News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898071
Total Topics: 90357
Most Online Today: 6336
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 6578
Total: 6578
Google

Dr Scott Hahn on "The Journey Home" - FULL VIDEO

Started by katholikos, Sat Jan 24, 2009 - 07:23:34

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

katholikos

Below is an episode of "The Journey Home" divided into six parts (due to file size). The guest is Dr Scott Hahn. Dr Scott Hahn is a former Presbyterian pastor and seminary professor, who through long study and prayer, became a Catholic, and is now Professor of Scripture and Theology at Franciscan University of Steubenvulle, Ohio.

For some of you folks who don't think that Catholics are Christians (I know most of you don't think that but there are some here that do), I invite you to relax and watch the show, and see a man who's sole reason for becoming Catholic was his love of Christ.

For the rest of you, there are many subjects addressed in this show that are topics of many threads in these forums. This video can offer some insight to those issues.

I hope you find it interesting.

PART ONE:


PART TWO:


PART THREE:


PART FOUR:


PART FIVE:


PART SIX:



[Spelling in title modified-marc]

kensington


katholikos

Quote from: kensington on Sat Jan 24, 2009 - 19:20:10
No thanks... it's nonsense.

How can a man's personal spiritual journey be "nonsense"?
Thats not very nice.
If I were to recount my spiritual journey would you call that nonsense too?

Lee Freeman

#3
I have several of Scott's books in my home library. Though not ultimately persuaded of the truth of the Catholic position(s), his books have deepened my understanding of the Catholic faith. He's a good scholar and I find that there's a lot that I do agree with him on, though. I regularly watch Franciscan University on EWTN and like much of the content of that show, of which Hahn is a panelist. I do wish that more Catholic and Protestant apologists had his caring, non-judgmental attitude when sharing/debating their views.

Thanks for posting that. If more Prots would take the time to understand what Catholics really believe-from Catholics themselves-while they probably wouldn't be persuaded to convert, they might at least understand why Catholics teach what they teach. They might still disagree, but they'd at least disagree in an intellectually honest way, having actually studied the evidence.

Pax.

katholikos

Quote from: Lee Freeman on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 12:46:17
I have several of Scott's books in my home library. Though not ultimately persuaded of the truth of the Catholic position(s), his books have deepened my understanding of the Catholic faith. He's a good scholar and I find that there's a lot that I do agree with him on, though. I regularly watch Franciscan University on EWTN and like much of the content of that show, of which Hahn is a panelist. I do wish that more Catholic and Protestant apologists had his caring, non-judgmental attitude when sharing/debating their views.

Yes, Catholics are Christians.

Pax.

I have:
The Lamb's Supper
Hail Holy Queen
and,
First Comes Love

And I watch Franciscan University Presents too. Its a great show

kensington

Quote from: katholikos on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 12:41:09
Quote from: kensington on Sat Jan 24, 2009 - 19:20:10
No thanks... it's nonsense.

How can a man's personal spiritual journey be "nonsense"?
Thats not very nice.
If I were to recount my spiritual journey would you call that nonsense too?

He is an apologetic... it's not just his testimony, it is used over and over again trying to convince people that the Catholic church is the only church an if we were right we would see things as he did become Catholic.  That is nonsense. 

He is not the first one that someone tried to push on me to "just listen to" about their journey. 

You only did this because someone posted some video about the Catholic church being the woman on the beast.  He asked you not to debate it, just watch it, and you refused, and then, you posted this.  I think BOTH of them belonged in the Catholic forum... but, I'm not a mod.  If you are going to post material here to evangelize, then you are going see the word "nonsense".  Not very nice?  OK.  I do not want Catholics trying to convert me, and I am not very nice about it.  Being converted from one religion to another is not what I come to a Protestant site to do. Sorry.

katholikos

Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 16:41:45
....If you are going to post material here to evangelize, then you are going see the word "nonsense".  Not very nice?  OK.  I do not want Catholics trying to convert me, and I am not very nice about it....

Convert you? I didn't ask you to participate in the thread.

See, thats the thing I don't get about people like you. If you don't like the videos, and you don't like what you percieve as Catholics trying to convert you, then why do you bother entering the thread in the first place? Thats what I don't get. If it were me and I felt that way, I'd just ignore the whole thread. But you can't do that, can you. No, you have to make sure that you post an insult before you move on, calling Dr. Hahn's testimony nonsense.

I didn't twist your arm asking you to watch the video. Frankly, I wish you had never seen the thread in the first place to be honest with you.

You should take the Moderator's advice, here:
Quote from: Lee Freeman on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 12:46:17
.....If more Prots would take the time to understand what Catholics really believe-from Catholics themselves-while they probably wouldn't be persuaded to convert, they might at least understand why Catholics teach what they teach. They might still disagree, but they'd at least disagree in an intellectually honest way, having actually studied the evidence.....

kensington

Sure you did....  When you said this...

"I invite you to relax and watch the show, and see a man who's sole reason for becoming Catholic was his love of Christ.

For the rest of you, there are many subjects addressed in this show that are topics of many threads in these forums. This video can offer some insight to those issues."

You can't have it both ways... you invite all or some, and include the rest...  You did invite me to participate.  You just did not anticipate my response. 

I've seen Lee's response... He has taken the time to discuss this matter with me before.  I like his perspective...  But, I still know this Dr Scott Hahn is an apologetic, who is out to convert.  This is not my first rodeo.  Of course you don't like that I saw this and spoke to it...  that's fine.   But, it doesn't change what I know.

Like I said, it's not just his testimony about becoming a Catholic, he is an apologetic, who is using it to try to convert "other believers" to Catholicism, and that is what I called nonsense. 

katholikos

Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 18:31:20
Sure you did....  When you said this...

"I invite you to relax and watch the show, and see a man who's sole reason for becoming Catholic was his love of Christ.....

And you think I was specifically talking to YOU in particular? Wow. Someone's a little full of themselves.

For future reference: When I use the word "you" in the general sense, you can rest assured that YOU are not included, okay?

kensington

Quote from: katholikos on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 18:37:58
Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 18:31:20
Sure you did....  When you said this...

"I invite you to relax and watch the show, and see a man who's sole reason for becoming Catholic was his love of Christ.....

And you think I was specifically talking to YOU in particular? Wow. Someone's a little full of themselves.

For future reference: When I use the word "you" in the general sense, you can rest assured that YOU are not included, okay?

No.. not at all...  You offered an invitation to posters here to see this and hear what he has to say.  I am one of those posters, I am invited to participate in anything here offered as a member. 

As to your telling me that invitations don't include me in the future... read the rules.  I'm a poster here, and I will post to what I think I'd like. I have done nothing wrong to you. 

katholikos

Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 18:40:48
...  You offered an invitation to posters here to see this and hear what he has to say....

Yes, that is exactly what I did. I would have welcomed your hearing it and your input. Or you could have declined and just moved on. But neither of those options were good enough for you, were they. No, you had to drop an insult bomb because thats the type of person you obviously are. I can't fathom what compels people like you - you just can't stand it. You just have to be rude, and all the while talking about Jesus and the Bible while you're doing it. Thats sad.

There always seems to be one rotten apple that screws up a thread. I hope you're happy

kensington

I'm fine... Happy?  I guess so... but it has nothing to do with this silly nonsense.  I'm pretty happy in my life in general, and I'm not going to get pulled into this with you.  I am going to post what I think about what is posted here.  I've been doing that for a while now, I enjoy that, I like the people here and I think I learn.  Peace.

katholikos

Below is an episode of "The Journey Home" divided into six parts (due to file size). The guest is Dr Scott Hahn. Dr Scott Hahn is a former Presbyterian pastor and seminary professor, who through long study and prayer, became a Catholic, and is now Professor of Scripture and Theology at Franciscan University of Steubenvulle, Ohio.

For some of you folks who don't think that Catholics are Christians (I know most of you don't think that but there are some here that do), I invite you to relax and watch the show, and see a man who's sole reason for becoming Catholic was his love of Christ.

For the rest of you, there are many subjects addressed in this show that are topics of many threads in these forums. This video can offer some insight to those issues.

I hope you find it interesting.

PART ONE:


PART TWO:


PART THREE:


PART FOUR:


PART FIVE:


PART SIX:

kensington

Now, that is the most mature thing I've seen in a while.  I hope it works for you. In whatever it is you seek. Peace.

Thanks for the invitation to see it again... but, I've seen it.  I'm just not interested in apologetic's at this time. God Bless.

Lee Freeman

#14
Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 16:41:45
Quote from: katholikos on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 12:41:09
Quote from: kensington on Sat Jan 24, 2009 - 19:20:10
No thanks... it's nonsense.

How can a man's personal spiritual journey be "nonsense"?
Thats not very nice.
If I were to recount my spiritual journey would you call that nonsense too?

He is an apologetic... it's not just his testimony, it is used over and over again trying to convince people that the Catholic church is the only church an if we were right we would see things as he did become Catholic.  That is nonsense. 

He is not the first one that someone tried to push on me to "just listen to" about their journey. 

You only did this because someone posted some video about the Catholic church being the woman on the beast.  He asked you not to debate it, just watch it, and you refused, and then, you posted this.  I think BOTH of them belonged in the Catholic forum... but, I'm not a mod.  If you are going to post material here to evangelize, then you are going see the word "nonsense".  Not very nice?  OK.  I do not want Catholics trying to convert me, and I am not very nice about it.  Being converted from one religion to another is not what I come to a Protestant site to do. Sorry.

Kensington, how is what Dr. Hahn does any different than Protestants trying to convince Catholics that our position is right? What is wrong with both sides presenting the evidence for their views and letting a person decide based on the evidence?

I don't interprtet katholikos' Journey Home clips as trying to evangelize or convert Protestants so much as our Catholic friend trying to inform us as to what the Catholic Church actually teaches-in this case that a high regrard of both Christ and scripture drove Dr. Scott Hahn to convert to Catholicism. He posted it here in order to catch the attention of more people who wouldn't normally visit the Catholic forum. I take it as a learning experience.

I've read several of Hahn's books and so far I haven't sprouted horns or started riding on large beatsts! I'm not afraid of what Catholics believe. I'm willing to hear the arguments and as objectively as possible weigh the evidence. So far Hahn has not convinced me to become a Catholic. But he (and other Catholic authors) has helped me to more accurately understand the Catholic faith.

Catholics and Prots can continue to yell past each other with caricatures and streotypes about the evils of what "they" believe, or they can enter into a respectful dialogue and learn from each other about what the other believes and possibly even find some common ground-which I personally think is more helpful. I'm sorry you had a negative experience with Catholics trying to convert you, but there's been a lot of Protestants trying to convert the Catholics here. Seems to me its a two-way street.

Pax.


johntwayne

I often wonder how we would all view each other if we lived under persecution. Would I really care if the guy sitting next to me was Catholic or Protestant? I don't think so.

As Lee suggested, we need to seek to understand each other better.

On the other hand, I believe this properly belongs in the Catholic section.

kensington

Lee, it may not be different.  An apologetic is an apologetic, but the truth remains, that is what he is and does.  Yes, he tells how he found the Catholic church to be the way.  But, it's purpose is to convince us that it is the only way for all of us.  I don't find that he is giving new evidence, if he was, then I would or might think it something I'd want to hear. It's not.  As I said before.. He is not the only one who has this as his personal mission. 

I find much error with Catholic doctrine.  I can do that without it being personal, I can do that without it being for me to convert anyone.  But, since Dr Hahn is a self proclaimed apologetic, I doubt that evidence by him is for any other reason than to convert. As a protestant member of the body of Christ, I am not interested. 

I'm not sure why katholikos got so bent about it, I'm sure I am not the first protestant they have met that did not want to be converted or given evidence that the Catholic church is the way for us all.  The "Right" way as it were.  I personally find that side of the argument to be nonsense.  Explaining why someone believes something that goes against scripture, does not make it OK to go against scripture. (I hope that makes sense). 

I won't say any more about Dr Hahn's testimony... as anything past this would be seen a personal attack on him. I'll just keep that to myself.  But, to say... He did nothing to convince me of "his truth". Sorry.

kensington

Quote from: johntwayne on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 21:55:57
I often wonder how we would all view each other if we lived under persecution. Would I really care if the guy sitting next to me was Catholic or Protestant? I don't think so.

As Lee suggested, we need to seek to understand each other better.

On the other hand, I believe this properly belongs in the Catholic section.

Lee does well to try to understand and to discuss with someone. I don't have to worry that if he doesn't like what I say or disagrees with it he will begin to tell me he feels sorry for me or that I am "of that ilk".  Iron sharpens iron, Lee sharpens the "discussion in peace" skills.  ;-)

kensington

Lee, Honestly... Does Dr Hahn offer anything new or that has not been discussed here on GCF before... or even offered by a Catholic who was trying to convince Protestants of something we don't believe? 

Afterall, isn't that what is implied in the OP by this comment.. "For some of you folks who don't think that Catholics are Christians"  Who would that be if not Protestants, for I am sure that Catholics believe that Catholics are Christians. (Which is probably why this should have been in the Catholic forum).

While there is nothing wrong with someone wanting to see it, or hear it, such as yourself, I don't think there is anything wrong with saying I've seen it, I find error in it, and I don't believe it. Such as myself. 




katholikos

#19
Quote from: johntwayne on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 21:55:57
.....On the other hand, I believe this properly belongs in the Catholic section.

If that is so, then everytime someone posts a lengthy writing or a video by a protestant pastor, it needs to be moved to the "Protestantism" section. Fair is fair.



Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 22:34:58
...that is what he is and does.  Yes, he tells how he found the Catholic church to be the way.  But, it's purpose is to convince us that it is the only way for all of us.

You are not a mind reader, and you do not know what my purpose is, despite the fact that I stated it pretty clearly in the OP:

"....For some of you folks who don't think that Catholics are Christians (I know most of you don't think that but there are some here that do), I invite you to relax and watch the show, and see a man who's sole reason for becoming Catholic was his love of Christ.

For the rest of you, there are many subjects addressed in this show that are topics of many threads in these forums. This video can offer some insight to those issues....
"
.

I have studied protestantism to a degree: I have read and looked into everything from Luthers' theses to books by modern day evangelicals. But how many people here can say that they've read the Catechism just for better understanding?: A precious few I'd wager.

My purpose to to elimanate some of the ridiculous things people believe about Catholics so that we can have more time to discuss the REAL differences. Half of the arguments regarding the Catholic Church I have seen in this forum are arguments over Straw Men. Its a pointless waste of time.

If you want to know what someone else believes, go to the source. Don't read what Jack Chick or Jimmy Swaggart or Dave Hunt believes about Catholicism, read what we say about ourselves. THEN, at that point, when you see things you disagree with, a real discussion can takle place.

Of course, if a person does NOT want to understand what we believe, thats fine too. But in that case, they should refrain from making false allegations in these thread, knowing that their charges are not based in fact.

THAT is my purpose.

Lee Freeman

Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 23:06:40
Lee, Honestly... Does Dr Hahn offer anything new or that has not been discussed here on GCF before... or even offered by a Catholic who was trying to convince Protestants of something we don't believe? 

Afterall, isn't that what is implied in the OP by this comment.. "For some of you folks who don't think that Catholics are Christians"  Who would that be if not Protestants, for I am sure that Catholics believe that Catholics are Christians. (Which is probably why this should have been in the Catholic forum).

While there is nothing wrong with someone wanting to see it, or hear it, such as yourself, I don't think there is anything wrong with saying I've seen it, I find error in it, and I don't believe it. Such as myself. 





First off, thanks for what you said above. Secondly, yes, I believe Hahn offers a different approach. Much of what I've read here is not so much apologetics, which implies a dispassionate, reasoned discussion of evidence, as much as polemic. I've read it from both sides. Some of the Protestants here have accused Catholicism of being thinly-disguised paganism, and some of the Catholics here have shot back and described Protestants as little better than upstart heretics who thrive on division like vultures on carrion.

True, Hahn is an apologist, however The Journey Home as I understand it from viewing it many times, is not so much geared toward converting Protestants as it is assisting Protestants undergoing the conversion process, and towards "cradle" Catholics, to show them what a conversion is like. But even when unabashedly engaged in apolegtics, Hahn's approach is non-dogmatic, non-confrontational. He doesn't sterotype Protestants in a negative way because for many years he was one of us. He's been on both sides of the fence.

I'm not endorsding a surface ecumenism that denies or downplays the very real differences between Protestant and Catholic theology. Nor would I deny anyone the right to disagree. All I'm saying is that we ought to be able to disagree without being disagreeable. And we ought to disagree based upon an accurate understanding of what the other side really believes/teaches. It's easier to stereotype and generalize than it is to really make an effort to understand. At the end of the day we may still disagree, but at least we will do so based upon an honset, objective appraisal of evidence rather than invective. That's all I'm saying.

Pax.

kensington

Lee:  "All I'm saying is that we ought to be able to disagree without being disagreeable. And we ought to disagree based upon an accurate understanding of what the other side really believes/teaches."

Then, that being the case, someone might take a look at Katholikos comments to me. Thanks.

I want to add, I do believe that Dr Hahn is preaching conversion.  The great commission was mentioned, which is to preach salvation.  He already had that, he was already a saved minister of the gospel, he is preaching conversion.  That is different.  IMO.  That is what I spoke to.  I don't need it.  I do understand that he believes he found a more complete way to LOVE God in conversion.  I just doubt that it's truth.  Not that it's not his truth, but that finding a more complete way to LOVE God than through salvation and the WORD of God.  The truth is Lee... I see this as him preaching another Jesus.

As much as he says he isn't, he really is.  A truely saved man, he claimed to be, who had Jesus to begin with,  and says he did, then finds another way and now helps others to find the other way...  to another Jesus.  It may be just me, I sometimes see things others don't, I think in ways someone else might not.  But, if he truely had Jesus to begin with, why not preach that, rather than preaching/teaching conversion from knowing Jesus to another knowing Jesus?  (I can't discuss this with him as he is not here and did not post his videos) But, it is the stance I have on his materials.

PS...  Katholikos... I've done studies on the CC and so have many here, including reading the Catechism and other books of the church to find what they believe.  But, when discussion happens, it's inevitable that we will be told we read it wrong, or we are ignorant of the true stance of the Catholic church.  I did ask you to go into the Catholic forum and read the discussions in there.  Many many good informed Protestants have offered good sound discussion based on the word of God to the topics there.  And the response is always the one you claim you are getting.  I'll wager a rare few Catholics takes us seriously.  We get comments like "Jack Trick, and Jimmy Swaggart"... in your anger.  I do NOT know ONE Protestant who goes to either of those sources for information on the Catholic church. I know I don't.

I can ask you what you believe, but when I point out that it does not line up with the word of God, (as in Purgatory)you will still reject it, call me names, get mad and imply I am ignorant.  It will happen to my protestant brothers who also bring forth biblical discussion on the matter. So, isn't that a waste of time also?  Peace.


Lee Freeman

#22
Hahn would (and has) argued that he was saved by and worships the same Jesus that Protestants do. He probably believes (I can't remember if he's specifically said this or not) he was really saved and converted as a Protestant, only he now has a deeper, fuller understanding of Jesus. From what I've read in the Catechism and seen on EWTN Hahn and other Catholic experts believe faithful baptized Protestants are saved, even though they regard us as "separated brethren" who do not possess the fullness of the faith.

I know you addressed this to Katholicos, but regarding purgatory, Catholics believe scripture teaches this doctrine. We don't. But its not as if one day a bored pope decided to invent a new doctrine just for kicks. Two of he foundational texts for the doctrine of purgatory are I Corinthians 3:15 and I Peter 1:7. They also cite the apocryphal Hebrew text of II Maccabees 12:46 (which says, in case folks aren't familiar with it): "Therefore, he [Judas Maccabeus] made atonement for the dead, that they might be delivered from their sin." But there's a lot more to the doctrine of purgatory than these three passages alone. Whole books have been written on the subject, both by Catholic and Protestant scholars. Since the topic came up, one excellent treatment by a Jewish scholar is Stephen Greenblatt's Hamlet in Purgatory, a historical and cultural tretment of the devlopment of the doctrine of purgatory. A great Protestant evaluation is the chapter in Bishop NT Wright's Surprised by Hope: Rethinking Heaven, the Resurrection, and the Mission of the Church. Also his For All the Saints: Remembering the Christian Departed.

If I were katholicos simply telling me purgatory isnt scriptural wouldn't convinnce me of anything. I haven't followed all of these discussions, but if you could give him some reasons why you think its not scriptural (maybe you did-I don't know) that'd be a start. IMHO purgatory is similar to the Protestant evangelical doctrine of the rapture. Neither word is found in scripture nor either doctrine explicitly stated, yet believers in both doctrines see them in scripture and wonder why others can't. I happen to believe both are mistaken, yet I understand how people could come to see both views there. As another related example, many Protestants are convinced that Dispensational Premillennialism is clearly and plainly taught in scripture (I don't, not by a long-shot); they have their proof-texts for their Disp. Premil. views, which they often simply take for granted as so obvious it doesn't need an apologetic defense. When people like me try to reason with them and show them from scripture and heremeneutics, that their views are based upon a misunderstanding of the apocalyptic texts they quote, they usually get defensive and tell me politely (sometimes not so politely) that I'm nuts! Any real Christian would see and admit the truth or Dispensational Premillennialism. If you've already shared with katholicos your arguments for not accepting the doctrine of purgatory you can ignore the above paragraph.

As for the polemics, I've admitted that I've read Catholic polemics against Protestants. A couple of posters in particular come to mind. The moderators have discussed it and are monitoring the situation.

I think Bob Hendren's advice is apropos here. Bob always encourages folks to be doxological rather than dogmatic.

Pax.

kensington

Well, I quoted word for word what the Catholic encyclopedia says about Purgatory not being a fact, but "an idea based on" ...  and I was told I was ignorant.  However, that was just an example of some "Catholic - Protestant" discussions that have gone on in the Forums.  It was not that Katholikos and I had directly discussed it ourselves...   More like an answer at this time to the accusation that Protestants don't bother to find a source or seek what is true.  I was responding that we have, and the response we get is "ignorant".

"From what I've read in the Catechism and seen on EWTN Hahn and other Catholic experts believe faithful baptized Protestants are saved, even though they regard us as "separated brethren" who do not possess the fullness of the faith."

You know, it is the idea that they do think of us this way, even though we are saved, that brings most division.  It's nonsense.  They really don't see the arrogance in that?  They really don't see the insult?  I guess not.  Being told that I do not possess the fullness of faith.... sets my teeth on edge.  If I don't just say... "nonsense" and move on... it's going to deteriorate. It's just too insane to deal with. Knowing the hundreds of Catholics I do, and being confident from knowing them as I do, that my prayer life is more consistant, my passion for the word is more consistant, my faith in the Authority and Holiness of God is more consistent, my submission to His word is more consistent, yet they regard me as "not possessing the fullness of faith"... NONSENSE.  See where it brings us?

I have to keep telling myself... it matters not that I am considered separated from them(by them), but I am not separated from God, who is my source. Who says I am not separated from Him. He died for me, He saved my soul, my eternity is in His hands and He sits on the throne. There is no real scriptural basis for this belief that we are separated.  In that is my confidence that the LORD God Almighty, Creator of Heaven and earth, can handle it. And, I won't allow myself to become separated from Him. His word says I am the body of Christ, the Bride, the saved, the redeemed. And THAT is the bottom line. Right?

I really think that if they cared about how we feel, they would stop trying to convince us of our "separated" statis or our "lack of fullness" (in their regard) and start seeing us as the Body Christ that the Bible says we are.  They might consider the depth and width of the separation this kind of regard causes.  It's a wound.  We question the theology of some of their practices... or many of them. And they in return question our faith and our place in the body.  It's kind of a one sided arrogance to me. 

It's a real shame that the teaching has been for these centuries that it is not the unrepented sin of the non believer that separates one from the body of Christ, but the fact that we are not Catholic. I mean... does any one of them really ever consider that point? I'm starting to believe that it won't be the sincere belief in Mary, or praying to saints or even the lack of biblical proof of the Purgatory they preach that they will stand accountable for at the Great White Throne...  it will be the arrogance of telling the body, they were not the body.  That we did not or have not found true fullness.  I'm going to pray about that. 

I could never imagine that all Catholics are separated from the body, or do not have fullness of faith, just because they are Catholic.  But, do they consider the wound of them saying that to someone just because they are "Protestant"?  That is why the image of Dr Hahn speaking to help us to conversion, is nonsense for me.  They speak of fullness of faith while calling true believers "not".  It's a living oxymoron.




Lee Freeman

My point is that most Catholics are every bit as sincere in their views as we Protestants are in ours. What we see as spiritual arrogance they do not. And spiritual arrogance is not solely a Catholic trait.

I knew a man (now deceased) who was Baptist; he once had a member of the Church of Christ tell him that he wasn't a saved Christian and was likely going to hell unless he was "scripturally" baptized and then joined "the Lord's Church." I know personally a CoC missionary who refused baptism to a woman who would not leave the Baptist Church! My own CoC was disfellowshipped and blacklisted by area churches and churches hundreds of miles away (most we'd never heard of, much less had fellowship with) after we had a joint assembly with an area Methodist Church. I've had Reformed Protestants question my status as a real Christian because I didn't accept the major tenets of Calvinism; I've had Lutherans question my status as a Christian because I don't accept the doctrine of the Real Presence in the bread and wine; I've had Orthodox tell me I'm out in left field because I do not accept the doctrine of the apostolic succession of the priesthood; I've had charismatics question my status as a saved Christian because I've never spoken in tongues; and just this past week I've had a Protestant here tell me that I probably do not have the Holy Spirit because I was baptized with water and receive communion each Sunday (apparently these are my literal misunderstandings of what are really spiritual realities)! That's way more spiritual arrogance than I've ever received from any of my Catholic friends! Many mainline and "anti" Churches of Christ don't even consider other denominations to even be separated brethren. They're not "brethren" in any sense; they're considered false churches entirely.

Significantly, none of them have ever tried to convert me. Nor did my Episcopalian grandmother ever try to convert me. Nor my Methodist grandmother; nor any of my Baptist friends; nor my Orthodox friend. I'm not aware of a systematic campaign within the Roman Catholic Church to Catholicize Protestants. Sure they'd love it if we did convert, but like Fr. Ken Roberts, I'm not sure they feel compelled to convert us. Perhaps there are pre-Vatican II old-school Catholics who do, but I don't know any of them.

I have personally known of three Catholic priests who were members of inter-faith Christian ministers associations. The priests from St. Joseph's and St. Michael's Catholic Churches here in Florence were participating members of the Shoals Ministerial Alliance, along with Charismatics, two "progressive" Churches of Christ, Presbyterians, Baptists, Methodists, Episcopalians, Lutherans, etc. And I met a priest in Grenada, Mississippi, who was a member of the ministerial association in that town. I don't know what the Grenada guys did, but the pastors and priests of our group assembled at least once a week to gather for prayer, to pray for each others' ministries. They didn't ignore the doctrinal differences, they just refused to argue about them. And this group jointly sponsored a couple of campus crusades (one of which featured Pastor Tony Evans) and three or four Marches for Jesus.

So, there's more than enough spiritual arrogance to go around. But there's also lots of humility and cooperation between the various denominations-including Catholics.

Pax.


kensington

#25
Thanks Lee...  You never cease to cause thinking. Trust me, I am not without the knowledge that there are protestants who walk in ignorance also. I know some of those as well.  Sometimes, the things they say... stun even me.

I have a friend who is a Catholic Priest.  We have a common love for the Word of God.  When I met him, I said to him... "I am not Catholic, what may I call you?"  He said... "You can call me brother".   The first time my sil heard me refer to him this way, she did not hesitate to correct me that he was "Father".  He was her parish priest and had just done her husband's funeral.  I think He knew something she did not.

Therein lies the difference between the Catholic or Protestant and the Believer.  One talks it, and the other walks it.  But, that is just me.

To this...  you said "My point is that most Catholics are every bit as sincere in their views as we Protestants are in ours. What we see as spiritual arrogance they do not. And spiritual arrogance is not solely a Catholic trait."

Yes, but depending on what idea it is they are viewing...  they may be just as sincere.... but they just might be sincerely wrong.   ROTFLOL!!   rofl  I gotta go... I'm so tired!   

Don't do this now Lee  ...   ::doh::   LOL!

kensington

"And spiritual arrogance is not solely a Catholic trait."

Hey... wait a minute... are you trying to imply something... giving a hint of some kind?  If you keep that up, I may have to report you to the powers that be.

Oh...   ::eek::

I see... you are the powers that be...   Nevermind.  ::shrug::

ROTFLOL...  rofl  J/K...   I'm so tired.  ::sleepingsoundly::

katholikos

Quote from: kensington on Mon Jan 26, 2009 - 23:18:47
......I could never imagine that all Catholics are separated from the body, or do not have fullness of faith, just because they are Catholic.  But, do they consider the wound of them saying that to someone just because they are "Protestant"?  That is why the image of Dr Hahn speaking to help us to conversion, is nonsense for me.  They speak of fullness of faith while calling true believers "not".  It's a living oxymoron.

I don't know who said that, but if a Catholic said flat out that you are not a member of the Body of Christ because you are protestant then they were wrong. And I'm pretty sure you already know that the Catholic Church does not teach that. And speaking of "wounds", do YOU consider the wound you cause everytime you keep saying that our Church is the "Beast"?

But back to the first point: In another thread - RIGHT HERE - I posted this:

(BEGIN)
.....Now here is what the Catechism says regarding protestants:
source link: http://www.vatican.va/archive/catechism/p123a9p3.htm

818 "However, one cannot charge with the sin of the separation those who at present are born into these communities [that resulted from such separation] and in them are brought up in the faith of Christ, and the Catholic Church accepts them with respect and affection as brothers . . . . All who have been justified by faith in Baptism are incorporated into Christ; they therefore have a right to be called Christians, and with good reason are accepted as brothers in the Lord by the children of the Catholic Church" (Unitatis redintegratio 3 § 1).

819 "Furthermore, many elements of sanctification and of truth" (Lumen Gentium 8 § 2) are found outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church: "the written Word of God; the life of grace; faith, hope, and charity, with the other interior gifts of the Holy Spirit, as well as visible elements" (UR 3 § 2; cf. LG 15). Christ's Spirit uses these Churches and ecclesial communities as means of salvation, whose power derives from the fullness of grace and truth that Christ has entrusted to the Catholic Church. All these blessings come from Christ and lead to him (Cf. UR 3), and are in themselves calls to "Catholic unity" (Cf. LG 8).


ALSO:

838 "The Church knows that she is joined in many ways to the baptized who are honored by the name of Christian, but do not profess the Catholic faith in its entirety or have not preserved unity or communion under the successor of Peter" (LG 15). Those "who believe in Christ and have been properly baptized are put in a certain, although imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church" (UR 3). With the Orthodox Churches, this communion is so profound "that it lacks little to attain the fullness that would permit a common celebration of the Lord's Eucharist" (Paul VI, Discourse, December 14, 1975; cf. UR 13-18).


Jimbob

Quote from: johntwayne on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 21:55:57
I often wonder how we would all view each other if we lived under persecution. Would I really care if the guy sitting next to me was Catholic or Protestant? I don't think so.

As Lee suggested, we need to seek to understand each other better.

On the other hand, I believe this properly belongs in the Catholic section.
I agree.

kensington

"I don't know who said that, but if a Catholic said flat out that you are not a member of the Body of Christ because you are protestant then they were wrong. And I'm pretty sure you already know that the Catholic Church does not teach that. And speaking of "wounds", do YOU consider the wound you cause every time you keep saying that our Church is the "Beast"?"

DO YOU READ?   ::doh::  Because I did not say the Catholic Church is the "Beast".... This is the second time I've told you that.

The Catholic system is the "WOMAN" who rides on the Beast is what I said I agree with ... go back and read it again.

Also.... I've asked you numerous times to go into the Catholic forum and read some of the discussions there.  YOU WILL FIND where it has been said that "Protestants" are NOT part of the body.  IF you would read some of the discussions here, you would not need to stand around demanding things of people that have already been done time and time again.

And if what you say is True...  then perhaps you could correct those who have said these things in those discussions..  Sometimes I do wonder why Catholics worry more about arguing with the Protestants than correcting the false things being taught in their own church by their own people, I've asked that in discussions also. 

Regardless of what you do... This conversation is over, I'm not answering your attacks any longer.  I was done arguing with you when I started discussing with Lee these things that have come up.  Peace.

ole Jake

Quote from: Lee Freeman on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 20:43:49
Quote from: kensington on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 16:41:45
Quote from: katholikos on Sun Jan 25, 2009 - 12:41:09
Quote from: kensington on Sat Jan 24, 2009 - 19:20:10
No thanks... it's nonsense.

How can a man's personal spiritual journey be "nonsense"?
Thats not very nice.
If I were to recount my spiritual journey would you call that nonsense too?

He is an apologetic... it's not just his testimony, it is used over and over again trying to convince people that the Catholic church is the only church an if we were right we would see things as he did become Catholic.  That is nonsense. 

He is not the first one that someone tried to push on me to "just listen to" about their journey. 

You only did this because someone posted some video about the Catholic church being the woman on the beast.  He asked you not to debate it, just watch it, and you refused, and then, you posted this.  I think BOTH of them belonged in the Catholic forum... but, I'm not a mod.  If you are going to post material here to evangelize, then you are going see the word "nonsense".  Not very nice?  OK.  I do not want Catholics trying to convert me, and I am not very nice about it.  Being converted from one religion to another is not what I come to a Protestant site to do. Sorry.

Kensington, how is what Dr. Hahn does any different than Protestants trying to convince Catholics that our position is right? What is wrong with both sides presenting the evidence for their views and letting a person decide based on the evidence?

I don't interprtet katholikos' Journey Home clips as trying to evangelize or convert Protestants so much as our Catholic friend trying to inform us as to what the Catholic Church actually teaches-in this case that a high regrard of both Christ and scripture drove Dr. Scott Hahn to convert to Catholicism. He posted it here in order to catch the attention of more people who wouldn't normally visit the Catholic forum. I take it as a learning experience.

I've read several of Hahn's books and so far I haven't sprouted horns or started riding on large beatsts! I'm not afraid of what Catholics believe. I'm willing to hear the arguments and as objectively as possible weigh the evidence. So far Hahn has not convinced me to become a Catholic. But he (and other Catholic authors) has helped me to more accurately understand the Catholic faith.

Catholics and Prots can continue to yell past each other with caricatures and streotypes about the evils of what "they" believe, or they can enter into a respectful dialogue and learn from each other about what the other believes and possibly even find some common ground-which I personally think is more helpful. I'm sorry you had a negative experience with Catholics trying to convert you, but there's been a lot of Protestants trying to convert the Catholics here. Seems to me its a two-way street.

Pax.




Haven't you figured out that Kensington responds to anything positive, even neutral, about the Catholic Church the way that Dracula responds to a crucifix?


kensington

Jake,
One has to wonder if you read the whole dialog between Lee and I... or if you just jumped on the first thing you read that gave you a reason to post your quippy comment.  LOL...  I guess the latter. 


katholikos

#32
Quote from: kensington on Tue Jan 27, 2009 - 22:30:35
Jake,
One has to wonder if you read the whole dialog between Lee and I... or if you just jumped on the first thing you read that gave you a reason to post your quippy comment.  LOL...  I guess the latter. 



...so says the person who posted the very first thing after the OP calling it "nonsense"

No constructive criticism, no thoughtful response...  ...just an insult. Look whos talking.

edited to remove name-calling

papist1

amen!  Scott Hahn was a integral part of my conversion to the Church.

peace, papist

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by Amo
Today at 08:51:25

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Today at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Yesterday at 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Yesterday at 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Yesterday at 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Tue Nov 17, 2026 - 14:42:57

Powered by EzPortal