News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898081
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 2227
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1869
Total: 1869
Google (2)

Catholicism is wrong

Started by gothruchrist, Sun Jan 24, 2010 - 22:33:25

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Charles Sloan

#35
The problem with the idea that our scientific advances have rendered the details of the Bible obsolete is that Jesus was God in the flesh knowing everything about the universe that can be known. Jesus referred to Adam and Eve as real people, the creation as literal events. Jesus also recognized Noah and the flood as a real historical events, among numerous other references he made to the first 11 chapters of Genesis. Not to mention the dozens of references to Genesis made by the Apostles.

larry2


Please remember the forum rules when addressing someone else's Christian beliefs.

1.3 You will only post negative statements about another individual's belief or religious organization (including non-Christian religions) with objective evidence provided.

Members are allowed to say "The doctrines X church is false because of Y scriptures and Z other relevant evidence."

Thanks.

Charles Sloan


Ryan2010

I think the catholic position regarding the creation account is not so much that the point of genesis is that it is a story of HOW God made that which He made, but that genesis is a story about how the entire creation's relationship with God began.  The beginning of that relationship shows creation in communion with God and then narrates what happened to that communion.  The point isn't the material aspects (which can't be taken literally).  How God did what he did regarding creation takes a backseat to the fact that God recognized what He made and what He made was good.  

If we take something that is literally metaphor or allegory or something that is literal and make it allegory etc. then we'll miss the mark.  

I mean, it says that there was light before the creation of the stars, the sun, the moon....  If we read the prophets Christologically and understand that all the things written were pointing towards Christ, we see that the point of the light isn't that there was sunlight or starlight or moonlight before the creation of the moon, sun, stars but that, THAT light was The Light of men, the light of creation - Jesus Christ, the Son of God.  

If we know that a day is about the same amount of time it takes the earth to rotate before it gets back to the place where the sun first touched it at that point and we know that there were three "days" prior to the creation of the sun, moons and stars, how are we to understand "days"?  Do we count a single rotation as a biblical "day"?  Or is the point not about the material aspects so much as it alludes to the fact that there were three days of light and darkness prior to the creation of the sun, moon and stars?  The question to ask is not what does that say about the natural world as it relates to creation but what does that say about the Son of God?

::pondering::

If we see read that Adam and Eve are the first people on earth we are faced with having to try and make assumptions that the bible doesn't logically provide.  

The assumed narrative is as follows:

Adam and Eve are the first people on Earth.  Everyone else are their "children".  Adam and Eve eat the forbidden fruit, get booted out the garden lest they take from the tree of life and live forever.  God tells Eve that she'll deliver babies with a lot of pain.  She gives birth to her first baby boy.  His name is Cain.  She then gives birth to Abel.  Cain kills Abel and what happens next disrupts the logic of the narrative that we've built:

Genesis 4 --

10 The LORD said, "What have you done? Listen! Your brother's blood cries out to me from the ground. 11 Now you are under a curse and driven from the ground, which opened its mouth to receive your brother's blood from your hand. 12 When you work the ground, it will no longer yield its crops for you. You will be a restless wanderer on the earth."

13 Cain said to the LORD, "My punishment is more than I can bear. 14 Today you are driving me from the land, and I will be hidden from your presence; I will be a restless wanderer on the earth, and whoever finds me will kill me."

15 But the LORD said to him, "Not so [e] ; if anyone kills Cain, he will suffer vengeance seven times over." Then the LORD put a mark on Cain so that no one who found him would kill him. 16 So Cain went out from the LORD's presence and lived in the land of Nod, [f] east of Eden.

17 Cain lay with his wife, and she became pregnant and gave birth to Enoch. Cain was then building a city, and he named it after his son Enoch. 18 To Enoch was born Irad, and Irad was the father of Mehujael, and Mehujael was the father of Methushael, and Methushael was the father of Lamech.


Here we see a major problem.  If Cain and Abel are the first "kids" of Adam and Eve then why is Cain talking about other people?  What other people?  I mean, if he's banished from God's presence then according to our logic based on what we believe is literal, then there are no other people.  We're forced to come up with an interpretation that the text doesn't offer which could distort what the narrative is really saying.  

You'll notice in verse 17 we see that Cain takes a wife..  Now, are we supposed to infer that this is his sister?  Why is she living in a place that is banished from God's presence?

The other interesting thing is that we don't believe that Adam and Eve had kids while in the garden of Eden.  We of course could assume this but again we have to go further than the texts actually say.  

I could for instance argue that Eve did have babies in the garden and had children prior to the expulsion from the garden.  I could use the following verse to support my interpretation.

Genesis 3:16
To the woman he said, "I will greatly increase your pains in childbearing; with pain you will give birth to children. Your desire will be for your husband, and he will rule over you."

I could say that how do you increase something you never knew?  I mean, if I said, I will increase your load then that means that you were already carrying something.  I could* say that Eve must have had babies before and here God is telling her that instead of the ease with which she was accustomed to giving birth, she must now endure "increased" childbearing pains...

So which interpretation is literal?  

I could also then using the same argument to say that all of humanity was created on the 6th day and Adam is actually created on the 8th day in order to point toward Christ as being the 2nd Adam, having been raised on the 8th day, the day of the beginning of the creation of the New! Heavens and New! Earth...  

but I don't have any authority to make such an assumption.  I don't have the scriptures full support of this just as the opposite view doesn't have full support.  I'm just bridging gaps to make it seem logical or perhaps I'm dead on Glory to Christ, but I really can't say that Genesis is a literal account of how God made creation because my understanding of light, days, humanity and even the numbers so prevalent in Genesis are written in God's language and what seems right to me, a mere man, are totally different.  

All I do know is that Jesus said the Old Testament prophets were merely a shadow of that which he casts.  He is the One that casts his shadow onto the Old Testament.  The Old Testament isn't a science manual but something that points to Christ.  

Luke 24

25He said to them, "How foolish you are, and how slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken! 26Did not the Christ have to suffer these things and then enter his glory?" 27And beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, he explained to them what was said in all the Scriptures concerning himself.


28As they approached the village to which they were going, Jesus acted as if he were going farther. 29But they urged him strongly, "Stay with us, for it is nearly evening; the day is almost over." So he went in to stay with them.

30When he was at the table with them, he took bread, gave thanks, broke it and began to give it to them. 31Then their eyes were opened and they recognized him, and he disappeared from their sight. 32They asked each other, "Were not our hearts burning within us while he talked with us on the road and opened the Scriptures to us?"

Looks here like the Apostles literally couldn't recognize Christ until they received that which Jesus broke.  Looks here like the Apostles literally couldn't see even after Jesus (whom they were blind to) explained the Old Testament prophets to them concerning him.  But after he broke bread, they literally recognize the One whom they longed to see, even longed to see in the passages of the Old Testament.  







Christ is risen











sharonb

I think the most important fact here is...whether you believe the stories literally or figuratively, makes no difference. It does give us fun little debates, but is not at all relative to salvation. Love God above all others and love each other....that is the greatest commandment!!!!!
I LOVE YOU GUYS!!!! ::announcment::

Rob, PGK

Quote from: sharonb on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 13:33:22
I think the most important fact here is...whether you believe the stories literally or figuratively, makes no difference. It does give us fun little debates, but is not at all relative to salvation. Love God above all others and love each other....that is the greatest commandment!!!!!
I LOVE YOU GUYS!!!! ::announcment::

Yeah, but can you show me in the bible where it says you can use smiley faces with bullhorns? I don't think you can. Sinner. ::wink::

gothruchrist

Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:26:11
Quote from: gothruchrist on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:12:24
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 08:56:07
As to the original post-

All other denominations split from the Catholic Church and base their teachings off of books compiled and tradition accepted by Catholics. (Let's not get into the Schism at this point, suffice it to say, the Orthodox do not belong in this category) So by your very own statement, does that not just make your Church a watered down version of the lie perpetrated by Satan?



this is false, they are not derived from the catholic church, the real christian church was just diminished by the catholic, but it came back through luther

You, sir, need to check your history. Luther was a Catholic monk turned priest. He left Church because he was upset at few things, the most of which was the idea that someone could "buy their forgiveness" through indulgences. Indulgences are set monetary penalty, paid to the Church, for certain offenses. This practice is no longer used and was never the official policy of the Catholic Church.

The original Churches, the ones that were writing letters back and forth, some of which make up most of the New Testament, were: The Roman Catholic Church, The Orthodox Churches in Ethiopia, Constantinople, Jerusalem, and Alexandria. These Churches had territories that Bishops oversaw all Churches within their boundaries. The Othodox and the Roman Catholics split over theological differences, but still regard each other as the original Church.

i understand that, but he saw the truth, and from that he split fro the catholic church, iam a bible-believing baptist christian, and i know that Luther was at first catholic, but he found out the truth and went further from there

gothruchrist

Quote from: Eagle on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:39:03
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Sun Jan 24, 2010 - 23:19:27
Quote from: gothruchrist on Sun Jan 24, 2010 - 23:13:29
Exodus 20:4-5

and nowhere in the bible does it say that you should worship or pray to mary so its false, oh, and im not scared of you catholics because i love and serve the true
god, not the false mary

There is no need to be scared of us Catholics. We aren't going to be coming after you with pitchforks and torches. You have your beliefs, we have ours. One of our beliefs is grammar and punctuation. I know, I know, it's not in the Bible, but it's still so much more fun to make sense to others that you are trying to communicate with.

If we do come after you, it will be with an elementary school grammar teacher. Man, will you be in for it.

yes, we are talking about God and eternity here, what should grammar and punctuation even be doing here in comparison


NOT FAIR!!  NOT FAIR!! leave grammer and punctuation out of it!!!!

gothruchrist

For everyone in this discussion i want to say one thing, jesus is the ONLY way to god and if you do not believe that and that jesus is the mediator between man and god, then you cannot call yourself a follower of christ, read the four gospels and you will uinderstand

chosenone

Jesus is the only mediator between us and God and He is also the head of His church, not the pope.That is what the Bible says.

Rob, PGK

Quote from: gothruchrist on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 13:55:01
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:26:11
Quote from: gothruchrist on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:12:24
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 08:56:07
As to the original post-

All other denominations split from the Catholic Church and base their teachings off of books compiled and tradition accepted by Catholics. (Let's not get into the Schism at this point, suffice it to say, the Orthodox do not belong in this category) So by your very own statement, does that not just make your Church a watered down version of the lie perpetrated by Satan?



this is false, they are not derived from the catholic church, the real christian church was just diminished by the catholic, but it came back through luther

You, sir, need to check your history. Luther was a Catholic monk turned priest. He left Church because he was upset at few things, the most of which was the idea that someone could "buy their forgiveness" through indulgences. Indulgences are set monetary penalty, paid to the Church, for certain offenses. This practice is no longer used and was never the official policy of the Catholic Church.

The original Churches, the ones that were writing letters back and forth, some of which make up most of the New Testament, were: The Roman Catholic Church, The Orthodox Churches in Ethiopia, Constantinople, Jerusalem, and Alexandria. These Churches had territories that Bishops oversaw all Churches within their boundaries. The Othodox and the Roman Catholics split over theological differences, but still regard each other as the original Church.

i understand that, but he saw the truth, and from that he split fro the catholic church, iam a bible-believing baptist christian, and i know that Luther was at first catholic, but he found out the truth and went further from there

Ah yes, the Southern Baptist. Things make more sense now. I was actually baptized Southern Baptist. Good people. Every one of them that I know, and I live in Oklahoma so I know a lot of them. God bless you, gothruchrist, and thank you for your concern.

Please understand that your unfounded vitriol toward Catholicism is based on ignorance of the faith. Don't listen to your leaders, don't listen to me, go find out for yourself. You will find that while you may not agree with all that we do, the reasons behind it are not nearly as sinister as others will have you believe.  

Rob, PGK

Quote from: gothruchrist on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 13:57:17
Quote from: Eagle on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:39:03
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Sun Jan 24, 2010 - 23:19:27
Quote from: gothruchrist on Sun Jan 24, 2010 - 23:13:29
Exodus 20:4-5

and nowhere in the bible does it say that you should worship or pray to mary so its false, oh, and im not scared of you catholics because i love and serve the true
god, not the false mary

There is no need to be scared of us Catholics. We aren't going to be coming after you with pitchforks and torches. You have your beliefs, we have ours. One of our beliefs is grammar and punctuation. I know, I know, it's not in the Bible, but it's still so much more fun to make sense to others that you are trying to communicate with.

If we do come after you, it will be with an elementary school grammar teacher. Man, will you be in for it.

yes, we are talking about God and eternity here, what should grammar and punctuation even be doing here in comparison


NOT FAIR!!  NOT FAIR!! leave grammer and punctuation out of it!!!!

The reason that grammar and punctuation are important is because we are discussing very weighty issues. There should be no room for others to misinterpret what we are trying to say. You are correct when you say that we are talking about God and eternity here. That exact reason is why grammar and punctuation is so important.

mclees8

Quote from: Ryan2010 on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:20:32
Firstly, let me welcome you to the forum gothruchrist.  Know that you are loved and will even be blessed by catholics because Our Lord commanded that we love those that don't love us and that we should bless those that curse us.  Also know that we will try our best to be gentle, respectful, kind, humble and above all extend to you the same love that has been extended to us by Our generous, merciful, patient, longsuffering God, who is Love Himself.  Why? - because this is what Our Lord has commanded us to do when we deal with anyone we come into contact with, whether they are a brother in Christ or even an enemy of him.  It's a commandment.  Commandments are to be followed.  

To address your comments:

Quote
"Catholicism is a heretical lie derived by satan to mislead the church of Christ

gothruchrist

Quote from: chosenone on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 14:05:12
Jesus is the only mediator between us and God and He is also the head of His church, not the pope.That is what the Bible says.

that is correct, jesus is the only mediator nothing and none can change that

Ryan2010

QuoteWow that was quite a post. I gave up on it toward the end. You had some good points and i agree with much you say . How ever you might try to shorten  you response  a little. People tend to not read things more than a page.

Yeah, I find that there just aren't any short answers to things this weighty.  I always feel like I've left out a ton of stuff.  I hate that our culture is so used to soundbites and one liners and rhetorical slogans.  But that's the culture we live in.  Thanks for reading as much as you did.  You've made it further than most.  lol. 


QuoteI agree in part with the other poster that the church was diminished by Roman Catholism. More than that they re-invented it  

I posted a thread called, Myths of the council of Nicaea that addresses those theories.  They are short videos and if you can make it through them they'll offer some food for thought (at the very least).

QuoteYou say we must have an authority figure such as  the pope to settle doctrinal issues. But what if he has doctrinal issues also. This thing is on both sides of the river.

Well, I agree.  I'm not a Roman Catholic.  I don't believe that individuals are allowed to interpret scripture.  I think that sound doctrine comes out of, not an individual as myself or any other person, but out of The Church.  I go to an Eastern Orthodox Church. 

QuoteYou chose to believe the RCC just because it has a central authority figure.

Well, I realized that authority is a very very important issue and puts things into context.  When Jesus said to take disputes to The Church and if that person in the wrong rejects The Church's correction then they are to be treated like a pagan or a tax collector.    !!!!

This is part of the reason that I'm an inquirer at the Orthodox Church.  They believe that the authority doesn't rest soley on an individual or an "office" but in the entire body - The Church. 

Quote
Do you condemn all protestants because they are divided. I would not condemn all Catholics because they are Catholics.  

I don't condemn any protestants.  The Orthodox perspective is that Salvation belongs to the Lord.  We can't say who will be saved or not saved in the end.  That even goes for Orthodox.  Just because you go to an Orthodox Church doesn't mean you're saved...  Judgment is out of my jurisdiction.  God will save who He saves.  I just don't presume to know who those people are. 

Quote
In the beginning only one church was founded, and it was neither Roman Catholic, or Protestant. They were one faith in Christ and that is how the Lord sees his church today.

I would encourage you to read David Bentley Hart's book titled, "Story of Christianity: An Illustrated History of 2000 Years of the Christian Faith". 

It's really neat to study the early early Christians then try and trace them throughout history and notice all the groups that break off and which individuals led which group into the thousands of groups we have now. 

It's a purty neat book because unlike most histories it actually doesn't ignore the Eastern Christians.  Most histories deal primarily with Rome and then only as a means to get to protestantism or as a means to show corruption.  But much of the history concerning the East is unknown to the Western World.

QuoteHe has no pet denominations protestant or Catholic.  

Yeah, I kind of get what your saying but I do believe that Jesus built a Church and there is a community of Christians that has complete continuity with those early Christians who were ordained by the Apostles. 

I'll leave research up to you.  But I wouldn't try to read books written by people of primarily one tradition because you'll get a lot of agenda biased revisionist junkerolla (that's so not a word but conveys the meaning purty good). 


God bless

sharonb

Actually, if you get right down to it, we should all probably be Ethiopian orthodox. Because of their remote location they had very few problems with people coming in with different viewpoints after it was initially set up. Plus they claim to have the ark of the covenant. HHHMMMMM!! ::pondering::

zoonance

church history is fascinating.  I suspect it finds itself interpreted differently depending on the eyes of the beholder.

mclees8

Quote from: sharonb on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 15:51:46
Actually, if you get right down to it, we should all probably be Ethiopian orthodox. Because of their remote location they had very few problems with people coming in with different viewpoints after it was initially set up. Plus they claim to have the ark of the covenant. HHHMMMMM!! ::pondering::

rofl

Ryan2010

Quote from: sharonb on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 15:51:46
Actually, if you get right down to it, we should all probably be Ethiopian orthodox. Because of their remote location they had very few problems with people coming in with different viewpoints after it was initially set up. Plus they claim to have the ark of the covenant. HHHMMMMM!! ::pondering::

I looked into the Ethiopian Orthodox but they come out of the Coptics (but they're in communion with the Coptics) but for me I just can't reconcile monophysitism though that charge was probably more political than anything else.  Hope the Coptics and Orthodox will be in communion in my lifetime.  No reason why they can't be.  Rome on the other hand looks like a very far off adventure.  Still looking forward to that too.  

But yeah.  I like them Ethiopian Orthodox. They have the largest canon of all Christian groups.  Enoch etc.  I think St. Thomas has some apostolicity in the Oriental Orthodox.  But can't remember off hand.  

From Wiki (yeah yeah, but it'll give you a general understanding):

Monophysitism (from the Greek monos meaning 'one, alone' and physis meaning 'nature'), or Monophysiticism, is the Christological position that Christ has only one nature, his humanity being absorbed by his Deity, as opposed to the Chalcedonian position which holds that Christ maintains two natures, one divine and one human.

Monophysitism and its antithesis, Nestorianism, were both hotly disputed and divisive competing tenets in the maturing Christian traditions during the first half of the fifth century; during the tumultuous last decades of the Western Empire, and marked by the political shift in all things to a center of gravity then located in the Eastern Roman empire, and particularly in Syria, the Levant, and Anatolia, where Monophysitism was popular among the people.

There are two major doctrines that can indisputably be called Monophysite (pronounced /məˈnɒfɨsaɪt/):

   * Eutychianism holds that the human and divine natures of Christ were fused into one new single (mono) nature: His human nature was "dissolved like a drop of honey in the sea".
   * Apollinarism or Apollinarianism holds that Christ had a human body and human "living principle" but that the Divine Logos had taken the place of the nous, or "thinking principle", analogous but not identical to what might be called a mind in the present day.

After Nestorianism, taught by Nestorius, Archbishop of Constantinople, was rejected at the First Council of Ephesus, Eutyches, an archimandrite at Constantinople, emerged with diametrically opposite views. Eutyches' energy and imprudence with which he asserted his opinions brought him the accusation of heresy in 448, leading to his excommunication. In 449, at the controversial Second Council of Ephesus Eutyches was reinstated and his chief opponents Eusebius, Domnus and Flavian, deposed. Monophysitism and Eutyches were again rejected at the Council of Chalcedon in 451.

Monophysitism's theological point of view is also rejected by the Oriental Orthodox Churches, but was widely accepted in Syria, Egypt and the Levant, leading to many tensions in the Coptic period of the Byzantine Empire.

Later, Monothelitism was developed as an attempt to bridge the gap between the Monophysite and the Chalcedonian position, but it too was rejected by the members of the Chalcedonian synod, despite at times having the support of the Byzantine emperors and once escaping the condemnation of a Pope of Rome, Honorius I. Some are of the opinion that Monothelitism was at one time held by the Maronites, but the Maronite community, for the most part, dispute this, stating that they have never been out of communion with the Catholic Church.

Miaphysitism, the christology of the Oriental Orthodox churches, was historically considered by the Chalcedonian churches as a variant of Monophysitism, but these churches view their theology as distinct from Monophysitism and anathematize Eutyches.





God bless

mclees8

Quote from: zoonance on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 16:34:19
church history is fascinating.  I suspect it finds itself interpreted differently depending on the eyes of the beholder.

That's so true but if you use a little God given common sense you can purty much get to the root of it. 

Rob, PGK

Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 16:47:03
Quote from: zoonance on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 16:34:19
church history is fascinating.  I suspect it finds itself interpreted differently depending on the eyes of the beholder.

That's so true but if you use a little God given common sense you can purty much get to the root of it. 

One of the things that I have learned in my short 36 years on this planet is that God was pretty stingy when he was handing out common sense.

Read through some of the threads all over this site, examples of this truth abound.

desertknight

Quote from: Ryan2010 on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 16:41:14
I looked into the Ethiopian Orthodox but they come out of the Coptics (but they're in communion with the Coptics) but for me I just can't reconcile monophysitism though that charge was probably more political than anything else.

That would be correct.  It is rejected by the Ethiopian Orthodox and on examination, has no real basis in fact.  It might be more appropriate to call them "Miaphysite", one, united nature.  The Ethiopians are actually, along with most Oriental Orthodox, in what both sides call partial communion with Rome.  I worshiped at an Ethiopian church while I lived for a year in Oakland, CA, with the permission of the local priest there and the permission of the Catholic Diocese of Oakland, and it was a wonderful experience.  Their parish was right next to my apartment.   Here is a link describing their official doctrine of the trinity...

http://www.ethiopianorthodox.org/english/dogma/monodyo.html

http://www.ethiopianorthodox.org/english/dogma/faith.html#trinity


Eagle


mclees8

Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 17:00:07
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 16:47:03
Quote from: zoonance on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 16:34:19
church history is fascinating.  I suspect it finds itself interpreted differently depending on the eyes of the beholder.

That's so true but if you use a little God given common sense you can purty much get to the root of it. 


One of the things that I have learned in my short 36 years on this planet is that God was pretty stingy when he was handing out common sense.

Read through some of the threads all over this site, examples of this truth abound.

Stingy may not be the right word for it. I don't think God was stingy but the unwillingness of the sheep to test for truth and see. Its a man problem.  ::shrug::

gothruchrist

Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 14:10:25
Quote from: gothruchrist on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 13:55:01
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:26:11
Quote from: gothruchrist on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 10:12:24
Quote from: Rob, PGK on Mon Jan 25, 2010 - 08:56:07
As to the original post-

All other denominations split from the Catholic Church and base their teachings off of books compiled and tradition accepted by Catholics. (Let's not get into the Schism at this point, suffice it to say, the Orthodox do not belong in this category) So by your very own statement, does that not just make your Church a watered down version of the lie perpetrated by Satan?



this is false, they are not derived from the catholic church, the real christian church was just diminished by the catholic, but it came back through luther



You, sir, need to check your history. Luther was a Catholic monk turned priest. He left Church because he was upset at few things, the most of which was the idea that someone could "buy their forgiveness" through indulgences. Indulgences are set monetary penalty, paid to the Church, for certain offenses. This practice is no longer used and was never the official policy of the Catholic



Church.

The original Churches, the ones that were writing letters back and forth, some of which make up most of the New Testament, were: The Roman Catholic Church, The Orthodox Churches in Ethiopia, Constantinople, Jerusalem, and Alexandria. These Churches had territories that Bishops oversaw all Churches within their boundaries. The Othodox and the Roman Catholics split over theological differences, but still regard each other as the original Church.

i understand that, but he saw the truth, and from that he split fro the catholic church, iam a bible-believing baptist christian, and i know that Luther was at first catholic, but he found out the truth and went further from there

Ah yes, the Southern Baptist. Things make more sense now. I was actually baptized Southern Baptist. Good people. Every one of them that I know, and I live in Oklahoma so I know a lot of them. God bless you, gothruchrist, and thank you for your concern.


Please understand that your unfounded vitriol toward Catholicism is based on ignorance of the faith. Don't listen to your leaders, don't listen to me, go find out for yourself. You will find that while you may not agree with all that we do, the reasons behind it are not nearly as sinister as others will have you believe.  


First of thank u for the kind language, second iam not southern naptist ia
m northern baptist, and i have searched through the bible and through history and found that catholicism has a much more sinister rootthan we would even believe today, thats why iam trying to help the mislead and bring them to the true jesus christ and the true faith

Ryan2010

QuoteFirst of thank u for the kind language, second iam not southern naptist ia
m northern baptist, and i have searched through the bible and through history and found that catholicism has a much more sinister rootthan we would even believe today, thats why iam trying to help the mislead and bring them to the true jesus christ and the true faith

Do the Baptists have the true Jesus and the true faith?  I think the best way you can help explain why the Baptists have the true Jesus and the true faith in contradiction to the catholic faith would be answer the following questions.   

What's the history of the baptist Church? 

When were they founded? 

When did people start calling themselves Baptists and why? 

What region of the world did these people that started calling themselves Baptists come from? 

How many sub-denominations of Baptists are there? 

Why do some Baptists speak in tongues and others not? 

Where do the Baptists come from? Were they called something else before they called themselves Baptists?

Would the Baptists of the past recognize today's Baptists? 

Do you know much about the Church of England or the Puritans?   

Would a person that was a separatist or a Puritan feel at home at a Baptist Church or just some of the Baptist Churches? 

Is John Smyth considered a Saint? 

Why should we take John Smyth's word over all of the early Church Fathers of the first ten centuries? 

How much of John Calvin's interpretation effects what Baptists believe?  Why did the Baptist seem to agree with some of what John Calvin was saying and disagreed with other parts?  Who decides on what to agree with and what to disagree with? 

How did the focus on immersion Baptism come about by the Baptists?  Was it based on word studies or were there individuals behind the movement that led to the formation of the Baptists?

Why do some Baptists believe that there is an actual genealogical lineage of the Apostles?  Like, a blood line?  What is the trail of blood that some Baptists talk about?

What are the Baptist dogmas?  What do I have to believe without a doubt in order to be a Baptist?  What do I have to refute in order to become a Baptist?  Who decided these dogmas and when did that come about and what were the circumstances surrounding those decisions? 

Are Roger Williams and John Clark considered Apostles?

Why do Baptists view the Eucharist (communion) and Baptism as symbols?  Why do they view sacraments as symbols? 

How do they view those symbolic sacraments as ordinances?  Is the symbol just as important as the thing being symbolized?  If not then you could change the symbol, right?  Like, instead of bread and wine for baptism, you could just cheez-its and soda and it would still be a valid Eucharist? 

Does the same go for the symbolic water?  If the water is only a symbol for the washing away of sins and a symbol for death and burial in Christ then why doesn't it work if this symbol is only sprinkled on?  Why does it have to be water at all if it is just a symbol? 

Do Baptists only recognize two sacraments?  Why isn't marriage a sacrament?  If there are only ordinances then what is the difference between an ordinance and a sacrament?  Are ordinances holy?  Or do they not relate to your salvation?  If ordinances do have to do with salvation why the emphasis on ordinances?  What purpose do they serve then?

Who gets to decide what is heretical and what isn't?  If one Baptist Church speaks in tongues and the other one doesn't and the one that doesn't believe that speaking in tongues is right who decides between the two of them so that they won't split?  In short, how does the structure of the government in the Baptist faith preserve unity?

Does a Baptist person believe that they have to go to church in order to be saved?  If not why do they put so much focus on Baptism if Baptism is just a symbol for the community - a coming out party to say you're a member of the Baptist Church?

Why do some Baptists accept membership based on a declaration of faith even if they haven't been Baptized?  What's the declaration say?  Who wrote it?  Who authorized it?  Can I write my own declaration of faith or do I have to submit to the particular Baptist's declaration of choice?

Why do the Baptists have so many conflicting teachings on the rapture?  Do you have to believe in the rapture to become a Baptist? 

Baptists reject the Priesthood but have Elders that they submit to.  Is this not the same thing? 

Why do Baptists have a smaller Old Testament Canon and why is that canon so young?  Did the early Christians and Apostles have the same canon? 

Why is there an altar call in a lot of Baptist Churches but they don't have an altar.  Why do they call it an altar call if there's no altar?  There's a pulpit and sometimes a podium but no altar.  Why?

Why is there such a strong belief of KJV only in the Baptist Churches?  What is it about the King James that makes it so special for Baptists especially?  If there are Baptists in other countries that don't speak English how do those Baptists view them? 

Being sola scriptura can be hard.  The Northern Baptists interpreted the bible to say that slavery was wrong and forbid slave owners from becoming missionaries.  When this happened, there was a Baptist split and the Southern Baptists were formed.  They believed that the bible said slavery was okay for a Christian. 

Why did the white baptists and black baptists seem to go their separate ways in both the North and the South?  Were cultural ties overriding the fact that we are all citizens of heaven or was it harder for the minority group to have a voice in the predominantly white Baptist Churches? 

Are there Baptist martyrs?  Baptists that died for the faith?  Is there a total number of Baptist martyrs?  Do Baptists remember or honor their heroes? 

If Baptist have the true Jesus and are the true faith does that apply to all sub-denominations of Baptists at all times everywhere or could I become a pentecostal or join the oneness movement or become a member of any of the Lutheran or Presbyterian or Episcopalian churches and still have the true Jesus and true faith just so long as I didn't go to a catholic church? 

What are seventh day Baptists?  Are those Baptists that go to Church on Saturday in order to keep what they understand as the Sabbath laws? 

What kind of Baptist Church did the founder of the Jehovah's Witnesses attend before he founded the Jehovah's Witnesses?  What about the Baptist teaching caused him to leave the Baptist church? 

John Smyth is often credited as the founder of the Baptists by historians.  John Smyth used to be an Anglican.  Can we find traces of Anglicanism in the Baptist teachings? 

What is a separatist?  Separatist from what? 

Smyth taught that true worship is from the heart and that any form of reading from a book in worship was an invention of sinful man.  Is that the same reason why a lot of Baptist Churches have a lot of strict rules about what you can and can't do in church worship?  Can you explain how that is not a Pharisee-esque position?  Who is John Smyth to say what is an "invention of sinful man" and not? 

If Baptists only believe in the Priesthood of all believers then why did Smyth get to rule on matters of worship style above others that disagreed with him?  Where in the bible does this come from?  What authority does he have to make such distinctions between what is an invention of sinful man or honest worship?  Does Smyth know our hearts? 

Why do the Baptists follow Smyth's traditions?  Are these not traditions of men?



John Smyth






God bless











jessie70

I have been having these same discussions, if not using the exact same questions.....
but theres are big reasons, why this makes no reasonable sense to us....

1.its not in scripture word for word what they say ....thus not backing up the belief they have.
2.they are not in a belief where they believe in the scriptures only.
3.they are in a belief that other people,other than whats in scripture, told them is ok and true.

they do not claim to believe in the scriptures, word for word, with what they teach and say.
they don't claim to be saved by the sole word of the scriptures(or they wouldn't call their priest father..as we know it says in the Bible to call "NOONE" father except our father in heaven.

also theres no proof in scripture, or anywhere, that Mary went through judgement and made it to heaven. theres also nowhere in scripture, saying that Mary is even in heaven( if so ...show it  WORD FOR WORD.

so if we are having a discussion with people that aren't living the word, in the BIBLE, and we absolutely know that it cant be made right, by the Bibles words, then its called false doctrine and false teaching and the Bible tells of it. 

I suggest to just leave it alone, because even Christ didn't try and bring Satan back to the faith because it was futile and useless......just like this false doctrine that's not in the scriptures...WORD FOR WORD  is useless and futile.

marie69

As Christians, we are called to love one another. I am a cradle Catholic. I do not believe that only Catholics will go to Heaven. My grandmother was a born and bred southern Baptist. She did not believe that only Baptists would go to Heaven. The foundation for all of us is that Jesus Christ died on the cross for our sins so that one day, we would be able to spend eternity in our Father's house.
The topic of this discussion started out on a bad foot. I do not believe that Jesus would have said one religion is wrong over another. I believe He is happy that we are all his followers. Shouldn't we be more focused on those who have no faith? Those who have turned away from the teachings of Jesus, or have never been introduced to His word?
I live in the south and so there is quite the diverse group of religions around me, and I have a diverse group of friends from all religions. We have many discussions about our beliefs and actually find it fascinating that our core belief is the same: it is only through Jesus Christ that we will get to Heaven. We all follow the teachings of the Bible. Our Bible's are basically the same except the Catholic Bible has seven extra books. I have a King James version and a Catholic version and a NIV study Bible and have compared them side by side. They teach the same commandments, have the same parables of Jesus, have the four gospels and all of them have an old testament and new testament.
The way we choose to worship our Savior is a matter of where we are comfortable. I have visited many other religions and I just feel comfortable in the Catholic church. My Baptist grandmother visited the Catholic church when I made my first communion and when I was confirmed. She never felt uneasy or uncomfortable but she felt more comfortable in the Baptist church because that's how she was raised. If you're not Catholic, then why be on this particular forum unless you have a legitimate question or comment?

Rob, PGK

Quote from: marie69 on Fri Feb 05, 2010 - 11:41:19If you're not Catholic, then why be on this particular forum unless you have a legitimate question or comment?

The following does not apply to the Orthodox Church.

All Protestant Churches either broke off of the Catholic Church, or broke off of someone who had already broken off of the Catholic Church. There are those that believe that the only way that their particular denomination can be correct is if the Catholic Church is wrong, otherwise, why does their denomination exist. There are those within particular denominations that have no idea what the Catholic Church believes or what she teaches, they just listen to other people and don't take the time to find out for themselves.

marie69

I guess I just thought this was more of a forum where Catholics could communicate with one another about issues within their own individual churches or have questions answered about something they were wondering about. I have read several posts on here and feel like this forum is more about defending the Catholic faith rather than discussions of the faith. Many of the posts are judgemental which goes against the very teaching of Jesus.
I do not feel that "bashing" another religion puts us on the path to Heaven. Where I live, we have our Easter Mass on Easter Sunday while all of the other Christian churches have their services. Then that afternoon, our priest and the pastors from the other churches join together for a community Easter service where everyone of every religion is invited. It is a wonderful and spiritual experience.
All of the Christian churches also sponsor a bingo group from each nursing home. They have tournaments on the weekends and once a year they have a party where all the different church's members bring food to congratulate the nursing home residents for their participation. Our Catholic church here is small, but we make a big impact on our community. I am not used to such animosity as I have read on this forum.

Rob, PGK

Quote from: marie69 on Fri Feb 05, 2010 - 13:18:35
I guess I just thought this was more of a forum where Catholics could communicate with one another about issues within their own individual churches or have questions answered about something they were wondering about. I have read several posts on here and feel like this forum is more about defending the Catholic faith rather than discussions of the faith. Many of the posts are judgemental which goes against the very teaching of Jesus.
I do not feel that "bashing" another religion puts us on the path to Heaven. Where I live, we have our Easter Mass on Easter Sunday while all of the other Christian churches have their services. Then that afternoon, our priest and the pastors from the other churches join together for a community Easter service where everyone of every religion is invited. It is a wonderful and spiritual experience.
All of the Christian churches also sponsor a bingo group from each nursing home. They have tournaments on the weekends and once a year they have a party where all the different church's members bring food to congratulate the nursing home residents for their participation. Our Catholic church here is small, but we make a big impact on our community. I am not used to such animosity as I have read on this forum.

I live in Oklahoma, I'm used to it.

marie69

That's sad. Christianity is about love whether you are Catholic, Baptist, Presyterian, Lutheran, Methodist, etc....
Sounds to me like the folks who write on this forum put way to much emphasis on what religion a person is rather than being a Christian. When the movie The Passion of Christ came out several years ago, I went to see it and so did most everybody I know. As I said, we are a diverse group of religions. At a get together one night we began discussing the movie and all of us were crying just thinking about the reality of what Jesus Christ went through for ALL OF US!!!!!!
Religion was never brought up. It was all about the fact that each and every one us, no matter what church we attend, believe in Jesus and what he went through to save our sins. The only area of religion that was ever brought up was the fact that Mel Gibson, the director, is Catholic. And if you read that last part and can't wait to say something about the sins Mel Gibson has committed that were so publicly displayed by the media, just remember...Jesus died on the cross for him too.

Selene

I find it amazing that people always ask Catholics to quote the Bible.  They claim that if it isn't in the Bible, then it is false, and that we are not following the Bible.  We follow both the Bible and the Apostolic Tradition handed down from the Apostles. The Bible speaks of two different kinds of tradition - the traditions of man (which Catholics don't follow) and the traditions of the Apostles handed down to the Church.  As St. Paul wrote: 

2 Th. 2:15  Therefore, brethren, stand fast; and hold the traditions which you have learned, whether by word, or by our epistle.

2 Th. 3:6 And we charge you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you withdraw yourselves from every brother walking disorderly, and not according to the tradition which they have received of us.

Wordman

Quote from: Selene on Fri Feb 05, 2010 - 14:32:15
I find it amazing that people always ask Catholics to quote the Bible.  They claim that if it isn't in the Bible, then it is false...[/b]

I agree with this.  Examples: Airplanes weren't mentioned in the bible, does this mean I should stop believing in airplanes.  ::noworries::


BTW Selene, I like your avatar, it's hot. ::crackup::



Angelos

I happen to believe that Christ cares about His Church on earth. The fact that the Catholic Church is more than 1 billion strong and growing (more than half of all Christians are still Catholics) is prrof enough of me that it has the support and protection of Jesus.

I'm not saying other churches don't have Jesus' support. Thi

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by 4WD
Today at 13:58:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Yesterday at 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Yesterday at 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Yesterday at 21:07:16

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Yesterday at 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Yesterday at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal