News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898068
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 6875
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 6266
Total: 6266
Google

How would you fix the Catholic church?

Started by Wycliffes_Shillelagh, Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Wycliffes_Shillelagh

Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt, starting with the pope in Rome and his funding project of the building of St. Peter's, financed by indulgences, mandated pilgramages, bribes and tributes from various kings, and so on and so forth. 

It is also manifest that the problem wasn't confined simply to the papacy, as the cardinals had become local and national power brokers, and the confessors and inquisitors had become extortionists and thugs.  The Bible itself was held hostage by the clergy in a dead language, the perfect solution to the problem of private interpretation.

What I see is that the system of apostolic succession is a system which leaves no room to challenge those in authority when they behave badly.

And that doesn't even touch the issue of bad theology.  Private interpretation, which you have so roundly criticized, is the very thing which would lead people to question bad theology (& bad behavior). 

Shouldn't the laity be ever questioning the clergy?  Challenging them to explain?  Shouldn't the clergy be transparent enough, well-behaved enough, and knowledgable enough to explain the most of the objections?..if in fact the faith delivered once and for all is coherent and logical.

What would you do when the entire system is corrupt?  When the whole head is sick?

The aim back then, obviously, was to reform the church, hence "Reformation."  I argue that it just wasn't possible without breaking away from the church and creating a rival.  After all, competition raises the standards of quality, and scrutiny raises self-awareness.

Thank you,

Jarrod

CDHealy

I'm not a Protestant (anymore), but my answer is: By having Rome come back to the rest of the Christian patriarchates.

MegaJedi

How would I fix the catholic chuch?

1.  Get rid of the idols
2, get frid of the Pope and the vatican
3 get rid of the rosery
4. Get rid of the crusifix
5. Get rid of the nuns
Basicly get rid of everything that is not Biblical.

broach972

Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt, starting with the pope in Rome and his funding project of the building of St. Peter's, financed by indulgences, mandated pilgramages, bribes and tributes from various kings, and so on and so forth. 

It is also manifest that the problem wasn't confined simply to the papacy, as the cardinals had become local and national power brokers, and the confessors and inquisitors had become extortionists and thugs.  The Bible itself was held hostage by the clergy in a dead language, the perfect solution to the problem of private interpretation.

What I see is that the system of apostolic succession is a system which leaves no room to challenge those in authority when they behave badly.

And that doesn't even touch the issue of bad theology.  Private interpretation, which you have so roundly criticized, is the very thing which would lead people to question bad theology (& bad behavior). 

Shouldn't the laity be ever questioning the clergy?  Challenging them to explain?  Shouldn't the clergy be transparent enough, well-behaved enough, and knowledgable enough to explain the most of the objections?..if in fact the faith delivered once and for all is coherent and logical.

What would you do when the entire system is corrupt?  When the whole head is sick?

The aim back then, obviously, was to reform the church, hence "Reformation."  I argue that it just wasn't possible without breaking away from the church and creating a rival.  After all, competition raises the standards of quality, and scrutiny raises self-awareness.

Thank you,

Jarrod

My time is very limited these days but I must make this point: you are primarly referring to discipline rather than doctrine.  Unfortunately, Luther started with questioning certain "disciplines" within the Chruch and then went to questioning core doctrines, which had stood for more than 1500 years prior to the Reformation.  One could certainly argue that the Reformation was actually good for the Church, maybe not for Christianity as a whole.  The event forced the Church to do some serious self-reflection.  Although some "disciplines" did change due to abuse or corruption, the doctrines never changed, as many of them were affirmed by the Council of Trent.

broach972

Quote from: CDHealy on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 13:05:47
I'm not a Protestant (anymore), but my answer is: By having Rome come back to the rest of the Christian patriarchates.

And then what?....

Howdyboyalan

The only way to fix the Catholic Church now is to remove it all together.

Tantor

1.) Let priests and nuns marry (but give preference to single ones).

2.) Remove all statues, icons and other items that could lead to possible idol worship.

3.) Remove the Eucharist from church and teach it as being part of a meal at home with fellow christians (encourage fellowship).

4.) Remove all robes and other artifical trappings from the clergy.. they are men and women just like everyone else.. let their actions speak for their character instead of their clothes.

5.) Sell all church assets and give them to the poor... existing cathedrals can become museums or whatever the community decides to do with them.

6.) Sell the vatican to italy and vacate the place.

7.) Establish a council of elders to replace the papacy.. where all elders are equal to one another... just like it was until the bishop of rome pulled his power play.

8.) Pay reparations to every single person who's families can trace back their lineage to murdered persons of different faiths or who were killed for being in opposition to the pope.

This would be a good start.


sopranette

Why #8?  Wouldn't we all owe someone money, if, in fact, we ARE guilty for the sins of our fathers?

love,

sopranette

Tantor

Quote from: sopranette on Thu Jan 29, 2009 - 11:16:01
Why #8?  Wouldn't we all owe someone money, if, in fact, we ARE guilty for the sins of our fathers?

love,

sopranette

Because of the institutional basis of the offense.


ole Jake

Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt, starting with the pope in Rome and his funding project of the building of St. Peter's, financed by indulgences, mandated pilgramages, bribes and tributes from various kings, and so on and so forth. 

It is also manifest that the problem wasn't confined simply to the papacy, as the cardinals had become local and national power brokers, and the confessors and inquisitors had become extortionists and thugs.  The Bible itself was held hostage by the clergy in a dead language, the perfect solution to the problem of private interpretation.

What I see is that the system of apostolic succession is a system which leaves no room to challenge those in authority when they behave badly.

And that doesn't even touch the issue of bad theology.  Private interpretation, which you have so roundly criticized, is the very thing which would lead people to question bad theology (& bad behavior). 

Shouldn't the laity be ever questioning the clergy?  Challenging them to explain?  Shouldn't the clergy be transparent enough, well-behaved enough, and knowledgable enough to explain the most of the objections?..if in fact the faith delivered once and for all is coherent and logical.

What would you do when the entire system is corrupt?  When the whole head is sick?

The aim back then, obviously, was to reform the church, hence "Reformation."  I argue that it just wasn't possible without breaking away from the church and creating a rival.  After all, competition raises the standards of quality, and scrutiny raises self-awareness.

Thank you,

Jarrod

This is one giant mess of fairy tales and garbled understanding. To begin, if you think that there were not Bibles in various vernaculars before Luther then you are far too ignorant of the subject to comment upon it. In fact, there were multiple versions of scripture in German before Luther. Not all were of full Bibles - some, for example were of the Gospels and Psalms and some were New Testaments, etc. But all of the Bible was available in German before Luther.

That men in any age misuse God's authority and the system God establsihed is no justification for any man to reject that pattern God established. If nothing else, the case of Judas should demonstrate that. If personal corruption by a Pope or a series of Cardinals invalidates the order established by Christ, then Judas did that very thing before the crucifixion and Christianity has zero merit.

There was no 'church-sponsored' government, save within the Vatican state. The government of France was civil: a King. Everybody had kings ruling them, not Cardinals who had replaced kings.

Just as no one had the right to 'challenge' the Apostles by preaching that which is heretical, no one in the laity today, or ever, has the right to proclaim heresy. My personal prefernce, for example, would be to allow women priests (preferably as part of a married team), but the Church, based on Apostolic succession, has ruled that women can never be priests. I have no more right to demand that recant that defined doctrine than I would have to tell an Apostle I reject something he taught.

In that, people either swallow pride and serve or they refuse to serve. Man has free will.

If the one church created by Christ, which Christ declared would stand forever, became corrupt as you assert, then Christ was a liar and a failure.

The only way to try to cheat that logic is to revert toward Gnostism and claim an invisible church that is the true reality, so that the visible church can be damned without meaning that Christianity is false.

I have no doubt that ancient Gnostics made the same arguements.

Luther rather naively believed that if only the world embraced his novel concoction sola fide that all its sins would begin to dissipate. Such passionionate faith in cure-all pills can lead to horror and chaos. Ih his case, it did. For example, the Reformation in England required that 100% of the Catholic Church property in England and Wales be stolen, along with the vast majority of Catholics who refused to convert. The body count to achieve the thefts was minimal compared to the Continent, but several thousand executed Catholic priests and monks and worshipers (Mass was made illegal) is something.

Perhaps we should discuss how all English-speaking Protestants collectively bear guilt for that and how they should pay reparations. I think all that property - which included tens of thousands of acres of farm and forest land, the only land on which English peasants could hunt and fish, land on which peasants ran their stock - could be paid for today with a couple billion dollars.

And that's just England. Luther and Lutheran princes did not buy Catholic Church property in the Germanies; they took it by force of arms. And then the father of Protestant rebellion had the Peasants War, in which he gave his full blessings to Lutheran princes as they - based on sola fide
and sola scriptura - slaughtered tens of thousands of 'Anabaptists' - who also based their views on Luther's two concoctions and who also were ready to slaughter other Protestants by the masses in order to acquire wealth and power in the 'reformed' world.

ole Jake

Quote from: broach972 on Thu Jan 29, 2009 - 08:56:20
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt, starting with the pope in Rome and his funding project of the building of St. Peter's, financed by indulgences, mandated pilgramages, bribes and tributes from various kings, and so on and so forth. 

It is also manifest that the problem wasn't confined simply to the papacy, as the cardinals had become local and national power brokers, and the confessors and inquisitors had become extortionists and thugs.  The Bible itself was held hostage by the clergy in a dead language, the perfect solution to the problem of private interpretation.

What I see is that the system of apostolic succession is a system which leaves no room to challenge those in authority when they behave badly.

And that doesn't even touch the issue of bad theology.  Private interpretation, which you have so roundly criticized, is the very thing which would lead people to question bad theology (& bad behavior). 

Shouldn't the laity be ever questioning the clergy?  Challenging them to explain?  Shouldn't the clergy be transparent enough, well-behaved enough, and knowledgable enough to explain the most of the objections?..if in fact the faith delivered once and for all is coherent and logical.

What would you do when the entire system is corrupt?  When the whole head is sick?

The aim back then, obviously, was to reform the church, hence "Reformation."  I argue that it just wasn't possible without breaking away from the church and creating a rival.  After all, competition raises the standards of quality, and scrutiny raises self-awareness.

Thank you,

Jarrod

My time is very limited these days but I must make this point: you are primarly referring to discipline rather than doctrine.  Unfortunately, Luther started with questioning certain "disciplines" within the Chruch and then went to questioning core doctrines, which had stood for more than 1500 years prior to the Reformation.  One could certainly argue that the Reformation was actually good for the Church, maybe not for Christianity as a whole.  The event forced the Church to do some serious self-reflection.  Although some "disciplines" did change due to abuse or corruption, the doctrines never changed, as many of them were affirmed by the Council of Trent.

Indulgences had been opposed by men, including Bishops, long before Luther began his opposition. There is nothing that Luther did or started that led to any needed change in discipline.

katholikos

#11
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt......

What you are basically saying is: How do we get rid of sinners in the Church?
The answer is: We don't

Jesus came not for the righteous, but for sinners. Show me a Church full of squeeky clean people, and I'll show you a building full of phonies.

Men will always be corrupt. But you don't leave Peter because of Judas, and we don't leave the Church because of some corrupt men.

Let me ask you: If you were a good Jew, and you saw all the Jews building a golden calf at the foot of Sinai, what would you do? Quit being a Jew?

When I argue in favor of the Church, I argue in favor of what the Church teaches, not for the holiness of any one particular Catholic. And WHAT THE CATHOLIC CHURCH TEACHES IS TRUE, even though many individual Catholics do not always live up to that truth.

I would also point out that over 2000 years the Church has continually reformed itself. Great saints, like Francis of Assisi, or reforming popes like Gregory the Great have popped up from time to time to reform the Church. But your "reformers" did not reform anything, they merely broke away and ripped the Body of Christ into pieces. That is not reform, the was REVOLT. Also, they were not soley concerned with abuses, but they introduced heretical teachings to boot, and that was something the Church could never accept

Tantor

Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 08:42:02
WHAT THE CATHOLIC CHURCH TEACHES IS TRUE

It is if you are a pagan.. only the statues have been changed to obfuscate the obvious.

broach972

Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 08:42:02
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt......

What you are basically saying: How do we get rid of sinners in the Church?
The answer is: We don't

Jesus came not for the righteous, but for sinners. Show me a Church full of squeeky clean people, and I'll show you a building full of phonies.

Men will always be corrupt. But you don't leave Peter because of Judas, and we don't leave the Church because of some corrupt men.

Let me ask you: If you were a good Jew, and you saw all the Jews building a golden calf at the foot of Sinai, what would you do? Quit being a Jew?

When I argue in favor of the Church, I argue in favor of what the Church teaches, not for the holiness of any one particular Catholic. And WHAT THE CATHOLIC CHURCH TEACHES IS TRUE, even though many individual Catholics do not always live up to that truth.

I would also point out that over 2000 years the Church has continually reformed itself. Great saints, like Frasncis of Assisi, or reforming popes like Gregory the Great have popped up from time to time to reform the Church. But your' reformers" did not reform anything, they merely broke away and ripped the Body of Christ into pieces. That is not reform, the was REVOLT. Also, they were not soley concerned with abuses, but they introduced heretical teachings to boot, and that was something the Church could never accept

Outstanding post...manna for you.

Wycliffes_Shillelagh

Quote from: ole Jake on Thu Jan 29, 2009 - 18:00:02
To begin, if you think that there were not Bibles in various vernaculars before Luther then you are far too ignorant of the subject to comment upon it.  In fact, there were multiple versions of scripture in German before Luther. Not all were of full Bibles - some, for example were of the Gospels and Psalms and some were New Testaments, etc. But all of the Bible was available in German before Luther.
Did you read my post?  My post nowhere mentions Luther or his translation of the Bible.  Or German.  Actually, the first person in this thread to mention Luther was a Catholic.  I suspect that this is because he an easy object to attack and/or refute.  But really the OP has nothing to do with this man.

QuoteThat men in any age misuse God's authority and the system God establsihed is no justification for any man to reject that pattern God established.  If nothing else, the case of Judas should demonstrate that. If personal corruption by a Pope or a series of Cardinals invalidates the order established by Christ, then Judas did that very thing before the crucifixion and Christianity has zero merit.
The problem here is that I don't believe there was any pattern established, other than to execute judgment and justice, and to seek good rather than evil.  I suppose your argument carries weight to those who believe in a pattern, but for me, well...you're trying to hang an argument on a hook that doesn't exist.

QuoteThere was no 'church-sponsored' government, save within the Vatican state. The government of France was civil: a King. Everybody had kings ruling them, not Cardinals who had replaced kings.
Riiiiight.  A little honest history please...the Vatican was levying taxes and creating laws enforceable by their own agents within these same countries that were ruled by "independent" kings.  Which kings had to be approved by the Pope, else they were deposed, excommunicated, or perhaps just an uprising was sponsored within their lands.

QuoteJust as no one had the right to 'challenge' the Apostles by preaching that which is heretical, no one in the laity today, or ever, has the right to proclaim heresy. My personal prefernce, for example, would be to allow women priests (preferably as part of a married team), but the Church, based on Apostolic succession, has ruled that women can never be priests. I have no more right to demand that recant that defined doctrine than I would have to tell an Apostle I reject something he taught.

In that, people either swallow pride and serve or they refuse to serve. Man has free will.
I don't have a problem with any of this, except the part where you accord to those "apostolic successors" the same authority that the apostles held.  They are bishops and not apostles, and should not have the ability to create doctrine.

QuoteIf the one church created by Christ, which Christ declared would stand forever, became corrupt as you assert, then Christ was a liar and a failure.

The only way to try to cheat that logic is to revert toward Gnostism and claim an invisible church that is the true reality, so that the visible church can be damned without meaning that Christianity is false.

I have no doubt that ancient Gnostics made the same arguements.
Can't say that I'm lovin the catch phrase "invisible church."  I simply believe that whether one is truly part of the church is visible in word and deed, rather than in status as a parishioner.  Invisible it is not.

Your understanding of gnosticism also leaves something to be desired if you are equating the gnostics conceptions of "the spiritual world" and the forms with this notion.  Would you like me to recommend some reading that will help you understand gnosticism?  It's really an interesting study, particularly with regard to understanding the book of Colossians.

QuoteLuther rather naively believed that if only the world embraced his novel concoction sola fide that all its sins would begin to dissipate. Such passionionate faith in cure-all pills can lead to horror and chaos. Ih his case, it did. For example, the Reformation in England required that 100% of the Catholic Church property in England and Wales be stolen, along with the vast majority of Catholics who refused to convert. The body count to achieve the thefts was minimal compared to the Continent, but several thousand executed Catholic priests and monks and worshipers (Mass was made illegal) is something.
No doubt.  I'm not really a Luther fan, myself, though I know many are.  But again I have to point out that this isn't about Luther @ all.

QuotePerhaps we should discuss how all English-speaking Protestants collectively bear guilt for that and how they should pay reparations. I think all that property - which included tens of thousands of acres of farm and forest land, the only land on which English peasants could hunt and fish, land on which peasants ran their stock - could be paid for today with a couple billion dollars.
Lol.  We'll just deduct it from what the RCC owes.  J/K.  I've never been a fan of reparations that are paid by descendents.  Just doesn't seem quite right to me, but I suppose Tantor's post asked for that.

QuoteAnd that's just England. Luther and Lutheran princes did not buy Catholic Church property in the Germanies; they took it by force of arms. And then the father of Protestant rebellion had the Peasants War, in which he gave his full blessings to Lutheran princes as they - based on sola fide
and sola scriptura - slaughtered tens of thousands of 'Anabaptists' - who also based their views on Luther's two concoctions and who also were ready to slaughter other Protestants by the masses in order to acquire wealth and power in the 'reformed' world.
But really, you've totally ignored the question...

What SHOULD have been done to fix the problems in the Catholic Church?
Do you think any measure short of breaking fellowship would have been effectual to reform the church?
Do you deny that the setting up of a rival to the RCC has instigated changes for the better?

Jarrod

Wycliffes_Shillelagh

Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 08:42:02
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt......

What you are basically saying is: How do we get rid of sinners in the Church?
The answer is: We don't

Well this is an interesting tactic.  Restating the question into a totally different question so that you can answer it.

I did not ask how to get rid of sinners in the church.

I asked what could have been done to reform the church during the Dark Ages & Renaissance rather than having a split in the church.

Can you not see that these are two very different things?

katholikos

Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 16:30:30
Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 08:42:02
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Jan 28, 2009 - 12:28:59
Dear Catholics,

I have heard many criticisms from you all of the Protestant fathers, and their disagreement with each other, about problems with Sola Scriptura and private interpretation.

I have to wonder...just how would you have fixed the Catholic church?

At the time of the Reformation, there is little denying that the church-sponsored government was abyssmally corrupt......

What you are basically saying is: How do we get rid of sinners in the Church?
The answer is: We don't

Well this is an interesting tactic.  Restating the question into a totally different question so that you can answer it.

I did not ask how to get rid of sinners in the church.

I asked what could have been done to reform the church during the Dark Ages & Renaissance rather than having a split in the church.

Can you not see that these are two very different things?

No, I cannot, and I'll tell you why.

Catholic Dogma is infallible. You cannot reform "Truth." I know that you disagree with this, but from our point of view, no dogmatically defined doctrine is wrong, therfore no doctrine needs to be reformed.

So what does that leave us with? It leaves us with corruption and abuses. Or, in a word: SIN. And since we cannot stop people from sinning, it will always be an ongonig battle  -  a lesson you guys have learned thanks to the likes of Jimmy Swaggart and Jim Baker.

Now, to go on from here, I will quote the another part of the post which you did not quote:

".......I would also point out that over 2000 years the Church has continually reformed itself. Great saints, like Francis of Assisi, or reforming popes like Gregory the Great have popped up from time to time to reform the Church. But your "reformers" did not reform anything, they merely broke away and ripped the Body of Christ into pieces. That is not reform, the was REVOLT. Also, they were not soley concerned with abuses, but they introduced heretical teachings to boot, and that was something the Church could never accept"

Wycliffes_Shillelagh

You don't see a difference between:

Sinners in the church
&
Sinners running the church

?

zoonance

Sinners making up the doctrines of the church on behalf of Christ the Head?

katholikos

Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:31:12
You don't see a difference between:

Sinners in the church
&
Sinners running the church

?

Hey, if you can find some sinless men to run your church then you're a better man than I am

Wycliffes_Shillelagh

Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:32:34
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:31:12
You don't see a difference between:

Sinners in the church
&
Sinners running the church

?

Hey, if you can find some sinless men to run your church then you're a better man than I am
Sinless is not the opposite of sinner.

I can't find some sinLESS men any more than you can.  But I can find some men who are not, at present, sinNING as they run the church.

Fallen Knight

Considering that ALL Christians should totally trust in Our Father, and His ability to do what is right, than simply pray.

If your prayer is answered and the wrongs you believe are in the Catholic Church are changed, than Praise Be To God

If your prayers are not answered than you have basically two decisions to make.

A) The Catholic Church is wrong but Almighty God has a purpose for it
B) The Catholic Church is right and Almighty God has a purpose for it

The simple truth is, there weren't any Bible Only Lutheran/Baptist/AOG/Calvinistic/Evangelical/Latter Day Saints/Etc/Etc/Etc around when Jesus said :
" The Holy Spirit will lead you in the ways of all truth" and "not even the gates of hell shall prevail against you"........2000 yrs ago

We know that Christians worshipped on a Sunday and offered up the Eucharist back then ( Gospell of John, Didache, St Ignatius )

We also know that Christian rejection of the Lord's Day and the Eucharist did not emerge for 1500 yrs after Our Lord's promise as a result of the reformation that splintered Christianity ( A Kingdom divided against itself )

You are not going to stand before Our Lord surrounded by Catholic Priests or Protestant Pastors. You are going to stand there by yourself

It's your call. Do you have faith in Jesus and be prepared that He kept His promise even though the truth may not fit into your "theology"??


chosenone

Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Feb 04, 2009 - 18:06:37
Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:32:34
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:31:12
You don't see a difference between:

Sinners in the church
&
Sinners running the church

?

Hey, if you can find some sinless men to run your church then you're a better man than I am
Sinless is not the opposite of sinner.

I can't find some sinLESS men any more than you can.  But I can find some men who are not, at present, sinNING as they run the church.

wow have you actually met men who are not sinning as they run the church? We all sin, we are all imperfect and have weaknesses. men who run a  church are no different then sin all the time even in little ways, such as getting stressed in a supermarket queue, feeling angry at someone who is speeding and nearly causes and accident, thinking something about someone that is less then charitable, and countless other ways.
I respect church leaders who admit to their struggles and mistakes, as I can relate to them. if someone thinks they are very good and spiritual I leave them well alone becuase they are lying.and have the sin of pride. ::prayinghard::

Wycliffes_Shillelagh

Quote from: chosenone on Wed Feb 11, 2009 - 05:29:59
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Wed Feb 04, 2009 - 18:06:37
Quote from: katholikos on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:32:34
Quote from: Wycliffes_Shillelagh on Fri Jan 30, 2009 - 17:31:12
You don't see a difference between:

Sinners in the church
&
Sinners running the church

?

Hey, if you can find some sinless men to run your church then you're a better man than I am
Sinless is not the opposite of sinner.

I can't find some sinLESS men any more than you can.  But I can find some men who are not, at present, sinNING as they run the church.

wow have you actually met men who are not sinning as they run the church? We all sin, we are all imperfect and have weaknesses. men who run a  church are no different then sin all the time even in little ways, such as getting stressed in a supermarket queue, feeling angry at someone who is speeding and nearly causes and accident, thinking something about someone that is less then charitable, and countless other ways.
I respect church leaders who admit to their struggles and mistakes, as I can relate to them. if someone thinks they are very good and spiritual I leave them well alone becuase they are lying.and have the sin of pride. ::prayinghard::
I'm talking about people who are using their positions in the church for personal gain, etc.

I'm not talking about guys who occasionally drive too fast, or say something crude when they hit their thumb with a hammer.

freedom.com

#24
1) allow prist to marry. they are responsible in planing family.they have complete information how to do it.  lets give chance thier race or spirit spread.thier siblings folow them become godfearing.

2)get rid of graven image,

3)get rid of rosary which is repeated. dont repeat much when praying

4)get rid of title or high names given to the leader of the church like reverend,papa or father, most high etc .instead lets call each of one us brother or sisters tru christ.us christ humble we humble also and call our self brother and sister

5) take away the purgatory doctrine
6) be humble and be ready to change the wrong doctrines.reform repent is holy dont be shy or embarrass, God loves who humble and reform and repent
7) adress always the meaning of the doctrines clearly. detail and specific complete
8) be deligent in expalining to the people or member the gospel of jesus in the mass. not just telling story but explain detail the meaning of the word of God. dont be trifty to explain to the people or your member the good news
9)dont allow them to charge the sacred obligation of church. baptism,bless in married should have no charge, because it is writen given free give it free.   when u alow has charge your bless is fake. ur baptism is fake. holy spirit will not exist.  because the sacred and holyness of the porpose will destroy if not given freely

proud catholic

There is nothing to fix.  We just need to pray that our Protestant brothers and sisters are open to the truth.  That they will be able to understand the fullest of the faith, which is what we have.

Tantor

Quote from: proud catholic on Wed Feb 25, 2009 - 14:30:36
There is nothing to fix.  We just need to pray that our Protestant brothers and sisters are open to the truth.  That they will be able to understand the fullest of the faith, which is what we have.

How about you divest yourself of the churches vast riches and give them to the poor first... then we can talk.

proud catholic

We do, we have Catholic Charities and my husband and I are involved in the homeless ministry and the Women's Help Center.

chosenone

The Catholic church will only be fixed if they stick to what the Bibke says and not believe all the things that have been added and taken away from it by man.There are SO MANY worng teachings that I cant even begin to name them but that have been named before many times on these forums.
Also for their members to do what GOD tells them in His word, and not go by their priests and wrong doctrines that they have been taught that are NOT in the Bible. When what WE believe becomes more important to us than what the Bible teaches, there is something very wrong. I personally think that nothing will change until it is too late for many at the end.

The fact that many of you have chosen catholic type names on these forum such as proud catholic shows that your demoniation holds far too much importance. Maybe proud Christian would be something more appropriate. it is God who we should be proud of and not a demionination, especially one that has so very many stark and obvious errors.   

proud catholic

Read the history of the Church.  Did you know Jesus was a Catholic?  Do you even know what Catholic means?  It means universal...All.  It means that until the 1600's we were all Catholic.  Unfortunately, Luthern decided he could not abide by Jesus's teachings thus left the Church and there you have it.  Yeap, it's not easy being Catholic.  Much is expected of us.  The road is VERY narrow.

Peace be with you.

Francis of Assisi

#30
The Church does NOT need to change it's doctrines in order to be fixed.  There is no Catholic doctrine or ritual that is preventing Catholics from following Christ.   If anything, Protestants should closely study Early Church history and realize that prayers for the deceased and prayers to the saints for intercession were widespread in the Early Church and that the celebration of the Eucharist was the focus of worship every single Lord's Day.  However, if the Church is to truly be fixed, to be a more shining example of the life of Christ and of His will to the world, it does need to purify itself and how does it do that?

I remember a banner that was hung in a St. Anthony of Padua parish long ago during Lent.  It read "turn away from sin and follow the Gospel".  The real meaning of that banner was a call for repentance.  This is what the Church needs to do more than anything else.  The Church needs to repent, not just in a general way, as John Paul II attempted to do, but in a very specific way.  The most single horrific sin committed by Popes and sons of the Church during the 2,000 years of Christendom was the use of torture against human beings during the Middle Ages.  There is no possible way to ever justify the use of torture on a a human being - never!  Looking at the words of the Lord in the Gospels, especially in the Sermon on the Mount, and look at how He was tortured Himself and how the Christian martrys were tortured in the Roman Arena.  It should be a given that Jesus would never look with favor upon torture.  The Pope should issue an encyclical, ex cathedra, with the aura of infallibility, teaching that the use of torture against a human being is a grave/mortal sin. 

If eating meat on Friday during Lent is a grave sin or the use of artificial contraception is a grave sin, surely torture is a grave sin.   The Pope should acknowledge in the same document that every Pope that authorized torture during the Inquisition and every Inquisitor that used torture committed a terrible sin against God and man.  We should not expect the Church to decree now that the authorization and use of torture was a grave/mortal sin during the Middle Ages, since such was not taught back then and thus those involved did not believe that such was the case.  Hence, this lessens their culpability.  However, the Church can certainly acknowledge with specificity that such acts were "terrible" sins.

Such a dramatic move by the Church would probably do more to heal the rift between the Church and Protestantism than any change in a single doctrine could ever do!   Perhaps such a move might well encourage Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants alike to follow the example of the Church itself and to truly repent and follow the Gospel of Christ.

kensington

Terrible sins? Grave sin?  Mortal sin?...  Jesus never said that, Sin is sin.  It's all punishable by death, Jesus died to save us from that death, and that is the gospel we should follow.  It matters what religion one practices or be they a layman or a Pope, if they did not follow that gospel, they will go to Hell.

Francis of Assisi

#32
Not only is it illogical to say that God views all sins equally, but this thesis is not what was believed by the Early Church.  The Early Church felt that certain sins were so serious, that they required some form of penance for a period of time before one could be fully restored and able to receive the Eucharist once again. (Ex: murder, adultery, etc.)

kensington

If that were true... then God would not have put "Killing" and "lying" in the same 10 commandments.   You speak of the early church....  they got off track from what Jesus taught pretty quickly didn't they.

chosenone

Quote from: Francis of Assisi on Sun Mar 15, 2009 - 12:32:21
Not only is it illogical to say that God views all sins equally, but this thesis is not what was believed by the Early Church.  The Early Church felt that certain sins were so serious, that they required some form of penance for a period of time before one could be fully restored and able to receive the Eucharist once again. (Ex: murder, adultery, etc.)

We hear a lot about the early church and what they did or didnt do but we are supposed to go by the bible . It sounds as kensington said that the early church must have quickly got off track, and added things that they were never meant to do. We should never follow something just becuase it has been done for many many years, but only what The Bible says.
The Bible gives no instructions for extra penances for certain sins or praying for the dead as far as I am aware. All we have to do is to be truly repentant, confess our sins to God and we are forgiven. Full stop.......................no penence required.

+-Recent Topics

American Socialism? by 4WD
Today at 11:38:36

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by pppp
Today at 11:12:21

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Today at 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Yesterday at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Yesterday at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Tue Nov 17, 2026 - 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

Powered by EzPortal