+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898061
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 4952
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 4308
Total: 4309
yogi bear
Google (2)

"Dialogue Doesn't Distance Us from Truth, but Leads Us to Whole Truth"

Started by epiphanius, Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 10:15:53

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

epiphanius

Vatican City, 28 June 2013 (VIS) http://www.news.va/en/news/dialogue-doesnt-distance-us-from-truth-but-leads-u - "Your presence is the sign of the profound bond that unites the Church of Constantinople with the Church of Rome in faith, in hope, and in charity," Pope Francis said this morning on receiving the delegation of the Ecumenical Patriarch, which had arrived in Rome to celebrate the Solemnity of Sts. Peter and Paul. The tradition of exchanging visits for the occasions of the respective patronal feasts dates back to 1969. The Pope emphasized that "fraternal gathering is an essential part of the journey towards unity."


"The search for unity among Christians is an urgent task—you have said that 'it is not a luxury, but an imperative'—from which, today more than ever, we cannot prescind. In our world that hungers and thirsts for truth, love, hope, peace, and unity, our witness demands that we should at last be able to proclaim, with one voice, the good news of the Gospel and celebrate together the Divine Mysteries of our new life in Christ. We are well aware that unity is primarily a gift from God that we must pray for unceasingly, but we all have the task of preparing the conditions, of cultivating the soil of the heart so that this extraordinary grace may be received."


Francis praised the Mixed International Commission for Theological Dialogue between the Catholic and Orthodox Churches'—which is headed by Metropolitan Ioannis and Cardinal Kurt Koch—fundamental contribution to the search for full communion. "The Commission has already produced many common texts and is now studying the theological and ecclesiological relationships between primacy and synodality in the life of the Church." In this regard, the Pope commented on the significance of, today, "being able to reflect together in truth and charity on these issues, starting from what we have in common without, however, concealing that which still separates us. This isn't a theoretical exercise: it demands in-depth knowledge of one another's traditions in order to understand them and sometimes also to learn from them. I am speaking, for example, of the Catholic Church's reflection on the meaning of episcopal collegiality and the tradition of synodality that is so characteristic of the Orthodox Churches."


"It comforts me," he added, "knowing that Catholics and Orthodox share the same conception of dialogue that doesn't seek a theological minimalism on which to reach a compromise, but that rather is based on the deepening of the truth that Christ has given to his Church and that we, moved by the Holy Spirit, never cease to understand better. This is why we shouldn't be afraid of encounter and true dialogue. It doesn't distance us from the truth but rather, through an exchange of gifts, leads us, under the guidance of the Spirit of truth, to the whole truth."


The Holy Father concluded his address to the ecumenical delegation, which tomorrow will attend a Eucharistic celebration presided by the Pope, by calling upon Sts. Peter and Paul, patrons of the Church of Rome, and the Apostle Andrew, patron of the Church of Constantinople, to intercede "for our faithful and for the needs of the whole world, especially the poor, the suffering, and those who are unjustly persecuted for their faith."

mclees8

It doesn't distance us from the truth but rather, through an exchange of gifts, leads us, under the guidance of the Spirit of truth, to the whole truth."


Anyone care to clarify just what he means by this statement. What would he consider to be the whole truth?

Would that be to consider papal primacy. Is that not the goal of the ecumenical movement.   Is that not their idea of unity for all to be in agreement  with the pope.

in these dialogues many right things are said but the perception is twisted.

Truth is we are already in agreement that Jesus is Lord. Is he not the glue of the gospel that we all agree on.  What the pope wants is a unity between factions if that can be a word used


epiphanius

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
QuoteIt doesn't distance us from the truth but rather, through an exchange of gifts, leads us, under the guidance of the Spirit of truth, to the whole truth.
Anyone care to clarify just what he means by this statement. What would he consider to be the whole truth?

I don't see any reason to doubt that the Pope intends this as a clear reference to John 16:13:
QuoteHowever when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth, for he will not speak from himself; but whatever he hears, he will speak. He will declare to you things that are coming.

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
Would that be to consider papal primacy. Is that not the goal of the ecumenical movement.   Is that not their idea of unity for all to be in agreement  with the pope.

Actually, a lot of the dialogue between the Catholic and Orthodox churches are about the meaning of "papal primacy." Certainly the term primacy itself simply means "having first place" (i.e. among the bishops), but does not necessarily imply that the Bishop of Rome is "above" all the other bishops. This point is still being discussed, with both sides prayerfully seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
Truth is we are already in agreement that Jesus is Lord. Is he not the glue of the gospel that we all agree on.
::amen!::


mclees8

Quote from: epiphanius on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 06:03:38
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
QuoteIt doesn't distance us from the truth but rather, through an exchange of gifts, leads us, under the guidance of the Spirit of truth, to the whole truth.
Anyone care to clarify just what he means by this statement. What would he consider to be the whole truth?

I don't see any reason to doubt that the Pope intends this as a clear reference to John 16:13:
QuoteHowever when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth, for he will not speak from himself; but whatever he hears, he will speak. He will declare to you things that are coming.

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
Would that be to consider papal primacy. Is that not the goal of the ecumenical movement.   Is that not their idea of unity for all to be in agreement  with the pope.

Actually, a lot of the dialogue between the Catholic and Orthodox churches are about the meaning of "papal primacy." Certainly the term primacy itself simply means "having first place" (i.e. among the bishops), but does not necessarily imply that the Bishop of Rome is "above" all the other bishops. This point is still being discussed, with both sides prayerfully seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
Truth is we are already in agreement that Jesus is Lord. Is he not the glue of the gospel that we all agree on.
::amen!::



Thanks for your input.  it is correct that the Holy Spirit will guide us into all the truth. My point is that the pope sees his primacy as being that truth (Whole truth). I disagree on the part where you suggest it does not mean he is over other bishops.  It is actually the whole drive here. #1 and be seen and respected as #!   . If Peter truly was #1 I don't think he would be trying to drive that point but this is all important to papal supremacy  And if Peter were here today he would see this as disgraceful and un-apostolic

AVZ

Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 13:43:46
Quote from: epiphanius on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 06:03:38
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
QuoteIt doesn't distance us from the truth but rather, through an exchange of gifts, leads us, under the guidance of the Spirit of truth, to the whole truth.
Anyone care to clarify just what he means by this statement. What would he consider to be the whole truth?

I don't see any reason to doubt that the Pope intends this as a clear reference to John 16:13:
QuoteHowever when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth, for he will not speak from himself; but whatever he hears, he will speak. He will declare to you things that are coming.

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
Would that be to consider papal primacy. Is that not the goal of the ecumenical movement.   Is that not their idea of unity for all to be in agreement  with the pope.

Actually, a lot of the dialogue between the Catholic and Orthodox churches are about the meaning of "papal primacy." Certainly the term primacy itself simply means "having first place" (i.e. among the bishops), but does not necessarily imply that the Bishop of Rome is "above" all the other bishops. This point is still being discussed, with both sides prayerfully seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Jun 29, 2013 - 12:37:13
Truth is we are already in agreement that Jesus is Lord. Is he not the glue of the gospel that we all agree on.
::amen!::



Thanks for your input.  it is correct that the Holy Spirit will guide us into all the truth. My point is that the pope sees his primacy as being that truth (Whole truth). I disagree on the part where you suggest it does not mean he is over other bishops.  It is actually the whole drive here. #1 and be seen and respected as #!   . If Peter truly was #1 I don't think he would be trying to drive that point but this is all important to papal supremacy  And if Peter were here today he would see this as disgraceful and un-apostolic

I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

winsome

Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Two points:

1. In dialogue each side can better understand the other. Sometimes disagreements occur because there are misunderstanding over terms used. A few years ago the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation published a joint declaration on Justification. Some say though that agreement was reached only by fudging terms slightly. I think there may be a moving towards an understanding between Catholic and Ortodox on the filioque issue. I would agree though that the Catholic understanding of "papal infallibility" is a difficult one.

2. As far as I am aware there have only been two dogmas that have been declared by the Pope apart from an Ecumenical Council. Therefore "papal infallibility" only affects two dogmas not 'every dogma ever declared'.

From what I heard a few years ago the approach is to discuss less contentious isuses and build trust before tacking the more contentious issues. It's a slow process but I think we ought to applaud that it is happening.

AVZ

Quote from: winsome on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 04:26:18
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Two points:

1. In dialogue each side can better understand the other. Sometimes disagreements occur because there are misunderstanding over terms used. A few years ago the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation published a joint declaration on Justification. Some say though that agreement was reached only by fudging terms slightly. I think there may be a moving towards an understanding between Catholic and Ortodox on the filioque issue. I would agree though that the Catholic understanding of "papal infallibility" is a difficult one.

2. As far as I am aware there have only been two dogmas that have been declared by the Pope apart from an Ecumenical Council. Therefore "papal infallibility" only affects two dogmas not 'every dogma ever declared'.

From what I heard a few years ago the approach is to discuss less contentious isuses and build trust before tacking the more contentious issues. It's a slow process but I think we ought to applaud that it is happening.

I am purposely using papal infallibility, because that is a main issue between the RCC and the orthodox church.

Lets imagine that by some miracle the RCC and the orthodox church would concede that the Pope is not infallible.
That would not only kick the legs from under the Pope...but since he was declared infallible through infallible revelation by the church, that would kick the legs from under every single dogma ever declared by the RCC.
If the church was wrong once, she could be wrong twice...

So the bishops are going to have a nice chat, likely some good food and a few drinks...and then everybody goes back to how it was.

DaveW

Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Actually I doubt that is the case. The specific of papal primacy aside; I was in on a discussion a little over a month ago at the Tikkun America conference between 2 representatives of Presbyterian Reform Mininstries Int'l (PRMI.org) and Dan Juster ThD, Director of Tikkun International.  Juster also is on the Toward Jerusalem Council 2 (TJCII.org)  board and has met regularly with upper level leaders in the RCC, including John Paul 2 and Benedict. (both before and during his pontificate)

When the new chatachism (sp?) was rolled out a couple of years ago, the monk who was Benedict's go-to man for theology and doctrine asked the TJCII representatives to look it over.  Dr Juster read the entire document (over 1000 pages he said) and then gave them his report on it.  (it was already being distributed) He showed them a fundamental flaw in their concept of Israel and the church to the end that all (including Benedict) could see it plainly.

My point is, these (RCC heirarcy) are serious men of God.  We may strongly disagree with some or many of the doctrines they hold; but that does not mean they are evil despots bent on global domination. They really do want to get it right. They really do want a real functional unity in the greater body of believers.

Ongoing talk and prayer seems to be the best way to move toward that goal.

trifecta

AVZ,

Your points are valid, yet as winsome says, it is good that they are talking. 

My 2 cents from an Orthodox perspective.   The good news is the dialogue has really helped reduce
the hostility between the east and west (EO and RCC).

Quote
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.

They could probably fudge on the infallible church idea, saying the times have changed.   Certain things are allowed
today (such as female altar servers) that were not allowed in the past.  (BTW, the EOs don't have female altar servers).

Moreover, the Pope doesn't need a consensus to do anything.  The real legwork for unity can be done by him instantly.
I do see a possibility of sharing communion, something that falls on the EO side to solve.  Why? The RCC already
allows EO to their communion.  Logistically, it will be much harder in the east because we do things by consensus and
each EO church (five of them) would have to approve it.

The co-celebrations of the Eucharist between Bartholomew and the Pope have been very controversial in Orthodox circles,
although I have no problem with it.  Perhaps that can be taken to the parish level: two priests (from east and west) can
serve and both EO and RCC can participate.  Possible in our lifetimes.  I hope it happens.

Papal infallibility is a problem, but I see a loophole there.  The Pope is infallible only when he speaks "from the chair
of Peter" (ex cathedra).  For example, JPII apologized for the role of the church in WWII.  Fair to say, the Pope at that time was not
speaking ex cathedra.

The filioque might be solvable too. Rome already allows it in their own eastern rite churches.  They can extend it to
all EO churches, although this would be tacit admission that we were right all along.  IMHO,  however, they already have by
allowing some of their churches to use it.

The big problem is universal jurisdiction of the Bishop of Rome.  This would be a real change for Rome to give up so much power (although we would call it a claim to power).  The Pope used to have the title of Patriarchate of the West.  Unfortunately, Pope
Benedict gave up this title (after more than 1000 years). If he would re-take that title and give up universal authority I think
that would do it.

Fr. Thomas Hopko, a prominent Orthodox priest respectful of RCC, wrote a good article on what it would take for RCC/EO
unity from the EO perspective.  It can be found here, if you are interested.

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/1698562/posts


Quote

It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

You're right about us agreeing to papal authority.  While we can ascent to the Bishop of Rome resuming his position as the leader of the patriarchs (that is papal primacy), we can't go for him having authority over every Christian (which he now claims, at least among Catholics).   The Pope should be happy with having control of the entire west, which is now more Christian than the east anyway.

But if Rome would renounce universal authority, reunification could well happen.  Not likely, but stranger things have happened.
"With man, it is impossible, with God, all things are possible."

I just read DaveW's post written as I was writing this,  good stuff. AVZ has a point too, but unity is still worth pursuing.

mclees8

Quote from: trifecta on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:59:21
AVZ,

Your points are valid, yet as winsome says, it is good that they are talking. 

My 2 cents from an Orthodox perspective.   The good news is the dialogue has really helped reduce
the hostility between the east and west (EO and RCC).

Quote
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.

They could probably fudge on the infallible church idea, saying the times have changed.   Certain things are allowed
today (such as female altar servers) that were not allowed in the past.  (BTW, the EOs don't have female altar servers).

Moreover, the Pope doesn't need a consensus to do anything.  The real legwork for unity can be done by him instantly.
I do see a possibility of sharing communion, something that falls on the EO side to solve.  Why? The RCC already
allows EO to their communion.  Logistically, it will be much harder in the east because we do things by consensus and
each EO church (five of them) would have to approve it.

The co-celebrations of the Eucharist between Bartholomew and the Pope have been very controversial in Orthodox circles,
although I have no problem with it.  Perhaps that can be taken to the parish level: two priests (from east and west) can
serve and both EO and RCC can participate.  Possible in our lifetimes.  I hope it happens.

Papal infallibility is a problem, but I see a loophole there.  The Pope is infallible only when he speaks "from the chair
of Peter" (ex cathedra).  For example, JPII apologized for the role of the church in WWII.  Fair to say, the Pope at that time was not
speaking ex cathedra.

The filioque might be solvable too. Rome already allows it in their own eastern rite churches.  They can extend it to
all EO churches, although this would be tacit admission that we were right all along.  IMHO,  however, they already have by
allowing some of their churches to use it.

The big problem is universal jurisdiction of the Bishop of Rome.  This would be a real change for Rome to give up so much power (although we would call it a claim to power).  The Pope used to have the title of Patriarchate of the West.  Unfortunately, Pope
Benedict gave up this title (after more than 1000 years). If he would re-take that title and give up universal authority I think
that would do it.

Fr. Thomas Hopko, a prominent Orthodox priest respectful of RCC, wrote a good article on what it would take for RCC/EO
unity from the EO perspective.  It can be found here, if you are interested.

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/1698562/posts


Quote

It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

You're right about us agreeing to papal authority.  While we can ascent to the Bishop of Rome resuming his position as the leader of the patriarchs (that is papal primacy), we can't go for him having authority over every Christian (which he now claims, at least among Catholics).   The Pope should be happy with having control of the entire west, which is now more Christian than the east anyway.

But if Rome would renounce universal authority, reunification could well happen.  Not likely, but stranger things have happened.
"With man, it is impossible, with God, all things are possible."

I just read DaveW's post written as I was writing this,  good stuff. AVZ has a point too, but unity is still worth pursuing.

I just have to ask. What would you see as being unified? What would papal Rome consider to be unity? What is the broad ideal and purpose for the ecumenical council be? Does this include bringing Protestants back to recognizing the pope and his primacy. I see the orthodox and the Catholic as two horses of the same breed each wanting the other to change their color.
But as AVZ says probably not going to happen. Still bishop wise they are a very colorful bunch ::pondering:: ::whistle::

Should there be a centralized authority to settle church problems and set standards. Probably but I see to much worldly corruptions for this to truly guide His church. For now The Holy Spirit and Gods word are the best guides.

AVZ

Quote from: DaveW on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:55:57
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Actually I doubt that is the case. The specific of papal primacy aside; I was in on a discussion a little over a month ago at the Tikkun America conference between 2 representatives of Presbyterian Reform Mininstries Int'l (PRMI.org) and Dan Juster ThD, Director of Tikkun International.  Juster also is on the Toward Jerusalem Council 2 (TJCII.org)  board and has met regularly with upper level leaders in the RCC, including John Paul 2 and Benedict. (both before and during his pontificate)

When the new chatachism (sp?) was rolled out a couple of years ago, the monk who was Benedict's go-to man for theology and doctrine asked the TJCII representatives to look it over.  Dr Juster read the entire document (over 1000 pages he said) and then gave them his report on it.  (it was already being distributed) He showed them a fundamental flaw in their concept of Israel and the church to the end that all (including Benedict) could see it plainly.

My point is, these (RCC heirarcy) are serious men of God.  We may strongly disagree with some or many of the doctrines they hold; but that does not mean they are evil despots bent on global domination. They really do want to get it right. They really do want a real functional unity in the greater body of believers.

Ongoing talk and prayer seems to be the best way to move toward that goal.

Dave,

I am sure that all these scholars are of good intent, and all of them take Gods Word very seriously.
We are however not talking about some small amendments in formulation of doctrines, no we are talking about amending theological roots (dogmas).

For example: How would you see an issue as purgatory resolved?
Obviously the RCC would never be able to retract the existence of purgatory. Can you imagine if the RCC would declare: "We are now going together with the EO, so we agreed purgatory does not exist anymore".

There is no other way. It is because of infallibility that the EO must give in to the RCC and not the other way around.
And all besides...even if the EO and RCC would come to some form of agreement, you know as well as I do that that simply will lead to schism within the EO church.

I do know that the RCC is not intentionally bent on global domination, but the mere fact that she rules from absolutes does make it so.
These absolutes were the reason that "you" were excommunicated in the first place. It was the RCC's way of saying, "I don't have to listen to you, you must listen to me".
A similar thing happened to the Protestants.

The real issues here are issues that cut deep in the heart of doctrines and dogma's.
Amendment from either side would have disastrous consequences and will give way for new schisms.
The rise of the Protestant East Orthodox Church.

epiphanius

Quote from: DaveW on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:55:57
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Actually I doubt that is the case. The specific of papal primacy aside; I was in on a discussion a little over a month ago at the Tikkun America conference between 2 representatives of Presbyterian Reform Ministries Int'l (PRMI.org) and Dan Juster ThD, Director of Tikkun International.  Juster also is on the Toward Jerusalem Council 2 (TJCII.org)  board and has met regularly with upper level leaders in the RCC, including John Paul 2 and Benedict. (both before and during his pontificate)

When the new [catechism] was rolled out a couple of years ago, the monk who was Benedict's go-to man for theology and doctrine asked the TJCII representatives to look it over.  Dr Juster read the entire document (over 1000 pages he said) and then gave them his report on it.  (it was already being distributed) He showed them a fundamental flaw in their concept of Israel and the church to the end that all (including Benedict) could see it plainly.

My point is, these (RCC hierarchy) are serious men of God.  We may strongly disagree with some or many of the doctrines they hold; but that does not mean they are evil despots bent on global domination. They really do want to get it right. They really do want a real functional unity in the greater body of believers.

Ongoing talk and prayer seems to be the best way to move toward that goal.

The RCC is continuing to struggle with the remnants of a legacy that was based on a medieval philosophy of government and authority which it has already more-or-less rejected as untenable.  This philosophy basically held that unity was *impossible* without a single source of authority.  (This is why the Pope of Rome was held to be in authority, not only over all bishops but all kings as well.)

With the advent of Vatican II, the long-held maxim that stated "there is no such thing as schism within the Church, there is only schism from the Church" was quietly but effectively set aside (despite its containing some statements that seem to recall it).  It did this by affirming that both Orthodox and Protestants were "fellow Christians" and "brethren in Christ," as well as by publishing an official decree entitled "Unitatis Redintegratio" (The Restoration of Unity).  Moreover, since that time Popes Paul VI, John Paul II, Benedict XVI and Francis have all reiterated the need for this restoration of unity, but most importantly (someone let me know if I'm mistaken about this)--none of them ever insisted that the desired unity meant "everyone else converting."

It is clear enough that the Orthodox Church has rejected and continues to reject the dogmatic statements made by Rome since the schism of 1054.  Both the Popes and the participants in these dialogues are very much aware of this, and none of them is under the illusion that any kind of unity between the RCC and the EOC can be achieved without revisiting all of these teachings, and either finding a mutually-acceptable expression of them, or (nobody is saying exactly how at this point) removing them from the list of dogmatic teachings.

Regarding Papal Infallibility in particular, the justification for this teaching was based on three things:
  • Our Lord's promise to be with His Church "even to the end of the age." (Mt. 28:20)
  • Our Lord's promise that "when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth." (Jn. 16:13)
  • The philosophical principle noted above
This puts the teaching into perspective, and opens the door to further discussion on it.

AVZ

Quote from: epiphanius on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 03:32:36
Quote from: DaveW on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:55:57
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Actually I doubt that is the case. The specific of papal primacy aside; I was in on a discussion a little over a month ago at the Tikkun America conference between 2 representatives of Presbyterian Reform Ministries Int'l (PRMI.org) and Dan Juster ThD, Director of Tikkun International.  Juster also is on the Toward Jerusalem Council 2 (TJCII.org)  board and has met regularly with upper level leaders in the RCC, including John Paul 2 and Benedict. (both before and during his pontificate)

When the new [catechism] was rolled out a couple of years ago, the monk who was Benedict's go-to man for theology and doctrine asked the TJCII representatives to look it over.  Dr Juster read the entire document (over 1000 pages he said) and then gave them his report on it.  (it was already being distributed) He showed them a fundamental flaw in their concept of Israel and the church to the end that all (including Benedict) could see it plainly.

My point is, these (RCC hierarchy) are serious men of God.  We may strongly disagree with some or many of the doctrines they hold; but that does not mean they are evil despots bent on global domination. They really do want to get it right. They really do want a real functional unity in the greater body of believers.

Ongoing talk and prayer seems to be the best way to move toward that goal.

The RCC is continuing to struggle with the remnants of a legacy that was based on a medieval philosophy of government and authority which it has already more-or-less rejected as untenable.  This philosophy basically held that unity was *impossible* without a single source of authority.  (This is why the Pope of Rome was held to be in authority, not only over all bishops but all kings as well.)

With the advent of Vatican II, the long-held maxim that stated "there is no such thing as schism within the Church, there is only schism from the Church" was quietly but effectively set aside (despite its containing some statements that seem to recall it).  It did this by affirming that both Orthodox and Protestants were "fellow Christians" and "brethren in Christ," as well as by publishing an official decree entitled "Unitatis Redintegratio" (The Restoration of Unity).  Moreover, since that time Popes Paul VI, John Paul II, Benedict XVI and Francis have all reiterated the need for this restoration of unity, but most importantly (someone let me know if I'm mistaken about this)--none of them ever insisted that the desired unity meant "everyone else converting."

It is clear enough that the Orthodox Church has rejected and continues to reject the dogmatic statements made by Rome since the schism of 1054.  Both the Popes and the participants in these dialogues are very much aware of this, and none of them is under the illusion that any kind of unity between the RCC and the EOC can be achieved without revisiting all of these teachings, and either finding a mutually-acceptable expression of them, or (nobody is saying exactly how at this point) removing them from the list of dogmatic teachings.

Regarding Papal Infallibility in particular, the justification for this teaching was based on three things:
  • Our Lord's promise to be with His Church "even to the end of the age." (Mt. 28:20)
  • Our Lord's promise that "when he, the Spirit of truth, has come, he will guide you into all truth." (Jn. 16:13)
  • The philosophical principle noted above
This puts the teaching into perspective, and opens the door to further discussion on it.

Epi,
Mighty interesting. Want to address the following however:

"...any kind of unity between the RCC and the EOC can be achieved without revisiting all of these teachings, and either finding a mutually-acceptable expression of them, or (nobody is saying exactly how at this point) removing them from the list of dogmatic teachings."

Basically the options are as follows:
One party says it's black and the other party says its white.
The solution, according to the above, will be to either select black or white as being true, or find a formula in which grey is true.

In my book that is not trying to find the "whole truth" but plain and simple formulating another untrue statement which is neither warm or cold.
Instead of inventing new untenable ways to keep complete or partial authority, it would serve both parties right to place authority and infallibility where it belongs...with Christ.

FireSword

Does there has to be a change of policies in order for unity?

Nations have strong alliances, yet their policies are very different. I'm not sure what an alliance of churches would look like, but maybe a strong allied opinion against corruptions of this world, such as human trafficking and then united prayer against such. I've heard of some church meetings, but most are just a sham full of uninfluential people and compromise of beliefs in Christ.

epiphanius

Quote from: AVZ on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 05:55:36
Epi,
Mighty interesting. Want to address the following however:

Quote from: epiphanius on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 03:32:36
It is clear enough that the Orthodox Church has rejected and continues to reject the dogmatic statements made by Rome since the schism of 1054.  Both the Popes and the participants in these dialogues are very much aware of this, and none of them is under the illusion that any kind of unity between the RCC and the EOC can be achieved without revisiting all of these teachings, and either finding a mutually-acceptable expression of them, or (nobody is saying exactly how at this point) removing them from the list of dogmatic teachings.

Basically the options are as follows:
One party says it's black and the other party says its white.
The solution, according to the above, will be to either select black or white as being true, or find a formula in which grey is true.

In my book that is not trying to find the "whole truth" but plain and simple formulating another untrue statement which is neither warm or cold.

One important detail of Catholic dogmatic theology is that it is never the words themselves that are infallible, but the truth that lies behind them.  One example of how this works in a real-life scenario goes back to when both East (Greek) and West (Latin) were trying to formulate the doctrine of the Trinity: the East adopted the formula three Hypostases in one Ousia, while the West chose three Personae in one Substantia.  What's interesting here is that the literal meaning of the Greek word hypostasis (singular of hypostases) is identical to that of the Latin word substantia--both mean "that which stands beneath!"

In other words, the term used in the West for the One was the same term used in the East for the Three.  Obviously, there was a potential here for *lots* of contention, but--by the grace of God--there was very little.  By the end of the 5th Century, each side accepted the other's formulation as being equivalent to their own, and this agreement has held now for some 16 centuries.

Yes, this is a very simple case, and the question of Papal Infallibility is more complex.  However, as Our Lord said:  "With men this is impossible, but with God all things are possible." (Mt. 19:26)


Quote from: AVZ on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 05:55:36Instead of inventing new untenable ways to keep complete or partial authority, it would serve both parties right to place authority and infallibility where it belongs...with Christ.
Absolutely!  But how do we do that in practical terms?  I think that coming together in faith and charity, and praying for the Holy Spirit to "guide us into all truth" is a good way indeed! ::clappingoverhead::

epiphanius

Quote from: FireSword on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 12:22:30
Does there has to be a change of policies in order for unity?

Nations have strong alliances, yet their policies are very different. I'm not sure what an alliance of churches would look like, but maybe a strong allied opinion against corruptions of this world, such as human trafficking and then united prayer against such.
FS,

Alliances can be very good things, and an alliance between the churches is certainly better than animosity towards each other.  However, it is only a step towards the unity that our blessed Savior desires for His Church.

Quote from: FireSword on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 12:22:30I've heard of some church meetings, but most are just a sham full of uninfluential people and compromise of beliefs in Christ.
Sorry to hear that.  I believe that the more we truly know Christ, the more we are able to see past our differences and see men and women who love Him as we do.

DaveW

Quote from: FireSword on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 12:22:30
Does there has to be a change of policies in order for unity?

I'm not sure what an alliance of churches would look like, but maybe a strong allied opinion against corruptions of this world, such as human trafficking and then united prayer against such. I've heard of some church meetings, but most are just a sham full of uninfluential people and compromise of beliefs in Christ.

Not so much a change of policy as a change of mentality; of understanding what unity is all about. 

Unity is NOT uniformity. Man and wife are ONE FLESH (unity) but are still different genders (Not uniformity).

In the first century bc there were 2 main leaders of the Pharisees: Rabbis Shammai and Hillel. (Paul's mentor Gameliel was Hillel's grandson) They both started rabbi training schools in Jerusalem and disagreed on almost every point of doctrine. They were also best friends. So much so that each put a rule in place that his students had to be married to a daughter of a graduate of the OTHER school.

THAT is the picture of what biblical unity looks like.  It was the cultural understanding of Our Lord and all the apostles.

Our Lord warned those apostles to not be like Gentiles who "lord it over" everyone.

Matt 20.25 But Jesus called them to Himself and said, You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great men exercise authority over them.
26 It is not this way among you, but whoever wishes to become great among you shall be your servant,
27 and whoever wishes to be first among you shall be your slave;

2 Corinthians 1:24  Not that we lord it over your faith, but are workers with you for your joy; for in your faith you are standing firm.

1 Peter 5:3  nor yet as lording it over those allotted to your charge, but proving to be examples to the flock.

Until the idea (that Our Lord linked to the gentiles) of lording it over everyone goes away, unity cannot be achieved. 

epiphanius

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
Quote from: FireSword on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 12:22:30
Does there has to be a change of policies in order for unity?

Not so much a change of policy as a change of mentality; of understanding what unity is all about.
Dave,

I like your insight here--it was a problem of mindset that got us where we are in the first place (a lot of confusing religion with politics).

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
Unity is NOT uniformity. Man and wife are ONE FLESH (unity) but are still different genders (Not uniformity).
This is a great parallel! 

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
In the first century bc there were 2 main leaders of the Pharisees: Rabbis Shammai and Hillel. (Paul's mentor Gameliel was Hillel's grandson) They both started rabbi training schools in Jerusalem and disagreed on almost every point of doctrine. They were also best friends. So much so that each put a rule in place that his students had to be married to a daughter of a graduate of the OTHER school.

THAT is the picture of what biblical unity looks like.  It was the cultural understanding of Our Lord and all the apostles. ).
QuotePSALM 133 (A Song of Ascents. By David.) See how good and how pleasant it is for brothers to live together in unity!
It is like the precious oil on the head, that ran down on the beard, even Aaron's beard; that came down on the edge of his robes;
like the dew of Hermon, that comes down on the hills of Zion: for there the LORD gives the blessing, even life forevermore.

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
Our Lord warned those apostles to not be like Gentiles who "lord it over" everyone.

Matt 20.25 But Jesus called them to Himself and said, You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great men exercise authority over them.
26 It is not this way among you, but whoever wishes to become great among you shall be your servant,
27 and whoever wishes to be first among you shall be your slave;

2 Corinthians 1:24  Not that we lord it over your faith, but are workers with you for your joy; for in your faith you are standing firm.

1 Peter 5:3  nor yet as lording it over those allotted to your charge, but proving to be examples to the flock.

Until the idea (that Our Lord linked to the gentiles) of lording it over everyone goes away, unity cannot be achieved. 
Since one of the Pope's titles is "Servant of the Servants of God" (based on a translation of Mt. 20:27 that uses "servant of all" instead of "slave"), it is clear that we do not have to abolish his office in order to achieve unity, only eliminate the "lording it over everyone" part (something Pope Francis appears to be trying very hard to do).

AVZ

Quote from: epiphanius on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 13:54:02
Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
Quote from: FireSword on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 12:22:30
Does there has to be a change of policies in order for unity?

Not so much a change of policy as a change of mentality; of understanding what unity is all about.
Dave,

I like your insight here--it was a problem of mindset that got us where we are in the first place (a lot of confusing religion with politics).

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
Unity is NOT uniformity. Man and wife are ONE FLESH (unity) but are still different genders (Not uniformity).
This is a great parallel! 

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
In the first century bc there were 2 main leaders of the Pharisees: Rabbis Shammai and Hillel. (Paul's mentor Gameliel was Hillel's grandson) They both started rabbi training schools in Jerusalem and disagreed on almost every point of doctrine. They were also best friends. So much so that each put a rule in place that his students had to be married to a daughter of a graduate of the OTHER school.

THAT is the picture of what biblical unity looks like.  It was the cultural understanding of Our Lord and all the apostles. ).
QuotePSALM 133 (A Song of Ascents. By David.) See how good and how pleasant it is for brothers to live together in unity!
It is like the precious oil on the head, that ran down on the beard, even Aaron's beard; that came down on the edge of his robes;
like the dew of Hermon, that comes down on the hills of Zion: for there the LORD gives the blessing, even life forevermore.

Quote from: DaveW on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 07:22:36
Our Lord warned those apostles to not be like Gentiles who "lord it over" everyone.

Matt 20.25 But Jesus called them to Himself and said, You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their great men exercise authority over them.
26 It is not this way among you, but whoever wishes to become great among you shall be your servant,
27 and whoever wishes to be first among you shall be your slave;

2 Corinthians 1:24  Not that we lord it over your faith, but are workers with you for your joy; for in your faith you are standing firm.

1 Peter 5:3  nor yet as lording it over those allotted to your charge, but proving to be examples to the flock.

Until the idea (that Our Lord linked to the gentiles) of lording it over everyone goes away, unity cannot be achieved. 
Since one of the Pope's titles is "Servant of the Servants of God" (based on a translation of Mt. 20:27 that uses "servant of all" instead of "slave"), it is clear that we do not have to abolish his office in order to achieve unity, only eliminate the "lording it over everyone" part (something Pope Francis appears to be trying very hard to do).

Is this really about what's on the Pope's business card?

epiphanius

Quote from: AVZ on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 20:59:27
Quote from: epiphanius on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 13:54:02
Since one of the Pope's titles is "Servant of the Servants of God" (based on a translation of Mt. 20:27 that uses "servant of all" instead of "slave"), it is clear that we do not have to abolish his office in order to achieve unity, only eliminate the "lording it over everyone" part (something Pope Francis appears to be trying very hard to do).
Is this really about what's on the Pope's business card?
AV,

I was really confused by your comment here, until I went back and re-read your previous posts in this thread, such as this one:
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.

If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.

I doubt that is ever going to happen.
It might be helpful to review a few facts about the Roman Papacy.  To begin with, in the year 754 AD, the Pope officially became a civil ruler as well as a religious leader, a situation that would last until 1870--more than 1000 years.  During this period, the concept of Church governance became deeply tied in with that of a monarchical form of government, in which two things were accepted as self-evident:
  • No government can be effective without having the fullness of authority vested in one person
  • Laws are to be enforced by coercion, using whatever means necessary to achieve compliance
First of all, one can easily see how a Papacy with that kind of attitude contributed to both the Great Schism and the Reformation.  What's not so easy to see is the progress that's been made since 1870 to "back away" from this monarchical (worldly) concept of the Papacy.

One of the first very visible signs of this transformation (there have been others that weren't so visible) came in 1963, when Pope Paul VI, after receiving the papal crown, set it aside and never used it again--no Pope since then has ever been crowned.  More recently, Pope Benedict XVI had his papal coat of arms designed with the image of a bishop's mitre in place of the usual image of the papal crown, starting a new tradition that Pope Francis has continued.

Yes, these are symbolic gestures, but they were made for a reason (and I do not believe deception was the reason!).  In addition to these gestures, we have the fact that both Protestant and Orthodox theologians were invited to participate as consultants at the 2nd Vatican Council (1962-1966).  These consultants took their roles very seriously, and the comments they made and the insight they provided were in turn taken very seriously by the Catholic bishops.  Since that time, high-level dialogues have gone on between Catholic theologians and both Protestant and Orthodox theologians, and both popes and bishops have endorsed them.

So, why is all this so significant?  Because it shows the fallacy of "one party says it's black and the other party says its white," as well as thinking of Rome as saying "I don't have to listen to you, you must listen to me."  (Only fools keep talking when nobody's listening--I don't think these people are fools.)

AVZ

Quote from: epiphanius on Thu Jul 11, 2013 - 16:41:33
Quote from: AVZ on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 20:59:27
Quote from: epiphanius on Wed Jul 10, 2013 - 13:54:02
Since one of the Pope's titles is "Servant of the Servants of God" (based on a translation of Mt. 20:27 that uses "servant of all" instead of "slave"), it is clear that we do not have to abolish his office in order to achieve unity, only eliminate the "lording it over everyone" part (something Pope Francis appears to be trying very hard to do).
Is this really about what's on the Pope's business card?
AV,

I was really confused by your comment here, until I went back and re-read your previous posts in this thread, such as this one:

The proposition in the above is to drop a meaning of a title in order to make the office acceptable to others.
Its a wrong proposition because it does not address the issue. The issue is not about a title, it is about the perception of the office.
The proposer basically tables the idea to keep everything as it is, but only dress it up in different wording.
There is no difference between a director who removes his title from his business card and still acts like a director, and a director who both has his title on his name card and acts like one?

Quote from: epiphanius on Thu Jul 11, 2013 - 16:41:33
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.

If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.

I doubt that is ever going to happen.
It might be helpful to review a few facts about the Roman Papacy.  To begin with, in the year 754 AD, the Pope officially became a civil ruler as well as a religious leader, a situation that would last until 1870--more than 1000 years.  During this period, the concept of Church governance became deeply tied in with that of a monarchical form of government, in which two things were accepted as self-evident:
  • No government can be effective without having the fullness of authority vested in one person
  • Laws are to be enforced by coercion, using whatever means necessary to achieve compliance
First of all, one can easily see how a Papacy with that kind of attitude contributed to both the Great Schism and the Reformation.  What's not so easy to see is the progress that's been made since 1870 to "back away" from this monarchical (worldly) concept of the Papacy.

One of the first very visible signs of this transformation (there have been others that weren't so visible) came in 1963, when Pope Paul VI, after receiving the papal crown, set it aside and never used it again--no Pope since then has ever been crowned.  More recently, Pope Benedict XVI had his papal coat of arms designed with the image of a bishop's mitre in place of the usual image of the papal crown, starting a new tradition that Pope Francis has continued.

Yes, these are symbolic gestures, but they were made for a reason (and I do not believe deception was the reason!).  In addition to these gestures, we have the fact that both Protestant and Orthodox theologians were invited to participate as consultants at the 2nd Vatican Council (1962-1966).  These consultants took their roles very seriously, and the comments they made and the insight they provided were in turn taken very seriously by the Catholic bishops.  Since that time, high-level dialogues have gone on between Catholic theologians and both Protestant and Orthodox theologians, and both popes and bishops have endorsed them.

So, why is all this so significant?  Because it shows the fallacy of "one party says it's black and the other party says its white," as well as thinking of Rome as saying "I don't have to listen to you, you must listen to me."  (Only fools keep talking when nobody's listening--I don't think these people are fools.)

I do know the historical logic of the papal title and have no offence with this.
I also agree with you that deception was not intended and I agree with you that in this specific circumstance having a single authority is fully understandable.

However, your argument once more displays how incorrect the notion of infallibility is.
If there was no such thing as declared infallibility, the Pope would long since been removed as single authority. It is by the claim of infallibility that the RCC simply is incapable and unable to amend the Popes position, because amending infallibility makes it fallible.
You can strip the Pope of his crown, his title and his symbols...but if the dogma remains, what is the difference?

I am not saying that popes and bishops are fools, but they are fools for embracing infallibility.
And as long ans this is embraced, they can talk the talk but they will never walk the walk.

epiphanius

Quote from: AVZ on Thu Jul 11, 2013 - 20:18:16
... your argument once more displays how incorrect the notion of infallibility is.
If there was no such thing as declared infallibility, the Pope would long since been removed as single authority.  It is by the claim of infallibility that the RCC simply is incapable and unable to amend the Popes position, because amending infallibility makes it fallible.
AV,

One reason why ecumenical dialogue is so important is that it's really the only way for different Christian groups to share their perceptions and understanding with regard to key terms used in expressing divine truth.  Papal infallibility is predicated on the infallibility of the Church, which is in turn derived from biblical promises, such as Matthew 16:18:
QuoteI also tell you that you are Peter,{Peter's name, Petros in Greek, is the word for a specific rock or stone.} and on this rock{Greek, petra, a rock mass or bedrock.} I will build my assembly, and the gates of Hades{or, Hell} will not prevail against it.

The supposition is that if the Church is protected from error, then the one who by his office has the authority to speak for the entire Church must also be protected from error--this, as you can see, is closely linked to the monarchistic political philosophy I mentioned above.

In other words, while the underlying doctrine (Christ protecting His Church from error) is not subject to revision, the expression of that doctrine (including the Pope speaking on behalf of the entire Church) *might* be.  The key is that all parties involved are seeking the truth in sincerity and faith, trusting in the Holy Spirit to "guide [them] into all truth."  This is the opposite of a worldly debate, in which the parties are seeking their own advantage and promoting their own agendas.

HRoberson

Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:14:18
Quote from: winsome on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 04:26:18
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Jul 01, 2013 - 20:22:48
I find it hard to believe that an equal dialogue is really feasible.
If a church has declared that she is infallible, than you can dialogue eternally without reaching a consensus.
It is simply not possible for the RCC to for example follow orthodox doctrine and do away with papal infallibility, because it will bring into question every dogma ever declared.

In this scenario, "the whole truth" simply expresses the wish of the orthodox church submitting herself fully to papal authority.
I doubt that is ever going to happen.

Two points:

1. In dialogue each side can better understand the other. Sometimes disagreements occur because there are misunderstanding over terms used. A few years ago the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation published a joint declaration on Justification. Some say though that agreement was reached only by fudging terms slightly. I think there may be a moving towards an understanding between Catholic and Ortodox on the filioque issue. I would agree though that the Catholic understanding of "papal infallibility" is a difficult one.

2. As far as I am aware there have only been two dogmas that have been declared by the Pope apart from an Ecumenical Council. Therefore "papal infallibility" only affects two dogmas not 'every dogma ever declared'.

From what I heard a few years ago the approach is to discuss less contentious isuses and build trust before tacking the more contentious issues. It's a slow process but I think we ought to applaud that it is happening.

I am purposely using papal infallibility, because that is a main issue between the RCC and the orthodox church.

Lets imagine that by some miracle the RCC and the orthodox church would concede that the Pope is not infallible.
That would not only kick the legs from under the Pope...but since he was declared infallible through infallible revelation by the church, that would kick the legs from under every single dogma ever declared by the RCC.
If the church was wrong once, she could be wrong twice...

So the bishops are going to have a nice chat, likely some good food and a few drinks...and then everybody goes back to how it was.
See, I can agree with this. In fact, the Easterners are just as adamant that THEY are the real church. If Rome is willing to give up her schismatic views and practices, those Easterners will be right proud to have her return to the Truth.

trifecta

Quote from: HRoberson on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:14:59
In fact, the Easterners are just as adamant that THEY are the real church. If Rome is willing to give up her schismatic views and practices, those Easterners will be right proud to have her return to the Truth.

I resemble that remark.  ::smile::

HRoberson

Quote from: trifecta on Sun Aug 18, 2013 - 16:39:34
Quote from: HRoberson on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:14:59
In fact, the Easterners are just as adamant that THEY are the real church. If Rome is willing to give up her schismatic views and practices, those Easterners will be right proud to have her return to the Truth.

I resemble that remark.  ::smile::
Hey, I'm doing my best to keep up your end of the argument!  ::whistle:: ::smile::

trifecta

Quote from: HRoberson on Sun Aug 18, 2013 - 16:56:26
Quote from: trifecta on Sun Aug 18, 2013 - 16:39:34
Quote from: HRoberson on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:14:59
In fact, the Easterners are just as adamant that THEY are the real church. If Rome is willing to give up her schismatic views and practices, those Easterners will be right proud to have her return to the Truth.

I resemble that remark.  ::smile::
Hey, I'm doing my best to keep up your end of the argument!  ::whistle:: ::smile::
And I appreciate it :)

Isn't there an ad slogan: "We do it so you don't have to?"   

HRoberson


epiphanius

Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:14:18
I am purposely using papal infallibility, because that is a main issue between the RCC and the orthodox church.

Lets imagine that by some miracle the RCC and the orthodox church would concede that the Pope is not infallible.
That would not only kick the legs from under the Pope...but since he was declared infallible through infallible revelation by the church, that would kick the legs from under every single dogma ever declared by the RCC.
If the church was wrong once, she could be wrong twice...

The fact is that the RCC definitely *has* admitted to having been wrong on a number of issues, albeit quietly.  The two most obvious examples that come to mind are the Vatican II declarations on Ecumenism and Religious Liberty.  Prior to the issuing of these documents, it was still an acceptable position for Catholics to believe, for example, that all non-Catholic Christians are heretics, or that Catholic governments have a right to deny the full privileges of citizenship to anyone who is not a practicing Catholic.  Needless to say, such notions have now rightly fallen into disfavor.

As for "kicking the legs from under the Pope," I believe that the popes have for some time now been moving away from a model of temporal authority and towards that of Christ himself, who said:
Quote"... If I don't do the works of my Father, don't believe me.  But if I do them, though you don't believe me, believe the works; that you may know and believe that the Father is in me, and I in the Father." (Jn. 10:37-38)

My prayer is that this will become more and more evident.

(BTW, for those who would say "well, why would the popes 'move away' from a previously-held position, rather than simply stand up and renounce it outright?"  The answer is that the discernment process takes time, while radical actions done abruptly usually do more harm than good.)

Quote from: HRoberson on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:14:59
Quote from: AVZ on Tue Jul 02, 2013 - 10:14:18
So the bishops are going to have a nice chat, likely some good food and a few drinks...and then everybody goes back to how it was.
See, I can agree with this. In fact, the Easterners are just as adamant that THEY are the real church. If Rome is willing to give up her schismatic views and practices, those Easterners will be right proud to have her return to the Truth.

As a matter of fact, there are many in the Orthodox communion who long for a return to communion with Rome and believe that the theological difficulties *can* be resolved--one of them being Patriarch Bartholomew himself (no mere coincidence that he attended Pope Francis' installation).  One problem here, however, is the fact that the Ecumenical Patriarch is *not* an "Orthodox Pope," and does not claim to speak for the entire Orthodox Church--and there are also *many* Orthodox who believe just as you said.

Little by little, the walls are coming down, but it's a s-l-o-w process!

mclees8

Quote from: epiphanius on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 14:10:05
Quote from: AVZ on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 05:55:36
Epi,
Mighty interesting. Want to address the following however:

Quote from: epiphanius on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 03:32:36
It is clear enough that the Orthodox Church has rejected and continues to reject the dogmatic statements made by Rome since the schism of 1054.  Both the Popes and the participants in these dialogues are very much aware of this, and none of them is under the illusion that any kind of unity between the RCC and the EOC can be achieved without revisiting all of these teachings, and either finding a mutually-acceptable expression of them, or (nobody is saying exactly how at this point) removing them from the list of dogmatic teachings.

Basically the options are as follows:
One party says it's black and the other party says its white.
The solution, according to the above, will be to either select black or white as being true, or find a formula in which grey is true.

In my book that is not trying to find the "whole truth" but plain and simple formulating another untrue statement which is neither warm or cold.

One important detail of Catholic dogmatic theology is that it is never the words themselves that are infallible, but the truth that lies behind them.  One example of how this works in a real-life scenario goes back to when both East (Greek) and West (Latin) were trying to formulate the doctrine of the Trinity: the East adopted the formula three Hypostases in one Ousia, while the West chose three Personae in one Substantia.  What's interesting here is that the literal meaning of the Greek word hypostasis (singular of hypostases) is identical to that of the Latin word substantia--both mean "that which stands beneath!"

In other words, the term used in the West for the One was the same term used in the East for the Three.  Obviously, there was a potential here for *lots* of contention, but--by the grace of God--there was very little.  By the end of the 5th Century, each side accepted the other's formulation as being equivalent to their own, and this agreement has held now for some 16 centuries.

Yes, this is a very simple case, and the question of Papal Infallibility is more complex.  However, as Our Lord said:  "With men this is impossible, but with God all things are possible." (Mt. 19:26)


Quote from: AVZ on Fri Jul 05, 2013 - 05:55:36Instead of inventing new untenable ways to keep complete or partial authority, it would serve both parties right to place authority and infallibility where it belongs...with Christ.
Absolutely!  But how do we do that in practical terms?  I think that coming together in faith and charity, and praying for the Holy Spirit to "guide us into all truth" is a good way indeed! ::clappingoverhead::

If we really saw Jesus for who he is and that he is not only thee truth but the whole truth. Truth is not in an institution or popes that want to be in charge. What I see in papal infallibility or papal supremacy  is wanting to be the Lord upon the earth. But true authority is not with men sitting on an earthly throne, but Jesus who sits on a heavenly throne at the right hand of the Father.  Why do they want to take His place and steel His glory for them selves. If they could only see how carnal this all is.   ::pondering::

DaveW

Quote from: epiphanius on Mon Aug 19, 2013 - 14:10:00
Little by little, the walls are coming down, but it's a s-l-o-w process!

Well - we have over a thousand years of junk to clear away.  That does not happen over night.

Praise God for movement in the right direction!

+-Recent Topics

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Today at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Today at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Today at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Today at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Yesterday at 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

Powered by EzPortal