News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898068
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 6875
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 4937
Total: 4938
mommydi
Google (2)

Catholics Do Not Worship Idols .

Started by Paulus, Sat Oct 25, 2014 - 08:39:43

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

winsome

#140
Let's start with some of the more peripheral issues (to the thread)

Quote from: AVZAnd that's why within the Catholic Church the even more misguided opinion arose to increasingly adore Mary, and now even want to make her co-redeemer.

The Church does not want to make Mary co-redeemer - see my post #82



Quote from: AVZthe Catholic Church has a hierarchical structure where everything flows upwards to the Pope

In hierarchy things flow down from the top not up.



Quote from: AVZand any behavior of any Catholic Church bears the stamp of approval......

No it doesn't . that is just wrong



Quote from: AVZ..or the so-called "nihil obstat".

You obviously have no idea what "nihil obstat" refers to and what it means.



Quote from: AVZThis whole thread has been completely void of any scripture that supports the Catholic position.

Untrue - see post #26

chosenone

Exodus 20:4Amplified Bible (AMP)

4 You shall not make yourself any graven image  or any likeness of anything that is in the heavens above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth;

So no humans or animals or similar. An idol of anything that is/was living and breathing.

I have never known a Christian to pray to or bow down to a cross. Its a reminder of what Jesus did for us.

kensington

#142
I don't know that a Cross is a "graven" image, meant for prayer and worship.  Is it?  NO... the church I attend does not have one. Nor did the one I attended before this one. 

But, it's not engraved to look like a person or an image of anyone you would pray to.  A cross is two pieces of wood, Put together to become one. How would one engrave that?  It's not an idol or an image of anything... it is a cross.  A simple shape.  No matter how many times you make one, it will still just be a cross.

Would it really be the same as carving images of Mary with golden crowns on her head, in garments of grandeur, and kneeling before it for any reason?  Especially, for honor and prayer? For reverence, or even serious reflection of what you believe that person is or did for you?  To revere or to venerate?

I mean, when the twin towers fell on 911, after the dust cleared, there was left standing in the dust, a cross.  Two junctures of metal that formed a cross.   It was left there after everything fell.  I think it's still standing somewhere.  I never saw anyone praying at it, kneeling before it.  Is that cross a sin? 

Catholics say that it's not a sin to have images, only to bow before them, to pray to them, to worship them.  We see pictures all over of people kneeling before them in prayer.  What are we supposed to think?  We do not bow to images or use them for prayer and veneration.  It would be hypocrisy for me to say that a protestant can have statues of anyone to use for prayer or venerating that person for who they are or what they have done.  It's not Okay, and I have not said it is.




winsome

Quote from: chosenone
Exodus 20:4Amplified Bible (AMP)

4 You shall not make yourself any graven image  or any likeness of anything that is in the heavens above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth;

So no humans or animals or similar. An idol of anything that is/was living and breathing.

Doesn't say "anything that is/was living and breathing". It just says anything




winsome

Quote from: kensingtonCatholics say that it's not a sin to have images, only to bow before them, to pray to them, to worship them.  We see pictures all over of people kneeling before them in prayer.  What are we supposed to think?

What are you to think?

Well you could ask Catholics and not just jump to conclusions based on either ignorance or prejudice (take your pick)

Paulus

Chosenone you say that you have never known a Christian pray to a cross .

Neither have I .

Who would be so silly as to think that Christians prayed to a cross , a statue , an icon etc. ? That would be to cease to worship the true God , substituting God for an idol .

But you post the following quote : " Exodus 20:4Amplified Bible (AMP)

4 You shall not make yourself any graven image  or any likeness of anything that is in the heavens above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; "

Now it has been said on this thread that the words you have quoted actually forbid the making of graven images of anything .

If you say that is true , you must also say that making crosses to put in churches is forbidden by God , because crosses are graven images .

Amo

Quote from: Paulus on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 08:51:38
Amo , you say : "  It is making a graven image that is sin. "

Ok . Following what you say there is only one logical conclusion .

A wooden cross is a graven image .

Therefore making a wooden cross is a sin .

People have made wooden crosses for their church buildings .

Therefore these people have sinned .

No image is a graven image until someone treats it like a god. Until then it is just an image. Kneeling before and praying to an image or whatever that image represents, is the act which makes it a graven image. You only see it the way you do, so that you can accuse others of what your own denomination does, that you might excuse the same. Others doing wrong along with us, can never justify our actions.

kensington

Well you could ask Catholics and not just jump to conclusions based on either ignorance or prejudice (take your pick)

I have asked Catholics, Catholics who say they pray to Mary, who say they do worship Mary, that Mary is to be worshipped.  That Mary is Co/redeemer with Jesus Christ. That they do pray to the saints, that Mary is present in her statues, and that they pray to Angels. You forget, I am related to a whole parish of Catholics. You 3 here, are the only ones who reflect in word something different, and yet in deed you reflect the same as they do with your images, people kneeling before them. THAT IS PRAYING/BOWING...   You know, if it walks like a duck, and talks like a duck, it's a duck. 

Anything else?





winsome

If a Catholic says they worship Mary, and that Mary is to be worshipped, then they are not a true Catholic. They are going directly against what the Church teaches.

If you watched the video that Paulus gave in the OP then you will have seen that the presenter mentioned some nuns who did that and refused to recant, and were excommunicated. It is not Catholic teaching.

Personally I think you have misinterpreted what they say, but if they truly believe that Mary is to be worshipped then they should be condemned. But do not condemn the Catholic Church on account of them. The Catholic Church is very clear in this.

winsome

Quote from: AmoNo image is a graven image until someone treats it like a god.

Graven in this context meams engraved or carved. It is nothing to do with whether it is treated as a god or not.

But I agree that the problem comes when an image is treated like a god.

Quote from: AmoKneeling before and praying to an image or whatever that image represents, is the act which makes it a graven image.

I disagree on that. A graven image is one that is engraved or carved.

Quote from: AmoYou only see it the way you do, so that you can accuse others of what your own denomination does, that you might excuse the same. Others doing wrong along with us, can never justify our actions.

Slanderous accusation.


Paulus

Amo , you say : " No image is a graven image until someone treats it like a god. "

But that is incorrect .

The word "graven" is the past participle of the verb "grave" .

Grave comes from the Old English word "grafan" and is related to the Old High German "graben" to dig .

To grave is to cut, carve, sculpture, or engrave .

Something graven is something which has been graved , cut , carved , sculptured or engraved .

An image is a physical likeness or representation of a person, animal, or thing, photographed, painted, sculptured, or otherwise made visible.

A graven image is a carved representation .

The statue of Admiral Nelson on the top of Nelson's Column in Trafalgar Square is a graven image , a sculptured representation of Admiral Nelson . It has never had to be treated as a god to make it such . It is such just because it has been graved , sculptured to create a likeness , representation of Nelson .

So as soon as a craftsman has carved , graved the image of someone/something he has created a graven image , a carved image .


kensington

#151
"were excommunicated"  "if they truly believe that Mary is to be worshipped then they should be condemned."

WOW...  rather than to seek to teach them the truth, you condemn them or excommunicate them?  You must be sinless.

I wonder if Jesus is really so unforgiving?  Almost every single denom or religion, (and yes the Catholic Church) has missed on something I will bet.  We are not perfect, but being perfected "by the WORD" until the day we see him face to face.  Only then will we achieve perfection, when He gives it to us, each one.

I have a son who drinks a bit too much when he parties, should I kick him out of the family?  What about my husband who snores loudly?  Is he worthless? 

Good grief.  You guys really have no idea how hideous Catholicism is, do you?

winsome

Quote from: kensington"were excommunicated"  "if they truly believe that Mary is to be worshipped then they should be condemned."

WOW...  rather than to seek to teach them the truth, you condemn them or excommunicate them?  You must be sinless.

I wonder if Jesus is really so unforgiving?  Almost every single denom or religion, (and yes the Catholic Church) has missed on something I will bet.  We are not perfect, but being perfected "by the WORD" until the day we see him face to face.  Only then will we achieve perfection, when He gives it to us, each one.

I have a son who drinks a bit too much when he parties, should I kick him out of the family?  What about my husband who snores loudly?  Is he worthless?

Good grief. 

Always seeking the negative response aren't you. Jumping straight into negativity.

Do you ever bother to actually read the post? I ,mean read it not just give a knee-jerk reaction?

I didn't say anything about excommunicating the catholics you know. I gave an example from the video where the nuns were confronted, by church authorities with church teaching still refused to recant. Then after giving them every chance to repent the church authorities excommunicated them following Jesus's advice:

If he refuses to listen even to the church, then treat him as you would a Gentile or a tax collector.( Mt 18:17).

Paulus

Amo , you say : " No image is a graven image until someone treats it like a god. "

But that is incorrect .

The word "graven" is the past participle of the verb "grave" .

Grave comes from the Old English word "grafan" and is related to the Old High German "graben" to dig .

To grave is to cut, carve, sculpture, or engrave .

Something graven is something which has been graved , cut , carved , sculptured or engraved .

An image is a physical likeness or representation of a person, animal, or thing, photographed, painted, sculptured, or otherwise made visible.

A graven image is a carved representation .

The statue of Admiral Nelson on the top of Nelson's Column in Trafalgar Square is a graven image , a sculptured representation of Admiral Nelson . It has never had to be treated as a god to make it such . It is such just because it has been graved , sculptured to create a likeness , representation of Nelson .

So as soon as a craftsman has carved , graved the image of someone/something he has created a graven image , a carved image .

So , some unreplied to posts :-

1. Amo , you say : "  It is making a graven image that is sin. "

Ok . Following what you say there is only one logical conclusion .

A wooden cross is a graven image .

Therefore making a wooden cross is a sin .

People have made wooden crosses for their church buildings .

Therefore these people have sinned .

2. Chosenone you say that you have never known a Christian pray to a cross .

Neither have I .

Who would be so silly as to think that Christians prayed to a cross , a statue , an icon etc. ? That would be to cease to worship the true God , substituting God for an idol .

But you post the following quote : " Exodus 20:4Amplified Bible (AMP)

4 You shall not make yourself any graven image  or any likeness of anything that is in the heavens above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; "

Now it has been said on this thread that the words you have quoted actually forbid the making of graven images of anything .

If you say that is true , you must also say that making crosses to put in churches is forbidden by God , because crosses are graven images .


Amo

Quote from: Paulus on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 15:40:09
Amo , you say : " No image is a graven image until someone treats it like a god. "

But that is incorrect .

The word "graven" is the past participle of the verb "grave" .

Grave comes from the Old English word "grafan" and is related to the Old High German "graben" to dig .

To grave is to cut, carve, sculpture, or engrave .

Something graven is something which has been graved , cut , carved , sculptured or engraved .

An image is a physical likeness or representation of a person, animal, or thing, photographed, painted, sculptured, or otherwise made visible.

A graven image is a carved representation .

The statue of Admiral Nelson on the top of Nelson's Column in Trafalgar Square is a graven image , a sculptured representation of Admiral Nelson . It has never had to be treated as a god to make it such . It is such just because it has been graved , sculptured to create a likeness , representation of Nelson .

So as soon as a craftsman has carved , graved the image of someone/something he has created a graven image , a carved image .

So , some unreplied to posts :-

1. Amo , you say : "  It is making a graven image that is sin. "

Ok . Following what you say there is only one logical conclusion .

A wooden cross is a graven image .

Therefore making a wooden cross is a sin .

People have made wooden crosses for their church buildings .

Therefore these people have sinned .

2. Chosenone you say that you have never known a Christian pray to a cross .

Neither have I .

Who would be so silly as to think that Christians prayed to a cross , a statue , an icon etc. ? That would be to cease to worship the true God , substituting God for an idol .

But you post the following quote : " Exodus 20:4Amplified Bible (AMP)

4 You shall not make yourself any graven image  or any likeness of anything that is in the heavens above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth; "

Now it has been said on this thread that the words you have quoted actually forbid the making of graven images of anything .

If you say that is true , you must also say that making crosses to put in churches is forbidden by God , because crosses are graven images .

Merriam-Webster disagrees - http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/graven%20image

Nor does Strong's Concordance -
Quote06459 ??? pecel peh'- sel

from 06458; n m; [BDB-820b] {See TWOT on 1788 @@ "1788a"}

AV-graven image 28, carved image 2, graven 1; 31

1) idol, image

Nor does Easton's Revised Bible Dictionary -
QuoteGraven Image

#De 27:15 Ps 97:7 (Heb. pesel), refers to the household gods of
idolaters. "Every nation and city had its own gods. Yet every family
had its separate household or tutelary god."



Paulus

So , Amo , are you saying that "graven image" means "idol" ?

And are you saying that every graven image , every man-made represention of someone/something is an idol ?

Amo

Quote from: Paulus on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 16:14:03
So , Amo , are you saying that "graven image" means "idol" ?

And are you saying that every graven image , every man-made represention of someone/something is an idol ?

No I am not saying that, I have made myself perfectly clear. The commandment is not addressing the making of an image alone, but rather the making of an image to be used in worship. Thus the added warning of not bowing down to the same. Which act makes an image more than just an image, but an idol.

Exo 20:4  Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: 5  Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me; 6  And shewing mercy unto thousands of them that love me, and keep my commandments.



Paulus

Thanks , Amo , for saying : " The commandment is not addressing the making of an image alone, but rather the making of an image to be used in worship. Thus the added warning of not bowing down to the same. Which act makes an image more than just an image, but an idol. "

I am pleased that you do not think that making an image is making an idol .

One has to worship the image to make it into an idol .

Creating an image is just creating an image .

Worshipping the image is what creates an idol .

But do you agree with those who say that God forbids the making of images even though they are not intended for worship ?

skeeter

Quote from: winsome on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 11:06:14
Quote from: kensingtonCatholics say that it's not a sin to have images, only to bow before them, to pray to them, to worship them.  We see pictures all over of people kneeling before them in prayer.  What are we supposed to think?

What are you to think?

Well you could ask Catholics and not just jump to conclusions based on either ignorance or prejudice (take your pick)
Having been a Catholic, I don't have to ask one... it's not from ignorance or prejudice.  I was taught mostly by nuns and priests - having gone to Catholic schools grades 4-12.  I went to Mass most wks 6 times and some wks 7 times.  I know what I was taught and what my school mates, friends and family did and said about it.  They prayed to Mary /Saints, knelt /lit candles before the statues - believing they could answer prayers. 
Also what many  Catholics here have said about it (and on other forums).  I do believe it was Catholica here who said I wasn't saved w/o  believing in these 'special' attributes of Mary/ praying to her. (he might not  have used the word 'saved'.  Catholics have only in recent times used that word).  - without BEING Catholic and 'following' the pope.

How many Catholics do I need to hear / read saying that Mary is MY mother?  (she isn't)  That she is sinless?  That she performs miracles?  That she is EV - not a normal human wife? (actually in violation of RC rules -  just cause for Joseph to get an annulment)  That without Mary we wouldn't have Jesus.  Really?  Mary just happened to BE God's plan. He doesn't make mistakes.  He doesn't operate on our time table - He knows everything before it happens.  Evidently some people think that if Mary had said 'no' to the angel we wouldn't have Jesus... If Mary was going to say 'no', God wouldn't have sent the angel TO her!


Amo

Quote from: Paulus on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 16:37:42
Thanks , Amo , for saying : " The commandment is not addressing the making of an image alone, but rather the making of an image to be used in worship. Thus the added warning of not bowing down to the same. Which act makes an image more than just an image, but an idol. "

I am pleased that you do not think that making an image is making an idol .

One has to worship the image to make it into an idol .

Creating an image is just creating an image .

Worshipping the image is what creates an idol .

But do you agree with those who say that God forbids the making of images even though they are not intended for worship ?

Not unless they can show me where scripture says as much without also addressing the real problem which is bowing down to or praying to an image. Of course people can make idols out of anything that they will place above God. Nevertheless, bowing down and or praying to an image, is breaking a commandment of God.

kensington

Always seeking the negative response aren't you. Jumping straight into negativity.

Do you ever bother to actually read the post? I ,mean read it not just give a knee-jerk reaction?

I didn't say anything about excommunicating the catholics you know. I gave an example from the video where the nuns were confronted, by church authorities with church teaching still refused to recant. Then after giving them every chance to repent the church authorities excommunicated them following Jesus's advice:

If he refuses to listen even to the church, then treat him as you would a Gentile or a tax collector.( Mt 18:17).

Hey, you are the one that brought excommunication and condemn them into the conversation. That wasn't me.  Aren't you the one who said "I'll keep this simple for skeeter"...  negative much? 

Catholica

Quote from: skeeter on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 03:15:50
Quote from: Paulus on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 02:45:32
Does anyone know what percentage of Protestant churches , either inside the building or outside , do NOT have a graven image of a cross ?
I haven't been in that many 'protestant' churches but the ones I've been in do have a cross.   They don't have a crucifix.
I've never seen anyone bow, genuflect or kneel in front of a cross.  It's a reminder that He died - AND rose again.

google it if you want to know.

Actually, I don't think you posted the question without already having googled it.

I googled it. A person kneeling in prayer before a cross is a very popular image for Christians, even ones who are not Catholic.

https://www.google.com/search?q=kneeling+before+a+cross&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=u5BVVOW7C5SBygTDpoGQCQ&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAQ&biw=1024&bih=644


AVZ

The term "graven image" simply refers to a man-made object. Whether this is a carved piece of wood, or a sculpted piece of stone or a representation made of clay...it all is man-made.
The command simply states that we are not to make those images for the purpose of bowing down to them, or worship them.

Nobody has an issue with creating a painting or drawing depicting a Biblical situation or personage.
The problem starts when men use that image to bow down to.
We make graven images all the time, technically a barbie doll is a graven image...but it becomes a violation of Gods command if I were to bow down to it.

Catholics pretend that they attribute no more "power" to a statues than any other picture or statues or image.
That simply is not true.
There are plenty of instances where Catholics humanize statues: for example statues that start weeping, or bleeding, or as mentioned earlier coming alive to spray milk on someones face.
Those statues become places of worship and pilgrimage in the Catholic Church because those statues display human treats. Thousands of Catholics flock to those places.

kensington

I googled it. A person kneeling in prayer before a cross is a very popular image for Christians, even ones who are not Catholic.



I've never bowed or kneeled to a cross, or prayed on my knees in front of one.  Those must be Catholics.


AVZ

Quote from: Catholica on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 21:06:57
Quote from: skeeter on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 03:15:50
Quote from: Paulus on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 02:45:32
Does anyone know what percentage of Protestant churches , either inside the building or outside , do NOT have a graven image of a cross ?
I haven't been in that many 'protestant' churches but the ones I've been in do have a cross.   They don't have a crucifix.
I've never seen anyone bow, genuflect or kneel in front of a cross.  It's a reminder that He died - AND rose again.

google it if you want to know.

Actually, I don't think you posted the question without already having googled it.

I googled it. A person kneeling in prayer before a cross is a very popular image for Christians, even ones who are not Catholic.

https://www.google.com/search?q=kneeling+before+a+cross&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=u5BVVOW7C5SBygTDpoGQCQ&ved=0CAgQ_AUoAQ&biw=1024&bih=644

Catholica,

You are trying to make a comparitive connection between the Catholic bowing before a statue, and the Protestant bowing before a cross. There is none.

Protestants do not invoke any power from the cross, and they do not imagine any mediator behind the cross other than Jesus Himself.
If at all a Protestant prays in front of the cross, then his prayers are not directed to that cross or to any secondary person behind that cross.
As far as Protestant theology goes, there is no power in a cross, it is not object of veneration, and if any awe is expressed it is only because a cross is a symbol of the death of Jesus only.

This is completely different in Catholic theology.
Catholics attribute specific powers and tasks to the person represented by the statue.
There is a whole scala of statues and saints to choose from, each of them holding some specific talent.
Peter for example is good in convincing God on behalf of sailors, and Luke is particularly equipped to receive the prayers of medical workers.

Catholics claim that when they pray to a statue, they still pray to God.
But that is absolutely not true, because if a sailor would to have a choice between praying in front of a statue of Luke or a statue of Peter...he would choose Peter's.
When a Catholic prays in front of a statue, he prays to the person represented by that statue...not God.

The theology behind this is that God needs convincing. He somehow is too busy listening to prayers, and He needs someone to remind Him or convince Him to respond.
There absolutely is no scriptural backup for this. None whatsoever.

And again, none of the responses by Catholics in this thread address scripture.
No Catholic here has posted any scripture that supports the idea of statues and praying to them or bowing to them.

God tore the temple curtain as the symbol that we humans can now come to God directly. We do no longer need any mediation besides God Himself to approach him.
The Catholic church has pumped all this stuff, statues, saints and bad theology right into that void, claiming that God still is beyond our reach and needs mediation on our behalf by saints.

This is straight in contradiction with Gods plan to come down to us humans and place Himself on our level to redeem us.
What the Catholic Church teaches is not the message of the gospel, and must therefore be rejected.
None of the Catholics think about these things, they just follow what the church teaches them and they do not even know why they do what they do.
They are being told that if they want to be sure God hears them, they better get help from a saint. In other words, a Catholic can never trust God to hear them.

And that's why this whole thing is idolatry.
Because Catholics cannot fully trust God is there for them, and they should vest their hopes in a saint who somehow is able to wake God up and make Him listen.

Paulus

Avz , thanks for confirming what I have been saying when you say : " The term "graven image" simply refers to a man-made object. Whether this is a carved piece of wood, or a sculpted piece of stone or a representation made of clay...it all is man-made. "

So is everyone agreeing now that God did not forbid the making of graven images , man-made objects , but rather forbade the worship of graven images , man-made objects ?

AVZ

Quote from: Paulus on Sun Nov 02, 2014 - 01:58:40
Avz , thanks for confirming what I have been saying when you say : " The term "graven image" simply refers to a man-made object. Whether this is a carved piece of wood, or a sculpted piece of stone or a representation made of clay...it all is man-made. "

So is everyone agreeing now that God did not forbid the making of graven images , man-made objects , but rather forbade the worship of graven images , man-made objects ?

Yes, I do not agree with Amo that we are forbidden to make graven images. We do that all the time (nowadays out of plastic mostly) such as miniature animals for our kids to play with.
The setting of the first and second command is that we are not to make graven images for the purpose of use in our worship to God, or bow to them, or worship them.

skeeter

Quote from: winsome on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 15:35:28
Quote from: kensington"were excommunicated"  "if they truly believe that Mary is to be worshipped then they should be condemned."

WOW...  rather than to seek to teach them the truth, you condemn them or excommunicate them?  You must be sinless.

I wonder if Jesus is really so unforgiving?  Almost every single denom or religion, (and yes the Catholic Church) has missed on something I will bet.  We are not perfect, but being perfected "by the WORD" until the day we see him face to face.  Only then will we achieve perfection, when He gives it to us, each one.

I have a son who drinks a bit too much when he parties, should I kick him out of the family?  What about my husband who snores loudly?  Is he worthless?

Good grief. 

Always seeking the negative response aren't you. Jumping straight into negativity.

Do you ever bother to actually read the post? I ,mean read it not just give a knee-jerk reaction?

this is the 2nd post I read of yours accusing someone else of being negative - and having a 'knee-jerk' reaction... AND not 'actually' reading a post. (and that's just tonight)

sounds more like you're the one who is negative - and having a knee problem.  arthritis maybe?  better not to funnel those problems into your posts...

btw, maybe you should re-read the sentence above (the last one - I underlined it).  Read with punctuation as posted.

Maybe the problem isn't with the person reading the post.

Paulus

Thanks , AVZ , for your reply .

I am in full agreement with you when you say : " Catholics in this thread are not dumb. " ::thumbup::

Red Baker

#169
Quote from: Catholica on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 21:06:57I googled it. A person kneeling in prayer before a cross is a very popular image for Christians, even ones who are not Catholic.

Andre, I have never seen anyone in person other than Catholics kneeling in prayer before a cross~never.  The site that you googled, are pictures done by men, instead of actually real people bowing before a cross.  Not saying that some do not, just that I have never seen it.  Most believers that I know of would never have a picture or even a cross in their homes, much less, bowing before one.   

Paulus

Red Baker , if you saw someone bowing before a cross would you see anything wrong in it ?

winsome

Quote from: AVZ
There are plenty of instances where Catholics humanize statues: for example statues that start weeping, or bleeding, or as mentioned earlier coming alive to spray milk on someones face.
Those statues become places of worship and pilgrimage in the Catholic Church because those statues display human treats. Thousands of Catholics flock to those places.

1. Can you provide some credible examples of this?

2. Do you make no differentiation between what some Catholics do and what the Catholic Church teaches? Is the Catholic Church to be held responsible for the actions of all Catholics everywhere?

skeeter

Quote from: Paulus on Sun Nov 02, 2014 - 11:16:17
Red Baker , if you saw someone bowing before a cross would you see anything wrong in it ?

I'd think they were Catholic.

In all my 40 yrs being a Christian, I have yet to see a Christian bow before a cross.

In the CC I saw it all of the time.


skeeter

Quote from: Red Baker on Sun Nov 02, 2014 - 06:59:24
Quote from: Catholica on Sat Nov 01, 2014 - 21:06:57I googled it. A person kneeling in prayer before a cross is a very popular image for Christians, even ones who are not Catholic.

Andre, I have never seen anyone in person other than Catholics kneeling in prayer before a cross~never.  The site that you googled, are pictures done by men, instead of actually real people bowing before a cross.  Not saying that some do not, just that I have never seen it.  Most believers that I know of would never have a picture or even a cross in their homes, much less, bowing before one.

where?  I've never seen a kneeler thing in a Christian church.  We don't kneel.  I've been is a good # of them in my 40 yrs as a Christian.

The only place I can remember seeing a cross is at the very, very front of the church and high up on the wall  (far behind where the minister usually stands)  or outside on top of the church.  We don't have crosses all around in the church.


skeeter

Quote from: winsome on Sun Nov 02, 2014 - 13:33:07
Quote from: AVZ
There are plenty of instances where Catholics humanize statues: for example statues that start weeping, or bleeding, or as mentioned earlier coming alive to spray milk on someones face.
Those statues become places of worship and pilgrimage in the Catholic Church because those statues display human treats. Thousands of Catholics flock to those places.

1. Can you provide some credible examples of this?

2. Do you make no differentiation between what some Catholics do and what the Catholic Church teaches? Is the Catholic Church to be held responsible for the actions of all Catholics everywhere?

#1 -
just google a saint by his/her name and pick a Catholic site to click on...

or you can check the library for a book on the 'Lives of the Saints'.   I  have a copy somewhere (along with my old catechism and hymnal). 

#2 -
does the CC care?  I don't think they do as long as they have the # count.  If they do, why aren't they teaching it from the pulpit?  Bible based Christian churches do (that doesn't include ALL that call themselves Christian).

+-Recent Topics

American Socialism? by 4WD
Today at 11:38:36

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by pppp
Today at 11:12:21

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Today at 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Yesterday at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Yesterday at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Tue Nov 17, 2026 - 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

Powered by EzPortal