+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898081
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 2227
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1391
Total: 1391
Google

The Virgin Mary says keeping the Ten Commandments is a sign of conversion

Started by drewhemm, Tue Dec 25, 2012 - 09:00:59

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ladonia

Quote from: drewhemm on Thu Dec 27, 2012 - 18:45:28
Quote from: Ladonia on Thu Dec 27, 2012 - 18:35:25
I don't subscribe to the visions at Medjugorje and neither does the Catholic Church. As of yet all this is under investigation. So the very beginning of your thread negates any following comments.

I was surprised no-one mentioned that sooner! I've heard rumours that that is about to change. If it did, would that affect your opinion?

Also, could you explain why you don't currently subscribe to the visions? You're not alone, I hear the local bishop doesn't either, but that doesn't seem to stop millions of others who are convinced they are genuine.

Personally, I have no problem believing they are of supernatural origin. That does not mean I believe they are from God...

If things changed I would be bound to accept the visions as a real event, but until then I will listen to the local Bishop, Ratko Perić who says: "The numerous absurd messages, lies, falsehoods and disobedience associated from the beginning with the events and "apparitions" of Medjugorje, all refute every claim of authenticity."

Even if the Church did declare them to be authentic, the Church still allows us the free will to decide whether we as individuals want to believe them. They would not be considered a dogma of the Church that must be believed to be able to remain an adherant in good standing. We have many mystics of the Church and the people are free to believe their revelations or not.

winsome

Quote from: drewhemm on Tue Dec 25, 2012 - 09:00:59
According to the visionaries at Medjugorje:

http://www.medjugorjetoday.tv/background-7/marys-basic-message/conversion/

Quote
The Ten Commandments are valid, establish the standard

The expressions are different, but the author was and is the same: Throughout the years many of the Virgin Mary's messages from Medjugorje have been reminders and warnings of not only the existence of Satan, but more particularly that the enemy of God and mankind alike is unusually strong in this our time.

Also one of these warnings, the following message is central for another reason, too: It establishes The Ten Commandments as the standard to stick to for anyone who wants to take The Blessed Virgin's hand on the path of conversion. Measuring ones own behavior and actions in the light of the Commandments is vital for remaining and growing on that path. But there will always be opposition:

"Satan wishes to destroy everything which I and my Son, Jesus, are building up. In a special way he wishes to destroy your souls. He wishes to guide you as far away from Christian life as possible as well as from the Commandments, to which the Church is calling you so you may live them. Satan wishes to destroy everything which is holy in you and around you". (September 25th 1992)

Quite a bit can be concluded from this message:

(1) Jesus and the Virgin Mary are building up a lot in our time – in Medjugorje alone about 1,5 million pilgrims are expected in 2011 -  because the Virgin says that Satan wants to destroy "everything that she and her Son are building up". This is so because the apparitions in Medjugorje will end Satan's tightened grip on humanity and launch an era of peace.

(2) An authentic Christian life including a respectful observance of The Ten Commandments is paramount for being with Jesus and the Virgin Mary in their raging battle with Satan, as these two were singled out as Satan's primary targets. Finally and not least notably:

(3) Living an authentic Christian life in respect for the Commandments makes holy.

Indeed, it is through the ongoing conversions and the growing holiness of still more people, still more of her children, that the Virgin Mary intends to bring about the conversion of the world. For this to be possible, over and over in her messages, time and time again, she has called everyone to personal conversion, that is: The daily attempts at replacing a sinful, unrepenting, self-centered life with the holy, God-centered life called for by the Virgin Mary.

For this to be possible, all influences and repercussions of Satan must be rooted out from the life of the believer. Because: "I want each of you to live a new life without the murder of all that God produces in you and is giving you". (March 25th 1987)

Opinions please...

"The Virgin Mary says keeping the Ten Commandments is a sign of conversion"

- No she doesn't. That is an interpretation by "Medjugorje Today" of what she is alleged to have said.

Nowhere in any quotations in the article does Mary mention "Ten Commandments" (unless I missed it)

drewhemm

Quote from: winsome on Fri Dec 28, 2012 - 13:47:11
"The Virgin Mary says keeping the Ten Commandments is a sign of conversion"

- No she doesn't. That is an interpretation by "Medjugorje Today" of what she is alleged to have said.

Nowhere in any quotations in the article does Mary mention "Ten Commandments" (unless I missed it)

Nearly:

Quote
"Satan wishes to destroy everything which I and my Son, Jesus, are building up. In a special way he wishes to destroy your souls. He wishes to guide you as far away from Christian life as possible as well as from the Commandments, to which the Church is calling you so you may live them. Satan wishes to destroy everything which is holy in you and around you". (September 25th 1992)

That's a message purported to have been given by Mary in 1992. Medjugorje Today then references Veritatis splendor written by Pope John Paul II a year later. This is an Encyclical Letter about the moral teaching of the Church, in which the Ten Commandments (also referred to therein as the Decalogue) feature heavily. In it he says:

Quote
As we read in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, "the Ten Commandments are part of God's Revelation. At the same time, they teach us man's true humanity. They shed light on the essential duties, and so indirectly on the fundamental rights, inherent in the nature of the human person".

Don't let the usage of terms such as "fundamental rights" escape you. These are words aimed at political leaders who, 13-years later, are pushing to have elements of the Ten Commandments enshrined in EU law (and by that I don't mean merely talking about it - actual primary legislation has been tabled and voted upon). If this was the US, Constitutionalists would be starting to worry about the future of the First Amendment...

Looks like an interesting piece and is the first time I have seen it, I will probably make time to read it over the weekend.

winsome

Quote from: drewhemm on Fri Dec 28, 2012 - 15:02:24
Quote from: winsome on Fri Dec 28, 2012 - 13:47:11
"The Virgin Mary says keeping the Ten Commandments is a sign of conversion"

- No she doesn't. That is an interpretation by "Medjugorje Today" of what she is alleged to have said.

Nowhere in any quotations in the article does Mary mention "Ten Commandments" (unless I missed it)

Nearly:

Quote
"Satan wishes to destroy everything which I and my Son, Jesus, are building up. In a special way he wishes to destroy your souls. He wishes to guide you as far away from Christian life as possible as well as from the Commandments, to which the Church is calling you so you may live them. Satan wishes to destroy everything which is holy in you and around you". (September 25th 1992)


Mary doesn't say TEN Commandments, just Commandments. That's very Sabbatarian assumption she is referring to the Ten Commandments. Mary is always pointing to to Jesus, as she does in the quote you give.

Jesus said:
"If you love me, you will keep my commandments." (Jn 14:15) - see also Jn 14:21 & 15:10

That's Jesus' Commandments not the Ten Commandments

Is Mary more likely to be referring to her Son's Commandments or to the commandments of the abrogated Sinai Covenant?

drewhemm

Quote from: winsome on Fri Dec 28, 2012 - 15:59:09
Mary doesn't say TEN Commandments, just Commandments. That's very Sabbatarian assumption she is referring to the Ten Commandments. Mary is always pointing to to Jesus, as she does in the quote you give.

Jesus said:
"If you love me, you will keep my commandments." (Jn 14:15) - see also Jn 14:21 & 15:10

That's Jesus' Commandments not the Ten Commandments

Is Mary more likely to be referring to her Son's Commandments or to the commandments of the abrogated Sinai Covenant?

What kind of reasoning is that? A Sabbatarian did not write the Medjugorje Today article! And neither did one write Veritatis splendor unless you're suggesting John Paul II was a Sabbatarian?

drewhemm

Ah, maybe you thought I was trying to use the article to show that the Virgin Mary is suggesting we keep the Sabbath? If so, not at all. I already assumed that would not be the case given her intended audience and I listed the Catholic 'rendition' of the Ten Commandments early in the thread for this reason.

I would fully expect any apparition of the Virgin Mary to support the Catholic Church's stance on Sunday being the day of rest and worship.

drewhemm

Quote from: Ladonia on Fri Dec 28, 2012 - 13:39:49
If things changed I would be bound to accept the visions as a real event, but until then I will listen to the local Bishop, Ratko Perić who says: "The numerous absurd messages, lies, falsehoods and disobedience associated from the beginning with the events and "apparitions" of Medjugorje, all refute every claim of authenticity."

Even if the Church did declare them to be authentic, the Church still allows us the free will to decide whether we as individuals want to believe them. They would not be considered a dogma of the Church that must be believed to be able to remain an adherant in good standing. We have many mystics of the Church and the people are free to believe their revelations or not.

I am fully with you on this. I am very curious to see if the Church concurs with the local Bishop and refutes the apparitions, thereby disappointing many millions of believers, or if it decides to sanctify a 'lie' for practical purposes.

By the way, on Christmas day, it was not Mary who spoke, but 'Baby Jesus'. They say this is the first time this has ever happened. Outside of Medjugorje, have there been any other apparitions of Jesus? If so, could anyone point me to the content of the messages?


Catholica

The visions at Medjugorje, if any are proved authentic, will likely be a mix of true an false apparitions.  There have been many seers there, and many messages have been received.   If the visions are discerned supernatural, this is not the same as indicating that the messages are themselves worthy of belief.  And some messages received from some visionaries may be false while others are orthodox.    We will have to wait and see.

As for the message itself about keeping the commandments, they are of course taken to be understood according to the spirit and not the letter, aka, according to their fulfillment in Christ and not strictly according to the word as written in the Old Testament, for example, keeping the saturday sabbath and everything that went with that, but rather the constant sabbath that is understood according to the spirit, as well as the fulfillment in the mass.

John the Baptist said "repent and believe the gospel".  To repent means to turn to face God, to love God.  If we love God then we keep his commandments and stop sinning.  So obviously it is a sign of conversion if we love God and keep his commandments as best as we possibly can, which gets better over time as we live the gospel and have Christ living in us.  A person being sanctified keeps the commandments more purely every day.  Keeping the ten commandments is a sign of our constant conversion.  Of course it is!

drewhemm

Quote from: drewhemm on Fri Dec 28, 2012 - 16:50:36
I am very curious to see if the Church concurs with the local Bishop and refutes the apparitions, thereby disappointing many millions of believers, or if it decides to sanctify a 'lie' for practical purposes.

Here is an example of exactly that kind of mentality, expressed by the local Bishop when describing the believers in the visions at Medjugorje:

Quote
The Truth about Medjugorje

The Marian theologian Rene Laurentin behaves in the same manner.  He came to visit me around Christmas 1983, and I offered him dinner.  He asked me why I did not believe in the apparitions.  I told him that according to the diary of Vicka and the words of the other "seers" this 'Lady' has been speaking against the bishop.  Laurentin quickly responded: "Don't publish that, because there are many pilgrims and converts there."  I was scandalized by this statement of this well known Mariologist!  This has remained Laurentin's position: to hide the truth, and defend falsehoods.  He has written around ten books on the topic of Medjugorje and in almost all of them, the truth and bishop Zanic are under fire.  He knows well what people like to hear.  Therefore, it was relatively easy for him to find those who would believe him.  "A veritate quidam auditum avertent, ad fabulas autem convertentur" - They will turn away from listening to the truth and wander into myths (2 Tim 4:4).  The "seers" and defenders of Medjugorje led by Laurentin, from the very outset have seen that the modern believer in a communist country very quickly believes in everything "miraculous", in apparent miraculous healings and apparent messages from "Our Lady".

I guess time will tell...

A question: If the events at Medjugorje are either evidently false (i.e. not at all supernatural) or are inspired by Satan (i.e. supernatural but not from God), why would there even be talk of giving Medjugorje shrine status!? Surely that will only have the effect of generating even more human traffic.

Selene

Do you have to use an anti-Catholic website?  Why not use a secular one instead?  Regarding the interview of Vicka in your anti-Catholic website, it stated: 

QuoteJanuary 3, 1982.  All the "seers" together asked Our Lady about Rev. Ivica Vego.  Our Lady answered:  "Ivica is innocent.  If they throw him out of the franciscan Order, may he remain courageous... Ivica is innocent."  Our Lady repeated this three times.

What your anti-Catholic website left out was the part that Rev. Ivica Vego was expelled from the Fransican Order for his immoral conduct for seducing a nun.  When the nun became pregnant, they both left their religious life and lived together.  See the weblink below: 

http://archive.org/stream/Medjugorge-AWarning/medugorje-AWarningByDavies_djvu.txt

It just goes to show how far the anti-Catholics will go to stretch the truth.  Why did they leave that part out.  If Our Lady actually said that he is innocent.....that alone already shows that she is NOT "Our Lady" speaking.  Breaking a vow of celibacy before God and fornication is against God's law...PERIOD.   

drewhemm

Quote from: Selene on Mon Dec 31, 2012 - 15:47:26
Do you have to use an anti-Catholic website?  Why not use a secular one instead?

Which is the anti-Catholic website? I just googled the "Truth about Medjugorje" and this site came up first. Looking at its homepage, it appears to me to be a Catholic website...

Quote from: Selene on Mon Dec 31, 2012 - 15:47:26
What your anti-Catholic website left out was the part that Rev. Ivica Vego was expelled from the Fransican Order for his immoral conduct for seducing a nun.  When the nun became pregnant, they both left their religious life and lived together.

Are you referring to the site I quoted from? It doesn't leave that part out at all; I read it there before you told me here...

Red Baker

Quote from: drewhemm on Thu Dec 27, 2012 - 10:38:48
Quote from: Willie T on Thu Dec 27, 2012 - 09:29:02
The one and only reason for the commandments was to vividly point out that we could never keep them, thus our need to have Jesus come to do it for us.

Agreed, as long as you mean Jesus doing it from within us?

This is blasphemy!  Jesus Christ in the flesh without us, kept the law of God perfectly for us!  We cannot keep the law as a regenerate child of God without sinning!  Read Romans chapter seven and many other scriptures!  Look at the very best of God's saints in the scriptures and what do we see?  They all sinned.  "Doing it from within us"????? What in the world are you talking about?

RB

drewhemm

Quote from: Red Baker on Mon Dec 31, 2012 - 16:00:29
Quote from: drewhemm on Thu Dec 27, 2012 - 10:38:48
Quote from: Willie T on Thu Dec 27, 2012 - 09:29:02
The one and only reason for the commandments was to vividly point out that we could never keep them, thus our need to have Jesus come to do it for us.

Agreed, as long as you mean Jesus doing it from within us?

This is blasphemy!  Jesus Christ in the flesh without us, kept the law of God perfectly for us!  We cannot keep the law as a regenerate child of God without sinning!  Read Romans chapter seven and many other scriptures!  Look at the very best of God's saints in the scriptures and what do we see?  They all sinned.  "Doing it from within us"????? What in the world are you talking about?

RB

How is it people can have difficulty with such a fundamentally Christian concept as Christ living within us?

Quote
Galatians 2:20

I am crucified with Christ: nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me: and the life which I now live in the flesh I live by the faith of the Son of God, who loved me, and gave himself for me.

Quote
Romans 6:4

Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death: that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life.

Quote
Colossians 2:6

As ye have therefore received Christ Jesus the Lord, so walk ye in him

Quote
Galatians 5
  22 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith,
  23 Meekness, temperance: against such there is no law.
  24 And they that are Christ's have crucified the flesh with the affections and lusts.
  25 If we live in the Spirit, let us also walk in the Spirit.

Please explain how Christ living in us and working obedience for us according to His example is in any way blasphemy. When did you see me equate a life characterised by obedience to God as being a life without sin, either in nature or in commission?

Selene

Oops!  My mistake.  I was reading the interview, and you are correct.  They did mention that Vega disobeyed the Pope and was living with his mistress, which is considered a sin in the Catholic Church.  If the apparation actually stated that this was okay, then it is evident that this is a false spirit.  Fornication, disobedience, and the breaking of one's vow are all sins. 

drewhemm

Quote from: Selene on Mon Dec 31, 2012 - 16:41:33
Oops!  My mistake.

No problem. For the record, I would not post here anything from an anti-Catholic website (and no-one until now has accused me of having done so), that would be the last thing I would do whilst wanting to present a credible message. Whenever I can I quote either from the Vatican site itself or other officially sanctioned sites such as the one made for the Seventh World Meeting of Families.

Sometimes I need to quote from third-party sites, such as the ones referring to Medjugorje because there are no official sites.

Catholica

The Vatican will not approve any apparition that approves of sin.  They never ever have before, and they never will, for any reason.

That being said, Medjugorje may prove partially true.  Some apparitions may be authentic and some may not be.  At this point that is the best I can see coming from Medjugorje.  There are multiple "seers" there.

drewhemm

Quote from: Catholica on Tue Jan 01, 2013 - 07:48:51
The Vatican will not approve any apparition that approves of sin.  They never ever have before, and they never will, for any reason.

That being said, Medjugorje may prove partially true.  Some apparitions may be authentic and some may not be.  At this point that is the best I can see coming from Medjugorje.  There are multiple "seers" there.

Having read the report of Bishop Zanic, it is hard to see how Medjugorje could even be partially true. I can assure you that were such a thing to have happened in my church, the 'seers' would have been placed under censure or removed from membership a long time ago. Certainly no shrine status would be given. That said, there are efforts to point to the 'fruit' of Medjugorje, i.e. the many conversions and healings.

You may be curious as to why I, as a Protestant would be keeping an eye on events at Medjugorje (most Protestants believe Mary is long dead and buried). I am watching it because it's impact upon the religious experience of millions is undeniable. I look in the Bible and I see a time when God gives people over to "strong delusion, that they should believe a lie." 2 Thessalonians 2. Medjugorje could be a fulfilment of that warning.

As I mentioned previously, I have no problem at all believing that Medjugorje is indeed supernatural, but by that I mean that Satan is behind the goings-on there. That there should be such clear testimony from the local Bishop, and that people would choose to disregard such testimony and cleave to fables and deceit shows us what kind of world we are living in.

I am particularly concerned about the idea of the 'permanent sign' they mention, especially as they have said it will involve fire. Fire as we know was a sign used by God to demonstrate His presence to Moses in the burning bush and His acceptance of Elijah's offering on Mount Carmel. But in Revelation 13, it is used as tool of deception and precedes some rather unpleasant events.

n2thelight


Quote
"Satan wishes to destroy everything which I and my Son, Jesus, are building up. In a special way he wishes to destroy your souls. He wishes to guide you as far away from Christian life as possible as well as from the Commandments, to which the Church is calling you so you may live them. Satan wishes to destroy everything which is holy in you and around you". (September 25th 1992)

The problem I see right off is the "I"....What exactly did Mary build up?????

drewhemm

Quote from: n2thelight on Tue Jan 01, 2013 - 23:15:40
The problem I see right off is the "I"....What exactly did Mary build up?????

I believe the "I" is in keeping with Roman Catholic Mariology which holds that Mary is - amongst other things - Co-Repemptrix and Mediatrix. This means that Mary has a non-trivial role in the salvation of man, both historically and in the present day.

drewhemm


+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by 4WD
Today at 13:58:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Yesterday at 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Yesterday at 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Yesterday at 21:07:16

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Yesterday at 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Yesterday at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal