News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898057
Total Topics: 90354
Most Online Today: 4569
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 2
Guests: 4369
Total: 4371
garee
Amo
Google (2)

the experts?

Started by archaeologist, Tue Sep 25, 2007 - 23:59:07

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

archaeologist

who does a christian listen to when it comes to matters of great importance.  most turn to the 'experts' as it is assumed they know what they are talking about, and in some cases that may be so.  but for the believer, we have different rules with which to operate by. 

we cannot just take anybody's word for whatever topic is being discussed because we have to discern between who is following God and who isn't.  then we must decide who is telling the truth and who isn't as they discuss evidence.

the Bible is very clear about 'not walking inthe cunselof the ungodly' and 'not being led astray by those who are being deceived and deceive themselves' so we need to apply such biblical instructions to those we may consider 'experts'.

here are some guidelines to help in knowing who we can listen to:

1.  everyone has the same evidence-

2.  the story of the evidence depends upon the interpretation/bias of the researcher  in other words, what they say the evidence is saying may not be what the evidence is saying. israel finkelstein and his writing partner silberman are prime examples of this as they seek to rewrite and redate israel's past.

QuoteThe Bible Unearthed is our attempt to formulate a new
archaeological vision of ancient Israel

http://sol.sci.uop.edu/~jfalward/Archaeology_and_the_Bible.htm

in other words secularists who do not believe the Bible seek alternatives to its record.

3.  non-believers have no motivation in proving the Bible true.  they will go with what fits their beliefs which may not be the truth of the past.

4. WE DO NOT have all the evidence from the past.  k.a. kitchen in his book, 'the Bible in its world' pgs. 11-13, talks about the scant amount of evidence we possess and the minute amount of the past that has been dug up.

5.  evidence is destroyed over the years.  what we have is very incomplete due to wars, construction, erosian and other destructive forces both natural and unnatural. (kitchen pg. 12)

6. dating is subjective and very prone to manipulation.  even the scientific methods can be manipulated or corrupted yielding false dates.

7. objectivity doesn't mean honesty.  in fact a personcan be 'objective' but lie.  honesty needs to return to research as one can be biased as well as honest but it is almost impossible to be 'objective'.

8.  not all christian archaeologists and researchers are honest.  just because they say they are christian does it mean they have the truth.  i.e. ron wyatt,, kent hovind and a few other embarrassments.  more on this another time.

9. the people of the past had the same brains, abilities, desires, & so on as we do now. the only difference between themand us, is technology and even then that is not always the case.  i.e. the greek computer, dentistry, plastic surgery and so on.  som eresearchers tend to think they were different creatures than we are but that just isn't so,  God made man, both ancient and modern, the same.

10. mitigating factors always play a part, whether it be financial, reputation, purpose, spiritual or whatever, one has to be sure of the integrity of the researcher and what he/she is writing.  some people are given a pass in their work because of their reputation.  i.e. kathleen kenyon

here are a few guidelines to help you when reading about how archaeology disagrees with the biblical record.  there are those who will generalize and say archaeology destgroys the Bible or all archaeologists agree---that just isn't so.

one of the ways to silence the critics of the Bible is to ask them to produce a list of archaeological discoveries which disproves the Bible.  they can't do it as allthey can produce is someone's interpretation of the evidence which does not qualify as an archaeological discovery.

david johnson

which archeologists do you believe to be accurate?

dj

archaeologist

besides k.a. kitchen, bryant wood is okay, gabriel barkay is honest, e. mazor is good  there area lot of good ones out there and i am not saying that the secularists are not finding evidence, i am saying their conclusions, theories and interpretations must be scrutinized. 

even finkelstein has found evidence for the israeli settlement, but he attributes it to an act from within the promised land and not the result of the exodus and conquest.  the non-religious researchers are out there looking and do dig up things we believers need, but we believers need to examine the evidence ourselves in light of God's word and come tothe right conclusions.

ryan and pittman made a discovery in the black sea, which has been confirmed on the coast of india--the waters rose and the shorelines receded--proof of the flood right there. they have found homes submerged and it wasn't an ice age action.

the evidence is subject to the interpretation, beliefs, bias etc. of those doing the analyzing and they aren't objective as they claim.

david johnson

are the findings not listed as 1) raw data, and then 2) interpretation/analysis.

dj

archaeologist

Quoteare the findings not listed as 1) raw data, and then 2) interpretation/analysis.

i am strictly talking about the interpretation and conclusions.  the work that is published.  in such works and they are too many to list, you can see how their thinking takes place and how it veers off into the wrong direction.  i just finished a book about catal hoyuk and it is a prime example of this.  dever's 'did God have a wife' is another example.{i believe that is the title}

david johnson

ok.  if they skew their data they are in danger of ridicule from their peers.  it's not that hard to pick apart conclusions if they give you honest findings.

dj

archaeologist

Quoteif they skew their data they are in danger of ridicule from their peers.  it's not that hard to pick apart conclusions if they give you honest findings

i think you are missing the point and donotunderstand the raw data aspect andhow they correlate that into their publications.  unless you have some archaeology experience you are not mentioning.

their raw data is what evidence is found, how it is interpretated is upto the archaeologist.  finkelstein's latest theory of israel arising in the highlands is without proof.  he has the settlement evidence, which also speaks of the exodus, he has no evidence that the israelites are actucally derived from the then existing canaanites.

dever is calling for evidence even though his theory is almost the same as finkelstein except he calls the ancestors 'proto-israelis'.  many people have differentopinion and since the majority of them throwout the bible, they have no proof to support their contentions.

to avoid ridicule, the theory has tomake sense and be realistic, it is not realistic todowhat finkelstein does and down date existing evidence to fit his theory.  i.e. the solomon gates, the stables and other such construction.  there is no reason to down date but finky does anyways and he is soundly criticized by his former professors but he and others keep on digging toprove what they can't prove.

i just found out that kenyon had anti-zionist views, these were never mentioned by any of the archaeologists i have studied or listened to.  such views do color one's perception  of the raw data and makes me wonder about her conclusions at jericho.


david johnson

'their raw data is what evidence is found, how it is interpretated is upto the archaeologist.

to avoid ridicule, the theory has tomake sense and be realistic, it is not realistic todowhat finkelstein does and down date existing evidence to fit his theory.'

that's what i'm saying.

dj

archaeologist

Quotethat's what i'm saying.

i normally stop responding to people who only give short,one sentence replies.  they aren't conducive to a good discussion.

zoonance


don has a plan

Are you an achaeologist, Archaeologist?  If so, where did you complete your studies?  I have some good friends in a grad program in archaeology here in Memphis.  It's a very interesting field.

archaeologist

yes it is an interesting field and i use my background to change the rules a bit as i do not believe that christians shoul dbe doing their work according to secular rules.  which is why i disagree with so many archaeologists.


one of the secular rules is to dismiss or not accept religious writings as archaeological evidence.  though they usuallyonly apply that to the Bible as many arch. use the popol vol or hindu scriptures for insight into those early civilizations .

{did you know that the popol vol actually has proof for the babel disporia)

when you are talking about the Bible you cannot throw it out or say it is wrong because the Biblical acccounts go by God's criteria and not man's.  so in investigating biblical archaeology, secular rules cannot be used as they are designed for a limited funtion which is why we have the finkesteins and devers claiming there was no exodus. 

God is not going toprovide physical evidence which destroys faith.  he will provide enough to strengthen our faith  because we need tobe strong inHis word and we need to follow Him not man's rules.

so i highly doubt we will ever find the ark, i highly doubt we wil lfind evidence for the exodus or wanderings and soon.  God's criteria is faith, taking Him at His word, so in this instance you have a choice--believe God or believe the secular world.

the secular world says you need physical proof or it didn't happen and for the believer thatis just not an option.

QuoteAre you an achaeologist, Archaeologist

i have been described as a theo-archaeologist since i have degrees in theology, history and archaeology.  i wouldn't consider myself an archaeologist as i do not do it professionally but use the field to help believers in their walks with God.

david johnson

Quote from: archaeologist on Thu Sep 27, 2007 - 16:07:01
Quotethat's what i'm saying.

i normally stop responding to people who only give short,one sentence replies.  they aren't conducive to a good discussion.

i have a low b/s tolerance. ::smile::

what i notice here at times is -
the more words, the less accuracy.  if you throw in lots of italics, bolding, and technicolor, the statements are probably way off base.

dj


marc

Quote from: archaeologist on Thu Sep 27, 2007 - 16:07:01
Quotethat's what i'm saying.

i normally stop responding to people who only give short,one sentence replies.  they aren't conducive to a good discussion.

Minimalism is good.

archaeologist

QuoteMinimalism is good.

Quotei have a low b/s tolerance.

what i notice here at times is -
the more words, the less accuracy.  if you throw in lots of italics, bolding, and technicolor, the statements are probably way off base.

well, when you are dealing with complex topics and academic opinions, sound bite answers do not fill the bill.  i do not b/s and have made such posts from years of work, study and investigation.

to make severly annotated replies tells me one is uneducated or unwilling to discuss which then causes me to question their posting in that particular thread.  which then makes me unwilling to share what i know so you do not have to duplicate the work i did in reaching those conclusions.

in academics, highlighting and other features are done solely for clarity and to avoid confusion.  such are a neccessary tool when making a point that invloves multiple  reasons.

i am looking for a discussion that will benefit those who read these threads which will help them even if all they do is read.  sound bites just don't do the job.

david johnson

'to make severly annotated replies tells me one is uneducated or unwilling to discuss which then causes me to question their posting in that particular thread.  which then makes me unwilling to share what i know so you do not have to duplicate the work i did in reaching those conclusions.

in academics, highlighting and other features are done solely for clarity and to avoid confusion.  such are a neccessary tool when making a point that invloves multiple  reasons.'

severly annotated?

i will discuss my academic qualifications via p/m if you require them.
we are, however, running into non-academic presentations here at times that misuse the tools you mention.
i am glad that the ones who mostly did that are gone for awhile.

dj

archaeologist

i am not interested in your academic qualifications, i would prefer a discussion that actually discussed instead of short-circuit.

marc

Quote from: david johnson on Fri Sep 28, 2007 - 17:06:09
Quote from: archaeologist on Thu Sep 27, 2007 - 16:07:01
Quotethat's what i'm saying.

i normally stop responding to people who only give short,one sentence replies.  they aren't conducive to a good discussion.

i have a low b/s tolerance. ::smile:: 
what i notice here at times is -
the more words, the less accuracy.  if you throw in lots of italics, bolding, and technicolor, the statements are probably way off base.

dj



Yeah, but throw in a few references to pagan dieties and music....::lookaround::

david johnson

Quote from: archaeologist on Sat Sep 29, 2007 - 16:06:29
i am not interested in your academic qualifications, i would prefer a discussion that actually discussed instead of short-circuit.

you brought academics, not i.  don't bring it up if you don't want to discuss it.

dj

archaeologist

obviously you are not worth talking to so please ignore my posts.

david johnson

'i have been described as a theo-archaeologist since i have degrees in theology, history and archaeology.' - arch.

arch:

you brought it all up in this very thread.  i offered to respond in kind (privately) and now i'm 'not worth talking to' ?

something not really right about your apparent attitude.

dj

archaeologist

either that or your 'replies' demonstrate that you are a taker and not a contributer.  these are complex issues i raised and one sentence replies do not cut it.

david johnson

i obviously choose 'that', since you did 'that'.
what contribution do you need?

dj

archaeologist

i know another person, claimed to be anglicanbut acted worse thansome sinners, who does exactly what you are doing.  waste of time and thread space.

david johnson

asking you what contribution you need is a waste?
then why would anyone respond?

dj

don has a plan

Quotei have been described as a theo-archaeologist since i have degrees in theology, history and archaeology.  i wouldn't consider myself an archaeologist as i do not do it professionally but use the field to help believers in their walks with God.

Cool.  I don't know very much about archaelogy (my undergrad degree is in history, but it's just plain old European history, nothing exciting), so I'm looking forward to reading more about the subject here.  It's always been very interesting to me.

Jaime

Quote from: archaeologist on Sun Sep 30, 2007 - 18:36:29
either that or your 'replies' demonstrate that you are a taker and not a contributer.  these are complex issues i raised and one sentence replies do not cut it.

rofl

david johnson

yep, archie is a funny one!

dj

Jaime

Quote from: archaeologist on Sat Sep 29, 2007 - 16:06:29
i am not interested in your academic qualifications, i would prefer a discussion that actually discussed instead of short-circuit.

We are not interested in your's either, or your arrogance.


david johnson



Quote from: don has a plan on Mon Oct 01, 2007 - 10:43:57
Quotei have been described as a theo-archaeologist since i have degrees in theology, history and archaeology.  i wouldn't consider myself an archaeologist as i do not do it professionally but use the field to help believers in their walks with God.

Cool.  I don't know very much about archaelogy (my undergrad degree is in history, but it's just plain old European history, nothing exciting), so I'm looking forward to reading more about the subject here.  It's always been very interesting to me.

did you go on any 'digs' while in school?  in europe?
we have some archeological sites in my home state that really interest me,
such as some indian mounds & the old arkansas post.

dj

archaeologist

QuoteWe are not interested in your's either, or your arrogance.
i do not have any arrogance but seeing how this thread got derailed so quickly i see you are not interested in information either.

with responses like this it is easy to confirm the accusations i got from the non-believers

Jaime

Quote from: archaeologist on Mon Oct 01, 2007 - 16:37:58
QuoteWe are not interested in your's either, or your arrogance.
i do not have any arrogance but seeing how this thread got derailed so quickly i see you are not interested in information either.

with responses like this it is easy to confirm the accusations i got from the non-believers

So ya don't have any arrogance at all, huh?

I believe the old saying applies here....."You're no better than everyone else thinks you are."

spurly

Archaeologist, this is a community.  Some people in the community are people who get their point across in a few words.  Other people in our community like to use a plethora of words.  Just because someone is able to sum up what they are saying in a sentence or two does not make their contribution any less important than someone who posts long posts.  As a matter of fact, many people prefer the shorter posts over the longer posts because of time - they don't have much.

david johnson

spurly speaks this truth well.

dj

mike

I concur with dj, jaime, and spurly.

I am quite interested in archeology, though. If you have something to teach us or discuss, I will listen.

+-Recent Topics

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Today at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Today at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Yesterday at 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Powered by EzPortal