News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898035
Total Topics: 90351
Most Online Today: 4207
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 3572
Total: 3573
The Barbarian
Google (2)

Universal Authority of Rome

Started by trifecta, Mon Apr 26, 2010 - 17:45:54

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

trifecta

Greetings all.

I want to briefly explain why Rome's claim to universal authority (of the Pope) is not historical.

1) The New Testament.
The Apostles in Matt 18:18 are given authority to forgive sins as is Peter. We see this repeated in the last chapter of the Gospel of John 20:23.  Peter is rebuked by Paul in Galatians 2.  I agree that Peter was the leader of the apostles, but this didn't give him to power to appoint apostles (as the Pope does today - see Acts 1) nor did it mean that Peter's opinion was more credible than the other apostles.  In Acts 15, it is James, the bishop of Jerusalem (NT does not say this, but it is logically), who announces the decision.   Peter was a leader of the 12, but his authority was definitely challengable.

2) Early Church History writings
We don't see any writings in the early church addressing the fact that the Bishop of Rome has 1) power to appoint bishops everything  2) enjoyed universal authority.
Why didn't Clement of Rome claim such authority in his letter to the Corinthians?
Cyprian of Carthage said plainly, There is no bishop of bishops.  The early church made decision by concensus, not by decision of one man.


3) Early Papal Attempt at Universal Authority.  In the early church, a Bishop of Rome wanted all places to celebrate Easter on the same day.  The Eastern sees said no thank you.  While in the long run, churches choose to have Easter on the same date (more or less), it was their decision, not Rome's. The east successfully rebuffed Rome's attempt to
make a unilateral decision.

4) Acts 15 and Ecumenical Councils - In Acts 15 we see a gathering of the entire church to resolve a circumcision issue.   In the 4th century, we see councils deciding on some important issues of the day.  If Rome had universal authority, why would councils exist deciding issues the Rome had authority for?   In fact, Rome opposed the 2nd council for a long time.   Two popes were anathematized in councils 4 and 5. 


Conclusion:  The RCC's claim to universal authority was not a claim believed by the early church.  In fact, the RCC says this idea developed over time.   Rome should return to being the Patriarchate of the West (a title given to it I think in the 5th century and retained until 2006), and admit that its claim to universal authority is not in agreement with the historical church.


Thank you for reading, especially if you disagree.


   

chestertonrules

#1
Quote from: trifecta on Mon Apr 26, 2010 - 17:45:54
Greetings all.

I want to briefly explain why Rome's claim to universal authority (of the Pope) is not historical.

1) The New Testament.
The Apostles in Matt 18:18 are given authority to forgive sins as is Peter. We see this repeated in the last chapter of the Gospel of John 20:23.  Peter is rebuked by Paul in Galatians 2.  I agree that Peter was the leader of the apostles, but this didn't give him to power to appoint apostles (as the Pope does today - see Acts 1) nor did it mean that Peter's opinion was more credible than the other apostles.  In Acts 15, it is James, the bishop of Jerusalem (NT does not say this, but it is logically), who announces the decision.   Peter was a leader of the 12, but his authority was definitely challengable.

2) Early Church History writings
We don't see any writings in the early church addressing the fact that the Bishop of Rome has 1) power to appoint bishops everything  2) enjoyed universal authority.
Why didn't Clement of Rome claim such authority in his letter to the Corinthians?
Cyprian of Carthage said plainly, There is no bishop of bishops.  The early church made decision by concensus, not by decision of one man.


3) Early Papal Attempt at Universal Authority.  In the early church, a Bishop of Rome wanted all places to celebrate Easter on the same day.  The Eastern sees said no thank you.  While in the long run, churches choose to have Easter on the same date (more or less), it was their decision, not Rome's. The east successfully rebuffed Rome's attempt to
make a unilateral decision.

4) Acts 15 and Ecumenical Councils - In Acts 15 we see a gathering of the entire church to resolve a circumcision issue.   In the 4th century, we see councils deciding on some important issues of the day.  If Rome had universal authority, why would councils exist deciding issues the Rome had authority for?   In fact, Rome opposed the 2nd council for a long time.   Two popes were anathematized in councils 4 and 5.  


Conclusion:  The RCC's claim to universal authority was not a claim believed by the early church.  In fact, the RCC says this idea developed over time.   Rome should return to being the Patriarchate of the West (a title given to it I think in the 5th century and retained until 2006), and admit that its claim to universal authority is not in agreement with the historical church.


Thank you for reading, especially if you disagree.


 


It is not a matter of the authority of Rome, but of the universal authority of the Church.   Did Jesus establish a Church with order and hierarchy?  Early Fathers seem to agree that he did:


Cyprian of Carthage

"The Lord says to Peter: 'I say to you,' he says, 'that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church.' . . . On him [Peter] he builds the Church, and to him he gives the command to feed the sheep [John 21:17], and although he assigns a like power to all the apostles, yet he founded a single chair [cathedra], and he established by his own authority a source and an intrinsic reason for that unity. Indeed, the others were that also which Peter was [i.e., apostles], but a primacy is given to Peter, whereby it is made clear that there is but one Church and one chair. So too, all [the apostles] are shepherds, and the flock is shown to be one, fed by all the apostles in single-minded accord. If someone does not hold fast to this unity of Peter, can he imagine that he still holds the faith? If he [should] desert the chair of Peter upon whom the Church was built, can he still be confident that he is in the Church?" (The Unity of the Catholic Church 4; 1st edition [A.D. 251]).


Augustine



"Among these [apostles] Peter alone almost everywhere deserved to represent the whole Church. Because of that representation of the Church, which only he bore, he deserved to hear 'I will give to you the keys of the kingdom of heaven'" (Sermons 295:2 [A.D. 411]).

"Some things are said which seem to relate especially to the apostle Peter, and yet are not clear in their meaning unless referred to the Church, which he is acknowledged to have represented in a figure on account of the primacy which he bore among the disciples. Such is 'I will give unto you the keys of the kingdom of heaven,' and other similar passages. In the same way, Judas represents those Jews who were Christ's enemies" (Commentary on Psalm 108 1 [A.D. 415]).

"Who is ignorant that the first of the apostles is the most blessed Peter?" (Commentary on John 56:1 [A.D. 416]).




"The Lord says to Peter: 'I say to you,' he says, 'that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church.' . . . On him [Peter] he builds the Church, and to him he gives the command to feed the sheep [John 21:17], and although he assigns a like power to all the apostles, yet he founded a single chair [cathedra], and he established by his own authority a source and an intrinsic reason for that unity. Indeed, the others were that also which Peter was [i.e., apostles], but a primacy is given to Peter, whereby it is made clear that there is but one Church and one chair. So too, all [the apostles] are shepherds, and the flock is shown to be one, fed by all the apostles in single-minded accord. If someone does not hold fast to this unity of Peter, can he imagine that he still holds the faith? If he [should] desert the chair of Peter upon whom the Church was built, can he still be confident that he is in the Church?" (The Unity of the Catholic Church 4; 1st edition [A.D. 251]).


Tertullian



"For though you think that heaven is still shut up, remember that the Lord left the keys of it to Peter here, and through him to the Church, which keys everyone will carry with him if he has been questioned and made a confession [of faith]" (Antidote Against the Scorpion 10 [A.D. 211]).

"[T]he Lord said to Peter, 'On this rock I will build my Church, I have given you the keys of the kingdom of heaven [and] whatever you shall have bound or loosed on earth will be bound or loosed in heaven' [Matt. 16:18–19]. . . . Upon you, he says, I will build my Church; and I will give to you the keys, not to the Church" (Modesty 21:9–10 [A.D. 220]).


St. John Chrysostom, Patriarch of Constantinople (c. 387)

Peter himself the Head or Crown of the Apostles, the First in the Church, the Friend of Christ, who received a revelation, not from man, but from the Father, as the Lord bears witness to him, saying, 'Blessed art thou, This very Peter and when I name Peter I name that unbroken Rock, that firm Foundation, the Great Apostle, First of the disciples, the First called, and the First who obeyed he was guilty ...even denying the Lord." (Chrysostom, T. ii. Hom)

Peter, the Leader of the choir of Apostles, the Mouth of the disciples, the Pillar of the Church, the Buttress of the faith, the Foundation of the confession, the Fisherman of the universe. (Chrysostom, T. iii Hom).

Peter, that Leader of the choir, that Mouth of the rest of the Apostles, that Head of the brotherhood, that one set over the entire universe, that Foundation of the Church. (Chrys. In illud hoc Scitote)

(Peter), the foundation of the Church, the Coryphaeus of the choir of the Apostles, the vehement lover of Christ ...he who ran throughout the whole world, who fished the whole world; this holy Coryphaeus of the blessed choir; the ardent disciple, who was entrusted with the keys of heaven, who received the spiritual revelation. Peter, the mouth of all Apostles, the head of that company, the ruler of the whole world. (De Eleemos, iii. 4; Hom. de decem mille tal. 3)

Theodoret, Bishop of Cyrus in Syria (450)
A native of Antioch, Theodoret ruled under the Antiochean Patriarch.

I therefore beseech your holiness to persuade the most holy and blessed bishop (Pope Leo) to use his Apostolic power, and to order me to hasten to your Council. For that most holy throne (Rome) has the sovereignty over the churches throughout the universe on many grounds. (Theodoret, Tom. iv. Epist. cxvi. Renato, p. 1197).

If Paul, the herald of the truth, the trumpet of the Holy Spirit, hastened to the great Peter, to convey from him the solution to those in Antioch, who were at issue about living under the law, how much more do we, poor and humble, run to the Apostolic Throne (Rome) to receive from you (Pope Leo) healing for wounds of the the Churches. For it pertains to you to have primacy in all things; for your throne is adorned with many prerogatives. (Theodoret Ibid, Epistle Leoni)


St. Proclus, Patriarch of Constantinople (434):
A disciple of St. John Chrysostom

Peter, the coryphaeus of the disciples, and the one set over (or chief of) the Apostles. Art not thou he that didst say, 'Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God'? Thou Bar-Jonas (son of the dove) hast thou seen so many miracles, and art thou still but Simon (a hearer)? He appointed thee the key-bearer of Heaven, and has though not yet layed aside thy fisherman's clothing? (Proclus, Or. viii In Dom. Transfig. t. ix. Galland)
John Cassian, Monk (c. 430)

That great man, the disciple of disciples, that master among masters, who wielding the government of the Roman Church possessed the principle authority in faith and in priesthood. Tell us, therefore, we beg of you, Peter, prince of Apostles, tell us how the Churches must believe in God (Cassian, Contra Nestorium, III, 12, CSEL, vol. 17, p. 276).

CDHealy

The primacy of the Roman bishop is a fairly well-established historical fact.  No one doubts that Rome was given place of chief honor.  And there was a limited acknowledgement that this primacy of honor was also useful in settling some disputes between patriarchates.

The problem, however, is that there is *zero* historical fact that Rome exercised universal jurisdiction over the Church.  This is not supported by any of the canons nor by the consensus of the historical documents.

Primacy does not equal universal jurisdiction.

chestertonrules

#3
Quote from: CDHealy on Tue Apr 27, 2010 - 22:58:31
The primacy of the Roman bishop is a fairly well-established historical fact.  No one doubts that Rome was given place of chief honor.  And there was a limited acknowledgement that this primacy of honor was also useful in settling some disputes between patriarchates.

The problem, however, is that there is *zero* historical fact that Rome exercised universal jurisdiction over the Church.  This is not supported by any of the canons nor by the consensus of the historical documents.

Primacy does not equal universal jurisdiction.

This seems like a semantics argument to me.  Primacy is primacy.

Without a leader, disunity is inevitable.  This is evident in Christianity outside of Catholicism.

CDHealy

Yes, primacy is primacy.  But it's not universal jurisdiction.  Equivocating on the matter won't change the historical facts.

We do have a leader, Jesus Christ.  But we do not need a single administrative head here on earth.  The Orthodox Church (of which I am a member), has her bishops which lead her flock, and like Acts 15, our bishops work in collegiality, mirroring the cooperation of the Persons of the Holy Trinity.  The fact that I, being a member of the Orthodox Church of Antioch, can commune in any Greek, Russian, Serbian, Bulgarian, [insert ethnicity here] Orthodox Church is proof that we are not divided but are in full communion (united) with one another.  Without a single administrative head here on earth.

mclees8

Quote from: CDHealy on Wed Apr 28, 2010 - 05:37:12
Yes, primacy is primacy.  But it's not universal jurisdiction.  Equivocating on the matter won't change the historical facts.

We do have a leader, Jesus Christ.  But we do not need a single administrative head here on earth.  The Orthodox Church (of which I am a member), has her bishops which lead her flock, and like Acts 15, our bishops work in collegiality, mirroring the cooperation of the Persons of the Holy Trinity.  The fact that I, being a member of the Orthodox Church of Antioch, can commune in any Greek, Russian, Serbian, Bulgarian, [insert ethnicity here] Orthodox Church is proof that we are not divided but are in full communion (united) with one another.  Without a single administrative head here on earth.

My dad can whip your dad.   ::preachit::

















chestertonrules

Quote from: CDHealy on Wed Apr 28, 2010 - 05:37:12
Yes, primacy is primacy.  But it's not universal jurisdiction.  Equivocating on the matter won't change the historical facts.

We do have a leader, Jesus Christ.  But we do not need a single administrative head here on earth.  The Orthodox Church (of which I am a member), has her bishops which lead her flock, and like Acts 15, our bishops work in collegiality, mirroring the cooperation of the Persons of the Holy Trinity.  The fact that I, being a member of the Orthodox Church of Antioch, can commune in any Greek, Russian, Serbian, Bulgarian, [insert ethnicity here] Orthodox Church is proof that we are not divided but are in full communion (united) with one another.  Without a single administrative head here on earth.

And yet a Catholic is permitted to receive communion in an Orthodox Church when necessary, but an Orthodox Christian is not permitted(by the Orthodox Church) to commune in a Catholic Church.

The division arose when the Orthodox left Rome, which has primacy in the Church.  How can you claim that you have not divided the Church?

Jesus gave the keys to a single person. 

CDHealy

As part of canonical discipline, no non-Orthodox is allowed to receive communion in an Orthodox Liturgy.  If such happens it mostly happens because the celebrant(s) are unaware (though they should be), or there is a local economia (like a dispensation) from the local bishop.

I know that Rome allows Orthodox to receive communion in their Masses, but Orthodox are not supposed to do so (unless under economia from the local bishop) and could be excommunicated for a time as a means of discipline if it becomes known.

As to who divided from whom, I remind you it was the papal legate who first placed the bull of excommunication for the Patriarch of Constantinople . . . on the altar in Constantinople . . . during the Nativity Liturgy.

Jesus did not give the keys to a single person.  Cf. 20.21ff

desertknight

#8
Quote from: CDHealy on Wed Apr 28, 2010 - 12:26:44
As part of canonical discipline, no non-Orthodox is allowed to receive communion in an Orthodox Liturgy.  If such happens it mostly happens because the celebrant(s) are unaware (though they should be), or there is a local economia (like a dispensation) from the local bishop.

I know that Rome allows Orthodox to receive communion in their Masses, but Orthodox are not supposed to do so (unless under economia from the local bishop) and could be excommunicated for a time as a means of discipline if it becomes known.

As to who divided from whom, I remind you it was the papal legate who first placed the bull of excommunication for the Patriarch of Constantinople . . . on the altar in Constantinople . . . during the Nativity Liturgy.

Jesus did not give the keys to a single person.  Cf. 20.21ff

Both cases are far more common than you may think.  I as a Catholic, attended and received Holy Communion from an Ethiopian Orthodox, (Oriental Orthodox), church while living in Oakland CA.  I went to my diocese who immediately approved and required only the local Ethiopian priests who also immediately approved after asking me only two questions, 1. Did I believe that the consecrated elements of bread and wine to be the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of our Lord, Jesus Christ?  2.  Did I believe that by eating His Flesh and drinking His Blood that I would have life eternal?  That being done, I was accepted to receive.

It is a common practice in the armed forces that Catholic chaplains, far outnumbering their Eastern Orthodox brothers, minister to Eastern and Oriental Orthodox service members.  I assume they have an agreement with the authoritative Orthodox bishops, but it was common for Orthodox service members to attend Catholic Masses and receive Holy Eucharist with us.

 

chestertonrules

Quote from: CDHealy on Wed Apr 28, 2010 - 12:26:44


Jesus did not give the keys to a single person.  Cf. 20.21ff

Yes he did.  All the apostles were given the authority to bind and loose, but only Peter was given the keys.

CDHealy

Quote from: desertknight on Wed Apr 28, 2010 - 13:36:00Both cases are far more common than you may think.  I as a Catholic, attended and received Holy Communion from an Ethiopian Orthodox, (Oriental Orthodox), church while living in Oakland CA.  I went to my diocese who immediately approved and required only the local Ethiopian priests who also immediately approved after asking me only two questions, 1. Did I believe that the consecrated elements of bread and wine to be the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of our Lord, Jesus Christ?  2.  Did I believe that by eating His Flesh and drinking His Blood that I would have life eternal?  That being done, I was accepted to receive.

It is a common practice in the armed forces that Catholic chaplains, far outnumbering their Eastern Orthodox brothers, minister to Eastern and Oriental Orthodox service members.  I assume they have an agreement with the authoritative Orthodox bishops, but it was common for Orthodox service members to attend Catholic Masses and receive Holy Eucharist with us.

I don't dispute your anecdotal evidence, but I also know several Orthodox service members for whom their experience is different than what you are suggestion.  And in any case, you merely affirm what I said.

+-Recent Topics

John 20:22 by pppp
Today at 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Today at 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Today at 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Today at 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Yesterday at 12:56:12

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Huguenots by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:11:46

Gibbon\Rome by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:07:07

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:05:00

Powered by EzPortal