News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898081
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 2356
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1710
Total: 1710

Do the scriptures support Papal Infallibility?

Started by Hobie, Sat May 18, 2013 - 05:52:03

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hobie

Where does the Pope get this doctrine, its not in scripture, and you cant just declare you have the power of God which is not sanctioned.

Well, as I was looking for what scripture says and found nothing, but came across something elsewhere on the issue, this interesting take on the Popes infallibility, interesting reading to say the least...

"...we are responsible as Catholics to understand, not only what the Church teaches, but what the Church doesn't teach to help clear up these misconceptions. The Church teaches in a simple summary that the Holy Father, the Pope, the Bishop of Rome, as the successor to Peter and the Vicar of Christ, when he speaks as the universal teacher from the Chair of Peter in defining faith and morals does so with an infallible charism or an infallible gift through the Holy Spirit so that we can give to him the full assent of our intellect and our will, and we can hear the voice of Christ coming to us through the voice of the Pope when he is speaking in this capacity. " http://www.star.ucl.ac.uk/~vgg/rc/aplgtc/hahn/m4/pp.html

mjrhealth


Red Baker

#2
As much as it does mine and yours~One big fat ZERO!  I might add, the scriptures support us, more than him, as far as truth goes.

RB

chosenone

Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

Red Baker

Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

Amen~You have 20/15 vision dear soul!

RB

MeMyself


Jimmy

Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.  Perhaps you misunderstand the RCC concept of papal infallibility.

Red Baker

#7
Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.

Not so fast Jimmy.  His letters, yes~his sermon on the day of Pentecost, NO!   Please hear me out carefully.  Peter was far from being fully converted to the absolute truth, just as we all are here on this forum and in our flesh.  Allow me to explain myself.

Consider Acts 2:21

"And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved."

I ask this question to you~Did Peter fully understand the meaning of whosoever?  Of course not.  Why do you think that God gave Peter the vision in Acts 10?

To teach him the meaning of whosoever!  Peter in his mind thought that the gospel was for Jews ONLY, and that the Gentiles were not to be part of the gospel of Jesus Christ. 

Paul alone fully understood the meaning of whosoever, not Peter, or any of the rest of the apostle, until they were converted to a fuller knowledge of the truth.   Listen to Peter's words after his sermon to Cornelius' household~

Acts 10:34,35

"Then Peter opened his mouth, and said. Of a truth I PERCEIVE that God is no respecter of persons:  But in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted of him."

Acts chapter ten is the first time he truly understood the word whosoever, up until that time, he did not.

Whosoever means all without distinction~Jews and Gentiles, and among them, he has an elect people, chosen by the free grace of God.  Acts 15:15-18

RB

LaSpino3

Scriptures reveal to us that all men have fallen short of the glory of God, and that all works of men are as filthy rags. There are many other verses that clarify the condition of mankind. Now my thinking is this, if any part of a whole is corrupt, how can the whole be infallible?

Answer, it can't! The Catholic Church sadly claims that the Pope is the Vicar of Christ, meaning he is authorized to perform the functions of Christ until Christ returns. Now add to this their declaration that any decisions that comes from any of their councils are infallible. Now I was brought up a Catholic as was my mother, father, and all my grandparents, but I left after I began to study the Scriptures.

The Catholic Church has served Christianity in some areas with love and great faith. But like many, their pride has gotten in the way. Yet in other areas they have failed completely. But when you take this and add their bloody history, especially the history of persecution against other Christians, it is horrifying to say the least. Yet there are many in the church that I would stand side to side with in their faithfulness to our Lord and Savior, those who understand the words that have been written in the Scriptures. 

Phil LaSpino

TruthScientist

All one needs to do is to get out of the company of catholics are read the history of the RCC...  Read about the lives of men who the vatican set up on their thorne.  what is called the catholic church is nothing of the kind and has most certainly perverted the message of Christ and Plan of God to an egotistical religion whose reliance is on numbers and people in high places.

As one writer said Peter had to be straightened out on at least one matter by Paul. 

Until both the presence and power of sin is taken from the world men are vunerable to be seduced and yield to it offer to the imagination.  this is why the RCC as a body is against sola scriptura...  much of it's doctrine can not be defended by the bible and thus that have extra bible and special revelations... 

you can imagine what kind of mental poison a person over the age of 18 who has had to deal with men in the world to convince themselves to believe that a man can be infallible...

to build itself up the so called catholic church has to weaken the bibles authority and convince men that God books, letters and writtings out side of the bible that can not be substantiated by the bible are Truth... 

Please don't fall for this certain lie from the mouth of satan...

Jimmy

Quote from: Red Baker on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:38:08
Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.

Not so fast Jimmy.  His letters, yes~his sermon on the day of Pentecost, NO!   Please hear me out carefully.  Peter was far from being fully converted to the absolute truth, just as we all are here on this forum and in our flesh.  Allow me to explain myself.

Consider Acts 2:21

"And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved."

I ask this question to you~Did Peter fully understand the meaning of whosoever?  Of course not.  Why do you think that God gave Peter the vision in Acts 10?

To teach him the meaning of whosoever!  Peter in his mind thought that the gospel was for Jews ONLY, and that the Gentiles were not to be part of the gospel of Jesus Christ. 

Paul alone fully understood the meaning of whosoever, not Peter, or any of the rest of the apostle, until they were converted to a fuller knowledge of the truth.   Listen to Peter's words after his sermon to Cornelius' household~

Acts 10:34,35

"Then Peter opened his mouth, and said. Of a truth I PERCEIVE that God is no respecter of persons:  But in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted of him."

Acts chapter ten is the first time he truly understood the word whosoever, up until that time, he did not.

Whosoever means all without distinction~Jews and Gentiles, and among them, he has an elect people, chosen by the free grace of God.  Acts 15:15-18

RB

It really doesn't matter whether Peter understood everything he said, or even anything he said.  He spoke the truth, infallibly so.  Whether Peter understood "whosoever" in terms of just Jews or Jews and Gentiles doesn't reflect on his infallibility.  What he spoke was absolutely true, whether or not he fully understood it.

TruthScientist

Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 10:07:33
Quote from: Red Baker on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:38:08
Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.

Not so fast Jimmy.  His letters, yes~his sermon on the day of Pentecost, NO!   Please hear me out carefully.  Peter was far from being fully converted to the absolute truth, just as we all are here on this forum and in our flesh.  Allow me to explain myself.

Consider Acts 2:21

"And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved."

I ask this question to you~Did Peter fully understand the meaning of whosoever?  Of course not.  Why do you think that God gave Peter the vision in Acts 10?

To teach him the meaning of whosoever!  Peter in his mind thought that the gospel was for Jews ONLY, and that the Gentiles were not to be part of the gospel of Jesus Christ. 

Paul alone fully understood the meaning of whosoever, not Peter, or any of the rest of the apostle, until they were converted to a fuller knowledge of the truth.   Listen to Peter's words after his sermon to Cornelius' household~

Acts 10:34,35

"Then Peter opened his mouth, and said. Of a truth I PERCEIVE that God is no respecter of persons:  But in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted of him."

Acts chapter ten is the first time he truly understood the word whosoever, up until that time, he did not.

Whosoever means all without distinction~Jews and Gentiles, and among them, he has an elect people, chosen by the free grace of God.  Acts 15:15-18

RB

It really doesn't matter whether Peter understood everything he said, or even anything he said.  He spoke the truth, infallibly so.  Whether Peter understood "whosoever" in terms of just Jews or Jews and Gentiles doesn't reflect on his infallibility.  What he spoke was absolutely true, whether or not he fully understood it.

If you study the word and have an opportunity to share the word in someones life and are yielded to the spirit of God what you say of His word will be infallible at that time.  and when you get in a cab to go home you can slip right back into flesh.  peter was no different and paul admitted as much.  As long as a person is sticking to the bible they are most likely infallible but as we know the bible can be twisted and used out of place...  the infallibility thing is another way for the papacy to be able to speak a thing to outside of scripture to support it...  The bible contains what God wanted to reveal to men and being Immutable God does not have to send an addendum...  He knows every thing already...he has already through grace slowed the step of a saint down to keep them from the instant of the missle is fired toward him, delayed another saint from going to a place where calamity would surely have peirced him and He put grace into our lives before the foundation of the world...

chosenone

Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.  Perhaps you misunderstand the RCC concept of papal infallibility.

I believe that Paul had to correct Peter on some matters later on, so he clearly wasn't infallible any more than the popes have been. There is nothing in the Bible to say that we need or will have, a man or men, who are infallible and who are somehow 'above' the rest of us in that way. 

notreligus

Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 10:07:33
Quote from: Red Baker on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:38:08
Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.

Not so fast Jimmy.  His letters, yes~his sermon on the day of Pentecost, NO!   Please hear me out carefully.  Peter was far from being fully converted to the absolute truth, just as we all are here on this forum and in our flesh.  Allow me to explain myself.

Consider Acts 2:21

"And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved."

I ask this question to you~Did Peter fully understand the meaning of whosoever?  Of course not.  Why do you think that God gave Peter the vision in Acts 10?

To teach him the meaning of whosoever!  Peter in his mind thought that the gospel was for Jews ONLY, and that the Gentiles were not to be part of the gospel of Jesus Christ. 

Paul alone fully understood the meaning of whosoever, not Peter, or any of the rest of the apostle, until they were converted to a fuller knowledge of the truth.   Listen to Peter's words after his sermon to Cornelius' household~

Acts 10:34,35

"Then Peter opened his mouth, and said. Of a truth I PERCEIVE that God is no respecter of persons:  But in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted of him."

Acts chapter ten is the first time he truly understood the word whosoever, up until that time, he did not.

Whosoever means all without distinction~Jews and Gentiles, and among them, he has an elect people, chosen by the free grace of God.  Acts 15:15-18

RB

It really doesn't matter whether Peter understood everything he said, or even anything he said.  He spoke the truth, infallibly so.  Whether Peter understood "whosoever" in terms of just Jews or Jews and Gentiles doesn't reflect on his infallibility.  What he spoke was absolutely true, whether or not he fully understood it.


This depends on what statements of Peter's that you refer to.  Peter was certainly just a man, and was not infallible.

This is Paul speaking about Peter:

Gal 2:11  But when Cephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned.
Gal 2:12  For before certain men came from James, he was eating with the Gentiles; but when they came he drew back and separated himself, fearing the circumcision party.
Gal 2:13  And the rest of the Jews acted hypocritically along with him, so that even Barnabas was led astray by their hypocrisy.

Jimmy

#14
notreligus, chosenone, TruthScientist,

First, let me state catagorically that I do not believe in the infallibility of the pope.

Then let me say that nothing you any of you have said makes a statement against the papal infallibility as presented by the RCC.  Clearly none of you understand what the RCC means by the concept.  Papal infallibility does not mean the pope is never wrong on anything he says and does.  Within the confines of the RCC definition of infallibility, I have no doubt that you would find Peter to be infallible.

To think otherwise would mean that we could not depend upon anything what Peter wrote and said as recorded in the NT to be inspired by the Holy Spirit and be truth. 

TruthScientist

wouldn't what you say they are trying to say is the anointing which is available to any believer and not just the catholic...  God is no respecter of persons I alway thought...   there are no walls or vails that restrict the believers access to God any more...   catholicism as a doctrine tries to paint God into their 'catholic box'...  He is not confined and will reach out to whom ever...  Luke was a gentile and his writings are infallable...he was not an apostle...

Thaddaeus

#16
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 11:31:30
Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.  Perhaps you misunderstand the RCC concept of papal infallibility.

I believe that Paul had to correct Peter on some matters later on, so he clearly wasn't infallible any more than the popes have been. There is nothing in the Bible to say that we need or will have, a man or men, who are infallible and who are somehow 'above' the rest of us in that way. 

and that includes all of you as well.  This forum is full of people proclaiming their interpretation of a text as infallible.  It is why the whole proptestant/sola scriptura arose.   Once Luther was excommunicated, He knew what that meant and thus formed a more perfect, correct infallible belief system based on his own infallible interpretation of scripture. He even wanted to unilaterally scrap James.  Since 1517 we literally have thousands of popes and they are very active on this forum. All proclaiming their authority over a text and that the interpretation they devise is absolutely infallible.

Jimmy

Quote from: TruthScientist on Sat May 18, 2013 - 12:54:44
wouldn't what you say they are trying to say is the anointing which is available to any believer and not just the catholic...  God is no respecter of persons I alway thought...   there are no walls or vails that restrict the believers access to God any more...   catholicism as a doctrine tries to paint God into their 'catholic box'...  He is not confined and will reach out to whom ever...  Luke was a gentile and his writings are infallable...he was not an apostle...

No I wouldn't say that.  Maybe you should just look it up to see what the RCC actually means by Papal Infallibility?

Lively Stone

Quote from: Hobie on Sat May 18, 2013 - 05:52:03
Where does the Pope get this doctrine, its not in scripture, and you cant just declare you have the power of God which is not sanctioned.

Well, as I was looking for what scripture says and found nothing, but came across something elsewhere on the issue, this interesting take on the Popes infallibility, interesting reading to say the least...

"...we are responsible as Catholics to understand, not only what the Church teaches, but what the Church doesn't teach to help clear up these misconceptions. The Church teaches in a simple summary that the Holy Father, the Pope, the Bishop of Rome, as the successor to Peter and the Vicar of Christ, when he speaks as the universal teacher from the Chair of Peter in defining faith and morals does so with an infallible charism or an infallible gift through the Holy Spirit so that we can give to him the full assent of our intellect and our will, and we can hear the voice of Christ coming to us through the voice of the Pope when he is speaking in this capacity. "

No, no, no!!! There is only ONE 'universal teacher' and He is Jesus Christ, through the power of Holy Spirit. No one and nothing is infallible but Him! He uses people to speak and teach truth, but He isn't confined to one person, and especially not one person who has been placed as some authority to a larger group that falsely claims to be the one true Church! It's only a ruse, but a very dangerous one, because so many are captivated by it.

HRoberson

I think that the answer depends on what one means by "support."

Are there verses that may lend themselves to such a use? Sure.

Unfortunately it is not clear that those passages actually do support papal infallibility. Since there is no conclusive indication that Peter, throughout Scripture, exercised some sort of juridical authority over the church - there is much more evidence that Paul may have, it is highly questionable whether there was any pal authority at all as we understand the concept. If there was no papal authority, there could not be anything infallible about it.

The idea of papal infallibility did not develop in a vacuum, but with the development of the church over time. The concept of papal infallibility is part and parcel tied up with the self assertion by the Bishop of Rome that he enjoyed some sort of superior juridical prerogative over the other patriarchs. The idea sets him above and the court of last resort over the other bishops.

This claim though has not been supported by the other bishops and seems to be contrary to the admonition that the disciples should not seek to "lord themselves over their brothers." History indicates exactly this development in the face of protest by the other bishops.

Thus, the universal church has never recognized this juridical position of the Bishop of Rome and in fact does not to this very day. Because the prerogatives have been self-assumed, we can conclude that they are far from infallible.

Hobie

Quote from: Jimmy on Sat May 18, 2013 - 09:19:52
Quote from: chosenone on Sat May 18, 2013 - 07:57:02
Answer. NO no no no no. Some from the RC church claim that Peter was the first pope, and he certainly wasn't infallible. All men fall short, God says, and that includes any church leaders. All means all, at least the last time I looked.

I am not RC and I certainly do not support many of the views and teachings of the RCC; but I do not think that your statement in any way refutes the RCC claim of papal infallibility.  Peter was most definitely infallible in his sermon at that first Pentecost.  And the letters by Peter in the NT are also written within the framework of infallibility, as were all the Books of the Bible.  Perhaps you misunderstand the RCC concept of papal infallibility.
Peter fell time and time again and even after the Pentecost he was prone to errors as Paul shows.

Red Baker

#21
Would some brave Catholic come and define for us in Catholic words what they believe as far as Papal infallibility, so as to setter the dust down, over the controversy at hand.  This is a sincere request.  I prefer Catholica~for, before God, I do respect him for his sober writings, and his sincerity for his faith. 

RB

Hobie

Quote from: Red Baker on Sat May 18, 2013 - 15:44:28
Would some brave Catholic come and define for us in Catholic words what they believe as far as Papal infallibility, so as to setter the dust down, over the controversy at hand.  This is a sincere request.  I prefer Catholica~for, before God, I do respect him for his sober writings, and his sincerity for his faith. 

RB
Is that a users name/specific person?

Hobie

Well it looks like they may be busy with more important topics or sleeping and must be awaked, or having IP conflict or router issues and cant post at this time. If I can have your permission to be excuse me at this time if that is ok with everyone, as I have other pressing appointments, but will check in later in the week to see if anyone has found some scripture they can present for our review.

Happy Sabbath...
Hobie

LightHammer

Yes the scriptures support and confirm papal infallibility. Now why you didn't put this in the Catholic Forum is beyond me.

Clarity

#25
Quote from: LightHammer on Sun May 19, 2013 - 20:29:53
Yes the scriptures support and confirm papal infallibility. Now why you didn't put this in the Catholic Forum is beyond me.

No the scriptures do not support and confirm papal infallibility. Now why you didn't provide any Scriptural evidence is beyond me.

TruthScientist

from a wannabe non denominationalist may I ask if it would in any way men that God would either trust a man to "keep His Word" or that He would somehow need to interupt what Jesus said the Holy Spirit was coming to do...


Lively Stone

Quote from: LightHammer on Sun May 19, 2013 - 20:29:53
Yes the scriptures support and confirm papal infallibility. Now why you didn't put this in the Catholic Forum is beyond me.

Scripture doesn't even teach a papal position, so what scriptures are you talking about?

LightHammer

Papal Infallibility teaches that the Apostle Peter as head of the Apostles has the right to speak for the entire Church. This right stems from Christ appointing Peter as Steward of the Church on Earth when He gave him the keys and through him the rest of the Church. This right means that Peter can declare a particular belief dogmatic and therefore required for all Christians to believe and that he can implement church policy on a universal level.

The scriptures that support this are apparent. In the Gospels the Apostle Peter declares the common faith of all true Christians, that is that Jesus Christ is God's Messiah. Then there is Matthew 16 where Christ gives Peter the keys to the kingdom. These keys were emblematic of the "key to the house of David" that Christ as the promised King inherited when He was born. This is the authority of the Church.

Papal Infallibility goes on to say that through the succession of St. Peter (whose first three successors were St. Linus mentioned in Thessalonians, St. Analectus and St. Clement) the current Bishop of Rome, Pope Francis I, inherits these same prerogatives that Christ gave to Peter for the physical governing and protection of His entire Church throughout the world. 

Below I will list the scriptures and sources for papal infallibility. These scriptures while not conclusive to some are undeniably supportive of Christ's design for Peter's ministry.

1) Matthew 16:18 Peter is given the keys.

2) Isaiah 22:22 The keys that are emblematic of the key of the house of David. (Metaphors as neither Christ nor Isaiah were talking about literal keys but authority)

3) Acts 15 Peter issues the declaration of the council of Jerusalem.

4) Galatians 2:11-21 Peter unilaterally implements policy.

Papal Infallibility search at the Catechism of the Catholic Church

and the decree of the Sacred Council held at the Vatican in the city of Rome ministered by Ss Peter and Paul and consecrated with the blood of their holy martyrdom.

http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.htm#6


Lively Stone

Peter was never the head of the Church. No one but Jesus is. Now, that's biblical. Neither is there any teaching about succession.

Clarity

#30
Quote from: LightHammer on Sun May 19, 2013 - 22:45:43
Papal Infallibility teaches that the Apostle Peter as head of the Apostles has the right to speak for the entire Church. This right stems from Christ appointing Peter as Steward of the Church on Earth when He gave him the keys and through him the rest of the Church. This right means that Peter can declare a particular belief dogmatic and therefore required for all Christians to believe and that he can implement church policy on a universal level.


You forgot to mention the Apostle Paul who was given this authority from the Master to speak to the Gentiles, of which you are one.

Quote

The scriptures that support this are apparent. In the Gospels the Apostle Peter declares the common faith of all true Christians, that is that Jesus Christ is God's Messiah.


Again you forgot to mention the Apostle Paul - do you have something "against" your brother Paul?

(For he that wrought effectually in Peter to the apostleship of the circumcision, the same was mighty in me (Paul) toward the Gentiles:) (Gal 2:8)

Lighthammer, let the truth be known to all in this forum that you stand apart from the Gospel of Jesus Christ and defend the doctrines of men.  You cannot discern between the Apostleship of Peter and of Paul seeing you make men as heads over you.  ::frown::

Quote

Then there is Matthew 16 where Christ gives Peter the keys to the kingdom. These keys were emblematic of the "key to the house of David" that Christ as the promised King inherited when He was born. This is the authority of the Church.


And those same Keys were given to Paul and all those who listened.

Quote

Papal Infallibility goes on to say that through the succession of St. Peter (whose first three successors were St. Linus mentioned in Thessalonians, St. Analectus and St. Clement) the current Bishop of Rome, Pope Francis I, inherits these same prerogatives that Christ gave to Peter for the physical governing and protection of His entire Church throughout the world. 


You forgot Paul once more!

1. Peter sent to the Jews
2. Paul sent to the Gentiles

You claim succession which had its roots in truth but now is apostate in practice and doctrine due to the philopshies of men.  Their fathers are Plato and Constantine and many like them.

Quote

Below I will list the scriptures and sources for papal infallibility. These scriptures while not conclusive to some are undeniably supportive of Christ's design for Peter's ministry.

1) Matthew 16:18 Peter is given the keys.

2) Isaiah 22:22 The keys that are emblematic of the key of the house of David. (Metaphors as neither Christ nor Isaiah were talking about literal keys but authority)

3) Acts 15 Peter issues the declaration of the council of Jerusalem.

4) Galatians 2:11-21 Peter unilaterally implements policy.

Papal Infallibility search at the Catechism of the Catholic Church

and the decree of the Sacred Council held at the Vatican in the city of Rome ministered by Ss Peter and Paul and consecrated with the blood of their holy martyrdom.

http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.htm#6

And then you quote Gal 2  ::headscratch::

But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed. (Gal 2:11)

And blamed he was!

Paul knew that Peter still held to orthodox doctrine - his beliefs about the gospel were correct. But his practices contradicted what he was believing. This type of inconsistency causes a disconnect between doctrine and practice, and the human mind tends to reconcile the problem by changing doctrine to correspond with the practice. This is what Paul was afraid might happen, so he stood firm for the truths of the faith.

Paul had greater understanding of the keys of the Kingdom at that time than your beloved "Saint" Peter and you have the audacity to present Gal 2 as evidence of apostolic succession. 

Lighthammer, you need to put away all your catechisms and start reading your Bible.

Enough said.

Clarity

TruthScientist

#31
Lighthammer...  no 1 the rock Jesus referred to is the doctrine of salvation which allows entrance into the Kingdom of heaven.  you might want to check out this verse>>>Revelation 21:25 (KJV)
25  And the gates of it shall not be shut at all by day: for there shall be no night there.

the usual relation to the rock is peter's name in greek petra...  notice what Jesus called Him...  if the rock were peter do you not think He would have emphasized it so you could use it today...  but he called him simon son of jonah...

the only authority of the church is what is found in the bible.  And Jesus or God did not authorize a pope but the Holy Spirit to be care taker in stead of Jesus after he Ascended into Heaven... 

Simon means one who hears and obeys...  peter did not always obey but he did listen.   a brutish man but yet most of the tyme brutally honest.  When he was not caught up in his emotions he was always on spot with an answer to Jesus...unlike when Jesus mentioned that he had to die...  now here we have 'the first infallible pope' wanting to deny the salvation and one of the vaticans most sacred traditions, the eucharist...  now would have been an slip up for the future pope... 

LightHammer

Quote from: TruthScientist on Sun May 19, 2013 - 23:33:59
Lighthammer...  no 1 the rock Jesus referred to is the doctrine of salvation which allows entrance into the Kingdom of heaven.  you might want to check out this verse>>>Revelation 21:25 (KJV)
25  And the gates of it shall not be shut at all by day: for there shall be no night there.

the usual relation to the rock is peter's name in greek petra...  notice what Jesus called Him...  if the rock were peter do you not think He would have emphasized it so you could use it today...  but he called him simon son of jonah...

the only authority of the church is what is found in the bible.  And Jesus or God did not authorize a pope but the Holy Spirit to be care taker in stead of Jesus after he Ascended into Heaven... 

Simon means one who hears and obeys...  peter did not always obey but he did listen.   a brutish man but yet most of the tyme brutally honest.  When he was not caught up in his emotions he was always on spot with an answer to Jesus...unlike when Jesus mentioned that he had to die...  now here we have 'the first infallible pope' wanting to deny the salvation and one of the vaticans most sacred traditions, the eucharist...  now would have been an slip up for the future pope... 

1. You are of course welcomed to your opinion. However Christ referred to a person named Simon as Peter not on anything Simon said or did. You asked for scriptures that are used to support papal infallibility.

2. Your mentioning of St. Peter's struggle with Christ's teachings do not apply to papal infallibility for several reasons.

A) St. Peter was not yet steward of the Church as Cheist was still physically on earth.

B) The coming of the Holy Spirit had not yet breathed life into the apostolic ministry therefore Peters rights were not yet endowed by God. Think of like the creation of man. First God made the body of Adam and all it's parts but only until God breathed the breath of life into Adam did he become a living soul. The same is the case here. Christ former the body of the Apostles but their ministry did not get life and power until Christ poured out His Spirit at Pentecost.

Your references to St. Peter predate that which in turn makes your point unviable.

Furthermore your reference doesn't actually touch the realm of papal infallibility. St. Peter wrestling against Christs crucifixion is not equivalent to doctrinal impropriety.

TruthScientist

Quote from: LightHammer on Mon May 20, 2013 - 00:53:18
Quote from: TruthScientist on Sun May 19, 2013 - 23:33:59
Lighthammer...  no 1 the rock Jesus referred to is the doctrine of salvation which allows entrance into the Kingdom of heaven.  you might want to check out this verse>>>Revelation 21:25 (KJV)
25  And the gates of it shall not be shut at all by day: for there shall be no night there.

the usual relation to the rock is peter's name in greek petra...  notice what Jesus called Him...  if the rock were peter do you not think He would have emphasized it so you could use it today...  but he called him simon son of jonah...

the only authority of the church is what is found in the bible.  And Jesus or God did not authorize a pope but the Holy Spirit to be care taker in stead of Jesus after he Ascended into Heaven... 

Simon means one who hears and obeys...  peter did not always obey but he did listen.   a brutish man but yet most of the tyme brutally honest.  When he was not caught up in his emotions he was always on spot with an answer to Jesus...unlike when Jesus mentioned that he had to die...  now here we have 'the first infallible pope' wanting to deny the salvation and one of the vaticans most sacred traditions, the eucharist...  now would have been an slip up for the future pope... 

1. You are of course welcomed to your opinion. However Christ referred to a person named Simon as Peter not on anything Simon said or did. You asked for scriptures that are used to support papal infallibility.

2. Your mentioning of St. Peter's struggle with Christ's teachings do not apply to papal infallibility for several reasons.

A) St. Peter was not yet steward of the Church as Cheist was still physically on earth.

B) The coming of the Holy Spirit had not yet breathed life into the apostolic ministry therefore Peters rights were not yet endowed by God. Think of like the creation of man. First God made the body of Adam and all it's parts but only until God breathed the breath of life into Adam did he become a living soul. The same is the case here. Christ former the body of the Apostles but their ministry did not get life and power until Christ poured out His Spirit at Pentecost.

Your references to St. Peter predate that which in turn makes your point unviable.

Furthermore your reference doesn't actually touch the realm of papal infallibility. St. Peter wrestling against Christs crucifixion is not equivalent to doctrinal impropriety.
As are you sir...  and each of the reasons you gave to my statements of the scripture were not refuted but you simply excused them saying peter had not yet assumed what you assume would be the post clearly given to the Holy Spirit in John 14.  The bible is clear sir and needs no help and neither does the Holy Spirit in keeping what Jesus sent it to do.  I admire Peter as a disciple and Apostle.  And like Mary I am sure that He is wondering right now how did a sect get so crossed to use him against what the scripture says... 

The keeping of popery is  the main reason for the anti sola scriptura stance by the vatican...  much of it's doctrine is only supported by writ outside of the canon...

Clarity

#34
Quote from: TruthScientist on Mon May 20, 2013 - 01:37:14
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon May 20, 2013 - 00:53:18
Quote from: TruthScientist on Sun May 19, 2013 - 23:33:59
Lighthammer...  no 1 the rock Jesus referred to is the doctrine of salvation which allows entrance into the Kingdom of heaven.  you might want to check out this verse>>>Revelation 21:25 (KJV)
25  And the gates of it shall not be shut at all by day: for there shall be no night there.

the usual relation to the rock is peter's name in greek petra...  notice what Jesus called Him...  if the rock were peter do you not think He would have emphasized it so you could use it today...  but he called him simon son of jonah...

the only authority of the church is what is found in the bible.  And Jesus or God did not authorize a pope but the Holy Spirit to be care taker in stead of Jesus after he Ascended into Heaven... 

Simon means one who hears and obeys...  peter did not always obey but he did listen.   a brutish man but yet most of the tyme brutally honest.  When he was not caught up in his emotions he was always on spot with an answer to Jesus...unlike when Jesus mentioned that he had to die...  now here we have 'the first infallible pope' wanting to deny the salvation and one of the vaticans most sacred traditions, the eucharist...  now would have been an slip up for the future pope... 

1. You are of course welcomed to your opinion. However Christ referred to a person named Simon as Peter not on anything Simon said or did. You asked for scriptures that are used to support papal infallibility.

2. Your mentioning of St. Peter's struggle with Christ's teachings do not apply to papal infallibility for several reasons.

A) St. Peter was not yet steward of the Church as Cheist was still physically on earth.

B) The coming of the Holy Spirit had not yet breathed life into the apostolic ministry therefore Peters rights were not yet endowed by God. Think of like the creation of man. First God made the body of Adam and all it's parts but only until God breathed the breath of life into Adam did he become a living soul. The same is the case here. Christ former the body of the Apostles but their ministry did not get life and power until Christ poured out His Spirit at Pentecost.

Your references to St. Peter predate that which in turn makes your point unviable.

Furthermore your reference doesn't actually touch the realm of papal infallibility. St. Peter wrestling against Christs crucifixion is not equivalent to doctrinal impropriety.
As are you sir...  and each of the reasons you gave to my statements of the scripture were not refuted but you simply excused them saying peter had not yet assumed what you assume would be the post clearly given to the Holy Spirit in John 14.  The bible is clear sir and needs no help and neither does the Holy Spirit in keeping what Jesus sent it to do.  I admire Peter as a disciple and Apostle.  And like Mary I am sure that He is wondering right now how did a sect get so crossed to use him against what the scripture says... 

The keeping of popery is  the main reason for the anti sola scriptura stance by the vatican...  much of it's doctrine is only supported by writ outside of the canon...
TruthScientist

I particularly liked your closing remark.

Clarity

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by 4WD
Yesterday at 13:58:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 21:07:16

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal