News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898031
Total Topics: 90351
Most Online Today: 5004
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 4151
Total: 4151
Google

Are we saved by faith or by works?

Started by hmb, Mon Mar 08, 2004 - 08:18:09

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

St. Rubicon

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (boringoldguy @ Mar. 15 2004,1:31)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--][/quote]
BOG,
Thanks for the reply.  It's obvious that you have thought a bit about these matters.  However, from my perspective you haven't dealt with the questions that I am asking of your position.  as such, I remain unmoved.

You said:

\"James and St. Rubicon,

As an objection to what he calls the \"not saved until baptized\" posistion, St. Rubicon brought up the example of Abraham who \"believed God and it was credited to him as righteousness\" and says that at that time in Abraham's story there were as yet no outward actions of faith.    He used this statement to support his conclusion that belief is an internal state.   I asked what made him believe that, in his words, in the Old Testament faith was internal, and pointed out that at the time those words were spoken of Abraham, he had exhibited his faith by obeying God's call to leave his home and head for parts unknown.\"

Let me reply:
Genesis 15:6-
1 After this, the word of the LORD came to Abram in a vision:

\"Do not be afraid, Abram.
I am your shield, [1]
your very great reward. [2] \"

2 But Abram said, \"O Sovereign LORD , what can you give me since I remain childless and the one who will inherit [3] my estate is Eliezer of Damascus?\" 3 And Abram said, \"You have given me no children; so a servant in my household will be my heir.\"
4 Then the word of the LORD came to him: \"This man will not be your heir, but a son coming from your own body will be your heir.\" 5 He took him outside and said, \"Look up at the heavens and count the stars-if indeed you can count them.\" Then he said to him, \"So shall your offspring be.\"
6 Abram believed the LORD , and he credited it to him as righteousness.

It appears to me (and I could easily be wrong, for I have been wrong before and surely will be again) that Abraham \"believes\" God's promise and *this* belief is what is reckoned as righteousness.  How can you say that his former actions are in view here?  Al the verse says is that Abraham responded to God's promise with believing and God reckoned this as righteousness.  That seems to be an obvious \"plain\" reading of the text.

Again, you said:

\"James attempted to bolster St. Rubicon's statements by quoting part of Romans 10:10 which says that man believes with the heart;   I pointed out the balance of that verse which says that with the mouth we confess with the mouth unto salvation - my point being that this doesn't strengthen the idea that we are saved merely by an internal state of mind not accompanied by some outward action.\"

Here's the verse:
9\"That if you confess with your mouth, \"Jesus is Lord,\" and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.  10For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you confess and are saved.  

Two promises are made
1: To the act of believing in the heart the promise is that of \"justification\"
2:  To the act of confession that \"Jesus is Lord\" is the  promise of  \"you will be saved\".

You seem to be saying that the first promise is not given unless one adds the second one.  One big problem- the verse doesn't say that.  

Your last response was this:
\"Finally, St. Rubicon, we come to your example of the Ethiopian eunuch.    You'll note that he requested baptism.  You'll also note that Philip's reply was not \"if you believe with all your heart you don't need to be baptized because that internal belief saves you.\"     In other words, I don't see how you think any of this vitiates what you call the \"not saved until baptized\" position, which is what you said.\"
My reply:
It doesn't \"vitiate\" (haven't heard that one in awhile :)  )
the position, true, but it backs up the idea that believing is a \"distinct, inner act\".  Remember what we were discussiing?  By changing the topic, I start to wonder why you do so ( I get suspicious that you are rationalizing).
Please forgive me for my impatience with you.

Blessings, Robert

Johnb

Bob
I will try one more time perhaps I will communicte more effectively or not.  But here goes.  When Paul spoke of being
saved by faith and not by works he was refering to not being able to work you way to salvation.  Paul's position in no way implied that we could continue to led a life of sin and not work for Christ. \" Shall we continue in sin that grace may abound God forbid...\"

James on ther other hand was talking about our faith being demonstrated by our works or righteousness. Note in James 2:21 \" Was not our ancestor Abraham considered righteous for what he did... 22 \"You see his faith and his actions were working togather and his faith was made complete by his actions.\"  It is righteousness that is the focus here not salvation.  Righteousness is right doing or doing what God would have you to do.  Doing the right or righteous acts demonstrates your faith or give testemony to you faith.  It is your righteousness that is justified by your works not your salvation.  You works show that you are a righteous man, one doing good works, therefore justifies or shows you are righteous.  One can be righteous and not have saving faith, Paul's position.  However, one can not have a faith that saves and not be righteous or do good works; James position.  At least this is how I see the 2 views.  Hope this helps.  Johnb

MIZ83

Chris,

Consider the preceeding chapter in Romans:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Rom 3:9 Now we know that whatever the Law says, it speaks to those who are under the Law, that every mouth may be closed, and all the world may become accountable to God; 20 because by the works of the Law no flesh will be justified in His sight; for through the Law comes the knowledge of sin. 21 But now apart from the Law the righteousness of God has been manifested, being witnessed by the Law and the Prophets,

Rom 3:28  For we maintain that a man is justified by faith apart from works of the Law.

[/quote]

Chris, the discussion of Abraham in chapter 4 merely continues the argument of Paul from chapter 3.  What better way to convince Jewish readers of the truth of his argument than to point to Abraham? Abraham was not justified by keeping the Law.  He was justified even before he was circumcised.  He was not justifed by works of law, but by trusting in God who justifies the ungodly.  The context is very much about \"works of Law\".  It is about law versus gospel.

The main argument in the book of Romans is that faith in the good news about Jesus is what saves us, not how well we measure up to God's laws.  We deserve condemnation.  God gives us life through His Son.  Our faith must be in the blood of Jesus, not in how well we perform compared to His standard.

Please bear in mind that I don't believe we must acheive some level of works to enter into a saving relationship with Jesus.  I don't believe we need ANY works to enter into a relationship with Jesus.  I do affirm along with James, however, that works complete our faith.  I affirm that mere profession of faith without accompanying works will not save.  I affirm that we will not stand justified before our Lord in the judgement without having lived a life consistent with our faith, as did our spiritual father Abraham.  In that sense, I believe, we are justified by works, and not by faith alone.  Discipleship is not optional.  We are called into the very love relationship with God for which we were created.  If we love, we will obey.  If we refuse obedience, we will not be saved.  Hebrews 10:26 \"For if we go on sinning willfully after receiving the knowledge of the truth, there no longer remains a sacrifice for sins, 27 but a certain terrifying expectation of judgment, and the fury of a fire which will consume the adversaries.\"

Blessings,

Bob

MIZ83

Steve wrote:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]We can both agree that the term \"works\" is not a bad word. We can both agree that all Christians are called to do good works. My question to you would be for what purpose are we called to do those works? And what do our \"works\" - which we are called to do - signify?[/quote]

Off the top of my head... Our works glorify God.  Our works graciously are used by Him to accomplish His purposes,  although He is not dependent upon us to accomplish them.  Our works express our love for Him and our faith in Him.  As to your second question, I don't know what you mean to ask.

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]If one believes that one is justified by works and that salvation is dependent upon the doing of works, then that makes the term \"works\" a bad word. [/quote]

Steve, you illustrate my point nicely.  James says, "You see, then, that a man is justified by works and not by faith alone.

Apollos

Bob

I believe I am in total agreement with your understanding on 'faith' save one point.

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--] The discussion of Abraham in chapter 4 merely continues the argument of Paul from chapter 3. What better way to convince Jewish readers of the truth of his argument than to point to Abraham? Abraham was not justified by keeping the Law. He was justified even before he was circumcised. He was not justifed by works of law, but by trusting in God who justifies the ungodly. The context is very much about \"works of Law\". It is about law versus gospel.[/quote]

Did the Law exist at the time of Abram? If not, Paul had used an extremely poor example to back up his argument. His readers of the Roman epistle could have argued 'how is it possible for Abram to be judged righteous by keeping the Law since the Law did not exist at that point in time?' In other words, how could Abram possibly keep the Law if there was no Law to keep?

Chris

MIZ83

Chris writes:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Did the Law exist at the time of Abram? If not, Paul had used an extremely poor example to back up his argument. His readers of the Roman epistle could have argued 'how is it possible for Abram to be judged righteous by keeping the Law since the Law did not exist at that point in time?' In other words, how could Abram possibly keep the Law if there was no Law to keep?[/quote]

Of course, the Law did not exist at the time of Abram.  I disagree that Paul used a poor argument, but however you feel about its strength or weakness, it is the one he used.  He does have the contrast between law and faith under consideration.  Not only is chapter 4 continuing the argument of chapter 3 where he talks about faith versus works of law, in chapter 4 he writes:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]12 And the father of circumcision to those who not only are of the circumcision, but who keep to the way of that faith which our father Abraham had before he underwent circumcision. 13 For God's word, that the earth would be his heritage, was given to Abraham, not through the law, but through the righteousness of faith. 14 For if they who are of the law are the people who get the heritage, then faith is made of no use, and the word of God has no power; 15 For the outcome of the law is wrath; but where there is no law it will not be broken.[/quote]

I've got to run,

Blessings,

Bob

boringoldguy

St. Rubicon,

I know you put a lot of your thought onto Gen. 15:6.  However, you're disregarding a couple of things:

James tells us that this scripture (Gen. 15:6) was fulfilled at the time that he offered Isaac.  (James 2:21 - 24).   So are you sure that Abraham's internal state was credited to him as righteousness at that very minute?   Or is James right that it was fulfilled years later?

Next, you are disregarding part of the very passage you rely on - In verse 8, Abraham asks for a sign, some kind of assurance of God's promise.  That seems to me to go beyond the mere \"internal state\" that you speak of.

As our friend Bob points out, James tells us that we are not justified by faith alone.   That's in the Bible, and until we can reconcile the idea of \"salvation by faith alone\" to that statement, we haven't really understood what the Bible says.

St. Rubicon

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (boringoldguy @ Mar. 16 2004,12:02)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]St. Rubicon,

I know you put a lot of your thought onto Gen. 15:6.  However, you're disregarding a couple of things:

James tells us that this scripture (Gen. 15:6) was fulfilled at the time that he offered Isaac.  (James 2:21 - 24).   So are you sure that Abraham's internal state was credited to him as righteousness at that very minute?   Or is James right that it was fulfilled years later?

Next, you are disregarding part of the very passage you rely on - In verse 8, Abraham asks for a sign, some kind of assurance of God's promise.  That seems to me to go beyond the mere \"internal state\" that you speak of.

As our friend Bob points out, James tells us that we are not justified by faith alone.   That's in the Bible, and until we can reconcile the idea of \"salvation by faith alone\" to that statement, we haven't really understood what the Bible says.[/quote]
BOG, you said:
\"James tells us that this scripture (Gen. 15:6) was fulfilled at the time that he offered Isaac.  (James 2:21 - 24).   So are you sure that Abraham's internal state was credited to him as righteousness at that very minute?   Or is James right that it was fulfilled years later?\"

Is your assumption that  Abraham was not justified until he offered up Isaac?  All that time beforehand that you mentioned earlier he was in a state of alienation from God, unjustified?

Why do you asume that jusiification only happened once?

Blessings,
Robert

MIZ83

Johnb writes:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]When Paul spoke of being
saved by faith and not by works he was refering to not being able to work you way to salvation. [/quote]

Agreed.  And to work your way to heaven, what would be necessary?  The answer...perfect performance of God's laws.
 
[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Gal 3:10 For as many as are of the works of the Law are under a curse; for it is written, \"Cursed is everyone who does not abide by all things written in the book of the law, to perform them.\" 11 Now that no one is justified by the Law before God is evident; for, \"The righteous man shall live by faith.\" 12 However, the Law is not of faith; on the contrary, \"He who practices them shall live by them.\" [/quote]

Seeking to be justified by works of law puts one under a curse.  Why?  Because we don't keep all of them, all of the time.  So do we trust in our performance, or do we trust in Jesus?  

The above passage shows what Paul has in mind when he talks about works.  He is talking about law-keeping.  He is talking about seeking to measure up to God's laws.  This is, BTW, an indictment of the checklist mentality that some have today...I'm okay and they're not because I do x, y, & z.  To be justified by law, whether by the Old or the so-called New Law, would require perfect practice on our part.

To say that I must be obedient, on the other hand, that my life must be one of \"faith working through love\", as Paul puts it a couple of chapters later, is a vastly different thing than seeking justification through works of law.  No matter how many good deeds I might do, I know that I deserve death according to God's laws.  God gives me life through Jesus.

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Paul's position in no way implied that we could continue to led a life of sin and not work for Christ. \" Shall we continue in sin that grace may abound God forbid...\"
[/quote]

You sound perilously close to saying what I am saying...until...

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]It is righteousness that is the focus here not salvation. [/quote]

But listen to James:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]14 What use is it, my brethren, if a man says he has faith, but he has no works? Can that faith save him? [/quote]

Then you say:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]It is your righteousness that is justified by your works not your salvation.  You works show that you are a righteous man, one doing good works, therefore justifies or shows you are righteous. [/quote]

I've heard this argument before, and this really gets to the heart of the matter.  Those who interpret Paul to be saying that a work is any action of obedience on our part come to James and reason, \"He can't be saying that we are saved or justified by works, by our good deeds.  This is a contradiction.  I choose Paul!  James can't be talking about salvation, and justification can't be used here in its usual sense.  It can't mean to be aquitted and counted as righteous by God.  It means that Abraham's works demonstrated that he was righteous.\"  

The problem, of course, is that explanation doesn't fit the context.  Again, James asks, Can that faith save him?  Sounds like he is talking about salvation to me.  And what about his use of justification?  James says:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]3 and the Scripture was fulfilled which says, \"And Abraham believed God, and it wasreckoned to him as righteousness,\" and he was called the friend of God. 24 You see that a man is justified by works, and not by faith alone. [/quote]

James certainly seems to be equating \"reckoned to him as righteousness\" and \"justified\", doesn't he?  No, giving \"justified\" a strained meaning just won't do.

What actually needs reexamination at the apparent contradiction between Paul and James is the interpretation that is put by many on \"works\" in Paul's writings.  \"Works\" in Paul are \"works of law\".  Read Romans.  Read Galatians.  Observe how Paul uses that phrase repeatedly.  Observe how he keeps discussing law.  The tension is not between obedience to Christ and faith.  Rather, it is between seeking justification through law versus through faith in Jesus.   I must live out my faith, but I don't trust in how well I live.  Now matter what I do from here on out, I still deserved to die.  I still have failed and continue to fail to meet God's holy standard.  I must put my hope in Jesus and follow Him, yet I don't trust in how well I follow, but trust in the strength that he supplies, weak wretch that I am.    

Brethren, it pains me to see us overreact against some who are legalistic in our movement by running to an opposite extreme of \"faith only\".  

Blessings,

Bob

St. Rubicon

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (MIZ83 @ Mar. 17 2004,03:40)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--][/quote]
******The above passage shows what Paul has in mind when he talks about works.  He is talking about law-keeping.  He is talking about seeking to measure up to God's laws.  This is, BTW, an indictment of the checklist mentality that some have today...I'm okay and they're not because I do x, y, & z.  To be justified by law, whether by the Old or the so-called New Law, would require perfect practice on our part. *********

I am not sure that I agree with you here.  God asks for certain responses to Him and attaches promises to them (faith expresed in repentance, confession and baptism.  These are not \"laws\", are they?  Those that comply recieve what He offers, those that deny miss out.  I think that you have to be more specific with your point, because taken at face value, it is false

MIZ83

Saint,

Good question.  Thank you for the opportunity to be more specific as my point relates to faith, repentance, confession, and baptism.

Lord willing, I will post more on keeping law tonight, when I have more time.  To get the ball rolling, however, I'll start by asking you a couple of related questions.  Do believing, repenting, confessing, and being baptized save us because we are performing law?  To be saved by law, what level of performance is required, according to the Scriptures?

Blessings,

Bob

segell

Bob

Greetings and thanks for your writings on this very interesting subject of grace and the works we Christians are called to do.
There are a number of things I would like to respond to - it may take a couple of different postings.  (Gee, I hope not).

You wrote:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]I am trying to affirm both what Paul says and what James says, not to redefine one out of existence.  I believe that saying works are only the thank you to salvation is wrong if that means one believes works play no role in our salvation.  I believe that saying, "By grace alone, through faith alone

MIZ83

St. Rubicon writes:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]I am not sure that I agree with you here.  God asks for certain responses to Him and attaches promises to them (faith expresed in repentance, confession and baptism.  These are not \"laws\", are they?  Those that comply recieve what He offers, those that deny miss out.  I think that you have to be more specific with your point, because taken at face value, it is false[/quote]

To which I asked:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Do believing, repenting, confessing, and being baptized save us because we are performing law?  To be saved by law, what level of performance is required, according to the Scriptures?
[/quote]

Here is the answer:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]10 For as many as are of the works of the Law are under a curse; for it is written, \"Cursed is everyone who does not abide by all things written in the book of the law, to perform them.\" 11 Now that no one is justified by the Law before God is evident; for, \"The righteous man shall live by faith.\" 12 However, the Law is not of faith; on the contrary, \"He who practices them shall live by them.\" [/quote]

To be justifed by law would require more than just keeping a few commandments.  It would require keeping the entire body of God's laws.  His laws are not arbitrary.  They reflect His holy character.  Thus Paul says that all sin and fall short of the glory of God.  If we kept all of God's laws all of the time we would show our character to be like His.  Jesus kept the Old Law perfectly.  He was God with us.  Although in the flesh, He lived in keeping with His Holy character.  He was accounted righteous through Law.  He did not fall short of the glory of God.  \"He who has seen Me has seen the Father, also.\"

So what is my point?  

Keeping a few commandments or laws is insufficient for us to be accounted as righteous on the basis of works.  Obedience to all of God's laws would be required.  If one wishes to call faith, repentance, confession, and baptism laws, they nonetheless do not justify us on the basis of our keeping them as law.  To be justified by law I must keep all of God's laws.

But I do not consider faith, repentance, confession, and baptism works at all in the sense Paul refers to \"works of law\".  Paul refers by this term to seeking righteousness through one's own performance rather than through trusting in God who justifies the ungodly.  None of these responses to the gospel are efforts on our part to be justified by law, to measure up to God's law.  Faith trusts not in ourselves but in Jesus' blood.  Repentance is the conviction that one's old life is worthless and needs abandoning to follow Jesus.  Confession is an act whereby we acknowledge who Jesus is.  Baptism gives dramatic physical expression to our faith in Jesus' death, burial, and resurrection, as well as to our renounciation of our old man.  Each of these is a denial of our own goodness.  They point away from ourselves and to Jesus.  

Does that clarify where I stand?  

In Him,

Bob

MIZ83

Steve,

I've got to get to bed.  I'm going out of town early tomorrow and will have a long day.  I'll post a response when I can.

Blessings to you.

Bob

Johnb

Bob
Just saw your responce.  Thanks
The end of both our views is the same.  One who is saved or under grace must have works.  Our difference is why we are to work.  The problem I have with your view is what is said about God.  To me this is like the predestination argument.  the end result is the same God can know.  The difference is what predesination says about God being a respector of persons.  This discussion has, at least to me, simular overtones.  Salvation is either by faith and grace (unmerited favor) or it is not.  We both agree that a child of God should have good works.  The difference is why?  
Are you saying that one is saved when they obey the Gospel through faith but must have works to continue to be saved?
Or are you saying that one is not saved until they demonstriat there faith by their works?  Or perhaps you are saying something different.  I can and often am caustic but I am not doing that here.  I am truley trying to understand what you are trying to say. If you are saying that the faith that saves causes one to work or try to be obedient to God and if they don't do that they don't have a savig faith then we agree.
If not then I guess we don't.  Johnb

St. Rubicon

Do you have faith while you sleep, yet nobody can see any evidence (works) of it?  Of course!, therefore this proves that faith is an inner principle that bears outer fruit or works.  But it needn't always do so at every moment to be real.

segell

Bob

Please take your time.  I know how these posts demand that precious commodity and the energy that goes along with it.  I'm still ruminating over some things and will post more later, also.  In the interim, have a great day.

Steve

Johnb

St
So you have a costic side also.  I agree with your post.  I just can't see how salvation can be by faith and grace and by works.  I can either merit salvation or not.  I think not.  Johnb

Skip

Does faith nullify the Law?
Or, in other words, is the Law made useless by faith?

Johnb

Skip
To which law are you refering?  Johnb

spurly

By the way, the answer to the opening post on this thread is simple.  The answer is Yes.

segell

Kevin

May I ask you to elaborate?  In particular, how does works save?

Thanks.

Steve

winky

Is it possible for us to agree on a working (ha!) definition of the word \"works\"? Many would say that baptism, confession, repentence, etc. are not works, but are simply the method of accepting Christ's grace or the expression of faith. Others classify some or all of those as being works. If we can't agree on what consitutes a \"work\" we'll never be able to agree on whether works save us and whether baptism is a part of salvation or an expression of salvation.  Would it be helpful to find out how the biblical writers defined works and use that definition?

Wendy

boringoldguy

Wendy,

that's the ultimate problem here;  a lot of the more radical of the \"faith-only\" believers will tell you that anything a person does in order to be saved is a work.  That includes, of course, baptism, repentance, confession, etc.

Of course, they can't go so far as to recognize that, under their definition, even faith is a \"work.\"   So they say that God gives us the faith.

But once you reach that point, the question becomes, why doesn't God give saving faith to everyone (or does he?).
You end up with either universalism (everybody is saved) or a sort of \"Christian fatalism.\"

Johnb

BOG

You may be able to point to one but I don't know of anyone on this board that believes that faith is a work or that God gives you the faith. Faith is what puts us in touch with God's unmerited grace and favor.  A saving faith causes us to want to work and be obedient.  Should we be baptized? yes  Should we confess, repent etc. ? yes. Yes we should be obedient.  However, those of us who believe we are under grace will still own as brother and sisters all who are trying to serve Christ even if their understanding of what all constitutes obedience is some what different than ours.  We teach the Gospel and the NT to the best of our understanding and depend on God's grace to cover all our short comings.  We don't get out the check list and try to force our understanding on all who come in contact with us.  All the rule keeping I can do will not cause God to love me any more or less.  I want my children to do the right things because they want to and know that that is how they should live their life not because I am standing ready to punish them if they make a mistake.  I believe the God I read about in the Bible is the same way.  johnb

ConnieLard

Are we saved by faith or by works?

From my reading of the Bible, it seems clear that salvation is unattainable through my own human effort.  So, I can't say that I think we are saved by works, for sure.  On the other hand, I don't want to make the mistake of going in the opposite direction and saying there is nothing I can do.  As a means of receiving the grace which God is freely offering me, I place myself before Him to be transformed into what He wants me to become.  Richard J. Foster (Celebration of Discipline) speaks of \"the path of disciplined grace.  It is grace because it is free; it is disciplined because there is something for us to do.\"  In gratitude for the completely unmerited gift of salvation, I place myself under the direction of  His Spirit.  The result will be works, yes, due to the continuing inner transformation or heart change that characterizes the life of the believer.  

So, I guess I would answer the question to say that I believe we are saved by faith, but that works will inevitably follow.

spurly

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (segell @ Mar. 18 2004,3:12)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Kevin

May I ask you to elaborate?  In particular, how does works save?

Thanks.

Steve[/quote]
We are saved by God's grace, through faith.  That faith will inevitably express itself in works.  To me it is rather simple.

Kevin

Johnb

Connie
AMEN.
Kevin
AMEN     Johnb

St. Rubicon

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (Johnb @ Mar. 18 2004,11:09)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--][/quote]
What brings salvation?  The works of Christ for us and in us.
How does one allow this to happen?  By saying yes to Christ's solution.  Our faith and works show that we have recieved Him.

segell

Kevin

I appreciate your response.  We are saved by grace.  Works are the result of our salvation as we received God's grace through faith.  Works do not save.

BOG -

It's been some time since we've chatted.  But call me paranoid, but I think you may have referred to me as a radical.  Oh, I suppose I am.  I am one of those that believe that in God's sovereignty He works His will in the lives of those who have turned to Him in faith.  Ezekiel 11:19-20 bears this out.  Note the sequence of events.

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]19 I will give them an undivided heart and put a new spirit in them; I will remove from them their heart of stone and give them a heart of flesh. 20 Then they will follow my decrees and be careful to keep my laws. They will be my people, and I will be their God. [/quote]

Further in Ezekiel 36:22-28, the Lord God tells us why He works in the lives of His people.  Not for their sakes, but for His glory and purpose.  It's a very humbling passage.

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]22 \"Therefore say to the house of Israel, 'This is what the Sovereign LORD says: It is not for your sake, O house of Israel, that I am going to do these things, but for the sake of my holy name, which you have profaned among the nations where you have gone. 23 I will show the holiness of my great name, which has been profaned among the nations, the name you have profaned among them. Then the nations will know that I am the LORD , declares the Sovereign LORD , when I show myself holy through you before their eyes.
24 \" 'For I will take you out of the nations; I will gather you from all the countries and bring you back into your own land. 25 I will sprinkle clean water on you, and you will be clean; I will cleanse you from all your impurities and from all your idols. 26 I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh. 27 And I will put my Spirit in you and move you to follow my decrees and be careful to keep my laws. 28 You will live in the land I gave your forefathers; you will be my people, and I will be your God.[/quote]

That, I contend, is the work of God, His purpose in so doing and our purpose as Christians.  We must always point to Jesus Christ alone, no one else.  We aren't saved for our purpose.

While you may conclude that such beliefs end up in one of two places - universalism or Christian fatalism - I suggest that what you seem to espouse (i.e., salvation being contingent upon what you do) leads to an ill placed focus where the glory of God is not ultimately celebrated, but the work of the individual towards His own salvation.  That would not necessarily lead one to a heart of humility, but perhaps a place of spiritual pride.  At least, that is what danger I see in such thinking.

BOG, I would be happy to explore more later, but I think your characterizations reveal a mistaken understanding of what Sola graca, sola fide, sola Cristo, sola scriptura truly means. And if you wish to characterize that as radical, well, that's unfortunate.  However, you may wish to illuminate the board as to what you brought, in addition to the redeeming work of Jesus Christ, that contributed to your salvation and was deemed meritoriously righteous.

Take care.

Steve

kanham

Wouldn't a better question be whether or not anyone had ever believed that works saved? Jews believe that they were Jews, not because of works, but because of their patriarch, Abraham. The Jewish believed that Abraham was an astrologer who from looking at creation decided their must be a God. God revealed himself to Abraham and their relationship began. Was Abraham faithful to this God who revealed himself, certainly, but this was a faithful response to the God who revealed himself.

The closest example I could give to what James is talking about and how it fits Jewish understanding is the Wisdom of Sirach, a Jewish document dating from 175-164 B.C. In it Sirach says that, "Abraham was a great father of many people: in glory was there none like unto him; Who kept the law of the most High, and was in covenant with him: he established the covenant in his flesh; and when he was tested, he was found faithful.

simple minded

Wouldn't surrender and recieve be an action or a work?  :doh: OOPS! Now I am really confused. It was the holy spirit that dwells within me and He did all the work. But how did He get there? And how do I know HE is really a HE?

Forgive me, didn't mean to pick from that tree. I like the chicken and the egg theory used before. Simply because if it wasn't for God's grace working :readytoeat:

simple minded

Interesting note about Abraham. Notice that when the Lord first revealed Himself, Abraham's name was Abram. In faith Abram followed God and took Him on His Word.

It is also interesting to note, at the age of ninety-nine, God came to confirm His covenant with Abram. He renamed Abram to Abraham, and revealed Himself to be, EL Shaddi, which I believe means: The God of Grace. (could be wrong on the precise wording)

I don't know about anyone else. Christ is the only thing that saved me. However, in order to reveal His grace, I had to chose to recieve Him.

One of the saddest things I noticed since returning to the Lutheran church. Theology is not there main focus like it is in the CoC. I think that is why it was so hard for me to go back. I fit in with those who dig there heals in and dispute many issues. I believed it to be the perfect family. Nothing is perfect. Which does not bode well for me. What I have seen are very loyal,committed, loving people, who lived up to their name which happens to be :Grace.

kanham

Simple Mind,

Thanks for sharing your thoughts and where you are. I am not sure if your posts were directed towards what I shared, I have just been studying a lot of Jewish literature and have really enjoyed discovering the thoughts of the early church.

Often times I have seen Romans as something new to those reading it. What I have enjoyed is discovering that Romans was not revelation to those reading/listening but instead was reminder.

Many thoughts shared by Paul in Romans are prevelant in Jewish writing from 1 and 2 century B.C. I guess this goes to the historian in me. God bless you in your journey.

simple minded

Kanham,

Actually your post reminded me of something I just studied. I think I understand what you are saying about Romans. My last pastor is a historian. His teaching continues to help me tremondously. I agree completely how it helps to put the scriptures in a different light.

Thank you for your kind words. The Lord is good, may He also bless your studies and journey. Peace be with you.

+-Recent Topics

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Today at 12:56:12

American Socialism? by 4WD
Today at 12:53:26

SDA Issues by Amo
Yesterday at 17:37:59

John 20:22 by Dave...
Yesterday at 15:39:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Huguenots by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:11:46

Gibbon\Rome by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:07:07

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:05:00

Matthew 6:21 by pppp
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 08:14:39

Acts 4:32, Sharing by pppp
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 08:04:12

Powered by EzPortal