I would much rather them come from Gods word over what other men publish. May we let Gods word be true and may we humble ourselves to be vessels for him to use to spread his truth that it may convict our hearts and conform us to his will.

marc

Quote from: mistergus on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 20:54:59
I am in the process of copying this tract word for word.  I give this board my word:  I will not start another thread until I have posted this tract, in its entirity.

Robert G

Rule No. 4 - No "Offensive" or "Illegal" Posts, PMs, Links, or Images

4.1 You will not post, attach, use or send any posts, PMs, links, images or files:
c. that violate or promote the violation of local or international laws and regulations (including the posting of any copyright material such as songs, movies or text). All quoted articles from external sources such as news articles must not be more than 10% of the original article to be legal or else copyright is infringed. A link must be provided to all quoted material. The only exception is quotes for AP (Associated Press) articles which are limited to one sentence only or where permission by the author is granted for reproduction in full with the permission statement.

Mere Nick

It was Catholics who built the hospital I was born in (St. Joseph in Asheville) and it was Catholics who built the hospital where I had a kidney repaired when I was but a wee lad (Mercy Hospital, Charlotte).  All this time I thought it was because they cared about me.  Little did I know it was all part of a plot toward world domination. 

That must be why Catholic church attendence in Europe is so weak and their birthrates are diddly.  It's a big disinformation campaign to throw us off into thinking they aren't really out to get us.

janine

Well, sure, the Catholic Church has done its bit to suppress religion/faith that didn't fit its mold (Inquisition, anyone?  Crusades?  Toasting Joan of Arc?  Assuming all those things really happened...)

Any big group of God-botherers that hangs around long enough and gains enough Earthly power, of its own, as an organism/entity, will sooner or later do something stupid like that.

It's 'cause they're people, not 'cause they're Catholic.

marc

Yep.  What's not mentioned is that Elizabeth I killed more Catholics than her predecessor, "Bloody Mary" killed protestants.

(from memory.  If I'm wrong, let me know.)

Religion+civil authority rarely goes well, imho.

I shudder to think what would have happened if the Church of Christ had been in charge of the government when I was growing up.

Mere Nick

Quote from: janine on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 22:04:29
Well, sure, the Catholic Church has done its bit to suppress religion/faith that didn't fit its mold (Inquisition, anyone?  Crusades?  Toasting Joan of Arc?  Assuming all those things really happened...)

Any big group of God-botherers that hangs around long enough and gains enough Earthly power, of its own, as an organism/entity, will sooner or later do something stupid like that.

It's 'cause they're people, not 'cause they're Catholic.

Us sofcocer's do it, too.  Just look at some of the periodicals at how folks rip each other up and try to suppress certain folks from speaking at various places.

Mere Nick

Quote from: marc on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 22:07:35
I shudder to think what would have happened if the Church of Christ had been in charge of the government when I was growing up.

It would be far out, man!

marc


mistergus

More from Batsell Barrett Baxters's tract...


"Ryan and Boland, in the book, " Catholic Principles of Politics", on page 303, say, "With reference to the so-called 'liberties', which are so greatly coveted in these days, all must stand by the judgement of the Apostolic See, and have the same mind.  Let no man be deceived by the outward appearance of these liberties, but let each one reflect whence these have had their orgin and by what efforts  they are everywhere upheld and promoted."  Pope Leo XIII had earlier said, "It is quite unlawful to demand, to defend, or to grant unconditional freedom of thought, or speech, or writing, or of worship as if these were so many rights given by nature to man."


Did everyone get that?  "It is quite unlawful to demand...freedom of worship..."

The howlings of some here are not unexpected.  However, I am quoting from Catholic sources, not anti-Catholic sources. 

"Am I your enemy, because I tell you the truth?"

It is a truth many would rather not face, but it is still the truth.  Where the Roman Catholic Church gains control, religious freedom is suppressed.

We see it this very day, in many parts of the world.

Robert G

DCR

We can speculate "what ifs" if a church rules over a land as the governing authority.

What church wouldn't run things the way the church believes they should be run?  Not just the Roman Catholic Church, but any church?

That's why we have a secular government... and one that is prohibited from making laws that respect one religion over the other.

The scenario described would simply not be allowed to happen in our form of government.

mistergus

Quote from: marc on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 21:44:47
Rule No. 4 - No "Offensive" or "Illegal" Posts, PMs, Links, or Images

4.1 You will not post, attach, use or send any posts, PMs, links, images or files:
c. that violate or promote the violation of local or international laws and regulations (including the posting of any copyright material such as songs, movies or text). All quoted articles from external sources such as news articles must not be more than 10% of the original article to be legal or else copyright is infringed.

I appreciate this, but this tract is not copyrighted.  All are free to use this information, and to quote from it.

This tract is broken into sections...


Basic Catholic Policy...
Syllabus of Errors...
Catholic Persecution - 1960...
Other Freedoms Endangered...
Both Church and State...
Absolute Authority Rests in Rome...
A Voice Is Raised...
The Doctrine of Mental Reservation...
Catholic Power Is Growing...
Conclusion...
Let Us Pray...


Robert G

CSloan

Quote from: mistergus on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 20:54:59The last time the Roman Catholic Church had world domination, we call it the "Dark Ages".  They suppressed  knowledge and science, burned heretics at the stake, denounced Galileo, etc..

Wasn't William Tyndale burned at the stake for translating the bible into the vernacular?

broach972

Mistergus, I think that I have heard these things before...let me see...I almost have it...It's coming to me...THAT'S IT!!...didn't we hear the same things during the Presidential election of 1960 in this country?  They were just as ludicrous then as they are now.

Mistergus, if you are not sure what I am talking about, you might want to study the 1960 U.S. Presidential election.

mistergus

Quote from: DCR on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 22:48:45
The scenario described would simply not be allowed to happen in our form of government.

It wouldn't?  More from Batsell Barrett Baxters' tract...


In the United States, it is no longer possible for a non-Catholic to be elected Mayor of the city of Boston, or of the city of New York, or of the city of Chicago.  Already because of congressional action  - spearheaded by members of the Roman Catholic Church  -  more than thirty million dollars of public funds have been channeled into providing services for Catholic parochial schools in various sections of the nation.  Catholic hospitals have already taken the lion's share of federal funds, made available to the construction of hospitals.


Any other religious group in America get this kind of treatment?

Don't get mad at me for making this information available.  Get mad that it's true.

Lot's more to come...I'll save the rest for when I post the entire tract.

Robert G

broach972

Quote from: marc on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 22:07:35
Yep.  What's not mentioned is that Elizabeth I killed more Catholics than her predecessor, "Bloody Mary" killed protestants.

(from memory.  If I'm wrong, let me know.)

Religion+civil authority rarely goes well, imho.

I shudder to think what would have happened if the Church of Christ had been in charge of the government when I was growing up.

You had a good history teacher Marc.  You are correct.  There is no doubt that man has done some outrageous and misguided actions in the name of God--both Protestant and Catholic alike.  History is full of different periods in which values and motivations were quite different from today.  Remember, at one time, it was perfectly normal to buy and maintain slaves in the South.  No one dared question it.  Be careful when you throw stones because you just might find yourself living in a glass house as well.

broach972

Quote from: mistergus on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 23:07:49
In the United States, it is no longer possible for a non-Catholic to be elected Mayor of the city of Boston, or of the city of New York, or of the city of Chicago.  Already because of congressional action  - spearheaded by members of the Roman Catholic Church  -  more than thirty million dollars of public funds have been channeled into providing services for Catholic parochial schools in various sections of the nation.  Catholic hospitals have already taken the lion's share of federal funds, made available to the construction of hospitals.

Let's just take a look at this particular statement, shall we.

Absolutely ridiculous.  Non-catholics are not barred from running from public office in any of these cities.  Please cite the statute.

As far as public money being given to parochial schools run by Catholic Churches...  There is a big push for vouchers in this country (which I oppose and I am Catholic).  These vouchers would be available to any parent wanting to send their child to a private school, whether it be Catholic or non-Catholic affiliated.  Ironically, many Protestant parents send their children to Catholic private schools (I know some myself).

As far as the hospitals...Not sure what you are talking about here.  If these hospitals are receiving grant money, then public funds are accessible to anyone, regardless of religious affiliation.

Again, you are citing these statements without proof or basis.

CSloan

Quote from: broach972 on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 23:18:49
Quote from: mistergus on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 23:07:49
In the United States, it is no longer possible for a non-Catholic to be elected Mayor of the city of Boston, or of the city of New York, or of the city of Chicago.  Already because of congressional action  - spearheaded by members of the Roman Catholic Church  -  more than thirty million dollars of public funds have been channeled into providing services for Catholic parochial schools in various sections of the nation.  Catholic hospitals have already taken the lion's share of federal funds, made available to the construction of hospitals.

Let's just take a look at this particular statement, shall we.

Absolutely ridiculous.  Non-catholics are not barred from running from public office in any of these cities.  Please cite the statute.

As far as public money being given to parochial schools run by Catholic Churches...  There is a big push for vouchers in this country (which I oppose and I am Catholic).  These vouchers would be available to any parent wanting to send their child to a private school, whether it be Catholic or non-Catholic affiliated.  Ironically, many Protestant parents send their children to Catholic private schools (I know some myself).

As far as the hospitals...Not sure what you are talking about here.  If these hospitals are receiving grant money, then public funds are accessible to anyone, regardless of religious affiliation.

Again, you are citing these statements without proof or basis.

Just to point out, it doesn't say barred from running. It says its not possible to get elected. That no different than someone being allowed to fill out an application for a job, when the employer knows full well he isn't going to get hired. What the tract is addressing is discrimination.

broach972

Quote from: CSloan on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 23:24:48
Just to point out, it doesn't say barred from running. It says its not possible to get elected. That no different than someone being allowed to fill out an application for a job, when the employer knows full well he isn't going to get hired. What the tract is addressing is discrimination.

And how would this be the Catholic Church's fault?  You are giving way too much credit where it doesn't belong.  Discrimination based on what?  Candidates are elected on a variety of reasons.   I am just pointing out just how ridiculous this claim is.

janine

And in some cities it's impossible to be elected mayor unless you are of a certain skin color.  So what?

mistergus

#24
This is not the central premise of Bro. Baxter's tract.  His main premise is the quoting of the words of Catholic authorities regarding their desire and intent to suppress other religious beliefs.  Such as...


"Ryan and Boland, in the book, " Catholic Principles of Politics", on page 303, say, "With reference to the so-called 'liberties', which are so greatly coveted in these days, all must stand by the judgement of the Apostolic See, and have the same mind.  Let no man be deceived by the outward appearance of these liberties, but let each one reflect whence these have had their orgin and by what efforts  they are everywhere upheld and promoted."  Pope Leo XIII had earlier said, "It is quite unlawful to demand, to defend, or to grant unconditional freedom of thought, or speech, or writing, or of worship as if these were so many rights given by nature to man."


"...unlawful to demand, or defend...freedom of worship..."


And this...



Francis J. Connell, Associate Professor of Moral Theology at the Catholic University of America, writing in the American Ecclesiastical Review, January 1946, on "Preserving the Faith Inviolate," said: "We believe that the rulers of a Catholic country have the right to restrict the activities of those who would lead the people away from their alligience to the Catholic Church...They possess the right to prevent propaganda against the Church."  The same author, in his book "Freedom of Worship, the Catholic Position", added: "In a country that is distinctly Catholic...the civil rulers can consider themselves justified in restricting and preventing denominational activities hostile to the [Roman] Catholic religion."

"A Dangerous Doctrine" - Batsell Barrett Baxter



"...the civil rulers can consider themselves justified in restricting and preventing denominational activities hostile to the [Roman] Catholic religion."

Pretty clear, I would say.

Lots more quotes like this from Catholic authorities are in the tract.  Again, this information is not from anti-Catholics.  No "Catholic bashing" here.  These are statements from Catholic authorities, up to and including Popes themselves, revealing their intents.

Robert G

mllevaleur

Quote from: mistergus on Sun Sep 02, 2007 - 00:26:56
  Again, this information is not from anti-Catholics.  No "Catholic bashing" here.  These are statements from Catholic authorities, up to and including Popes themselves, revealing their intents.

Robert G

Oh please, now come on, don't kid yourself like that.

Baxter is hardly Catholic-friendly.  ::frown:: The fact that there are some quotes supposedly from Catholic sources (likely taken out of context and/or misconstrued and/or mistranslated) does NOT make the tract any less anti-Catholic or any less Catholic bashing. I can pick the Bible apart and quote random texts to say anything I want it to say, that doesn't mean what I'm trying to prove is therefore not "anti-biblical."

So far I've seen a quote from some guys who wrote a book and a Catholic professor? That's hardly a "Catholic authority," they could say anything they want, that doesn't mean it's Church teaching. As far as the papal quotes, if you're going to put forth a quote from a pope as evidence, you need to provide a precise citation.

And what's with all the addition of [Roman] before Catholic everywhere? The Latin Rite is only one of the many rites of the Catholic Church, if someone is talking about the Catholic Church as a whole and not just the one rite, the proper name is Catholic, not Roman Catholic.

The really ridiculous thing is that in this day and age, most of the so-called "Catholic" politicians out there openly reject many of the teachings of the Catholic Church. But I guess maybe that's all a ruse intended to trick people into voting for them, and THEN they'll all jump out with  the Papist agenda once they're all in office. Or something... ::shrug::

Jimbob

Quote from: mistergus on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 23:07:49
Quote from: DCR on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 22:48:45
The scenario described would simply not be allowed to happen in our form of government.

It wouldn't?  More from Batsell Barrett Baxters' tract...


In the United States, it is no longer possible for a non-Catholic to be elected Mayor of the city of Boston, or of the city of New York, or of the city of Chicago.  Already because of congressional action  - spearheaded by members of the Roman Catholic Church  -  more than thirty million dollars of public funds have been channeled into providing services for Catholic parochial schools in various sections of the nation.  Catholic hospitals have already taken the lion's share of federal funds, made available to the construction of hospitals.


Any other religious group in America get this kind of treatment?

Don't get mad at me for making this information available.  Get mad that it's true.

Lot's more to come...I'll save the rest for when I post the entire tract.

Robert G
Robert, that's not the reality now anyway.  Mitt Romney was governor of Mass (a Mormon, even).  Ed Koch, and nonreligious Jew has been mayor of NY, and Catholic parochial schools in the Northeast are being shuttered right and left, partly because of funding challenges.  I drive past their buildings with "For Sale" signs all the time. Catholic hospitals are struggling, too, in part because the don't receive certain funds because of their stances on birth control and abortion (there was a recent row in Boston over this).  I know, I live up here live in what used to be a Catholic dominated area, now a secular dominated area.   The world in which the tract was written is long gone.

(btw, I say all that not to shine a poor light on the Catholic's situation in the NE, but simply to show Robert the reality doesn't match what the bolded statement says.  And, fwiw, no church of any sort is going gangbusters in the NE, especially mainline liberal Protestantism, which has so capitulated to PC views that people no longer see the point, they can stay home and read the NYTimes and hear the same sermons...but that's another thread.)

DCR

Quote from: mistergus on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 23:07:49
Quote from: DCR on Sat Sep 01, 2007 - 22:48:45
The scenario described would simply not be allowed to happen in our form of government.

It wouldn't?  More from Batsell Barrett Baxters' tract...


In the United States, it is no longer possible for a non-Catholic to be elected Mayor of the city of Boston, or of the city of New York, or of the city of Chicago.  Already because of congressional action  - spearheaded by members of the Roman Catholic Church  -  more than thirty million dollars of public funds have been channeled into providing services for Catholic parochial schools in various sections of the nation.  Catholic hospitals have already taken the lion's share of federal funds, made available to the construction of hospitals.


Any other religious group in America get this kind of treatment?

Don't get mad at me for making this information available.  Get mad that it's true.

Lot's more to come...I'll save the rest for when I post the entire tract.

Robert G

In addition to the points others have made to this, which I won't reiterate... this tract by Baxter was written decades ago.  Who's to say that his assessment of what may have applied then still applies today?  If a heavily Catholic population in a city voted for mayor from a list of candidates who may have been mostly Catholic... then, yes, I would expect it might have been difficult for non-Catholics to have been elected in some of those cities during that day and time.

But, that says nothing about whether Catholics, if elected, would be allowed to oppress non-Catholics in our country, which was my point.  Do you think the ACLU would stand idly by and let that happen? (Not that they have any sympathies for Christianity anyway).

spurly

Mistergus, what is your point in this thread other than to do a lot of complaining which is not true?

yogi bear

Whether Mistergus intended or not the only thing that threads like this can do is sow discord. There is no good that can come from post like these. They put everyone in defense  and attack mode and are simply disguised bashing. That is all there is to them. As said the track was written many moons ago and if ever is no longer the case today. To bring up such is not productive to brotherly Love and unity. It is only good to divide just that much farther. We need to deal with the times we are in and not point to errors in the past as if they were present threat.

We are followers of Christ called to spread the gospel and live in brotherly love. We are not called to sow discord among ourselves but called to give God the glory and let others see God in us. These types of thread surely do not show God.  If we think we see false teaching we don't start defending against it by saying the X group but instead we say the teaching of such doctrine is not lining up with the word of God. We do not attack the group as a whole but attack the doctrine that seems to be in error. We do it in brotherly love and we do not bash but show love for one another and if it goes no where we don't fight harder but shake the dust from our feet and move on.

Please lets stop with all of the the Catholic Church did or the Church of Christ did or the Pentecostal Church did and get back to God said and Jesus did. We love our Father in heaven and so we do. God said it Jesus lived it therefore I believe it and I follow.

+-Recent Topics

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Yesterday at 15:21:41

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Yesterday at 15:16:06

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Yesterday at 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Powered by EzPortal