News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898061
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 4952
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 4708
Total: 4708
Google (3)

Scripture and Tradition

Started by winsome, Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:27:43

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

winsome

Jesus wrote nothing but taught his apostles orally. They in turn passed on the teaching of Jesus orally.

We can see this in Paul's letters to Timothy. Paul tells Timothy to take as a norm the sound words that he heard from Paul and to guard it carefully (2Tim 1:13-14 & 1Tim 6:20). Timothy is in turn to pass this on to others, who will pass it on in their turn (2Tim 2:1-2).

In time some of this teaching (known as the deposit of faith) was written down and later gathered together (in the 4th century) in what we know as the New Testament. Other teaching continued to be passed on orally, although this in turn was eventually written down in creeds, liturgies and the decisions of Church Councils. This is known as Sacred Tradition or just Tradition. This is not to be confused with disciplinary, liturgical and devotional traditions and practices that have grown up over time in particular places.

The Catholic Church believes that Scripture and Tradition together contain the fullness of the truth that Jesus taught. Tradition also includes authoritative teaching that expands on what was originally passed on. Though public revelation ceased with the death of the last apostle, the deepening understanding of the truths contained in that revelation continues.

Scripture itself attests that it is not complete (Mk 4:33-34 & 6:34, Jn 16:12, 20:30 & 21:25, Acts 1:2-3)

Paul instructs people to hold to the traditions he has passed on to them (1Cor 11:2, 2Thess 2:15 & 3:6)

The Catholic Church believes that "The task of giving an authentic interpretation of the Word of God, whether in its written form or in the form of Tradition, has been entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church alone. Its authority in this matter is exercised in the name of Jesus Christ. This means that the task of interpretation has been entrusted to the bishops in communion with the successor of Peter, the Bishop of Rome.

larry2

Quote from: Winsome

Scripture itself attests that it is not complete (Mk 4:33-34 & 6:34, Jn 16:12, 20:30 & 21:25, Acts 1:2-3)


Dear Brother Winsome, how would you then interpret the following scripture concerning more understanding to be added. To me the revelation to Paul by the risen Lord Jesus in Galatians 1:11-12 did complete those things hid from generations, and Paul wrote in Galatians 1:8 "But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed."

Colossians 1:25  Whereof I am made a minister, according to the dispensation of God which is given to me for you, to fulfill the word of God;

Colossians 1:26  Even the mystery which hath been hid from ages and from generations, but now is made manifest to his saints:

winsome

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:55:31
Quote from: Winsome

Scripture itself attests that it is not complete (Mk 4:33-34 & 6:34, Jn 16:12, 20:30 & 21:25, Acts 1:2-3)


Dear Brother Winsome, how would you then interpret the following scripture concerning more understanding to be added. To me the revelation to Paul by the risen Lord Jesus in Galatians 1:11-12 did complete those things hid from generations, and Paul wrote in Galatians 1:8 "But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed."

Note that Paul says the gospel he preached to them. Paul doesn't say the gospel that I am writing down for you. Paul taught them orally. How much of what Paul taught did he write down in his epistles?

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:55:31
Colossians 1:25  Whereof I am made a minister, according to the dispensation of God which is given to me for you, to fulfill the word of God;

Colossians 1:26  Even the mystery which hath been hid from ages and from generations, but now is made manifest to his saints:


The mystery is being made manifest. How? - By Paul's preaching, and the preaching of the other apostles.

Paul doesn't say that what he writes is everything that has been made manifest. Obviously it isn't.

If we only had Paul's epistles how much would we know?


I can't see that either of these texts says that scripture is complete. Quite the opposite.

AVZ

Quote from: winsome on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 11:15:05
Quote from: larry2 on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:55:31
Quote from: Winsome

Scripture itself attests that it is not complete (Mk 4:33-34 & 6:34, Jn 16:12, 20:30 & 21:25, Acts 1:2-3)


Dear Brother Winsome, how would you then interpret the following scripture concerning more understanding to be added. To me the revelation to Paul by the risen Lord Jesus in Galatians 1:11-12 did complete those things hid from generations, and Paul wrote in Galatians 1:8 "But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed."

Note that Paul says the gospel he preached to them. Paul doesn't say the gospel that I am writing down for you. Paul taught them orally. How much of what Paul taught did he write down in his epistles?

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:55:31
Colossians 1:25  Whereof I am made a minister, according to the dispensation of God which is given to me for you, to fulfill the word of God;

Colossians 1:26  Even the mystery which hath been hid from ages and from generations, but now is made manifest to his saints:


The mystery is being made manifest. How? - By Paul's preaching, and the preaching of the other apostles.

Paul doesn't say that what he writes is everything that has been made manifest. Obviously it isn't.

If we only had Paul's epistles how much would we know?


I can't see that either of these texts says that scripture is complete. Quite the opposite.


Once again this is a matter of speculation.
After 2000 years of hearsay who is to say what was the original message?

We have been given the Scriptures and we have been given the Holy Spirit to explain these Scriptures to us.
That should be sufficient.

LightHammer

Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 13:22:37
Quote from: winsome on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 11:15:05
Quote from: larry2 on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:55:31
Quote from: Winsome

Scripture itself attests that it is not complete (Mk 4:33-34 & 6:34, Jn 16:12, 20:30 & 21:25, Acts 1:2-3)


Dear Brother Winsome, how would you then interpret the following scripture concerning more understanding to be added. To me the revelation to Paul by the risen Lord Jesus in Galatians 1:11-12 did complete those things hid from generations, and Paul wrote in Galatians 1:8 "But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed."

Note that Paul says the gospel he preached to them. Paul doesn't say the gospel that I am writing down for you. Paul taught them orally. How much of what Paul taught did he write down in his epistles?

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 10:55:31
Colossians 1:25  Whereof I am made a minister, according to the dispensation of God which is given to me for you, to fulfill the word of God;

Colossians 1:26  Even the mystery which hath been hid from ages and from generations, but now is made manifest to his saints:


The mystery is being made manifest. How? - By Paul's preaching, and the preaching of the other apostles.

Paul doesn't say that what he writes is everything that has been made manifest. Obviously it isn't.

If we only had Paul's epistles how much would we know?


I can't see that either of these texts says that scripture is complete. Quite the opposite.


Once again this is a matter of speculation.
After 2000 years of hearsay who is to say what was the original message?

We have been given the Scriptures and we have been given the Holy Spirit to explain these Scriptures to us.
That should be sufficient.

Actually the Holy Spirit gave us the ordained priesthood to both write and compile together the Sacred Scriptures. Its only natural that the same ordained priesthood would be chosen by the Holy Spirit to be the teaching authority as well.

Now of course I believe any Christian who dedicates his/her life to study and spiritual discipline can arrive at the same teachings as the College of Bishops. I mean we're not Gnostics here. The priesthood is not the keeper of some secret knowledge that we have to go through them to become aware of. However they are the teaching authority. The tool that God uses to indetinfy Truth from personal interpretation.

larry2

Quote from: winsome on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 11:15:05

If we only had Paul's epistles how much would we know?


We would know enough. Romans 2:16  In the day when God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ according to my gospel.

1 Corinthians 11:1  Be ye followers of me, even as I also am of Christ.
 

AVZ

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 13:31:27
Actually the Holy Spirit gave us the ordained priesthood to both write and compile together the Sacred Scriptures. Its only natural that the same ordained priesthood would be chosen by the Holy Spirit to be the teaching authority as well.

Now of course I believe any Christian who dedicates his/her life to study and spiritual discipline can arrive at the same teachings as the College of Bishops. I mean we're not Gnostics here. The priesthood is not the keeper of some secret knowledge that we have to go through them to become aware of. However they are the teaching authority. The tool that God uses to indetinfy Truth from personal interpretation.

The Holy Spirit did not give us an ordained priesthood as this is not His task.
The Holy Spirit chooses none, it is the Father who chooses.

Example: The disciples were chosen before they received the Holy Spirit.
And after the disciples many more were chosen to proceed the work of God, each in his/her own way and each with his/her own talents.

God is not a God of kings and title bearers, on the contrary, thoughout history God has chosen the "unlikely" to be His messengers and prophets.
Now many of these "unlikely" messengers were disposed off by the then ruling clergy.

Better the catholic Church doesnt make the same mistake as the Sanhedrin has made throughout history.
Gods Spirit or indwelling is not an exclusive gift to clergy or the Papacy, in fact it was the clergy that crucified our Saviour on the cross.r

LightHammer

Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 18:04:08
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 13:31:27
Actually the Holy Spirit gave us the ordained priesthood to both write and compile together the Sacred Scriptures. Its only natural that the same ordained priesthood would be chosen by the Holy Spirit to be the teaching authority as well.

Now of course I believe any Christian who dedicates his/her life to study and spiritual discipline can arrive at the same teachings as the College of Bishops. I mean we're not Gnostics here. The priesthood is not the keeper of some secret knowledge that we have to go through them to become aware of. However they are the teaching authority. The tool that God uses to indetinfy Truth from personal interpretation.

The Holy Spirit did not give us an ordained priesthood as this is not His task.
The Holy Spirit chooses none, it is the Father who chooses.

Example: The disciples were chosen before they received the Holy Spirit.
And after the disciples many more were chosen to proceed the work of God, each in his/her own way and each with his/her own talents.

God is not a God of kings and title bearers, on the contrary, thoughout history God has chosen the "unlikely" to be His messengers and prophets.
Now many of these "unlikely" messengers were disposed off by the then ruling clergy.

Better the catholic Church doesnt make the same mistake as the Sanhedrin has made throughout history.
Gods Spirit or indwelling is not an exclusive gift to clergy or the Papacy, in fact it was the clergy that crucified our Saviour on the cross.r

???


What produced this tangent? Did you even read my post?

AVZ

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 19:11:47
Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 18:04:08
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jun 19, 2012 - 13:31:27
Actually the Holy Spirit gave us the ordained priesthood to both write and compile together the Sacred Scriptures. Its only natural that the same ordained priesthood would be chosen by the Holy Spirit to be the teaching authority as well.

Now of course I believe any Christian who dedicates his/her life to study and spiritual discipline can arrive at the same teachings as the College of Bishops. I mean we're not Gnostics here. The priesthood is not the keeper of some secret knowledge that we have to go through them to become aware of. However they are the teaching authority. The tool that God uses to indetinfy Truth from personal interpretation.

The Holy Spirit did not give us an ordained priesthood as this is not His task.
The Holy Spirit chooses none, it is the Father who chooses.

Example: The disciples were chosen before they received the Holy Spirit.
And after the disciples many more were chosen to proceed the work of God, each in his/her own way and each with his/her own talents.

God is not a God of kings and title bearers, on the contrary, thoughout history God has chosen the "unlikely" to be His messengers and prophets.
Now many of these "unlikely" messengers were disposed off by the then ruling clergy.

Better the catholic Church doesnt make the same mistake as the Sanhedrin has made throughout history.
Gods Spirit or indwelling is not an exclusive gift to clergy or the Papacy, in fact it was the clergy that crucified our Saviour on the cross.r

???


What produced this tangent? Did you even read my post?

Yes I did. Being the real Catholic you are, you try to assign authoritive truth to priesthood.
I am telling you that Biblical priesthood shows that many of these authoritive figures have stumbled and enforced false theologies on people.

You are saying that God uses priests as a tool to proclaim truth. That may well be the case.
I am telling you that Biblical history shows that truth was often proclaimed by people other than those in the priesthood, or in fact by people we would not even feel worthy of being a messenger of God.

Now, thats the power of God. He does not use the people you and I expect Him to use.
We have all been given the Holy Spirit so when we open our eyes we know what is good and what is wrong.

Contrary to what you teach, personal interpretation is a very important part of spiritual life.
Personal interpretation is the tool God uses for us to separate the true from the false teachers.

Its exactly the opposite of what you preach.

matt1

Did not Christ promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to teach us all truth?
He did not promise that the Holy Spirit would constantly guide, teach, and give clarity to each individual separately.
If every individual were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all who read Scripture sincerely should come to the same conclusion. But they do not.
The frightful chaos as to the meaning of Scripture is proof positive that the Holy Spirit has not chosen this way of leading men to the truth.
It is blasphemy to say that the Holy Spirit does not know His own mind, and that He deliberately leads men into contradictory notions.
Christ promised to preserve His Church as a Church by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the only Church which shows signs of having been preserved is the consistent Catholic Church.
The individual is guided by the Holy Spirit to a certain extent in the ways of holiness, but in the knowledge of revealed truth he is to be guided by the Catholic Church which Christ sent to teach all nations.

Ancient Israel had many problems Cannabilism, Homosexuality, polgymy, idolatry, murder, adultery, genocide, child sacrifice, almost every vice imaginable.
However, out of that nation of so much wickedness, the Holy Spirit guided prophets, priests, and Kings to deposit the true faith, the true traditions.
Oral tradition was passed on and guided by the spirit of God for hundreds of years before it was written.
That was how it was done for thousands of years.
Christ is faitful to his word, the Holy Spirit guides the Church and the Traditions, we can rest assured that the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Christ built upon the Rock.
The Devil shall do all that he can to destroy the Church, he has done much damage throuhout the centuries, many wicked sheperds will inflitrate the Church to destroy it within, but the Church always emerges victorious in the end.
After the darkest trials and persecutions comes a most glorious ressurection.




AVZ

Quote from: matt1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 - 18:08:04
Did not Christ promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to teach us all truth?
He did not promise that the Holy Spirit would constantly guide, teach, and give clarity to each individual separately.
If every individual were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all who read Scripture sincerely should come to the same conclusion. But they do not.
The frightful chaos as to the meaning of Scripture is proof positive that the Holy Spirit has not chosen this way of leading men to the truth.
It is blasphemy to say that the Holy Spirit does not know His own mind, and that He deliberately leads men into contradictory notions.
Christ promised to preserve His Church as a Church by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the only Church which shows signs of having been preserved is the consistent Catholic Church.
The individual is guided by the Holy Spirit to a certain extent in the ways of holiness, but in the knowledge of revealed truth he is to be guided by the Catholic Church which Christ sent to teach all nations.

Ancient Israel had many problems Cannabilism, Homosexuality, polgymy, idolatry, murder, adultery, genocide, child sacrifice, almost every vice imaginable.
However, out of that nation of so much wickedness, the Holy Spirit guided prophets, priests, and Kings to deposit the true faith, the true traditions.
Oral tradition was passed on and guided by the spirit of God for hundreds of years before it was written.
That was how it was done for thousands of years.
Christ is faitful to his word, the Holy Spirit guides the Church and the Traditions, we can rest assured that the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Christ built upon the Rock.
The Devil shall do all that he can to destroy the Church, he has done much damage throuhout the centuries, many wicked sheperds will inflitrate the Church to destroy it within, but the Church always emerges victorious in the end.
After the darkest trials and persecutions comes a most glorious ressurection.


For centuries the Sanhedrin argued exactly the same as you.
They were the Pharisees, Sadducees and priests and they claimed they were the ones that knew it all.
They too were under the same promise of God, that God would never forsake His people.
They too claimed that only they had the authority to state what was right and what was wrong.
They too drew their conclusions from lists of sucessions.

How wrong they were!

Acts 7:51-53 "You stiff-necked people, with uncircumcised hearts and ears! You are just like your fathers: You always resist the Holy Spirit! Was there ever a prophet your fathers did not persecute? They even killed those who predicted the coming of the Righteous One. And now you have betrayed and murdered him you who have received the law that was put into effect through angels but have not obeyed it."

mclees8

Quote from: matt1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 - 18:08:04
Did not Christ promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to teach us all truth?
He did not promise that the Holy Spirit would constantly guide, teach, and give clarity to each individual separately.
If every individual were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all who read Scripture sincerely should come to the same conclusion. But they do not.
The frightful chaos as to the meaning of Scripture is proof positive that the Holy Spirit has not chosen this way of leading men to the truth.
It is blasphemy to say that the Holy Spirit does not know His own mind, and that He deliberately leads men into contradictory notions.
Christ promised to preserve His Church as a Church by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the only Church which shows signs of having been preserved is the consistent Catholic Church.
The individual is guided by the Holy Spirit to a certain extent in the ways of holiness, but in the knowledge of revealed truth he is to be guided by the Catholic Church which Christ sent to teach all nations.

Ancient Israel had many problems Cannabilism, Homosexuality, polgymy, idolatry, murder, adultery, genocide, child sacrifice, almost every vice imaginable.
However, out of that nation of so much wickedness, the Holy Spirit guided prophets, priests, and Kings to deposit the true faith, the true traditions.
Oral tradition was passed on and guided by the spirit of God for hundreds of years before it was written.
That was how it was done for thousands of years.
Christ is faitful to his word, the Holy Spirit guides the Church and the Traditions, we can rest assured that the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Christ built upon the Rock.
The Devil shall do all that he can to destroy the Church, he has done much damage throuhout the centuries, many wicked sheperds will inflitrate the Church to destroy it within, but the Church always emerges victorious in the end.
After the darkest trials and persecutions comes a most glorious ressurection.





Matti is our salvation personal or congrigational ? Are we saved by faith or by affiliation?

Ladonia

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Jun 21, 2012 - 01:41:53
Quote from: matt1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 - 18:08:04
Did not Christ promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to teach us all truth?
He did not promise that the Holy Spirit would constantly guide, teach, and give clarity to each individual separately.
If every individual were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all who read Scripture sincerely should come to the same conclusion. But they do not.
The frightful chaos as to the meaning of Scripture is proof positive that the Holy Spirit has not chosen this way of leading men to the truth.
It is blasphemy to say that the Holy Spirit does not know His own mind, and that He deliberately leads men into contradictory notions.
Christ promised to preserve His Church as a Church by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the only Church which shows signs of having been preserved is the consistent Catholic Church.
The individual is guided by the Holy Spirit to a certain extent in the ways of holiness, but in the knowledge of revealed truth he is to be guided by the Catholic Church which Christ sent to teach all nations.

Ancient Israel had many problems Cannabilism, Homosexuality, polgymy, idolatry, murder, adultery, genocide, child sacrifice, almost every vice imaginable.
However, out of that nation of so much wickedness, the Holy Spirit guided prophets, priests, and Kings to deposit the true faith, the true traditions.
Oral tradition was passed on and guided by the spirit of God for hundreds of years before it was written.
That was how it was done for thousands of years.
Christ is faitful to his word, the Holy Spirit guides the Church and the Traditions, we can rest assured that the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Christ built upon the Rock.
The Devil shall do all that he can to destroy the Church, he has done much damage throuhout the centuries, many wicked sheperds will inflitrate the Church to destroy it within, but the Church always emerges victorious in the end.
After the darkest trials and persecutions comes a most glorious ressurection.





Matti is our salvation personal or congrigational ? Are we saved by faith or by affiliation?

We are saved by Christ, but affiliation is important for the correct interpretation of God's word.

highrigger

QuoteActually the Holy Spirit gave us the ordained priesthood to both write and compile together the Sacred Scriptures. Its only natural that the same ordained priesthood would be chosen by the Holy Spirit to be the teaching authority as well.

Now of course I believe any Christian who dedicates his/her life to study and spiritual discipline can arrive at the same teachings as the College of Bishops. I mean we're not Gnostics here. The priesthood is not the keeper of some secret knowledge that we have to go through them to become aware of. However they are the teaching authority. The tool that God uses to indetinfy Truth from personal interpretation.

lighthammer,

Funny the holy spirit never told that to the NT authors or the early ECFs. There was no ordination or christian priesthood in the NT or among the ECFs until the 3rd century when it was fabricated. Fr Brown plainly explains no ordination in those days

"Apostolic Succession concerns the fact that the bishops eventually took over
the pastoral tasks of the apostles;It does not involve HOW the early bishops
were chosen or appointed. We know little about that, not even being certain
that there was a formal action designating them....That does not mean of course
that all the presbtyer-bishops of the early church were appointed by apostles,
but there is a good chance that somewere that occurred....Eventually, of course,
the church developed a regularized pattern of selection and ordination of bishops,
and from the third century on that was universally followed.
Raymond Brown, 101 Questions and Answers On The Bible. page 120.
Approved for publication with the Imprimatur.

We do not know how the bishops were selected he says.That means we do not know. So why do you pretend to know what scholars do not know?

You even think you have to go through them? When no such thing existed for 200 years after the apostles?
Makes no sense at all.

Peace, JohnR

mclees8

Quote from: Ladonia on Thu Jun 21, 2012 - 02:42:37
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Jun 21, 2012 - 01:41:53
Quote from: matt1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 - 18:08:04
Did not Christ promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to teach us all truth?
He did not promise that the Holy Spirit would constantly guide, teach, and give clarity to each individual separately.
If every individual were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all who read Scripture sincerely should come to the same conclusion. But they do not.
The frightful chaos as to the meaning of Scripture is proof positive that the Holy Spirit has not chosen this way of leading men to the truth.
It is blasphemy to say that the Holy Spirit does not know His own mind, and that He deliberately leads men into contradictory notions.
Christ promised to preserve His Church as a Church by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the only Church which shows signs of having been preserved is the consistent Catholic Church.
The individual is guided by the Holy Spirit to a certain extent in the ways of holiness, but in the knowledge of revealed truth he is to be guided by the Catholic Church which Christ sent to teach all nations.

Ancient Israel had many problems Cannabilism, Homosexuality, polgymy, idolatry, murder, adultery, genocide, child sacrifice, almost every vice imaginable.
However, out of that nation of so much wickedness, the Holy Spirit guided prophets, priests, and Kings to deposit the true faith, the true traditions.
Oral tradition was passed on and guided by the spirit of God for hundreds of years before it was written.
That was how it was done for thousands of years.
Christ is faitful to his word, the Holy Spirit guides the Church and the Traditions, we can rest assured that the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Christ built upon the Rock.
The Devil shall do all that he can to destroy the Church, he has done much damage throuhout the centuries, many wicked sheperds will inflitrate the Church to destroy it within, but the Church always emerges victorious in the end.
After the darkest trials and persecutions comes a most glorious ressurection.





Matti is our salvation personal or congrigational ? Are we saved by faith or by affiliation?

We are saved by Christ, but affiliation is important for the correct interpretation of God's word.

I asked is or salvation personal? Who is saved by Christ. In the resurection who will be resurected, the established hierarchial order or the individual believers? Think about this and answer carefully.

Will you be resurected or will it be the eartly establishment?

LightHammer

Quotelighthammer,

Funny the holy spirit never told that to the NT authors or the early ECFs.

I take this as an attempt to be funny.

The New Testament sends the Apostles and the 70 as the teaching authority and they chose successors. St. Ignatius of Antioch, one of the earliest Church fathers, taught us to run in all things in accordance with the bishops.

QuoteThere was no ordination or christian priesthood in the NT or among the ECFs until the 3rd century when it was fabricated.

Nop that is your meaningless opinion where critical history can not verify one way or the other before the 3rd century when Christians couldn't document much anyway seeing how they were an underground society.

QuoteFr Brown plainly explains no ordination in those days

No he doesn't. He "plainly" says that such is historically unverifiable. He has not now nor ever said that there was no ordination until the 3rd century only that there is no historical proof either way.

You're doing that lying thing again.

Quote"Apostolic Succession concerns the fact that the bishops eventually took over
the pastoral tasks of the apostles;It does not involve HOW the early bishops
were chosen or appointed. We know little about that, not even being certain
that there was a formal action designating them....That does not mean of course
that all the presbtyer-bishops of the early church were appointed by apostles,
but there is a good chance that somewere that occurred....Eventually, of course,
the church developed a regularized pattern of selection and ordination of bishops,
and from the third century on that was universally followed.
Raymond Brown, 101 Questions and Answers On The Bible. page 120.
Approved for publication with the Imprimatur.

We do not know how the bishops were selected he says. That means we do not know. So why do you pretend to know what scholars do not know?

::headscratch::

I'm confused. First you say that scholars (mainly Raymond Brown) "plainly explains no ordination in those days". Now here in the very same breath you say that I'm arrogant for claiming to know that there was an ordination rite when your quotation says that scholars actually don't know.

Get your lie togther and try again.

QuoteYou even think you have to go through them?

Completely opposite of what I said.

highrigger









QuoteThe New Testament sends the Apostles and the 70 as the teaching authority and they chose successors. St. Ignatius of Antioch, one of the earliest Church fathers, taught us to run in all things in accordance with the bishops.

lighthammer,

You have no evidence at all that they chose successors. You made that up.


QuoteNop that is your meaningless opinion where critical history can not verify one way or the other before the 3rd century when Christians couldn't document much anyway seeing how they were an underground society.

If something cannot be verified historically it should not be claimed as historic fact. That is my point. You keep claiming what cannot be supported by history.

QuoteNo he doesn't. He "plainly" says that such is historically unverifiable. He has not now nor ever said that there was no ordination until the 3rd century only that there is no historical proof either way.

Then you should not claim what cannot be historically verified.

QuoteYou're doing that lying thing again.

Try to be nice. I do not call you names. I am simply dealing with the facts of history and scripture. No need to get angry and make it personal.


QuoteWe do not know how the bishops were selected he says. That means we do not know. So why do you pretend to know what scholars do not know?

If you do not know something then do not claim it.

QuoteI'm confused. First you say that scholars (mainly Raymond Brown) "plainly explains no ordination in those days". Now here in the very same breath you say that I'm arrogant for claiming to know that there was an ordination rite when your quotation says that scholars actually don't know.

No need to be confused. All I am asking is you stick to what is historically known and not make it up as you go along.

QuoteGet your lie togther and try again.

When soneone gets angry and starts calling names it means they are losing the argument. I did not insult you and I ask for the same consideration. Are you not a monitor? Dont you know the rules of this website?

Peace, JohnR

LightHammer

#17
QuoteYou have no evidence at all that they chose successors. You made that up.

Nope actually I have ample evidence.

I have the biblical accounts in Acts where the Apostles chose St. Matthias to replace Judas Ischariot and the directives of the Holy Spirit in 2Timothy to continue to entrust the teaching and leadership of the congregations to capable men.

Then I have the history of the early Christiabs listing who some of those men were and where they were stationed.

It's not my fault your denomination has no history before the middle ages in Europe.

QuoteIf something cannot be verified historically it should not be claimed as historic fact. That is my point. You keep claiming what cannot be supported by history.

Of course I can claim it. Just because you seek to impose a set of standards that can neither prove nor disprove my claim does not serve to make it false or void.

It just means you're deaf dumb and blind to the validity of the truths of the Church.

Not my problem.

QuoteThen you should not claim what cannot be historically verified.

You mean by your standards of history? That's like making your own rules. I have expert testimony from the earliest documented records of Christianity.

I have read several Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox historians and the best your guys can do to cast doubt on the accounts of the early Church are to claim that they're unverifiable and act within that crevous of doubt to give your 33,0000 sects a glimmer of credibility.  

Sad really.

QuoteTry to be nice. I do not call you names. I am simply dealing with the facts of history and scripture. No need to get angry and make it personal.
 

lol

I think it makes you feel to good to consider that your posts rattle my cage in any way. They don't. I'm not angry or bothered. Your entire objections amounts to significance of the insect that degrades my room by forming cobwebs in my corner.

The webs are very elegant but feeble and immaterial.

You have cited historians and then distorted their work. Well I guess I can't blame you it is the tradition of your Reformation roots. You're just following in the craft of your forefathers.

QuoteIf you do not know something then do not claim it.

Why did you quote yourself and then respond to it as if you were responding to something I said?

QuoteWhen soneone gets angry and starts calling names it means they are losing the argument. I did not insult you and I ask for the same consideration. Are you not a monitor? Dont you know the rules of this website?

???

I didn't call you a name. I did say you were positing a lie and an inconsistent one at that but that's not addressing you but your posts. There's no rule against calling something a lie.

Again I'm not angry or frustrated but I think it makes you feel good to pretend that your posts are that consequential so feel free to lie to yourself.

highrigger

















QuoteNope actually I have ample evidence.

I have the biblical accounts in Acts where the Apostles chose St. Matthias to replace Judas Ischariot and the directives of the Holy Spirit in 2Timothy to continue to entrust the teaching and leadership of the congregations to capable men.

Lighthammer,


Matthias was chosen because they needed 12 for the twelve tribes of Israel. None of the rest supports your assertion. Thus no evidence at all.

QuoteThen I have the history of the early Christiabs listing who some of those men were and where they were stationed.

It's not my fault your denomination has no history before the middle ages in Europe.

We use the history books which does not include the mythology someone taught you. Your listing was fabricated and that is a known fact by the historians of the subject.

QuoteOf course I can claim it. Just because you seek to impose a set of standards that can neither prove nor disprove my claim does not serve to make it false or void.

So if no one knows if it happened or not, then it must be true? Amazing how you are taken in by that.

QuoteIt just means you're deaf dumb and blind to the validity of the truths of the Church.

More insults does not help your case.

QuoteNot my problem.

When anyone believes falsehoods they have a problem.

QuoteYou mean by your standards of history? That's like making your own rules. I have expert testimony from the earliest documented records of Christianity.

Oh sure, those fabricated bishops lists? Gimmeabreak.

QuoteI have read several Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox historians and the best your guys can do to cast doubt on the accounts of the early Church are to claim that they're unverifiable and act within that crevous of doubt to give your 33,0000 sects a glimmer of credibility. 

My church sticks with real history and does not fabricate myths to puff up our importance over others. I can see you perfer the opposite course. Are you going to reveal your support? I guess not.


I
Quotethink it makes you feel to good to consider that your posts rattle my cage in any way. They don't. I'm not angry or bothered. Your entire objections amounts to significance of the insect that degrades my room by forming cobwebs in my corner.

I understand. Real history has no effect on you. i get it.

QuoteI didn't call you a name. I did say you were positing a lie and an inconsistent one at that but that's not addressing you but your posts. There's no rule against calling something a lie.

Again I'm not angry or frustrated but I think it makes you feel good to pretend that your posts are that consequential so feel free to lie to yourself.

It is quite obvious you are angry because of your demeaning personal comments. Actual facts and historical support helps a case but so often when one lacks that, the final defense is anger. It seems to happen every time. Not very convincing.

Peace, JohnR

LightHammer

QuoteMatthias was chosen because they needed 12 for the twelve tribes of Israel. None of the rest supports your assertion. Thus no evidence at all.

Chapter and verse.

Note that you're ignoring my other citations.

QuoteWe use the history books which does not include the mythology someone taught you. Your listing was fabricated and that is a known fact by the historians of the subject.

The lists may not be 100% accurate seeing how they're a 3rd century attempt to document two hundred years of lineage.

The resounding and obvious proof is that the succession is there while your community has none.

QuoteSo if no one knows if it happened or not, then it must be true? Amazing how you are taken in by that.

Not what I said.

QuoteWhen anyone believes falsehoods they have a problem.

Which is why it's not my problem.

QuoteOh sure, those fabricated bishops lists? Gimmeabreak.

They're not perfect simply because they're second generation attempts to salvage heritage clouded by persecution that drove the churches underground.

That doesn't make them false.

Don't be such a sour puss. It's not our fault your church has no heritage in the Early Church.

QuoteMy church sticks with real history and does not fabricate myths to puff up our importance over others. I can see you perfer the opposite course. Are you going to reveal your support? I guess not.


No your church attempts to crawl itself to equality with original Christianity by trying to legitimacy in the areas where history is unverifiable.

I don't particularly care the vast majority of Christians haven't been dubbed by the petty attempts of distortion.





highrigger








QuoteNote that you're ignoring my other citations.

Lighthammer,

I explained what happened and why when Mattias was chosen. Your other verses did not even relate. Simply to throw up a number of verses that have nothing to do with the issue is not an argument.

QuoteThe lists may not be 100% accurate seeing how they're a 3rd century attempt to document two hundred years of lineage.

The lists were mostly fabricated. Simple as that. There was no lineage and they were made up to make the faithful think there was one. It sure fooled you even though common sense should tell you not to accept it.

QuoteThe resounding and obvious proof is that the succession is there while your community has none.

We are honest about the historical facts of the matter whereas you are trying to support your claim with fabricated documents.
I prefer our approach because the church is the pillar of the truth and thus should tell the truth. 


QuoteThey're not perfect simply because they're second generation attempts to salvage heritage clouded by persecution that drove the churches underground.

Second generation? The apostles died in the 60s. The 3rd century is at least 300AD. In those days generations were no more than 30 years apart. Thats 5 generations. They contained at least 140 years of fabricated names. 

QuoteThat doesn't make them false.

They have been proven false. No scholars accept them. They are only for fooling Catholics. It is working with you as I can see.

QuoteDon't be such a sour puss. It's not our fault your church has no heritage in the Early Church.

Ours is no less than yours except that we include the truth. The truth is important we think. False documents and fabricated history is not part of our heritage thank goodness. In fact without the truth, a church is not a church at all siince it must be a pillar of the truth. 

QuoteNo your church attempts to crawl itself to equality with original Christianity by trying to legitimacy in the areas where history is unverifiable.

We of course reject false history. You may call that crawling if you want. We call it the truth as oppposed ot falsehood. Your view of original christianity is fabricated.

QuoteI don't particularly care the vast majority of Christians haven't been dubbed by the petty attempts of distortion

Many have been fooled by falsified history. You seem to be one of them. You even admit those bishops lists are not perfect then still defend them. They are actually of no use at all since they are mostly made up for 140 + years. It might as well be 1400 years. In addition, the one for Rome starts with a falsehood off the get-go since Peter was never a bishop of Rome. That falsehood alone breaks any connection. And there was no bishop of Rome until mid 2nd century. Even so you simply have no idea of the line of bishops of Rome for that time period until some time into the 3rd century. 

Fact is you have no connection directly that is provable. My church has no direct connection that is provable. You have nothing that we do not have. Simple fact and when a church can admit that, it then and only then can claim to teach the truth. If it claims otherwise it cannot claim to be a pillar of the truth, since the pillar of the truth tells the truth.

Peace, JohnR

LightHammer

QuoteLighthammer,

I explained what happened and why when Mattias was chosen. Your other verses did not even relate. Simply to throw up a number of verses that have nothing to do with the issue is not an argument.

You explained your interpretation and provided nothing to back it up. Forgive me if I'm not swayed.

My other verses do correlate as they are apostolic directives to continue to appoint leaders and teachers thereby affirming the tradition of succession in communion with the succession of Matthias.


QuoteThe lists were mostly fabricated. Simple as that. There was no lineage and they were made up to make the faithful think there was one. It sure fooled you even though common sense should tell you not to accept it.

That is immaterial opinion. Its stupid to think that Christ went through all the trouble to appoint the twelve and seventy to tend to a flock of less than a million Christians but that such strictly established leadership would be unnecessary for the billions that would come after them.


QuoteWe are honest about the historical facts of the matter whereas you are trying to support your claim with fabricated documents.
I prefer our approach because the church is the pillar of the truth and thus should tell the truth. 

You separated yourself from full communion with the Church. Our did you forget the slaughter of warfare that brought your Reformation into existence?

You are simply trying to make claims from silence over a thousand years removed from the times in question. Thats not honesty its speculation.


QuoteSecond generation? The apostles died in the 60s. The 3rd century is at least 300AD. In those days generations were no more than 30 years apart. Thats 5 generations. They contained at least 140 years of fabricated names. 

The Apostles did not all die in the 60's. There is ample evidence to support that St. John lasted until the 90's. Furthermore the 3rd century is not at least 300 AD its at least 200AD learn the basics of historic recording.

Going on the very plausible account of St. John dying in the 90's and Irenaeus in the second century that makes two generations. Elders within his community were alive with the Apostles.


QuoteThey have been proven false. No scholars accept them. They are only for fooling Catholics. It is working with you as I can see.

No scholar has proven them false. Only that they were drafted in the 2nd century no more than a 2 or 3 genertaions from the author and the Apostles.


QuoteOurs is no less than yours except that we include the truth. The truth is important we think. False documents and fabricated history is not part of our heritage thank goodness. In fact without the truth, a church is not a church at all siince it must be a pillar of the truth. 

You guys don't have truth either which is why you all split into 33,000 different sects. Some deny the divinity of Christ. Some reduce the Trinity to mere manfiestations. Some believe we don't have freewill. Most have denied that Christ is present in the Eucharist and on and on. 

There is not much to talk about.


QuoteWe of course reject false history. You may call that crawling if you want. We call it the truth as oppposed ot falsehood. Your view of original christianity is fabricated.

There is no false history. You have not quoted a single source that says so. You have only quoted scholars who cast doubt andf then you(highrigger) misrepresent them by adding your own conclusions.

Of course I don't blame you considering the history of your sect.

QuoteFact is you have no connection directly that is provable. My church has no direct connection that is provable.

Negative we have an epistle in the Bible and the testimony of the earliest Christians that support us.

Furthermore your church isn't simply lacking in a provable connection (or one that can be manipulated to cast doubt on). Your church does not have any connection at all.

Its a fact of history. Methodism was founded by an Englishmen in the Middle Ages. It has zero apostolic origins. John Wesley was not an Apostle.

St. Peter and St. Paul went to Rome together and St. Peter was the bishop therein. That's only common sense. As if a non Apostle is going to head any area when an Apostle is present.

Our apostolic heritage is a fact of history. Your lack of apostolic heritage is also a fact of history.


highrigger



QuoteNope actually I have ample evidence.

I have the biblical accounts in Acts where the Apostles chose St. Matthias to replace Judas Ischariot and the directives of the Holy Spirit in 2Timothy to continue to entrust the teaching and leadership of the congregations to capable men.

lighthammer,

You have no such thing. We know only that Judas was replaced by Matthias as one of the 12.  It has nothing to do with ordination or apostolic succession

QuoteThen I have the history of the early Christiabs listing who some of those men were and where they were stationed.

Those bishops lists are fabricated. Scholars know that but you rely on that for your theory of apostolic succession. It is false and proven such. You cannot rely on those fake bishops lists.

QuoteIt's not my fault your denomination has no history before the middle ages in Europe.

The history of my faith is the common history of Christianity. My church is catholic. We claim succession from the apostles since our bishops and pastors have taken on the tasks of the apostles. Your church has no more valid claim. If you depend on those bishops lists you are just decieving yourself.

QuoteOf course I can claim it. Just because you seek to impose a set of standards that can neither prove nor disprove my claim does not serve to make it false or void.

Yes you can claim it but that is all. You cannot support it . A historical claim not supported by historical evidence or sources is simply myth. That is the extent of your claim. Not very convincing.

QuoteIt just means you're deaf dumb and blind to the validity of the truths of the Church.

Not my problem.

Your own church no longer claims what you claim. I suspect I know more than you do about your own church.

QuoteYou mean by your standards of history? That's like making your own rules. I have expert testimony from the earliest documented records of Christianity.

Those bishop lists have been shown by scholars to be fabricated and no relaible. You have nothing that is reliable.

QuoteI have read several Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox historians and the best your guys can do to cast doubt on the accounts of the early Church are to claim that they're unverifiable and act within that crevous of doubt to give your 33,0000 sects a glimmer of credibility. 

Simple history that you choose to ignore. You prefer the myths over real history for obvious reasons.

QuoteI think it makes you feel to good to consider that your posts rattle my cage in any way. They don't. I'm not angry or bothered. Your entire objections amounts to significance of the insect that degrades my room by forming cobwebs in my corner.

The webs are very elegant but feeble and immaterial.

I am glad you are not angry. No reason for it. We are simply engaged in a friendly debate. No reason to get upset. Best to present the facts that you know if you want to support your case. Getting angry just means you lost the argument.

Again I'm not angry or frustrated but I think it makes you feel good to pretend that your posts are that consequential so feel free to lie to yourself.

Just a friendly debate. No reason to accuse anyone of telling lies.

Peace, JohnR

Catholica

Quote from: AVZ on Wed Jun 20, 2012 - 23:20:19
Quote from: matt1 on Wed Jun 20, 2012 - 18:08:04
Did not Christ promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to teach us all truth?
He did not promise that the Holy Spirit would constantly guide, teach, and give clarity to each individual separately.
If every individual were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all who read Scripture sincerely should come to the same conclusion. But they do not.
The frightful chaos as to the meaning of Scripture is proof positive that the Holy Spirit has not chosen this way of leading men to the truth.
It is blasphemy to say that the Holy Spirit does not know His own mind, and that He deliberately leads men into contradictory notions.
Christ promised to preserve His Church as a Church by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and the only Church which shows signs of having been preserved is the consistent Catholic Church.
The individual is guided by the Holy Spirit to a certain extent in the ways of holiness, but in the knowledge of revealed truth he is to be guided by the Catholic Church which Christ sent to teach all nations.

Ancient Israel had many problems Cannabilism, Homosexuality, polgymy, idolatry, murder, adultery, genocide, child sacrifice, almost every vice imaginable.
However, out of that nation of so much wickedness, the Holy Spirit guided prophets, priests, and Kings to deposit the true faith, the true traditions.
Oral tradition was passed on and guided by the spirit of God for hundreds of years before it was written.
That was how it was done for thousands of years.
Christ is faitful to his word, the Holy Spirit guides the Church and the Traditions, we can rest assured that the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church that Christ built upon the Rock.
The Devil shall do all that he can to destroy the Church, he has done much damage throuhout the centuries, many wicked sheperds will inflitrate the Church to destroy it within, but the Church always emerges victorious in the end.
After the darkest trials and persecutions comes a most glorious ressurection.


For centuries the Sanhedrin argued exactly the same as you.
They were the Pharisees, Sadducees and priests and they claimed they were the ones that knew it all.
They too were under the same promise of God, that God would never forsake His people.
They too claimed that only they had the authority to state what was right and what was wrong.
They too drew their conclusions from lists of sucessions.

How wrong they were!

Acts 7:51-53 "You stiff-necked people, with uncircumcised hearts and ears! You are just like your fathers: You always resist the Holy Spirit! Was there ever a prophet your fathers did not persecute? They even killed those who predicted the coming of the Righteous One. And now you have betrayed and murdered him you who have received the law that was put into effect through angels but have not obeyed it."

The Pharisees sinned, yes, and resisted the Holy Spirit in that way, but they still had the truth.  At least, that is what Jesus said.

Matthew 23
1 Then Jesus spoke to the crowds and to his disciples,
2 saying, "The scribes and the Pharisees have taken their seat on the chair of Moses.
3 Therefore, do and observe all things whatsoever they tell you, but do not follow their example. For they preach but they do not practice.


LightHammer

Quotelighthammer,

You have no such thing. We know only that Judas was replaced by Matthias as one of the 12.  It has nothing to do with ordination or apostolic succession

I hear you saying that but prove. Substantiate your claim for once.

QuoteThose bishops lists are fabricated. Scholars know that but you rely on that for your theory of apostolic succession. It is false and proven such. You cannot rely on those fake bishops lists.

There's nothing false about them. You made that up.

QuoteThe history of my faith is the common history of Christianity. My church is catholic. We claim succession from the apostles since our bishops and pastors have taken on the tasks of the apostles. Your church has no more valid claim. If you depend on those bishops lists you are just decieving yourself.

Your pastors were not ordained and thus have no authority or legitimacy. They are just men imposing themselves on Christian leadership.

QuoteYes you can claim it but that is all. You cannot support it . A historical claim not supported by historical evidence or sources is simply myth. That is the extent of your claim. Not very convincing.

As I said, I have provided ample evidence.  You simply call myth what gives my Church legitimacy and your community a hope for equality with true Christianity.

QuoteYour own church no longer claims what you claim. I suspect I know more than you do about your own church.

I doubt it but go ahead try and back it up.

QuoteThose bishop lists have been shown by scholars to be fabricated and no relaible. You have nothing that is reliable.

By their definition of "fabrication" all of the Bible is fabricated as well.

You simply must have something better to come at this with.

QuoteSimple history that you choose to ignore. You prefer the myths over real history for obvious reasons.

You have no basis to call them myths.



highrigger


QuoteI hear you saying that but prove. Substantiate your claim for once.

lighthammer,

Here again is Fr Raymond Brown.

Raymond Brown, 101 Questions and Answers on the Bible.

"In the early church there never was a suggestion of replacing any members of the Twelve
when they died. The replacement of Judas is because he gave up his role among the Twelve,
and there had to be twelve to begin the renewal of Israel, since there were twelve
patriarchs for the old Israel."

He also plainly explains as I have provided in other places that laying on of hands is not ordination. If you think it is the burden should be on you to suport that view. But I can show it is not via historians and scholars like Brown.

QuoteThose bishops lists are fabricated. Scholars know that but you rely on that for your theory of apostolic succession. It is false and proven such. You cannot rely on those fake bishops lists.

No I did not make it up. I get it from Andrew Louth as follows.

Andrew Louth, translator of Esubius' History of the Church
in his introduction P xxii regarding the bishop list for the Roman Church.

"The problem for the first century or so is what it is a list of: for evidence
that there was a single bishop leading the Roman Church is lacking for that
period; indeed what evidence there is suggests a rather different picture.
When Clement wrote to the Corinthian Church, he wrote not as a bishop in the
later sense but as one of the presbyters of the Roman Church entrusted with
the task of writing on behalf of the whole Roman Church to the erring Church
of Corinth, similarly, Ignatius writing perhaps a decade later to the Roman
Church, does not seem to envisage a 'bishop of Rome', despite his enthusiasm
for monepiscopacy."

"The other odd thing about Eusebius' use of the succession list for Rome is more
venial; that for the last half of the third century he has clearly misread it,
reading years for months and months for years, so that, overlooking the
martydom of Xystus II, he has him reigning for another ten years, which upsests
the chronology of the bishops of Rome for the rest of the century."

"The list of the bishops of Antoc seems also to have been not much more than a
list of names that Eusebius has worked into the Histoy of the Church by guesswork,
(helped by the fact that Ignatius, Theophilus and serapion were more than just
names): He never records the length of an episcopate as he does in the cases of
Rome and Alexandria."

QuoteYour pastors were not ordained and thus have no authority or legitimacy. They are just men imposing themselves on Christian leadership.

My pastors have been ordained by my church and their ordination has no less value than yours. You are unable to explain why yours is valid and mine are not.

QuoteAs I said, I have provided ample evidence.  You simply call myth what gives my Church legitimacy and your community a hope for equality with true Christianity.

Your claim is a myth since it cannot be verified through real history. That is the defintiion of a myth. You cannot substantiate it. All the scholars say so and that is good enough for me even if not for you. I will give you Gary Wills again. There are a number of Catholic scholars saying the same thing.

Garry Wills, Professor of History Emeritus, Northwestern U.,
Pulitzer Prize Winner
author of WHY I AM A CATHOLIC, wrote the following in his
Best Seller WHAT JESUS MEANT page 81.

"The idea that Peter was given some special power that could be
handed on to a successor runs into the problem that he had no
successor. The idea that there is an "apostolic succession"
to Peter's fictional episcopacy did not arise for several
centuries, at which time Peter and others were retrospectively
called bishops of Rome, to create an imagined succession.Even
so, there has not been an unbroken chain of popes."

QuoteI doubt it but go ahead try and back it up.


I back it up time after time by providing Catholic scholars to tell you what is real history.

QuoteBy their definition of "fabrication" all of the Bible is fabricated as well.

Not true. They never teach that. You are just trying to deflect the argument.


QuoteYou have no basis to call them myths.

When a history is asserted that is not real history it is called a myth. Gary Wills above plainly says the apostolic succession does not exist. That makes it a myth. It is a story that cannot be substantiated and in fact much can be provided as I have done to show it is false.
That makes it a myth. Call it what you want. There is no evidence to support it. It is a made up story to make you think your church is the only real one. Entirely false and scholars and historians know this. Even your own church no longer teaces your view. I can give you historian after historian to tell you that Peter was never a bishop of Rome. You have no support at all except the story by those who had no way to know one way or the other. That makes it a myth.

Peace, JohnR

+-Recent Topics

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Today at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Today at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Today at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Today at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Yesterday at 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

Powered by EzPortal