News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898078
Total Topics: 90358
Most Online Today: 1685
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 0
Guests: 1678
Total: 1678
Google

Are the Decrees of The Council of Trent Still Binding?

Started by To Know is to Serve, Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:30:05

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

To Know is to Serve

Are the Decrees of The Council of Trent Still Binding?

Catholica


winsome



BlackSepulcher

Can Geico save you 15% or more on car insurance?

Quote from: To Know is to Serve on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:30:05
Are the Decrees of The Council of Trent Still Binding?


HRoberson

Here's a fun little site: http://vaticaninexile.com/


If you follow the links to their seminary, you'll learn about their plans to train men and women to be married priests (just the men of course), and their wives (just the women, of course).


It is rather entertaining reading (unless you're an arch-feminist in which case, you might blow a gasket).


These guys don't even like Traditional Catholics. How 'bout that?

winsome

Quote from: HRoberson on Sat Jul 20, 2013 - 14:44:40
Here's a fun little site: http://vaticaninexile.com/


If you follow the links to their seminary, you'll learn about their plans to train men and women to be married priests (just the men of course), and their wives (just the women, of course).


It is rather entertaining reading (unless you're an arch-feminist in which case, you might blow a gasket).


These guys don't even like Traditional Catholics. How 'bout that?

It's the old story. Once they split off from the Catholic Church they then split into smaller (and often increasingly stranger) groups.

Catholica


Amo

Quote from: Catholica on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:46:07
Of course they are!

All emphasis in the following is mine.

The Council of Trent
The Fourth Session
The canons and decrees of the sacred
and oecumenical Council of Trent,
Trans. J. Waterworth (London: Dolman, 1848), 17-21.

Hanover Historical Texts Project
Scanned by Hanover College students in 1995.
The page numbers of Waterworth's translation appear in brackets.

...
DECREE CONCERNING THE CANONICAL SCRIPTURES

The sacred and holy, ecumenical, and general Synod of Trent,--lawfully assembled in the Holy Ghost, the Same three legates of the Apostolic Sec presiding therein,--keeping this [Page 18] always in view, that, errors being removed, the purity itself of the Gospel be preserved in the Church; which (Gospel), before promised through the prophets in the holy Scriptures, our Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, first promulgated with His own mouth, and then commanded to be preached by His Apostles to every creature, as the fountain of all, both saving truth, and moral discipline; and seeing clearly that this truth and discipline are contained in the written books, and the unwritten traditions which, received by the Apostles from the mouth of Christ himself, or from the Apostles themselves, the Holy Ghost dictating, have come down even unto us, transmitted as it were from hand to hand; (the Synod) following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and venerates with an equal affection of piety, and reverence, all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament--seeing that one God is the author of both --as also the said traditions, as well those appertaining to faith as to morals, as having been dictated, either by Christ's own word of mouth, or by the Holy Ghost, and preserved in the Catholic Church by a continuous succession. And it has thought it meet that a list of the sacred books be inserted in this decree, lest a doubt may arise in any one's mind, which are the books that are received by this Synod. They are as set down here below: of the Old Testament: the five books of Moses, to wit, Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy; Josue, Judges, Ruth, four books of Kings, two of Paralipomenon, the first book of Esdras, and the second which is entitled Nehemias; Tobias, Judith, Esther, Job, the Davidical Psalter, consisting of a hundred and fifty psalms; the Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, the Canticle of Canticles, Wisdom, Ecclesiasticus, Isaias, Jeremias, with Baruch; Ezechiel, Daniel; the twelve minor prophets, to wit, Osee, Joel, Amos, Abdias, Jonas, Micheas, Nahum, Habacuc, Sophonias, Aggaeus, Zacharias, Malachias; two books of the Machabees, the first and the second. Of the New Testament: the four Gospels, according [Page 19] to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John; the Acts of the Apostles written by Luke the Evangelist; fourteen epistles of Paul the apostle, (one) to the Romans, two to the Corinthians, (one) to the Galatians, to the Ephesians, to the Philippians, to the Colossians, two to the Thessalonians, two to Timothy, (one) to Titus, to Philemon, to the Hebrews; two of Peter the apostle, three of John the apostle, one of the apostle James, one of Jude the apostle, and the Apocalypse of John the apostle. But if any one receive not, as sacred and canonical, the said books entire with all their parts, as they have been used to be read in the Catholic Church, and as they are contained in the old Latin vulgate edition; and knowingly and deliberately contemn the traditions aforesaid; let him be anathema. Let all, therefore, understand, in what order, and in what manner, the said Synod, after having laid the foundation of the Confession of faith, will proceed, and what testimonies and authorities it will mainly use in confirming dogmas, and in restoring morals in the Church.

DECREE CONCERNING THE EDITION, AND THE USE, OF THE SACRED BOOKS

Moreover, the same sacred and holy Synod,--considering that no small utility may accrue to the Church of God, if it be made known which out of all the Latin editions, now in circulation, of the sacred books, is to be held as authentic,--ordains and declares, that the said old and vulgate edition, which, by the lengthened usage of so many years, has been approved of in the Church, be, in public lectures, disputations, sermons and expositions, held as authentic; and that no one is to dare, or presume to reject it under any pretext whatever.

Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; [Page 20] or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published. Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries, and be punished with the penalties by law established.

And wishing, as is just, to impose a restraint, in this matter, also on printers, who now without restraint,--thinking, that is, that whatsoever they please is allowed them,--print, without the license of ecclesiastical superiors, the said books of sacred Scripture, and the notes and comments upon them of all persons indifferently, with the press ofttimes unnamed, often even fictitious, and what is more grievous still, without the author's name; and also keep for indiscriminate sale books of this kind printed elsewhere; (this Synod) ordains and decrees, that, henceforth, the sacred Scripture, and especially the said old and vulgate edition, be printed in the most correct manner possible; and that it shall not be lawful for any one to print, or cause to be printed, any books whatever, on sacred matters, without the name of the author; nor to sell them in future, or even to keep them, unless they shall have been first examined, and approved of, by the Ordinary; under pain of the anathema and fine imposed in a canon of the last Council of Lateran: and, if they be Regulars, besides this examination and approval, they shall be bound to obtain a license also from their own superiors, who shall have examined the books according to the form of their own statutes. As to those who lend, or circulate them in manuscript, without their having been first examined, and approved of, they shall be subjected to the same penalties as printers: and they who shall have them in their possession or shall read them, shall, unless they discover the authors, be themselves regarded as the authors. And the said approbation of books of this kind shall be given in writing; and for this end it shall appear authentically at the beginning of the book, whether the book be written, or printed; and all this, that is, both the approbation and the examination, shall be done gratis, that so what ought to be approved, may be approved, and what ought to be condemned, may be condemned.




Catholica

Amo, what is your point?  What do you think your highlighted portions mean?

mclees8

#10
Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; [Page 20] or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published. Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries, and be punished with the penalties by law established.

And wishing, as is just, to impose a restraint, in this matter, also on printers, who now without restraint,--thinking, that is, that whatsoever they please is allowed them,--print, without the license of ecclesiastical superiors, the said books of sacred Scripture, and the notes and comments upon them of all persons indifferently, with the press ofttimes unnamed, often even fictitious, and what is more grievous still, without the author's name; and also keep for indiscriminate sale books of this kind printed elsewhere; (this Synod) ordains and decrees, that, henceforth, the sacred Scripture, and especially the said old and vulgate edition, be printed in the most correct manner possible; and that it shall not be lawful for any one to print, or cause to be printed, any books whatever, on sacred matters, without the name of the author; nor to sell them in future, or even to keep them, unless they shall have been first examined, and approved of, by the Ordinary; under pain of the anathema and fine imposed in a canon of the last Council of Lateran: and, if they be Regulars, besides this examination and approval, they shall be bound to obtain a license also from their own superiors, who shall have examined the books according to the form of their own statutes. As to those who lend, or circulate them in manuscript, without their having been first examined, and approved of, they shall be subjected to the same penalties as printers: and they who shall have them in their possession or shall read them, shall, unless they discover the authors, be themselves regarded as the authors. And the said approbation of books of this kind shall be given in writing; and for this end it shall appear authentically at the beginning of the book, whether the book be written, or printed; and all this, that is, both the approbation and the examination, shall be done gratis, that so what ought to be approved, may be approved, and what ought to be condemned, may be condemned.


It sounds to me that they declared that it should be illegal for anyone to reprint any of the sacred scriptures and or interpretations independently without approval and consent of the Holy Mother church and if any did they would be declared anathema ( banished from the church)  Is this a correct idea here. please comment if not
I only copied the parts that contained the highlight. It did not past the highlight. Just scroll up to view them.  sorry 

Catholica

#11
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 09:51:24
Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; [Page 20] or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published. Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries, and be punished with the penalties by law established.

And wishing, as is just, to impose a restraint, in this matter, also on printers, who now without restraint,--thinking, that is, that whatsoever they please is allowed them,--print, without the license of ecclesiastical superiors, the said books of sacred Scripture, and the notes and comments upon them of all persons indifferently, with the press ofttimes unnamed, often even fictitious, and what is more grievous still, without the author's name; and also keep for indiscriminate sale books of this kind printed elsewhere; (this Synod) ordains and decrees, that, henceforth, the sacred Scripture, and especially the said old and vulgate edition, be printed in the most correct manner possible; and that it shall not be lawful for any one to print, or cause to be printed, any books whatever, on sacred matters, without the name of the author; nor to sell them in future, or even to keep them, unless they shall have been first examined, and approved of, by the Ordinary; under pain of the anathema and fine imposed in a canon of the last Council of Lateran: and, if they be Regulars, besides this examination and approval, they shall be bound to obtain a license also from their own superiors, who shall have examined the books according to the form of their own statutes. As to those who lend, or circulate them in manuscript, without their having been first examined, and approved of, they shall be subjected to the same penalties as printers: and they who shall have them in their possession or shall read them, shall, unless they discover the authors, be themselves regarded as the authors. And the said approbation of books of this kind shall be given in writing; and for this end it shall appear authentically at the beginning of the book, whether the book be written, or printed; and all this, that is, both the approbation and the examination, shall be done gratis, that so what ought to be approved, may be approved, and what ought to be condemned, may be condemned.


It sounds to me that they declared that it should be illegal for anyone to reprint any of the sacred scriptures with out approval and consent of the Holy Mother church and if any did they would be declared anathema ( banished from the church)  Is this a correct idea here. please comment if not

Yes, that is correct.  Let's consider context...

* The printing press had just been invented and was a powerful tool for reprinting.
* Any Joe could print anything he wanted easily,  including corrupted Bible translations with heretical notes in the side bars.
* The intended audience were Catholics, faithful and those who were apostatizing while promoting heretical doctrines.

It was then that the official teaching of the Church was that the Bible was so important that they wanted there to only be valid translations, which included all the books of the Bible, and without just any old (possibly heretical) sidebar comments.

I can read what he bolded.  I wished to know what HE thought that meant.  It is easier for me to correct misunderstanding if I actually know what the author of the post thought it meant.

For example.  Some people think that anathema means that someone is damned to hell.  Not so.  From that they assume that misunderstood "proclamation of damnation" is meant to extend to non-Catholics.  Not so.

Basically all the Church was saying is they didn't want bad translations of the Bible out and they were doing what was rightly in their jurisdiction to stop that from happening.

It was not to keep the Bible out of peoples' hands that they did this but to keep bad Bibles out of peoples' hands and keep good Bibles in their hands, good Bibles which were already being produced, such as the Gutenberg bible.

Nowadays the proliferation of bad Bibles has led to not only abandoning seven books of scripture by many, but also to translations made with bias toward false doctrine.  It led to Luther's sidenotes on Roman 3:28 to lead people to believe the Bible actually said "faith alone" (it only says "not by faith alone").  It led to groups like the Watchtower society and the New World Bible.  It led to horrible translations like "The Message" which is filled with new age terminology.  There are some good translations out there by non-Catholic groups as well, but they are nearly all missing some books of the OT. 

This was a clear message to Catholics that it was against the will of God that they should produce, on their own, possibly bad translations with false doctrine in the sidebar.


epiphanius

Catholica,

All in all, a good analysis.  However, I don't think it's fair to put Luther's translation and notes on the same level with the Watchtower translation and some New Age translation.  Also, it's hardly accurate to blame the abandoning of the Deuterocanonical books on the "proliferation of bad Bibles."

The story of the Deuterocanonical books is actually quite interesting, and very closely linked to the Septuagint (LXX) Greek translation of the OT.  The LXX, which was made in Alexandria ~200 BC, was widely used and accepted in First-Century Israel and included the Deuterocanonical books.  After the Fall of Jerusalem and the definitive split between Christians and Jews, the LXX was rejected by the Jews, and with it the Deuterocanonical books.  Christians, on the other hand, continued to accept both, and while there was some discussion of the canonicity of these books in the first four centuries AD, most questions of canonicity at that time had to do with the NT books.  After that, the subject of the OT canon did not come up again for about 1000 years.  Then, shortly before Luther's time, scholars took a new interest in the subject, and their consensus came to be that the Deuterocanonical books needed to be re-evaluated, and probably excluded.  Being a scholar himself, Luther concurred with this opinion.

It is easy to see, moreover, why Luther would reject 2 Maccabees in particular, since it describes a practice that closely resembles what he was condemning:
Quote(A)nd they turned to prayer, beseeching that the sin which had been committed might be wholly blotted out. And the noble Judas exhorted the people to keep themselves free from sin, for they had seen with their own eyes what had happened because of the sin of those who had fallen.  He also took up a collection, man by man, to the amount of two thousand drachmas of silver, and sent it to Jerusalem to provide for a sin offering [i.e. for those who had fallen].  In doing this he acted very well and honorably, taking account of the resurrection.  For if he were not expecting that those who had fallen would rise again, it would have been superfluous and foolish to pray for the dead.  But if he was looking to the splendid reward that is laid up for those who fall asleep in godliness, it was a holy and pious thought. Therefore he made atonement for the dead, that they might be delivered from their sin. (2 Macc 12:42–45)

FireSword

That passage talks about a resurrection of the dead

epiphanius

Quote from: FireSword on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 21:00:09
That passage talks about a resurrection of the dead

Yes, and the Pharisees, who accepted all the books of the Septuagint as given by God, also believed that the dead would one day be raised.  The Sadducees, who accepted only the Torah/Pentateuch as given by God, did not.

The significance of the passage, though, is that it speaks of prayers for the dead, and of sending money to Jerusalem specifically to have sacrifices offered for the fallen soldiers (who had been found to be carrying idols with them--presumably to protect them in battle--and were therefore guilty of a serious sin).

mclees8

#15
Quote from: Catholica on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 10:15:10
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 09:51:24
Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; [Page 20] or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published. Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries, and be punished with the penalties by law established.

And wishing, as is just, to impose a restraint, in this matter, also on printers, who now without restraint,--thinking, that is, that whatsoever they please is allowed them,--print, without the license of ecclesiastical superiors, the said books of sacred Scripture, and the notes and comments upon them of all persons indifferently, with the press ofttimes unnamed, often even fictitious, and what is more grievous still, without the author's name; and also keep for indiscriminate sale books of this kind printed elsewhere; (this Synod) ordains and decrees, that, henceforth, the sacred Scripture, and especially the said old and vulgate edition, be printed in the most correct manner possible; and that it shall not be lawful for any one to print, or cause to be printed, any books whatever, on sacred matters, without the name of the author; nor to sell them in future, or even to keep them, unless they shall have been first examined, and approved of, by the Ordinary; under pain of the anathema and fine imposed in a canon of the last Council of Lateran: and, if they be Regulars, besides this examination and approval, they shall be bound to obtain a license also from their own superiors, who shall have examined the books according to the form of their own statutes. As to those who lend, or circulate them in manuscript, without their having been first examined, and approved of, they shall be subjected to the same penalties as printers: and they who shall have them in their possession or shall read them, shall, unless they discover the authors, be themselves regarded as the authors. And the said approbation of books of this kind shall be given in writing; and for this end it shall appear authentically at the beginning of the book, whether the book be written, or printed; and all this, that is, both the approbation and the examination, shall be done gratis, that so what ought to be approved, may be approved, and what ought to be condemned, may be condemned.


It sounds to me that they declared that it should be illegal for anyone to reprint any of the sacred scriptures with out approval and consent of the Holy Mother church and if any did they would be declared anathema ( banished from the church)  Is this a correct idea here. please comment if not

Yes, that is correct.  Let's consider context...

* The printing press had just been invented and was a powerful tool for reprinting.
* Any Joe could print anything he wanted easily,  including corrupted Bible translations with heretical notes in the side bars.
* The intended audience were Catholics, faithful and those who were apostatizing while promoting heretical doctrines.

It was then that the official teaching of the Church was that the Bible was so important that they wanted there to only be valid translations, which included all the books of the Bible, and without just any old (possibly heretical) sidebar comments.

I can read what he bolded.  I wished to know what HE thought that meant.  It is easier for me to correct misunderstanding if I actually know what the author of the post thought it meant.

For example.  Some people think that anathema means that someone is damned to hell.  Not so.  From that they assume that misunderstood "proclamation of damnation" is meant to extend to non-Catholics.  Not so.

Basically all the Church was saying is they didn't want bad translations of the Bible out and they were doing what was rightly in their jurisdiction to stop that from happening.

It was not to keep the Bible out of peoples' hands that they did this but to keep bad Bibles out of peoples' hands and keep good Bibles in their hands, good Bibles which were already being produced, such as the Gutenberg bible.

Nowadays the proliferation of bad Bibles has led to not only abandoning seven books of scripture by many, but also to translations made with bias toward false doctrine.  It led to Luther's sidenotes on Roman 3:28 to lead people to believe the Bible actually said "faith alone" (it only says "not by faith alone").  It led to groups like the Watchtower society and the New World Bible.  It led to horrible translations like "The Message" which is filled with new age terminology.  There are some good translations out there by non-Catholic groups as well, but they are nearly all missing some books of the OT. 

This was a clear message to Catholics that it was against the will of God that they should produce, on their own, possibly bad translations with false doctrine in the sidebar.



I looked up anathema. it often likened to excommunication. Something in all this is bothering me. Who are they saying should be banished from the church. Who are the ones using the printing press. Are they ones who come to Christ and therefor have come into the church that they could then be banished from it. I went to the Catholic encyclopedia and it all read very properly according to what Paul taught but who was Paul speaking of when he taught this about putting one out of the church in hopes he would repent. How does one come into the church. Do they not come into the church after hearing the gospel and believing in Jesus as his savior. Did the church then have any concern for secular law. All the churches were basically autonomous so when it came to church conduct they determined if a member should be removed from the congregation according to the apostles teaching.
Making rulings of what legal or unlawful in the church was confined to that church. 

It appears to me about the council of Trent that they saw themselves ( the popes and hierarchy of the church) were making laws over the people of the land and not real Christians who have personally come to Christ for salvation. I noted while reading that it said the church was the body of Christ which is right but how can they make laws then to govern the people of the land many of who never knew personal salvation.

Was the church acting form a position of religious political authority which was not what Paul taught or envisioned?

Catholica

#16
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
Quote from: Catholica on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 10:15:10
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 09:51:24
Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, It decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; [Page 20] or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published. Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries, and be punished with the penalties by law established.

And wishing, as is just, to impose a restraint, in this matter, also on printers, who now without restraint,--thinking, that is, that whatsoever they please is allowed them,--print, without the license of ecclesiastical superiors, the said books of sacred Scripture, and the notes and comments upon them of all persons indifferently, with the press ofttimes unnamed, often even fictitious, and what is more grievous still, without the author's name; and also keep for indiscriminate sale books of this kind printed elsewhere; (this Synod) ordains and decrees, that, henceforth, the sacred Scripture, and especially the said old and vulgate edition, be printed in the most correct manner possible; and that it shall not be lawful for any one to print, or cause to be printed, any books whatever, on sacred matters, without the name of the author; nor to sell them in future, or even to keep them, unless they shall have been first examined, and approved of, by the Ordinary; under pain of the anathema and fine imposed in a canon of the last Council of Lateran: and, if they be Regulars, besides this examination and approval, they shall be bound to obtain a license also from their own superiors, who shall have examined the books according to the form of their own statutes. As to those who lend, or circulate them in manuscript, without their having been first examined, and approved of, they shall be subjected to the same penalties as printers: and they who shall have them in their possession or shall read them, shall, unless they discover the authors, be themselves regarded as the authors. And the said approbation of books of this kind shall be given in writing; and for this end it shall appear authentically at the beginning of the book, whether the book be written, or printed; and all this, that is, both the approbation and the examination, shall be done gratis, that so what ought to be approved, may be approved, and what ought to be condemned, may be condemned.


It sounds to me that they declared that it should be illegal for anyone to reprint any of the sacred scriptures with out approval and consent of the Holy Mother church and if any did they would be declared anathema ( banished from the church)  Is this a correct idea here. please comment if not

Yes, that is correct.  Let's consider context...

* The printing press had just been invented and was a powerful tool for reprinting.
* Any Joe could print anything he wanted easily,  including corrupted Bible translations with heretical notes in the side bars.
* The intended audience were Catholics, faithful and those who were apostatizing while promoting heretical doctrines.

It was then that the official teaching of the Church was that the Bible was so important that they wanted there to only be valid translations, which included all the books of the Bible, and without just any old (possibly heretical) sidebar comments.

I can read what he bolded.  I wished to know what HE thought that meant.  It is easier for me to correct misunderstanding if I actually know what the author of the post thought it meant.

For example.  Some people think that anathema means that someone is damned to hell.  Not so.  From that they assume that misunderstood "proclamation of damnation" is meant to extend to non-Catholics.  Not so.

Basically all the Church was saying is they didn't want bad translations of the Bible out and they were doing what was rightly in their jurisdiction to stop that from happening.

It was not to keep the Bible out of peoples' hands that they did this but to keep bad Bibles out of peoples' hands and keep good Bibles in their hands, good Bibles which were already being produced, such as the Gutenberg bible.

Nowadays the proliferation of bad Bibles has led to not only abandoning seven books of scripture by many, but also to translations made with bias toward false doctrine.  It led to Luther's sidenotes on Roman 3:28 to lead people to believe the Bible actually said "faith alone" (it only says "not by faith alone").  It led to groups like the Watchtower society and the New World Bible.  It led to horrible translations like "The Message" which is filled with new age terminology.  There are some good translations out there by non-Catholic groups as well, but they are nearly all missing some books of the OT. 

This was a clear message to Catholics that it was against the will of God that they should produce, on their own, possibly bad translations with false doctrine in the sidebar.



I looked up anathema. it often likened to excommunication.

This is true.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
Some in all this is bothering me. Who are they saying should be banished from the church. Who are the ones using the printing press. Are they ones who come to Christ and therefor have come into the church that they could then be banished from it.

They are the ones who are the established authority in the Catholic Church.  The ones using the printing press whom they have authority over are people baptized Catholic or received into the Catholic Church.  For example, Johannes Gutenberg, who invented the printing press, was a person baptized Catholic.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
I went to the Catholic encyclopedia and it all read very properly according to what Paul taught but who was Paul speaking of when he taught this about putting one out of the church in hopes he would repent.

Paul is speaking of people who are sinning.  And heresy is a sin.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
How does one come into the church. Do they not come into the church after hearing the gospel and believing in Jesus as his savior.

They come into the Church through baptism primarily.  If one is baptized Catholic, he is bound to the authority of the Church.  If one is baptized validly but not as a Catholic, and then wants to become Catholic, he is received formally and makes a choice to become Catholic and bind himself to that authority.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
Did the church then have any concern for secular law. All the churches were basically autonomous so when it came to church conduct they determined if a member should be removed from the congregation according to the apostles teaching.

There were never any but heretical faith communities that were "autonomous" since Christianity was founded.  This can be understood simply by looking at the apostles' authority in Acts 15, and in the letters they wrote.  All of Christianity bound themselves to believe the truth taught by the apostles.  The apostles sometimes wrote letters to correct people.  Or visited them.  Primarily visited them or ordained bishops such as St. Timothy in 1 and 2 Timothy, to be their delegated authority.  Authority always came from one head, Jesus Christ, and there were never any orthodox autonomous Christian communities.

The Church has always sought to guide secular law insofar that it should follow (flow from) the law of God.  Secular members of the Church in secular authority, to different degrees, have at times done more or less to make that come about.  And doing so is for the best of humanity, not just Christians.  All secular offices derive their authority from God (Jesus said) and so their laws should be in accord with the law of God.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
Making rulings of what legal or unlawful in the church was confined to that church. 

It appears to me about the council of Trent that they saw themselves ( the popes and hierarchy of the church) were making laws over the people of the land and not real Christians who have personally come to Christ for salvation. I noted while reading that it said the church was the body of Christ which is right but how can they make laws then to govern the people of the land many of who never knew personal salvation.

The Council of Trent was binding for Catholics; anyone who was baptized Catholic or who entered the Catholic Church from another religion.  The Church has authority over it's members, which is both a duty and a responsibility, in order to guide them on the right path.  And the wrong path was to publish heresy.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 14:33:43
Was the church acting form a position of religious political authority which was not what Paul taught or envisioned?

They have religious authority over persons, not just doctrine.  And so their authority extends to guiding lay people in their everyday lives to keep them free from sin.

mclees8

#17
I have more to say about all this and I will, but for the moment I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved. And if you do not you are not saved and you are going to hell. Thats how it was then Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths  also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation. Yet in my spirit I am deeply troubled that many have never truly found Christ and rest their salvation on ritual ordinance. I don't know how others know they are saved but I know that I am saved not because I was baptized but with tears asked Him to reveal himself to me one night and in that very moment I knew Him and what he truly did for me.. When Jesus said you must be Born again of the spirit( and I emphasize it say must be) in order to come into the kingdom it is not just a commandment but an absolute truth. I was saved from the moment tears ran down my face and not from formal baptism but a true revelation that changed my life forever . I pray you feel My emotion about this. So before you think your baptism saves you might check you brokenness first. 

epiphanius

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved.
McL,

Your comments show you're doing some real reflection on these matters, which is always a good thing.  You are right that in the Middle Ages, the Church and the State had gotten so intertwined that both tended to deal with problems in the same way, hence the emphasis on Baptism (which is visible and measurable) over faith (which is not).

Interestingly, though, the Catholic Church has always taught the need for both.  Moreover, it has always allowed for God's judgment to override any requirements put forth by the Church.  For example, "Baptism of Desire," which allows that someone who dies while still a catechumen (or otherwise having professed faith in Jesus Christ but not yet received Baptism) is saved, has long been an accepted teaching--even though it has never been formally defined as dogma (and is even rejected by some Catholic traditionalists).  Furthermore, it has always allowed that the divine judgment supercedes any excommunication or anathema pronounced by the Church.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation.

I heard a very interesting discussion on the radio one time between two theologians, one Baptist and one Reformed.  The Baptist stated that a profession of faith must always come first, and pointed out that there is no mention of infant Baptism in the New Testament.  The Reformed then countered that not only was infant Baptism a well-established practice of the Church by the 2nd Century, but that the practice clearly has its roots in the Old Testament practice of Circumcision, in that Baptism now takes the place of Circumcision as the "Sign of the Covenant."  (Naturally, he did not minimize the importance of making a personal profession of faith, but he did not require it to come first.)

Also, regarding the real significance of Baptism in the Christian life, I offer Romans 6:3-4:
QuoteOr don't you know that all we who were baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death?  We were buried therefore with him through baptism to death, that just like Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we also might walk in newness of life.

Clearly, St. Paul is speaking here of our participating in the death and Resurrection of Christ by means of Baptism!

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
... Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

I can see how the Pope's words can be taken to mean this, but I don't believe this is what he is saying or what he intends to say.



Catholica

#19
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I have more to say about all this and I will, but for the moment I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved. And if you do not you are not saved and you are going to hell. Thats how it was then Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths  also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

You should have a hard time with mechanical salvation, because it is false.  But it is not what the Catholic Church teaches.  The Catholic Church does not teach that if you are a baptized Catholic under the rule of the pope you will be saved.  It also does not teach that if you are not then you are going to hell.

What it does teach is that, what has been revealed are two things, that baptism has been given to us as the normal means of initially being justified (having both original and actual sins forgiven) and becoming part of the body of Christ, and that Christ gave his authority to the Church so that we may also have our sins forgiven through it.  This message, understood positively in this way, shows that Christ has given the Church to us as His delivery mechanism for salvation, if you will.  However the following facts remain:

* Those who are baptized and still consider themselves Catholic may be lost through unrepentant mortal sin.
* Those who are catechumens who have not yet been baptized, if they die, will be saved as if they had received baptism.
* Those who are martyred for the faith even without receiving baptism will be saved (witness the Holy Innocents)
* God MAY still save those who, through no fault of their own, have never received baptism nor knowledge of the gospel as so are invincibly ignorant

That is not to say that one can be saved by merely having (the immeasurably squishy) "faith alone".  Nor should one hope to be saved even though they reject the gifts Christ has given humanity though the Catholic Church in the sacraments.  It is a desperate hope that is very vain, and in some ways borders or adopts pelagianism, the belief that one can be saved without Jesus (in practice, not in belief) WHEN one considers that Jesus, who is God, died and resurrected for them AND founded the Church with his authority and sent them "as God sent (Him)".(John 20:21)

For what purpose did God send Jesus?  To bring salvation.  Now the Church is told to go forth teaching and baptizing. (Matthew 28:19-20) That, mclees8, makes the Church the means of salvation, and if one rejects the Church, he rejects Jesus, and if he rejects Jesus, he rejects the Father (Luke 10:16).

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation. Yet in my spirit I am deeply troubled that many have never truly found Christ and rest their salvation on ritual ordinance.

There is salvation through baptism for those who cannot understand the gospel, who are incapable.  The Bible, in multiple places, states directly or infers that baptism is the washing away of sins, the regenerative act, without which no one can be saved.  It is through baptism and repentance (of personal sins) and faith, which is more specific than belief, that one is saved.  Faith is a supernatural virtue, a grace from God.  Babies and people with severe mental handicap or human vegetables, they cannot comprehend the gospel, nor can they personally sin, but they are not born worthy of heaven.  To say otherwise is, again, pelagianism.  Yet God can and does still save them through baptism, and baptism infuses faith to them even through the incapacity for them to rationally believe. 

Baptism is a free gift which requires nothing, absolutely NOTHING from the recipient.  Infant baptism is a profound expression on the true gratuitousness of this gift, because it shows that we truly can do nothing to save ourselves.

And yet we should never rest on the sacraments to believe that they will save us in spite of ourselves, and our choices to sin and reject the grace God gives us.  Well-catechized Catholics know this.  Faith grows and solidifies us in God, and through the sacraments and prayer we receive the grace we need to persevere in holiness, without which no one will see God.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I don't know how others know they are saved but I know that I am saved not because I was baptized but with tears asked Him to reveal himself to me one night and in that very moment I knew Him and what he truly did for me.. When Jesus said you must be Born again of the spirit( and I emphasize it say must be) in order to come into the kingdom it is not just a commandment but an absolute truth. I was saved from the moment tears ran down my face and not from formal baptism but a true revelation that changed my life forever . I pray you feel My emotion about this. So before you think your baptism saves you might check you brokenness first. 

I know that your emotions and brokenness suggest you have realized your need for Christ.  And this brokenness we all feel who seek Christ.  But emotions don't suggest that we are saved.  Emotions can be felt absolutely naturally by people who are not saved who also feel their brokenness.  And baptism isn't a cure for our brokenness.  But it is the actual meaning of being born again of "water and spirit".  So you were initially justified through your baptism, whether you believe such or not.  But you shouldn't rely on your emotions nor your baptism to save you, nor an idea that being sad for your sins will save you, nor even that Jesus changed your life as evidence that you will be ultimately saved.  Jesus also changed Judas' life, but ultimately it doesn't appear that he was saved.  And even Paul knew that if he did not persevere in the faith, he could become reprobate.

Ultimately, it comes down to the grace of God to save you.  You received grace to believe in Christ, and you received grace in your baptism, and you receive grace whenever you wish to repent.  But being unable to receive the sacraments, you are missing out on the many graces which God wants to continue to give you because he loves you.  These graces will give you peace, help you become humble and help you get closer and closer to God, more close than anyone can be without them, of his own desire.

God wants you in his Church, mclees.  Many people on this board who simply dismiss the Catholic faith, you actually research it and I can sense that you try to understand it, even though it seems offensive to you in many ways.  I encourage you at least to continue in that, and I pray that God will continue to lead you on the path which He desires for you, whatever that may be.

mclees8

#20
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 09:36:13
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I have more to say about all this and I will, but for the moment I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved. And if you do not you are not saved and you are going to hell. Thats how it was then Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths  also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

You should have a hard time with mechanical salvation, because it is false.  But it is not what the Catholic Church teaches.  The Catholic Church does not teach that if you are a baptized Catholic under the rule of the pope you will be saved.  It also does not teach that if you are not then you are going to hell.

What it does teach is that, what has been revealed are two things, that baptism has been given to us as the normal means of initially being justified (having both original and actual sins forgiven) and becoming part of the body of Christ, and that Christ gave his authority to the Church so that we may also have our sins forgiven through it.  This message, understood positively in this way, shows that Christ has given the Church to us as His delivery mechanism for salvation, if you will.  However the following facts remain:

* Those who are baptized and still consider themselves Catholic may be lost through unrepentant mortal sin.
* Those who are catechumens who have not yet been baptized, if they die, will be saved as if they had received baptism.
* Those who are martyred for the faith even without receiving baptism will be saved (witness the Holy Innocents)
* God MAY still save those who, through no fault of their own, have never received baptism nor knowledge of the gospel as so are invincibly ignorant

That is not to say that one can be saved by merely having (the immeasurably squishy) "faith alone".  Nor should one hope to be saved even though they reject the gifts Christ has given humanity though the Catholic Church in the sacraments.  It is a desperate hope that is very vain, and in some ways borders or adopts pelagianism, the belief that one can be saved without Jesus (in practice, not in belief) WHEN one considers that Jesus, who is God, died and resurrected for them AND founded the Church with his authority and sent them "as God sent (Him)".(John 20:21)

For what purpose did God send Jesus?  To bring salvation.  Now the Church is told to go forth teaching and baptizing. (Matthew 28:19-20) That, mclees8, makes the Church the means of salvation, and if one rejects the Church, he rejects Jesus, and if he rejects Jesus, he rejects the Father (Luke 10:16).

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation. Yet in my spirit I am deeply troubled that many have never truly found Christ and rest their salvation on ritual ordinance.

There is salvation through baptism for those who cannot understand the gospel, who are incapable.  The Bible, in multiple places, states directly or infers that baptism is the washing away of sins, the regenerative act, without which no one can be saved.  It is baptism and faith, which is more specific than belief that one is saved.  Faith is a supernatural virtue, a grace from God.  Babies and people with severe mental handicap or human vegetables, they cannot comprehend the gospel, but God can and does still save them through baptism, and baptism infuses faith to them even through the incapacity for them to rationally believe. 

Baptism is a free gift which requires nothing, absolutely NOTHING from the recipient.  Infant baptism is a profound expression on the true gratuitousness of this gift, because it shows that we truly can do nothing to save ourselves.

And yet we should never rest on the sacraments to believe that they will save us in spite of ourselves, and our choices to sin and reject the grace God gives us.  Well-catechized Catholics know this.  Faith grows and solidifies us in God, and through the sacraments and prayer we receive the grace we need to persevere in holiness, without which no one will see God.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I don't know how others know they are saved but I know that I am saved not because I was baptized but with tears asked Him to reveal himself to me one night and in that very moment I knew Him and what he truly did for me.. When Jesus said you must be Born again of the spirit( and I emphasize it say must be) in order to come into the kingdom it is not just a commandment but an absolute truth. I was saved from the moment tears ran down my face and not from formal baptism but a true revelation that changed my life forever . I pray you feel My emotion about this. So before you think your baptism saves you might check you brokenness first. 

I know that your emotions and brokenness suggest you have realized your need for Christ.  And this brokenness we all feel who seek Christ.  But emotions don't suggest that we are saved.  Emotions can be felt absolutely naturally by people who are not saved who also feel their brokenness.  And baptism isn't a cure for our brokenness.  But it is the actual meaning of being born again of "water and spirit".  So you were initially justified through your baptism, whether you believe such or not.  But you shouldn't rely on your emotions nor your baptism to save you, nor an idea that being sad for your sins will save you, nor even that Jesus changed your life as evidence that you will be ultimately saved.  Jesus also changed Judas' life, but ultimately it doesn't appear that he was saved.  And even Paul knew that if he did not persevere in the faith, he could become reprobate.

Ultimately, it comes down to the grace of God to save you.  You received grace to believe in Christ, and you received grace in your baptism, and you receive grace whenever you wish to repent.  But being unable to receive the sacraments, you are missing out on the many graces which God wants to continue to give you because he loves you.  These graces will give you peace, help you become humble and help you get closer and closer to God, more close than anyone can be without them, of his own desire.

God wants you in his Church, mclees.  Many people on this board who simply dismiss the Catholic faith, you actually research it and I can sense that you try to understand it, even though it seems offensive to you in many ways.  I encourage you at least to continue in that, and I pray that God will continue to lead you on the path which He desires for you, whatever that may be.

I understand about your squishy faith alone. True faith is transforming. It entails a life change. Faith without works is dead. One who has been truly transformed will produce good fruit (good works) No brag or merit badge but the love of Christ works in him.

No it wasn't just tears that saved me but a heart cry. You see I was desperate to find truth in my life and I was struggling with Who Jesus really was. I desperately wanted to believe but it all changed when with my tears I said I believe. It was in that very moment Jesus was truly revealed and all doubt was gone. I was able then to say as Peter, " thou art the Christ the Son of the living God" I might not have fully understood it all but I know now I was saved that very moment. Until we truly believe we cannot fully comprehend or appreciate  the grace of God.

I do not want to hinder another faith concerning their faith in the Eucharist. I was brought up in Protestant churches and still believe in communion. It is the heart the Lords sees when one approaches His table.

One  who's life is truly given will never forget who His Lord is. Again I do not want to hinder anyone

I almost have to chuckle. You said the Lord wants me in His church. I already am and have been the first moment I believed.
2 But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name: 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God
. Jn 1:12,13

How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Catholica

#21
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 09:36:13
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I have more to say about all this and I will, but for the moment I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved. And if you do not you are not saved and you are going to hell. Thats how it was then Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths  also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

You should have a hard time with mechanical salvation, because it is false.  But it is not what the Catholic Church teaches.  The Catholic Church does not teach that if you are a baptized Catholic under the rule of the pope you will be saved.  It also does not teach that if you are not then you are going to hell.

What it does teach is that, what has been revealed are two things, that baptism has been given to us as the normal means of initially being justified (having both original and actual sins forgiven) and becoming part of the body of Christ, and that Christ gave his authority to the Church so that we may also have our sins forgiven through it.  This message, understood positively in this way, shows that Christ has given the Church to us as His delivery mechanism for salvation, if you will.  However the following facts remain:

* Those who are baptized and still consider themselves Catholic may be lost through unrepentant mortal sin.
* Those who are catechumens who have not yet been baptized, if they die, will be saved as if they had received baptism.
* Those who are martyred for the faith even without receiving baptism will be saved (witness the Holy Innocents)
* God MAY still save those who, through no fault of their own, have never received baptism nor knowledge of the gospel as so are invincibly ignorant

That is not to say that one can be saved by merely having (the immeasurably squishy) "faith alone".  Nor should one hope to be saved even though they reject the gifts Christ has given humanity though the Catholic Church in the sacraments.  It is a desperate hope that is very vain, and in some ways borders or adopts pelagianism, the belief that one can be saved without Jesus (in practice, not in belief) WHEN one considers that Jesus, who is God, died and resurrected for them AND founded the Church with his authority and sent them "as God sent (Him)".(John 20:21)

For what purpose did God send Jesus?  To bring salvation.  Now the Church is told to go forth teaching and baptizing. (Matthew 28:19-20) That, mclees8, makes the Church the means of salvation, and if one rejects the Church, he rejects Jesus, and if he rejects Jesus, he rejects the Father (Luke 10:16).

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation. Yet in my spirit I am deeply troubled that many have never truly found Christ and rest their salvation on ritual ordinance.

There is salvation through baptism for those who cannot understand the gospel, who are incapable.  The Bible, in multiple places, states directly or infers that baptism is the washing away of sins, the regenerative act, without which no one can be saved.  It is baptism and faith, which is more specific than belief that one is saved.  Faith is a supernatural virtue, a grace from God.  Babies and people with severe mental handicap or human vegetables, they cannot comprehend the gospel, but God can and does still save them through baptism, and baptism infuses faith to them even through the incapacity for them to rationally believe. 

Baptism is a free gift which requires nothing, absolutely NOTHING from the recipient.  Infant baptism is a profound expression on the true gratuitousness of this gift, because it shows that we truly can do nothing to save ourselves.

And yet we should never rest on the sacraments to believe that they will save us in spite of ourselves, and our choices to sin and reject the grace God gives us.  Well-catechized Catholics know this.  Faith grows and solidifies us in God, and through the sacraments and prayer we receive the grace we need to persevere in holiness, without which no one will see God.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I don't know how others know they are saved but I know that I am saved not because I was baptized but with tears asked Him to reveal himself to me one night and in that very moment I knew Him and what he truly did for me.. When Jesus said you must be Born again of the spirit( and I emphasize it say must be) in order to come into the kingdom it is not just a commandment but an absolute truth. I was saved from the moment tears ran down my face and not from formal baptism but a true revelation that changed my life forever . I pray you feel My emotion about this. So before you think your baptism saves you might check you brokenness first. 

I know that your emotions and brokenness suggest you have realized your need for Christ.  And this brokenness we all feel who seek Christ.  But emotions don't suggest that we are saved.  Emotions can be felt absolutely naturally by people who are not saved who also feel their brokenness.  And baptism isn't a cure for our brokenness.  But it is the actual meaning of being born again of "water and spirit".  So you were initially justified through your baptism, whether you believe such or not.  But you shouldn't rely on your emotions nor your baptism to save you, nor an idea that being sad for your sins will save you, nor even that Jesus changed your life as evidence that you will be ultimately saved.  Jesus also changed Judas' life, but ultimately it doesn't appear that he was saved.  And even Paul knew that if he did not persevere in the faith, he could become reprobate.

Ultimately, it comes down to the grace of God to save you.  You received grace to believe in Christ, and you received grace in your baptism, and you receive grace whenever you wish to repent.  But being unable to receive the sacraments, you are missing out on the many graces which God wants to continue to give you because he loves you.  These graces will give you peace, help you become humble and help you get closer and closer to God, more close than anyone can be without them, of his own desire.

God wants you in his Church, mclees.  Many people on this board who simply dismiss the Catholic faith, you actually research it and I can sense that you try to understand it, even though it seems offensive to you in many ways.  I encourage you at least to continue in that, and I pray that God will continue to lead you on the path which He desires for you, whatever that may be.

I understand about your squishy faith alone. True faith is transforming. It entails a life change. Faith without works is dead. One who has been truly transformed will produce good fruit (good works) No brag or merit badge but the love of Christ works in him.

No it wasn't just tears that saved me but a heart cry. You see I was desperate to find truth in my life and I was struggling with Who Jesus really was. I desperately wanted to believe but it all changed when with my tears I said I believe. It was in that very moment Jesus was truly revealed and all doubt was gone. I was able then to say as Peter, " thou art the Christ the Son of the living God" I might not have fully understood it all but I know now I was saved that very moment. Until we truly believe we cannot fully comprehend or appreciate  the grace of God.

I do not want to hinder another faith concerning their faith in the Eucharist. I was brought up in Protestant churches and still believe in communion. It is the heart the Lords sees when one approaches His table.

One  who's life is truly given will never forget who His Lord is. Again I do not want to hinder anyone

I almost have to chuckle. You said the Lord wants me in His church. I already am and have been the first moment I believed.
2 But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name: 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God
. Jn 1:12,13

I do believe that you are in the Church in one sense; what I am trying to say is that I believe that the Lord is calling you into deeper communion and intimacy to Himself through the sacraments of the Catholic Church, the sacraments which he instituted for all Christians of good will.  I didn't mean to imply that you weren't a member of the Church in the general sense, that is, the the Church which is the body of Christ.

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Paul never said that to me personally and individually.  He said that to a group of believers who were part of a church he went to Corinth and started.  They were just as "institutionalized" as I am.  Within that same letter (1 Corinthians) he gives the earliest written account of the meaning of the Eucharist, written even before the gospels were written, by someone who wasn't even there at the Last Supper.

God intends us to be one in mind and spirit, to worship in spirit and truth, and not a truth to which we have labored to discern for ourselves, but one that has been handed on to us through the Church.

mclees8

Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 13:21:48
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 09:36:13
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I have more to say about all this and I will, but for the moment I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved. And if you do not you are not saved and you are going to hell. Thats how it was then Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths  also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

You should have a hard time with mechanical salvation, because it is false.  But it is not what the Catholic Church teaches.  The Catholic Church does not teach that if you are a baptized Catholic under the rule of the pope you will be saved.  It also does not teach that if you are not then you are going to hell.

What it does teach is that, what has been revealed are two things, that baptism has been given to us as the normal means of initially being justified (having both original and actual sins forgiven) and becoming part of the body of Christ, and that Christ gave his authority to the Church so that we may also have our sins forgiven through it.  This message, understood positively in this way, shows that Christ has given the Church to us as His delivery mechanism for salvation, if you will.  However the following facts remain:

* Those who are baptized and still consider themselves Catholic may be lost through unrepentant mortal sin.
* Those who are catechumens who have not yet been baptized, if they die, will be saved as if they had received baptism.
* Those who are martyred for the faith even without receiving baptism will be saved (witness the Holy Innocents)
* God MAY still save those who, through no fault of their own, have never received baptism nor knowledge of the gospel as so are invincibly ignorant

That is not to say that one can be saved by merely having (the immeasurably squishy) "faith alone".  Nor should one hope to be saved even though they reject the gifts Christ has given humanity though the Catholic Church in the sacraments.  It is a desperate hope that is very vain, and in some ways borders or adopts pelagianism, the belief that one can be saved without Jesus (in practice, not in belief) WHEN one considers that Jesus, who is God, died and resurrected for them AND founded the Church with his authority and sent them "as God sent (Him)".(John 20:21)

For what purpose did God send Jesus?  To bring salvation.  Now the Church is told to go forth teaching and baptizing. (Matthew 28:19-20) That, mclees8, makes the Church the means of salvation, and if one rejects the Church, he rejects Jesus, and if he rejects Jesus, he rejects the Father (Luke 10:16).

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation. Yet in my spirit I am deeply troubled that many have never truly found Christ and rest their salvation on ritual ordinance.

There is salvation through baptism for those who cannot understand the gospel, who are incapable.  The Bible, in multiple places, states directly or infers that baptism is the washing away of sins, the regenerative act, without which no one can be saved.  It is baptism and faith, which is more specific than belief that one is saved.  Faith is a supernatural virtue, a grace from God.  Babies and people with severe mental handicap or human vegetables, they cannot comprehend the gospel, but God can and does still save them through baptism, and baptism infuses faith to them even through the incapacity for them to rationally believe. 

Baptism is a free gift which requires nothing, absolutely NOTHING from the recipient.  Infant baptism is a profound expression on the true gratuitousness of this gift, because it shows that we truly can do nothing to save ourselves.

And yet we should never rest on the sacraments to believe that they will save us in spite of ourselves, and our choices to sin and reject the grace God gives us.  Well-catechized Catholics know this.  Faith grows and solidifies us in God, and through the sacraments and prayer we receive the grace we need to persevere in holiness, without which no one will see God.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I don't know how others know they are saved but I know that I am saved not because I was baptized but with tears asked Him to reveal himself to me one night and in that very moment I knew Him and what he truly did for me.. When Jesus said you must be Born again of the spirit( and I emphasize it say must be) in order to come into the kingdom it is not just a commandment but an absolute truth. I was saved from the moment tears ran down my face and not from formal baptism but a true revelation that changed my life forever . I pray you feel My emotion about this. So before you think your baptism saves you might check you brokenness first. 

I know that your emotions and brokenness suggest you have realized your need for Christ.  And this brokenness we all feel who seek Christ.  But emotions don't suggest that we are saved.  Emotions can be felt absolutely naturally by people who are not saved who also feel their brokenness.  And baptism isn't a cure for our brokenness.  But it is the actual meaning of being born again of "water and spirit".  So you were initially justified through your baptism, whether you believe such or not.  But you shouldn't rely on your emotions nor your baptism to save you, nor an idea that being sad for your sins will save you, nor even that Jesus changed your life as evidence that you will be ultimately saved.  Jesus also changed Judas' life, but ultimately it doesn't appear that he was saved.  And even Paul knew that if he did not persevere in the faith, he could become reprobate.

Ultimately, it comes down to the grace of God to save you.  You received grace to believe in Christ, and you received grace in your baptism, and you receive grace whenever you wish to repent.  But being unable to receive the sacraments, you are missing out on the many graces which God wants to continue to give you because he loves you.  These graces will give you peace, help you become humble and help you get closer and closer to God, more close than anyone can be without them, of his own desire.

God wants you in his Church, mclees.  Many people on this board who simply dismiss the Catholic faith, you actually research it and I can sense that you try to understand it, even though it seems offensive to you in many ways.  I encourage you at least to continue in that, and I pray that God will continue to lead you on the path which He desires for you, whatever that may be.

I understand about your squishy faith alone. True faith is transforming. It entails a life change. Faith without works is dead. One who has been truly transformed will produce good fruit (good works) No brag or merit badge but the love of Christ works in him.

No it wasn't just tears that saved me but a heart cry. You see I was desperate to find truth in my life and I was struggling with Who Jesus really was. I desperately wanted to believe but it all changed when with my tears I said I believe. It was in that very moment Jesus was truly revealed and all doubt was gone. I was able then to say as Peter, " thou art the Christ the Son of the living God" I might not have fully understood it all but I know now I was saved that very moment. Until we truly believe we cannot fully comprehend or appreciate  the grace of God.

I do not want to hinder another faith concerning their faith in the Eucharist. I was brought up in Protestant churches and still believe in communion. It is the heart the Lords sees when one approaches His table.

One  who's life is truly given will never forget who His Lord is. Again I do not want to hinder anyone

I almost have to chuckle. You said the Lord wants me in His church. I already am and have been the first moment I believed.
2 But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name: 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God
. Jn 1:12,13

I do believe that you are in the Church in one sense; what I am trying to say is that I believe that the Lord is calling you into deeper communion and intimacy to Himself through the sacraments of the Catholic Church, the sacraments which he instituted for all Christians of good will.  I didn't mean to imply that you weren't a member of the Church in the general sense, that is, the the Church which is the body of Christ.

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Paul never said that to me personally and individually.  He said that to a group of believers who were part of a church he went to Corinth and started.  They were just as "institutionalized" as I am.  Within that same letter (1 Corinthians) he gives the earliest written account of the meaning of the Eucharist, written even before the gospels were written, by someone who wasn't even there at the Last Supper.

God intends us to be one in mind and spirit, to worship in spirit and truth, and not a truth to which we have labored to discern for ourselves, but one that has been handed on to us through the Church.

We are already in an intimate relationship as I am in Him and he is in me. Just as Jesus is one with the Father so am I also one with Him. You can't get much more intimate than that.  Yes you have been institutionalized alright and they have robbed you of knowing Him personally. What Pau said is for all of us personally and individually.

By the gift of the Holy Spirit we have become as the Temple of God

Catholica

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:36:49
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 13:21:48
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Paul never said that to me personally and individually.  He said that to a group of believers who were part of a church he went to Corinth and started.  They were just as "institutionalized" as I am.  Within that same letter (1 Corinthians) he gives the earliest written account of the meaning of the Eucharist, written even before the gospels were written, by someone who wasn't even there at the Last Supper.

God intends us to be one in mind and spirit, to worship in spirit and truth, and not a truth to which we have labored to discern for ourselves, but one that has been handed on to us through the Church.

We are already in an intimate relationship as I am in Him and he is in me. Just as Jesus is one with the Father so am I also one with Him. You can't get much more intimate than that.  Yes you have been institutionalized alright and they have robbed you of knowing Him personally. What Pau said is for all of us personally and individually.

By the gift of the Holy Spirit we have become as the Temple of God

Like I said, I am no more institutionalized than the believers in Corinth to whom Paul said had the Spirit of God living in him.  You know nothing of me.  My adherence to the Church certainly doesn't rob me of knowing God personally, no more than it did the Corinthians.

But there IS a deeper intimacy with him, who comes to us in a special way in the Most Holy Eucharist.  You are free to walk away if you choose, John 6:66.

I'm not one to take part in this "you have been robbed, you are not Christian" pettiness.  I am just inviting you into an even deeper relationship and intimacy with him, which you haven't experienced before, which isn't possible outside of receiving the Eucharist.  If you don't want to accept it, then that is your free will to not accept it. 

mclees8

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:36:49
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 13:21:48
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 09:36:13
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I have more to say about all this and I will, but for the moment I have a very hard time with mechanical salvation. By that I mean being told by some Religious political order that rules over the people of the land and says if you are baptized a Catholic under the authoritarian rule of the pope that you  will be saved. And if you do not you are not saved and you are going to hell. Thats how it was then Yet now today welcome the pope say other faiths  also worthy of salvation without coming Christ.

You should have a hard time with mechanical salvation, because it is false.  But it is not what the Catholic Church teaches.  The Catholic Church does not teach that if you are a baptized Catholic under the rule of the pope you will be saved.  It also does not teach that if you are not then you are going to hell.

What it does teach is that, what has been revealed are two things, that baptism has been given to us as the normal means of initially being justified (having both original and actual sins forgiven) and becoming part of the body of Christ, and that Christ gave his authority to the Church so that we may also have our sins forgiven through it.  This message, understood positively in this way, shows that Christ has given the Church to us as His delivery mechanism for salvation, if you will.  However the following facts remain:

* Those who are baptized and still consider themselves Catholic may be lost through unrepentant mortal sin.
* Those who are catechumens who have not yet been baptized, if they die, will be saved as if they had received baptism.
* Those who are martyred for the faith even without receiving baptism will be saved (witness the Holy Innocents)
* God MAY still save those who, through no fault of their own, have never received baptism nor knowledge of the gospel as so are invincibly ignorant

That is not to say that one can be saved by merely having (the immeasurably squishy) "faith alone".  Nor should one hope to be saved even though they reject the gifts Christ has given humanity though the Catholic Church in the sacraments.  It is a desperate hope that is very vain, and in some ways borders or adopts pelagianism, the belief that one can be saved without Jesus (in practice, not in belief) WHEN one considers that Jesus, who is God, died and resurrected for them AND founded the Church with his authority and sent them "as God sent (Him)".(John 20:21)

For what purpose did God send Jesus?  To bring salvation.  Now the Church is told to go forth teaching and baptizing. (Matthew 28:19-20) That, mclees8, makes the Church the means of salvation, and if one rejects the Church, he rejects Jesus, and if he rejects Jesus, he rejects the Father (Luke 10:16).

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
Also there is no salvation by ritual baptism unless one has already believed in their heart Christ is their salvation. Yet in my spirit I am deeply troubled that many have never truly found Christ and rest their salvation on ritual ordinance.

There is salvation through baptism for those who cannot understand the gospel, who are incapable.  The Bible, in multiple places, states directly or infers that baptism is the washing away of sins, the regenerative act, without which no one can be saved.  It is baptism and faith, which is more specific than belief that one is saved.  Faith is a supernatural virtue, a grace from God.  Babies and people with severe mental handicap or human vegetables, they cannot comprehend the gospel, but God can and does still save them through baptism, and baptism infuses faith to them even through the incapacity for them to rationally believe. 

Baptism is a free gift which requires nothing, absolutely NOTHING from the recipient.  Infant baptism is a profound expression on the true gratuitousness of this gift, because it shows that we truly can do nothing to save ourselves.

And yet we should never rest on the sacraments to believe that they will save us in spite of ourselves, and our choices to sin and reject the grace God gives us.  Well-catechized Catholics know this.  Faith grows and solidifies us in God, and through the sacraments and prayer we receive the grace we need to persevere in holiness, without which no one will see God.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 13, 2013 - 17:51:24
I don't know how others know they are saved but I know that I am saved not because I was baptized but with tears asked Him to reveal himself to me one night and in that very moment I knew Him and what he truly did for me.. When Jesus said you must be Born again of the spirit( and I emphasize it say must be) in order to come into the kingdom it is not just a commandment but an absolute truth. I was saved from the moment tears ran down my face and not from formal baptism but a true revelation that changed my life forever . I pray you feel My emotion about this. So before you think your baptism saves you might check you brokenness first. 

I know that your emotions and brokenness suggest you have realized your need for Christ.  And this brokenness we all feel who seek Christ.  But emotions don't suggest that we are saved.  Emotions can be felt absolutely naturally by people who are not saved who also feel their brokenness.  And baptism isn't a cure for our brokenness.  But it is the actual meaning of being born again of "water and spirit".  So you were initially justified through your baptism, whether you believe such or not.  But you shouldn't rely on your emotions nor your baptism to save you, nor an idea that being sad for your sins will save you, nor even that Jesus changed your life as evidence that you will be ultimately saved.  Jesus also changed Judas' life, but ultimately it doesn't appear that he was saved.  And even Paul knew that if he did not persevere in the faith, he could become reprobate.

Ultimately, it comes down to the grace of God to save you.  You received grace to believe in Christ, and you received grace in your baptism, and you receive grace whenever you wish to repent.  But being unable to receive the sacraments, you are missing out on the many graces which God wants to continue to give you because he loves you.  These graces will give you peace, help you become humble and help you get closer and closer to God, more close than anyone can be without them, of his own desire.

God wants you in his Church, mclees.  Many people on this board who simply dismiss the Catholic faith, you actually research it and I can sense that you try to understand it, even though it seems offensive to you in many ways.  I encourage you at least to continue in that, and I pray that God will continue to lead you on the path which He desires for you, whatever that may be.

I understand about your squishy faith alone. True faith is transforming. It entails a life change. Faith without works is dead. One who has been truly transformed will produce good fruit (good works) No brag or merit badge but the love of Christ works in him.

No it wasn't just tears that saved me but a heart cry. You see I was desperate to find truth in my life and I was struggling with Who Jesus really was. I desperately wanted to believe but it all changed when with my tears I said I believe. It was in that very moment Jesus was truly revealed and all doubt was gone. I was able then to say as Peter, " thou art the Christ the Son of the living God" I might not have fully understood it all but I know now I was saved that very moment. Until we truly believe we cannot fully comprehend or appreciate  the grace of God.

I do not want to hinder another faith concerning their faith in the Eucharist. I was brought up in Protestant churches and still believe in communion. It is the heart the Lords sees when one approaches His table.

One  who's life is truly given will never forget who His Lord is. Again I do not want to hinder anyone

I almost have to chuckle. You said the Lord wants me in His church. I already am and have been the first moment I believed.
2 But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name: 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God
. Jn 1:12,13

I do believe that you are in the Church in one sense; what I am trying to say is that I believe that the Lord is calling you into deeper communion and intimacy to Himself through the sacraments of the Catholic Church, the sacraments which he instituted for all Christians of good will.  I didn't mean to imply that you weren't a member of the Church in the general sense, that is, the the Church which is the body of Christ.

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Paul never said that to me personally and individually.  He said that to a group of believers who were part of a church he went to Corinth and started.  They were just as "institutionalized" as I am.  Within that same letter (1 Corinthians) he gives the earliest written account of the meaning of the Eucharist, written even before the gospels were written, by someone who wasn't even there at the Last Supper.

God intends us to be one in mind and spirit, to worship in spirit and truth, and not a truth to which we have labored to discern for ourselves, but one that has been handed on to us through the Church.

We are already in an intimate relationship as I am in Him and he is in me. Just as Jesus is one with the Father so am I also one with Him. You can't get much more intimate than that.  Yes you have been institutionalized alright and they have robbed you of knowing Him personally. What Pau said is for all of us personally and individually.

By the gift of the Holy Spirit we have become as the Temple of God
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:50:53
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:36:49
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 13:21:48
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Paul never said that to me personally and individually.  He said that to a group of believers who were part of a church he went to Corinth and started.  They were just as "institutionalized" as I am.  Within that same letter (1 Corinthians) he gives the earliest written account of the meaning of the Eucharist, written even before the gospels were written, by someone who wasn't even there at the Last Supper.

God intends us to be one in mind and spirit, to worship in spirit and truth, and not a truth to which we have labored to discern for ourselves, but one that has been handed on to us through the Church.

We are already in an intimate relationship as I am in Him and he is in me. Just as Jesus is one with the Father so am I also one with Him. You can't get much more intimate than that.  Yes you have been institutionalized alright and they have robbed you of knowing Him personally. What Pau said is for all of us personally and individually.

By the gift of the Holy Spirit we have become as the Temple of God

Like I said, I am no more institutionalized than the believers in Corinth to whom Paul said had the Spirit of God living in him.  You know nothing of me.  My adherence to the Church certainly doesn't rob me of knowing God personally, no more than it did the Corinthians.

But there IS a deeper intimacy with him, who comes to us in a special way in the Most Holy Eucharist.  You are free to walk away if you choose, John 6:66.

I'm not one to take part in this "you have been robbed, you are not Christian" pettiness.  I am just inviting you into an even deeper relationship and intimacy with him, which you haven't experienced before, which isn't possible outside of receiving the Eucharist.  If you don't want to accept it, then that is your free will to not accept it. 

Let me ask do you think you could have meaningful personal relationship With Christ out side of you Catholic church relationship.  Do you think you could maintain you saving faith?   

AVZ

Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:50:53
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 14:36:49
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 13:21:48
Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Aug 15, 2013 - 11:25:16
How is it that you have let you church institutionalize you.   Did not Paul say Know ye not you are the temple and the spirit of God is in you

Paul never said that to me personally and individually.  He said that to a group of believers who were part of a church he went to Corinth and started.  They were just as "institutionalized" as I am.  Within that same letter (1 Corinthians) he gives the earliest written account of the meaning of the Eucharist, written even before the gospels were written, by someone who wasn't even there at the Last Supper.

God intends us to be one in mind and spirit, to worship in spirit and truth, and not a truth to which we have labored to discern for ourselves, but one that has been handed on to us through the Church.

We are already in an intimate relationship as I am in Him and he is in me. Just as Jesus is one with the Father so am I also one with Him. You can't get much more intimate than that.  Yes you have been institutionalized alright and they have robbed you of knowing Him personally. What Pau said is for all of us personally and individually.

By the gift of the Holy Spirit we have become as the Temple of God

Like I said, I am no more institutionalized than the believers in Corinth to whom Paul said had the Spirit of God living in him.  You know nothing of me.  My adherence to the Church certainly doesn't rob me of knowing God personally, no more than it did the Corinthians.

But there IS a deeper intimacy with him, who comes to us in a special way in the Most Holy Eucharist.  You are free to walk away if you choose, John 6:66.

I'm not one to take part in this "you have been robbed, you are not Christian" pettiness.  I am just inviting you into an even deeper relationship and intimacy with him, which you haven't experienced before, which isn't possible outside of receiving the Eucharist.  If you don't want to accept it, then that is your free will to not accept it. 

I just wonder how deep this intimacy with Him can be if you need Mary to intercede with Him on your behalf, and if you do not know if you are saved?
See, I can offer you to sit at the table in my church, where you do not need Mary or Purgatory to be between you and Jesus.

Amo

Quote from: Catholica on Mon Aug 12, 2013 - 05:18:37
Amo, what is your point?  What do you think your highlighted portions mean?

They mean what they have always meant, an anti-Christ power has presumed authority to control and manipulate the words of the writers of the bible which were intended for examination by all, to herself and that only which she approves. At the time it was written, this meant fines, imprisonment, torture, and even death for those who dared defy it wherever Catholic authority prevailed. For which reason countless people died at the hands of Rome for many a century before the Council under examination existed. Eventually, the world at large rejecting such Catholic authority, she lost the power to do such to non Catholics. Thus today the Council of Trent applies to Catholics only, and rightly so.

If of course Catholic political power and influence continue to grow until she once again has the full cooperation of the state to enforce her dogmas upon all, the same will happen once again. Unless she graciously grants the present state of freedom to continue, though many neither care for or will ever acknowledge her claim to any authority pertaining to the same. All attempts by "Christian" entities to enforce their dogmas or social teachings by force through civil legislation, are signs of the spirit of anti-Christ within the same. There is no combining the power of the true church of Christ, with the powers that be of this world, but by anti-Christ.

Let me ask the same question, in relation to the topic at hand, that I have asked many times of Catholics without any answer for the same. Do you believe the following statement from the papal bull Unum Sanctum, in relation to the topic at hand and the command of the Council of Trent we are discussing?

"Furthermore, we declare, we proclaim, we define that it is absolutely necessary for salvation that every human creature be subject to the Roman Pontiff."

epiphanius

Quote from: Amo on Sat Aug 17, 2013 - 14:22:37
Do you believe the following statement from the papal bull Unam Sanctam, in relation to the topic at hand and the command of the Council of Trent we are discussing?

"Furthermore, we declare, we proclaim, we define that it is absolutely necessary for salvation that every human creature be subject to the Roman Pontiff."
Amo,

While some Catholics may disagree, I think this is a question that needs to be addressed.  The fact is that from the time it was written in 1302, Unam Sanctam was seen by Catholic bishops and theologians as nothing more than an attempt by Boniface VIII to re-assert the dubious teaching of the authority of the Papacy over all temporal rulers (i.e. not only spiritual but temporal authority over kings, princes, etc.), an idea that by this time was almost universally rejected--and continued to be, despite Unam Sanctam.

In other words, Unam Sanctam was a fiasco from the day it was written, and actually served to diminish the credibility of the Papacy.

(On the other hand, the Orthodox Church teaches that a statement does not become dogmatic simply by being proclaimed as such, but only after it is received and embraced by the entire Church--Unam Sanctam seems to have failed this criterion.)

FWIW, I have never heard it stated that Unam Sanctam was reaffirmed by the Council of Trent.


mclees8

Quote from: winsome on Mon Aug 19, 2013 - 13:47:21

  See - The Unam Sanctam "Problem" Resolved


I tried reading some of this but I just don't have enough time to read all this stuff which to quote one of your brothers seems more than a little squishy.

Its like what he said was not really what he meant but it was this and that. All in all from what I did read it still sounded that if you are not a member of the Catholic church you cannot submit to the pope which if you are not a member of the one visible church you are not saved, but if you are not a catholic you are not damned. ???????

I would ask now if you would simply define What the Lord said if there are two or three gathered in my name there I am in the mist. Who are the two or three. Could that possibly mean you the pope and a cardinal?




winsome

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 20, 2013 - 10:58:38
Quote from: winsome on Mon Aug 19, 2013 - 13:47:21

  See - The Unam Sanctam "Problem" Resolved


I tried reading some of this but I just don't have enough time to read all this stuff which to quote one of your brothers seems more than a little squishy.

Its like what he said was not really what he meant but it was this and that. All in all from what I did read it still sounded that if you are not a member of the Catholic church you cannot submit to the pope which if you are not a member of the one visible church you are not saved, but if you are not a catholic you are not damned. ??? ??? ?

I would ask now if you would simply define What the Lord said if there are two or three gathered in my name there I am in the mist. Who are the two or three. Could that possibly mean you the pope and a cardinal?





"All in all from what I did read it still sounded that if you are not a member of the Catholic church you cannot submit to the pope" - correct

"which if you are not a member of the one visible church you are not saved," - incorrect

"but if you are not a catholic you are not damned." - only God can say who is damned

mclees8

Quote from: winsome on Tue Aug 20, 2013 - 11:07:16
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Aug 20, 2013 - 10:58:38
Quote from: winsome on Mon Aug 19, 2013 - 13:47:21

  See - The Unam Sanctam "Problem" Resolved


I tried reading some of this but I just don't have enough time to read all this stuff which to quote one of your brothers seems more than a little squishy.

Its like what he said was not really what he meant but it was this and that. All in all from what I did read it still sounded that if you are not a member of the Catholic church you cannot submit to the pope which if you are not a member of the one visible church you are not saved, but if you are not a catholic you are not damned. ??? ??? ?

I would ask now if you would simply define What the Lord said if there are two or three gathered in my name there I am in the mist. Who are the two or three. Could that possibly mean you the pope and a cardinal?





"All in all from what I did read it still sounded that if you are not a member of the Catholic church you cannot submit to the pope" - correct

"which if you are not a member of the one visible church you are not saved," - incorrect

"but if you are not a catholic you are not damned." - only God can say who is damned


You know I am glad we have a bible today that for me makes it clear who I am in Christ. I am glad it tells me that if I have given myself to Christ to believe he paid for my sins and I forsake sin I will have eternal life. This according to John 1:12 makes me of His church not by membership but adoption. The word membership should never be associated with being of the true church. One may join a certain fellowship but being of a fellowship does not define the church. Being of the institution does not define salvation. But if I were to be of a certain fellowship I would not choose to be of one where a guy wants to be a glorified monarch waveing at people from a balcony.

FireSword

Praise the Lord for the freedom of his word to be read.

AnnaM


Catholica

Quote from: AnnaM on Sun Sep 15, 2013 - 11:10:08
Quote from: winsome on Wed Jul 17, 2013 - 14:51:09
Do I detect "Baptism of Desire" on the horizon?

"Baptism of Desire" is a myth.

So if early Catechumens were martyred, they were considered damned?

+-Recent Topics

Creation scientists by Amo
Yesterday at 21:18:03

Roman politics by Amo
Yesterday at 21:12:56

Sabbath, Sunday, and Legalism by Amo
Yesterday at 21:07:16

Upgrade madness by Amo
Yesterday at 16:09:41

Please pray for the Christians as they continue to face injustice by pppp
Yesterday at 15:55:55

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by Amo
Yesterday at 08:01:04

Hakeem Jeffries by mommydi
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 17:33:49

American Socialism? by 4WD
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 11:38:36

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Thu Nov 19, 2026 - 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Wed Nov 18, 2026 - 13:24:52

Powered by EzPortal