News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898071
Total Topics: 90357
Most Online Today: 6032
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 6069
Total: 6069
Google (2)

The Sign of the Cross (wrong/ok?)

Started by Lily76, Tue Jun 26, 2012 - 20:59:33

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:17:38
Quote from: Lively Stone on Fri Jun 29, 2012 - 14:19:26
That is a false generalization. I refer to born again Christians, and not protestants, who, for the most part runt he gamut of pagans to Christians. I don't receive that appellation.

Born again Christians know that they must know their Bible, because that is where God speaks.
I would agree that born again Christians are versed on the Epistles. Maybe they also read the Gospels.

You obviously aren't familiar with born again Christians. We are led to know the entire word.

QuoteBut in probably 90% of my discussions with "born again Christians", the verses they will quote will be overwhelmingly from the Epistles (mostly one liners) and they will fail to give a proper contextual reading of the verse they are quoting precisely because they have a habit of extracting the verse from the rest of the chapter or book.

What I see is a dearth of biblical knowledge and understanding in 99% of Catholics.

QuoteAs a matter of fact, if you go back through all your posts in this forum, that is what you will find.  It is true of your posts and it is true of the other "born again Christians" posts.

That's a lie, of course, born out of confusion about what the word says and means.

QuoteWhen you are confronted with a long discourse from Jesus (taken from the Gospels) your knee jerk rebuttal is to quote one liners from the Epistles. As if Paul would contradict what Christ is saying.

That is false. You contradict what Jesus says, by your religious indoctrination.

QuoteYour advice is like a blind man saying, "Let me drive".

QuoteMy advice is appropriate for the kind of posts that I have seen come from you.  Go back through all your posts, list every citation that you have given and you will know that I am right.

Not. Everything I have offered from the word, whether quoted or explained is appropriate to show how you have been infected with the spirit of religion.

Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:42:51
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:37:36
It is all a part of worship, Teresa! We don't sit in our chairs and be entertained. Our hearts join in with the choir in the same worship they offer to God!
Worship is more than singing songs.

What a childish comeback. I have already said that.

QuoteIt is a cold heart that sees it as entertainment. You obviously do not understand how Holy Spirit works in His people.
There certainly is more going on there than if you were to go to a secular concert.  Nonetheless, it is not worship although there are elements of worhip in it.[/quote]

I think this is your problem:

1 Corinthians 2:14
But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.

Teresa

Quote from: HRoberson on Fri Jun 29, 2012 - 13:45:34
To focus on Christianity (read: NT) or Judaism (read: OT) is to miss the point.

The history of God's interaction with, love for, and frustration with people is our common history. To arbitrarily separate the two and toss one or the other out is to not quite understand that to which you are called.

Israel was selected - in fact, created - by the Creator. Not because they were special so much, but the simple fact that they were given the very presence of God and His revelation is something to be quite cognizant of, for others to honor them for, and for them to cherish. There aren't very many other peoples who have had as close a relationship to the Creator as have the Jews.

It is not honorable for any people to fail to grasp the calling of God which is evident through the entire Scripture (OT and NT), nor to reject Messiah. The actual death of Messiah did not happen in a vacuum; but was the epitome of Israel's (as a nation) final rejection of her God.

Christians have the same calling, but not as a distinct people on their own. They stand in the history of God's working with people to craft for the benefit of those people and the rest of creation, a people who live in the image in which they were made.

That image is defined variously, but is described succinctly in Galatians chapter 5. It includes a ready acceptance and thankfulness to the God that crafted us to live in His image, blessed in a creation made for our sustenance and blessing. That acceptance includes the desire to pursue life in that image, not as some foreign character change but rather as living into the very image in which we are made. It is, actually, the most natural way for us to live.

We owe a debt to Abraham and his faithfulness to God, and to God for his faithfulness in fulfilling that promise. We are the fulfillment of that promise to Abraham, that he would have descendants as the sand on the shore. Paul makes it clear that the descendants of Abraham are not strictly limited to direct descendants by blood (Jews), but includes all those who respond to God in trust and transformation.

Abraham may not have saved us, but he gave us Messiah, and God's faithfulness specifically to Abraham resulted in our lives in God.
This is hardly something to sneer at.

That is overall a beautiful post.

However I take issue with the wording of the last part.  Abraham did not give us the Messiah.  God gave us the Messiah.  Abraham had nothing to do with the Messiah except for the fact that God chose Abraham to be the root from which the Messiah is to come.  God chose a people to be light to the world and it is from this people that the Light of the World burst forth.

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Teresa

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:49:07
What a childish comeback. I have already said that.
No you did not say that. You said that you go there to worship through the songs. But as I have said, worship is more than singing worship songs.

QuoteI think this is your problem:

1 Corinthians 2:14
But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
Yet another quotation that has no bearing on what we are discussing.

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Teresa

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:46:41
You obviously aren't familiar with born again Christians. We are led to know the entire word.
It boggles the mind then why most citations from "born again Christians" are from the Epistles and hardly ever from the Gospels.

QuoteWhat I see is a dearth of biblical knowledge and understanding in 99% of Catholics.
I would not say 99% - maybe 80% would be more on the mark when it comes to Catholics not being able to quote Biblical verses.

But that does not address the fact that "born again Christians", almost without fail can quote from the Epistles but hardly ever reference the Gospels.  I have encountered that time and time again. When you give them a verbatim quote from the Lord, taken from the Gospels, they will give you one liners from Paul or Hebrews.

QuoteThat's a lie, of course, born out of confusion about what the word says and means.
That is all true. Go ahead and go through every single post you have made.  Write the verses you have quoted and you will find that what I said is all very true.

QuoteThat is false. You contradict what Jesus says, by your religious indoctrination.
Sorry but your posts prove me right.  Take the exercise.  Go through your posts. Write down the references you have cited.
After you have done that - count how many sentences there are in your references (you will find that they are overwhelmingly one verse or half a verse).

Next, count how many of these references came from the Epistles. I think you will find that it is around the 90% mark.

QuoteNot. Everything I have offered from the word, whether quoted or explained is appropriate to show how you have been infected with the spirit of religion.
Yet again, a reply that does not address the matter at hand.


Peace and All Good

Teresa

Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:52:28
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:49:07
What a childish comeback. I have already said that.
No you did not say that. You said that you go there to worship through the songs. But as I have said, worship is more than singing worship songs.

Lie. I did say it, if you would kindly read.

QuoteI think this is your problem:

1 Corinthians 2:14
But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned.
QuoteYet another quotation that has no bearing on what we are discussing.

And you are guilty of helping take this thread off-topic. I simply posted the video to show how our house of worship is no empty place, in response to someone who stated it was empty. Now the continual spirit of criticism pushes on, speaking out against what God enjoys from His people.

Those who know Christ intimately would welcome it with joy, but those who lack His Spirit criticize like Pharisees. It is very much like blasphemy, except I don't expect those who are not Spirit-filled to understand. If you did, then it would most definitely fall under blasphemy.

The only thing I am guilty of here is casting my pearls.


Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:01:47
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:46:41
You obviously aren't familiar with born again Christians. We are led to know the entire word.
It boggles the mind then why most citations from "born again Christians" are from the Epistles and hardly ever from the Gospels.

It all must depend on what the subject matter is. It has nothing to do with our experience with God and His word. We post what is germane. Perhaps we expect that you know the Gospel...at the very least.

QuoteWhat I see is a dearth of biblical knowledge and understanding in 99% of Catholics.
QuoteI would not say 99% - maybe 80% would be more on the mark when it comes to Catholics not being able to quote Biblical verses.

99% to 100% in my experience, and I live in a very Catholic city.

QuoteBut that does not address the fact that "born again Christians", almost without fail can quote from the Epistles but hardly ever reference the Gospels.  I have encountered that time and time again. When you give them a verbatim quote from the Lord, taken from the Gospels, they will give you one liners from Paul or Hebrews.

Once again, if you don't know the Gospel, you will get quotes from the Gospel. You may have a lack of understanding of the epistles, which show us how to experience God. It's the same Jesus that taught Paul and the others. They all jive.

QuoteThat's a lie, of course, born out of confusion about what the word says and means.
QuoteThat is all true. Go ahead and go through every single post you have made.  Write the verses you have quoted and you will find that what I said is all very true.

It isn't necessary. I know what the verses mean in context, and I post what is relevant. If you want to learn the truth, go to those references and read the entire portion for greater context. You are just making excuses to remain where you are spiritually.

QuoteThat is false. You contradict what Jesus says, by your religious indoctrination.
QuoteSorry but your posts prove me right.  Take the exercise.  Go through your posts. Write down the references you have cited.
After you have done that - count how many sentences there are in your references (you will find that they are overwhelmingly one verse or half a verse).

Next, count how many of these references came from the Epistles. I think you will find that it is around the 90% mark.

It isn't necessary, although I am happy you seem to pay attention to what I have posted. What is necessary is for you and others to take the references seriously, read them and from whence they come and see just how appropriate they are to the topic of discussion, and know that they express truth to you.

QuoteNot. Everything I have offered from the word, whether quoted or explained is appropriate to show how you have been infected with the spirit of religion.

QuoteYet again, a reply that does not address the matter at hand.

It is the underlying problem here.

Teresa

#112
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:04:14
Lie. I did say it, if you would kindly read.
Sigh! If you will only read what you actually said there will be none of this.

This is what you wrote: We don't sit in our chairs and be entertained. Our hearts join in with the choir in the same worship they offer to God.

What does that say? That in the singing you join your hearts to the song and worship in that manner.

But as I have said, worship is MORE THAN JUST SINGING WORSHIP SONGS.

QuoteAnd you are guilty of helping take this thread off-topic. I simply posted the video to show how our house of worship is no empty place, in response to someone who stated it was empty. Now the continual spirit of criticism pushes on, speaking out against what God enjoys from His people.  
Actually, since I am merely replying to what you posted (when you gave that video) you are the one who took this thread out of topic.

QuoteThose who know Christ intimately would welcome it with joy, but those who lack His Spirit criticize like Pharisees. It is very much like blasphemy, except I don't expect those who are not Spirit-filled to understand. If you did, then it would most definitely fall under blasphemy.
Yet another irrelevant post.

QuoteThe only thing I am guilty of here is casting my pearls.
Did you have any?

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Lively Stone

Question: "What is true worship?"

Answer: The Apostle Paul described true worship perfectly in Romans 12:1-2: "I urge you therefore, brethren, by the mercies of God to present your bodies a living and holy sacrifice, acceptable to God which is your spiritual service of worship. And do not be conformed to this world but be transformed by the renewing of your mind that you may prove what the will of God is, that which is good and acceptable, or well pleasing and perfect.

Teresa

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:15:13
It all must depend on what the subject matter is. It has nothing to do with our experience with God and His word. We post what is germane. Perhaps we expect that you know the Gospel...at the very least.
Therefore the Gospels must have very little subject matter that they can address which is why you hardly ever quote from them.

Quote99% to 100% in my experience, and I live in a very Catholic city.
Considering your errors, that is hardly credible.  

Besides, that does not get you out of the fact that you are only slightly better than them.

QuoteOnce again, if you don't know the Gospel, you will get quotes from the Gospel.
HUh?  That is probably one of your more ill-thought posts.  How can you reference the Gospel if you don't know the Gospel?

QuoteYou may have a lack of understanding of the epistles, which show us how to experience God. It's the same Jesus that taught Paul and the others. They all jive.
You are right they all jive. But since you counter the Gospel with the Epistles, obviously to you, they don't jive.

The fact that you quote only one liners show that you don't know the Epistles either.

QuoteIt isn't necessary. I know what the verses mean in context, and I post what is relevant.
Yes, I think you have referrenced relevant verses in about 10% of your posts.

The rest are just way off the mark.

QuoteIf you want to learn the truth, go to those references and read the entire portion for greater context. You are just making excuses to remain where you are spiritually.  
Since they are overwhelmingly one liners, no I won't. I  read the entire text - not the 1% that you quote.

QuoteIt isn't necessary, although I am happy you seem to pay attention to what I have posted. What is necessary is for you and others to take the references seriously,  
Since they are only one liners they are hardly serious references.

And yes I pay attention to the posts that I reply to.  If everyone did that there would not be so much muddle headed reply.
Quoteread them and from whence they come and see just how appropriate they are to the topic of discussion, and know that they express truth to you.
I prefer the whole text.

QuoteIt is the underlying problem here.

Yes, particularly of your posts.

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:21:29

Sigh! If you will only read what you actuall said there will be none of this.

This is what you wrote: We don't sit in our chairs and be entertained. Our hearts join in with the choir in the same worship they offer to God.

What does that say? That in the singing you joing your hearts and worship in that manner.

But as I have said, worship is MORE THAN JUST SINGING WORSHIP SONGS.

Yes, when we sing we join our hearts together in praise and worship of God. That is a part of what worship is.

Did you not read all of what I said? Or do you cherry pick that for more llama drama?

From post #96:
Quote from: Lively StoneWorship isn't entertainment. You are judging by appearance, which is shallow, and that is why you are tripping over your own false notion of what worship is. It isn't music, or singing, or instrument playing, or dancing---it is expressed in those ways, and more, but worship is reveling in who God is, which leads us into His very presence.

QuoteActually, since I am merely replying to what you posted (when you gave that video) you are the one who took this thread out of topic.

You insist on contributing to the nasty spin placed on my video, which was not off topic, and taking it further off topic. I am allowed to defend against the nasty criticism.

QuoteThose who know Christ intimately would welcome it with joy, but those who lack His Spirit criticize like Pharisees. It is very much like blasphemy, except I don't expect those who are not Spirit-filled to understand. If you did, then it would most definitely fall under blasphemy.
QuoteYet another irrelevant post.

It is entirely relevant.

QuoteThe only thing I am guilty of here is casting my pearls.
QuoteDid you have any?

You found them!


Teresa

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:45:58
Yes, when we sing we join our hearts together in praise and worship of God. That is a part of what worship is.  
Exactly my point again.  PART of worship. Singing is only PART of worship.
Which is why I said: worship IS MORE THAN JUST SINGING.

QuoteDid you not read all of what I said? Or do you cherry pick that for more llama drama?

From post #96:
Quote from: Lively StoneWorship isn't entertainment. You are judging by appearance, which is shallow, and that is why you are tripping over your own false notion of what worship is. It isn't music, or singing, or instrument playing, or dancing---it is expressed in those ways, and more, but worship is reveling in who God is, which leads us into His very presence.
You gave a video link and classified its content as worship. My comment was stricly about the video link.

QuoteYou insist on contributing to the nasty spin placed on my video, which was not off topic, and taking it further off topic. I am allowed to defend against the nasty criticism.
You're the one who post the video and I am allowed to comment on it considering you said it was worship.  Singing is only part of true worship.

I don't think you have replied to my question yet.

If there were none of the lively music and hyped up music, would you still join your congregation in worship or would you find some other congregation with lively music?

QuoteYou found them!
Was that you among the baubles? If they were your pearls that must be you. ::smile::

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:31:27
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:15:13
It all must depend on what the subject matter is. It has nothing to do with our experience with God and His word. We post what is germane. Perhaps we expect that you know the Gospel...at the very least.
Therefore the Gospels must have very little subject matter that they can address which is why you hardly ever quote from them.

I do, but I quote from every place in scripture that is germane to the topic, and ultimately what the Lord lays on my heart to use. I have no leaning toward any parts of scripture----only what will express the truth to someone who needs it.

Quote99% to 100% in my experience, and I live in a very Catholic city.
QuoteConsidering your errors, that is hardly credible.  

Besides, that does not get you out of the fact that you are only slightly better than them.

You have no proof that anything I believe is error.

Who says I am better---even slightly---than anyone?  That is weird, even coming from you.

QuoteOnce again, if you don't know the Gospel, you will get quotes from the Gospel.
QuoteHUh?  That is probably one of your more ill-thought posts.  How can you reference the Gospel if you don't know the Gospel?

I said if you show yourself to be unknowledgeable of the Gospel, then you will get the Gospel in my references. We are all assuming that at least you know the Gospel---do you?


What may be happening is that we are seeing that several of you lack the understanding of matters that the epistles teach, and that is why you may see a lot of references to them. But I don't see any disproportionate use of any part of scripture. It is all available to me to use and I use it, and reference whatever is germane.

QuoteYou may have a lack of understanding of the epistles, which show us how to experience God. It's the same Jesus that taught Paul and the others. They all jive.
QuoteYou are right they all jive. But since you counter the Gospel with the Epistles, obviously to you, they don't jive.

That's rubbish and you have no basis for saying it.

QuoteThe fact that you quote only one liners show that you don't know the Epistles either.

Yeah, well succinct replies do not mean lack of the grasp of scripture.

QuoteIt isn't necessary. I know what the verses mean in context, and I post what is relevant.
QuoteYes, I think you have referrenced relevant verses in about 10% of your posts.

The rest are just way off the mark.

No 100% relevant, 90% over your head.

QuoteIf you want to learn the truth, go to those references and read the entire portion for greater context. You are just making excuses to remain where you are spiritually.  
QuoteSince they are overwhelmingly one liners, no I won't. I  read the entire text - not the 1% that you quote.

I don't believe you do that at all.

QuoteIt isn't necessary, although I am happy you seem to pay attention to what I have posted. What is necessary is for you and others to take the references seriously,  
QuoteSince they are only one liners they are hardly serious references.

Judging poorly is a problem with you. I keep it simple for just that reason.

QuoteAnd yes I pay attention to the posts that I reply to.  If everyone did that there would not be so much muddle headed reply.

Yes you do, but I discern it is only to continue in your bickery ways. You offer nothing but criticism and offensive comments, and not much in the way of scriptural defense.

Quoteread them and from whence they come and see just how appropriate they are to the topic of discussion, and know that they express truth to you.
QuoteI prefer the whole text.

You have no excuse not to go and read it.

Quote from: TeresaYet again, a reply that does not address the matter at hand.
Quote from: Lively StoneIt is the underlying problem here.

Quote from: TeresaYes, particularly of your posts.

Then get back on track and defend your position with scripture, which is what I am always ready, willing and able to do..


Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:59:02
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 01:45:58
Yes, when we sing we join our hearts together in praise and worship of God. That is a part of what worship is.  
Exactly my point again.  PART of worship. Singing is only PART of worship.
Which is why I said: worship IS MORE THAN JUST SINGING.

QuoteDid you not read all of what I said? Or do you cherry pick that for more llama drama?

From post #96:
Quote from: Lively StoneWorship isn't entertainment. You are judging by appearance, which is shallow, and that is why you are tripping over your own false notion of what worship is. It isn't music, or singing, or instrument playing, or dancing---it is expressed in those ways, and more, but worship is reveling in who God is, which leads us into His very presence.
You gave a video link and classified its content as worship. My comment was stricly about the video link.

Yeah...right.  ::frown::

QuoteYou insist on contributing to the nasty spin placed on my video, which was not off topic, and taking it further off topic. I am allowed to defend against the nasty criticism.
QuoteYou're the one who post the video and I am allowed to comment on it considering you said it was worship.  Singing is only part of true worship.

Then you should have enjoyed the video as an expression of worship. don;t you worship Jesus Christ in your church with special music at Christmastime?

QuoteI don't think you have replied to my question yet.

If there were none of the lively music and hyped up music, would you still join your congregation in worship or would you find some other congregation with lively music?

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.

QuoteYou found them!
QuoteWas that you among the baubles? If they were your pearls that must be you. ::smile::

I only offered you a few to trample. I see you found them. Cute.

winsome

#119
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
.

Where does His Word teach us that worship is three screen entertainment?

Where does His Word teach us that worship is just singing songs?

What is the heart of worship to you and what is the biblical support for that??

As Matt Redmond sings in his song The Heart of Worship
I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus.


Your video was all about the congregation being entertained. Just because the songs mentioned Jesus doesn't make it all about Jesus.

Your church needs to be sorry for the thing they have made it.

Lively Stone

Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:35:35
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
.

Where does His Word teach us that worship is three screen entertainment?

Where does His Word teach us that worship is just singing songs?

What is the heart of worship to you and what is the biblical support for that??

As Matt Redmond sings in his song The Heart of Worship
I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus.


Your video was all about the congregation being entertained. Just because the songs mentioned Jesus doesn't make it all about Jesus.

Your church needs to be sorry for what they have made it.

Well, there ya go again, winsome, short-sighted as always. What I offered was a video showing a choir singing in a church service at Christmastime, and you go off half-cocked in judgment! You are displaying the wrong spirit.

Your part in this discussion is comical, really. When I say worship is all about Jesus glorifying Him, you come in and say, "No, it's all about Jesus!"

Oh, the inanity.

It is all about Jesus.

winsome

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:59:06
Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:35:35
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
.

Where does His Word teach us that worship is three screen entertainment?

Where does His Word teach us that worship is just singing songs?

What is the heart of worship to you and what is the biblical support for that??

As Matt Redmond sings in his song The Heart of Worship
I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus.


Your video was all about the congregation being entertained. Just because the songs mentioned Jesus doesn't make it all about Jesus.

Your church needs to be sorry for what they have made it.

Well, there ya go again, winsome, short-sighted as always. What I offered was a video showing a choir singing in a church service at Christmastime, and you go off half-cocked in judgment! You are displaying the wrong spirit.

Your part in this discussion is comical, really. When I say worship is all about Jesus glorifying Him, you come in and say, "No, it's all about Jesus!"

Oh, the inanity.

It is all about Jesus.

And you told someone else to lay off the ad-hominum attacks!!!!


You said: "Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word"

As usual you have no scripture to back up your opinions.

Where is the scripture to back up that claim?


You don't have a clue about worship. You have reduced it to singing songs.


Lively Stone

#122
Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 03:04:44
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:59:06
Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:35:35
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
.

Where does His Word teach us that worship is three screen entertainment?

Where does His Word teach us that worship is just singing songs?

What is the heart of worship to you and what is the biblical support for that??

As Matt Redmond sings in his song The Heart of Worship
I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus.


Your video was all about the congregation being entertained. Just because the songs mentioned Jesus doesn't make it all about Jesus.

Your church needs to be sorry for what they have made it.

Well, there ya go again, winsome, short-sighted as always. What I offered was a video showing a choir singing in a church service at Christmastime, and you go off half-cocked in judgment! You are displaying the wrong spirit.

Your part in this discussion is comical, really. When I say worship is all about Jesus glorifying Him, you come in and say, "No, it's all about Jesus!"

Oh, the inanity.

It is all about Jesus.

And you told someone else to lay off the ad-hominum attacks!!!!

Then get a clue...please. Your ad hominem attacks about my church are obscene and appear to come from a bitter place, because you have nothing to base them on.

QuoteYou said: "Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word"

As usual you have no scripture to back up your opinions.

Where is the scripture to back up that claim?


You don't have a clue about worship. You have reduced it to singing songs.



Scripture that teaches us about worship is found in the article I posted, and the worship we do in the house of worship  that is an outward expression is taught in Psalms. We pattern our worship after what David did and said.

Worship is not about singing songs, although God is blessed when we sing, dance and play our instruments to His glory! I have already stated that. You are blinded by your own animosity, apparently.  ::doh::

Lively Stone

Seeing as the OP has left GraceCentered forums, I see no reason to carry on with this thread. Nothing good has come from it, as it has come down to more of the same back and forth bickering. I want nothing to do with it.


Toodles!

Teresa

#124
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:14:56
I do, but I quote from every place in scripture that is germane to the topic, and ultimately what the Lord lays on my heart to use. I have no leaning toward any parts of scripture----only what will express the truth to someone who needs it.
That's just it - you don't quote from every part of scripture.  You have a leaning towards the Epistles.

QuoteYou have no proof that anything I believe is error.
I do. But that would get us away from the thread even more.

QuoteWho says I am better---even slightly---than anyone?  That is weird, even coming from you.
In terms of scripture quoting you are better than most Catholics. I did not say you are better as a person. See how you quickly forget what we are talking about.

QuoteI said if you show yourself to be unknowledgeable of the Gospel, then you will get the Gospel in my references. We are all assuming that at least you know the Gospel---do you?
I am talking particular of the 4 Gospels not the Gospel in general. You rarely ever quote from Matthew, Mark, Luke or John.

QuoteWhat may be happening is that we are seeing that several of you lack the understanding of matters that the epistles teach, and that is why you may see a lot of references to them.
In the same vein we could say that you like the understanding from the Gospels that is why you see most of our references go back to them.  They are after all Jesus's own words that we quote.

QuoteBut I don't see any disproportionate use of any part of scripture. It is all available to me to use and I use it, and reference whatever is germane.
As I have said, go back through all your posts and list the Biblical references you have given. Go ahead. Take the time and you will realize that I am correct.

QuoteThat's rubbish and you have no basis for saying it.
Ohh but I soo do. Remember our discussion on whether one is saved by faith alone.  You kept referencing 1 liners from the Epistles while I quoted to you the Gospel according to Matthew - rather long references from Chapters 19 and 25.  You could not reconcile the verses you quoted with the ones I gave.  

QuoteYeah, well succinct replies do not mean lack of the grasp of scripture.
It's not succinct. It was insufficient and failed to correctly reference the entirre text.

QuoteNo 100% relevant, 90% over your head.
The ones that went over my head were your explanation. They were totally illogical. The verses you quoted were way off the mark.

QuoteI don't believe you do that at all.
But I do. That is why I know you were referencing them wrong.

QuoteJudging poorly is a problem with you. I keep it simple for just that reason.
Not simple but illogical.  You have an incapacity at apprehending logic.

QuoteYes you do, but I discern it is only to continue in your bickery ways. You offer nothing but criticism and offensive comments, and not much in the way of scriptural defense.
Ha, ha. It takes two tango my dear. And you were the one who said: shall we dance?

As for offensive comments, your posts drip with them.  You are annoyed because I don't back down when you throw insults.  

QuoteYou have no excuse not to go and read it.
Which is why I do every time you give those 1 verse and half-verses.  You should take the time to understand the rest you know. Not just the one liners you are fond of referencing.

QuoteThen get back on track and defend your position with scripture, which is what I am always ready, willing and able to do..
But I do. All the time. But you don't like them because I quote mostly from the Gospels.

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Teresa

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05
Then you should have enjoyed the video as an expression of worship. don;t you worship Jesus Christ in your church with special music at Christmastime?
We have carols before Mass but that is not part of our worship. We have the Mass. That is worship. And of course there is music at Mass but even without music, it remains worship.

QuoteMy congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
You did not answer my question. My question was, if there is no lively and hyped up music (i.e. take away the music from your service) would you still attend your church's services? Or would you look for another church - one with lively and hyped up music?

QuoteI only offered you a few to trample. I see you found them. Cute.
Since you were the one who posted them, it was you who "found" them (they never left your possesion). So yes, that must be you among the baubles.

Peace and  All Good

Teresa

Ladonia

Lively, don't go. In case you look back, I was just wondering why are you celebrating Christmas anyway?

With your previous stances on many things religious and your approach to the Holy Scriptures, just where are you commanded to celebrate Our Lord's birth? I am surprised that you have the Yule Tide season on your calender, after all, this, the winter solstice is really the most pagan of holidays.

Imagine, Lively Stone recognizing the Christmas season, who would have thought?

Selene

Quote from: Ladonia on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 06:30:03
Lively, don't go. In case you look back, I was just wondering why are you celebrating Christmas anyway?

With your previous stances on many things religious and your approach to the Holy Scriptures, just where are you commanded to celebrate Our Lord's birth? I am surprised that you have the Yule Tide season on your calender, after all, this, the winter solstice is really the most pagan of holidays.

Imagine, Lively Stone recognizing the Christmas season, who would have thought?

Yeah.  Where in scripture did it say that we're supposed to celebrate Christmas?  Imagine that.....Lively Stone recognizing something that's not in scripture.   ::smile::

Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 05:50:28
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:14:56
I do, but I quote from every place in scripture that is germane to the topic, and ultimately what the Lord lays on my heart to use. I have no leaning toward any parts of scripture----only what will express the truth to someone who needs it.
That's just it - you don't quote from every part of scripture.  You have a leaning towards the Epistles.

FALSE.

QuoteYou have no proof that anything I believe is error.
QuoteI do. But that would get us away from the thread even more.

FALSE.

QuoteWho says I am better---even slightly---than anyone?  That is weird, even coming from you.
QuoteIn terms of scripture quoting you are better than most Catholics. I did not say you are better as a person. See how you quickly forget what we are talking about.

That goes without saying.

QuoteI said if you show yourself to be unknowledgeable of the Gospel, then you will get the Gospel in my references. We are all assuming that at least you know the Gospel---do you?
QuoteI am talking particular of the 4 Gospels not the Gospel in general. You rarely ever quote from Matthew, Mark, Luke or John.

If you need something from Matthew, Mark, Luke or John, you will get it from me.

QuoteWhat may be happening is that we are seeing that several of you lack the understanding of matters that the epistles teach, and that is why you may see a lot of references to them.
QuoteIn the same vein we could say that you like the understanding from the Gospels that is why you see most of our references go back to them.  They are after all Jesus's own words that we quote.

You references go to the Gospels because that is all you know.

QuoteBut I don't see any disproportionate use of any part of scripture. It is all available to me to use and I use it, and reference whatever is germane.
QuoteAs I have said, go back through all your posts and list the Biblical references you have given. Go ahead. Take the time and you will realize that I am correct.

No, you are not correct.

QuoteThat's rubbish and you have no basis for saying it.
QuoteOhh but I soo do. Remember our discussion on whether one is saved by faith alone.  You kept referencing 1 liners from the Epistles while I quoted to you the Gospel according to Matthew - rather long references from Chapters 19 and 25.  You could not reconcile the verses you quoted with the ones I gave.  

Nonsense.

QuoteYeah, well succinct replies do not mean lack of the grasp of scripture.
QuoteIt's not succinct. It was insufficient and failed to correctly reference the entirre text.

That's your opinion based on the desire for pithy replies.

QuoteNo 100% relevant, 90% over your head.
QuoteThe ones that went over my head were your explanation. They were totally illogical. The verses you quoted were way off the mark.

I expect they did fly over your head...despite of the simplicity with which I present things.

QuoteI don't believe you do that at all.
QuoteBut I do. That is why I know you were referencing them wrong.

My references are on point.

QuoteJudging poorly is a problem with you. I keep it simple for just that reason.
QuoteNot simple but illogical.  You have an incapacity at apprehending logic.

Simple is more important for you. Logic appeals to those who cannot grasp the simple, however.

QuoteYes you do, but I discern it is only to continue in your bickery ways. You offer nothing but criticism and offensive comments, and not much in the way of scriptural defense.
QuoteHa, ha. It takes two tango my dear. And you were the one who said: shall we dance?

Yes, it takes two, and that is why I said I would bow out---yet you continue the barrage...

QuoteAs for offensive comments, your posts drip with them.  You are annoyed because I don't back down when you throw insults.  

I don't expect you to back down, but I do expect you to carry on a discussion. Instead, you nit pick and make personal comments, which I feel I must defend.

QuoteYou have no excuse not to go and read it.
QuoteWhich is why I do every time you give those 1 verse and half-verses.  You should take the time to understand the rest you know. Not just the one liners you are fond of referencing.

I understand the context of what I reference. I don;t believe for one minute you bother to read anything, except to try to maintain your view and to rebut.

QuoteThen get back on track and defend your position with scripture, which is what I am always ready, willing and able to do..
QuoteBut I do. All the time. But you don't like them because I quote mostly from the Gospels.

That is something you rarely do.



Lively Stone

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 05:55:17
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05
Then you should have enjoyed the video as an expression of worship. don;t you worship Jesus Christ in your church with special music at Christmastime?
We have carols before Mass but that is not part of our worship. We have the Mass. That is worship. And of course there is music at Mass but even without music, it remains worship.

Christmas carols? Not part of your worship? Why sing them, then? for entertainment?

QuoteMy congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
QuoteYou did not answer my question. My question was, if there is no lively and hyped up music (i.e. take away the music from your service) would you still attend your church's services? Or would you look for another church - one with lively and hyped up music?

If our church suddenly stopped worshiping the way God desires, I would have to  consider leaving, because God blesses us with music to glorify Him, and if we ever stopped glorifying Him in those ways, it would grieve Him. It is the worship of His people in praise and in song that brings His presence in. He revels in the praises of His people, and joins in with us, which is why it is an important part of our time together.

QuoteI only offered you a few to trample. I see you found them. Cute.
QuoteSince you were the one who posted them, it was you who "found" them (they never left your possesion). So yes, that must be you among the baubles.

Obviously you don't understand the imagery that Jesus spoke (in the Gospel of Matthew).

Matthew 7:6
"Do not give what is holy to the dogs; nor cast your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you in pieces.


Lively Stone

Quote from: Ladonia on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 06:30:03
Lively, don't go. In case you look back, I was just wondering why are you celebrating Christmas anyway?

With your previous stances on many things religious and your approach to the Holy Scriptures, just where are you commanded to celebrate Our Lord's birth? I am surprised that you have the Yule Tide season on your calender, after all, this, the winter solstice is really the most pagan of holidays.

Imagine, Lively Stone recognizing the Christmas season, who would have thought?

We are free people! We are free to celebrate the Lord's birth, and we do so as a witness to the community on just how to do it.

Lively Stone

NOW! Nitpickers be aware!

I am not going to respond. You will probably continue with your gossipy side remarks and snide comments, but I will skip right over them.

Buh-bye!

Ladonia

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 10:17:53
Quote from: Ladonia on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 06:30:03
Lively, don't go. In case you look back, I was just wondering why are you celebrating Christmas anyway?

With your previous stances on many things religious and your approach to the Holy Scriptures, just where are you commanded to celebrate Our Lord's birth? I am surprised that you have the Yule Tide season on your calender, after all, this, the winter solstice is really the most pagan of holidays.

Imagine, Lively Stone recognizing the Christmas season, who would have thought?

We are free people! We are free to celebrate the Lord's birth, and we do so as a witness to the community on just how to do it.

Well, halelueahh! A holiday not really commanded to be observed specifically in the Scriptures, instituted by the Catholic Church and you celebrate it.  ::amen!::

winsome

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 03:21:06
Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 03:04:44
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:59:06
Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:35:35
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
.

Where does His Word teach us that worship is three screen entertainment?

Where does His Word teach us that worship is just singing songs?

What is the heart of worship to you and what is the biblical support for that??

As Matt Redmond sings in his song The Heart of Worship
I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus.


Your video was all about the congregation being entertained. Just because the songs mentioned Jesus doesn't make it all about Jesus.

Your church needs to be sorry for what they have made it.

Well, there ya go again, winsome, short-sighted as always. What I offered was a video showing a choir singing in a church service at Christmastime, and you go off half-cocked in judgment! You are displaying the wrong spirit.

Your part in this discussion is comical, really. When I say worship is all about Jesus glorifying Him, you come in and say, "No, it's all about Jesus!"

Oh, the inanity.

It is all about Jesus.

And you told someone else to lay off the ad-hominum attacks!!!!

Then get a clue...please. Your ad hominem attacks about my church are obscene and appear to come from a bitter place, because you have nothing to base them on.

QuoteYou said: "Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word"

As usual you have no scripture to back up your opinions.

Where is the scripture to back up that claim?


You don't have a clue about worship. You have reduced it to singing songs.



Scripture that teaches us about worship is found in the article I posted, and the worship we do in the house of worship  that is an outward expression is taught in Psalms. We pattern our worship after what David did and said.

Worship is not about singing songs, although God is blessed when we sing, dance and play our instruments to His glory! I have already stated that. You are blinded by your own animosity, apparently.  ::doh::

No actual scripture to back up your opinions about worship then. Well I didn't expect  it to be any different.

winsome

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 09:49:02

If our church suddenly stopped worshiping the way God desires, I would have to  consider leaving, because God blesses us with music to glorify Him, and if we ever stopped glorifying Him in those ways, it would grieve Him. It is the worship of His people in praise and in song that brings His presence in. He revels in the praises of His people, and joins in with us, which is why it is an important part of our time together.


As you don't understand worship and can provide no scriptures to explain what worship is, how do you know you are worshipping in a way that  God desires?

Ladonia

Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 09:49:02
Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 05:55:17
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05
Then you should have enjoyed the video as an expression of worship. don;t you worship Jesus Christ in your church with special music at Christmastime?
We have carols before Mass but that is not part of our worship. We have the Mass. That is worship. And of course there is music at Mass but even without music, it remains worship.

Christmas carols? Not part of your worship? Why sing them, then? for entertainment?

QuoteMy congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
QuoteYou did not answer my question. My question was, if there is no lively and hyped up music (i.e. take away the music from your service) would you still attend your church's services? Or would you look for another church - one with lively and hyped up music?

If our church suddenly stopped worshiping the way God desires, I would have to  consider leaving, because God blesses us with music to glorify Him, and if we ever stopped glorifying Him in those ways, it would grieve Him. It is the worship of His people in praise and in song that brings His presence in. He revels in the praises of His people, and joins in with us, which is why it is an important part of our time together.

QuoteI only offered you a few to trample. I see you found them. Cute.
QuoteSince you were the one who posted them, it was you who "found" them (they never left your possesion). So yes, that must be you among the baubles.

Obviously you don't understand the imagery that Jesus spoke (in the Gospel of Matthew).

Matthew 7:6
"Do not give what is holy to the dogs; nor cast your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and turn and tear you in pieces.



Well, I have no problem with music as a form of worship to God. I just don't care for certain instuments being used in church. And if a certain way is your way, then more power to you. God knows what's in our hearts and that is what really matters. Our main difference is on certain truth's as regards the interprtation of His holy word. But really, it's nice to know that as far as the Christmas season is concerned you have not rejected everything.

HRoberson

Quote from: Teresa on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 00:50:32
Quote from: HRoberson on Fri Jun 29, 2012 - 13:45:34
To focus on Christianity (read: NT) or Judaism (read: OT) is to miss the point.

The history of God's interaction with, love for, and frustration with people is our common history. To arbitrarily separate the two and toss one or the other out is to not quite understand that to which you are called.

Israel was selected - in fact, created - by the Creator. Not because they were special so much, but the simple fact that they were given the very presence of God and His revelation is something to be quite cognizant of, for others to honor them for, and for them to cherish. There aren't very many other peoples who have had as close a relationship to the Creator as have the Jews.

It is not honorable for any people to fail to grasp the calling of God which is evident through the entire Scripture (OT and NT), nor to reject Messiah. The actual death of Messiah did not happen in a vacuum; but was the epitome of Israel's (as a nation) final rejection of her God.

Christians have the same calling, but not as a distinct people on their own. They stand in the history of God's working with people to craft for the benefit of those people and the rest of creation, a people who live in the image in which they were made.

That image is defined variously, but is described succinctly in Galatians chapter 5. It includes a ready acceptance and thankfulness to the God that crafted us to live in His image, blessed in a creation made for our sustenance and blessing. That acceptance includes the desire to pursue life in that image, not as some foreign character change but rather as living into the very image in which we are made. It is, actually, the most natural way for us to live.

We owe a debt to Abraham and his faithfulness to God, and to God for his faithfulness in fulfilling that promise. We are the fulfillment of that promise to Abraham, that he would have descendants as the sand on the shore. Paul makes it clear that the descendants of Abraham are not strictly limited to direct descendants by blood (Jews), but includes all those who respond to God in trust and transformation.

Abraham may not have saved us, but he gave us Messiah, and God's faithfulness specifically to Abraham resulted in our lives in God.
This is hardly something to sneer at.

That is overall a beautiful post.

However I take issue with the wording of the last part.  Abraham did not give us the Messiah.  God gave us the Messiah.  Abraham had nothing to do with the Messiah except for the fact that God chose Abraham to be the root from which the Messiah is to come.  God chose a people to be light to the world and it is from this people that the Light of the World burst forth.

Peace and All Good

Teresa

Messiah is Abraham's seed, at least as far as Paul is concerned.

It is through the people who call Abraham their father that Messiah came. Mary was Jewish, a daughter of Abraham.

So yes, Abraham gave us both a people of God and a Messiah.

FireSword

Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 03:04:44
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:59:06
Quote from: winsome on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:35:35
Quote from: Lively Stone on Sat Jun 30, 2012 - 02:20:05

My congregation? Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word, so it would never be a quiet place.
.

Where does His Word teach us that worship is three screen entertainment?

Where does His Word teach us that worship is just singing songs?

What is the heart of worship to you and what is the biblical support for that??

As Matt Redmond sings in his song The Heart of Worship
I'm coming back to the heart of worship
And it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus
I'm sorry Lord for the thing I've made it
When it's all about You, it's all about You Jesus.


Your video was all about the congregation being entertained. Just because the songs mentioned Jesus doesn't make it all about Jesus.

Your church needs to be sorry for what they have made it.

Well, there ya go again, winsome, short-sighted as always. What I offered was a video showing a choir singing in a church service at Christmastime, and you go off half-cocked in judgment! You are displaying the wrong spirit.

Your part in this discussion is comical, really. When I say worship is all about Jesus glorifying Him, you come in and say, "No, it's all about Jesus!"

Oh, the inanity.

It is all about Jesus.

And you told someone else to lay off the ad-hominum attacks!!!!


You said: "Of course. We worship God the way He desires and teaches us in His word"

As usual you have no scripture to back up your opinions.

Where is the scripture to back up that claim?


You don't have a clue about worship. You have reduced it to singing songs.



Interesting reply was quite expected. For some reason Catholics complain about protestants butchering the bible, but yet butcher scriptures out of their minds, such as the Joy of the Lord is my strength. Rejoice oh nun, your sacrifice is pleasing to God but didn't the scriptures say there is a time too weep and a time to Rejoice, so why spend all the time weeping when God said to have time to rejoice.






Lily76

Quote from: Lively Stone on Fri Jun 29, 2012 - 02:01:06
It was our sin that nailed Jesus to the cross, and blaming any group of people for Jesus' death just removes the real reason why He came and what was done for us on Calvary. He voluntarily laid down His life.

Jesus forgave. You need to also.


As for Abraham:

Romans 4:16
So the promise is received by faith. It is given as a free gift. And we are all certain to receive it, whether or not we live according to the law of Moses, if we have faith like Abraham's. For Abraham is the father of all who believe.




Quote"You reveal you may not belong to God when you express disdain for His people.

Lily76

#139
Quote from: DaveW on Fri Jun 29, 2012 - 07:10:09
Quote from: Lily76 on Thu Jun 28, 2012 - 23:12:34
I do not know anything about Messianic Jews, but I hope they are not anything like the Catholics, are they?

Hmmmm ... where to start ... where to start ...  ::headscratch::

Why do you hope we are not "like catholics?"  In what way?
QuoteI heard Messianic Jews keep Jewish tradition, no?
Yes.  In fact we see it as a requirement under the New Covenant. (if you are Jewish)

QuoteWhy would those people consider themselves "Jews

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by Amo
Today at 08:51:25

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Today at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Yesterday at 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Yesterday at 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Yesterday at 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Tue Nov 17, 2026 - 14:42:57

Powered by EzPortal