News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898078
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 1685
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1180
Total: 1180

Is Public School Evil?

Started by Richard, Fri Oct 11, 2002 - 15:31:16

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

MASouth

Looking at the bigger picture, the world is evil.  Children of God are in the world but are not of the world.  We have to function in an evil world.  This is hard for me to accept a lot of times as I am very politically active and I cannot muster a good sense of humor.

I have debated the homeschool vs public in my mind for a long time.  We recently moved to a new city where the schools reflect stronger moral values than our former city, which in my opinion was extremely corrupt.  Our state board of education has mandated a system of upholding moral values in the classroom called \"Charater Counts\" where noble values such as honesty, courage, and respect are discussed and encouraged.  In our former city mere lip service was paid to these values and they preferred to teach that Heather has two mommies.  In the new one there are billboards proclaiming that \"(Such and Such Town) is a Character Counts Community\" and extreme social agendas would not be considered.  Our daughter's teacher has fine moral character and has very high expectations.

What I think it is boiling down to is that our public schools have fallen prey to political agendas and socialism on the grand scale.  But there are some schools and teachers who pay lip service to that and try to do what they believe is right. And they can do so since the state cannot be in every classroom at every moment. (I am sure it is looking for ways to so, however.)


I do not homeschool because I don't think I would be good at it. I am trying to adjust to the attitude that my daughter must learn to be in the world and not of it.  This is really difficult because mothers want to naturally shield and protect. This is what prompted our move to a more morally conservative city!  Yet, I must remember that many of those who are morally conservative may still be of the world.  I have to teach and train my children in the ways of God and pray they will choose them when they are grown.

MaSouth

david johnson

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote (Richard @ Oct. 11 2002,10:01)[/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]I have a question for the group.
There is a small but vocal group in our church who proclaim that the Public School system is evil and that anyone who works for, teaches in, supports, or sends their kids to Public Schools need to repent of their sin, quit their jobs, and/or homeschool their children.
Is this a common viewpoint amongst homeschoolers?
I always assumed that most homeschoolers did so because they felt that was what is best for their own children and families.  I had no idea, until recently, that there are militant homeschoolers.
Am I out of touch?

Richard[/quote]
richard:

you are in touch, they are slanderous nuts.  that's fact, not opinion!  i challenge them to truthfully declare evil never appears in their home.  pass it on to them.

dj :angry: (not feeling patient with those who have insulted the high quality of my working peers and many of my students.  we're church of Christ and baptist heavy in our public school)

marc

Just read this this evening and thought I'd share it.  I believe it's as true today as when it was written:

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]A memorable change must be made in the system of education and knowledge must become so general as to raise the lower ranks of society nearer to the higher.  The education of a nation instead of being confined to a few schools and universities for the instruction of the few, must become the national care and expense for the formation of the many--John Adams[/quote]

What remains true is that education is the key to our continued progress as a nation.  And as such, it is indeed the place of the government to make a quality education available to everyone.

janine

What if all the homeschoolers agreed to 'take on' one additional child...

kanham

Skip,

To simply take history certainly has to be selective doesn't it? We had an agriculture based society where children were educated at home. Why do you think public schools came about? Public schools didn't appear in a vacuum. They came about because the people of those times wanted them. Have they grown into a monster? Yes, but I don't believe history teaches us public schools are evil, just that people are.

The society at that time was relatively simple. The knowledge they needed to get a job etc. was much less then it is today. Most children simply continued what their father did, which would make home school logical. The parents didn't need greater knowledge then they had. How many of us followed in our fathers footsteps? How many of us can keep up with technology? How many of us should teach our children the math skills etc. needed?

The dynamic has changed in our country so I don't see history as being relevant. Today not going to college can really hinder your ability to sustain a living standard, just ask the working poor. The people of history did not even go to college. To me you ar comparing apples to oranges.

The reason I post is we planned on home schooling our children but the home schooling crowed and the attitude we experienced sent us in a different direction. So I post to say home schoolers do you want more people to do it or less? Are you more interested in showing your superiority or helping people? I did not experience help.

Skip

I've been following the 'story' of government schools pretty closely for the last five years.
Forty or more years ago the story was quite different, but now its nothing less than shocking. Some of the statistics on dropouts and standardized test scores point toward the label \"poorly managed daycare\" rather than \"school\".
But read it for yourself.

A small sample of government schools in the news...
In their own words...
(Entire articles, and more articles, are available upon request.)

\"...Parents who say they don't want their children being graded, labeled and compared are challenging Seattle Public Schools' mandatory use of report cards...\"
--\"Parents appeal required use of report cards\",  June 12, 2002, SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER REPORTER

Palm Beach County high school students taking a new standardized history exam this week need to answer just over half of the 100 questions correctly to get an A grade on the test; to earn a B, only 39 correct answers are required...\"
''Half right in history gets A\", Palm Beach Post, May 30, 2002

Nearly six in 10 of the nation's high school seniors lack even a basic knowledge of American history, a finding virtually unchanged from seven years earlier, according to results released today from a widely respected national test. The results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP)...
--\"Students' History Knowledge Lacking, Test Finds\", May 9, 2002, Washington Post

\"Number of 'failing' schools hits 7,200 ... out of 91,000\"
--USA Today

\"...Now comes word that public school fourth graders in the U.S. still can't read very well. In fact, the latest statistics just released last week show an astounding 63 percent of black fourth graders can barely read at all. And 60 percent of all the poor children in this country read well below the basic level.
The new secretary of education, Roderick Paige, is quoted as saying that after spending $125 billion in Title I money, the federal government has achieved basically nothing in poor school districts...\"

--April 17, 2001, By Bill O'Reilly, Fox News

\"LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Officials in the nation's second largest school district will continue to advance failing students, saying tens of thousands would flunk next year if the practice was scrapped.
About 350,000 students in the Los Angeles Unified School District -- or half the 711,000 total -- would be held back a grade next year if social promotion was dropped, district leaders said.\"

--The Associated Press, 12/1/99

\"Public school administrators, long the enthusiastic adherents of a \"Just Say No!\" policy on drug use, appear to have a new motto for the parents of certain tiny soldiers in the war on drugs: \"Medicate or Else!\" It is a new and troubling twist in the psychiatric drugs saga, in which public schools have begun to issue ultimatums to parents of hard-to-handle kids, saying they will not allow students to attend conventional classes unless they are medicated. In the most extreme cases, parents unwilling to give their kids drugs are being reported by their schools to local offices of Child Protective Services, the implication being that by withholding drugs, the parents are guilty of neglect.\"
Just say yes to Ritalin!, By Lawrence H. Diller, M.D., Sept. 25, 2000

Kevin-

Obviously, you can read.  You can write.  You can spell.  You are able to hold down a job.  Operate a computer.  You can make change.  Figure a tip.  Understand enough history to make informed voting decisions.  You have (presumably) received basic vaccinations and vision and hearing screenings.  

These are the things a public education system is supposed to provide.  The whole point of our system is to offer a basic education to EVERY child - including poor children, disabled children, abused children, the children of unschooled parents, and just plain children.  

Those who advocate discarding public education are apparently willing to leave a large portion of our population illiterate.  Do you actually believe that would be better for the country as a whole?  

Yes, our education system fails many children.  No one can argue that it doesn't.  Yes, private schools or home schools can very often educate individual children better than the public school can.  But private schools and home schools CANNOT educate ALL children better than a public program.  

That's the whole point of federal programs - education, welfare, defense.  That as a community we can provide better for the WHOLE GROUP than we can provide for the WHOLE GROUP as individuals.

Rather than deciding that you don't want to pay to educate the poor (which is exactly what you're saying when you say you don't want to pay to educate other people's children), why not try to improve the system we've got?

PatriciaRedstone-

Are we saying then that there are two 'types' of education?  Reading/writing/math v. philosophy/poetry?  Or that the entire 'school' model no longer fits and needs to be scrapped?

In my view, the essential reason for public education is the idea that every child, no matter their circumstance, deserves to be able to read.  Their mere residence in this country gives them the right to a basic education, whether or not they can pay for it, or will use it to advantage, or in any other way deserve it.  

The children of this country don't have to earn a minimal education-they get it for free.

Sort of like the way children of God don't have to earn salvation-we get it for free.

Of course, the model may well need changing.  But I don't believe the notion of education for every child is outdated at all.

Kari.

Spurly-I'm sorry to hear of your school background.  I was in much the same situation as a child.  But I see that as a failure of the individual school itself, not as a failure of the idea of education for all.

Skip-there are very many children who could not afford any education they had to purchase.  Please tell me straight out-if you privatize education, without tax funding (which is merely the way the community pitches in)-will the very poor be educated?  Yes or No?

Privatization is not the cure-all some want it to be.  It inevitably leaves some people out, because it is profit-based.  And you cannot make a profit from people with no money.

I had some folks whose lives are shaped more by television than the Bible say I was a narrow-minded, self righteous, old-fashioned bigot with no right to judge another.  HMMMMMMMMM.  Could they be right? Is that true? I believe that we should homeschool. It is morally right and unconscionable not to. We are NOT freaks. Jason

4kidsandadog

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]Not one acts like a child.  If we think this is good then why do we have kids if we want them be grownups before they are. [/quote]

Well, susieface.... my kids must certainly be the exception!  I am always wishing they would grow up a bit, but they are firmly entrenched in their childhoods.  I know other homeschoolers whose children not only know how to act like children, but who possess a great deal of responsibility.  It is what I am hoping to instill in my children.  Personally, I feel childhood's reign has been lengthened a bit too much by our modern society.  Let's face it: I know we don't live in little houses on the prairie anymore, but today's kids have little concept of what it means to have responsibilities.  The world has been made to revolve around them and making them happy.  

I am no more bothered by having a courteous and thoughtful homeschooled child in on a conversation I may be having with adults, than I am by having rude little other-schooled children running between my legs during the same time.  I was public-schooled, but always felt more comfortable talking to adults than other kids.  Hooray that there are kids out there who can relate to someone other than other kids!!!  

I understand that you have seen some kids who tend to fall to one extreme of the homeschooling arena, but unless you are intimately acquainted with the family, you may not know the real reason these kids are not hanging with the others.  It may have very little to do with homeschooling and lots to do with the other kids or just those particular kids in general.


Your observations of a few families whom you may or may not be intimately involved with isn't a good basis for disapproving of homeschooling.

Karen

Richard

I have a question for the group.
There is a small but vocal group in our church who proclaim that the Public School system is evil and that anyone who works for, teaches in, supports, or sends their kids to Public Schools need to repent of their sin, quit their jobs, and/or homeschool their children.
Is this a common viewpoint amongst homeschoolers?
I always assumed that most homeschoolers did so because they felt that was what is best for their own children and families.  I had no idea, until recently, that there are militant homeschoolers.
Am I out of touch?

Richard

patriciaredstone

The only thing that is evil is the way people throw around the word \"evil.\"

We have homeschooled for six years now and even though we have been able to customise and integrate faith and academics (actually the integration just happens naturally. The  hard work would be to seperate them!) and can't imagine spending the last six years any other way, we would never pressure anyone through nuance or direct advice to homeschool their children. People often come to us for advice and we are happy to share with them the good and the bad, the pain and the glory.

It is very unwise to use guilt and scare tactics to play a political game with the public schools. Children deserve better than that. Parents who educate their children should be called to that task out of love. People who send their child to school should be called to that task (and yes, it is just as much if not more work than homeschooling) out of love.

I have been invited to attend a Christian Homeschooling group in my area. I'm not much of a joiner, but I checked it out. I discovered that many of the parents were homeschooling because they want to spank their children without being reported to Child Protection Services! We are a no-spanking family and I was a bit shocked to see parents whacking their children for things like whining and hitting their friends. Most said that they were homeschooling their children because \"God called them.\" My guess is that their conservative preacher put a guilt trip on them because these parents were barely suitable as parents much less as educators. Their children were not dressed suitably for the weather, they let them run too close to busy street, allowed them carry large sticks while running and playing with other children, modeled disrespectful behavior and language.

A decision to homeschool should not be based on politics. Parents should love being with their children, should be avid learners, should love and want to bless their communities. We began homeschooling because I was dissapointed in the minimal emphasis the public schools placed on the arts in our district and the private schools were doing no better. As time went by we continued homeschooling because it is such a wonderful way of life! Given a choice every year of entering the rat-race from the hasty morning routine to being tied to a calender that will effect every decision I make all year ... we  continually choose home schooling.

patriciaredstone

Sorry about my sloppy post. Julie, of course I should have said \"educate their children outside educational institutions\" -- I guess I thought the context would be clear. My mistake. We all educate our children. I think we have a whole thread on about that somewhere in the archives. I also mentioned in that same post that both situations (homeschooling and institutional schooling) require just as much effort for parents. Again, sorry for any misunderstanding. I do not believe that public school is a bad thing. My primary complaint about school is that it is static and unbending and exerts too much control over our familiy's time and lifestyle. We prefer the freedom of homeschooling.

Janine ... it's one of those things. You'd just have to be there.

Skip

Just a couple of quick comments...

That John Adams quote is fascinating, since public / government education in the US did not begin until the decade after his death, in the 1830's. Perhaps he did not envision public/government education as we do today. I know that top US government officials today don't send THEIR kids to the public / government schools...

Back on the previous page I made a comment regarding God and the Bible being banned from the schools, and some asked how God could be banned from anywhere...
Of course He cannot - but try to tell that to the judges sitting in the US court system! :p

Someone else mentioned the possibility of no public / government education at all. Could we get by without it?
When one realizes that many of the great thinkers of all times were homeschooled, such as (from unconfirmed sources) Abraham Lincoln, Thomas Edison, C. S. Lewis, Agatha Christie, Alexander Graham Bell... need I continue? :)

Most of the Biblical characters, too, were probably homeschooled, as there were few alternatives. But we see from Moses and Paul, who received formal educations, that they both commited murder ... is there something about formal schooling that brings out a mean streak?! ;)
But they both turned out ok in the end.

And a final observation ... those Sylvan Learning Centers are booming in our area, advertising on TV and growing by leaps and bounds.
What does it say about the state of the US public / government education system, that a whole industry can spring up to re-teach their students?  ???

marc

[!--QuoteBegin--][/span][table border=\"0\" align=\"center\" width=\"95%\" cellpadding=\"3\" cellspacing=\"1\"][tr][td]Quote [/td][/tr][tr][td id=\"QUOTE\"][!--QuoteEBegin--]That John Adams quote is fascinating, since public / government education in the US did not begin until the decade after his death, in the 1830's. Perhaps he did not envision public/government education as we do today. I know that top US government officials today don't send THEIR kids to the public / government schools[/quote]

Interestingly, Jefferson, the father of small government, also proposed a system of education supported by public funds.  His idea was that the poor who demonstrated a knack for learning but could not afford to be sent to the private schools of the day be educated for the betterment of society as a whole.

And I think that last sentiment--the betterment of society as a whole--is what often can get lost when we think about such things.

As to homeschooling, if you have the ablility to do this, great.  But not everyone has the gift of teaching.  Some do a great job homeschooling their kids; others need help.   When advocating everyone take their kids out of the \"evil\" public education system and teach them at home, this is something to keep in mind.

janine

I rather enjoy repeating myself :p....

My guess is Skip is approaching the whole idea of education from a Biblical model, like in Deuteronomy 6:7 and 11:19.  Of course those spots focused on the ways of God... but following Him is the paramount tippy-top of what we need to learn and teach, isn't it?

Thus I see his point.

I still don't want to jerk the government schools out from under people, though, if only for the selfish interests of my self, my family, my bloodline.  We do better in a society where people have access to some sort of education, whether or not their own families can provide such.

julie danley

My first reaction to your post, Skip, was to be extremely negative and lash out at your comments...but I have thought about it and I will just give you some personal experiences that are positive that took place or are taking place in our public schools.  
First, let me say that I am a product of the public school system and I am an RN practicing in a very urban labor and delivery setting.  My public school education has served me well, not only educationally but in how to deal with others who are not the same as my family.  
My husband works for the local public schools as a counselor at a rough high school where he is respected and looked to for help by many students...also greatly loved throughout the county because he has touched lives in whichever school he was in at the moment.  He is also the youth minister at our church and doesn't readily tell people that because he wants his life and not his title to tell who he is.
My oldest son was not a very diligent student...very bright but didn't like school.  He made it through high school because his public school friends told him it was important to finish and that he would regret it later.  I am not sure at that point in his life that he would've heard it from his parents.  He went on to Nascar school and is successfully on his own.  His friends are from all walks of life and he can relate to almost anyone.
My second son is a freshman at Lipscomb University... also a product of public schools.  He is in the honors program majoring in history/political science with a minor in philosophy.  He loves to learn.  His senior year in high school I went to open house where you get to go to all their classes.  I was so impressed with the quality of his teachers...their enthusiasm, competence and obvious love for their students made me want to go back to high school.  
My first daughter is a freshman in high school and has blossomed in the public school system.  She is very shy and excels academically.  She plays the flute and plays lacrosse.  Her shyness overcome through the years with many patient teachers.
My youngest daughter is nine and a little spitfire.  She can challenge anyone on any given point and needs lots of guidance.  Her kindergarten teacher (in public school)  was the most incredible teacher and ambassador for Christ that I have ever seen.  She always spoke in soft tones and called her students her sweethearts.  She is a gracious young black woman who devotes her life to her students.  She taught about racism in such a gentle, tender manner that I was in tears in the back of the room while cutting out construction paper letters for a bulletin board.  Also this very daughter is now reading on a 10th grade level.
My own experience and those of my children have far exceeded our expectations and we are thrilled.  We are in a county that is known for their substandard schools and we are thriving.  Our children have learned that even when others are looking at the negative, you can grab hold of the positive and end up on the other side...with knowledge and enlightenment and skills for the future.  
Skip, I know that we disagree on this issue and may always disagree on this but I just wanted you to see there is good out there.  grace, Julie

spurly

I am a product of public school systems.  What did I gain from my 13 years of school?  Not much.  As a matter of fact I can say that the public school system had a very negative impact on my life.  I was basically self-educated though I don't have time to go into the details right now.

Kevin

Skip

Kari,

The blunt answer is, \"Yes, they will be educated.\"

If their parents, in violation of the law, fail to provide for their education, then the truancy system is already in place to step in.

Some religious private schools already, right now, will take in hardship cases for free. I know that for a fact; I've seen it in action.

Homeschooling can be done entirely free, on library resources and freebies and hand-me-downs and elbow grease - if the parent wants to. I've seen that, too.

Not to mention that given the state of the poor in government schools, as documented in studies and news articles (I've already posted a portion of one) shows that just because they're in the building doesn't mean that they're being educated. The article posted above showed that more than 60% of poor African American 4th-graders couldn't read. That's institutionalized failure, not just a few falling through the cracks. I contend that, given the evidence as it stands now, that private schools and home schools would far surpass the performance of the government schools even for the poorest.

Case in point:
In New York City the Parochial schools offered to take over the government schools that were failing for their standard tuition cost - which would have saved the government money - but they REFUSED! There was just too much politics, union power, judical separation of church and state, and worry that they might actually educate the kids to the embarrasment of the System.

But I've rambled enough...

WileyClarkson

Omega,

I'm curious where your area of the country is.

My neice graduated from home school last year (she's now 17 I think--kids grow up soooooo fast these days!!!!!!!) and is now an active part of her parent's homeschool ministry (Wholeheart Ministries --http://www.wholeheart.org--and she has one book already in publication).  I have two nephews and one neice still being homeschooled.

We did not homeschool our three girls (although we discussed it).  We are very fortunate to have a decent school system available (we live in a very rural area with a total school enrollment of [200 students K-12).  There are some good school systems out there.  

I agree with you that homeschooled kids will become more prevelant in the future in the leadership positions.  However, I think this will be because of the growing numbers.   I have already seen some very poor quality homeschooling going on here in this area by parents who have no business even considering homeschooling.


Arkstfan,

We think a whole lot alike and have shared some similar experiences with the same type situations!

how come there are so few family topics?

Bon Voyage

If there are no Christians in the public schools and the schoolchildren have no access to kids who believe in the gospel of Jesus Christ, is that not evil?

I understand there are good reasons to homeschool.  There are good things about public schools as well.  Depends on the situation.  But to bind something on sin for which there is no biblical argument such as homeschooling or instruments is absolutely stupid in my opinion.

janine

How freaky, an entire Christian homeschooling group running around with snotty-nosed underdressed/overdressed kids, who are whacking each other with big ol' dirty sticks as they run unsupervised along the curb of a busy street.

patriciaredstone, it will likely be very difficult to find a group to join, in which you would feel very safe with your son.  I doubt anyone you know has made the Flambeau Family so nearly a reality as you have.

julie danley

Kevin,  You need to be careful and think through your thoughts on this a little more.  Play it out to the very end.  If everyone had to pay for education for their children, those most needy families would be trapped in the cycle of poverty.  The only way out would be education and then you would be denying them that avenue out of poverty.  In my own case, I would probably be able to educate my children...maybe homeschool or paying for private education but then I would be limiting my children.  If I had to pay for their education through 12th grade then I might not be able to pay for college and that would stunt their potential.  The offering of education to all benefits you and all of society.  It is not a perfect system but it is better than nothing.  grace, Julie

Skip

Julie / Janine,

Look at the big picture?!

There were NO government schools in the U. S., not one, for more than threescore years... that would appear to be about 100% of the picture from the 1770s to the 1830s... is that big enough?

I would ask that you step back from your preconceived notions. What's in vogue now is not necessarily representative of the way its always been. Government schools as the norm are brand new in terms of world history. Government schools are barely newer than the Big Mac - and just because the assembly line works for cars and fast food doesn't mean that it will work for education.

Look at God's plan for Israel in the Old Testament. It was good enough, in His eyes (and He sees the BIG picture) to command the parents to take charge of the education of the children. No government schools for Israel.

Hey, looking at the 'standard' today, the standardized test - homeschoolers are blowing away both public and private institutions.
In the backyard of the U.S. government schools, which spend more on each child's education than any other government in the world, a one-word question comes to mind:
Why?

Could it be that God's way was best after all?

As for us, even in the heart of the Bible Belt, with some of the best government schools in the state at our disposal, I'm convinced that I have no choice but to homeschool.

If we want a more Christian society, don't we as Christians need to try to shape our community to reflect the way Christ told us to be?

What happened to the idea that we're all in this together?

For any community to thrive, the individual must, to some extent, sacrifice the personal good for the good of the community.  Everyone pitches in to educate the children of the community.  

Single people work to educate the children, the young help pay take care of the old.  

In recent years there's been such an increase in \"What's in it for me?\"  We've forgotton all about \"Love your neighbor as yourself\"  

Kevin, if you ever get a society which doesn't see to the education of all children, you sure going to need that National defense, court system and police.

lucybelle

Skip,

There are valuable programs in high school (International Baccaulaureate, Advanced Placement) that aren't necessarily available in the private schools, let alone in the home schools.  Private school parents put their kids into public schools to get them into the IB program.  There are many failing schools systems out there today, but there are many successful ones too.  You can't just look to the negative side of things.

Skip

Is that anything like the \"Pepsi Challenge\"?

Government school positives... Hmmm... Nope, there aren't any.
Just kidding! :D

Government schools have vast resources at their disposal, since they are, as has been noted before, on the receiving end of more money than any school system than any other today, and perhaps ever. As a result, resources such as computer labs and science labs, complete with expensive equipment and materials, are provided. And I know what some of that equipment costs, and know that most of us (individual families) can't afford it...

Government schools have handled millions of students over the course of their existence.

Government schools provide schooling in a black box, so to speak, and the course of study meets state and federal standards and will progress in a direction toward college upon graduation. And you can take a high school diploma from a government school anywhere, and it will be accepted without question.

Government schools excel at providing opportunities for extracurricular activities, ranging from various sports, to band, to drama and chorus, and so on – and extracurricular activities are often the very strongest advantage of government schooling over home schooling due to the pooling of resources and grouping of peer students together. And government schools typically have facilities to host extracurricular activities, such as stadiums, ball fields, gymnasiums, and auditoriums.

Government schools have teachers who are college-educated.

Government schools will take in the poor students. And feed them lunch, too.

Government schools have programs or separate schools to handle special-needs students and students who are discipline problems.

Government schools are measuring and students with standardized testing, and holding teachers accountable, often with background checks to ensure their suitability.

Government schools can provide counseling and assistance in preparing for college, as well as assist in the search for scholarships and student aid.

Government schools give both parents the freedom to work outside the home without concern about the care and education of the kids.

These are several positives, and of course there are more positives that I missed...
Did I pass?

patriciaredstone

I am reading with interest on two levels, as a homeschooling parent and as a moderator. As a moderator I want to encourage everyone to lace your posts with facts and \"I\" messages rather than \"you\" and \"them\" messages ... \"I feel ...\" \"I believe...\" \" I have seen ...\" This helps communication by keeping us all aware that there are different ways to see things.

As a homeschooling parent, I made my choice to oversee the complete education of my son because of defiencies in both private and government schools. School, in my opinion, is not the \"real world\" or \"the world.\" The world is nothing like school.

Schools are based on antiquated hierarchal management devices which simply do not work in a free society. They are based on the old european factory model with a \"Lord\" overseeing the peasant workers with the help of minor \"lords\" or \"bosses\". The individual is lost in such a society as each is forced to produce on the same level, under the same conditions, within the same factory style construct. No operation in America functions like a convetional school in our country. The best schools depart from this model and the teachers become a governing body that functions to guide and lead and learn together with the body at large which includes the students. There are very few of these schools. In homeschool, this model just happens naturally and it is a model that opens the mind. Some schools try to imitate this model, but the efforts are only short diversions from the old hierarchal norm.

My husband and I were educated in government schools. We were lost in the crowd. Because our school was in an impoverished minority neighborhood, the district gave us a school counselor that the other schools in the district would surely have fired. This counselor was a member of our church. He behaved as though he hated kids and thought we all were too stupid to go to college! So we had to find our own way ... which has been good ... very good ... but that smart kids will find a way is not a good excuse for poor guidance.

Finally, I do not think that the government schools contain the essence of the schools our nation's forefathers had in mind when they endorsed public education. The priviledged were educated in formal institutions (which most did not enter until they were well past 9 or 10 years old) in order to become good and wise not filthy rich. Education was not designed to help a person get a job back then, it was to develop character and to broaden the awareness of those destined to be leaders. Teaching morality was primary because these students were going to be \"lords\" in a class society. It was up to them to carry on the social standards of grace and dignity with human compassion. They studied religion, the poets, the philosophers. But as class society fell, the urgent need to teach compassion and morality fell with it. School has become about making productive members of society not about nurturing the soul and mind. It works against the social structure of the public school when children are brought together in community to learn how to \"get mine.\"

marc

I'll probably get some of this wrong, but here goes.

In West Virginia, the school system is funded almost completely by property taxes.  In 1975 a parent from the area where I live sued saying that this funding system caused schools in the poorer areas to be underfunded and the state cnstitution says all counties must be funded equally. The wealthier counties protested, afraid this would take money away from their systems.  In 1982 Circuit Court Judge Arthur Recht ruled in her favor, and sent the case back to the state government to be implemented.

They did practically nothing.  The state school building authority was established and forced school consolidation on several counties on the theory that maybe counties that couldn't afford to operate 4 schools could afford to operate one.  Our local consolidation still hasn't happened, although it now looks like it will.  Unfortunately ours is a large county geographically, and cosolidation will mean increased transportation costs and hour-plus bus rides.

In the meantime, the state's economy, never the best to begin with, took a nose dive.  The recession of '82 saw an unbelievable number of coal mines closing and devastated our chemical industry.  This trend has continued ever since, with another chemical company announcing its closing just last week.  This has led to a mass exodus from the state, decreasing property values,

and even less money for education.

Compounding this problem, school boards in the poorer counties are controlled by local political machines who use the systems as a feeding trough for their supporters.  They exist not to improve education, but to provide jobs for the relatives and cronies of politicians.  Few members of the school boards show any concern for the state of the school systems.  A couple of years ago, the state stepped in and took over our counties system, ostensibly on the grounds that the political hiring had gotten out of hand. In reality, given that the legislative education chairman at the time was one of our political bosses, this was most likely done so the state could force the unpopular consolidation and our local politicians wouldn't get blamed for it. (a few years agothe population got so upset over consolidation they actually voted a couple of write-in candidates into office).  In the two years since the state took over, very little has changed.  The same people remain in charge.

Which brings us back to the Recht decision.  He made his ruling without telling the state how to implement the decision.  Other states (including neighboring Kentucky) had been forced by similar rulings to revamp their systems and had implemented real change.  But because of the vagueness of the ruling and the lack of will of the politicians, nothing was done in West Virginia.  Every few years someone would go to court and try to force the state to fund the schools, and a decision would be put off once again.

This week a new set of hearings are being held.  The original judge has been called out of retirement to hear the case.  There is some speculation that the decision will be to force the hiring of more personell.  Personally, I think this would only be a cosmetic solution.  We will only make real progress if we find a new, permanent way to fund our school systems, as other states that have been faced with this problem have done.

One thing that has kept progress from being made is that people who have received a poor education tend to not value education, and thus have no will to have their hard-earned tax money go to the schools.  To many of them, teachers are overpaid (so many people in this area live below the poverty line some in wealthier areas would find this unfathomable) and education isn't about real life anyway.  Some areas provide additional funds through excess levies, but not our area. Our biggest obstacle is apathy.  People complain endlessly about the lack of jobs in this area, but few seem to see the link between our poor economy and our poor education system.  And unfortunately, this is not only a link, it is a cycle.

janine

Possibly because we are all priggishly self-satisfied with the wonderfulness of our families?

:blush:  :eek:

Seriously, that's one thing I want to improve/increase is the topics that might fit under \"Family Life\", precisely because my family life is NOT[/b] all I think I'd like it to be...

And I've only a very short time before my older two children are out of my house, out from under my wing.

Scary thought.  Incorrect thought, maybe, 'cause any protection I provided through childhood
(a) got its power from God, and He'll still be with them when they leave, and
(b) I've had 21 and 17 years to instill in them the strength and wisdom to protect themselves, to stay right there in the palm of God's hand.

Ah, well.

Have you any topics you'd like to look at here, Newtome?

Skip

\"The Bible is banned in public (really 'government') schools.\"

So, does a Christian belong in an environment where the Bible and God are banned?!

Take that and run with it!

As a homeschooler, I'd go for the complete privatization of schools, myself.

But no, there is no common militant feeling against government schools in the homeschool group that my family is a part of.

Pity and horror are probably the general reactions to government school achievement and behaviors (student AND teacher).

janine

I figure public school is just about as evil as public transportation.

Offers just as many opportunities for good or evil to occur.

For each, depends on what the government entities that run it are willing to put up with from employees and users.

julie danley

Patricia,  I took offense to one thing that you said and you may not have even meant it that way.  You said that some of us choose to educate our children and some choose to send them to public school.  I send my children to public school and my husband also works for the public school system but I also educate my children.  I may not have them in my classroom Monday through Friday but I talk with them at every opportunity and feel ultimately responsible for their education.  I do feel that I educate my children in all areas of life.  They are my most precious gifts from God and I am just careful with my children as anyone who homeschools.  grace, Julie

janine

Since I don't know the people who say that stuff in your church, Richard, I can't give a good opinion about exactly where they're coming from.

I do know there is much evil, attitudinal evil, acted-out evil, spoken evil, whatever, in a public school.  I've been there, my kids are there now.  I know.  

But, then, there's a \"Christian\" school in town where some friends send their kids, and there's much of the same stuff.  The good difference about a private school is the teeth still in the discipline bite there.  Public school administrators and teachers have their fangs pulled in many ways.

No matter how you educate your kids, you will still be homeschooling them if you are a good parent.  The school cannot raise your children; you must.  School-raised kids are \"pack\" kids.

But, to make some sort of salvational issue out of sending your kids to school is just plain wacky.  Such a blanket argument sounds like the stuff spouted by people who are mindlessly placing themselves under the authority of a \"pastor\" with such a hobby horse.  What's your church leadership say on it?  I mean, as a from-the-pulpit opinion?

+-Recent Topics

Creation scientists by Amo
Yesterday at 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Yesterday at 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Yesterday at 21:07:16

Upgrade madness by Amo
Yesterday at 16:09:41

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Yesterday at 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Yesterday at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal