+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898035
Total Topics: 90351
Most Online Today: 4207
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 3060
Total: 3061
Rella
Google

Do you Believe Vatican 2 is a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

Started by To Know is to Serve, Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

To Know is to Serve


BlackSepulcher

Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40
Is Vatican 2 a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

*You even lift, bro?*  ::headspin::



It's a contradictory question, that only makes sense within your own convictions.

You should quit being so self-indulgent. In your eyes there's a right and wrong answer, you're just lining bait for whoever bites.


To Know is to Serve

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:53:03
Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40
Is Vatican 2 a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

*You even lift, bro?*  ::headspin::



It's a contradictory question, that only makes sense within your own convictions.

You should quit being so self-indulgent. In your eyes there's a right and wrong answer, you're just lining bait for whoever bites.

Are you claiming Dogmatic Councils and Pastoral Councils do not exist in the Catholic Church?


winsome

Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40
Is Vatican 2 a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

Vatican II was the twenty first Ecumenical Council

To Know is to Serve


HRoberson

This is an interesting site [url]http://www.traditio.com/tradlib/faq08.txt[url]

It makes one wonder how any bishop expects any of his flock to believe or do anything he says without those magic words.

To Know is to Serve

Quote from: winsome on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:24:56
Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40
Is Vatican 2 a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

Vatican II was the twenty first Ecumenical Council

You still refuse to answer this simple Catholic question.

Do you believe Vatican 2 is a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

winsome

Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 15:14:50
Quote from: winsome on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:24:56
Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40
Is Vatican 2 a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

Vatican II was the twenty first Ecumenical Council

You still refuse to answer this simple Catholic question.

Do you believe Vatican 2 is a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

Since you have not defined your terms I will use what I believe the Council intended.

It was BOTH a Dogmatic Council AND a Pastoral Council since it promulgated two Dogmatic Constitutions (Dei Verbum and Lumen Gentium) and one Pastoral Constitution (Gaudium Et Spes)

BlackSepulcher

Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:06:05
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:53:03
Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 13:19:40
Is Vatican 2 a Dogmatic Council or a Pastoral Council?

*You even lift, bro?*  ::headspin::



It's a contradictory question, that only makes sense within your own convictions.

You should quit being so self-indulgent. In your eyes there's a right and wrong answer, you're just lining bait for whoever bites.

Are you claiming Dogmatic Councils and Pastoral Councils do not exist in the Catholic Church?

You're talking about Vatican II. It's not an ordinary Council.

I think a better word instead of contradiction would be 'invalid'- it's a question built on invalidity, like asking how far below the sky is beneath us.

To Know is to Serve

QuoteYou're talking about Vatican II. It's not an ordinary Council.

Vatican 2 is not an ordinary council because it is not binding on Catholics.

winsome

Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 18:30:13
QuoteYou're talking about Vatican II. It's not an ordinary Council.

Vatican 2 is not an ordinary council because it is not binding on Catholics.

Oh, all right. Why is it not binding on Catholics?

HRoberson

Because it was a pastoral, not dogmatic, and was issued without the required de fide formulas.

It is, according to the argument, simply the personal preferences of the attendees and the Vicar. As such, apparently individual Catholics are free to disagree, disparage, and essentially blow it off.

Oh, and some of the pronouncements are heretical. An example would be the idea that there are Christians not in the visible Roman Catholic Church. This pronouncement being in contridiction to past pronouncements that one must be in the Church of Christ, adhering to the catholic faith to be "saved."

winsome

Quote from: HRoberson on Thu Jul 18, 2013 - 13:19:21
Because it was a pastoral, not dogmatic, and was issued without the required de fide formulas.

It is, according to the argument, simply the personal preferences of the attendees and the Vicar. As such, apparently individual Catholics are free to disagree, disparage, and essentially blow it off.

Oh, and some of the pronouncements are heretical. An example would be the idea that there are Christians not in the visible Roman Catholic Church. This pronouncement being in contridiction to past pronouncements that one must be in the Church of Christ, adhering to the catholic faith to be "saved."

Yes, I think you have caught the drift nicely ::applause::

epiphanius

Quote from: HRoberson on Thu Jul 18, 2013 - 13:19:21
Oh, and some of the pronouncements are heretical. An example would be the idea that there are Christians not in the visible Roman Catholic Church. This pronouncement being in contridiction to past pronouncements that one must be in the Church of Christ, adhering to the catholic faith to be "saved."

I suppose that depends on how you define "heretical." I for one believe that term was used extensively in the past--even in the early centuries of Christianity--as a tool to marginalize those who held different theological views (and at times this was done in a manner that was decidedly uncharitable and un-Christian).  This ultimately led to a false assumption that faith had more to do with doctrinal formulations than a real encounter with the Living God.  (Please note that I am *not* saying here that doctrinal formulations are a bad thing, only that it is possible to use them inappropriately--even as a weapon to tear apart the Church of Christ.)

Furthermore, it was Augustine who said, "there are some who appear to be in the Church and are really outside of it, while there are others who appear to be outside the Church, and are really in it."

+-Recent Topics

John 20:22 by pppp
Today at 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Today at 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Today at 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Today at 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Yesterday at 12:56:12

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Huguenots by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:11:46

Gibbon\Rome by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:07:07

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:05:00

Powered by EzPortal