News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898033
Total Topics: 90351
Most Online Today: 4207
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 3082
Total: 3083
Amo
Google (3)

Christian polygamy??

Started by Dee Dee Warren, Sat Mar 29, 2003 - 15:56:57

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Son of a Preacher Man

After further review, this is what it is like to be married to one person. :juggling:

This is what it would be like married to more than one person.
:juggling:  :juggling:  :juggling:  :juggling:

I'm sorry, Dee Dee.  I have nothing to really offer you in the way of resources to further assist you, but I do find it intriguing that some in this day and age would want this... I mean... most people my age are terrified of marriage--period.  Self was included until about a year ago.

Good Luck.  I hope somebody else has something valid to offer you.

SoaPMan

Dee Dee Warren

Randy satyrs LOL!!!  That is good, but I am serious here.  I do not know if there is a taboo or rule against posting the link (at my forum we generally do not allow it so I assume it is the same here).  If anyone is interested in seeing their arguments, drop me an email.

Otherwise, be on the lookout for stuff for me.. I know how God works and funny you guys may just run into something out of the blue that may assist me as God places resources in your path.  I just wrote part of my latest rebuttal, spending a LOT of time in Matthew 19, and if I do not say so myself, I think it is pretty good.   I will be posting it later today.

Dee Dee Warren

]]He has no set rules for us except to love Him and whom He sent and for us to love one antother...no matter what He uses to accomplish that. ]]

Really?  That is simply not Biblical.

janine

\"love hurts
love scars
lovewounds
and mars
any heart...\"


or

\"You only hurt the one you love...\"

janine

Depending upon the branch of Islam you're talking about... I don't think the women are allowed to think.

Dee Dee Warren

I am in a discussion right now on another forum board with a couple of men advocating Christian polygamy.  I know the basic arguments very well, but I am looking if anyone has any recommendations on some more advanced resources dealing with this issue.  I found surprisingly nothing on the internet dealing with this in depth.

Booty

Dee Dee,

Personally I believe you need to change forums.

crocless aussie

I found one woman who would have me, but I doubt I could find another.

Allan the Happily Married (25 yrs this year!) :thumbup:

samloveall

I think maybe the strongest verse against polygamy goes something like, \"No man can serve two masters\"! :sarcasim:

kmv

Very excellent, seekr.

One the other hand, doesn't the very concept of polygamy carry an element of selfishness that contradicts 'love each other?'

I can't imagine my husband coming up with 'if you love me, you'd want me to be happy with a newer, enhanced-model wife!'  He knows instead I love him enough to knock him in the head until he came to his senses.

Kari

boringoldguy

This is slightly off topic, but my wife and I discussed it last night, and it does have a remote relationship to this.

We hear that these Islamic suicide bombers and such believe that if are \"martyred\" they'll go to a paradise where they have 72 lovely maidens all to themselves.

What do you reckon their wives think, knowing their husband's ideas of paradise?

janine

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Dee Dee,

Personally I believe you need to change forums.[/quote]
Well, polygamy is one way to get a \"Family Life\" quicker...

Dee Dee Warren

Dear Seekr:

I will get in touch with you when I am done with my response.  I do not wish to double-post it here becuase I do not wish to have to, in case anyone disagrees, be involved in this debate on two forums.  I was more posting here seeking some advise on resources, not to debate the issue.

Bon Voyage

Yep, I guess I was backwards with that one.

kmv

But aren't there some situations that are essentially not compatible with love?  

To me, polygamy is one of those situations.  It requires the betrayal of the marriage bond, and it requires that the desires of one partner be elevated above the marriage bond itself.

Perhaps in some science-fiction-type situation (ninety percent of the men have been eaten by aliens, or something) it would not be based on selfishness.  Otherwise, I can't reconcile the practice with love.

Kari.

janine

Do you think you'll find anything serious that's not Mormon stuff?

Or renegade Mormon stuff, anyway; the \"official\" Mormon stuff is against polygamy.

I always assumed some new converts in the infant Church were polygamous.  Heaven knows some beloved OT Bible people were (David, Solomon).

I never did take to any of the angles some in my church espouse re: the \"husband of one wife\" bit in the NT list of \"elder qualifications\"  (i.e., that (a) an elder can't have been divorced, and (b) he'd better step down when his wife dies).

It always and only seemed to me to be simply primarily a thrust toward monogamous people leading.

But, God made two, originally, and Jesus stood up for two, only.  It will be interesting to see what (if any) serious references those guys come up with to support their side.

I mean, other than the fact that they are probably randy satyrs. :blush:   Oink, squeal.



[p.s. Are there any women arguing \"for\" it?]

crocless aussie

Doesn't polygamy usually bring the major problem of additional mothers-in-law? :eek:

\"Behind every successful man, there's a woman - his mother-in-law saying \"he'll never make it\".

spurly

Christian Polygamy :doh: .  It's an oxymoron if I've ever heard one.

Kevin

seekr

Deedee, looking forward to your rebuttal. But even with scriptures to present a case...what does God really say? Is there a scripture prohibiting it? If God hasn't changed...why did He allow David to have multiple wives AND concubines? I know His perfect will is for one man and one woman...but do any of us do His perfect will? And if love being the law, matters most...would He allow someone to have another spouse if it benefitted the person?

I think it is funny that this issue keeps coming up, here. i recently thought of starting a topic on this very subject. I have stated many times it is still about a person's heart before God. So some things are sin for those who are not right, even though claiming righteousness, and some are free and if they are looking to God for direction and hearing from Him...much more is allowed than we even could fathom. I know what He is asked of me, because of His great love.

seekr

Janine

God's law always supercedes man's. \"What God has joined together...\". So would you say \"but Lord, the law won't let me\", IF He chose another spouse for someone? Just questioning.

seekr

admin

Here's an article that may help you that talks about the one man one woman relationship. http://gcm.ibelieve.com/content.asp?CID=17346

I think he gets into it a little. :reading:

Lee

seekr

I am not really advocating polygamy. What I am trying to get across is that God still allows us a lot more freedom than we can even grasp. I will say again...His perfect will has ALWAYS been one man one woman, but He still out of love, may allow someone to have more than one spouse. He has no set rules for us except to love Him and whom He sent and for us to love one antother...no matter what He uses to accomplish that. If we would just look at really what happens in this life of ours, we would see, that rarely is His perfect will done. How many are truly monogamous. I do not mean just the marriage certificate, either. \"All have sinned and fallen short\"...and God has forgiven and paid the debt.

seekr

seekr

Deedee

Not biblical??? Love is the essence of the law and our covenant as believers. Romans 13:9-10 \"...and whatever other commandment there may be, are summed up in this ONE rule: 'Love your neighbor as yourself.' Love does no harm to its neighbor. Therefore LOVE is the fulfillment of the law.\" Proverbs 10:11-13 \"...love covers over ALL wrongs.\" Love covers a multitude of sin..carry each others burdens and you have FULFILLED the law of Christ...Gal.5:14 \"The ENTIRE law is summed up in a SINGLE command: \"Love your neighbor as yourself...but if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under law.\"

Read God's word and tell my what He used to accomplish His will. The OT has many recordings of what He did and God has not changed. He just has brought us into relationship and freed us from the chains of the law.

seekr

seekr

kari

On some of my earlier postings I have addressed that. It is heart issues that would allow something like polygamy, not selfish issues. If this truly were to happen, God would prepare you for it also. His love goes beyond anything we can imagine and it would be only about healing and love. If it was just an excuse for sin, then it would be sin. My point still is not just about polygamy, but that God knows each of us personally and knows what would lead us closer to Him. It would still be His call, not ours.

seekr

seekr

Janine, pretty much, that is my point. If we are following God, then it is what He puts before us and not what we think He wants.

seekr

Son of a Preacher Man

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (Dee Dee Warren @ Mar. 29 2003,08:52)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]I am in a discussion right now on another forum board with a couple of men advocating Christian polygamy.  [/quote]
They must be single. :D
:juggling:

seekr

Deedee

See you are also speaking heart issues. If that is the heart of the man, what you stated, then it is sin. But can we say that about all? Can we about David...a man after God's heart?

Please email me your response or maybe just post it here. I really would love to hear it.

seekr

Bon Voyage

Polygamy - no thanks.

An amen about not needing more than one mother-in-law.

And also why would I want another woman?

If I do \"A\" I am screamed at for not doing differently, same situation but I do the opposite of \"A\" and again I am in trouble.  Sometimes you just can't win.  

The polygamist is a glutton for punishment.  Some kind of sadist or something.

You know what they say, you can't live with or without women.  They are a mystery wrapped in an enigma.

janine

Seeing it from the other side... if, big IF[/b], God had the plan that it be so, then of course it would be the way to go.  What idiot bucks God?  (Yeah, I know, an idiot like me, all the time... :cry:  )

It would take something spectacular in the way of unmistakeable signs for me to think God wanted it, though.

boringoldguy

But you know how contrary women are.  They're probably doing it anyway!

seekr

I'm all for it. Making plans for my new 25 year old with hubby's permission and God's.


(will answer a little more seriously, later)

seekr

Dee Dee Warren

Dear Seekr:

I will be posting my response at my forum later tonight.  Email me if you want the link.  And yes there are very specific Scriptures which forbid it which I exegete in detail in my rebuttal.

Christian polygamy is I believe an excuse for these men not to learn to control their sexuality.  I can tell you that I am worth having one man love only me.  I would not settle for anything less.

janine

I think you mean masochist, JB.  :uhh:

Seekr, I do not believe that God would ever tell a married person to add on another spouse.  Two shall become one flesh, not several a monster ball of flesh with 43 arms and legs sticking out of it, its various heads poking out, its various mouths mewling wildly different demands...

Does God feel the same shocked emotions as a Puritanical sexually inhibited tight-laced little old church lady over marriage irregularities?  No, not hardly, I don't think so.  He's not that limited.

But just because David did it, does that mean it's a prefered plan of God?

seekr

kmv

I guess too, I think of it in terms of Christ's sacrifice. God sent His only son to die. What would a person sacrifice for love? If God asked you to sacrifice something that was precious to you, would you? If God said it would heal your husband from the past and create in him a new heart and a greater love, later, for you...would you be willing. And, again, I am not really just speaking of polygamy, but of anything in our life. I also realize that we cannot grasp certain things because of our finite minds. Think of Hosea who married a prostitute knowing he would be betrayed. He did it because it was God's will. Even though he suffered pain, he knew God had a greater plan through it. We do not acknowledge the unseen, until God reveals it. We do not see the bigger picture but stay focused on God, no matter what He would ask of us. Some of the things He has asked of me, seem really strange and I just follow. I eventually see the truth in it, but it seems unreal, because the world really is like the matrix in a lot of ways. I think this is where so many stumble. Our perspectives are very short-sighted. We believe the lie that we see.

seekr

seekr

What significance is the number 72? Then in their religion anything less would be frowned upon?

\"Salt Lake City\" experience? Nah. I think this was concocted for the lechers (sp?)in the group. More like a \"David\" or \"Solomon\" or \"Hosea\" experience. Ya just never know whar God may have up his sleeve...does He have sleeves?

seekr

+-Recent Topics

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Today at 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Today at 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Yesterday at 12:56:12

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

John 20:22 by Dave...
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 15:39:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Huguenots by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:11:46

Gibbon\Rome by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:07:07

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:05:00

Matthew 6:21 by pppp
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 08:14:39

Powered by EzPortal