News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898080
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 1685
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 2
Guests: 1355
Total: 1357
Amo
Rella
Google

Catholic

Started by Basherbelding, Mon Nov 02, 2009 - 15:29:30

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

winsome

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 13:49:13
Quote from: winsome on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 13:19:30

Why do you think gross misreprentation of Catholicism is funny?


I do not know all of what "Saint banished" has said is a misreprentation, but it reminds me of many things I believed, and much of the bondage I was in as a Catholic. In my case, my wife could not be married within the altar unless I was a Catholic, and the list goes on.

Though I don't consider Catholics false brethren as in Galatians 2:4, but there are many that would deny our liberty which we have in Christ Jesus, that they might bring us into bondage.

If you believe "Saint banished" has misrepresented a religious organization, why don't you bring supporting evidence even if it is cannon law.


DesertKnight has done that in post #30

larry2

#36
Quote from: winsome on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 13:53:48
Quote from: larry2 on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 13:49:13
Quote from: winsome on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 13:19:30

Why do you think gross misrepresentation of Catholicism is funny?


I do not know all of what "Saint banished" has said is a misrepresentation, but it reminds me of many things I believed, and much of the bondage I was in as a Catholic. In my case, my wife could not be married within the altar unless I was a Catholic, and the list goes on.

Though I don't consider Catholics false brethren as in Galatians 2:4, but there are many that would deny our liberty which we have in Christ Jesus, that they might bring us into bondage.

If you believe "Saint banished" has misrepresented a religious organization, why don't you bring supporting evidence even if it is cannon law.


DesertKnight has done that in post #30


To me it seems desertknight substantiated much of what "Saint banished" said. The things he brought forth were not anything but heresay without backing it up by cannon law. It seems desertknight seemly attempted to justify their taking money. Another thing I might ask; why did it need changed?

I have just noticed I was on the Catholic Forum and do not mean any disrespect of your faith in God. I'm not sure if I came here on a notice or what, but I will back out of the thread at this time.

banished

Quote from: desertknight on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 13:05:34


Quote from: banishedAs I recall, the living in sin part was lifted recently, and now the marrage is simply  classified as "not recongnized" by the Catholic Chruch.  If my wife was to agree to getting  married again in the Catholic Church we would have to stop having sex for a peroid of time before receiving the Sacrament of Marriage. I assume that the new Canon Law says that we are not living in sin as long as we stay on the Protestant side.  However, I can't be in communion with the Catholic Church and sleep with a Protestant.  Believe this or not, the Church has Canon Lawyers (for a fee) and the everyone knows that the Bishop's 401K is supported by Radical Sanation (payola). We are talking about millions upon millions of Catholics who slipped up and married a Protestant.  Then there are countless divorsed Catholics who slipped up and got remarried with out the approval of the Church. The Bishop's 401K keeps building up, so why change it?
Banished, I have no idea what your "real" story is or where you have gotten this, but it is totally bogus.  I have been Catholic for decades and have known dozens of Catholic/Protestant, Catholic/Other faith, marriages and they are fairly simple to obtain permission for and totally accepted within the Church.  It's as common an occurrence as there is.  Any prohibition against such marriages was done completely away with long before I was born and do not apply to anyone living.  If you or your wife were legitimately married before than that can be a factor in your marriage now not being recognized, but to make claims that, "I can't be in communion with the Catholic Church and sleep with a Protestant." is utterly false.  I have no idea where you could come up with this bazaar information.  You can't be divorced from a legitimate marriage and re-marry within the Church, that is true.  You can obtain an annulment if that marriage was of questionable validity, and yes, it involves some legal research and that may require a fee.  It would in any civil procedure as well and they are not simply acting for the Church, but that it goes into the Bishops 401K is an outright lie.  Clergy retirement funds are very small and are handled in exactly the same fashion as any private sector fund is.  Each diocese, as required by canon law, must make public all salaries, funds, expenditures, etc, from the Bishop on down to the janitor, at least once a year.  They are readily available.  If you are Catholic than you remember that one week per year in every parish this is done and copies are handed out or made available to every parishioner detailing every penny spent.  It has been so in every parish that I have ever belonged to.  This is some good information on interfaith marriage within the Catholic Church...

http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q102.htm

Jimmy Akin is as good a source as you will find on this.
 


desertnight,

By you calling my story bogus you have pushed me over to the Protestant side with my argument.  You absolutely don't know what you are talking about, and are blindly defending something that is untrue.  I will add that I have been given the boot twice from the famous Catholic Answers Forum by, "Jean Anthony" for mentioning the bad treatment I am getting because of being married to a Protestant, and also given the boot from all 3 Yahoo Catholic Forums, and not allowed to join the Catholics on Line Forum.  Apparently, this is a sore spot with the Catholics and they would like to keep it swept under the rug. Remember, we are talking about million upon millions of legally married Catholics.

You were so anxious to defend the faith that you missed the fact the a Catholic must file for DISPENSATION papers from the Bishop before the marriage in order to have permission to marry a baptized non-Catholic.  There is a long list to terms and conditions that must be met after the marriage in the form of an oath.  Well, both my wife and I were Baptized and Confirmed Catholics in good standing when we decided to get married in a Born Again Protestant Church without DISPENSATION from the Bishop. That means that we are guilty on 2 counts, first for turning our backs on the Catholic Church by attending a Born Again Charismatic Church, and second for not getting DISPENSATION papers from the Bishop before getting married.

To add the frosting onto the cake, if I ever do go through the legal process with the Bishop and pay all fees, I have to get up in front of the whole Church and give a little speech about how wrong I was (22 years ago) when I turned my back on the Catholic Church, and how glad I am to be back in Communion with the Church.  Then of course, there is the fact that my wife is so mad that she will never go back to the Catholics, so I can't take the easier route and get married again in the Catholic Church.  I must get a Radical SANATION from the Bishop, and it would have to be a Bishop who was willing to risk causing a divorce and be willing to have me live in a Protestant marriage where my children are raised Protestant.  Not so easy! 

If memory serves me right it was during the mid 70's that the living in sin while married to a Protestant clause was lifted from Canon Law, and we are to have our children raised as Catholics.  We put my boy through a Protestant school and he is a Born Again Christian, as with both my wife and myself.


desertknight

#38
Quote from: larry2To me it seems desertknight substantiated much of what "Saint banished" said. The things he brought forth were not anything but heresay without backing it up by cannon law. It seems desertknight seemly attempted to justify their taking money. Another thing I might ask; why did it need changed?
And you got this from my post?   ???  Uhhh...no.  That is not what I said.  You cannot be excommunicated for having a Protestant wife.  You do not pay into the Bishop's 401k in order to obtain an annulment, assuming that is what banished is even refering to.  I have never heard of most of what he is referring to and know for certain that much of the doctrinal premises it is based on are totally false.  I posted a relevant link to back that up.  I would be happy to post others on request.  From what I am just guessing at from my reading of banished's confusing post and your misreading of it, I can say this.

1.  Catholic/Protestant or Catholic/ Other faith marriages are quite common and accepted by the Catholic Church.  One needs only write a short letter to the Bishop of your diocese in order to obtain it.  It is routine.

2.  If you have already been in a valid marriage to another person and have never received an annulment, then no, you cannot be married as a Catholic or have your marriage recognised within the Church as we follow the exact marriage formula as given to us in the NT and adhere to the truth that "what God has joined together, let no man set apart".  You, "for better or worse", become one.  If your previous marriage does have some basis for an annulment, then yes, you must actually pay a fee to process it.  So what?  It is similar to a civil procedure that may require and investigation of the parties claims, statements taken into evidence, application to the Ecclesiastical Tribunal, etc.  Lawyers do not come cheap, including canon ones.  When my knights order at my parish rents out our hall, we charge a few.  Just because something is associated with a "Church", doesn't mean that the bills don't come at the end of the month.  

3.   Follow the money?  If you want to know where each parish or diocese gets it's money and what they do with it...down to the penny, just ask.  The information, as I stated earlier, is required under Church law to be made available and is done so in every fiscal year during an "open the books" week in each parish.  It may differ from parish to parish, and each country's Bishops may implement the guidelines to meet local conditions, (For example, providing copies for each parishioner in an African village may not be practical.).  Catholic clergy receive very little pay, no matter what their rank, and have only a modest retirement.   If not under an actual "vow of poverty", they are still called to live very modest lives under some other similar vow and most earn only a small amount for personal goods and food which they share with other religious living with them.  Even if they live in a grand old parish or diocese house, they certainly don't own it.  That they must live there because they simply do not have the money for living elsewhere is a fact that will get you closer to the truth.  "Payolla' for a 401k?"  I can't wait to tell my parish priest that one.  He'll give me a good eye roll and head shake over that.

banished


desertknight,

I would like to remind you that both my wife and I are Baptized and Confirmed Catholics, and I would like to know under what authority do you pass judgement on other Confirmed Catholics?  As a lay person you are to keep buttoned-up!

desertknight

#40
Quote from: banishedWell, both my wife and I were Baptized and Confirmed Catholics in good standing when we decided to get married in a Born Again Protestant Church without DISPENSATION from the Bishop. That means that we are guilty on 2 counts, first for turning our backs on the Catholic Church by attending a Born Again Charismatic Church, and second for not getting DISPENSATION papers from the Bishop before getting married.
I am not passing judgement on you, but I am not going to let you post something as if it were Catholic doctrine when it clearly isn't.  winsome already corrected your assertion that being married to a Protestant without a dispensation was a "sin".  But I am utterly confused by your situation.  A "dispensation" is for an interfaith marriage, which you said that yours was, now you are saying that both you and your wife are baptised and confirmed Catholics.  Yes?  That you both started attending a "born again church" and now, if I understand you, you want to receive communion or somehow return to the Church?  Well, then make a good confession and do so.  That's it.  Whatever the status of your marriage, banished, you cannot be cut off from the sacraments unless you have been excommunicated for some grave disobedience, but what you described is not.  Marrying outside of the Church?  If that's all it takes...   ALL Catholics are sinners and if being one can cut you off from the Church and Christ's Body and Blood at Mass, then there would no longer be a Church.
Quote from: banishedI have to get up in front of the whole Church and give a little speech about how wrong I was (22 years ago) when I turned my back on the Catholic Church, and how glad I am to be back in Communion with the Church.

Oh my Gosh!  You can't be serious.  That is the most bazaar load of bull-puck I have ever heard in my life as a Catholic.  That beats anything I have ever heard from the anti-Catholics here.  Please, you are embarrassing yourself.  I guarantee if anyone here goes and asks any knowledgeable Catholic about this, they will laugh and wonder who in the heck told you something that odd.  Never heard of it in my life.  No Bishop or priest can force you to get up and talk about your personal sins or the state of your marriage in front of the congregation.  Horse-feathers.

Canon Law 983-1  "The sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent in words or in any manner and for any reason."

Quote from: banishedI must get a Radical SANATION from the Bishop, and it would have to be a Bishop who was willing to risk causing a divorce and be willing to have me live in a Protestant marriage where my children are raised Protestant.
Well, no, you can't if your wife does not wish it.  Do you know what it even is?  A 'radical sanation' is for when two Catholics were married outside of the Church and then wish to have that marriage 'convalidated' by her.  If your wife and children are practising Evangelical Protestants then it is not a punishment that you cannot have one, you simply don't qualify to receive one as your wife is no longer a practising Catholic and does not wish to be one.  You cannot have a 'Sanation' or have your marriage convalidated simply because you alone wish it.  It isn't the Church's fault, they simply can't force your wife to be a party to something that you have repeatedly stated that she does not believe in or wants to participate in.

banished

Quote from: desertknight on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 17:48:19
Quote from: banishedWell, both my wife and I were Baptized and Confirmed Catholics in good standing when we decided to get married in a Born Again Protestant Church without DISPENSATION from the Bishop. That means that we are guilty on 2 counts, first for turning our backs on the Catholic Church by attending a Born Again Charismatic Church, and second for not getting DISPENSATION papers from the Bishop before getting married.
I am not passing judgement on you, but I am not going to let you post something as if it were Catholic doctrine when it clearly isn't.  winsome already corrected your assertion that being married to a Protestant without a dispensation was a "sin".  But I am utterly confused by your situation.  A "dispensation" is for an interfaith marriage, which you said that yours was, now you are saying that both you and your wife are baptised and confirmed Catholics.  Yes?  That you both started attending a "born again church" and now, if I understand you, you want to receive communion or somehow return to the Church?  Well, then make a good confession and do so.  That's it.  Whatever the status of your marriage, banished, you cannot be cut off from the sacraments unless you have been excommunicated for some grave disobedience, but what you described is not.  Marrying outside of the Church?  If that's all it takes...   ALL Catholics are sinners and if being one can cut you off from the Church and Christ's Body and Blood at Mass, then there would no longer be a Church.
Quote from: banishedI have to get up in front of the whole Church and give a little speech about how wrong I was (22 years ago) when I turned my back on the Catholic Church, and how glad I am to be back in Communion with the Church.

Oh my Gosh!  You can't be serious.  That is the most bazaar load of bull-puck I have ever heard in my life as a Catholic.  That beats anything I have ever heard from the anti-Catholics here.  Please, you are embarrassing yourself.  I guarantee if anyone here goes and asks any knowledgeable Catholic about this, they will laugh and wonder who in the heck told you something that odd.  Never heard of it in my life.  No Bishop or priest can force you to get up and talk about your personal sins or the state of your marriage in front of the congregation.  Horse-feathers.

Canon Law 983-1  "The sacramental seal is inviolable; therefore it is absolutely forbidden for a confessor to betray in any way a penitent in words or in any manner and for any reason."

Quote from: banishedI must get a Radical SANATION from the Bishop, and it would have to be a Bishop who was willing to risk causing a divorce and be willing to have me live in a Protestant marriage where my children are raised Protestant.
Well, no, you can't if your wife does not wish it.  Do you know what it even is?  A 'radical sanation' is for when two Catholics were married outside of the Church and then wish to have that marriage 'convalidated' by her.  If your wife and children are practising Evangelical Protestants then it is not a punishment that you cannot have one, you simply don't qualify to receive one as your wife is no longer a practising Catholic and does not wish to be one.  You cannot have a 'Sanation' or have your marriage convalidated simply because you alone wish it.  It isn't the Church's fault, they simply can't force your wife to be a party to something that you have repeatedly stated that she does not believe in or wants to participate in.

desert knight,

Okay you are correct on #3.  I can't get a Sanaton if my wife is not willing to go along with it. That is exactly what I have been saying!

You are absolutely wrong-wrong-wrong on #2.  My first wife and I were remarried in the Catholic Church and went though the entire process (1974).  I am talking about actual experience of both my first wife and I getting up in front of the whole church to make our little speech. The deacon helped us prepare for it, and was a witness for one of the steps of the process.  Let me ask you, why is it that you pass judgment and are 100 percent wrong?

You are absolutely wrong-wrong-wrong again on #1.  As late as a couple of months ago I went into St Margaret Mary's in Oakland, California to confess my sins to a priest.  It was face to face with me on my knees inside the booth. I started my confession with the facts of my marriage and the priest stopped me and told me that he could not not Absolve my sins.

Let me ask you again, How you can make these rash judgment against another Catholic?  Plus, you are wrong 2 out of 3 times. What make you so high and mighty. Have you ever asked a few questions first before passing your judgements?


desertknight

#42
Quote from: banishedMy first wife and I were remarried in the Catholic Church and went though the entire process (1974).  I am talking about actual experience of both my first wife and I getting up in front of the whole church to make our little speech. The deacon helped us prepare for it, and was a witness for one of the steps of the process. Let me ask you, why is it that you pass judgment and are 100 percent wrong?
First, again, I am not passing judgement on you banished, I just don't want you to be stating that this or that is Catholic doctrine or practice when you have it wrong.  Second, I may not have the facts of what you are trying to express here correct and they are really none of my business, but because you opened the door on this yourself by posting them, I have to try to make heads or tails of what you are saying.  Now you are saying that you had a first wife?  I am unclear on this.  And she and you were also, both Catholic and yet, as with this wife, decided to marry outside of the Church?  If so, then you obtained a 'radical sanation' in order to have your Protestant marriage con-validated and then had a Catholic ceremony in which some public confession was required?  If that was the case then it would seem appropriate.  For one thing, some public explanation would seem appropriate in order to explain why two people who are married are getting...married.  Second, a pro-forma account in the manner of our "Confiteor" during Mass is to be expected, but that is not how you put it.  

Quote from: banishedAs late as a couple of months ago I went into St Margaret Mary's in Oakland, California to confess my sins to a priest.  It was face to face with me on my knees inside the booth. I started my confession with the facts of my marriage and the priest stopped me and told me that he could not not Absolve my sins.
I am uncomfortable in delving into what happened during your confession and so I will not go further into it, however, I will say that no priest is required to grant absolution if you have no intention to stop doing whatever sin it is that you are commiting.  Now I don't know what that is...and I don't want to.  However, if the wife you are with now is a second wife following a divorce, that could have some bearing on your confessional status, to say the least.   I apologise if I made incorrect comment earlier while not understanding your actual situation but you did not make it clear that you were once validly married within the Church once before, divorced, and now remarried, (If that is in fact the case.).   You presented your situation as if the problem was simply one of either marrying a Protestant, (Recieving an episcopal dispensation.), or one of two Catholics who became involved with a evangelical Protestant church, married within it, and then decided to return to the Catholic church.  Now, it seems from this last post that neither was the case.   

Quote from: banishedLet me ask you again, How you can make these rash judgment against another Catholic?  Plus, you are wrong 2 out of 3 times. What make you so high and mighty. Have you ever asked a few questions first before passing your judgements?

I try not to make "rash judgements", but I will comment on a public Christian message board when someone is out and out distorting or providing wrong information about the Catholic Church.  When you make some of the statements that you have made about, "Payola' into the Bishop's 401K" and "being married to a Protestant is a sin.", well then it just begs for correction.  I am far from "high and mighty".  I am a terrible sinner who is a hypocrite for coming across like I am some great Catholic Christian.  I am not.  I try to be faithful and stumble all the time, but that does not mean that I am going to "button up" when wrong things are being said about Holy Mother Church.

banished

desertknight-

I am widowed from my first wife and never have been divorced and neither was she.  My present wife (who never was married) and I did what many single Catholics have done.  We went on a date to a Christian Crusade at the the Convention Center.  A popular TV Evangelist who asked for an alter call at the end of the service for people to become Born Again.  Most of the people got up out of their seat and went to the front.  We all prayed the Sinner's Prayer and were given a tract. Then we formed small individual groups and prayed together.  My present wife and I were in love with each other and decided to get married with the Born Again people we were with.  They seemed to be so happy and full of Jesus that we didn't think about what might happen to us at our home church.  Canon Law ? ? Huh?     

desertknight

#44
Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 20:40:35
desertknight-

I am widowed from my first wife and never have been divorced and neither was she.  My present wife (who never was married) and I did what many single Catholics have done.  We went on a date to a Christian Crusade at the the Convention Center.  A popular TV Evangelist who asked for an alter call at the end of the service for people to become Born Again.  Most of the people got up out of their seat and went to the front.  We all prayed the Sinner's Prayer and were given a tract. Then we formed small individual groups and prayed together.  My present wife and I were in love with each other and decided to get married with the Born Again people we were with.  They seemed to be so happy and full of Jesus that we didn't think about what might happen to us at our home church.  Canon Law ? ? Huh?      

OK, I'll admit it.  You got me stumped.  I have never heard of a scenario like yours and am ignorant of specific Church doctrine as to what to say about it.  It's a new one on me.  It would seem to be more complicated than just one marriage outside the church, after you became a widower from the first one, that was conducted without proper dispensation, but maybe not.  It would also seem that your wife's refusal to participate in any convalidation, even though she would remain Protestant, adds to the conundrum.  St. Margaret Mary parish in Oakland is an excellent church with great and very orthodox priests so I would take heed as to what you were told in the confessional.  If you are living in a persistent state of sin without desire to make amends then it is the priest's duty to deny absolution and yours to pray and reflect on what to do about it.  I can only offer you a prayer, and I have done that.      

trifecta

Greetings banished!

Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 00:04:48

trifecta-

I agree with the Orthodox about Vatican II.

It's Vatican I that I have a problem with.

Quote
I don't know how they could justified going against the Creed of St Athanasius? "Whoever wishes to be saved must, above all, keep the Catholic faith. For unless a person keeps this faith whole and entire, he will undoubtedly be lost for ever."

You may have heard of the saying of St. Vincent of Lerins--the faith is "what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all".    The Creed of Saint Athanasius was a local affirmation that only curriculated in the West (I think Spain mainly.) and therefore, would not qualify under St. Vincent's criteria.  Firstly, it was not written by St. Athanasius (whom we love a lot), and secondly, it was not approved by any ecumenical council (I don't know if it was approved by a western council.) and therefore does not hold universal authority. Thirdly, it contains the filioque, and that we definitely reject.

banished

Quote from: trifecta on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 22:22:32
Greetings banished!

Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 00:04:48

trifecta-

I agree with the Orthodox about Vatican II.

It's Vatican I that I have a problem with.

Quote
I don't know how they could justified going against the Creed of St Athanasius? "Whoever wishes to be saved must, above all, keep the Catholic faith. For unless a person keeps this faith whole and entire, he will undoubtedly be lost for ever."

You may have heard of the saying of St. Vincent of Lerins--the faith is "what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all".    The Creed of Saint Athanasius was a local affirmation that only curriculated in the West (I think Spain mainly.) and therefore, would not qualify under St. Vincent's criteria.  Firstly, it was not written by St. Athanasius (whom we love a lot), and secondly, it was not approved by any ecumenical council (I don't know if it was approved by a western council.) and therefore does not hold universal authority. Thirdly, it contains the filioque, and that we definitely reject.


I live in California so I'm more tuned into the Spanish and Our Lady of Guadalupe, That is probably why St Athanasius comes to mind.  We used to say the Creed of St Athanasius on Trinity Sunday before Vatican II, but it was not included in the modern NO Mass.  St Athanasius went out the window with the Latin Mass, communion cloths, and communion rails. I always thought that St Athanasius was the Doctor of the church? I don't remember anything about St Vincent of Lerins.  Was he under the Church of Rome or the Eastern Church?

winsome

Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 23:06:19
Quote from: trifecta on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 22:22:32
Greetings banished!

Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 00:04:48

trifecta-

I agree with the Orthodox about Vatican II.

It's Vatican I that I have a problem with.

Quote
I don't know how they could justified going against the Creed of St Athanasius? "Whoever wishes to be saved must, above all, keep the Catholic faith. For unless a person keeps this faith whole and entire, he will undoubtedly be lost for ever."

You may have heard of the saying of St. Vincent of Lerins--the faith is "what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all".    The Creed of Saint Athanasius was a local affirmation that only curriculated in the West (I think Spain mainly.) and therefore, would not qualify under St. Vincent's criteria.  Firstly, it was not written by St. Athanasius (whom we love a lot), and secondly, it was not approved by any ecumenical council (I don't know if it was approved by a western council.) and therefore does not hold universal authority. Thirdly, it contains the filioque, and that we definitely reject.


I live in California so I'm more tuned into the Spanish and Our Lady of Guadalupe, That is probably why St Athanasius comes to mind.  We used to say the Creed of St Athanasius on Trinity Sunday before Vatican II, but it was not included in the modern NO Mass.  St Athanasius went out the window with the Latin Mass, communion cloths, and communion rails. I always thought that St Athanasius was the Doctor of the church? I don't remember anything about St Vincent of Lerins.  Was he under the Church of Rome or the Eastern Church?

St. Vincent Lerins lived in southern Gaul (now France) in the 5th century, well before the split between east and west.

He wrote this excellent piece about the development of dcotrine:

"Is there to be no development of Doctrine in Christ's Church? Certainly there should be great development.
Who could be so grudging towards his fellow-men and so hostile to God as to try to prevent it? But care should be taken to ensure that it is development of the faith and not alteration. Development implies that each point of doctrine is expanded within itself, while alteration suggests that a thing has been changed from what it was into something different..
It is desirable that development takes place..........But it must be growth within the framework of its own nature, that is to say it is development within the framework of the same dogma and of the same meaning.....
The limbs of infants are tiny, while those of young men are large, but they are the same limbs. The man has no more parts to his body than the little child...as a result it can be said that nothing new is produced in old men that was not already present in an undeveloped form when they were boys.....
But if the human form is changed into some shape that is not of its own kind, or at least if something is added or taken away from the full complement of its members, then the body must perish, or become a monster or at least be weakened in some way......So then, when something evolves from those first beginnings, as from seeds, it should now be received with joy and cultivated with care.

banished

Quote from: trifecta on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 22:22:32
Greetings banished!

Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 00:04:48

trifecta-

I agree with the Orthodox about Vatican II.

It's Vatican I that I have a problem with.

Quote
I don't know how they could justified going against the Creed of St Athanasius? "Whoever wishes to be saved must, above all, keep the Catholic faith. For unless a person keeps this faith whole and entire, he will undoubtedly be lost for ever."

You may have heard of the saying of St. Vincent of Lerins--the faith is "what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all".    The Creed of Saint Athanasius was a local affirmation that only curriculated in the West (I think Spain mainly.) and therefore, would not qualify under St. Vincent's criteria.  Firstly, it was not written by St. Athanasius (whom we love a lot), and secondly, it was not approved by any ecumenical council (I don't know if it was approved by a western council.) and therefore does not hold universal authority. Thirdly, it contains the filioque, and that we definitely reject.


I have been using the "Filioque" in my prayer life without realizing it until now.  I sometimes go direct to the Father and ask that the Holy Spirit have the freedom in me to bring forth his son Jesus.  When praying for a person who seems weak in his faith I have been using the "Filioque".  This the first time I came in contact with that word.  Wonder how I picked up that prayer habit? Why do Orthodox reject the filioque, becasue I can always change the way I pray.

Basherbelding

Quote from: desertknight on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 11:53:43
Yes, it makes a difference.

John 3:5  "Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God."

If you have been baptized under the sign of water through the power of the Holy Spirit in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, within any Christian tradition, that is sufficient.  It need not be Catholic.

What does this mean? Does this mean because i have been christened a Chatholic i cannot enter the Kingdom of God?

banished

Quote from: Basherbelding on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 10:09:45
Quote from: desertknight on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 11:53:43
Yes, it makes a difference.

John 3:5  "Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God."

If you have been baptized under the sign of water through the power of the Holy Spirit in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, within any Christian tradition, that is sufficient.  It need not be Catholic.

What does this mean? Does this mean because i have been christened a Chatholic i cannot enter the Kingdom of God?

I already explained that yesterday.  If you take John 3:16 out of text you will go into Heaven with the Protestants as Born Again, and if want to go with all of John 3 as Baptism then you will go in with the Catholics.  The choice is yours, but if you go with the Catholics it is a renewable process until the day you die.  If you are old enough to be on the Internet you are old enough to proceed with the Sacraments of the Catholic Church if you go that route.  As a Catholic you can't just sit there and do nothing and expect salvation, becasue you are not Born Again like the Protestants.  I think at this stage in your life you had better do what your parents tell you to do.

Basherbelding

When your said then you will go in with the Chatholics do you mean go into Heaven with them or go into Hell with them?

banished

Quote from: Basherbelding on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 14:48:09
When your said then you will go in with the Chatholics do you mean go into Heaven with them or go into Hell with them?

Someday we will all stand before Jesus Christ for his judgement.

mclees8

Quote from: desertknight on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 21:06:03
Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 20:40:35
desertknight-

I am widowed from my first wife and never have been divorced and neither was she.  My present wife (who never was married) and I did what many single Catholics have done.  We went on a date to a Christian Crusade at the the Convention Center.  A popular TV Evangelist who asked for an alter call at the end of the service for people to become Born Again.  Most of the people got up out of their seat and went to the front.  We all prayed the Sinner's Prayer and were given a tract. Then we formed small individual groups and prayed together.  My present wife and I were in love with each other and decided to get married with the Born Again people we were with.  They seemed to be so happy and full of Jesus that we didn't think about what might happen to us at our home church.  Canon Law ? ? Huh?      

OK, I'll admit it.  You got me stumped.  I have never heard of a scenario like yours and am ignorant of specific Church doctrine as to what to say about it.  It's a new one on me.  It would seem to be more complicated than just one marriage outside the church, after you became a widower from the first one, that was conducted without proper dispensation, but maybe not.  It would also seem that your wife's refusal to participate in any convalidation, even though she would remain Protestant, adds to the conundrum.  St. Margaret Mary parish in Oakland is an excellent church with great and very orthodox priests so I would take heed as to what you were told in the confessional.  If you are living in a persistent state of sin without desire to make amends then it is the priest's duty to deny absolution and yours to pray and reflect on what to do about it.  I can only offer you a prayer, and I have done that.      
[/quote

What is convalidation?

trifecta

#54
Quote from: banished on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 09:06:41


I have been using the "Filioque" in my prayer life without realizing it until now.  I sometimes go direct to the Father and ask that the Holy Spirit have the freedom in me to bring forth his son Jesus.

This doesn't sound so bad to me.   We can address any of the Trinity in our prayer life.  Their are Orthodox prayers directed towards all three.  

Quote
When praying for a person who seems weak in his faith I have been using the "Filioque".  This the first time I came in contact with that word.  Wonder how I picked up that prayer habit?

Must be from the west!  

Quote
Why do Orthodox reject the filioque, becasue I can always change the way I pray.

The problem with the filioque lies both in its theology and its history.   It comes from the Nicene Creed talking about the Holy Spirit.  The words were chosen very carefully from scripture.  (John 14:26)  Jesus says The Holy Spirit is sent from (proceeds from) the Father.   The Filioque is the phrase --and the son--which follows (in the Catholic Nicene Creed) "The Holy Spirit . . . who proceeds from the Father."   (I find it interesting that the Protestants go along with this Catholic change to the creed).  Theologically, the problem is that it puts the Father and Son above the Spirit, since they both have this power that the Holy Spirit can't do.  

The other problem with it is historical.  The original Nicene Creed did not include these three words.  In dealing with a heresy someone added the three words in the Creed.   Some popes outright rejected it, others said it was okay to do in local recitations of the creed, but the creed of the whole church should remain as the original version.  Eventually, the RCC decided that it was necessary and expelled the eastern church; this is the great schism.

Today, the Catholics feel less strongly about it, since their own eastern churches are allowed to delete the phrase from the Nicene Creed.   (Important sidebar: You have to wonder about a church that claims to be the Pillar and Ground of the Truth when the filioque is mandated in one time and place and is optional in another.  )

Confused yet?  

The eastern churches were not thrilled to be excommunicated but there was another problem.  When the Creed was created, it was at an ecumenical council, in, you guessed it, Nicea.  Such a change would need to be approved by the entire church as it is gathered in council (see Acts 17).
Rome unilaterally imposed the filioque and that just not how the church historically did it.

 

banished

Quote from: mclees8 on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 18:29:26
Quote from: desertknight on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 21:06:03
Quote from: banished on Tue Nov 03, 2009 - 20:40:35
desertknight-

I am widowed from my first wife and never have been divorced and neither was she.  My present wife (who never was married) and I did what many single Catholics have done.  We went on a date to a Christian Crusade at the the Convention Center.  A popular TV Evangelist who asked for an alter call at the end of the service for people to become Born Again.  Most of the people got up out of their seat and went to the front.  We all prayed the Sinner's Prayer and were given a tract. Then we formed small individual groups and prayed together.  My present wife and I were in love with each other and decided to get married with the Born Again people we were with.  They seemed to be so happy and full of Jesus that we didn't think about what might happen to us at our home church.  Canon Law ? ? Huh?      

OK, I'll admit it.  You got me stumped.  I have never heard of a scenario like yours and am ignorant of specific Church doctrine as to what to say about it.  It's a new one on me.  It would seem to be more complicated than just one marriage outside the church, after you became a widower from the first one, that was conducted without proper dispensation, but maybe not.  It would also seem that your wife's refusal to participate in any convalidation, even though she would remain Protestant, adds to the conundrum.  St. Margaret Mary parish in Oakland is an excellent church with great and very orthodox priests so I would take heed as to what you were told in the confessional.  If you are living in a persistent state of sin without desire to make amends then it is the priest's duty to deny absolution and yours to pray and reflect on what to do about it.  I can only offer you a prayer, and I have done that.      
[/quote

What is convalidation?

mclees8-

I could explain the legal process of convalidation, because my first wife and I went through it. It would be a waste of time.  You can take my word for it, the Catholic Priests and Bishops are not married, so they don't understand the process.  When it comes to the romanitic relationship between married couples they are heartless bastards, and don't have a clue.  All they know is Canon Law and how to hang you with it. I will never give up my Catholic Faith, but I don't like convalidation with a priest's finger in my marrage.

banished

mclees8-

I could explain the legal process of convalidation, because my first wife and I went through it. It would be a waste of time.  You can take my word for it, the Catholic Priests and Bishops are not married, so they don't understand the process.  When it comes to the romanitic relationship between married couples they are heartless bastards, and don't have a clue.  All they know is Canon Law and how to hang you with it. I will never give up my Catholic Faith, but I don't like convalidation with a priest's finger in my marrage.

desertknight

Quote from: McCleesWhat is convalidation?
It simply means Catholic Church recognition of a non-Catholic marriage.

banished

Quote from: trifecta on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 19:08:43
Quote from: banished on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 09:06:41


I have been using the "Filioque" in my prayer life without realizing it until now.  I sometimes go direct to the Father and ask that the Holy Spirit have the freedom in me to bring forth his son Jesus.

This doesn't sound so bad to me.   We can address any of the Trinity in our prayer life.  Their are Orthodox prayers directed towards all three.  

Quote
When praying for a person who seems weak in his faith I have been using the "Filioque".  This the first time I came in contact with that word.  Wonder how I picked up that prayer habit?

Must be from the west!  

Quote
Why do Orthodox reject the filioque, becasue I can always change the way I pray.

The problem with the filioque lies both in its theology and its history.   It comes from the Nicene Creed talking about the Holy Spirit.  The words were chosen very carefully from scripture.  (John 14:26)  Jesus says The Holy Spirit is sent from (proceeds from) the Father.   The Filioque is the phrase --and the son--which follows (in the Catholic Nicene Creed) "The Holy Spirit . . . who proceeds from the Father."   (I find it interesting that the Protestants go along with this Catholic change to the creed).  Theologically, the problem is that it puts the Father and Son above the Spirit, since they both have this power that the Holy Spirit can't do.  

The other problem with it is historical.  The original Nicene Creed did not include these three words.  In dealing with a heresy someone added the three words in the Creed.   Some popes outright rejected it, others said it was okay to do in local recitations of the creed, but the creed of the whole church should remain as the original version.  Eventually, the RCC decided that it was necessary and expelled the eastern church; this is the great schism.

Today, the Catholics feel less strongly about it, since their own eastern churches are allowed to delete the phrase from the Nicene Creed.   (Important sidebar: You have to wonder about a church that claims to be the Pillar and Ground of the Truth when the filioque is mandated in one time and place and is optional in another.  )

Confused yet?  

The eastern churches were not thrilled to be excommunicated but there was another problem.  When the Creed was created, it was at an ecumenical council, in, you guessed it, Nicea.  Such a change would need to be approved by the entire church as it is gathered in council (see Acts 17).
Rome unilaterally imposed the filioque and that just not how the church historically did it.

 


trifecta,


I did a Google search and found that as a Christmatic I pray as an Orthodox and not Catholic. The Western Church believes that the Holy Spirit came from both the Father and Son and Eastern Church the Holy Spirit to be only of the Father. I sometimes go direct to the Father and ask that the Holy Spirit have the freedom in me to bring forth his son Jesus. I never ask the Father and the Son to give the Holy Spirt the freedon in to minister through me. Maybe that's why my prayers have been so effective in the past?

Another thing that I found with this Google Search was that the dispute over the Nicene Creed known as the (filioque) was a key issue for the split of the Orthodox from the Catholics. I think it's interesting that as many times as I have prayed the Nicene Creed during Mass, it did not effect my prayer life as a Christmatic.  My anointed prayers are Orthodox.  Thanks, you really helped me.

winsome

Quote from: banished on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 23:30:42


trifecta,


I did a Google search and found that as a Christmatic I pray as an Orthodox and not Catholic. The Western Church believes that the Holy Spirit came from both the Father and Son and Eastern Church the Holy Spirit to be only of the Father. I sometimes go direct to the Father and ask that the Holy Spirit have the freedom in me to bring forth his son Jesus. I never ask the Father and the Son to give the Holy Spirt the freedon in to minister through me. Maybe that's why my prayers have been so effective in the past?

Banished,

As a Charismatic have you come across, or been involved with, Catholic Charismatic Renewal?


Quote from: banished on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 23:30:42
Another thing that I found with this Google Search was that the dispute over the Nicene Creed known as the (filioque) was a key issue for the split of the Orthodox from the Catholics. I think it's interesting that as many times as I have prayed the Nicene Creed during Mass, it did not effect my prayer life as a Christmatic.  My anointed prayers are Orthodox.  Thanks, you really helped me.


I suppose we all have our views on this but personally I don't think the filioque clause was the key issue as such. My understanding is that it was the way it was inserted that upset the Eastern Church more than the actual clause. It was about authority.

And the big spilt came several hundred years after the filioque dispute. I think the main dispute was over the authority of the Pope, plus when the split came there were big personality clashes and the whole dispute at that time was badly handled on both sides.

But that just my two pennyworth.  ::smile::


Basherbelding

Quote from: banished on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 15:32:35
Quote from: Basherbelding on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 14:48:09
When your said then you will go in with the Chatholics do you mean go into Heaven with them or go into Hell with them?

Someday we will all stand before Jesus Christ for his judgement.

What did you mean when you said that ''Then you will go in with the Chatholics' though?

banished

Quote from: Basherbelding on Thu Nov 05, 2009 - 10:02:41
Quote from: banished on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 15:32:35
Quote from: Basherbelding on Wed Nov 04, 2009 - 14:48:09
When your said then you will go in with the Chatholics do you mean go into Heaven with them or go into Hell with them?

Someday we will all stand before Jesus Christ for his judgement.

What did you mean when you said that ''Then you will go in with the Chatholics' though?

Basherbelding,

There are different forms of worship, and it's up to you to chose which form you are comfortable with. When you walk into a Catholic Church and the Shrine of the Virgin Mary is the most beautiful thing you have ever seen, and the Mass with its medieval art and music make you feel like no other church can, then you are called to be Catholic.  If on the other hand, the place reminds you of a funeral during the dark ages down in a dungeon, then that is not your calling.

If you go into a Protestant Church and the 2 hour long sermon causes you to fall asleep, and the theology sounds phony, then that's not your calling.  If every word that the minister says, captures your attention and penetrates your heart then you are under the anointing of that Pastor.

Basically, 1 John says that you need not that anyone should teach you, because the anointing that you received in the beginning teaches you all things.  The anointing abides and remains in you forever until Jesus comes. This anointing that I'm telling you about will guide you through your Christian walk.

Now remember, when St John said that you need not that anyone should teach you, he didn't mean the Bible or Church rituals and procedures.  He was talking about the anointing that all Christians have, but sometimes they don't listen to

Basherbelding

Okay, thanks. I'm going to start going to church and I'm going to a Roman Catholic church i think. Thank you for your long posts and be trying to and succeeding to help me.

Bikelite

Im  a catholic does this make me a Christian , you just answered  your question NO.

Bikelite

OK lets take it a step forword ... If you are a Catholic are you a Morman? AND IF NOT WHY NOT?

winsome

Quote from: Bikelite on Sat Nov 14, 2009 - 19:26:48
Im  a catholic does this make me a Christian , you just answered  your question NO.

If you are a Catholic you are a Christian. If you do not believe this then please explain why.

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by Amo
Today at 07:39:58

Creation scientists by Amo
Yesterday at 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Yesterday at 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Yesterday at 21:07:16

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Yesterday at 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Yesterday at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal