News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898031
Total Topics: 90351
Most Online Today: 4207
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 3499
Total: 3499
Google

Did the Crusades do more harm or good in your opinion?

Started by matt1, Mon Jun 04, 2012 - 12:27:53

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mclees8

Quote from: matt1 on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 05:31:27
No if I could see the Crusades for the Holy Land never happen I would be greatful
However, the fact remains, it seemed God worked some miracles when the Muslims were defeated at Spain, France, Italy, and Austria.
Im grateful that some brave men chose to fight rather than let their wives and children get raped, sodomized, enslaved, and murdered.
The Turks especially were into selling children to the sex trade where they would be raped every way possible by hundreds of men and die of STD's and be buried in a shallow unmarked grave without honor or a Christian burial.

Oh so if somebody was coming after your son/daughter to rape/murder him/her and you had the oppurtunity to protect her/him, would you do so?
Even if it meant firing a gun?
I understand turning the other cheek, but I think a man who chooses not to defend those who cannot defend themselves, when no one is there to defend them, is not much of a man.


I would have to agree with you on that point. But I wonder when the very early Christians were persecuted many things like that must have happened. Forgiving your enimy must be one of the hardest things a believer would ever have to do. I would wanto kiill the man who would touch my daugthter.

matt1

Especially when doing so could save her from having to endure such abuse that could cause her lifelong mental and emotional problems
I understand forgiving the guy that does such a thing
but what about stopping him from doing the deed in the first place?

AVZ

Quote from: matt1 on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 06:40:44
Especially when doing so could save her from having to endure such abuse that could cause her lifelong mental and emotional problems
I understand forgiving the guy that does such a thing
but what about stopping him from doing the deed in the first place?

I guess then nothing is holding us back from pre-emptive strikes on North Korea, Burma, Zimbabwe, Sudan and Syria

PS. If God would think exactly the same as you and kills everyone who sins or is going to sin...you wouldn't be alive.

FireSword

Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jun 11, 2012 - 19:51:21
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Jun 11, 2012 - 14:56:58
It depend on how one sees the crusades.

If one sees it as a force in order to convert people via the sword rather than evangelism, then this is clearly not a biblical mandate.

But if the crusades was a force to defend the existence of God's words and peoples, then why are we compelled to defend the destroyers.



You need to go back and truly learn about Jesus and his Gospel. Jesus could have called down a legion of angels to defend him and save Him from the cross. clearly you do not understand.

Ah you mean that Gods people do not need a gun to defend themselves or a sword, but need faith in God or his angels?

Ok that is a noble thought, but yet is it practical?

Most men do not have that kind of faith.

take the disciples of Jesus. These men waxed bold, as they continued to see God working with them. They then get confident enough as Jesus empowers them out to heal the sick and cast out devils.

but yet they are flesh and blood and after Jesus died, they fell into apathy and fear and no longer believed.

such is life of such temptations as to render a man faithless and many a time must rely on his flesh to survive.

Perhaps that's why Jesus said to his disciples, before he went to the cross, to go out and buy a sword.




AVZ

Quote from: FireSword on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 09:31:42
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jun 11, 2012 - 19:51:21
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Jun 11, 2012 - 14:56:58
It depend on how one sees the crusades.

If one sees it as a force in order to convert people via the sword rather than evangelism, then this is clearly not a biblical mandate.

But if the crusades was a force to defend the existence of God's words and peoples, then why are we compelled to defend the destroyers.



You need to go back and truly learn about Jesus and his Gospel. Jesus could have called down a legion of angels to defend him and save Him from the cross. clearly you do not understand.

Ah you mean that Gods people do not need a gun to defend themselves or a sword, but need faith in God or his angels?

Ok that is a noble thought, but yet is it practical?

Most men do not have that kind of faith.

take the disciples of Jesus. These men waxed bold, as they continued to see God working with them. They then get confident enough as Jesus empowers them out to heal the sick and cast out devils.

but yet they are flesh and blood and after Jesus died, they fell into apathy and fear and no longer believed.

such is life of such temptations as to render a man faithless and many a time must rely on his flesh to survive.

Perhaps that's why Jesus said to his disciples, before he went to the cross, to go out and buy a sword.


Sometimes a little white lie is also more practical.
You are saying, as long as it is more practical we can do whatever we want?

FireSword

Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 09:53:21
Quote from: FireSword on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 09:31:42
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jun 11, 2012 - 19:51:21
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Jun 11, 2012 - 14:56:58
It depend on how one sees the crusades.

If one sees it as a force in order to convert people via the sword rather than evangelism, then this is clearly not a biblical mandate.

But if the crusades was a force to defend the existence of God's words and peoples, then why are we compelled to defend the destroyers.



You need to go back and truly learn about Jesus and his Gospel. Jesus could have called down a legion of angels to defend him and save Him from the cross. clearly you do not understand.

Ah you mean that Gods people do not need a gun to defend themselves or a sword, but need faith in God or his angels?

Ok that is a noble thought, but yet is it practical?

Most men do not have that kind of faith.

take the disciples of Jesus. These men waxed bold, as they continued to see God working with them. They then get confident enough as Jesus empowers them out to heal the sick and cast out devils.

but yet they are flesh and blood and after Jesus died, they fell into apathy and fear and no longer believed.

such is life of such temptations as to render a man faithless and many a time must rely on his flesh to survive.

Perhaps that's why Jesus said to his disciples, before he went to the cross, to go out and buy a sword.


Sometimes a little white lie is also more practical.
You are saying, as long as it is more practical we can do whatever we want?

I'm saying the right perspective is needed always.


AVZ

Quote from: FireSword on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 10:02:58
I'm saying the right perspective is needed always.

And who is deciding the "right" perspective?
Where do you draw the line? General opinion, international pressure, economic consequences?

Jesus asks from us to place our lives in His hands, unconditionally.

Luke 21:10
"Then he said to them: Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom.
There will be great earthquakes, famines and pestilences in various places, and fearful events and great signs from heaven.
But before all this, they will lay hands on you and persecute you.
They will deliver you to synagogues and prisons, and you will be brought before kings and governors, and all on account of my name.
This will result in your being witnesses to them.
But make up your mind not to worry beforehand how you will defend yourselves.
For I will give you words and wisdom that none of your adversaries will be able to resist or contradict.
You will be betrayed even by parents, brothers, relatives and friends, and they will put some of you to death.
All men will hate you because of me.
But not a hair of your head will perish.
By standing firm you will gain life."

FireSword

Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 10:23:53
Quote from: FireSword on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 10:02:58
I'm saying the right perspective is needed always.

And who is deciding the "right" perspective?
Where do you draw the line? General opinion, international pressure, economic consequences?

Jesus asks from us to place our lives in His hands, unconditionally.

Luke 21:10
"Then he said to them: Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom.
There will be great earthquakes, famines and pestilences in various places, and fearful events and great signs from heaven.
But before all this, they will lay hands on you and persecute you.
They will deliver you to synagogues and prisons, and you will be brought before kings and governors, and all on account of my name.
This will result in your being witnesses to them.
But make up your mind not to worry beforehand how you will defend yourselves.
For I will give you words and wisdom that none of your adversaries will be able to resist or contradict.
You will be betrayed even by parents, brothers, relatives and friends, and they will put some of you to death.
All men will hate you because of me.
But not a hair of your head will perish.
By standing firm you will gain life."

I think it's a matter of concious whether it be right in Gods sight.

Because Gods will can vary.

Most Christians are defenceless and therefore give up their lives as martyrs and many, most do not have the ability to fight.

A poor widows choice does not necessarily mean that a Goliath or a David should follow her choice of martyrdom.

There are many reports of supernatural grace of God upon, martyrs, so that they are spared from pain.

Like wise there are also Gods supernatural grace upon the battlefield and that includes ministers healing injured soldiers.




AVZ

Quote from: FireSword on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 12:29:47
Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 10:23:53
Quote from: FireSword on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 10:02:58
I'm saying the right perspective is needed always.

And who is deciding the "right" perspective?
Where do you draw the line? General opinion, international pressure, economic consequences?

Jesus asks from us to place our lives in His hands, unconditionally.

Luke 21:10
"Then he said to them: Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom.
There will be great earthquakes, famines and pestilences in various places, and fearful events and great signs from heaven.
But before all this, they will lay hands on you and persecute you.
They will deliver you to synagogues and prisons, and you will be brought before kings and governors, and all on account of my name.
This will result in your being witnesses to them.
But make up your mind not to worry beforehand how you will defend yourselves.
For I will give you words and wisdom that none of your adversaries will be able to resist or contradict.
You will be betrayed even by parents, brothers, relatives and friends, and they will put some of you to death.
All men will hate you because of me.
But not a hair of your head will perish.
By standing firm you will gain life."

I think it's a matter of concious whether it be right in Gods sight.

Because Gods will can vary.

Most Christians are defenceless and therefore give up their lives as martyrs and many, most do not have the ability to fight.

A poor widows choice does not necessarily mean that a Goliath or a David should follow her choice of martyrdom.

There are many reports of supernatural grace of God upon, martyrs, so that they are spared from pain.

Like wise there are also Gods supernatural grace upon the battlefield and that includes ministers healing injured soldiers.

What do you mean, God's will can vary.
Are you saying God can change His plan for us? Like maybe today He wants us to be saved, but tomorrow He may want something different?

If that is indeed the case, you will never know "what is right in Gods sight", because what is right today may be wrong tomorrow.

FireSword

Romans 8:14
For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God.

Gods will can change, he might decide to punish someone with sickness, then he might repent and heal and remove the cankerworm his great army sent among .


I am not convinced with scriptures, whether man made defence is biblical or not biblical, so just like eating meat, I guess it is a matter of personal choice.

Perhaps those who truly follow the spirit will receive  victory just like David,while those who are deceived such as Saul who thought he did Gods will, are destroyed.

.


matt1

It is ridiculous for any of us to say we have all the Scriptures figured out.
There is so much that is not cut and dry.
Jesus said he did not come to abolish the Law but to perfect it.
nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. 1 Cor 6:10

Matthew 2541 "Then he will say to those on his left, 'Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.
42 For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink,
43 I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me.'
44 "They also will answer, 'Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing clothes or sick or in prison, and did not help you?'
45 "He will reply, 'Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.'
46 "Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life.

AVZ

Quote from: matt1 on Tue Jun 12, 2012 - 21:23:44
It is ridiculous for any of us to say we have all the Scriptures figured out.
There is so much that is not cut and dry.
Jesus said he did not come to abolish the Law but to perfect it.
nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. 1 Cor 6:10

Matthew 2541 "Then he will say to those on his left, 'Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.
42 For I was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink,
43 I was a stranger and you did not invite me in, I needed clothes and you did not clothe me, I was sick and in prison and you did not look after me.'
44 "They also will answer, 'Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing clothes or sick or in prison, and did not help you?'
45 "He will reply, 'Truly I tell you, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.'
46 "Then they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life.

matt1

I actually never said the Catholic Church has it all right.
The truth is, "I dont know".
I can prove nothing.
I do feel from my research that it can be proven that there were no Protestant Churches until the 16th century.
I feel it is clear that the Church dates back to Christ.

I have tried many Churches Pentecostal/baptist/seventh day adventist/Messainic/non-denominational  (even did some research on Mormonism and Islam thank God i got disenchanted right away)

I find that right now I feel like im wasting my time with religions other than Catholicism
However, I do like to pray with Protestants, I have plenty of Protestant friends, i admit many of them are more fervent about the faith than a lot of Catholics I know

It doesnt change the fact that I get more out of recieving the Eucharist at a catholic Church than a protestant Church
I feel there is something missing at protestant churches
Plus I dont Jive with all the "Rapture" hysteria and all these people giving their end time hypothesis and their understanding of Revelation
I believe God established an authoritative interpreter of his Word because he knew many people would encounter confusion.


FireSword

QuoteIt might be helpful to review a few facts about the Roman Papacy.  To begin with, in the year 754 AD, the Pope officially became a civil ruler as well as a religious leader, a situation that would last until 1870--more than 1000 years.  During this period, the concept of Church governance became deeply tied in with that of a monarchical form of government, in which two things were accepted as self-evident:•No government can be effective without having the fullness of authority vested in one person
•Laws are to be enforced by coercion, using whatever means necessary to achieve compliance
First of all, one can easily see how a Papacy with that kind of attitude contributed to both the Great Schism and the Reformation.  What's not so easy to see is the progress that's been made since 1870 to "back away" from this monarchical (worldly) concept of the Papacy.

One of the first very visible signs of this transformation (there have been others that weren't so visible) came in 1963, when Pope Paul VI, after receiving the papal crown, set it aside and never used it again--no Pope since then has ever been crowned.  More recently, Pope Benedict XVI had his papal coat of arms designed with the image of a bishop's mitre in place of the usual image of the papal crown, starting a new tradition that Pope Francis has continued.

Yes, these are symbolic gestures, but they were made for a reason (and I do not believe deception was the reason!).  In addition to these gestures, we have the fact that both Protestant and Orthodox theologians were invited to participate as consultants at the 2nd Vatican Council (1962-1966).  These consultants took their roles very seriously, and the comments they made and the insight they provided were in turn taken very seriously by the Catholic bishops.  Since that time, high-level dialogues have gone on between Catholic theologians and both Protestant and Orthodox theologians, and both popes and bishops have endorsed them.

So, why is all this so significant?  Because it shows the fallacy of "one party says it's black and the other party says its white," as well as thinking of Rome as saying "I don't have to listen to you, you must listen to me."  (Only fools keep talking when nobody's listening--I don't think these people are fools.)

Eucephenis


I think this is another reason for the crusades is that the pope acted as a king as well as a pope and had to secure Europe from the Saracen and protect the church from Islam taking over and destroying bibles.
I don't understand why they the crusades had to attack minority religious groups though, such as cathars.


BlackSepulcher

#49
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jun 04, 2012 - 14:15:29
Quote from: matt1 on Mon Jun 04, 2012 - 12:27:53
Did the Crusades do more harm or good? Your opinion?
The purpose of this thread is to have an open debate on whether the Crusades did more good or harm.
 
What is your opinion about the Crusades?
You are surely ashamed of the atrocities, as I am.

These might not seem like advantages to you, but they clearly benefited the Christians of that time,
The failed Crusades at the Holy land caused the Muslims to concentrate their forces at the Holy land rather than being able to concentrate forces on conquering mainland European countries.

The First Crusade achieved its military objectives, postponing the Muslim expansionists for many years.
Crusades brought Christendom into contact with more advanced east that they learned much from.
New priceless relics from the Holy land were taken back to Europe.
New supplies and inventions from the East were brought back to Europe.

Also, because of the Crusades, Christians were able to have control of the Holy Sepulchre and other pilgrimage sites which they still had control over up until the 20th century.
I don't understand this because the Crusades cost so much, but the wealth and power of the Church increased dramatically during and because of the Crusades, according to what I read.

Improved navigational knowledge allowed Europeans such as Marco Polo to explore more of the world and to have better trade routs to Asia.
Western hygiene improved.
Thousands of the crusaders, returning broken in spirits and in health, having seen their brethren die,
realized how short, fragile and vain this life is, and began entering monasteries and becoming consecrated religious brothers, priests, and deacons.

War usually produces more vocations. For example, after World War 2 there was a huge boom in religious vocations.
In addition to this, the increase of piety, prayer, and penance among Europeans back home exploded with unprecedented fervor and religious enthusiasm that dominated this period in Church History.

Even in the failed Crusade to save the Byzantine Empire and Constantinople, by repeatedly repelling the advancing Turks, the fall of Constantinople was postponed for more than three centuries.
This gave the early Christian civilization of Germany time to acquire sufficient strength to defeat the tide of Mohammedan invaders who assaulted Europe in the fifteenth century.

The Crusades also humbled Christians and brought back many men who had great sympathy for their enemies.
They brought these sympathies back to Christendom which prevented future mistakes, and still exists to this day.
Well, the Christian armies that went on the Crusades hadn't come from countries that had been evangelized much, and the Church still had a lot of growing to do.

Many of the soldiers who went on the Crusades had a lust for luxury, Glory, and adventure.
They were not going there for God or with purity of intention. And for the most part, many of them were Christian by name and not by deed.

In fact, when they sacked Constantinople, they were disobeying the orders of the Pope. God let it become a disaster just like he let the Israelites fall into military disasters when they were unfaithful and disobedient.
However, many of the Crusaders, who were corrupt and immoral men before the Crusades, found God, repented, and lived penitential lives as a result of the Crusades.

Consider this, the Crusades defeated the Muslim expansionists at Spain, France, Italy, and Austria.
Spain and France literally had to be reconquered.
Had there been no organized military force to combat the Muslims, Europe would today be Muslim.

Also, the feast of our Lady of the Rosary was instituted on the Day (Oct 7) that the Christians defeated the Turks at Lepanto, saving Rome from being conquered.
It was God and our Lady's will that the Christians should win that battle.
This proves that God was at least some of the time, on the side of the Crusaders.

Saint Louis IX, king, confessor of the Faith, a leader of a crusade and model of a Catholic head of state, died fighting for this cause.
Could it be that great Saints were lead into fighting and dying for an evil cause or an unjust war?

People accuse the Crusades as being unprovoked aggressors.
Interesting, the Crusades were all fought on Christian soil or land that had been Christian and was conquered by the Muslims.
Long before the Crusades began the Muslims had conquered more than 25% of Christendom. In fact, Muslims have been unceasingly at war.

War that began when Mohammed was alive and continues to this day in many countries.
Shouldn't it be considered just for people to defend themselves?
And does the Church not to this day believe in a just war.

I personally think we owe a debt of gratitude to the Christians soldiers who payed the ultimate sacrifice which prevented all of Christendom from being conquered, our religion made illegal, and the Koran replacing the Bible.

Please refute whatever you may object to.


There is simply no opinion here. The crusades were not of Christ but of men. we are not taking the world by force then or now. Jesus nor the apsotles ever taught that his church was to raise up an army relgious or politically to fight anyone. Did the apostles or any of the persecuted early believers take up arms?. No! The church of Jesus Christ was never to be a religious political power rulling empires and building armies. There is no good or bad to reflect on or any justification. The church that did this was not Christs true church but one that was far from Him.

The Bible states that the gates of Hell will not prevail against the Church. It is also stated that Jesus did not come to bring peace, but a sword. This no doubt is dictating that there is a difference in gambit between personal belief and political endeavors.

The Crusades strengthened the Christian world, which expanded it as well as kept it relevant and current. Without such, Christianity may very well not have even existed past that age.


mclees8

#50
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Aug 23, 2013 - 14:02:45
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jun 04, 2012 - 14:15:29
Quote from: matt1 on Mon Jun 04, 2012 - 12:27:53
Did the Crusades do more harm or good? Your opinion?
The purpose of this thread is to have an open debate on whether the Crusades did more good or harm.
 
What is your opinion about the Crusades?
You are surely ashamed of the atrocities, as I am.

These might not seem like advantages to you, but they clearly benefited the Christians of that time,
The failed Crusades at the Holy land caused the Muslims to concentrate their forces at the Holy land rather than being able to concentrate forces on conquering mainland European countries.

The First Crusade achieved its military objectives, postponing the Muslim expansionists for many years.
Crusades brought Christendom into contact with more advanced east that they learned much from.
New priceless relics from the Holy land were taken back to Europe.
New supplies and inventions from the East were brought back to Europe.

Also, because of the Crusades, Christians were able to have control of the Holy Sepulchre and other pilgrimage sites which they still had control over up until the 20th century.
I don't understand this because the Crusades cost so much, but the wealth and power of the Church increased dramatically during and because of the Crusades, according to what I read.

Improved navigational knowledge allowed Europeans such as Marco Polo to explore more of the world and to have better trade routs to Asia.
Western hygiene improved.
Thousands of the crusaders, returning broken in spirits and in health, having seen their brethren die,
realized how short, fragile and vain this life is, and began entering monasteries and becoming consecrated religious brothers, priests, and deacons.

War usually produces more vocations. For example, after World War 2 there was a huge boom in religious vocations.
In addition to this, the increase of piety, prayer, and penance among Europeans back home exploded with unprecedented fervor and religious enthusiasm that dominated this period in Church History.

Even in the failed Crusade to save the Byzantine Empire and Constantinople, by repeatedly repelling the advancing Turks, the fall of Constantinople was postponed for more than three centuries.
This gave the early Christian civilization of Germany time to acquire sufficient strength to defeat the tide of Mohammedan invaders who assaulted Europe in the fifteenth century.

The Crusades also humbled Christians and brought back many men who had great sympathy for their enemies.
They brought these sympathies back to Christendom which prevented future mistakes, and still exists to this day.
Well, the Christian armies that went on the Crusades hadn't come from countries that had been evangelized much, and the Church still had a lot of growing to do.

Many of the soldiers who went on the Crusades had a lust for luxury, Glory, and adventure.
They were not going there for God or with purity of intention. And for the most part, many of them were Christian by name and not by deed.

In fact, when they sacked Constantinople, they were disobeying the orders of the Pope. God let it become a disaster just like he let the Israelites fall into military disasters when they were unfaithful and disobedient.
However, many of the Crusaders, who were corrupt and immoral men before the Crusades, found God, repented, and lived penitential lives as a result of the Crusades.

Consider this, the Crusades defeated the Muslim expansionists at Spain, France, Italy, and Austria.
Spain and France literally had to be reconquered.
Had there been no organized military force to combat the Muslims, Europe would today be Muslim.

Also, the feast of our Lady of the Rosary was instituted on the Day (Oct 7) that the Christians defeated the Turks at Lepanto, saving Rome from being conquered.
It was God and our Lady's will that the Christians should win that battle.
This proves that God was at least some of the time, on the side of the Crusaders.

Saint Louis IX, king, confessor of the Faith, a leader of a crusade and model of a Catholic head of state, died fighting for this cause.
Could it be that great Saints were lead into fighting and dying for an evil cause or an unjust war?

People accuse the Crusades as being unprovoked aggressors.
Interesting, the Crusades were all fought on Christian soil or land that had been Christian and was conquered by the Muslims.
Long before the Crusades began the Muslims had conquered more than 25% of Christendom. In fact, Muslims have been unceasingly at war.

War that began when Mohammed was alive and continues to this day in many countries.
Shouldn't it be considered just for people to defend themselves?
And does the Church not to this day believe in a just war.

I personally think we owe a debt of gratitude to the Christians soldiers who payed the ultimate sacrifice which prevented all of Christendom from being conquered, our religion made illegal, and the Koran replacing the Bible.

Please refute whatever you may object to.


There is simply no opinion here. The crusades were not of Christ but of men. we are not taking the world by force then or now. Jesus nor the apsotles ever taught that his church was to raise up an army relgious or politically to fight anyone. Did the apostles or any of the persecuted early believers take up arms?. No! The church of Jesus Christ was never to be a religious political power rulling empires and building armies. There is no good or bad to reflect on or any justification. The church that did this was not Christs true church but one that was far from Him.

The Bible states that the gates of Hell will not prevail against the Church. It is also stated that Jesus did not come to bring peace, but a sword. This no doubt is dictating that there is a difference in gambit between personal belief and political endeavors.

The Crusades strengthened the Christian world, which expanded it as well as kept it relevant and current. Without such, Christianity may very well not have even existed past that age.



It did no such thing, but only to misrepresent  and give a very wrong idea of the church Jesus founded . You misuse scripture to justify what was not justified.  Either you don't think I know scripture and what it says, or you have a very poor command of scripture yourself

First Jesus does not have to raise an army to defend it against hell. That war is in the spirit which is something you may no little of.  Since the church is first established in our hearts  and by His Holy Spirit the gates of hell cannot prevail against  it. No not even death for our faith for it is eternal.  Long before the Vatican the apostle were martyred   and many believers were martyred also for the faith and I tell you the gates of hell could not steel Christ form them nor did the church need political support to survive.  But I tell you right now what is of men and brick and mortar will be destroyed surely as the  stones of the Temple came down so  also shall the Vatican be a ruins.

Next you say misquote Jesus when he said He came to bring a sword because you left out the rest which says the a mans enemy would be of his own house. This meant that there was going to be division and hatred because of one coming to Christ in a house where the family will reject and despise him to go against the families beliefs.

And again I tell you Jesus does not force or use the sword to make war by religious political means.  We do not use armies as  police to enforce law or even dogmas.

Helen

Did the Crusades do more harm than good?  The Crusades did nothing but harm -- the Muslims are still using them as an excuse to attack Christians everywhere.  Most of the Crusades ended up with most the Crusaders, children and adults, dead.  The promise that if one went on a Crusade one was guaranteed a place in heaven was a hellish lie. 

FireSword

Quote from: Helen on Wed Aug 28, 2013 - 16:57:12
Did the Crusades do more harm than good?  The Crusades did nothing but harm -- the Muslims are still using them as an excuse to attack Christians everywhere.  Most of the Crusades ended up with most the Crusaders, children and adults, dead.  The promise that if one went on a Crusade one was guaranteed a place in heaven was a hellish lie.

Lives are always lost in war and sometimes war is needed for peace.

If Muslims today use the crusades to justify murder then they need to repent for harbouring such ill conceived thoughts.

The going to heaven for fighting is probably a lie.

BlackSepulcher

#53
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Aug 26, 2013 - 13:51:08
It did no such thing, but only to misrepresent  and give a very wrong idea of the church Jesus founded . You misuse scripture to justify what was not justified.  Either you don't think I know scripture and what it says, or you have a very poor command of scripture yourself

It takes an extreme amount of naivety to believe that the world wouldn't have swallowed Christendom whole if it weren't for such actions.
Think about the fact that is was the Medieval Ages- a very hostile and unforgiving time.

Thought about it? Good, now accept the fact that you are just complaining from an ivory tower. I can only imagine what the consequence would have been if Christendom simply put it's head to the heels of heretics; you WOULD NOT be a Christian today, I can promise you this.



Catholica

Quote from: Helen on Wed Aug 28, 2013 - 16:57:12
Did the Crusades do more harm than good?  The Crusades did nothing but harm -- the Muslims are still using them as an excuse to attack Christians everywhere. 

That's actually not true.  Muslims in general don't even remember the crusades.  It is only those opponents of the Catholic Church who like to bring them up as some kind of "proof text" against the Catholic Church's authority.

Case in point, here is a list of "crusades" by the Muslims during the first 400 years of Islam, before the first crusade ever happened:

630 Two years before Muhammad's death of a fever, he launches the Tabuk Crusades, in which he led 30,000 jihadists against the Byzantine Christians. He had heard a report that a huge army had amassed to attack Arabia, but the report turned out to be a false rumor. The Byzantine army never materialized. He turned around and went home, but not before extracting 'agreements' from northern tribes. They could enjoy the 'privilege' of living under Islamic 'protection' (read: not be attacked by Islam), if they paid a tax (jizya).
This tax sets the stage for Muhammad's and the later Caliphs' policies. If the attacked city or region did not want to convert to Islam, then they paid a jizya tax. If they converted, then they paid a zakat tax. Either way, money flowed back to the Islamic treasury in Arabia or to the local Muslim governor.
632-634 Under the Caliphate of Abu Bakr the Muslim Crusaders reconquer and sometimes conquer for the first time the polytheists of Arabia. These Arab polytheists had to convert to Islam or die. They did not have the choice of remaining in their faith and paying a tax. Islam does not allow for religious freedom.
633 The Muslim Crusaders, led by Khalid al-Walid, a superior but bloodthirsty military commander, whom Muhammad nicknamed the Sword of Allah for his ferocity in battle (Tabari, 8:158 / 1616-17), conquer the city of Ullays along the Euphrates River (in today's Iraq). Khalid captures and beheads so many that a nearby canal, into which the blood flowed, was called Blood Canal (Tabari 11:24 / 2034-35).
634 At the Battle of Yarmuk in Syria the Muslim Crusaders defeat the Byzantines. Today Osama bin Laden draws inspiration from the defeat, and especially from an anecdote about Khalid al-Walid. An unnamed Muslim remarks: 'The Romans are so numerous and the Muslims so few.'  To this Khalid retorts: 'How few are the Romans, and how many the Muslims! Armies become numerous only with victory and few only with defeat, not by the number of men. By God, I would love it . . . if the enemy were twice as many' (Tabari, 11:94 / 2095). Osama bin Ladin quotes Khalid and says that his fighters love death more than we in the West love life. This philosophy of death probably comes from a verse like Sura 2:96. Muhammad assesses the Jews: '[Prophet], you are sure to find them [the Jews] clinging to life more eagerly than any other people, even polytheists' (MAS Abdel Haleem, The Qur'an, Oxford UP, 2004; first insertion in brackets is Haleem's; the second mine).
634-644 The Caliphate of Umar ibn al-Khattab, who is regarded as particularly brutal.
635 Muslim Crusaders besiege and conquer of Damascus
636 Muslim Crusaders defeat Byzantines decisively at Battle of Yarmuk.
637 Muslim Crusaders conquer Iraq at the Battle of al-Qadisiyyah (some date it in 635 or 636)
638 Muslim Crusaders conquer and annex Jerusalem, taking it from the Byzantines.
638-650 Muslim Crusaders conquer Iran, except along Caspian Sea.
639-642 Muslim Crusaders conquer Egypt.
641 Muslim Crusaders control Syria and Palestine.
643-707 Muslim Crusaders conquer North Africa.
644 Caliph Umar is assassinated by a Persian prisoner of war; Uthman ibn Affan is elected third Caliph, who is regarded by many Muslims as gentler than Umar.
644-650 Muslim Crusaders conquer Cyprus, Tripoli in North Africa, and establish Islamic rule in Iran, Afghanistan, and Sind.
656 Caliph Uthman is assassinated by disgruntled Muslim soldiers; Ali ibn Abi Talib, son-in-law and cousin to Muhammad, who married the prophet's daughter Fatima through his first wife Khadija, is set up as Caliph.
656 Battle of the Camel, in which Aisha, Muhammad's wife, leads a rebellion against Ali for not avenging Uthman's assassination. Ali's partisans win.
657 Battle of Siffin between Ali and Muslim governor of Jerusalem, arbitration goes against Ali
661 Murder of Ali by an extremist; Ali's supporters acclaim his son Hasan as next Caliph, but he comes to an agreement with Muawiyyah I and retires to Medina.
661-680 the Caliphate of Muawiyyah I. He founds Umayyid dynasty and moves capital from Medina to Damascus
673-678 Arabs besiege Constantinople, capital of Byzantine Empire
680 Massacre of Hussein (Muhammad's grandson), his family, and his supporters in Karbala, Iraq.
691 Dome of the Rock is completed in Jerusalem, only six decades after Muhammad's death.
705 Abd al-Malik restores Umayyad rule.
710-713 Muslim Crusaders conquer the lower Indus Valley.
711-713 Muslim Crusaders conquer Spain and impose the kingdom of Andalus. This article recounts how Muslims today still grieve over their expulsion 700 years later. They seem to believe that the land belonged to them in the first place.
719 Cordova, Spain, becomes seat of Arab governor
732 The Muslim Crusaders stopped at the Battle of Poitiers; that is, Franks (France) halt Arab advance
749 The Abbasids conquer Kufah and overthrow Umayyids
756 Foundation of Umayyid amirate in Cordova, Spain, setting up an independent kingdom from Abbasids
762 Foundation of Baghdad
785 Foundation of the Great Mosque of Cordova
789 Rise of Idrisid amirs (Muslim Crusaders) in Morocco; foundation of Fez; Christoforos, a Muslim who converted to Christianity, is executed.
800 Autonomous Aghlabid dynasty (Muslim Crusaders) in Tunisia
807 Caliph Harun al-Rashid orders the destruction of non-Muslim prayer houses and of the church of Mary Magdalene in Jerusalem
809 Aghlabids (Muslim Crusaders) conquer Sardinia, Italy
813 Christians in Palestine are attacked; many flee the country
831 Muslim Crusaders capture Palermo, Italy; raids in Southern Italy
850 Caliph al-Matawakkil orders the destruction of non-Muslim houses of prayer
855 Revolt of the Christians of Hims (Syria)
837-901 Aghlabids (Muslim Crusaders) conquer Sicily, raid Corsica, Italy, France
869-883 Revolt of black slaves in Iraq
909 Rise of the Fatimid Caliphate in Tunisia; these Muslim Crusaders occupy Sicily, Sardinia
928-969 Byzantine military revival, they retake old territories, such as Cyprus (964) and Tarsus (969)
937 The Ikhshid, a particularly harsh Muslim ruler, writes to Emperor Romanus, boasting of his control over the holy places
937 The Church of the Resurrection (known as Church of Holy Sepulcher in Latin West) is burned down by Muslims; more churches in Jerusalem are attacked
960 Conversion of Qarakhanid Turks to Islam
966 Anti-Christian riots in Jerusalem
969 Fatimids (Muslim Crusaders) conquer Egypt and found Cairo
c. 970 Seljuks enter conquered Islamic territories from the East
973 Israel and southern Syria are again conquered by the Fatimids
1003 First persecutions by al-Hakim; the Church of St. Mark in Fustat, Egypt, is destroyed
1009 Destruction of the Church of the Resurrection by al-Hakim (see 937)
1012 Beginning of al-Hakim's oppressive decrees against Jews and Christians
1015 Earthquake in Palestine; the dome of the Dome of the Rock collapses
1031 Collapse of Umayyid Caliphate and establishment of 15 minor independent dynasties throughout Muslim Andalus
1048 Reconstruction of the Church of the Resurrection completed
1050 Creation of Almoravid (Muslim Crusaders) movement in Mauretania; Almoravids (aka Murabitun) are coalition of western Saharan Berbers; followers of Islam, focusing on the Quran, the hadith, and Maliki law.
1055 Seljuk Prince Tughrul enters Baghdad, consolidation of the Seljuk Sultanate
1055 Confiscation of property of Church of the Resurrection
1071 Battle of Manzikert, Seljuk Turks (Muslim Crusaders) defeat Byzantines and occupy much of Anatolia
1071 Turks (Muslim Crusaders) invade Palestine
1073 Conquest of Jerusalem by Turks (Muslim Crusaders)
1075 Seljuks (Muslim Crusaders) capture Nicea (Iznik) and make it their capital in Anatolia
1076 Almoravids (Muslim Crusaders) (see 1050) conquer western Ghana
1085 Toledo is taken back by Christian armies
1086 Almoravids (Muslim Crusaders) (see 1050) send help to Andalus, Battle of Zallaca
1090-1091 Almoravids (Muslim Crusaders) occupy all of Andalus except Saragossa and Balearic Islands
1094 Byzantine emperor Alexius Comnenus I asks western Christendom for help against Seljuk invasions of his territory; Seljuks are Muslim Turkish family of eastern origins; see 970
1095 Pope Urban II preaches first Crusade; they capture Jerusalem in 1099

It is nonsense to believe that Christians fighting back made even a ripple in the mindsets of Muslims.  The only thing that really bothered them was when the first crusade took back Spain and the Iberian peninsula.  Once they conquer something, they consider it to be Muslim territory forever.

Quote from: Helen on Wed Aug 28, 2013 - 16:57:12
Most of the Crusades ended up with most the Crusaders, children and adults, dead.  The promise that if one went on a Crusade one was guaranteed a place in heaven was a hellish lie. 

It was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.

mclees8

#55
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Aug 29, 2013 - 11:47:54
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Aug 26, 2013 - 13:51:08
It did no such thing, but only to misrepresent  and give a very wrong idea of the church Jesus founded . You misuse scripture to justify what was not justified.  Either you don't think I know scripture and what it says, or you have a very poor command of scripture yourself

It takes an extreme amount of naivety to believe that the world wouldn't have swallowed Christendom whole if it weren't for such actions.
Think about the fact that is was the Medieval Ages- a very hostile and unforgiving time.

Thought about it? Good, now accept the fact that you are just complaining from an ivory tower. I can only imagine what the consequence would have been if Christendom simply put it's head to the heels of heretics; you WOULD NOT be a Christian today, I can promise you this.




What I find sad is not being able to see the church that Jesus truly founded based on reaching the lost with the Gospel of Salvation, and being at peace with all men. It is one thing for a man to defend His family from evil men. It is quite another to think that the church was to raise armies to fight off Muslims and chase down heretics.

You sight that the medieval church was during a hostile and unforgiving time and think this is justification for crusaders. The whole world is hostile and unforgiving since the fall of man. What about  the early church long before crusaders and monarchial popes being brutalized in coliseums, and tortured and made into lampposts for garden parties? Was that not  a very cruel and dark time. Nothing in our New Testament said we were to take up the sword and build armies. Jesus could have had legions of angels to save Him from the cross. He told Peter to put down his sword. The apostles were martyred with out a fight as well multitudes of Christians who went peaceably to their death for the Gospel.

And you then call me naïve.  We are not like the world where war is common. It is always going to be a cruel and unforgiving world because sin still exists. Why else the judgment. Why then the souls under the alter saying how long before we are avenged for giving their life for Christ sake. These are the ones who shall have justice on that day.   

I don't know what Gospel you are living by but it is not Christ gospel. Get your head out of the world and its politics. 

What does the pope say about Syria. What if some of those are Christians caught up in a war that they had nothing to do with. What about the persecuted church all over this hostile world being martyred every day because they loved not their life to the death for Christ sake who take up no sword. The only army for us is the one who Christ Himself shall lead clothed in the white robes of truth and righteousness. Rev. 19: 11 - 16 

1 And I saw heaven opened, and behold a white horse; and he that sat upon him was called Faithful and True, and in righteousness he doth judge and make war. 12 † His eyes were as a flame of fire, and on his head were many crowns; and he had a name written, that no man knew, but he himself. 13 And he was clothed with a vesture dipped in blood: and his name is called The Word of God. 14 And the armies which were† in heaven followed him upon white horses, clothed in fine linen, white and clean. 15 And out of his mouth goeth a sharp sword, that with it he should smite the nations: and he shall rule them with a rod of iron: and he treadeth the winepress of the fierceness and wrath of Almighty God. 16 And he hath on his vesture and on his thigh a name written, KING OF KINGS, AND LORD OF LORDS. 



Helen

QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.

Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm

Catholica

#57
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

Helen

Ok, try this one:

" One of the major incentives for many was the guarantee of eternal life as well the granting of indulgences for those who participated in the crusades. Roman Catholic doctrine teaches that there are two kinds of sin: mortal and venial. Venial sins require satisfaction, or temporal punishment, e.g., performance of some prescribed good work, an act of self-denial, or after death, time in purgatory. However, venial sins do not endanger one's eternal salvation. Mortal sins not only require temporal punishment, but also endanger one's eternal salvation. When absolution is granted by a priest, the guilt of a sin is removed but temporal punishment is still required. A penance imposed by a priest is a good work required as satisfaction for sin. However, an indulgence can be substituted for penance or time spent in purgatory. "A plenary indulgence removes all the temporal punishment due to a sin; a partial indulgence removes some or part of the temporal penalties still owed to God after he forgives our sins" (THE QUESTION AND ANSWER CATHOLIC CATECHISM, John A. Hardon, p. 278).

The theory that was developed in the 13th century to explain the practice of indulgences is this: The good works of Jesus and the saints constitute a treasury of extra merit in heaven, which can be administered by the Church to its members as satisfaction for sin. It should be emphasized that the explanation for the efficacy of Indulgences had not yet been made when they were used in the 11th and 12th centuries.

The various promises made by various popes during the crusades included eternal life to crusaders and parents of crusaders, and plenary indulgence to those who contributed in any way to the crusades, whether by going himself, sending someone in his place, or aiding in the construction of ships which would carry the crusaders."

from http://www.diktuon.com/smelser_j/history7.htm

What your church has taught you is some very, VERY whitewashed history.

mclees8

Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

Catholica

Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:02:38
Ok, try this one:

" One of the major incentives for many was the guarantee of eternal life as well the granting of indulgences for those who participated in the crusades. Roman Catholic doctrine teaches that there are two kinds of sin: mortal and venial. Venial sins require satisfaction, or temporal punishment, e.g., performance of some prescribed good work, an act of self-denial, or after death, time in purgatory. However, venial sins do not endanger one's eternal salvation. Mortal sins not only require temporal punishment, but also endanger one's eternal salvation. When absolution is granted by a priest, the guilt of a sin is removed but temporal punishment is still required. A penance imposed by a priest is a good work required as satisfaction for sin. However, an indulgence can be substituted for penance or time spent in purgatory. "A plenary indulgence removes all the temporal punishment due to a sin; a partial indulgence removes some or part of the temporal penalties still owed to God after he forgives our sins" (THE QUESTION AND ANSWER CATHOLIC CATECHISM, John A. Hardon, p. 278).

The theory that was developed in the 13th century to explain the practice of indulgences is this: The good works of Jesus and the saints constitute a treasury of extra merit in heaven, which can be administered by the Church to its members as satisfaction for sin. It should be emphasized that the explanation for the efficacy of Indulgences had not yet been made when they were used in the 11th and 12th centuries.

The various promises made by various popes during the crusades included eternal life to crusaders and parents of crusaders, and plenary indulgence to those who contributed in any way to the crusades, whether by going himself, sending someone in his place, or aiding in the construction of ships which would carry the crusaders."

from http://www.diktuon.com/smelser_j/history7.htm

What your church has taught you is some very, VERY whitewashed history.

Crusaders were promised eternal life IF they died on crusade.  That is the same thing as being a martyr.  That being said: 

Greater love has no one than this, than to lay down one's life for his friends. John 15:13

Martyrs for the faith go to heaven.

As for those "parents of crusaders" I cannot find any such guarantee of eternal life made by the Church.  As for indulgences, I can't find any information save for those who actually went on crusade.  And your source has no references given.  Which makes it as good as popular myth.



Catholica

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:20:07
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

The Lord chastises every son he acknowledges.  Hebrews 12:6ff.  That is what is meant by "punishment" by "temporal punishment" is that chastisement for sins.  It is part of the sanctification process and due to God's justice and love.  God wants us to be perfect, and sin leaves a stain on our soul.

The goal of a secular court punishing law breakers has a good purpose, which is an external influence to both keep someone from breaking a crime or for justice due to a crime and time to reform from evil actions.  Jail time is not only good for the protection of society but also is meant to help the criminal reform.

We know that nothing unclean will enter heaven.  Rev. 21:27.  In that case, which I believe, I am thankful for purgatory, indulgences and the mercy of God.  Because there is very little possibility that anyone is truly ready to be in God's presence in our fallen, redeemed but imperfect state.  That is how holy God is.

mclees8

#62
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:01:21
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:20:07
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

The Lord chastises every son he acknowledges.  Hebrews 12:6ff.  That is what is meant by "punishment" by "temporal punishment" is that chastisement for sins.  It is part of the sanctification process and due to God's justice and love.  God wants us to be perfect, and sin leaves a stain on our soul.

The goal of a secular court punishing law breakers has a good purpose, which is an external influence to both keep someone from breaking a crime or for justice due to a crime and time to reform from evil actions.  Jail time is not only good for the protection of society but also is meant to help the criminal reform.

We know that nothing unclean will enter heaven.  Rev. 21:27.  In that case, which I believe, I am thankful for purgatory, indulgences and the mercy of God.  Because there is very little possibility that anyone is truly ready to be in God's presence in our fallen, redeemed but imperfect state.  That is how holy God is.

I want to ask three  questions. Who is a Son that he should be chastised?

Who is a heretic? 

Who is one who obeys the law of the land but does not abide by the church.  ( Midlevel times)


We all know that secular  law is necessary.   

Please just give short and direct answers.


Catholica

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:01:21
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:20:07
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

The Lord chastises every son he acknowledges.  Hebrews 12:6ff.  That is what is meant by "punishment" by "temporal punishment" is that chastisement for sins.  It is part of the sanctification process and due to God's justice and love.  God wants us to be perfect, and sin leaves a stain on our soul.

The goal of a secular court punishing law breakers has a good purpose, which is an external influence to both keep someone from breaking a crime or for justice due to a crime and time to reform from evil actions.  Jail time is not only good for the protection of society but also is meant to help the criminal reform.

We know that nothing unclean will enter heaven.  Rev. 21:27.  In that case, which I believe, I am thankful for purgatory, indulgences and the mercy of God.  Because there is very little possibility that anyone is truly ready to be in God's presence in our fallen, redeemed but imperfect state.  That is how holy God is.

I want to ask three  questions. Who is a Son that he should be chastised?
A son is the beloved child of a father who wants the best for him.  Chastisement brings about purity.

Hebrews 12
5 You have also forgotten the exhortation addressed to you as sons: "My son, do not disdain the discipline of the Lord or lose heart when reproved by him;
6 for whom the Lord loves, he disciplines; he scourges every son he acknowledges."
7 Endure your trials as "discipline"; God treats you as sons. For what "son" is there whom his father does not discipline?
8 If you are without discipline, in which all have shared, you are not sons but bastards.
9 Besides this, we have had our earthly fathers to discipline us, and we respected them. Should we not [then] submit all the more to the Father of spirits and live?
10 They disciplined us for a short time as seemed right to them, but he does so for our benefit, in order that we may share his holiness.
11 At the time, all discipline seems a cause not for joy but for pain, yet later it brings the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who are trained by it.
12 So strengthen your drooping hands and your weak knees.
13 Make straight paths for your feet, that what is lame may not be dislocated but healed.

Who is a son whom the father doesn't discipline?  A bastard, according to the Bible.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is a heretic?
A heretic is someone who has been given the Catholic faith and rejected it. 

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is one who obeys the law of the land but does not abide by the church.  ( Midlevel times)
That depends.  If one was baptized, and we are speaking of medieval times in western Europe, then that person was a disobedient son of God, possibly a schismatic.  If one was not baptized, then he is simply God's beloved creature (but not a child of God).   

Not sure why you are asking, or how this pertains?  If I understood that, I could probably give a more appropriate and succinct answer.

mclees8

#64
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:50:44
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:01:21
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:20:07
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

The Lord chastises every son he acknowledges.  Hebrews 12:6ff.  That is what is meant by "punishment" by "temporal punishment" is that chastisement for sins.  It is part of the sanctification process and due to God's justice and love.  God wants us to be perfect, and sin leaves a stain on our soul.

The goal of a secular court punishing law breakers has a good purpose, which is an external influence to both keep someone from breaking a crime or for justice due to a crime and time to reform from evil actions.  Jail time is not only good for the protection of society but also is meant to help the criminal reform.

We know that nothing unclean will enter heaven.  Rev. 21:27.  In that case, which I believe, I am thankful for purgatory, indulgences and the mercy of God.  Because there is very little possibility that anyone is truly ready to be in God's presence in our fallen, redeemed but imperfect state.  That is how holy God is.

I want to ask three  questions. Who is a Son that he should be chastised?
A son is the beloved child of a father who wants the best for him.  Chastisement brings about purity.

Hebrews 12
5 You have also forgotten the exhortation addressed to you as sons: "My son, do not disdain the discipline of the Lord or lose heart when reproved by him;
6 for whom the Lord loves, he disciplines; he scourges every son he acknowledges."
7 Endure your trials as "discipline"; God treats you as sons. For what "son" is there whom his father does not discipline?
8 If you are without discipline, in which all have shared, you are not sons but bastards.
9 Besides this, we have had our earthly fathers to discipline us, and we respected them. Should we not [then] submit all the more to the Father of spirits and live?
10 They disciplined us for a short time as seemed right to them, but he does so for our benefit, in order that we may share his holiness.
11 At the time, all discipline seems a cause not for joy but for pain, yet later it brings the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who are trained by it.
12 So strengthen your drooping hands and your weak knees.
13 Make straight paths for your feet, that what is lame may not be dislocated but healed.

Who is a son whom the father doesn't discipline?  A bastard, according to the Bible.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is a heretic?
A heretic is someone who has been given the Catholic faith and rejected it. 

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is one who obeys the law of the land but does not abide by the church.  ( Midlevel times)
That depends.  If one was baptized, and we are speaking of medieval times in western Europe, then that person was a disobedient son of God, possibly a schismatic.  If one was not baptized, then he is simply God's beloved creature (but not a child of God).   

Not sure why you are asking, or how this pertains?  If I understood that, I could probably give a more appropriate and succinct answer.


For my first question that is right for any son in the world. Who then is a son of God that he should be chastised by the church. According to your third response it would be one who is baptized  So the heretic and the unbaptized would never be chastised or punished by the church. The church deals with her own. Would that be correct?

For you second response. Would then the heretic be punished by the church for being a heretic?

For the third response. So if one does not abide by the church and is not baptized is one who is not saved. So the heretic and the unbaptized are not sons of God and the church would not punish them for anything because they are not of the church.  Correct?. Who has to obey the church, all the people of the land or just those who are baptized. If one is baptized does that make him truly saved  ?  If not why?

I pray for your patience.  I am going somewhere with all this. I want to distinguish who the church is that they be chastised by the church hierarchy and who are the people of the land. Are all the people of the land subject to the church for any secular  crimes out side the church

Pleas still answer for each of the three original  question? Thank you and remember Im speaking of the midlevel church






mclees8

#65
I posed the above questions to Catholica  but he seems to have ran from it. Can any other Catholic here answer these questions. I have studied  some from the catholic encyclopedia about the crusades and it has become clear that the church became a religious political force using the crusaders to maintain its power and authority over the lands and its people from apposing  forces. The picture is clear that the people of Europe were subject to the popes not because any were of true personal faith in Christ as the apostles preached, but because the church operated as the law and rule of the land.   However in our Knew Testament epistles we see that the church delt only with those of the faith having come personally  to Christ. All others who have never come to Christ were not of the church there for the church delt only  with its own in matter of sin with in the church.

So how is it that the church order became forced Christianity and far from what Christ founded. In My devotional today it taught about false apostles who are as wolves in sheep's clothing. Satan is expert in posing as an angle of light.


AVZ

Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:52:28
Crusaders were promised eternal life IF they died on crusade.  That is the same thing as being a martyr.  That being said: 

Actually its the same thing as being a terrorist.

mclees8

Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 02:32:24
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:52:28
Crusaders were promised eternal life IF they died on crusade.  That is the same thing as being a martyr.  That being said: 

Actually its the same thing as being a terrorist.

I would have to say its sad then to be a martyr for a cause that Christ did not have any part of.  Being a matyr because you were deceived by the church about salvation.

Catholica

#68
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:50:44
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:01:21
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:20:07
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

The Lord chastises every son he acknowledges.  Hebrews 12:6ff.  That is what is meant by "punishment" by "temporal punishment" is that chastisement for sins.  It is part of the sanctification process and due to God's justice and love.  God wants us to be perfect, and sin leaves a stain on our soul.

The goal of a secular court punishing law breakers has a good purpose, which is an external influence to both keep someone from breaking a crime or for justice due to a crime and time to reform from evil actions.  Jail time is not only good for the protection of society but also is meant to help the criminal reform.

We know that nothing unclean will enter heaven.  Rev. 21:27.  In that case, which I believe, I am thankful for purgatory, indulgences and the mercy of God.  Because there is very little possibility that anyone is truly ready to be in God's presence in our fallen, redeemed but imperfect state.  That is how holy God is.

I want to ask three  questions. Who is a Son that he should be chastised?
A son is the beloved child of a father who wants the best for him.  Chastisement brings about purity.

Hebrews 12
5 You have also forgotten the exhortation addressed to you as sons: "My son, do not disdain the discipline of the Lord or lose heart when reproved by him;
6 for whom the Lord loves, he disciplines; he scourges every son he acknowledges."
7 Endure your trials as "discipline"; God treats you as sons. For what "son" is there whom his father does not discipline?
8 If you are without discipline, in which all have shared, you are not sons but bastards.
9 Besides this, we have had our earthly fathers to discipline us, and we respected them. Should we not [then] submit all the more to the Father of spirits and live?
10 They disciplined us for a short time as seemed right to them, but he does so for our benefit, in order that we may share his holiness.
11 At the time, all discipline seems a cause not for joy but for pain, yet later it brings the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who are trained by it.
12 So strengthen your drooping hands and your weak knees.
13 Make straight paths for your feet, that what is lame may not be dislocated but healed.

Who is a son whom the father doesn't discipline?  A bastard, according to the Bible.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is a heretic?
A heretic is someone who has been given the Catholic faith and rejected it. 

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is one who obeys the law of the land but does not abide by the church.  ( Midlevel times)
That depends.  If one was baptized, and we are speaking of medieval times in western Europe, then that person was a disobedient son of God, possibly a schismatic.  If one was not baptized, then he is simply God's beloved creature (but not a child of God).   

Not sure why you are asking, or how this pertains?  If I understood that, I could probably give a more appropriate and succinct answer.


For my first question that is right for any son in the world. Who then is a son of God that he should be chastised by the church. According to your third response it would be one who is baptized  So the heretic and the unbaptized would never be chastised or punished by the church. The church deals with her own. Would that be correct?
There are two concepts that we must consider to answer this.  One is Church discipline for internal matters.  The other is God's discipline and/or punishment for sin.  We can read in the Bible that God can use anyone, even pagans, to punish for sin.  And therefore he can also use the Church to punish for sin, anyone's sin.

Any son of God could be chastised by the Church.  If he is publicly disobedient, or if he is teaching heresy, then excommunication is just one way the Church can chastise someone.  Heretics can be both members of the Church and non-members.  But in terms of Church discipline, yes, the Church deals with her own.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
For you second response. Would then the heretic be punished by the church for being a heretic?
Yes, if the heretic is in the Church, then the heretic could be punished, typically by excommunication or suppression under obedience.  Typically this is limited to clergy only.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
For the third response. So if one does not abide by the church and is not baptized is one who is not saved. So the heretic and the unbaptized are not sons of God and the church would not punish them for anything because they are not of the church.  Correct?.
Only partially correct.  The heretic may be a son of God, and they may be part of the Church.  But the unbaptized and the non-Catholic have not submitted themselves to the Church, and thus the Church doesn't use Church discipline.  This doesn't exempt them, however, from punishment/chastisement from God for their sins.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
Who has to obey the church, all the people of the land or just those who are baptized. If one is baptized does that make him truly saved  ?  If not why?
All the people of the land have to obey the commandments or they will experience punishment from God.  The Church is God's representative which God works through to preserve true teaching on faith and morals.  So if people know what's good for them, they will abide by the Church's moral teaching even if they are not members of the Church.  So in that sense, everyone has to obey the moral teachings of the Church, because they come from God.  In terms of being obedient to the Church hierarchy in terms of what they teach, the Church only disciplines people who have entered the Catholic Church.  That being said, the Church fights against heresy wherever it is taught, and that includes by people who are outside the Church, but it is not the same as Church discipline.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
I pray for your patience.  I am going somewhere with all this. I want to distinguish who the church is that they be chastised by the church hierarchy and who are the people of the land. Are all the people of the land subject to the church for any secular  crimes out side the church

Pleas still answer for each of the three original  question? Thank you and remember Im speaking of the midlevel church
People who are in the land are subject to the laws of the government.  Those people who make laws receive the authority to make those laws from God, and so even if they are not members of the Church, they all should and are in reality under God's authority and so should make laws which flow from the divine law.  The Church is the teacher of the divine moral law, and so just laws in any country should be in unity with the moral teachings of the Church, and lawmakers do well to take into account Church teaching on morals when they make laws.  Thus the secular authority is rightly influenced by Church teaching, even if the people therein are not subject to church discipline.

Thus when the secular rulers of certain countries make laws which are in unity with what the Church teaches and enact penalties for disobeying those laws, the people living in that country are bound to obey those laws, even if those laws flow from Church teaching, and even if they aren't members of the Church.

Catholica

Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 02:32:24
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:52:28
Crusaders were promised eternal life IF they died on crusade.  That is the same thing as being a martyr.  That being said: 

Actually its the same thing as being a terrorist.

I guess God commanded a lot of terrorism in the books of Joshua and Judges, then.  Such actions are well within what God revealed.  Why is that so hard for people who love the Bible to understand?  The God of the Old Testament and the New Testament are the same God.  You believe that right?

+-Recent Topics

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Yesterday at 12:56:12

American Socialism? by 4WD
Yesterday at 12:53:26

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

John 20:22 by Dave...
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 15:39:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Huguenots by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:11:46

Gibbon\Rome by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:07:07

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:05:00

Matthew 6:21 by pppp
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 08:14:39

Acts 4:32, Sharing by pppp
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 08:04:12

Powered by EzPortal