News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898064
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 4862
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 4430
Total: 4431

Sacramentals

Started by winsome, Fri Mar 15, 2013 - 15:50:17

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

FireSword

Protestantisms is a gift to the poor. The catholic church is for the rich and only esteemed people.


Lively Stone

Quote from: Catholica on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 11:27:50
Quote from: Lively Stone on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:52:48
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

The problem is that it is misunderstood just what the Church of Jesus Christ is.

Agreed.  However one defines the Church of Jesus Christ, the definition of that Church is not true if said definition leads to demonstrable contradictions between the parties with teaching authority within.

For example, the "Church of Jesus Christ" cannot be "the invisible Church of all believers" because there are contradicting doctrines being taught by different people who are considered authorities within that "Church".

The Church of Jesus Christ must have an authority unified in doctrine, just like the early Church had in the apostles.  Any definition of Church that doesn't have that has had the gates of hell prevail against it.

Sorry, but that is confusion. The church of Jesus Christ consists of ALL BELIEVERS, and JESUS IS THE AUTHORITY.

Any other definition is not of God, but of man.

Lively Stone

Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:35:29

We receive the Holy Spirit, but as individuals we do not have Christ's promise that we will be lead into all truth. Only the Church has that promise.

False. As individuals we receive Holy Spirit, who leads us into all truth.

What do you mean only the Church has that promise?? Jesus' promises are to all of His people! The Church is His people!

Lively Stone

Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:37:34
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:31:44
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

It has shown the plan of God better than the Catholic ever could.

Jesus said he would protect his church room hell. He did not say to protect it from error. The RCC get puffed up on knowledge and shown little grace. The protestant shown the true gospel of Jesus in simplicity and truth, there's not much comparison. Pride tends to attract a lot of people, that's why many flock to puffed up churches



Protestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals.

The Catholic religion has no promise like that. As a follower of Jesus---His disciple---and a member of His Church, His Body on the earth, I have His command to preach His gospel to the lost.

winsome

#144
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:40:38
QuoteProtestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals

No, the same gospel and text and words of Paul and the apostles. Only a few teach their own gospel, this happened before Luther.



If there was one gospel they would be teaching the same thing. But they are not. Or would you call it multiple flavours of the same gospel or pick and mix?


Dispensationalists actually teach there are multiple gospels.

winsome

Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:42:39
Protestantisms is a gift to the poor. The catholic church is for the rich and only esteemed people.


The Catholic Church is the biggest welfare provider for the poor in the world outside of governments themselves. They provide hospitals, schools, soup kitchens, food banks, homeless shelters etc. etc.

Did the "prosperity gospel" come from the Catholic Church or Protestantism?

Is it Catholics priests or Protestant tele-evangelists who rake in pots of money promising "blessings" for money and ride around in big cars & who own private jets??

Lively Stone

Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:55:03
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:40:38
QuoteProtestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals

No, the same gospel and text and words of Paul and the apostles. Only a few teach their own gospel, this happened before Luther.



If there was one gospel they would be teaching the same thing. But they are not. Or would you call it multiple flavours of the same gospel or pick and mix?


Dispensationalists actually teach there are multiple gospels.

What is a dispensationalist, to you? Please give us an example of various gospels they are supposed to promote.

LightHammer

QuoteThe point is that there are no complicated mysterious details to the Gospel. That is make believe by the RCC

???

So you understand the subtleties of the Trinity? Can you explain it to me? You understand how the infinite all power uncontainable God was able to dwell as a zygote in a virgin's womb?

I could go on but the fact that your own community is divided into 33,000 divergent sects contradicts your trivializing statements.

QuoteThe RCC is totally hung up in her claim of infallibility and monopoly of true interpretation.
So logically the more complicated you make things out to be, the easier it is to convince the believers that they should just sit tight and believe what they are told.

Well if "logically" that makes no sense. The simplified view of protestants where scripture interprets itself while in practice you all individually follow your own interpretations has divided you on your accord into thousands of different communities.

The protestant experiment hasn't introduced anyone to Christ it has condemned them to search ad nauseam on 33000 different paths for Him.

"Logically" if you have millions of people applying the same method (sola scriptura/ scripture interpreting scripture) to a control (scripture) then something is obviously wrong with either the method or the one applying it.

QuoteI say it once again: there are no hidden, secretive or mysterious details to the Gospel.

I never said anything about hidden or secretive but yes there are mysteries God Himself of course. Look I'm not a mason or some gnostic so try not to misunderstand what I'm saying (assuming that you actually care to understand what I'm saying). What I'm saying is that Christ didn't empower individuals to interpret HIS scriptures individually. He empowered the entire Church as body in communion with HIS apostles and the ones HE, by providence, determined to succeed them.

Notice the Catholic emphasis is on Him (God) and His Church and not on ME (protestants) and reason in light of a simple God whose actions and being are so trivial that I can comprehend them on my own.

chosenone

Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:37:34
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:31:44
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

It has shown the plan of God better than the Catholic ever could.

Jesus said he would protect his church room hell. He did not say to protect it from error. The RCC get puffed up on knowledge and shown little grace. The protestant shown the true gospel of Jesus in simplicity and truth, there's not much comparison. Pride tends to attract a lot of people, that's why many flock to puffed up churches



Protestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals.

No one is infallible except Jesus. All have fallen short Paul says, and that includes all the popes. We have the word to teach us, and we also have God in us through his Holy Spirit.

You seem to forget that billions upon billions of believers through the ages, have managed to have a close intimate and strong relationship with The Father without any input whatsoever from the Catholic church, and they will carry on doing so.

chosenone

Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:00:45
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:42:39
Protestantisms is a gift to the poor. The catholic church is for the rich and only esteemed people.


The Catholic Church is the biggest welfare provider for the poor in the world outside of governments themselves. They provide hospitals, schools, soup kitchens, food banks, homeless shelters etc. etc.

Did the "prosperity gospel" come from the Catholic Church or Protestantism?

Is it Catholics priests or Protestant televangelists who rake in pots of money promising "blessings" for money and ride around in big cars & who own private jets??

Believers of all denominations are deeply involved with the things you mentioned. We have them in my own town. Tele evangelists are not representative of  protestants, just as priests who abuse children are not reflective of Catholics.

jmldn2

The church is the body of Christ (believers).  I believe we should meet together on a regular basis to worship and fellowship.  I think this place of worship can vary for different people.  It can be in a building built just for such a purpose or it can be in a  home or in someone's backyard.  Jesus will be in the midst

LightHammer

Quote from: chosenone on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 15:06:56
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:37:34
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:31:44
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

It has shown the plan of God better than the Catholic ever could.

Jesus said he would protect his church room hell. He did not say to protect it from error. The RCC get puffed up on knowledge and shown little grace. The protestant shown the true gospel of Jesus in simplicity and truth, there's not much comparison. Pride tends to attract a lot of people, that's why many flock to puffed up churches



Protestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals.

No one is infallible except Jesus. All have fallen short Paul says, and that includes all the popes. We have the word to teach us, and we also have God in us through his Holy Spirit.

You seem to forget that billions upon billions of believers through the ages, have managed to have a close intimate and strong relationship with The Father without any input whatsoever from the Catholic church, and they will carry on doing so.

1. Thats not what infallible means and you should know that by now.

2. "billions upon billions"? Thats being very generous.

chosenone

Quote from: jmldn2 on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 15:17:02
The church is the body of Christ (believers).  I believe we should meet together on a regular basis to worship and fellowship.  I think this place of worship can vary for different people.  It can be in a building built just for such a purpose or it can be in a  home or in someone's backyard.  Jesus will be in the midst

Yes, and whether we are part of a demonination or not, makes no difference to that. God is there is the middle.

mclees8

Quote from: AVZ on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:26:33
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 11:52:46
QuoteUnfortunately you are under estimating the power of the Holy Spirit.

Not the Holy Spirit just those who are not successors of the Apostles claiming collectively to be led into 33,000 different denominations by that Holy Spirit.

QuoteWe do not need much proof of the simplicity of the Gospel

Hence I said the Gospel message is "very very very simple".

Details not so simple.

A child knows how to turn on a light switch but can scarcely comprehend the electrical engineering that invented the alternating flow or the physics that went into conducting electricity.

QuoteWhich brings me to Mary, a rather influential person in the RCC.

Luke 1:48 For behold, henceforth all generations will call me blessed

She only gave birth to God upon the earth. I would assume she would be "influential" to any true Christian.

QuoteWell unfortunately she was a house wife so what could she have known?

Mary was actually not a great thinker of the Church. She wrote no epistles and didn't preach. She was guard by the Apostle John after Christ's ascension. That's why she's the Seat of Wisdom.

Even still she is the greatest of Christ's followers so what's your point?


QuoteWas it not Jesus who said:
"Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these." Matthew 19:14
and
"Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." Matthew 5:3

If you want to convince me that the Gospel is too complicated for a house wife, then the Bible tells you exactly the opposite.

The RCC claims to have a monopoly on the correct interpretation of the scriptures...but reasoning from that position is arrogance. (sorry for the word choice)
Where in the Bible do you find that the Holy Spirit was only given to a select, well educated, few?

It's rather the opposite:

Acts 19:1-6
Here you have 12 men who do know very little (just like your "house wife").
They didnt know there was such a thing as the Holy Spirit.

"While Apollos was at Corinth, Paul took the road through the interior and arrived at Ephesus. There he found some disciples and asked them, "Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?" They answered, "No, we have not even heard that there is a Holy Spirit."
So Paul asked, "Then what baptism did you receive?" "John's baptism," they replied.
Paul said, "John's baptism was a baptism of repentance. He told the people to believe in the one coming after him, that is, in Jesus."
On hearing this, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. When Paul placed his hands on them, the Holy Spirit came on them, and they spoke in tongues and prophesied.
There were about twelve men in all."

So, now you tell me that the Gospel is too complicated? See how little time it took for the above 12 men?
The full simplicity of the Gospel is for everybody to understand, not only the basics and you do not need to be an highly educated superbrain.

Matthew 7:
"Ask and it will be given to you; seek and you will find; knock and the door will be opened to you.
For everyone who asks receives; the one who seeks finds; and to the one who knocks, the door will be opened."

And then the chapter ends with a swing at the religious teachers who claimed to have a monopoly on scripture explanation:
"When Jesus had finished saying these things, the crowds were amazed at his teaching, because he taught as one who had authority, and not as their teachers of the law."

???

What are you talking about? Did you even read what I wrote? I said the opposite of what you're claiming I said.

I said and I quote myself "The Gospel message is what's simple not the details." I did not say a housewife couldn't understand the Gospel message I said she and the average Christian would be unable to ascertain the details of the message. I mentioned "housewife" and "worker" to illustrate that the average Christian has duties in life that command the majority of their time i.e. parenting and/or working.

You don't listen. I even wrote out a simple profession of the Gospel message to illustrate the simplicity of it.

The point is that there are no complicated mysterious details to the Gospel. That is make believe by the RCC.
The Gospel in its complete is simple and easy to understand.

The RCC is totally hung up in her claim of infallibility and monopoly of true interpretation.
So logically the more complicated you make things out to be, the easier it is to convince the believers that they should just sit tight and believe what they are told.

What the RCC has done is take a perfectly simple Gospel, added a healthy amount of unverifyable tradition, included stacks of visualisations, statues, holy objects and purgatory.
The Church declared herself infallible, took posession of Peter's position, declared a monopoly on the Holy Spirit, implemented a series of dogma's to establish this and made the whole thing even more complicated by adding Mary to the mix.

Of course by then the Gospel has become so complicated that the average person cannot make sense of it anymore, so in order not to bother the common believer beyond their ability to comprehend, the RCC tells them that it now is perfectly fine not to open, touch or read a Bible even once in their life.

I say it once again: there are no hidden, secretive or mysterious details to the Gospel.

Amen AVZ that was well said

FireSword

Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:00:45
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:42:39
Protestantisms is a gift to the poor. The catholic church is for the rich and only esteemed people.


The Catholic Church is the biggest welfare provider for the poor in the world outside of governments themselves. They provide hospitals, schools, soup kitchens, food banks, homeless shelters etc. etc.

Did the "prosperity gospel" come from the Catholic Church or Protestantism?

Is it Catholics priests or Protestant tele-evangelists who rake in pots of money promising "blessings" for money and ride around in big cars & who own private jets??


A baptist church can be set up with a hammer, saw wood and nails and a man sent by God.

The catholic church needs gold, paintings, multiple priests, degrees in religious studies, permission by the vatican  ::sleepingsoundly::

The prosperity gospel teaches that christians be rich to help the poor and to live good lives, undoing the damage done by the catholic church of living in poverty and giving all income to fancy stuff, like cups and cathedrals.


Lively Stone

Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:21:15
What I'm saying is that Christ didn't empower individuals to interpret HIS scriptures individually. He empowered the entire Church as body in communion with HIS apostles and the ones HE, by providence, determined to succeed them.

The TRUTH is that God does do that very thing! He empowers every individual who seeks after Him to know the truth of the word, and those who have received salvation in Jesus Christ He empowers to not only know the word, understand the word, but to live out the word with His power and His authority. How does He do that? His Spirit comes to live in and through every believer.

We are the Church.


mclees8

#156
Quote from: Catholica on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:25:01
Quote from: mclees8 on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 11:42:21
Quote from: Catholica on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 11:27:50
Quote from: Lively Stone on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:52:48
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

The problem is that it is misunderstood just what the Church of Jesus Christ is.

Agreed.  However one defines the Church of Jesus Christ, the definition of that Church is not true if said definition leads to demonstrable contradictions between the parties with teaching authority within.

For example, the "Church of Jesus Christ" cannot be "the invisible Church of all believers" because there are contradicting doctrines being taught by different people who are considered authorities within that "Church".

The Church of Jesus Christ must have an authority unified in doctrine, just like the early Church had in the apostles.  Any definition of Church that doesn't have that has had the gates of hell prevail against it.

You have no idea about the invisisble church. If you did you would not make such comments without understanding. It isn't that there is no visible church to seen. The problem is one that has forgotten who the Holy Spirit is and is become drunken on the idea of authority demanding you recognise only that which is tangible

Actually I do have an idea of the invisible Church.  They are all persons who have been made holy by the Holy Spirit through baptism, whether they are explicitly Catholic or not.  In baptism, they receive the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit *sanctifies* them, but does not make them individually *infallible*, that is, someone who the Holy Spirit makes their own private authority.

The invisible Church is demonstrably very confused when they operate as the invisible church imagines to be: on their own as individuals.  Take a look around this forum at all the arguments between people who reject the teaching authority of the visible Church.  There is no guarantee of truth there; each person proclaims the truth as they believe it to be, and anyone who doesn't agree with them is wrong.  Each person has become their own personal "visible teaching authority".  But the reality is that none are their own personal "visible teaching authority".

An invisible teaching authority has as much authority as a person's own mental meanderings because people are very prone to confuse the two.  In other words, without a visible teaching authority, people are prone to think that their own thoughts are the Holy Spirit.  That is what Luther recognized.

"There are almost as many sects and beliefs as there are heads; . . . There is not an individual, however clownish he may be who does not claim to be inspired by the Holy Ghost, and who does not put forth as prophecies his ravings and dreams" - Martin Luther

The teaching authority of God's kingdom must be visible so that the Church can know the truth and submit to it.  And the Bible can not be sufficient for this, nor does it claim to be, for many reasons, one is that every person can read it in a way that suits his fancy.  Again, just look around at all the foundational arguments that plague the invisible church who deny the existence of a visible authority.  Even people who call themselves Catholic who reject the visible authority are subject to the same. 

The Bible says that the Church is the "bulwark and foundation of the truth".  Bulwarks and foundations are both visible and do not behave as something unstable as this other so-called "invisible church" behaves.  The visible Church provides something stable and capable of upholding the truth.  And that is why Jesus founded the "Church": a Church which he imbued with his own authority, to which he promised to protect with the Holy Spirit.  The visible teaching authority of the Catholic Church is the only reasonable fulfillment of that promise, because the Catholic Church has both had its structure from the beginning and has never reverted or contradicted anything it has officially taught is truth, and the teachings of the Catholic Church neither contradict scripture nor reason and when followed faithfully have demonstrably led to lives of deep connection to God and love for neighbor and charity in the world.

Actually you don't
One who has the Holy Spirit is very physical yet the one who is invisible (the The Holy Spirit ) resides in him. The bulwark and foundation of truth is Gods word and all who proclaim it. It is not like it's a building but a people who know that God is not just some earthly tangible establishment but stand on the truth and righteousness of Christ, knowing that the kingdom of God is not made with hands but is heavenly. Knowing the God is Spirit and we must worship Him in spirit and in truth. John 4:24  This is a bulwark but not as you see it.
No one denies that which is visible and sits in the visb le seat of authority. But one who is born of the spirit recognizes the authority of the invisible God and His kingdom and the Holy Spirit whom the world cannot see but we see Him for he is with us and in us.John 14:17 Can you see the Holy Ghost. Third person of the Godhead.  One who denies the authority of the heavenly God head denies Christ.
John 16:13
Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come. 14 He shall glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you. 15 All things that the Father hath are mine: therefore said I, that he shall take of mine, and shall shew it unto you.   

Rom 1:20
For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even† his eternal power and Godhead;   

Col 1:15
Who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of every creature: 16 For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him: 

1st Tim 1:17
7 Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God, be honour and glory for ever and ever. Amen.   

Heb 11:27
By faith he forsook Egypt, not fearing the wrath of the king: for he endured, as seeing him who is invisible. 

trifecta

Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 16:17:56



A baptist church can be set up with a hammer, saw wood and nails and a man sent by God.

The original churches were established by Jesus in Matt 16:18 without a single nail.  Moreover, it says
that church would continue for all time, so no need for new ones.

Quote
The catholic church needs gold, paintings, multiple priests, degrees in religious studies, permission by the vatican  ::sleepingsoundly::

Oh yeah, we see no gold, priests, and even religious studies in the OT?  No.   And oh, do you have gold and paintings?  So do I.  So what?

Quote

The prosperity gospel teaches that Christians be rich to help the poor and to live good lives, undoing the damage done by the catholic church of living in poverty and giving all income to fancy stuff, like cups and cathedrals.


Still doesn't sound like the Acts church where wealth was shared by those in the church.  Yes, my church doesn't do this either, but if you think a church shouldn't have beautiful things, then you shouldn't have them at home.  What is good for the goose is good for the gander.

AVZ

#158
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:21:15
QuoteThe point is that there are no complicated mysterious details to the Gospel. That is make believe by the RCC

???

So you understand the subtleties of the Trinity? Can you explain it to me? You understand how the infinite all power uncontainable God was able to dwell as a zygote in a virgin's womb?

I could go on but the fact that your own community is divided into 33,000 divergent sects contradicts your trivializing statements.

QuoteThe RCC is totally hung up in her claim of infallibility and monopoly of true interpretation.
So logically the more complicated you make things out to be, the easier it is to convince the believers that they should just sit tight and believe what they are told.

Well if "logically" that makes no sense. The simplified view of protestants where scripture interprets itself while in practice you all individually follow your own interpretations has divided you on your accord into thousands of different communities.

The protestant experiment hasn't introduced anyone to Christ it has condemned them to search ad nauseam on 33000 different paths for Him.

"Logically" if you have millions of people applying the same method (sola scriptura/ scripture interpreting scripture) to a control (scripture) then something is obviously wrong with either the method or the one applying it.

QuoteI say it once again: there are no hidden, secretive or mysterious details to the Gospel.

I never said anything about hidden or secretive but yes there are mysteries God Himself of course. Look I'm not a mason or some gnostic so try not to misunderstand what I'm saying (assuming that you actually care to understand what I'm saying). What I'm saying is that Christ didn't empower individuals to interpret HIS scriptures individually. He empowered the entire Church as body in communion with HIS apostles and the ones HE, by providence, determined to succeed them.

Notice the Catholic emphasis is on Him (God) and His Church and not on ME (protestants) and reason in light of a simple God whose actions and being are so trivial that I can comprehend them on my own.

LH, if I were to ask you if you could explain to me the subtleties  of creation, could you?
Or maybe the subtleties of Jonah being swallowed up by a fish. Or the subtleties of a talking snake...
I can go on for a long time.
Nowhere in the Bible is written that you must be able to explain things in order to inherit the Kingdom of Heaven.
On the contrary. The Bibkle teaches us exactly the opposite.

Besides that, even after hundreds of years of study even the RCC today would not be able to explain the subtleties of the Trinity.
At some point even all the wise men in the Church have to raise their hands and admit that there are many things they can't comprehend.
Can the RCC explain Revelation?

It is pure arrogance of the RCC to claim that she has a "more developed" type of Holy Spirit. There is not a single reference in all the scriptures that supports the idea that the Holy Spirit works differently in the Church than in individuals.

The RCC has measured herself an exclusivity that it not contained in the Gospel. The Gospel in its simplicity and understandability is meant to be freely accessable to everyone who wants to believe and seek a personal relationship with our Saviour.
Something the RCC plainly rejects in order to maintain power and control.

winsome

Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 16:17:56
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:00:45
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:42:39
Protestantisms is a gift to the poor. The catholic church is for the rich and only esteemed people.


The Catholic Church is the biggest welfare provider for the poor in the world outside of governments themselves. They provide hospitals, schools, soup kitchens, food banks, homeless shelters etc. etc.

Did the "prosperity gospel" come from the Catholic Church or Protestantism?

Is it Catholics priests or Protestant tele-evangelists who rake in pots of money promising "blessings" for money and ride around in big cars & who own private jets??


A baptist church can be set up with a hammer, saw wood and nails and a man sent by God.

And are many Catholic churches in the poor countries, and the early Anglo-Saxon churches in England (for example) were simple wooden structures. It depends on what a community can afford to give glory to God.

In the OT God instructed the Israelites to give of their best - gold, jewels etc and use their best craftmen. We still do the same, but what is best depends on what the community has at the time.

Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 16:17:56
The catholic church needs gold, paintings, multiple priests, degrees in religious studies, permission by the vatican  ::sleepingsoundly::

This is nonesense.

Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 16:17:56
The prosperity gospel teaches that christians be rich to help the poor and to live good lives, undoing the damage done by the catholic church of living in poverty and giving all income to fancy stuff, like cups and cathedrals.

The prosperity gospel teaches that if you give lots of money to your pastor then God will bless you with even more money.

LightHammer

Quote from: AVZ on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 20:41:38
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:21:15
QuoteThe point is that there are no complicated mysterious details to the Gospel. That is make believe by the RCC

???

So you understand the subtleties of the Trinity? Can you explain it to me? You understand how the infinite all power uncontainable God was able to dwell as a zygote in a virgin's womb?

I could go on but the fact that your own community is divided into 33,000 divergent sects contradicts your trivializing statements.

QuoteThe RCC is totally hung up in her claim of infallibility and monopoly of true interpretation.
So logically the more complicated you make things out to be, the easier it is to convince the believers that they should just sit tight and believe what they are told.

Well if "logically" that makes no sense. The simplified view of protestants where scripture interprets itself while in practice you all individually follow your own interpretations has divided you on your accord into thousands of different communities.

The protestant experiment hasn't introduced anyone to Christ it has condemned them to search ad nauseam on 33000 different paths for Him.

"Logically" if you have millions of people applying the same method (sola scriptura/ scripture interpreting scripture) to a control (scripture) then something is obviously wrong with either the method or the one applying it.

QuoteI say it once again: there are no hidden, secretive or mysterious details to the Gospel.

I never said anything about hidden or secretive but yes there are mysteries God Himself of course. Look I'm not a mason or some gnostic so try not to misunderstand what I'm saying (assuming that you actually care to understand what I'm saying). What I'm saying is that Christ didn't empower individuals to interpret HIS scriptures individually. He empowered the entire Church as body in communion with HIS apostles and the ones HE, by providence, determined to succeed them.

Notice the Catholic emphasis is on Him (God) and His Church and not on ME (protestants) and reason in light of a simple God whose actions and being are so trivial that I can comprehend them on my own.

LH, if I were to ask you if you could explain to me the subtleties  of creation, could you?
Or maybe the subtleties of Jonah being swallowed up by a fish. Or the subtleties of a talking snake...
I can go on for a long time.
Nowhere in the Bible is written that you must be able to explain things in order to inherit the Kingdom of Heaven.
On the contrary. The Bibkle teaches us exactly the opposite.

Besides that, even after hundreds of years of study even the RCC today would not be able to explain the subtleties of the Trinity.
At some point even all the wise men in the Church have to raise their hands and admit that there are many things they can't comprehend.
Can the RCC explain Revelation?

It is pure arrogance of the RCC to claim that she has a "more developed" type of Holy Spirit. There is not a single reference in all the scriptures that supports the idea that the Holy Spirit works differently in the Church than in individuals.

The RCC has measured herself an exclusivity that it not contained in the Gospel. The Gospel in its simplicity and understandability is meant to be freely accessable to everyone who wants to believe and seek a personal relationship with our Saviour.
Something the RCC plainly rejects in order to maintain power and control.

It becomes necessary to explain things in response to heresy which are false representations. What do you think the Church just sat back one day and "Hey lets start trying to explain every iota of God that we can"?

No thats not how this works AVZ. The Church had very little desire to do anything other than evagelize until controversies arose around what was actually being spread around the world; the gospel message itself. In the course of the Church's history you had people Christians and nonChristians beginning to ask questions. "Who exactly is this Jesus of Nazareth?" "How do I become Christian?" 'What does salvation mean?" "What is the Church?" "What is Scripture?"

These are the questions (among others) that sprung up in Churc's history. The Church would've gladly left the subtleties as a mystery to contemplate but then something else happened. In teh void of the Church's silence others began to claim that they had the answer and began to lead people astray.

The Bible canon you hold do you know how and why it came to be?

An early Christian heretic named Marcion decided one day to create an official Bible canon. Up until this point scripture reading was relative to the epistles that every community had on hand and had read from the eareliest times.

Marcion decided that the Old Testament should be discarded because the God of the Old Testament was different than the God of the New Testament. The OT God was a cruel and evil God while the NT God was a good and holy God. This is what led to standardized canons recognized by Church councils.

Protestant lay do not understand this because you do not understand Christian history. That is because you do not believe in Christian history after the time of Constantine I. Your entire belief system is predicated on the entire Church falling into ruin wit Constantine I which made a reformation necessary to restore the Church that had been conquered.

Because you feel that the majority of the Church's history is dominated by error you never consider that history. So when you read the scriptures, look at the simplicit of the Early Church and then open your eyes to the world 2,000 years later you like a child are awed and confused.

"What happened?"
"This looks nothing like the Church meeting in houses, running from Jews and Roman soldiers?"

Thats where we are having are disconnect.

Lively Stone

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Apr 02, 2013 - 14:05:08

In the course of the Church's history you had people Christians and nonChristians beginning to ask questions. "Who exactly is this Jesus of Nazareth?" "How do I become Christian?" 'What does salvation mean?" "What is the Church?" "What is Scripture?"

Christians? They don't have to ask such things.

QuoteProtestant lay do not understand this because you do not understand Christian history.

This is patently false.

QuoteBecause you feel that the majority of the Church's history is dominated by error you never consider that history. So when you read the scriptures, look at the simplicit of the Early Church and then open your eyes to the world 2,000 years later you like a child are awed and confused.

We never consider history? What a silly statement!

QuoteThats where we are having are disconnect.

I think that the disconnect is in yourself and your view of other Christians in the world.


mclees8

Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 15:28:39
Quote from: chosenone on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 15:06:56
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:37:34
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:31:44
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

It has shown the plan of God better than the Catholic ever could.

Jesus said he would protect his church room hell. He did not say to protect it from error. The RCC get puffed up on knowledge and shown little grace. The protestant shown the true gospel of Jesus in simplicity and truth, there's not much comparison. Pride tends to attract a lot of people, that's why many flock to puffed up churches



Protestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals.

No one is infallible except Jesus. All have fallen short Paul says, and that includes all the popes. We have the word to teach us, and we also have God in us through his Holy Spirit.

You seem to forget that billions upon billions of believers through the ages, have managed to have a close intimate and strong relationship with The Father without any input whatsoever from the Catholic church, and they will carry on doing so.

1. Thats not what infallible means and you should know that by now.

2. "billions upon billions"? Thats being very generous.


1Infallible - dictionary definition

: incapable of error : unerring <an infallible memory>
2

: not liable to mislead, deceive, or disappoint : certain <an infallible remedy>
3

: incapable of error in defining doctrines touching faith or morals

Related Words
ERRORLESS, FAULTLESS, FLAWLESS, IMPECCABLE; CERTAIN, FOOLPROOF, INERRANT, PERFECT, SURE; DEPENDABLE, RELIABLE

I would say is correct. You sure can't say this aof any man. even the pope


winsome

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Apr 02, 2013 - 17:00:49
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 15:28:39
Quote from: chosenone on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 15:06:56
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:37:34
Quote from: FireSword on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 12:31:44
Quote from: winsome on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 10:36:38
Jesus knew that fallible men (and women) would go their own way and get it wrong. That is why he left his Church to teach, and promised that, guided by the Holy Spirit, it would never teach error.



You would have thought that 500 years of Protestantism would have shown the wisdom of His plan. But fallible men (and women) still think they know better and try to do it their way.

It has shown the plan of God better than the Catholic ever could.

Jesus said he would protect his church room hell. He did not say to protect it from error. The RCC get puffed up on knowledge and shown little grace. The protestant shown the true gospel of Jesus in simplicity and truth, there's not much comparison. Pride tends to attract a lot of people, that's why many flock to puffed up churches



Protestantism has produced multiple "gospels". Only the Catholic Church has Christ's promise to infallibly teach the truth in faith and morals.

No one is infallible except Jesus. All have fallen short Paul says, and that includes all the popes. We have the word to teach us, and we also have God in us through his Holy Spirit.

You seem to forget that billions upon billions of believers through the ages, have managed to have a close intimate and strong relationship with The Father without any input whatsoever from the Catholic church, and they will carry on doing so.

1. Thats not what infallible means and you should know that by now.

2. "billions upon billions"? Thats being very generous.


1Infallible - dictionary definition

: incapable of error : unerring <an infallible memory>
2

: not liable to mislead, deceive, or disappoint : certain <an infallible remedy>
3

: incapable of error in defining doctrines touching faith or morals

Related Words
ERRORLESS, FAULTLESS, FLAWLESS, IMPECCABLE; CERTAIN, FOOLPROOF, INERRANT, PERFECT, SURE; DEPENDABLE, RELIABLE

I would say is correct. You sure can't say this aof any man. even the pope



It is Christ that is infallible and He has given His Church a share in that infallibility. It can exercise that share in three ways:

"God, who is absolutely infallible, thus deigned to bestow upon His new people, which is the Church, a certain shared infallibility, which is restricted to matters of faith and morals, which is present when

"the whole People of God unhesitatingly holds a point of doctrine pertaining to these matters, and finally which always depends upon the wise providence and anointing of the grace of the Holy Spirit, who leads the Church into all truth until the glorious coming of her Lord....."

"....the bishops scattered throughout the world but teaching in communion with the Successor of Peter present a doctrine to be held irrevocably. It occurs even more clearly both when the bishops by a collegial act (as in Ecumenical Councils), together with their visible Head, define a doctrine to be held ......"

"when the Roman Pontiff speaks ex cathedra, that is, when, exercising the office of Pastor and Teacher of all Christians, through his supreme apostolic authority he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the universal Church."


Quotes from Mysterium Ecclesiae.
http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19730705_mysterium-ecclesiae_en.html

AVZ

#164
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Apr 02, 2013 - 14:05:08
Quote from: AVZ on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 20:41:38
Quote from: LightHammer on Mon Apr 01, 2013 - 13:21:15
QuoteThe point is that there are no complicated mysterious details to the Gospel. That is make believe by the RCC

???

So you understand the subtleties of the Trinity? Can you explain it to me? You understand how the infinite all power uncontainable God was able to dwell as a zygote in a virgin's womb?

I could go on but the fact that your own community is divided into 33,000 divergent sects contradicts your trivializing statements.

QuoteThe RCC is totally hung up in her claim of infallibility and monopoly of true interpretation.
So logically the more complicated you make things out to be, the easier it is to convince the believers that they should just sit tight and believe what they are told.

Well if "logically" that makes no sense. The simplified view of protestants where scripture interprets itself while in practice you all individually follow your own interpretations has divided you on your accord into thousands of different communities.

The protestant experiment hasn't introduced anyone to Christ it has condemned them to search ad nauseam on 33000 different paths for Him.

"Logically" if you have millions of people applying the same method (sola scriptura/ scripture interpreting scripture) to a control (scripture) then something is obviously wrong with either the method or the one applying it.

QuoteI say it once again: there are no hidden, secretive or mysterious details to the Gospel.

I never said anything about hidden or secretive but yes there are mysteries God Himself of course. Look I'm not a mason or some gnostic so try not to misunderstand what I'm saying (assuming that you actually care to understand what I'm saying). What I'm saying is that Christ didn't empower individuals to interpret HIS scriptures individually. He empowered the entire Church as body in communion with HIS apostles and the ones HE, by providence, determined to succeed them.

Notice the Catholic emphasis is on Him (God) and His Church and not on ME (protestants) and reason in light of a simple God whose actions and being are so trivial that I can comprehend them on my own.

LH, if I were to ask you if you could explain to me the subtleties  of creation, could you?
Or maybe the subtleties of Jonah being swallowed up by a fish. Or the subtleties of a talking snake...
I can go on for a long time.
Nowhere in the Bible is written that you must be able to explain things in order to inherit the Kingdom of Heaven.
On the contrary. The Bibkle teaches us exactly the opposite.

Besides that, even after hundreds of years of study even the RCC today would not be able to explain the subtleties of the Trinity.
At some point even all the wise men in the Church have to raise their hands and admit that there are many things they can't comprehend.
Can the RCC explain Revelation?

It is pure arrogance of the RCC to claim that she has a "more developed" type of Holy Spirit. There is not a single reference in all the scriptures that supports the idea that the Holy Spirit works differently in the Church than in individuals.

The RCC has measured herself an exclusivity that it not contained in the Gospel. The Gospel in its simplicity and understandability is meant to be freely accessable to everyone who wants to believe and seek a personal relationship with our Saviour.
Something the RCC plainly rejects in order to maintain power and control.

It becomes necessary to explain things in response to heresy which are false representations. What do you think the Church just sat back one day and "Hey lets start trying to explain every iota of God that we can"?

No thats not how this works AVZ. The Church had very little desire to do anything other than evagelize until controversies arose around what was actually being spread around the world; the gospel message itself. In the course of the Church's history you had people Christians and nonChristians beginning to ask questions. "Who exactly is this Jesus of Nazareth?" "How do I become Christian?" 'What does salvation mean?" "What is the Church?" "What is Scripture?"

These are the questions (among others) that sprung up in Churc's history. The Church would've gladly left the subtleties as a mystery to contemplate but then something else happened. In teh void of the Church's silence others began to claim that they had the answer and began to lead people astray.

The Bible canon you hold do you know how and why it came to be?

An early Christian heretic named Marcion decided one day to create an official Bible canon. Up until this point scripture reading was relative to the epistles that every community had on hand and had read from the eareliest times.

Marcion decided that the Old Testament should be discarded because the God of the Old Testament was different than the God of the New Testament. The OT God was a cruel and evil God while the NT God was a good and holy God. This is what led to standardized canons recognized by Church councils.

Protestant lay do not understand this because you do not understand Christian history. That is because you do not believe in Christian history after the time of Constantine I. Your entire belief system is predicated on the entire Church falling into ruin wit Constantine I which made a reformation necessary to restore the Church that had been conquered.

Because you feel that the majority of the Church's history is dominated by error you never consider that history. So when you read the scriptures, look at the simplicit of the Early Church and then open your eyes to the world 2,000 years later you like a child are awed and confused.

"What happened?"
"This looks nothing like the Church meeting in houses, running from Jews and Roman soldiers?"

Thats where we are having are disconnect.

Sorry LH, but that is a load of ****.

Both the Catholic and Protestant church share a MAJORITY common history which are recognized by both.
Reformation happened many centuries after Constantine.

After Constantine the Catholic Church looked far more like the original church as she does today, and it were those changes that lead to the reformation.

You say that the Catholic Church would gladly let mysteries be mysteries and move on? How untrue!

Where does purgatory come from? - Invention by the RCC
Where does a monolpoly on the Holy Spirit come from? - Invention by the RCC
Where do indulgences come from? - Invention by the RCC
Where does the veneration of Mary come from? - Invention by the RCC
Where does infallibility come from? - Invention by the RCC

All those inventions were done hundreds of years after Constantine. Nobody asked the RCC to invent these "mysteries of faith", the RCC just did.

You say: "So when you read the scriptures, look at the simplicit of the Early Church and then open your eyes to the world 2,000 years later you like a child are awed and confused."
What do you mean? Is it not the Catholic Church that teaches that the Gospel is too complicated and Catholics are better off not to read the Bible?
Yet you claim the early church was simple, and in the same breath you claim that the RCC still is like the early church.

You know when you can see a child that is confused and awed? If you give a Catholic a Bible and ask him to read the Gospel.
That is if he actually knows where to start, because most Catholics do not even know where to find the New Testament.

The Catholic Church has become an institute engaged in a continuous stream of controversies and schandals, heading a mass of believers that are utterly clueless beyond what they hear and see during mass.
How could you possibly compare yourself to the early Church? There is really nothing left in the RCC that even slightly resembles the simplicity of the early church.

Protestantism is not predicated on a Church or on a person like Constantine. Protestantism is based on what it all started with: God's Word...the Bible.
The thing the RCC feels she has to discourage her members from having, holding or reading.

LightHammer

#165
QuoteSorry LH, but that is a load of ****.

That's all I needed to hear. Thank you AVZ. Have a nice day.

Pax Christi

LightHammer

mclees8

#166
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Mar 26, 2013 - 06:16:05
Quote from: AVZ on Tue Mar 26, 2013 - 02:19:25
Quote from: winsome on Fri Mar 15, 2013 - 15:50:17
Another point is not to confuse sacramental objects with devotional objects such as rosaries and religious pictures which are used in private prayer and devotions.

There is no difference between the two. Both sacramental objects and devotional objects hold no power and are only symbols or reminders of the believes and sacraments.

This is not true. As one example, demons hate holy water and blessed salt.

And vampires cringe at a crucifix   rofl

+-Recent Topics

American Socialism? by Texas Conservative
Today at 07:48:00

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Yesterday at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Yesterday at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Tue Nov 17, 2026 - 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

Powered by EzPortal