News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898081
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 2227
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1468
Total: 1468
Google (2)

Please, I need advice on my relationship, not what I expected

Started by Nashguy30, Tue Feb 16, 2010 - 01:02:22

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Nashguy30

I've been dating a young lady for almost 9 months.  I'm 30 and she's 25.  This is the longest relationship I've ever been in.  I thought this relationship was destined for greatness because I met her in church.  I've always had difficulty getting to know women out in the world because I don't even want to get a romantic relationship started unless she's God-fearing and has similar values...yet I have difficulty bringing those topics up in general conversation.  So meeting someone who is active in a church I'm comfortable with seemed like a solution (I attend a southern Baptist church).   Strange how things have worked out.  I consider myself a fairly conservative person, and she's expressed attitudes that to me seem very liberal and worldly.  Some of them include a desire to be involved in nudism, like going to a nude beach.  She went to a bachelorette party recently where she purchased some penis straws for the other attendees.  She called it good clean fun since it wasn't bringing another person in as a temptation.  Granted, it's not like there was a stripper, but it kind of made me uncomfortable as far as what a Christian should be doing (in her defense, the bride is not Christian and probably influenced the party favor choice).   And she's also very blunt, sometimes to the point of embarrassing me.  One time we were in a restaurant and when faced with the choice of eating sometime she didn't like she said out loud that it would give her explosive diarrhea if she did.  I believe in the right to bear arms and capital punishment, and she's uncomfortable with gun ownership and more or less against the death penalty.  While not condoning homosexuality, she definitely has a more relaxed view of it than me and seems to enjoy the homosexual characters on TV shows.   I've kind of ignored these under the excuse that she's Christian.  And trust me I don't doubt that she has Jesus in her heart.  She spends time studying the Bible and is more active in church than me.

So I'm kind of confused.  Am I crazy or a square for having a problem with these things?  These are all attitudes I've seen in women I've met in the world and concluded that they probably weren't right for me and I'd do better to meet a girl in church.  For a guy that had certain expectations from a church girl, I'm surprised and confused.  

We had a falling out recently and I'm not sure if our relationship will continue.  We've both invested a lot and I don't want to call it quits just yet but need some advice.  A long time ago she said this is the first relationship she's prayed about and hoped God would answer her with a big "no" if it wasn't the right one.  That never happened and so now that things might end I wouldn't want to shake up her faith.  We haven't had sex but have engaged in lots of sensual activity, including manual stimulation.  I've never had that before and somehow feel like it will have been wrong if we don't work out.  I'm a virgin but she's had sex with one person she was in a relationship with for several years, something she regrets.  When it comes to our sexual future, I have some concerns.  Sometimes I think her idea of marriage and a husband is too focused on having the 3-5 kids that she wants.  She said she looks forward to being pregnant so she won't need to have sex for 9 months.  That almost scared me off, and when I addressed it she said she would take it into consideration.  Apparently her sexual history wasn't very fulfilling, as she's not even sure if she will have enjoyment from sex.  Evidently sex isn't part of her fantasy life (she told me she's never even masturbated).

Do I love her?  I don't know.  I've never been in love before and don't know how it should feel.  One thing I know is that we should be comfortable with each other and compliment each other, and obviously there are some things that bother me.  I just don't know if they should or not.  She's very devoted and has been there for me in times of trouble.  

The other issue, a big one for me, is that she isn't as physically attractive to me as she was at first.  I feel guilty about that.  I don't want to be superficial but it's hard to see past it, especially since she doesn't exercise or eat as healthy as me and I'm concerned for how that will impact her appearance over time.  How can I see past that?

What should I do?  Should I end this now or try to work through it?  What kind of discussions should I be having?  Should we be getting some kind of Christian counseling?

chosenone

From what you have said there are lots of red flags that may well lead to many problems if you did get married.
I really, dont think that YOU think she is the one for you, and that is why you are having doubts. You dont find her attractive and you dont know if you love her apart from all the other things you mentioned. Yor doubts may well be The Holy Spirit speaking to you.

No you are not square, I would have worries about many of the things that she said and did also.   My advice would be to stay apart and pray about it, but from what you have said I am doubtful that God has bought you together. (Just my opinion based on what you have said)

Just because you met in church, doesnt mean that she is the one for you.

comfy

I don't think God needs to tell her "NO". You are seeing enough to tell you. And you do not need to depend on her becoming honest enough to know and deal the right way with this.

For advice, I would say to socialize with her only while there are more mature and sound Christian people present, who are influencing how everyone is relating. You should not be alone with her, considering how she or both of you have been influencing your activities by yourselves, I would . . .  consider.

But she can grow, and you can get to know her as she develops, and while you are discovering other women and seeing how the ladies of Jesus develop, and noticing if she is turning out to become like these for-real ladies of Jesus.

Have you become aware of Ephesians 5:23? It says, "For the husband is head of the wife, as also Christ is head of the church; and He is the Savior of the body." Have you been developing to be more and more her "head" (and I mean as her Christian *example*, not just her boss or micro-manager, etc. 1 Peter 5:3), or has she been doing a lot of the steering and this not in really wholesome ways? A lady of Jesus is your *helpmate* to help you get more real with God and love all people like Jesus wants. You haven't shared anything about her doing this, though I do get that you say she is devoted.

I notice how you have shared some pretty personal and descriptive stuff. But you did not say what you had that falling-out about; for some reason, this is something you did not give clear details about. What that was about could be revealing, and in case you have not indirectly told us details about that, this could mean this has something to do with what you deeply may not really want to bring to light. So, it could be a bigger deal, than you think.

So, you've got me really interested in this; I hope I'm Ok with you, so we can continue with this. And Chosen One has given good stuff. I hope others do, too. God bless you, Nash Guy ::smile::

Nashguy30

Thank you for your responses, these have been helpful thusfar.

COMFY, you are wanting to dig deeper and about the "falling out".  This has prompted me to give more details, even at the risk of exposing my weaknesses and my lack of Christlike attitudes.  In this I'll refer to my girlfriend by the name Karen.  I'm going to talk more about her because I don't want to misrepresent her.

I started dating Karen and after a couple months had questions about whether she was the right one.  I wanted to break up but decided to wait, partly to give her a chance but mostly because that was the longest dating relationship I had had in a long time and I'd been desperately wanting one.  Also, thinking about the act of breaking up frustrated me because I didn't want to be the bad guy.  Funny how looking back after 9 months together makes it seem like it should have been easier and guilt-free to have broken up after 2 months. 

Anyhow, a major even in my life occurred where I lost my job.  I went into a deep debilitating depression that led me to believe I was going crazy and would be unable to hold a job in the future.  I became very needy and Karen was the only close friend I had where I live.  Unfortunately I developed a dependent attitude instead of being a leader and that really frustrated her.   But she was always there for me and trying to encourage me.  Despite my mental anguish I got a new job fairly quickly, although I jumped into it without thinking if I liked it and now I know I don't.

Since then I have wanted to break up but didn't because I didn't know what I would do with myself if I didn't have Karen as a friend.  I don't have any other close friends where I live.  The lack of physical attraction and my issues with some of her personality traits were always nagging at me but subdued by my neediness and the fact that she had been so considerate of me.

Karen was very pretty to me at first but has since willingly undergone some changes I don't like, despite my disapproval.  She cut her hair really short when I told her I like long hair.  She lost weight off her already small frame to the point of being underweight, when I like a body type that is athletic to average but with some curves.  She's extremely picky with food, and unfortunately that list doesn't include a lot of healthy items.  I want her to make reasonable changes that would make her more attractive.  I've done the same for her.  I've tried to open my mind, forcing myself to find her attractive but it's hard.

Am I wrong for wanting a woman that is attractive to me?  I guess I feel guilty because in the past I had some very superficial expectations, but that's not so true anymore.

This is so aggravating, I want to stay because Karen has been there for me in tough times and when I was sick.  She's mostly smart and responsible and has a lot of good qualities.  However, the negatives really get to me.  She said early on and has repeatedly said that if I'm not interested then I need to say so.  She said she's rather be sad with my honestly than be mad with living a lie.

Well, after all my reluctance to make a move, Karen hit me with a message a couple weeks ago asking if I was happy with her or if I was staying with her for convenience and didn't want to break up because I was afraid of hurting her feelings.  I broke down and admitted my longstanding unhappiness.  She was very hurt and angry, saying that she felt like she wasted the last 9 months of her life.  I recanted some of the things I said and have tried to patch things up without explicitly saying I want us to be a couple. 

Since then, we have done some things together.  We aren't as physical as we had been, just tickling and giving peck kisses.  Right now I'm in a holding pattern.  Some moments I want to love her for who she is and forget all the physical stuff, especially since if she made some changes I'd find her attractive in the future.  She is a person deserving of love from a man and what I would really like is to force myself to find her attractive.  Other moments I think I owe it to both of us to break up.  I'm experiencing lots of mixed feelings that make it hard for me to make decision, this one and other life decisions.  I know this torture is not what God wants for me. 

I want to get what I want and be a winner without feeling guilty.  But there are bad things about me that I am trying to break, depression and a lingering weakness to pornography that has had a stronghold in my life for over years.  I pray to God for help.  But it's hard to have discernment and I am often of two minds on lots of things.  I'm seeing a psychiatrist right now about depression, especially my lack of interests, motivation, and initiative.  I am also going to a small group meeting with other guys my age at a local church  (at the recommendation of Karen, and she is taking a ladies one).

Karen doesn't deserve to bear the brunt of my problems.  However, I've been open and admitted them to her.  She's not happy about them obviously but has been understanding.  I feel like I wouldn't have admitted these things to someone I didn't care about.  With depression, I have problems identifying what should make me happy and what shouldn't, and so I don't trust my feelings.  Hence the problems with making decisions.

I just don't know what to do.  I may sound like a real shabby guy.  I feel that way a lot.  At times I feel inspired, like she's the one and I want to marry her and be happy with her.  Obviously I'm not equipped for that right now.  But even if I break up I care about her deeply and don't want to hurt her.  Sorry for such a long message.  I hope it was clear. 

Thank you for your understanding and advice.  I'd rather hear it from people that are followers of Christ than elsewhere, which is why I'm here.  I love the Lord but I've lived a lot of my life taking my blessings for granted and being a CINO (Christian in name only).  Those attitudes have gotten to me.  I know I'm not a perfect person and not a perfect Christian.  I also know Karen isn't.  I just want to do what is right and will bring joy into my life.

My your day be blessed by Him.

IamStefanie

Hello OP,
Because you met this young lady in church does not mean she is the woman for you. Sure, we are all different, but certain values should match up between two people who desire marriage (I believe). It seems like you guys are completely different. The age difference is cool, but obviously her 'values' are different from yours. And that's OK. But that doesn't mean you should marry her because you have invested time. Sometimes we invest time in things that really aren't for us in the long term (God could also use these experience to bring you into Him, or closer to Him). You know if this lady is right for you or not. Follow what you know...

I just read the fact that you don't know if you love her. Let me tell you this, LOVE comes from God. Experience His love first. And the rest of your life will begin to make a little more sense.

Also, it sounds like you need to get yourself together and closer to Christ too. I'm not saying that as judgment or to be rude, but that's what I sense from you. You have some depression issues and while that's OK (thank God you are getting help for it and have admitted it), it's not healthy to get into a new relationship with someone with those sort of strongholds. Get closer to God as a single man. Pray more. Allow Him to have that alone time to heal you from the inside out and prepare you for the RIGHT woman.

Karen is probably a lovely lady, but she is on another level than you. You said 2 months into it you started to question whether she was the one or not; but then she was there for you. Yeah, that can make you want to stay, because now you are staying with this person out of appreciation for something they did. But really, you don't WANT them. You are just are being thankful for what they did. BIG DIFFERENCE. I've been there...

My story (in a nutshell). I wasn't re-born yet at this time (of the story). At the age of 23 (March of 07), I met this guy. Well, we hooked up (had sex) the same night we met. And we exchanged #s. . So I called him...And I found out that he was jobless and didn't have his stuff together. But he seemed so sweet. Now, at this time, I was just getting out of a relationship with a woman and planned on doing my own thing, then he came along. So, I guess the sex must have been so good because I was sprung. I allowed this man to stay at my home for a few days. Mind you, I'm a single mom so he said he would help me out with my son (it seemed like they got along very well) by taking him to school and picking him up (yes, I know, I didn't make smart choices). Well, anyway, I thought this was CONVENIENT for me. He would have a decent place to stay, I would get help with my boy. Cool, right? WRONG!! In about a month or so, I noticed how he got easily angered. At first I thought it was funny but it happened more often than not. Then I found out he had a pending court case. I also noticed that he lived pillar to post, you know, staying with his mom for a while, then staying with this friend here and there, and that he has 3 kids by 3 diff women. I also found out that he was dating this other girl when he had sex with me that first night, but I guess I was more 'stable' so he stayed with me (but I believe he was still 'with her' behind my back - that's another story though). So when I got that feeling of 'I don't think this is the right relationship', we argued and he would always cry, telling me how much he needs me and making me feel guilty for wanting to break up with him. (I had issues of my own because I let this go on obviously).

OK, so I stick it out, right (because I don't want to experience another break-up)? So, about 4 months in, I had some issues with my son's father and this boyfriend @ the time was very supportive of me. So I thought 'oh he is the one'. And while he was very rude at times to me, he treated my son OK (so I thought, but after the fact I realized it wasn't right with my son either. He never abused him or anything like that) but just didn't treat him well. The relationship just didn't seem right b/c little things I thought I liked about him started to disgust me. (so with you and Karen, it may not be her per se, it may be the disconnection you have with her and those little things are turning into big issues for you).

OK, so we start to go to church about 4 months into the relationship I guess. Now let me stop there - I hadn't broken up with him yet because I didn't want to go through another relationship nor did I want to hurt his feelings. Also, he had some health issues, so I didn't want to stress him out anymore. So, we started to attend church, it was great. I thought this was going to be a breakthrough for us. Things would get better I thought. Well, not really. He had been jobless through the whole relationship and hadn't done much at all (if anything) to find work. Well, we kept on going to church, and one of the ministers said to my (now ex) boyfriend: 'you better get yourself together or that girl (me) will leave you.' Guess that opened his eyes - LOL, so the next week, he proposed to me (Sept 16, 07) in front of the entire congregation. How COULD I say no? (I guess I could have just said it, but golly! that would have been devastating). So I said yes. Well, I planned a date and everything. But the relationship was getting worse. So I called it quits October of 2007.

We stay broken up for 2 months or so. We get back together. I'm talking about marriage. He's still the same. But this time, he says, 'why do we have to rush this thing?' Oh, I didn't mention, he was STILL LEGALLY MARRIED TO HIS FIRST BABY MAMA AT THE TIME! So, some sense starts to kick in. Now, when we broke up in Oct, I was the 'bad guy', I was wrong, I was called all sorts of names (but it's OK now because really, I didn't know what I wanted, and I wasn't sure if I truly loved him or not. I cared about him, yes, but I also was scared of breaking up with him more than anything). But the 2nd time around, I didn't stay in as long (March 5 2008 I was too through with him), I let him go (I have no hard feelings against this man, but I knew he wasn't the one for me). And in March of 2008, God saved me!! Yes! And I knew then, I had to get right with God I could be right with ANY man in a GODLY relationship! And after trying a few more whirlwind relationships after being saved, I have made a commitment to do this God's way. I am learning about God and what He desires and to get that into my heart and I'm learning what I want and need as well (of course God knows more than I do, but His spirit is within me, thanks be to God!). I won't go back to.

I know this is a long story, but I wanted to tell you that I understand. You know what you need to do. It's OK to be single for a while and it will be challenging at times but God is with you through it all. God will supply all of your needs. And he will give you peace during your 'singledom'.

May God bless you and keep you!

Stefanie

comfy

I think that is clear, Nash Guy. Thank you for sharing so personally. I'm glad Stefanie came. I think she has very special perspective. Thank you, Stefanie.

Nash Guy, one thing I'd say is Karen may want you, somehow, but it doesn't seem like she's interested in adapting in reasonable ways to you. And how you both are, now, is contributing to you two being not compatible, really, I suspect. So, if she gave you a fix of attention, this is not enough. And you both need to be with some more mature Christians, so you can be with people who have learned better how to relate with people. I hope ones in your group are more mature than just being pals and peers.

And I will offer, that if we are involved in something like pornography or immorality or other wrong things that have us hooked, the spirit of this degrades our ability to relate well with other people. We can not sin and be lovingly relating, at the same time.

I found a woman who was a match for my "list" of what I wanted in my wife. Since I was a white middle class prim and proper ex-religious sort, I wanted someone who was Afro, had been in a street sin-style so we together could be familiar with and reach to more people. And if she had AIDS, so much the better, so I could understand needy people and she could help me minister to people with AIDS. What a plan, eh? I was quietly delighted. And I had been in situations where I was sure I was going to die or could die and I understood Jesus does not want me to be impressed about dying; so, I was not afraid of death and suffering with her, in case I got AIDS. So, I acted accordingly, had it all figured out, like this ::doh::

But *sin* was the danger, not the AIDS. After the first night, already I could feel in myself how I was broken, down, not with it like I knew I could be in the goodness of the LORD. And the relating broke down, a little at a time; and I was not having the benefit of sharing with various brothers and sisters who were good for me, partly because of her interfering with me mixing with real Christians. She was jealous. But there was one line I would not cross; she tried to get me to join in her unforgiveness against someone. When she tried this, I basically knew there was no way for us.

So, with the first sin can come another and another, and breaking us down so we are not in God's love. And in our weakness it is easy to argue. But we have a basic commandment about how to love: "Do all things without complaining and disputing," (Philippians 2:14) Also, "Husbands, love your wives and do not be bitter toward them." (Colossians 3:19) To me, this means there is nothing, whatsoever, that excuses me to get bitter against my wife; and I would say this goes for all my relating with all people, too, in God's love. So, with every person I can practice this and train in this, in case God ever wants me to get married.

I'd say this is good, to become how I want to be in marriage with a really Christian lady, so that I can connect with a true lady of Jesus. How I really am can decide who I can connect with. But "how I want to be in marriage" needs to be, of course, how *You*, LORD, want me to become, including pleasing to You in Your love's "incorruptible beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is" so precious to You (see 1 Peter 3:4). And I can check myself out in relating with any and all people, to see if I'm becoming how God wants me to be submitting to Him and relating with people. There can not be any snapping back at people (James 1:19-20), not even in my mind. But be caring for any and all people, in prayer blessing (1 Peter 3:8-9).

And do only what God has me doing with Him in His peace (Colossians 3:15);
*this* can test if I belong with someone, or not exactly  ::idea::

And staying with this has gotten me involved with more and more different really Christian people who are good examples for me and encouraging me. And I've recently gotten invited to a couple of parties ::smile:: This, for me with a history of being a loner, is quite a record: two parties in two weeks, I think; once a year was more like it, while I stayed with my mommy.

So . . . God does not make copies, does He? ::smile::
God bless you, too ::smile::
                 Bill

janine

She's obviously not good enough for you.

At least, she doesn't seem to fit the requirements of what you think a woman ought to be, before you deign to relate to her as potential wife material.

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by 4WD
Today at 13:58:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Yesterday at 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Yesterday at 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Yesterday at 21:07:16

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Yesterday at 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Yesterday at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal