News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898081
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 1897
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1291
Total: 1291
Google

The Vicar of Christ

Started by LightHammer, Tue Apr 06, 2010 - 08:54:56

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mclees8

Quote from: Selene on Mon Apr 19, 2010 - 17:17:23
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Apr 19, 2010 - 12:11:53
I tell you what else is amazing. it the absolute arrogance of many RC,s that post on this board. How they totally exclude the body of Christ because they are not Catholic. I've been around for a long time and have been friends with many believers of other denominations and such. I know how they truly love Christ from their heart. No we don't always agree on doctrine but i do not say they are not the body of Christ as if they were some none entity.

God bless

Mike, have you ever noticed that when I speak of the Catholic Church, I always capitalized the "C" in Church and when I speak of the Methodist church or any others that are non-Catholics, I don't capitalized the "c?"  The true Church that Christ built is the Catholic Church.  Because you are a Christian, you are still my brother in Christ.  You are part of the body of Christ, but the church that you belong to is not God's true Church.  Your church did not put together the Bible.  You were never excluded.  It was you who excluded us.     

So you capitalize when speaking of your church and don't capitlize any church outside of your church. but you still say we are are brothers in Christ. i thought all brothers in Christ were the church. so were are not the church but we are all brothers. Are you on a higher cloud than us? ::angel:: ::pondering::

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Mon Apr 19, 2010 - 21:49:59
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 19, 2010 - 19:11:13
God canonized the Bible. Your church leaders were just the mindless puppets that pointed in the direction the Master chose.

By the way you completely ignored the post before the one you commented to. Why is that?

Mindless puppets?  Many of the Apostles wrote the New Testament under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit.  And you think these men were mindless puppets?  It was the Holy Spirit that showed our Church leaders which books to cannonize.  The Holy Spirit did not choose YOUR church leaders to do that.  And when the Holy Spirit was there showing our Church leaders which books to cannonize, the Holy Spirit did not make them into mindless puppets to do that.  Our Church leaders simply obeyed the Holy Spirit. 

Which post was that?  I was responding to Mike's post.  


I think you misunderstand my position. You're going off halfcocked because you think I undermind the role of the disciples. For some reason you're acting like you're defending the honor of the leaders of the early church or something. I honor and respect the early followers as men greater than I could ever hope to be. I know full and well which physical hands wrote the Bible but I will never honor men with credit that belongs to God.  I would never utter the words

QuoteIt was the Church that wrote the Bible, compiled it together and cannonized it.

This is false. God wrote the Bible compiled it together and cannonized it. Your Catholic leaders were the ones He chose to do this through because they were the ONLY christian power in such a position to impact the world at the time.

QuoteSo the fact that the Protestant Christianity that you adhere to today rejects Arianism is just some odd and happy coincidence?  How nice for you! 

Your sarcasm is unimpressive. We all know where Protestantism originates. But just like America broke away from England to free itself from corruption while still forming its own laws based primarily off the Magna Carta, free thinking christians broke away from your Catholic organization while trying to keep the good points that you do have.

I think you also misunderstand my position. Im not attacking the Catholic Church Im just stating facts and scripture to support my position. So you guys dont have to go on the offensive. Your little club isnt that improtant so I dont really have to waste the energy in attacking it.

LightHammer

#72
QuoteQuote from: Rob, PGK on Yesterday at 02:39:56 PM
Quote from: mclees8 on Yesterday at 12:11:53 PM
Quote from: Jimmy on Yesterday at 09:47:06 AM
Quote from: Selene on Yesterday at 07:14:57 AM
Quote from: mclees8 on April 18, 2010, 05:04:43 PM
Quote from: Selene on April 12, 2010, 11:05:40 PM
And haven't you noticed that the only people whom God refers to as a "holy nation" is only to those who actually became a nation.  Of course, we are set apart because the Church that Christ built was not part of this world.  As a Catholic, I believe that I am not of this world.  Even the Catholic Church teaches this.  Our Church calls itself the "Mystical Body of Christ" because it is not of this world.  We always say that the Church is pure because she is part of Christ's body and not of this world.  It is only the churchMEN who are sinners. 



As believers yes we are a nation yet not of this world. You should tell that to the pope and the papacy that is up to its neck in the world and its politics

god bless



Mike, when Moses said to a group of slaves that they will become a holy nation, they actually became a nation - a country.  The Apostle Peter said the same thing to a group of Christians, and the only Christian denomination that became a nation just like Israel were the Catholics. The Baptists, Methodists, Seventh Day Adventists, and whatever church you belong to didn't become a nation.  As a matter of fact, the church that DID become a nation was also the same church that put together the Bible.  The New Testaments were cannonized in the fourth century by the Catholic Church.  Whatever church you belong to didn't put the Bible together. 


It is truly amazing how God can use even the worst of people to accomplish His ends.  He used the Pharisee, Judas and the Romans Rulers to bring us the sacrifice of Christ.  That is no indication that God condones either them or their acts.


I tell you what else is amazing. it the absolute arrogance of many RC,s that post on this board. How they totally exclude the body of Christ because they are not Catholic. I've been around for a long time and have been friends with many believers of other denominations and such. I know how they truly love Christ from their heart. No we don't always agree on doctrine but i do not say they are not the body of Christ as if they were some none entity.

God bless


What is even more amazing is the absolute ignorance of many Protestants that post on this board. How they have been told time and time again in thread after thread that the Catholic Church considers all Christians Catholic, just not all of them in complete communion with the the Church. So when a Catholic says "Church" in the broad sense of what "Church" means, they mean all of Christianity, not the building they visit for mass.

And all I want is some scripture to back up the nonsense I'm hearing.

The wedding of Christ, The Groom and the Bride, His Church is limited only to those of the Catholic submission? How impudent. But I'm still loving this debate way too much to falter now.

As a Protestant I will not deny that the Church has authority. Rather than being a Sola Scriptura I think it would be more accurate to refer to me as a Prima Scritpura. But I have to be honest in saying that the Church is NOT limited to those denominations of the one Catholic communion.

John 2
19Jesus answered and said unto them, Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.

20Then said the Jews, Forty and six years was this temple in building, and wilt thou rear it up in three days?

21But he spake of the temple of his body.


In Judaism the temple is the ONLY place the Spirit of God would descend. Other than the prophets who received special commute with the Spirit of God the priest were the only ones who received the truth of God and therefore taught the masses. Thats why the only road to salvation was to become a Jew under the Old Law.

Here Christ clearly refers to the Temple being rebuilt as the body of the true believer who shoulders his cross. This came to be by Christ death burial and resurrection.

John 14
15"If you love me, you will obey what I command.  16And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Counselor to be with you forever--  17the Spirit of truth. The world cannot accept him, because it neither sees him nor knows him. But you know him, for he lives with you and will be[3] in you. 18I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you.  19Before long, the world will not see me anymore, but you will see me. Because I live, you also will live.  20On that day you will realize that I am in my Father, and you are in me, and I am in you.  21Whoever has my commands and obeys them, he is the one who loves me. He who loves me will be loved by my Father, and I too will love him and show myself to him."


Notice throughout this passage how Christ is repetitive in using phrases like "in you" "in me" and "in my Father". Christ is promising the establishing of a spiritual union between the spirit of the true believer and His own. Now although I don't think any Catholic would disagree with what Ive said so far, I do think you argue that Christ limited this to leaders of the Church.


Acts 2:17And it shall come to pass in the last days, saith God, I will pour out of my Spirit upon all flesh: and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams:

18And on my servants and on my handmaidens I will pour out in those days of my Spirit; and they shall prophesy:


Actually Peter Himself quoted this after some in the crowd who didn't receive the Holy Spirit began to mock those who did as being drunk. Look at the words in the texts "sons" "daughters" "servants" "handmaidens". These are words used to describe those who take up the cross for Christ as He did for man. Tell me you don't limit such attributes to only Catholics.

Now if the Holy Spirit resides within each individual heart of each individual believer then collectively those followers are the Bride meant for Christ. Then collectively they are the Church that Israel was meant give birth to through her pain and suffering. Then collectively the Universal Church isnt limited to the Catholic Church.



Ryan2010


QuoteI'm not seeing the problem here. I'm a Protestant who will openly confess that the disciples as the leaders of the Church on Earth had Apostolic Authority.

Do you believe that the elders also had authority?  That when the Apostles died, the authority of those elders persevered? 


QuoteI will even accept that the Church has authority over matters in the Christian community; as a matter of fact the only authority on earth that trumps the Church is Scripture.

Hm.  But consider Luther and Zwingli.  How does your view of Scripture trumping The Church play out here?  I'm not being antagonistic here but only would like to hear how you see the role of scripture in the following context. 

You have Luther who believes that Christ is present in the Eucharist or communion.  Then you have a fellow protestant named Zwingli who is the major dispenser of the belief that Christ is not present but that the communion is just a symbol. 

Both use scripture to back up their interpretations.  Both believe that what they think true is what the bible means to say even though they hold contradictory teachings on the doctrines of Christ.  Their theologies are and were in sharp dispute.  Luther had quite a temper and this temper flared when trying to iron out this dispute with Zwingli.  They both believed the other had missed the mark and was teaching false, unsound doctrine.  Both sought to use the bible as the means through which to correct and refute so that the other might be profited.  But they reached stalemate. 

But what does the Holy Scripture say to do?  I would ask in a more matter of fact way, what did Jesus say to do?  Christ said to tell it to The Church.  Tell it to The Church and if whoever is in the wrong does not listen even! to The Church?  This one must be considered like a pagan or a tax collector. 

But which "Church" does Luther and Zwingli take their dispute to?  They both believe in the authority of the Holy Scriptures but neither of them agrees on the authoritative teaching of the Holy Scriptures.  Both of them believes that what they believe the bible MEANS TO SAY is synonymous with what the Holy Scriptures say. 

If Luther took Zwingli to his church what would happen to Zwingli?  He would be found to be in the wrong.  If Zwingli took Luther to his church what would happen to Luther? 

I only ask this because I don't see how the authority of the scriptures would trump The Church.  If you believe that the Lutherans are just as much as The Church that Jesus spoke of in Matt 18 as the Zwinglians are The Church that Jesus spoke of, then the only conclusion we can arrive at is pluralism.  We HAVE TO say for the sake of continuity in Matt 18 that both Luther and Zwingli are right.  But then look what happens....

It's often said that the Holy Spirit is in both Luther and Zwingli and so therefore according to the teaching that the Holy Spirit teaches, that the Holy Spirit has taught Luther one thing and Zwingli another.  But in our hearts of hearts do we believe that the Holy Spirit would teach two contradictory teachings?  I do think that all Christians believe that the Holy Spirit does not teach contradictory doctrines of Christ but only One, True doctrine of Christ. 

So I ask how is it that Holy Scripture trumps The Church? 

(for the record I am not saying that The Church trumps Holy scripture but that The Church and the Holy Scriptures are in accordance with one another)

QuoteI acknowledge the authority of the Church, to an extent. Its just seems that you guys are refusing to quote any other scripture besides 1 Timothy 3:15.

In the bible anytime you see the laying on of hands, ordinations or appointments, the "sending out" of a person or persons, disputes being settled such in the case of the appointment of the "seven" that we read in Acts and also the council of the Apostles and elders (who were not all present btw, I'll expound on this at a later time, haven't forgotten about you).  Any time you read an introduction in an epistle to so and so or the mere fact that the letter was specifically written to a certain church and that this letter was considered authoritative and meant to be obeyed by not only that church but all churches.  Any time it mentions the function or purpose or office such as deacon or overseer or elder.   Any.  Time.   Though they may seem mundane these are all illustrations of an actual community with authority. 

A person did not just believe and so went out on their own and started up their own church and so appointed their own elders.  We do not see this in any scripture whatsoever.  The only time we see this in scripture is when people are attacking or subverting the authority of The Church.

If you look at Wesley and how he started his churches this is telling. He ordains his own.  He sets himself up as head.  He even gives himself the power to strip bishops out of office unilaterally.   But by what scriptural authority does he have to do this when he himself has not been ordained to function in an office such as this?  Every elder was appointed from above.  Not only God but in co-operation with actual people.  The Apostles laid hands on elders to make them elders.  The elders then! had the authority to lay hands on the people. 

So anytime you see even so much as a hint of this in the Holy Scriptures, this is evidence of the Authority of The Church.  But Jesus himself said, "tell it to The Church" and so we must.  If we agree that the elders had authority even after the Apostles died and that The Church continued on within the framework of ordination and office and purpose and function as depicted in the Holy Scriptures, then we have to know that this "Church" that Jesus spoke of goes back prior to the epistles written to them.  And so anything that pops up after the writing of the Epistles outside of the laying on of hands, offices and their functions and purposes, we must! conclude that these are not the communities or gatherings that Christ mentions and that these communities don't even have in common the very things that the community we read about in the Holy Scriptures have:  ordination through the laying on of hands, inherited tradition and liturgical practice, offices and the function and purposes of those offices.  Apostolicity.  Authority.  Unity. 

Matt 5:18 - Not one jot or title shall pass away
Matt 24:35 - The word shall not pass away
1 Peter 1:25 - The word of God endures forever
Ps. 12:6-7 - God Shall preserve his wors forever
Is. 40:8 - The word shall endure forever

If we can trust in the Authority of the Holy Scriptures and that they endure and persevere throughout the centuries we must also trust in the very communities that Christ works through in the way in which they are preserved in the Scriptures.  Apostolicity can not be thwarted because it is written and what is written shall not be overcome. 

2 Thess 2:15 - Hold on to the tradition whether by word or letter
2 Thess 3:6 - Withdraw yourselves from those who do not keep the tradition
2 Tim 1:13-14  - Hold fast by the Holy Spirit the words you have heard <- this was/is an authoritative letter written to members of the community that acknowledged the authority of The Church and affirms the authority of oral proclamation.
1 Tim 3:15 - The Church is called the pillar and ground of truth.  (the scriptures themselves affirms this)
2 Tim 2:1-2 - Illustrates the passing down of Tradition
1 Cor 11:2 - Keep the tradition as I have delivered it to you

You must realize that the reason there was no debate over baptisms and how to do it and what it means and whether it's an ordinance or a sacrament or what the scriptures really mean to say about baptisms, is because back then you got dunked by the Apostles themselves, dunked! by those the Apostles dunked. 

You didn't need a PHD or the ability to read and philosophize and versify what it meant because it was taught to you and shown to you visually orally and physically.  It was as it is written in Hebrews 5-6 wherein "baptisms" is listed as an ELEMENTARY TEACHING OF CHRIST.   

This is what happens when you couple the Authority of Tradition and Holy Scripture WITHIN the life of The Church.  You don't have to subject the Holy Scriptures to private interpretation because you are being showed what it is the Apostles showed.  You are hearing what the Apostles said with your own two eyes.  You are worshiping in the way the Apostles worshiped.  You are touching, seeing, hearing, and even tasting that which the Apostles touched, saw, heard and even tasted. 

This community surrounded by the Apostles and elders was preserved.  This community retained what the Apostles taught.  Read the Didache! from the early early days and it mentions to a "t" an Orthodox baptism.  You want to see an Orthodox baptism, read the Didache.  But here too the Didache was only a general list of these teachings and in order to be written down had to have pre-existence in the life of The Church.  And the fact that this document was lost for so long and yet the practice was preserved is telling. 

That which is the word of God, written or oral, shall not pass away but continue on. The Holy Scriptures point to this reality and are only in context within the very life of The Church that existed to receive those letters that we today call Holy Scripture. 

::prayinghard::








Ryan2010



QuoteSo I guess you think your little club is special because it can trace back its alleged union of leaders to a mere follower of Christ. My heart beats with the love of Christ and He who dwells in me is greater than any who dwells within this insignificant rock called Earth. So don't be too proud Selene.

It's getting heated in here but I want to say that no one doubts the love or heart of a person for Christ.  That's not what this is about.  We are all making statements here and they draw a certain line in the sand.  But do know that your love for Christ is not doubted regardless of the denomination.  Neither do Orthodox believe that God loves anyone less because they are not Orthodox.  Again, this is not what this about.  Orthodox also believe as do RCC, I think, that within Christ is the end of all "clubs" religion, ritual and rite.  But you have to understand how the Orthodox or RCC views itself.  Orthodox do not view the ritual, rites etc. as ends within themselves. 

So please please, know that I don't think anyone questions another persons salvation here.  Because we view The Church as more as the individual, but something you must enter into in order to become it, you have to realize we aren't saying that you are not saved or don't have love for Christ or don't know him etc.  That's not being said here. 

What we are saying is that the more ancient Christian faiths see "The Church" as more than just a group of independent individuals. 


QuoteLike I said in the Eucharist thread( speaking of which Ryan you still owe me a response on that point) the Church didn't completely unify under Rome.

Well, I did think that I addressed this but perhaps there's mis-communication here.   Ask yourself is all the elders from all of the churches decided upon the issue in Acts wherein they say, "what seemed right to us and the Holy Spirit"? 

And I'm not entirely sure what you mean by "unify" UNDER Rome????   Are you not familiar with Eastern Orthodoxy and how they view the Papacy?  The Orthodox and Rome have different views on both Holy Tradition, Apostolic Succession and also function in regards to the offices such as Priest etc. 

QuoteAt the time of Constantine's call, there were 1800 Apostolic Successors and in the end only 318 of them actually attended the Council of Nicaea. That discention is hardly enough to even whisper the decisions made in that Council as valid so don't talk to me about your little club. History itself validates what I say and scripture to boot.

I am not sure why you call this a dissension?  Are you suggesting that out of the ones invited that the others did not consider themselves "catholic" or did not obey or recognize the authority of the councils?  Are you saying that the remaining numbers were somehow a different entity or out of communion?  You will have to clarify here. 

In regards to the validity of the council, are you aware of what was decided upon at those councils?  The Divinity of Christ was defended. I don't see how you don't see this council as valid?  Which Christian communities rebelled against the councils decision?  They can be named and if you look at their beliefs I am confident that even you would label these heretical. 

How does history validate what you say?   You believe that every Elder must be present in order to be valid?  I am not sure.  Please clarify and expound because I don't think we understand what you're saying.  The connection is not being made.


Quote
God canonized the Bible. Your church leaders were just the mindless puppets that pointed in the direction the Master chose.


I don't know.  I mean would we say that the Apostles and Elders who made decisions that were to be obeyed by the people, mindless puppets?   How do we go from the authority of the Elders in the NT to no authority and or puppets?  I don't understand. 


Regardless, I hope that I am being respectful to you and haven't offended you.  You were right in an earlier post to say that we must make sure to be a light. 

I think the whole point that we have these discussions is so that we won't just continue to agree to disagree but that we might become of one mind and attain to the unity of the faith.   Complete unity.  To preserve disunity would be counter to not only Holy Scriptures but the vary prayers of our Lord and Savior, Jesus, who is The Christ. 



ICXC

Ryan2010

Amo, one of the problems I have with the Waldenesian theories is that it would be one thing if they actually had apostolic succession but another if they didn't believe things that you probably don't even believe as a SDA. 

They believed that all matter was evil.  that Marriage was sin.  The also denied the validity of the sacraments administered by unworthy clerics.  So in their theological mindset they believe that the "potency" of the sacraments such as communion and baptism depended on the cleric administering.  So if you were baptized by a guy that later turns out to be an apostate, you need a new baptism. 

The other groups that Anabaptists try to tie a lineage to are Novations, Montanist, Donatists and Paulicans.  But if you just look at what these groups taught and believed and practiced you wouldn't even call them Christian.  These groups when you look at them are more like the gnostics and the JWs and Mormons (no offense Mormons and JWs but when you deny the divinity of Christ and reduce him to "a" god and have "new" revelations that Jesus and Satan were brothers etc. then you sort of show up on the radar as counter to the faith once delivered by the Apostles to the Saints). 


But I hope I make my point.    To try and say that these groups have Apostolic Succession and so have touched the protestants and therefore validate their authority as Church etc. is quite loose.  The reason why these histories were much more important in the past to protestants was because they knew that when they came out of Roman Catholicism they had rejected Apostolicity and so needed a way to be free from the authority of Church but at the same time become Church.   They were aggressively trying to define themselves against Rome as the One true Church and believed themselves to be, though today few will admit to this, that their way of thinking, practicing, reading and approaching the bible is The One True Church.  The True Faith handed down by the Apostles. 


Blessings





LightHammer

Man I like this guy. I can just feel the desire to go more in depth. This is going to be so much fun!

QuoteWhat we are saying is that the more ancient Christian faiths see "The Church" as more than just a group of independent individuals.

I believe that the Church is the universal community of every believer that shoulders his or her cross and lives a life pleasing to God. Basically all who obtain salvation are apart of the Church. Those individuals transcend different denominations and deifferent backgrounds.

This my take on the Church.

Help me my friends to better understand the Catholic viewpoint. Are Catholics only apart of the Church? In Revelation when Christ meets with the multitude we acknowledge as the Church was that community strictly Catholic?


QuoteAnd I'm not entirely sure what you mean by "unify" UNDER Rome?

What I mean is why did the rest of those who held Apostolic Authority not answer the call of Constantine to attend the Council if they were all in agreement to accept his request for unity? How is that a few can make absolute decisions without the collective? Can Congress declare War with only the senate's approval?

QuoteHow do we go from the authority of the Elders in the NT to no authority and or puppets?

For this one I have to apologize. I just felt like I was being talked down to and lost my cool. I love the early followers and appreciate their sacrifice. I honor them as men of faith I can only hope to achieve and I never meant to hint at any other form of disrespect.

LightHammer

QuoteDo you believe that the elders also had authority?  That when the Apostles died, the authority of those elders persevered? 

I believe in Apostolic Authority. Let me clarify what I believe. I believe that the Church holds the authority of the Twelve. I believe that they have can pretty much do anything as longs as it does not violate scripture. They can formualte official doctrine and christian positions as long as their actions remain within the boundaries of the true absolute authority which is God's Word.

The problem Im having is finding where the authority of Peter and the Twelve truly lie. I cant wrap my mind around the glitch in the attendance of the First Council of Nicaea. If the Church leaders didnt unify in Rome Im wondering what happened to the authority of the apostles. Did  it go into hiding like in revelations when scripture fortells the woman giving wings like an eagle to hide in the dessert?


QuoteHow does your view of Scripture trumping The Church play out here?

Im not a traditional Prrotestant. I dont agree entirely with all of Martin Luther's Five Solas or Zwingili. So I guess it doesnt play out too well.

LightHammer

Oh and is anyone going to respond to the scripture I posted supporting my idea of the universal church?

desertknight

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 11:23:49
Oh and is anyone going to respond to the scripture I posted supporting my idea of the universal church?

Sure.

Quote from: LightHammerlives a life pleasing to God.

The crux of the problem.  God certainly wants us to love Him and our neighbour, but that has more detail to it than what most of the post-modern "feel-gooders" care to look into.  He is not pleased by and does not want His Church to preach and proclaim different and opposing beliefs concerning baptism, salvation, the Eucharist, authority, etc.  He made His Church, one with His Body and it is to be the pillar of fire and truth.  It is to have one doctrine, one unified authority, be of one mind.  God does not consider it love when we mislead people, confuse them with thousands of preachers, all preaching different doctrines on vitally important matters.  He does not tell us to go and "Do this", in celebrating Holy Eucharist, but what you believe Eucharist to actually be, is of no real consequence as long as you love.  To the contrary, the Acts of the Apostles and the letters of the NT, over and over, stress the importance of "right belief", i.e., literally, orthodoxy, and adhering to proper authority, which is passed on through the imposition of the hands of only those who already posses it legitimately.

To say that those things are not important as long as you simply believe in God, is not true and it is not loving God with all your heart, etc, nor is it loving your neighbor.  It is engaging in leading them astray and even if done with the best of intentions, is doing the Devil's own work!

Christ has one Body, one Church, with the authority passed down from the Apostles through the laying on of hands.  That Church has one baptism, one Holy Eucharist, which is His Body and Blood for our salvation, one truth which does not change through the ages.

We are not being good Christians nor good neighbors when we lead our brothers astray by telling them that all those things are just unimportant details that good men can differ on.  

larry2


LightHammer - I believe that the Church is the universal community of every believer that shoulders his or her cross and lives a life pleasing to God. Basically all who obtain salvation are apart of the Church. Those individuals transcend different denominations and deifferent backgrounds.

Oh and is anyone going to respond to the scripture I posted supporting my idea of the universal church?

larry2 - I can't do anything more than quote the Roman Catholic Church's stand on those not of their organization. And seemingly if you do not belong to the Roman Catholic Church you are going to hell according to them. Do I believe the following? In no way Jose.

fanuvmxpx  - For those who do not know, Pope Benedict has already publicly said that protestants are not true Christians and will not inherit salvation outside the catholic church:

Outside the Church No Salvation

A theological axiom which means that membership in the Church founded by Christ is necessary for the salvation of every individual man. Since the Roman Catholic Church is the Church founded by Christ and since many millions of men are not members thereof, it might be thought that these millions, according to Catholic theology, will inevitably be damned. Catholic theologians have commonly held that to many of those who are outside the Church through no fault of their own can be saved by doing God's will as they see it, and theologians explain the axiom "outside the Church no salvation" to allow for such cases.

The teaching on this theological axiom can be summed up in the following seven points

1.   The axiom is a revealed truth which must be believed by Catholics: but it must be understood in the sense in which the Church understands it, not according to the personal interpretation of any individual.

2.    The axiom means that Christ commands all men to be baptized into the Catholic Church and to remain therein, united to the pope, who is the Vicar of Christ on earth. Hence anyone knowing of this strict command of Christ and refusing to obey it cannot be saved.

3.    All men are not only commanded to join the Church, but Christ also has made the Catholic Church the means by which they are to enter into heaven.

4.   The Church is a necessary means of salvation, not only because of any intrinsic necessity (i.e., Christ could have arranged other means of salvation), but solely because it was established by Christ.

5.   In some circumstances, according to God's infinite mercy, salvation may be obtained by those who are not actually members of the Church but who have a wish or a desire to become members.

6.    The wish or the desire that can sometimes substitute for actual membership in the Church need not always be explicit (e.g., as it is in those who are taking instructions in preparation for baptism), but it may be explicit, that is, it may be included in the good disposition of a person who wishes to do God's will.

7.   For the desire of membership in the Church to be effective in insuring one's eternal salvation, it must be joined in perfect charity or love of God and the individual must have supernatural faith.

Ryan2010

QuoteI believe that the Church is the universal community of every believer that shoulders his or her cross and lives a life pleasing to God. Basically all who obtain salvation are apart of the Church. Those individuals transcend different denominations and deifferent backgrounds.

This my take on the Church.

I believe that this is a wonderful start.  I would agree to some extent even. 

But if you look at your statements:

Quote
I believe that the Church is the universal community of every believer that shoulders his or her cross and lives a life pleasing to God.

Now this statement suggests communion with God.  Union.  Unity.  One. 

What we have to remember is that how this "union" is achieved and plays out in our life varies in explanation.  It varies from denomination to denomination.  Sect to sect.   For instance if you talk to a person who believes in Once Saved Always Saved, this "union" takes on a new meaning.  And likewise if you speak to someone who says that this union only takes place in the eschatological "end of ends" you get another meaning of what this "union" is.   

When you say, "believer" do you mean that one that simply has faith that Jesus is The Son of God?  Does this person keep the faith?  And what is this faith anyway? 

When St. Paul says not to receive any other good news than the one delivered to The Church by the Apostles themselves, does this mean that one who places faith in their understanding of the faith mean that they too are believers or have somehow departed from the keeping* of The Faith? 


QuoteBasically all who obtain salvation are apart of the Church.

Again, if you just peruse the boards on here, you will see that this statement is not agreed upon across denominations.  The meaning of "all" varies from group to group.  The meaning of "obtain" varies from group to group.  The meaning of salvation varies.  And though you meant, "a" part, not "apart" this too varies from group to group.  What does it mean to be a "part"?  Part of doctrinal contradiction as to who Christ is?  Or should we reduce the importance of doctrine and increase the disposition of heart above who Christ is? 

There is a post on the main board that talks about "non-essential doctrines".  It's interesting because if a doctrine is in reality a window into who Christ is, then we have to say that the doctrine is important.  But then look at all the different groups.  One group will label a doctrine or practice as essential and another as unessential.  Their reason for doing this is dependent upon their tradition.  If they belong to a tradition that says that you do not need to believe in XYZ in order to be saved, then any doctrine that does not fall under what they believe salvation to be, winds up on the chopping block. 

More than this.  If you see that to obtain salvation you must ABC then you will see that people that do not conform to your ABCs are in danger of losing their salvation. 

Now all of these different teachings on what these things are have roots.  For instance, if you look at rapture you can see the root in John Nelson Darby.  Of course those who say the root is in the bible will not see that it is Darby who taught others to read Thessa 4 according to his teaching.  And people will not see that Scolfield was one such person and when he published books the rapture teaching according to Darby was injected into the teachings of several groups.  Then those groups began to approach Thessa 4 as Darby through Scolfield taught and time passes on.  Time passes on and people don't even know who this Darby fellow is.  The teaching and tradition of Darby becomes invisible and all they can see is their consistent approach to Thessa 4.  This then permeates the culture and becomes ingrained.   

So now, if you go to nearly any protestant study and come across Thessa 4 you can not avoid talk about the rapture.  People don't see that it has Darby's fingerprints all over it because they have been so trained to look and approach in the Darby fashion, that their interpretation becomes synonymous with the word of God to them. 

We have not even gotten to the word, "Church" in your second statement but already we have a few hundred years of different mutations at work against us.  We have cultural presuppositions.  We have strain after strain of teachings that are in contradiction even against each other within protestantism.  But look at this reality against the over all point of the statement. 

The overall point of the statement is union, communion, unity, being One, as The Son is ONE with The Father and The Holy Spirit.  They are indivisible in their divisions.  They each dwell fully in one another in a perpetual movement of Love.

We are called to be One as Christ is One with The Father.  This is why Christ prays for complete unity. 


QuoteHelp me my friends to better understand the Catholic viewpoint. Are Catholics only apart of the Church? In Revelation when Christ meets with the multitude we acknowledge as the Church was that community strictly Catholic?

I'm going to post an article that more fully expounds on "Church" from the Orthodox perspective.  I'll start a new thread so that those interested can give a read separate from all the issues being discussed here.  The understanding of "Church" differs from the Roman Catholic point of view and so if you want an explanation as to what "The Church" means to the Roman Catholics, one of them will have to explain Rome's view. 

But do give it a careful read if you want to know how Orthodoxy views herself.   

QuoteWhat I mean is why did the rest of those who held Apostolic Authority not answer the call of Constantine to attend the Council if they were all in agreement to accept his request for unity? How is that a few can make absolute decisions without the collective? Can Congress declare War with only the senate's approval?

Well, there's a few presuppositions in your question.  You say, "the call of Constantine".  Why do you view this as Constantine's call? 

You say, "why did the rest not answer the call?".  What leads you to believe that they did not answer a call to unity?  Are you saying that they rejected the decisions of the council?  If so, who are "they"? 

And then you ask, "how is it that a few can make absolute decisions without the collective?".   I asked you how the Elders could make authoritative decisions without ALL the other elders being present?  In Acts did ALL of the elders show up? 

Again, you seem to be saying that because not ALL of the bishops showed up that this somehow made the decision void.  But then I asked you if you were familiar with the decisions arrived at.  If you agree with Arius then perhaps I could see you arguing as to why the council's decision might be void but that would only be out reasons that are self interested. 

You also have to show what groups disobeyed or disagreed or didn't submit to the council.  But if you do this we will have to look at who that group is and what they believed and taught. 

Consider the following:

Acts 16:4
As they traveled from town to town, they delivered the decisions reached by the apostles and elders in Jerusalem for the people to obey.


Quote
QuoteHow do we go from the authority of the Elders in the NT to no authority and or puppets?

For this one I have to apologize. I just felt like I was being talked down to and lost my cool. I love the early followers and appreciate their sacrifice. I honor them as men of faith I can only hope to achieve and I never meant to hint at any other form of disrespect.

I completely understand.  I am prone to the same thing.  But again, this becomes a question of authority.  If the Apostles came to your neighborhood and placed you in the care of elders and overseers would you not view them as authoritative?  If the answer is yes then you have to go one further. 

Would you obey the authority of the elders and overseers that were ordained by those elders and overseers who were ordained by the Apostles? 

If the answer is yes, you have to go one further. 

Tuesday, April 20, 2010


Do you believe that this authority was destroyed?  Do you believe that the teachings and traditions that the Christ through the Apostles deposited into the community we call The Church were destroyed?  Will not the word of the Lord endure forever? 

How can that which Christ revealed to the Apostles and the Apostles to The Church be destroyed?  Why are we so willing to believe in the miracle of the written words of God but not in the teachings and traditions of God? 

If the Apostles baptized you and ordained an elder over you do you believe that you and this elder would forget how to baptize?  Do you think they would forget to baptize others as they have been baptized?  Do you think that those who were baptized by those who were baptized would forget?  Do you think that the teachings regarding baptisms would be lost? 

Hebrews 6

1Therefore let us leave the elementary teachings about Christ and go on to maturity, not laying again the foundation of repentance from acts that lead to death, and of faith in God, 2instruction about baptisms, the laying on of hands, the resurrection of the dead, and eternal judgment.

Take baptisms and laying of hands.  Even the Baptists and the Methodists disagree on these things.  Throw in the Pentecostals for laying on of hands and other groups. 

The point I hope you get from the article I post on "The One True Church" is that it is about unity of the faith, continuity with the good news that the Apostles preached, continuity with the very self-same organism that we read about in the Holy Scripture and today call The Church. 

Consider how it is possible that instructions on baptisms and the laying on of hands could be called, "elementary teachings about Christ".   Also notice that these were not called, teachings that don't matter but "teachings of or about CHRIST". 

And the context here is maturity.  The point of The Church is not unlike marriage in regards to an image of a more "mature/fuller" loving relationship (union) with God. 


The article is of course quite long but I am finding that the Orthodox don't have many slogans other than, "come and see". 

::smile::



Christ is risen!


ICXC


Ryan2010

#82

QuoteHow does your view of Scripture trumping The Church play out here?

Im not a traditional Prrotestant. I dont agree entirely with all of Martin Luther's Five Solas or Zwingili. So I guess it doesnt play out too well.


Well, you can replace Zwingli and Luther with the Methodists and the Presbyterians or any group or even individuals.  If you say what the scriptures mean to say contradicts what the fellow next to you believes and you are both using scripture then how do you decide which is the more authoritative interpretation?  

You say the bible will decide but between the two of you your bibles both read differently.  Each will be convinced that their bible reads the right way but in the end, where is the authority that you speak of?  Each might even go so far as to say that the Holy Spirit has personally guided them to the correct interpretation and practice.  But you both contradict one another.  How do you make the Scriptures the authority when both suffer from their own interpretations of those scriptures?  

For Orthodox the scriptures make sense within the context of the life within The Church.  If someone said that baptism means this when it contradicts what the Apostles showed The Church, then The Church rejects that person's teaching.  

To say that just because you believe that Jesus is Lord means that you know the elementary teachings independent from The Church (the community that Christ deposited the faith into through the Apostles and Elders) rejects the very community that we read about in our bibles.  

If "The Church" is only "yourself", Matt 18 doesn't even make sense.  If it's an invisible gathering of this fellow here and that fellow there then how on earth are we to "tell it to the church?"   Do we just choose the person who agrees with us against the other fellow?  It doesn't add up.  Church is something more as scripture points out.  

Matthew 18:17

17If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to yourself?; and if he refuses to listen even to yourself?, treat him as you would a pagan or a tax collector.



God Bless


blituri

#83
Down Through History The Church of Christ existed under that PUBLIC CONFESSION OF FAITH. The "catholics" before confiscated by pagans after Constantine bore that name.  The did not make music, the observed the weekly Lord's Supper as an ACT OF EVANGELISM and not the pagan "eating and drinking of the body of the gods." They baptized FOR the remission of sins.  John Smyth called his group The Church of Christ.  Those who "baptized" were not Baptists in the sect sense.

THE APOSTLES HAD NO AUTHORITY TO COMMAND TEACHING THE LAW OF MOSES

Well, I did think that I addressed this but perhaps there's mis-communication here.   Ask yourself is all the elders from all of the churches decided upon the issue in Acts wherein they say, "what seemed right to us and the Holy Spirit"?

Pseudo-Christians denouncing the old PATTERN in favor of a NEW PARADIGM use the same passage to say that they are NOT bound by the commands, examples and inferences in the olden, obsolete Bible.  Unfortunately, such an attitude makes Christ GUARANTEE that they will never be able to read BLACK TEXT on BROWN PAPER. Both jews and Christians are blind, says Paul to the Corinthian Jews, because they have not TURNED to Christ as a review of all of the books, songs and sermons in HIGH PLACES prove.

The Holy Spirit HAD SPOKEN through the Scriptures: His NAME is Jesus Christ.
     (1 Peter 1:11; 2 Cor 3; Rev 19:11)
They agreed to SEND LETTERS but made no DOCTRINAL decisions but to RADICALLY OUTLAW the marks of almost all christianism engaged in "ceremonial legalism" rather than being a school (only) of the word (only).

None of the apostles taught keeping the law: false!
ALL teachings were based on the Word of God or face-to-face revelation through Jesus Christ THE SPIRIT.
James used the CENI principle based on WORD and not OPINES

WHAT WAS THE "WITHOUT REDEMPTION" TEACHING OF SOME DISCIPLES?

Acts 15:1 AND certain men which came down from Judaea taught the brethren,
        and said, Except ye be circumcised after
        the manner of Moses,
               imposed under The Book of The Law after they lost the Abrahamic Covenant.
        ye cannot be saved.

However, the OPPOSITE DECISION was made by the Holy Spirit of Christ in the PROPHETS.

Simeon hath declared how God at the first
        did visit the Gentiles,
        to take out of them a people for his name. Acts 15:14

And to this agree the words of the prophets; as it is WRITTEN, Acts 15:15

After this I will return, and will
        build again the tabernacle of David, which is fallen down;
        and I will build again the ruins thereof, and I will set it up: Acts 15:16

God did not purpose to rebuild a pagan Temple devoted to the Stars. The TENT of David was the family of David.

    God promised David a TENT built on Mount Zion
    But, Solomon built God a HOUSE on Moriah were "god had ALREADY PROVIDED through Abraham."
    But, God does not LIVE in houses built by human hands nor is he WORSHIPPED by human hands:
           Raising, Clapping, Picking or Pointing.

    The Tabernacle of David was a WITNESS: Godly people did not go to "tent to worship."
            the Loud SOUND at Temple Dedication abandoned the tabernacle
            and took God INTO EXILE beyond the reach of the PEOPLE.

    This is from Amos 9: After fall into MUSICAL IDOLATRY God abandoned Israel
            but promised a REMNANT: those who had not bowed to Baal

    "You Israelites are just like the Ethiopians in my sight," says the Lord.
    "Certainly I brought Israel up from the land of Egypt,
            but I also brought the Philistines from Caphtor
            and the Arameans from Kir. Amos 9:7

   1. CHOSEN means that God had a tiny remnant of those STILL LIVING in Jerusalem
   2. Chose means that they had been TESTED as if by FIRE.
   3. They had not BOWED to Baal as the Jewish Dionysus worshipers TRIED to force Jesus
                They PIPED and you were supposed to bow or BEND OVER.
                Then, you would be "initiated" and you would sing or lament and DANCE.
      This is called the Vineyard or the New Wineskin religion
   4. Jesus said that the MEN in Jerusalem were like these CHILDREN: wholly perverted.
   5. They were of the world or COSMOS and Jesus neither preached to them and would NOT pray for them.
   6. The CHOSEN or TESTED were then PREDESTINATED to be able to HEAR the Gospel and be saved.
   7. If you have not turned TO CHRIST you have not heard the gospel and are of the WORLD.
   8. This unique word COSMOS is marked by the Scribes and Pharisees Jesus called hypocrites by
       Naming rhetoricians, singers and instrument players.  Jesus neither PREACHED to them nor prayed for them.

That the residue of men might seek after the Lord,
        and all the Gentiles, upon whom my name is called,
        saith the Lord, who doeth all these things. Acts 15:17

   1. THIS WAS GOD'S PREDESTINATED PLAN: those who sacrificed and burnt animals when the old
        Levite musical cult made NOISE were abandoned to worship the STARRY HOST including SATURN #666
   3. The Jews of the COSMOS who operated the sacrificial system were called by Christ ROBBERS AND PARASITES.
             Their story is told by the LYING PEN OF THE SCRIBES called preachers, singers and instrument players.
   4. The Church of Christ was the Synagogue which was a SCHOOL OF THE WORD and not a pagan "worship center."
   5. The Abrahamic Covenant was LOST to the Israelites of the Sacrificial system.
   6. However, Godly people lived by Godly Fear and Social Justic: never practiced by the Jews.

The LAW OF MOSES was IMPOSED on idolaters wholly abandoned to WORSHIP THE STARRY HOST.  SATURN or 666 is the STAR OF DAVID as Jewish Scholars readily admit.

The Law of Moses was IMPOSED on the Jews and its blessing was that it protected the godly people from the Civil-Military-Clergy complex IMPOSED when the elders fired God and demanded a king LIKE the nations which God knew mant WORSHIP like the nations.  There is no part of the sacrificial system which you can IMPOSE without MARKING yourself as part of the end-time Babylon mother of harlots (Sophia-Zoe) in mortal combat with the Jehovah-Logos pattern of being a School of Christ through the prophets and the prophecies made more certain.  The Levites prophesying is called SOOTHSAYING and the preachers, singers and instrument players under Sophia-Zoe are called SORCERERS.

Known unto God are all his works
        from the beginning of the world. Acts 15:18
        Wherefore my sentence is,
        that we trouble not them,
        which from among the Gentiles are turned to God: Acts 15:19

Troubling either Jews or Gentiles would to COMMAND them to be circumcised and keep the Law of Moses.
They DID NOT send out letters commanding that they KEEP that which had been added as a FIREY LAW to protect the weak from the nobility of Civil-Military-Clergy complext Christ called PARASITES AND ROBBERS.

Turned or converted has the same meaning as BEING BAPTIZED.

The RULES would keep the Gentiles OUT of the marketplace where Jesus consigned the pipers, singers and dancers.
There would be the pagan temples, animal slaughter, shambles, prostitutes, sodomites, singers, musicians, rhetoricians and sellers of Radishes.  Paul used the PSALLO word to MARK anyone driven into CHURCH by the blood, red-painted psallo cord.

No one decided that the Gentiles or anyone should follow the Law of Moses.

But that we write unto them,
        that they abstain from pollutions of idols,
        and from fornication,
        and from things strangled,
        and from blood. Acts 15:20

These were MARKS of Gentile paganism: the women got aroused by wine and music and strangled an animal and then tore it limb to limb, ate the raw flesh (the meaning of eucharist), and drank the blood and baptized in blood rather than PURE water.  Part of all paganism including much of the history of the Jews was that fornication was an ACT of worship. The Vineyard (aka wineskins) still identifies the arousal singing as a way to have a sexual relationship with the "spirit" which was just before the last ACT of worship "giving of substance" and therefore not commanded by Paul.

The Law of Moses was widely taught and known to be right: NORMAL people were not  IDOLATERS and would already have rejected these MARKS.

THE GODLY PEOPLE ATTENDED The Church of Christ, Qahal or Synagogue from the wilderness oneward

http://www.piney.com/Synagogue1.html

The GODLY PEOPLE were quarantined FROM the Sacrificial System which was NOT COMMANDED but came with the Civil-Military-Priestly complex being TURNED OVER TO WORSHIP THE STARRY HOST.

For Moses of old time hath
        in every city them that PREACH him,
        being READ in the synagogues every sabbath day. Acts 15:21

They didn't slaughter innocent animals because of BLOOD and FLESH lust in the Synagogue.
They did not make Vocal or instrumental noises which meant to "Make the lambs dumb before the Slaughter."

THE APOSTLES AND ELDERS DID NOT MAKE ANY DOCTRINAL DECISIONS:

Then pleased it the apostles and elders, with the whole church,
         to send chosen men of their own company to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas;
         namely, Judas surnamed Barsabas, and Silas, chief men among the brethren: Acts 15:22

And they wrote letters by them after this manner; The apostles and elders and brethren send greeting unto the brethren which are of the Gentiles in Antioch and Syria and Cilicia: Acts 15:23

THE LETTER WAS TO PROVE WHAT THEY HAD NOT COMMANDED:

Forasmuch as we have heard,
        that certain which went out from us have troubled you with words,
        subverting your souls,
              saying, Ye must be circumcised,
              and keep the law:
              to whom we gave no such commandment: Acts 15:24

Those who tell you to be circumcised and keep the Law are SUBVERTING YOUR SOULS: INTENTIONALLY.
Those who practice the female form of worship intended to AROUSE your spirit are VIOLATING the clear commands of the Apostles.
Those who appeal to the Levites (an old baby burning cult from Egypt) and burning the GOATS with the instruments of the King and commanders of the ARMY to COMMAND YOU to imitate that PATTERNISM have imposed one law and are therefore GUILT of violating all 613 and there can be no redemption.

Those who GO OUT from the BIBLE AS AUTHORITY impose the SAME sacrificial noise--defined to exclude MUSIC--
Are those TO WHOM GOD GAVE NO SUCH COMMANDMENT.

It was the Spirit OF Christ Who spoke through the PROPHETS: never through kings and priests.

Jesus said my WORDS are SPIRIT and LIFE (John 6:63)

Christ as THE Spirit laid out the PATTERNISM of CENI in the prophets.
These were the primary resource for the Synagogue: The Bible was open to Isaiah when Jesus STOOD UP to read and then decently SAT DOWN. That was, is and ever shall be THE UNIQUE inclusive and exclusive patternism.

Is. 8:19 And when they shall say unto you,
      Seek unto them that have familiar spirits,  (old WINESKINS)
      and unto wizards that peep, and that mutter:  (musical sounds)
      should not a people seek unto their God? for the living to the dead?
Is. 8:20 To the law and to the testimony:
      if they speak not according to this word,
      it is because there is no light in them.
Is. 8:21 And they shall pass through it, hardly bestead and hungry:
      and it shall come to pass, that when they shall be hungry,
      they shall fret themselves, and curse their king and their God, and look upward.


LightHammer

The wedding of Christ, The Groom and the Bride, His Church is limited only to those of the Catholic submission? How impudent. But I'm still loving this debate way too much to falter now.

As a Protestant I will not deny that the Church has authority. Rather than being a Sola Scriptura I think it would be more accurate to refer to me as a Prima Scritpura. But I have to be honest in saying that the Church is NOT limited to those denominations of the one Catholic communion.

John 2
19Jesus answered and said unto them, Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.

20Then said the Jews, Forty and six years was this temple in building, and wilt thou rear it up in three days?

21But he spake of the temple of his body.


In Judaism the temple is the ONLY place the Spirit of God would descend. Other than the prophets who received special commute with the Spirit of God the priest were the only ones who received the truth of God and therefore taught the masses. Thats why the only road to salvation was to become a Jew under the Old Law.

Here Christ clearly refers to the Temple being rebuilt as the body of the true believer who shoulders his cross. This came to be by Christ death burial and resurrection.

John 14
15"If you love me, you will obey what I command.  16And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Counselor to be with you forever--  17the Spirit of truth. The world cannot accept him, because it neither sees him nor knows him. But you know him, for he lives with you and will be[3] in you. 18I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you.  19Before long, the world will not see me anymore, but you will see me. Because I live, you also will live.  20On that day you will realize that I am in my Father, and you are in me, and I am in you.  21Whoever has my commands and obeys them, he is the one who loves me. He who loves me will be loved by my Father, and I too will love him and show myself to him."


Notice throughout this passage how Christ is repetitive in using phrases like "in you" "in me" and "in my Father". Christ is promising the establishing of a spiritual union between the spirit of the true believer and His own. Now although I don't think any Catholic would disagree with what Ive said so far, I do think you argue that Christ limited this to leaders of the Church.


Acts 2:17And it shall come to pass in the last days, saith God, I will pour out of my Spirit upon all flesh: and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams:

18And on my servants and on my handmaidens I will pour out in those days of my Spirit; and they shall prophesy:
[/color]

Actually Peter Himself quoted this after some in the crowd who didn't receive the Holy Spirit began to mock those who did as being drunk. Look at the words in the texts "sons" "daughters" "servants" "handmaidens". These are words used to describe those who take up the cross for Christ as He did for man. Tell me you don't limit such attributes to only Catholics.

Now if the Holy Spirit resides within each individual heart of each individual believer then collectively those followers are the Bride meant for Christ. Then collectively they are the Church that Israel was meant give birth to through her pain and suffering. Then collectively the Universal Church isnt limited to the Catholic Church.


This is the foundation of my belief on the True Church. If you want to discuss this topic with me start by tackling this. I would happily submit to Church authority. I know that if there are disputes over christian doctrine at the end of the day the leaders of the Churh were meant to make the call.

The Authority of the Church is not in question here.

What is the True Church?

Lets begin.

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 06:11:50
I think you misunderstand my position. You're going off halfcocked because you think I undermind the role of the disciples. For some reason you're acting like you're defending the honor of the leaders of the early church or something. I honor and respect the early followers as men greater than I could ever hope to be. I know full and well which physical hands wrote the Bible but I will never honor men with credit that belongs to God.  I would never utter the words

QuoteIt was the Church that wrote the Bible, compiled it together and cannonized it.

This is false. God wrote the Bible compiled it together and cannonized it. Your Catholic leaders were the ones He chose to do this through because they were the ONLY christian power in such a position to impact the world at the time.

My brother, it was men inspired by the Holy Spirit who wrote the Bible.  And it was men guided by the Holy Spirit who compiled it together and cannonized it.  That is the Truth.  As I said, the Bible didn't just appear out of the sky.  God does not make us into mindless puppets."  It wasn't me who went halfcocked because it was not me who used the term "mindless puppets."  To say that these Church leaders who cannonized the books were mindless puppets undermind the role of the Holy Spirit who was there guiding these Church leaders.  And if that is what you actually think of our Church leaders who were guided by the Holy Spirit, then you also believe that those who wrote the New Testament were also mindless puppets.  This is a false misconception of how the Holy Spirit works.  The truth is - it was the Catholic Church (under the guidance of the Holy Spirit) that compiled together and cannonized the books. 

Furthermore, the Catholics were not the only Christians who were in existance in the fourth century.  The Arians and the Gnostics existed.  If the Holy Spirit wanted to choose them to cannonize the books,  He would regardless of how powerful the Catholics were at the time.  Afterall, God chose a small shepherd boy with no military skills named David to defeat a warrior like Goliath; therefore, God can also choose a small group of Gnostics or even Arians who believe in Jesus to carry out His Will.  However, the fact is - He did not choose them.     


larry2


Outside the Church No Salvation

1.   The axiom is a revealed truth which must be believed by Catholics:

2.    The axiom means that Christ commands all men to be baptized into the Catholic Church and to remain therein, united to the pope, who is the Vicar of Christ on earth. Hence anyone knowing of this strict command of Christ and refusing to obey it cannot be saved.

Selene addressing LightHammer - My brother, (Reply #85)

Dear Selene, did you not read the above directive concerning those commanded to join the Catholic Church and remain united to the Pope? How can you possibly address someone as your Christian brother that is going to hell according to your religion? And then are you not also commanded to believe everything 100% they say.

So far I can think of six of us on this thread going to hell by your church's standards, and even possibly any Roman Catholic that messes up and misses a holy day of obligation for instance, or am I wrong?

Selene

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 18:02:14

Outside the Church No Salvation

1.   The axiom is a revealed truth which must be believed by Catholics:

2.    The axiom means that Christ commands all men to be baptized into the Catholic Church and to remain therein, united to the pope, who is the Vicar of Christ on earth. Hence anyone knowing of this strict command of Christ and refusing to obey it cannot be saved.

Selene addressing LightHammer - My brother, (Reply #85)

Dear Selene, did you not read the above directive concerning those commanded to join the Catholic Church and remain united to the Pope? How can you possibly address someone as your Christian brother that is going to hell according to your religion? And then are you not also commanded to believe everything 100% they say.

So far I can think of six of us on this thread going to hell by your church's standards, and even possibly any Roman Catholic that messes up and misses a holy day of obligation for instance, or am I wrong?

The term "extra ecclesiam nulla salus" (Outside the Church, there is no salvation) does not mean that ONLY Catholics are saved.   This phrase has often been misinterpreted.  Below is a weblink that explains it better:  

http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0043.html

Ryan2010

Quote
The wedding of Christ, The Groom and the Bride, His Church is limited only to those of the Catholic submission?

I am not sure if you are replying to me here.  I am not Roman Catholic.   At the same time I think I addressed this earlier when I said that from the Orthodox perspective that The Church is not necessarily a proclamation on one's "salvation".  

In other words if I recognize that you do not recognize The Church I can't say, "you are not saved".  What I am saying when I say, 'The Church' is not bound up in your theology on what you believe Church is.  You can't juxtapose your understanding of what Church is onto Orthodoxy.  

Again, I am not Roman Catholic.  I believe that the Eastern Orthodox Church is the One True Church.  And again, to say only an Orthodox person will be "saved", in the way you understand it, would be presumptuous and false.  

QuoteThis is the foundation of my belief on the True Church. If you want to discuss this topic with me start by tackling this. I would happily submit to Church authority. I know that if there are disputes over christian doctrine at the end of the day the leaders of the Churh were meant to make the call.

What is the True Church?

Lets begin.

I did post that article for you to read so that some of these questions might be addressed and we could move beyond some of the common reactions that occur when this topic comes up.  Here's just a portion of the beginning of what I posted on The Church.

Now I went through and bolded what I believe pertains to your reply.  See if it doesn't address what it is you were talking about.  

If you read the entire article I posted it will give you a bit more than what you might be able to glean from our casual conversation.  It's called, Does Orthodoxy Really Think It Is the "True Church"?  


***

First, the most common understanding is that the Church in its essence is spiritual, is primarily built by adding to its numbers people who believe in Jesus Christ as the Son of God as their personal savior and who have their names written in the Lamb's book of Life spoken of in Revelations. This Church is one, connected by their devotion to Jesus Christ, and will only be fully manifested as such in the last days when Jesus Christ will return for His Church. Until then, the visible manifestation of the Church on Earth is divided by differing theologies on various points, various governing bodies and groups which in and of themselves are known to not be the fullness of the Church. They are only partially the Church in as much as there are true Christians in them, in as much as their theology reflects true Biblical theology, and to the degree that God can be seen to work in and through a particular group bearing the name "Christian".

Secondly, there are some groups who bear the name "Christian", while in the minority, consider themselves to be the Church and the sole people who will be "saved" in the end. To be part of the Church and to be saved one must join their group or participate in their rituals. This is the basic antithesis to the other view that no one group can claim to be "The Church".

Within these broad categories, various groups will "draw the line" at different points, excluding some groups that others might include. It is a mixed bag and there are no hard and fast rules as to where one might find the "Church" on earth. Part of this comes from a very personalized relationship with Christ in many quarters of Protestantism, so much so that a corporate Body is a secondary, and in some cases, an unnecessary issue.

It should be evident to most Orthodox, if they readily understand this divergence, why it so goes against most Protestants to say that the Orthodox Church is the fullness of The Church. On the one hand, to say that goes against the Protestant foundation of what it means to be the Church and is usually interpreted as "you are on the outside and will not be saved unless you join our group." For the others who believe they are the Church, it is like two children saying "I'm the Church," "No, I'm the Church!"

These reactions, while understandable for one coming from a Protestant background, are reacting to Protestant understandings superimposed upon Orthodoxy, and not upon Orthodoxy's understanding of itself. So it is critical that we look at what the Orthodox understanding is. Before we do that, however, it will be helpful to look at what the Orthodox understanding of the Church does not say.

When the Orthodox Church says that it is "The Church", they are making no pronouncement upon the salvation of anyone inside or outside membership in Orthodoxy. This may be hard for Protestants to grasp since being saved and being part of The Church is practically synonymous when linked to the spiritual Church. The knowledge that not everyone, let's say, in the Baptist Churches will be saved only serves to reinforce the fact that the Baptist Church cannot say it is "The Church". Yet, they also firmly believe that there are many who will be saved, so neither can one say that any other group is "The Church."

While Orthodoxy does believe that ultimately to be saved means being in the Church and those outside the Church will not be saved, that issue is not fully decided until judgment day. Because salvation is not looked at within Orthodoxy as either an in or out position but a journey into God. We readily recognize that anyone inside or outside the Church at any particular point in time can be in the currents of salvation or not participating in it. Thus, there is no ability to point to any one person either inside or outside the visible Church and say they are saved or not saved. Whether any one particular person is going to make it to heaven we leave in God's hands. We cannot know the heart of the person, much less the disposition of God towards a particular individual short of God revealing that to us.

Orthodoxy also does not say that the visible governing body of hierarchs and the organizations that are called the Orthodox Church are in and of themselves "The Church".
This is an understandable confusion because what is generally labeled as synonymous with the visible church in Protestant circles, if they have any concept of that, is the governing body, the denomination or local church. It is by becoming a member of such-and-such group that one attaches themselves with like-minded Christians and is called "a church" in a visible aspect. Therefore, when a group says it is "The Church", Protestants will tend to think that the group is claiming that their fellowship, their organization, their denomination or local church body is a one-to-one equivalent to all those names written down in the Book of Life.


Read the Entire Article:
http://www.gracecentered.com/christian_forums/catholic-forum/does-orthodoxy-really-think-it-is-the-%27true-church%27/



ICXC

desertknight

Quote from: SeleneThe term "extra ecclesiam nulla salus" (Outside the Church, there is no salvation) does not mean that ONLY Catholics are saved.

For one thing, it may include those who can receive sacramental grace outside of the Church through their maintaining of proper Apostolic authority in their priesthood and correct intent and action in those sacraments,  like our Eastern Orthodox bros.  ::smile::

Ryan2010

#90
Quote from: Selene on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 18:22:19
Quote from: larry2 on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 18:02:14

Outside the Church No Salvation

1.   The axiom is a revealed truth which must be believed by Catholics:

2.    The axiom means that Christ commands all men to be baptized into the Catholic Church and to remain therein, united to the pope, who is the Vicar of Christ on earth. Hence anyone knowing of this strict command of Christ and refusing to obey it cannot be saved.

Selene addressing LightHammer - My brother, (Reply #85)

Dear Selene, did you not read the above directive concerning those commanded to join the Catholic Church and remain united to the Pope? How can you possibly address someone as your Christian brother that is going to hell according to your religion? And then are you not also commanded to believe everything 100% they say.

So far I can think of six of us on this thread going to hell by your church's standards, and even possibly any Roman Catholic that messes up and misses a holy day of obligation for instance, or am I wrong?

The term "extra ecclesiam nulla salus" (Outside the Church, there is no salvation) does not mean that ONLY Catholics are saved.   This phrase has often been misinterpreted.  Below is a weblink that explains it better:  

http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0043.html

Thank you for this Selene. I've not read a Roman Catholic apologetic on this before.  


ICXC

larry2


Dear Saline, I do understand the lessening of the strictness of the original axiom as the one I pasted, but have they really changed their stance on recognizing  that Christ commands all men to be baptized into the Catholic Church and to remain therein, united to the pope, who is the Vicar of Christ on earth. Can one knowing of this ever be saved?

Thanks.

Selene

Quote from: larry2 on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 19:19:59

Dear Saline, I do understand the lessening of the strictness of the original axiom as the one I pasted, but have they really changed their stance on recognizing  that Christ commands all men to be baptized into the Catholic Church and to remain therein, united to the pope, who is the Vicar of Christ on earth. Can one knowing of this ever be saved?

Thanks.

Dear Larry, Salvation comes only through Jesus Christ.  This is what the Church have always taught.  The Catholic Church still wants all men to be united to God's true Church and to Him.  This is the reason Christ sent men out to evangelize.  But it was never the Church who determines who is saved or who is not saved.  The Church cannot judge the hearts of men.  Only God can judge.   The phrase "Outside the Church, there is no salvation" expresses an understanding of the Church in relation to her role in the salvation of the world.   It doesn't mean that only baptized Catholics are saved.   

larry2


Dear Selene, I'm glad to hear you say that because that is certainly not the way it was taught to me some near fifty years ago. I knew that as does anyone else that has read the Bible, but I would venture a guess that if you questioned every Catholic you came into contact with what interpretation of that Axiom they would have, the answer you wold get.

Thanks and God bless you in Jesus' name.

LightHammer

QuoteMy brother, it was men inspired by the Holy Spirit who wrote the Bible.  And it was men guided by the Holy Spirit who compiled it together and cannonized it.  That is the Truth.  As I said, the Bible didn't just appear out of the sky.  God does not make us into mindless puppets."  It wasn't me who went halfcocked because it was not me who used the term "mindless puppets."  To say that these Church leaders who cannonized the books were mindless puppets undermind the role of the Holy Spirit who was there guiding these Church leaders.  And if that is what you actually think of our Church leaders who were guided by the Holy Spirit, then you also believe that those who wrote the New Testament were also mindless puppets.  This is a false misconception of how the Holy Spirit works.  The truth is - it was the Catholic Church (under the guidance of the Holy Spirit) that compiled together and cannonized the books.

So if a blind mind has his best friend write down his ideas as he's brainstorming and then has this friend organized the ideas into a novel as he instructs him to who is the author? Is the credit due to the blind man who is the author of the thoughts and ideals or to the friend who physically wrote down the ideas in which he contributed no thought(which is what I meant when I referred to the early disciples and Catholics as "mindless)?

QuoteFurthermore, the Catholics were not the only Christians who were in existance in the fourth century.  The Arians and the Gnostics existed.  If the Holy Spirit wanted to choose them to cannonize the books,  He would regardless of how powerful the Catholics were at the time.  Afterall, God chose a small shepherd boy with no military skills named David to defeat a warrior like Goliath; therefore, God can also choose a small group of Gnostics or even Arians who believe in Jesus to carry out His Will.  However, the fact is - He did not choose them. 


The Arians were followers of a rapidly decaying heresy and the Gnostics were no where near as influential or potentially devastating as the Catholic Church. There is no way around the facts Selene. The Catholic was literally the most powerful Christian titled organization of that time; because of anything Godly but because a few of the leaders reorganized in Rome during the height of Pax Romana. That is why God acted through them.

LightHammer

Still waiting for someone to tackle the scriptures I posted.

Ryan started to but didnt really comment on my scriptures.

Selene

#96
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 21:26:11
So if a blind mind has his best friend write down his ideas as he's brainstorming and then has this friend organized the ideas into a novel as he instructs him to who is the author? Is the credit due to the blind man who is the author of the thoughts and ideals or to the friend who physically wrote down the ideas in which he contributed no thought(which is what I meant when I referred to the early disciples and Catholics as "mindless)?

First of all, the Holy Spirit is not blind and He isn't human.  He definitely is NOT Hebrew. So, when He inspired the sacred authors to write, He didn't take away their knowlege or their minds.  The Apostles and our Church leaders who were inspired and guided by the Holy Spirit were not made "mindless" or even without thought as you assume.  For example, the Bible is filled with Hebrew idioms that came from the writer as he tries to dictate what the Holy Spirit is telling him.  We know that these Hebrew idioms came from the writer because the Holy Spirit is not Hebrew.  The writer hears what the Holy Spirit tells him, but he writes it in a way that he understood it according to his culture and the knowledge of his days.  

As an example, if the Holy Spirit tells me that I will win the volleyball game tonight, and I am to write it down, I may write, "Tonight, God says that I will slaughter the other team."  Now, 2000 years from now, someone might interpret what I wrote as me killing the other team with a weapon.  Why?  Because the word "slaughter" means to kill.  In the Bible, there are several Hebrew idioms like that.  So, the Holy Spirit never took away their minds.  The writers were not mindless or without thought.  

QuoteThe Arians were followers of a rapidly decaying heresy and the Gnostics were no where near as influential or potentially devastating as the Catholic Church. There is no way around the facts Selene. The Catholic was literally the most powerful Christian titled organization of that time; because of anything Godly but because a few of the leaders reorganized in Rome during the height of Pax Romana. That is why God acted through them.

If you read your Bible, you will know that God acts only through the weak, the humble, the poor, and through the greatest sinners.  He never chooses the strong, the wealthiest, or the greatest of men.  Abraham was chosen because he was old and his wife was barren.  God chose him to show everyone that it is God who can make an old man into a father of many nations and give life to a barren womb.  David was chosen to defeat Goliath because he was only a shpeherd boy with no military skills.  If God had chosen a strong warrior to defeat Goliath, everyone would think that it was the talent and skills of this strong warrior and NOT God's power who defeated Goliath.  So, David was chosen to show God's power.  And it was a woman who was chosen (Judith) by God to defeat an entire army.  St. Paul was a murderer of Christians and he was chosen by God.  The Catholics were chosen by God because God's true Church were filled with sinners.  



Ryan2010

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Apr 20, 2010 - 21:27:15
Still waiting for someone to tackle the scriptures I posted.

Ryan started to but didnt really comment on my scriptures.

The Orthodox view of The Church is in accordance with the scriptures you posted.  I posted what I had in hopes that you would then read on so that you don't misunderstand the Eastern Orthodox position.  If you read the beginning of that article and you know what it is we aren't saying then what do you believe the Orthodox ARE saying in regards to what Church is?

We aren't denying an invisible Church.   

What I am asking is how do you reconcile the visible Church?  Again, not talking about a building here or merely the offices of leadership. 

But take your definition of "church" and put it in the context of the NT when The Church decides on certain matters with authority.  It doesn't add up.  If I am to go to the Baptist or Methodist I will get two contradictory answers on elementary teachings.  But in the context of The Church as we read about in Hebrews, these elementary teachings are already in place.  These doctrines and traditions and teachings that the bible talks about have already been deposited into The Church. 

But if you ask individuals they arrive at different conclusions.  This doesn't square with The Church that we read about in the bible.  The Church in the bible has the elementary teachings.  Their elders have been ordained by those who have been ordained by Apostles or other elders that were ordained by the Apostles. 

Of course it's Christ through the Apostles but nontheless, this mark that is present in the bible is not found in the protestant collective.  The Church in the bible is not just invisible but also visible.  They had been appointed by Christ through real people and those who were appointed later appoint. 

The Apostles deposited the faith into The Church we read about in the bible but that deposit is not found in the bible itself.  If it were there would be no debate over those elementary teachings we read about in Hebrews. 

I mean, how do you reconcile this? 

If you were shown how to baptize by the Apostles themselves, would you doubt their instructions on baptisms?  No.  Because to receive the Apostles was to receive Christ.  Now, the elders who were taught by the Apostles who then instructed others, do you think that anyone would be confused as to how to baptize?  No. 

But when we try to side-step that very community that has continuity with those Christians we read about in our bibles then you wind up not having received what that community received, not only by letter but by ear, sight, mouth, touch and taste, mind, heart, soul.  It was deposited into that community.  You can't deduce those things by reading the bible. 

The difference is that you have a community that received those letters we call scripture now and they received far more than just letters.   ::groupprayer::  Here they are doing as they were shown to do and they haven't even received the letters we call scripture today.  They are liturgical and many aspects of their Christian lives are informed by the very things that the Apostles deposited into them  ::groupprayer::. 

Now one of the Apostles hears that in Corinth this and that is happening and so he writes them a letter.  So these guys  ::groupprayer:: receive a letter  ::reading::.  The overseers and elders read it and read it to The Church and so they correct that which is ALREADY in place.  They strayed from what was in place and so the letter is there. 

But now fast forward two thousand years and they print these letters so anyone can read them.  Most individuals don't know that this community  ::groupprayer:: still exists and so they just read it as if it is written to them personally  ::clappingoverhead::.   

This isn't necessarily bad but what happens is that they totally ignore this community that exists.  They have been taught by the Holy Spirit for two thousand years.  They have as a community faced heresies and all sorts of things that the Holy Spirit has brought them through and they have retained the lessons from those battles.  And the lessons they received from those battles enrich the community.  It is so rich with what they all collectively throughout all time experienced and learned. 

So because this community doesn't even show up on the radar of most people this guy  ::clappingoverhead:: decides to start up his own "church".  He ordains himself and ordains others and everyone that agrees with him gathers around him.   They teach things according to their own understanding. 

Meanwhile the guy across the street does the same thing and what they teach about who Christ is, is totally contradictory.  So on and so forth until you have tons of these groups.  And most people just see the point of truth as just picking and choosing what seems right to the individual.  You believe a little of this, I a little of that.  No one knows up from down but we still love Christ and so we must be The Church that is written about in the bible. 

But again, turn back the clock.  The Church has certain marks that can not just be side-stepped.  The Church was something you entered into.  It's not something you just started up or went off to do your own thing with.  Why?  Because The Faith was deposited into that very community. 

I don't mean a general proclamation that Jesus is Christ but in regards to the FULLNESS of the Truth.  It's like a well that has been gathering water for two thousand years and every drop is a doctrine or a lesson or just a plain ol' Mystery that has been put there to instruct and prepare humanity for the Reign of God to come. 

It's visible.  You can see it.  You can enter into it.  It has authority.  It has kept the traditions that those Christians were told to keep.  They were willing to have their eyes gouged out rather than pinch a little incense to a statue.  They kept The Faith that Christ delivered to them through the Apostles.  It has retained the doctrines from elementary to not so elementary.  It has defeated countless heresies so that you don't have to rediscover the wheel over and over and over.  The Church in it's fullness.  And the Holy Spirit doesn't teach contradictory things to those who enter in. 

You can have hands laid on you that have had hands laid on them who had hands laid on them by the Apostles who had hands laid on them by Christ himself.  You can be breathed on with the same breath that breathed on the Apostles through those the Apostles breathed on. 

Sounds crazy but it's right there in the bible. 

Laying on of hands is right there in the elementary teachings.  Do you think that the community that received those letters had not been instructed in what those things mean?  And more than this, even if they had not even paid attention to what was being instructed, they still would have participated in the laying on of hands.  They would know who it is that lays hands and in which way and when and in what context.  Children brought up in The Church would know what these things were as would their childrens children.  Not because they could read but because they were participating in the very community we read about in our bible. 

That community has not gone anywhere.  The difference between other communities and their own is that Christ through his Apostles instructed them, physically manifested himself through them to them.   They saw, touched, tasted, heard, smelled even those things that we shown to them by Christ through the Apostles. 

Remove the actual communities that we read about in our bibles and you remove the context and replace it with your own context, history and vacuum of experiences.  In short, you are forced to preserve disunity for the sake of the individual who believes they personally know what the bible means to say even though they totally disagree with the guy who is reading the very same bible next to him.  The community becomes invisible to you and so it is believed that all communities must be invisible. 

But again, who then do you tell it to the Church?

How then do you keep the traditions if you have not received them? 

How then do you keep what was both written and transmitted by word of mouth?

How then do you know for certain the elementary teachings of Christ and have confidence in your maturity? (Hebrews 5-6)



the link: http://www.gracecentered.com/christian_forums/catholic-forum/does-orthodoxy-really-think-it-is-the-%27true-church%27/










LightHammer

#98
Selene

QuoteFirst of all, the Holy Spirit is not blind and He isn't human.  He definitely is NOT Hebrew. So, when He inspired the sacred authors to write, He didn't take away their knowlege or their minds.  The Apostles and our Church leaders who were inspired and guided by the Holy Spirit were not made "mindless" or even without thought as you assume.  For example, the Bible is filled with Hebrew idioms that came from the writer as he tries to dictate what the Holy Spirit is telling him.  We know that these Hebrew idioms came from the writer because the Holy Spirit is not Hebrew.  The writer hears what the Holy Spirit tells him, but he writes it in a way that he understood it according to his culture and the knowledge of his days.  

As an example, if the Holy Spirit tells me that I will win the volleyball game tonight, and I am to write it down, I may write, "Tonight, God says that I will slaughter the other team."  Now, 2000 years from now, someone might interpret what I wrote as me killing the other team with a weapon.  Why?  Because the word "slaughter" means to kill.  In the Bible, there are several Hebrew idioms like that.  So, the Holy Spirit never took away their minds.  The writers were not mindless or without thought.  

Well I would never say that the Holy Spirit is Hebrew. I never referred to the Holy Spirit as a blind human either. Apparently someone doesnt understand the word "analogy" or you just chose not to care.

I do like your point on using cultural idioms as the means to say that these men were influential in what the Holy Spirit was giving them. Honestly that was actually a decent point.

However if you recall the old scriptures, God validated His truth not only through the written word but in the tradition the Hebrew's so desperately clung to. Do you get where Im going with this? The truth was upheld not only through written texts which is referred to as the Holy Scriptures it was also upheld through word of mouth(mainly the mouth of one who held Jewish religious authority). This is called Sacred Tradition I think. So when the Holy Spirit worked through the old Jews HE purposely used Hebrew idioms in describing what He wanted. If you recall history, Israel was God's firstborn and the only path to salvation was becoming a Jew. So with this in mind there is no reason why the Holy Spirit would write scriptures with cultural idioms pointed at anyone other than who they were meant for. The Jews.

So that pretty much crushes about the only good point I found it that paragraph.


QuoteIf you read your Bible, you will know that God acts only through the weak, the humble, the poor, and through the greatest sinners.  He never chooses the strong, the wealthiest, or the greatest of men.  Abraham was chosen because he was old and his wife was barren.  God chose him to show everyone that it is God who can make an old man into a father of many nations and give life to a barren womb.  David was chosen to defeat Goliath because he was only a shpeherd boy with no military skills.  If God had chosen a strong warrior to defeat Goliath, everyone would think that it was the talent and skills of this strong warrior and NOT God's power who defeated Goliath.  So, David was chosen to show God's power.  And it was a woman who was chosen (Judith) by God to defeat an entire army.  St. Paul was a murderer of Christians and he was chosen by God.  The Catholics were chosen by God because God's true Church were filled with sinners.  


Ok there may not be any quotes but at least I got you using scripture in some format or another.

What you say is true but first answer me this question. (And when I say answer I mean like with less than a paragraph and try not to stray off into some other point without answering.)  

Now to the question.

What happened to the Arians and the Gnostics?

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Wed Apr 21, 2010 - 16:19:01
Selene

Well I would never say that the Holy Spirit is Hebrew. I never referred to the Holy Spirit as a blind human either. Apparently someone doesnt understand the word "analogy" or you just chose not to care.

I do like your point on using cultural idioms as the means to say that these men were influential in what the Holy Spirit was giving them. Honestly that was actually a decent point.

However if you recall the old scriptures, God validated His truth not only through the written word but in the tradition the Hebrew's so desperately clung to. Do you get where Im going with this? The truth was upheld not only through written texts which is referred to as the Holy Scriptures it was also upheld through word of mouth(mainly the mouth of one who held Jewish religious authority). This is called Sacred Tradition I think. So when the Holy Spirit worked through the old Jews HE purposely used Hebrew idioms in describing what He wanted. If you recall history, Israel was God's firstborn and the only path to salvation was becoming a Jew. So with this in mind there is no reason why the Holy Spirit would write scriptures with cultural idioms pointed at anyone other than who they were meant for. The Jews.

So that pretty much crushes about the only good point I found it that paragraph.

My brother, the whole point I made is that the Apostles and our Church leaders were not "mindless" as you assume. 

What you say is true but first answer me this question. (And when I say answer I mean like with less than a paragraph and try not to stray off into some other point without answering.) 

Now to the question.

What happened to the Arians and the Gnostics?
 

The Arians started to decline by the 8th century.  Today, they go by another name called "Unitarians" or "Nontrinitarian Christians."  As for the Gnostics, many of them converted to Islam while others continued to exist today and identify themselves as renewals or earlier Gnostic groups.  And Islam is the second largest monotheistic religion - second to Christianity and growing. 

LightHammer

QuoteMy brother, the whole point I made is that the Apostles and our Church leaders were not "mindless" as you assume.

I understand that and I totally respect your opinion. But I say that when the Holy Spirit worked in men, those men contributed nothing to the message which therefore makes them mindless. When it came to the Truth they didnt do anything besides write down what they saw or heard. Thats what Im saying.

QuoteThe Arians started to decline by the 8th century.  Today, they go by another name called "Unitarians" or "Nontrinitarian Christians."  As for the Gnostics, many of them converted to Islam while others continued to exist today and identify themselves as renewals or earlier Gnostic groups.  And Islam is the second largest monotheistic religion - second to Christianity and growing.

And what happened to Catholicism?

Selene

What exactly do you mean when you say "What happen to Catholicsm?"

LightHammer

The Gnostics seized to exist as christians in the modern world and the Arians still remain a powerless minority.

What happened to Catholicism? How is the catholic church doing in the modern world?

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Wed Apr 21, 2010 - 19:31:19
The Gnostics seized to exist as christians in the modern world and the Arians still remain a powerless minority.

What happened to Catholicism? How is the catholic church doing in the modern world?

The Gnostics didn't ceased to exist.  There are still here today and they claim to be Christians.  They are just a small minority.  Most of them converted to Islam, and one can even see Gnosticism in the Qu'ran.  As a matter of fact, most of the Qu'ran came from Gnostic literature.  As for the Catholics, they also exist in the modern world.  Of all the Christian denomination, the Catholics are the largest.   

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Wed Apr 21, 2010 - 19:51:58
Quote from: LightHammer on Wed Apr 21, 2010 - 19:31:19
The Gnostics seized to exist as christians in the modern world and the Arians still remain a powerless minority.

What happened to Catholicism? How is the catholic church doing in the modern world?

The Gnostics didn't ceased to exist.  There are still here today and they claim to be Christians.  They are just a small minority.  Most of them converted to Islam, and one can even see Gnosticism in the Qu'ran.  As a matter of fact, most of the Qu'ran came from Gnostic literature.  As for the Catholics, they also exist in the modern world.  Of all the Christian denomination, the Catholics are the largest.   

Of all the Christian denomination the Catholic organization is the largest.

So what do you think would have happened to the Truth if the Holy Spirit decided to wotk through the Arians or the Gnostics? You cant say that the Truth would've inspired them to growth because they beleieved their doctrines were truth regardless. They believed that the Holy Spirit worked through them regardless. And truth in men's heart is selective. As long as they believe something is truth then thats good enough.

So where would God's true message lie if the Holy Spirit decided to work through the Gnostics or the Arians?

+-Recent Topics

Upgrade madness by 4WD
Yesterday at 13:58:26

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 21:07:16

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 20, 2026 - 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal