News:

Our Hosting and Server Costs Are Expensive! Please Subscribe To Help With Monthly Donations.

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898068
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 6274
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 6174
Total: 6175
yogi bear
Google (2)

Did the Crusades do more harm or good in your opinion?

Started by matt1, Mon Jun 04, 2012 - 12:27:53

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Helen

Same God, Catholica, but WAYYY different  circumstances.  The Pope is NOT God and what God commands and what the Pope commands are not necessarily the same.  In addition, God had given the Promised Land to the Hebrew.  The Crusades were most certainly not done with the intention of making sure the Jews got their land back.  In fact, the Roman Catholic Church spent an awful lot of years and time not only trying to conquer the Muslims, but also trying to eliminate the Jews themselves. 

Jimmy

When the brothers of Joseph sold him in slavery, God used that for a very good purpose.  That does not make what the brothers did any less vile.  Same for the crusades.  Whatever good God might cause to come from the crusades does not make the crusades any less perverse and repulsive.

mclees8

Quote from: Catholica on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 09:29:53
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:50:44
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:01:21
Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:20:07
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 14:09:20
Quote from: Helen on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 13:40:55
QuoteIt was never promised to crusaders that going on a crusade guaranteed them a place in heaven.  That is not what indulgences do.  This statement of yours comes from a position of ignorance, to put it bluntly.
Well, I guess my ignorance is also the ignorance of the universities teaching history.

"Urban II offered full indulgence to any Christian participating in the Crusade.  This meant quite simply that any and all sins would be forgiven and the Crusader would enter heaven.  As you can imagine, this only encouraged Crusaders to engage in the worst types of sin -- rape, robbery, murder -- during the Crusades.  By the time of the Crusades, indulgences were already granted by the Church to Christians for various reasons -- a pilgrimage to Jerusalem could already buy one partial or full remission of sins, and those who died during the pilgrimage were believed to go directly to heaven, regardless of previous sins."

from http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/engl257/Medieval/crusades.htm
Why yes, it is also the ignorance of people teaching at universities as well.  In this case, not a history teacher, but an English teacher.

Indulgences, including the ones offered for the crusaders, only remitted the temporal punishment due to sins already committed and forgiven through the sacrament of reconciliation.  A person had to first confess sins that they committed before an indulgence could help with anything.  That is, the indulgence itself did not grant them entrance to heaven in spite of their sins.

Someone might wonder why the University of Idaho, a public, secular university, would be anyone's resource for information about Catholic doctrine.

From the article:

"Like most other key historical events covered this semester, we will only glance at the Crusades and do them little justice.  Again, our attention will focus on how this historical movement worked to shape literature, but we are also interested in how these events, and the literature they shaped, in turn shaped our own "Western Civilization" view of history and our current relationship to, in this case, "The Other", the "Infidel": Muslims and the Turkish, Arabic and Islamic world."

You quoted an English teacher.   I will quote the Catechism of the Catholic Church, emphasis mine:

QuoteX. INDULGENCES

1471 The doctrine and practice of indulgences in the Church are closely linked to the effects of the sacrament of Penance.

What is an indulgence?

"An indulgence is a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven, which the faithful Christian who is duly disposed gains under certain prescribed conditions through the action of the Church which, as the minister of redemption, dispenses and applies with authority the treasury of the satisfactions of Christ and the saints."
That being said, Protestant doctrine goes a step further and says that there is no temporal punishment due to sins at all.  They say that people also go to heaven without confessing their sins, that there is no need to confess their sins.

The implication that the indulgences of the crusades would lead people to believe that they could rape and murder with impunity is just as valid as saying that as soon as one accepts Jesus that they are led to believe that they can rape and murder with impunity.  In other words: it lead the crusaders to believe no such thing.

And what does the Lord's church have to do with temporal punishment, or anything temporal for that matter. Is the church like secular courts and plea bargains and all that.  You have any scriptural support from our Knew Testament.   

The Lord chastises every son he acknowledges.  Hebrews 12:6ff.  That is what is meant by "punishment" by "temporal punishment" is that chastisement for sins.  It is part of the sanctification process and due to God's justice and love.  God wants us to be perfect, and sin leaves a stain on our soul.

The goal of a secular court punishing law breakers has a good purpose, which is an external influence to both keep someone from breaking a crime or for justice due to a crime and time to reform from evil actions.  Jail time is not only good for the protection of society but also is meant to help the criminal reform.

We know that nothing unclean will enter heaven.  Rev. 21:27.  In that case, which I believe, I am thankful for purgatory, indulgences and the mercy of God.  Because there is very little possibility that anyone is truly ready to be in God's presence in our fallen, redeemed but imperfect state.  That is how holy God is.

I want to ask three  questions. Who is a Son that he should be chastised?
A son is the beloved child of a father who wants the best for him.  Chastisement brings about purity.

Hebrews 12
5 You have also forgotten the exhortation addressed to you as sons: "My son, do not disdain the discipline of the Lord or lose heart when reproved by him;
6 for whom the Lord loves, he disciplines; he scourges every son he acknowledges."
7 Endure your trials as "discipline"; God treats you as sons. For what "son" is there whom his father does not discipline?
8 If you are without discipline, in which all have shared, you are not sons but bastards.
9 Besides this, we have had our earthly fathers to discipline us, and we respected them. Should we not [then] submit all the more to the Father of spirits and live?
10 They disciplined us for a short time as seemed right to them, but he does so for our benefit, in order that we may share his holiness.
11 At the time, all discipline seems a cause not for joy but for pain, yet later it brings the peaceful fruit of righteousness to those who are trained by it.
12 So strengthen your drooping hands and your weak knees.
13 Make straight paths for your feet, that what is lame may not be dislocated but healed.

Who is a son whom the father doesn't discipline?  A bastard, according to the Bible.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is a heretic?
A heretic is someone who has been given the Catholic faith and rejected it. 

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 16:23:46
Who is one who obeys the law of the land but does not abide by the church.  ( Midlevel times)
That depends.  If one was baptized, and we are speaking of medieval times in western Europe, then that person was a disobedient son of God, possibly a schismatic.  If one was not baptized, then he is simply God's beloved creature (but not a child of God).   

Not sure why you are asking, or how this pertains?  If I understood that, I could probably give a more appropriate and succinct answer.


For my first question that is right for any son in the world. Who then is a son of God that he should be chastised by the church. According to your third response it would be one who is baptized  So the heretic and the unbaptized would never be chastised or punished by the church. The church deals with her own. Would that be correct?
There are two concepts that we must consider to answer this.  One is Church discipline for internal matters.  The other is God's discipline and/or punishment for sin.  We can read in the Bible that God can use anyone, even pagans, to punish for sin.  And therefore he can also use the Church to punish for sin, anyone's sin.

Any son of God could be chastised by the Church.  If he is publicly disobedient, or if he is teaching heresy, then excommunication is just one way the Church can chastise someone.  Heretics can be both members of the Church and non-members.  But in terms of Church discipline, yes, the Church deals with her own.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
For you second response. Would then the heretic be punished by the church for being a heretic?
Yes, if the heretic is in the Church, then the heretic could be punished, typically by excommunication or suppression under obedience.  Typically this is limited to clergy only.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
For the third response. So if one does not abide by the church and is not baptized is one who is not saved. So the heretic and the unbaptized are not sons of God and the church would not punish them for anything because they are not of the church.  Correct?.
Only partially correct.  The heretic may be a son of God, and they may be part of the Church.  But the unbaptized and the non-Catholic have not submitted themselves to the Church, and thus the Church doesn't use Church discipline.  This doesn't exempt them, however, from punishment/chastisement from God for their sins.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
Who has to obey the church, all the people of the land or just those who are baptized. If one is baptized does that make him truly saved  ?  If not why?
All the people of the land have to obey the commandments or they will experience punishment from God.  The Church is God's representative which God works through to preserve true teaching on faith and morals.  So if people know what's good for them, they will abide by the Church's moral teaching even if they are not members of the Church.  So in that sense, everyone has to obey the moral teachings of the Church, because they come from God.  In terms of being obedient to the Church hierarchy in terms of what they teach, the Church only disciplines people who have entered the Catholic Church.  That being said, the Church fights against heresy wherever it is taught, and that includes by people who are outside the Church, but it is not the same as Church discipline.

Quote from: mclees8 on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 18:49:26
I pray for your patience.  I am going somewhere with all this. I want to distinguish who the church is that they be chastised by the church hierarchy and who are the people of the land. Are all the people of the land subject to the church for any secular  crimes out side the church

Pleas still answer for each of the three original  question? Thank you and remember Im speaking of the midlevel church
People who are in the land are subject to the laws of the government.  Those people who make laws receive the authority to make those laws from God, and so even if they are not members of the Church, they all should and are in reality under God's authority and so should make laws which flow from the divine law.  The Church is the teacher of the divine moral law, and so just laws in any country should be in unity with the moral teachings of the Church, and lawmakers do well to take into account Church teaching on morals when they make laws.  Thus the secular authority is rightly influenced by Church teaching, even if the people therein are not subject to church discipline.

Thus when the secular rulers of certain countries make laws which are in unity with what the Church teaches and enact penalties for disobeying those laws, the people living in that country are bound to obey those laws, even if those laws flow from Church teaching, and even if they aren't members of the Church.

Thank you Catholica  for your answers.  fist I want to say from proverbs there is a way the seemeth right to a man but the end there of is death. You say many things that seem right yet there are flaws and misconceptions. I am not able to just blurt out the answers with out careful thought and prayer and ican only devote my time as I have it. Be assured though I will answer.
Quote from: Catholica on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 09:31:33
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 02:32:24
Quote from: Catholica on Tue Sep 03, 2013 - 15:52:28
Crusaders were promised eternal life IF they died on crusade.  That is the same thing as being a martyr.  That being said: 

Actually its the same thing as being a terrorist.

I guess God commanded a lot of terrorism in the books of Joshua and Judges, then.  Such actions are well within what God revealed.  Why is that so hard for people who love the Bible to understand?  The God of the Old Testament and the New Testament are the same God.  You believe that right?

You are right however  in the New covenant God no longer deals with nations but his laws are put in the heart of each believer. God no longer deals with governments and nations kings and rulers in the knew testament church even though he is sovereign over all creation. Sin is in the hearts of all men, even those of the church. So also goes the leaders of the world. It is because sin is in the world that God sanctions law, but not all law is of God. Evil exists in all governments but law is just a necessary thing because of sin. Read the Knew testament a couple more times and you will this. The unbelieving world ( all that is out side of Christ) and its Governments is coming to judgment. All the world outside of faith in Christ is Babylon. Study REV 18 and you will see what all the unbelieving world is. There is only one judgment for all things and it has not come yet. If you feel I have this wrong then find it in the Knew testament and share it.

Catholica

#73
Quote from: Helen on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 10:44:33
Same God, Catholica, but WAYYY different  circumstances.  The Pope is NOT God and what God commands and what the Pope commands are not necessarily the same.  In addition, God had given the Promised Land to the Hebrew.  The Crusades were most certainly not done with the intention of making sure the Jews got their land back.  In fact, the Roman Catholic Church spent an awful lot of years and time not only trying to conquer the Muslims, but also trying to eliminate the Jews themselves. 

No one is saying that the Pope is God, nor does anyone believe that he is.

What God commands and what the Pope commands are not necessarily the same, but they can be.

Not all wars that God endorsed were for the purpose of the Jews getting their lands back.  For example, in Judges 19-21, I believe, God sanctions a war which nearly eliminates the tribe of Benjamin at the hands of the rest of Israel, in response to a heinous sin that took place in Benjamin.

What can you cite that demonstrates that the Catholic Church was trying to eliminate the Jews?  This is a common secular myth.  Yes, Jews were wrongly slaughtered in the retaking of Jerusalem, but that was at the failings of men who had been nearly starved and parched to death, not by order of the hierarchy, not by authority of the Church.  The slaughter of Jews has always been condemned by the Catholic Church.  That doesn't stop the failings of men, even Catholics, but it IS evidence that contradicts what you believe.

Christians decided to fight back against the Muslim conquerors who were nearly ready to take France after taking Spain and the Iberian peninsula and the Holy Land.  Muslims were persecuting Christians on pilgrimage to the Holy Land  There is nothing unjust in the intent of these wars.  The acts that happened because of some of the crusades, for example, the sacking of Constantinople and the slaughter of Jews in Jerusalem are certainly lamentable and terrible, but they were not the intent of the crusades.

BlackSepulcher

#74
Quote from: Helen on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 10:44:33
Same God, Catholica, but WAYYY different  circumstances.  The Pope is NOT God and what God commands and what the Pope commands are not necessarily the same.  In addition, God had given the Promised Land to the Hebrew.  The Crusades were most certainly not done with the intention of making sure the Jews got their land back.  In fact, the Roman Catholic Church spent an awful lot of years and time not only trying to conquer the Muslims, but also trying to eliminate the Jews themselves.

What should have been the intent of the Crusades? Unless you can answer in relevance to the era and circumstance, you can't give any good answer.
Those like yourself live in a liberal age where liberal actions aren't synonymous with destruction. People outside of Christendom were barbarians, living in a world ruled by religion. I simply do not see HOW THAT IS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND.

I really think some of you simply need to parachute off that big ivory tower and zip the lips. The Crusades were certainly crusades, that about as much as you should really be concerned about. Pointing the finger at the Church, blaming the Church for everything- seriously, take your discrimination somewhere it is relevant.



AVZ

A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

BlackSepulcher

#76
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:35:56
A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

The army of Islam has always been the way it is, only today we call them terrorists. Yes, there was religious madness- it was a world entirely ruled by religion.

A simple 'check' on the conditions of the first crusade, entirely constructed by atheists and Protestants, is going to read just like the myth of the Spanish Inquisitions- demonizing the Church and putting the culture of the writer up in the heavenly bowels of  benevolence.

Quite frankly, I don't even consider that nonsense. Christendom took back what was theirs to suppress the arrogance of heretics.
It's called Middle Age warfare, welcome to planet Earth where bad things happen. One monumental thing that anti-Catholics completely fail to realize, likely due to their overly pretentious attitude of the Church, is that it was a time of enormous expansion. Can you think of any instance in human history where such expansion does not result in some sort of bloodshed?

No, you can't. So stop blaming the Church for everything.



mclees8

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:34:37
Quote from: Helen on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 10:44:33
Same God, Catholica, but WAYYY different  circumstances.  The Pope is NOT God and what God commands and what the Pope commands are not necessarily the same.  In addition, God had given the Promised Land to the Hebrew.  The Crusades were most certainly not done with the intention of making sure the Jews got their land back.  In fact, the Roman Catholic Church spent an awful lot of years and time not only trying to conquer the Muslims, but also trying to eliminate the Jews themselves.

What should have been the intent of the Crusades? Unless you can answer in relevance to the era and circumstance, you can't give any good answer.
Those like yourself live in a liberal age where liberal actions aren't synonymous with destruction. People outside of Christendom were barbarians, living in a world ruled by religion. I simply do not see HOW THAT IS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND.

I really think some of you simply need to parachute off that big ivory tower and zip the lips. The Crusades were certainly crusades, that about as much as you should really be concerned about. Pointing the finger at the Church, blaming the Church for everything- seriously, take your discrimination somewhere it is relevant.




Let me tell you black what is truly relevant. Their never was a divine call by God for the Bishops of Rome  to be authoritarian Monarchs ruling the empire and forming armies to wage wars. This was never the purpose  of Christ church, and you will find nothing in Knew Testament scripture to support that.  But if you can than by all means share it.

BlackSepulcher

Quote from: mclees8 on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 16:19:40
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:34:37
Quote from: Helen on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 10:44:33
Same God, Catholica, but WAYYY different  circumstances.  The Pope is NOT God and what God commands and what the Pope commands are not necessarily the same.  In addition, God had given the Promised Land to the Hebrew.  The Crusades were most certainly not done with the intention of making sure the Jews got their land back.  In fact, the Roman Catholic Church spent an awful lot of years and time not only trying to conquer the Muslims, but also trying to eliminate the Jews themselves.

What should have been the intent of the Crusades? Unless you can answer in relevance to the era and circumstance, you can't give any good answer.
Those like yourself live in a liberal age where liberal actions aren't synonymous with destruction. People outside of Christendom were barbarians, living in a world ruled by religion. I simply do not see HOW THAT IS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND.

I really think some of you simply need to parachute off that big ivory tower and zip the lips. The Crusades were certainly crusades, that about as much as you should really be concerned about. Pointing the finger at the Church, blaming the Church for everything- seriously, take your discrimination somewhere it is relevant.




Let me tell you black what is truly relevant. Their never was a divine call by God for the Bishops of Rome  to be authoritarian Monarchs ruling the empire and forming armies to wage wars. This was never the purpose  of Christ church, and you will find nothing in Knew Testament scripture to support that.  But if you can than by all means share it.

Jesus told Peter that the gates of Hell will not prevail against the Church. He says that he did not come to bring peace, but a sword. The Apocalypse of John makes the Antichrist synonymous to false prophets and idolators.

There plenty of scriptural armament, you just choose not to put yourself in the steed of a Medieval world with Medieval issues and consequences.
That's basically WHAT IS WRONG with those such as yourself, it is 2013 buddy.


AVZ

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 14:35:36
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:35:56
A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

The army of Islam has always been the way it is, only today we call them terrorists. Yes, there was religious madness- it was a world entirely ruled by religion.

A simple 'check' on the conditions of the first crusade, entirely constructed by atheists and Protestants, is going to read just like the myth of the Spanish Inquisitions- demonizing the Church and putting the culture of the writer up in the heavenly bowels of  benevolence.

Quite frankly, I don't even consider that nonsense. Christendom took back what was theirs to suppress the arrogance of heretics.
It's called Middle Age warfare, welcome to planet Earth where bad things happen. One monumental thing that anti-Catholics completely fail to realize, likely due to their overly pretentious attitude of the Church, is that it was a time of enormous expansion. Can you think of any instance in human history where such expansion does not result in some sort of bloodshed?

No, you can't. So stop blaming the Church for everything.

I think you should not get your knickers in a twist and stop playing the accused Catholic.
There is nothing typical Catholic about the crusades, and there is nothing typical Protestant about the objections.
The crusades are COMMON church history. It is as much Catholic church history as it is Protestant church history.

Christendom did take nothing back.
The holy land wasn't a possession of the church and has never been the possession of the church.
For as far as the people in the holy land were concerned, the church was as much a foreign invader as the Muslims.

Neither are the historical records atheist or Protestant.
The most reliable historical records were taken down by the church herself and give us insight of the background on which decisions were made to initiate the first crusade.

I honestly don't know why you are so upset about all this. Church history hasn't always been love and charity...this is just one example.
People were misguided under misguided council by misguided doctrine and through misguided promises.

And lets be honest, the Catholic Church has already apologized for the crusades so I guess some amount of misguidance has already been admitted.

BlackSepulcher

Quote from: AVZ on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 00:17:00
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 14:35:36
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:35:56
A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

The army of Islam has always been the way it is, only today we call them terrorists. Yes, there was religious madness- it was a world entirely ruled by religion.

A simple 'check' on the conditions of the first crusade, entirely constructed by atheists and Protestants, is going to read just like the myth of the Spanish Inquisitions- demonizing the Church and putting the culture of the writer up in the heavenly bowels of  benevolence.

Quite frankly, I don't even consider that nonsense. Christendom took back what was theirs to suppress the arrogance of heretics.
It's called Middle Age warfare, welcome to planet Earth where bad things happen. One monumental thing that anti-Catholics completely fail to realize, likely due to their overly pretentious attitude of the Church, is that it was a time of enormous expansion. Can you think of any instance in human history where such expansion does not result in some sort of bloodshed?

No, you can't. So stop blaming the Church for everything.

I think you should not get your knickers in a twist and stop playing the accused Catholic.
There is nothing typical Catholic about the crusades, and there is nothing typical Protestant about the objections.
The crusades are COMMON church history. It is as much Catholic church history as it is Protestant church history.

Christendom did take nothing back.
The holy land wasn't a possession of the church and has never been the possession of the church.
For as far as the people in the holy land were concerned, the church was as much a foreign invader as the Muslims.

Neither are the historical records atheist or Protestant.
The most reliable historical records were taken down by the church herself and give us insight of the background on which decisions were made to initiate the first crusade.

I honestly don't know why you are so upset about all this. Church history hasn't always been love and charity...this is just one example.
People were misguided under misguided council by misguided doctrine and through misguided promises.

And lets be honest, the Catholic Church has already apologized for the crusades so I guess some amount of misguidance has already been admitted.

Jerusalem was under Christianity before Islam took it over, by which the Church took back as one of it's actions to help the Byzantine Empire.

What part of "the entire world was governed by religion" does not register? It's like you all see it, but don't actually absorb it. Do you understand the totality of the statement?
Is an atheist or Muslim going to keep Christendom prevalent? No. Is a heretic going to maintain orthodoxy? No. Therefore, the Church did what they had to.

It was not a world of free speech, free gathering, and manifest destiny. That is the pulpit your lot preaches from, and quite frankly, it is extraordinarily ignorant.

That is why I'm upset.
And yes, the Church has nonetheless apologized because she tries to be humble even if what she is humbling herself for is blown completely and unfairly out of proportion.

I don't see protestants apologizing for their witch trials, Genevian trials, and hundreds of other amazingly despicable things they've done throughout their history. Guess I'll just leave it to you to read what the Bible says about demanding something one doesn't practice.


AVZ

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 01:34:58
Quote from: AVZ on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 00:17:00
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 14:35:36
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:35:56
A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

The army of Islam has always been the way it is, only today we call them terrorists. Yes, there was religious madness- it was a world entirely ruled by religion.

A simple 'check' on the conditions of the first crusade, entirely constructed by atheists and Protestants, is going to read just like the myth of the Spanish Inquisitions- demonizing the Church and putting the culture of the writer up in the heavenly bowels of  benevolence.

Quite frankly, I don't even consider that nonsense. Christendom took back what was theirs to suppress the arrogance of heretics.
It's called Middle Age warfare, welcome to planet Earth where bad things happen. One monumental thing that anti-Catholics completely fail to realize, likely due to their overly pretentious attitude of the Church, is that it was a time of enormous expansion. Can you think of any instance in human history where such expansion does not result in some sort of bloodshed?

No, you can't. So stop blaming the Church for everything.

I think you should not get your knickers in a twist and stop playing the accused Catholic.
There is nothing typical Catholic about the crusades, and there is nothing typical Protestant about the objections.
The crusades are COMMON church history. It is as much Catholic church history as it is Protestant church history.

Christendom did take nothing back.
The holy land wasn't a possession of the church and has never been the possession of the church.
For as far as the people in the holy land were concerned, the church was as much a foreign invader as the Muslims.

Neither are the historical records atheist or Protestant.
The most reliable historical records were taken down by the church herself and give us insight of the background on which decisions were made to initiate the first crusade.

I honestly don't know why you are so upset about all this. Church history hasn't always been love and charity...this is just one example.
People were misguided under misguided council by misguided doctrine and through misguided promises.

And lets be honest, the Catholic Church has already apologized for the crusades so I guess some amount of misguidance has already been admitted.

Jerusalem was under Christianity before Islam took it over, by which the Church took back as one of it's actions to help the Byzantine Empire.

What part of "the entire world was governed by religion" does not register? It's like you all see it, but don't actually absorb it. Do you understand the totality of the statement?
Is an atheist or Muslim going to keep Christendom prevalent? No. Is a heretic going to maintain orthodoxy? No. Therefore, the Church did what they had to.

It was not a world of free speech, free gathering, and manifest destiny. That is the pulpit your lot preaches from, and quite frankly, it is extraordinarily ignorant.

That is why I'm upset.
And yes, the Church has nonetheless apologized because she tries to be humble even if what she is humbling herself for is blown completely and unfairly out of proportion.

I don't see protestants apologizing for their witch trials, Genevian trials, and hundreds of other amazingly despicable things they've done throughout their history. Guess I'll just leave it to you to read what the Bible says about demanding something one doesn't practice.

So what you are saying is regardless of the Roman and Byzantine occupation of the holy land, the fact that the emperor was a Christian makes the holy land a "Christian possession"?
Obviously you are mistaken, the holy land was the possession of the people living there, and not the possession of a string of conquerors.
Christianity does not possess countries.

The assistance the church rendered to the Byzantine empire was politically motivated and was given religious content by spiritual misguidance.

mclees8

#82
  Catholica said >  All the people of the land have to obey the commandments or they will experience punishment from God.  The Church is God's representative which God works through to preserve true teaching on faith and morals.  So if people know what's good for them, they will abide by the Church's moral teaching even if they are not members of the Church.  So in that sense, everyone has to obey the moral teachings of the Church, because they come from God.  In terms of being obedient to the Church hierarchy in terms of what they teach, the Church only disciplines people who have entered the Catholic Church.  That being said, the Church fights against heresy wherever it is taught, and that includes by people who are outside the Church, but it is not the same as Church discipline.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Mike> I have to ask you another question now. You said all people have to Obey the comandments of God or they will be punished by Him. God punishes or chatises no man for sin that do not profess faith in Jesus.  Can all the people of the land obey His commandments? Yes or no. This is a very important question because all that you just said is completely flawed and a distortion of the truth and Im going to prove it from Gods word. So can all the people of the land or the world keep Gods commandments. Yes or no. Why did Jesus go to the cross.? Its because if He did not No man could be saved.

One more thing. What happened in the Garden when man fell? Did Paul not say that by the disobedience of one man (Adam) sin came into the world.  This meant that all men are now under the curse of the sin the nature and being good cannot overcome this nature and no matter how much one tries to obey God he cannot. Is this Right or wrong?

There are two major themes in Gods word from Genesis to Revelation. First is the plan of redemption and the other is separation. This means with out Christ sacrifice no one will be saved. Seperation means not all will be saved so the once who are saved must separate themselves for the world and all its sinful lusts.   It is the plan of separation that is least understood by your church but it is directly counter to all you just said. 

Who were the ones the ten commandmest given to along with all the ritual and moral laws that were given to Moses? Were not these laws for the children of Isreal. Even the Ten commandments. Were there any other peoples or nations there when God Gave the Jews the ten commandments?  They were not intended for any other people or nations. Then and now they only apply to Gods own people and Christian believers who are  extensions of His covenant people.
 
Lets go to the Old testament when Abraham was called out from the ER of the Caldese because they were idolaters. He wanted him to be separated from them.  Latter he told Abraham he would be the Father of a new nation. Not just any nation but a special nation and a peculiar people called to Himself to be separate from all other nations who were heathen idolaters. So again who were Gods laws for ?

In America we say the country was founded on Judael Christian principles. Our laws were originally fashioned with these principles, but principles do not make anyone saved or of Christ church. Principles in this case are just principles. A code of moral ethics and standards. We used to display the Ten commandments in our schools and institutions. Today they are outlawed. Is our nation saved because of principles we used to believe that some how men would adhere to them? No! So again who are God's commandment for? They apply only to those who love Christ and His Spirit in them compels us then to obey Gods commandments. The world could care less. And to all who have received Christ the commandment is to be separate from the unbelieving world with all its idolitiries,lusts and corruptions.

Old Testament  To the children of Israel
2 For thou art an holy people unto the LORD thy God, and the LORD hath chosen thee to be a peculiar people unto himself, above all the nations that are upon the earth.     Deut 14:2

17 Thou hast avouched the LORD this day to be thy God, and to walk in his ways, and to keep his statutes, and his commandments, and his judgments, and to hearken unto his voice: 18 And the LORD hath avouched thee this day to be his peculiar people, as he hath promised thee, and that thou shouldest keep all his commandments;       Deut 26:18

New Testament for the New Covenant church
But ye are a chosen generation, a royal priesthood, an holy nation, a peculiarb people; that ye should shew forth the praises of him who hath called you out of darkness into his marvellous light: 10 Which in time past were not a people, but are now the people of God: which had not obtained mercy, but now have obtained mercy. 

Be not unequally yoked with unbeliever for what concord have believers with unbelievers 2nd Cor 6:14

verse18 wherefore come out from amongst them and be ye separate Saith the Lord

Out side the church the world is the world so there fore God chasens none of them. Their woes are brought on by their own life choices. All men reap what they sow. So Sin does bring people to their knees but the Lord does not punish anyone for their sins but only offers them salvation that they are forgiven for them and then brought into the church by his grace and grace alone. The only sin that will send anyone to hell is their own unbelief.



So God does not call all men to obey his commandmens or be punished by popes or any other religious order.  Their time will come at the judgment. So what is all this stuff you church teaches you that  God punishes worldly men not of the church.

BlackSepulcher

Quote from: AVZ on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 02:00:11
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 01:34:58
Quote from: AVZ on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 00:17:00
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 14:35:36
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:35:56
A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

The army of Islam has always been the way it is, only today we call them terrorists. Yes, there was religious madness- it was a world entirely ruled by religion.

A simple 'check' on the conditions of the first crusade, entirely constructed by atheists and Protestants, is going to read just like the myth of the Spanish Inquisitions- demonizing the Church and putting the culture of the writer up in the heavenly bowels of  benevolence.

Quite frankly, I don't even consider that nonsense. Christendom took back what was theirs to suppress the arrogance of heretics.
It's called Middle Age warfare, welcome to planet Earth where bad things happen. One monumental thing that anti-Catholics completely fail to realize, likely due to their overly pretentious attitude of the Church, is that it was a time of enormous expansion. Can you think of any instance in human history where such expansion does not result in some sort of bloodshed?

No, you can't. So stop blaming the Church for everything.

I think you should not get your knickers in a twist and stop playing the accused Catholic.
There is nothing typical Catholic about the crusades, and there is nothing typical Protestant about the objections.
The crusades are COMMON church history. It is as much Catholic church history as it is Protestant church history.

Christendom did take nothing back.
The holy land wasn't a possession of the church and has never been the possession of the church.
For as far as the people in the holy land were concerned, the church was as much a foreign invader as the Muslims.

Neither are the historical records atheist or Protestant.
The most reliable historical records were taken down by the church herself and give us insight of the background on which decisions were made to initiate the first crusade.

I honestly don't know why you are so upset about all this. Church history hasn't always been love and charity...this is just one example.
People were misguided under misguided council by misguided doctrine and through misguided promises.

And lets be honest, the Catholic Church has already apologized for the crusades so I guess some amount of misguidance has already been admitted.

Jerusalem was under Christianity before Islam took it over, by which the Church took back as one of it's actions to help the Byzantine Empire.

What part of "the entire world was governed by religion" does not register? It's like you all see it, but don't actually absorb it. Do you understand the totality of the statement?
Is an atheist or Muslim going to keep Christendom prevalent? No. Is a heretic going to maintain orthodoxy? No. Therefore, the Church did what they had to.

It was not a world of free speech, free gathering, and manifest destiny. That is the pulpit your lot preaches from, and quite frankly, it is extraordinarily ignorant.

That is why I'm upset.
And yes, the Church has nonetheless apologized because she tries to be humble even if what she is humbling herself for is blown completely and unfairly out of proportion.

I don't see protestants apologizing for their witch trials, Genevian trials, and hundreds of other amazingly despicable things they've done throughout their history. Guess I'll just leave it to you to read what the Bible says about demanding something one doesn't practice.

So what you are saying is regardless of the Roman and Byzantine occupation of the holy land, the fact that the emperor was a Christian makes the holy land a "Christian possession"?
Obviously you are mistaken, the holy land was the possession of the people living there, and not the possession of a string of conquerors.
Christianity does not possess countries.

The assistance the church rendered to the Byzantine empire was politically motivated and was given religious content by spiritual misguidance.

That's exactly what the holy lands were- under the possession of Christendom. You can make the difference between political and religious all you want, there was no difference then.

It's called the medieval ages. I know you don't want to accept that fact, it wouldn't have mattered if it was Catholicism, Protestantism, you or me- in those times, crusades were an inevitable part of the world.

Blaming the Church marks you as proverbially ignorant. That is another reason it upsets me- you all think you know everything, think you have it all figured out thinking you can point fingers at people. You live in a liberal age where your 'benevolent' standing is granted. For now, anyway..



mclees8

#84
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 15:17:16
Quote from: AVZ on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 02:00:11
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 01:34:58
Quote from: AVZ on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 00:17:00
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 14:35:36
Quote from: AVZ on Thu Sep 05, 2013 - 12:35:56
A simple check on the conditions of the first crusade will show that the reason of this crusade was religious madness.
There was nothing holy about it, but it was made holy as to give it some form of legitimacy.

Muslims were considered heretics and deserved to be destroyed.
That's the whole reason for the crusades.

The army of Islam has always been the way it is, only today we call them terrorists. Yes, there was religious madness- it was a world entirely ruled by religion.

A simple 'check' on the conditions of the first crusade, entirely constructed by atheists and Protestants, is going to read just like the myth of the Spanish Inquisitions- demonizing the Church and putting the culture of the writer up in the heavenly bowels of  benevolence.

Quite frankly, I don't even consider that nonsense. Christendom took back what was theirs to suppress the arrogance of heretics.
It's called Middle Age warfare, welcome to planet Earth where bad things happen. One monumental thing that anti-Catholics completely fail to realize, likely due to their overly pretentious attitude of the Church, is that it was a time of enormous expansion. Can you think of any instance in human history where such expansion does not result in some sort of bloodshed?

No, you can't. So stop blaming the Church for everything.

I think you should not get your knickers in a twist and stop playing the accused Catholic.
There is nothing typical Catholic about the crusades, and there is nothing typical Protestant about the objections.
The crusades are COMMON church history. It is as much Catholic church history as it is Protestant church history.

Christendom did take nothing back.
The holy land wasn't a possession of the church and has never been the possession of the church.
For as far as the people in the holy land were concerned, the church was as much a foreign invader as the Muslims.

Neither are the historical records atheist or Protestant.
The most reliable historical records were taken down by the church herself and give us insight of the background on which decisions were made to initiate the first crusade.

I honestly don't know why you are so upset about all this. Church history hasn't always been love and charity...this is just one example.
People were misguided under misguided council by misguided doctrine and through misguided promises.

And lets be honest, the Catholic Church has already apologized for the crusades so I guess some amount of misguidance has already been admitted.

Jerusalem was under Christianity before Islam took it over, by which the Church took back as one of it's actions to help the Byzantine Empire.

What part of "the entire world was governed by religion" does not register? It's like you all see it, but don't actually absorb it. Do you understand the totality of the statement?
Is an atheist or Muslim going to keep Christendom prevalent? No. Is a heretic going to maintain orthodoxy? No. Therefore, the Church did what they had to.

It was not a world of free speech, free gathering, and manifest destiny. That is the pulpit your lot preaches from, and quite frankly, it is extraordinarily ignorant.

That is why I'm upset.
And yes, the Church has nonetheless apologized because she tries to be humble even if what she is humbling herself for is blown completely and unfairly out of proportion.

I don't see protestants apologizing for their witch trials, Genevian trials, and hundreds of other amazingly despicable things they've done throughout their history. Guess I'll just leave it to you to read what the Bible says about demanding something one doesn't practice.

So what you are saying is regardless of the Roman and Byzantine occupation of the holy land, the fact that the emperor was a Christian makes the holy land a "Christian possession"?
Obviously you are mistaken, the holy land was the possession of the people living there, and not the possession of a string of conquerors.
Christianity does not possess countries.

The assistance the church rendered to the Byzantine empire was politically motivated and was given religious content by spiritual misguidance.

That's exactly what the holy lands were- under the possession of Christendom. You can make the difference between political and religious all you want, there was no difference then.

It's called the medieval ages. I know you don't want to accept that fact, it wouldn't have mattered if it was Catholicism, Protestantism, you or me- in those times, crusades were an inevitable part of the world.

Blaming the Church marks you as proverbially ignorant. That is another reason it upsets me- you all think you know everything, think you have it all figured out thinking you can point fingers at people. You live in a liberal age where your 'benevolent' standing is granted. For now, anyway..


This is not about ignorant blaming. This is about what the church was truly to be, and not what it became, which was forced Christianity and territorial possessions. Put the ignorant shoe on the right persons  foot. 


AVZ

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 15:17:16
That's exactly what the holy lands were- under the possession of Christendom. You can make the difference between political and religious all you want, there was no difference then.

It's called the medieval ages. I know you don't want to accept that fact, it wouldn't have mattered if it was Catholicism, Protestantism, you or me- in those times, crusades were an inevitable part of the world.

Blaming the Church marks you as proverbially ignorant. That is another reason it upsets me- you all think you know everything, think you have it all figured out thinking you can point fingers at people. You live in a liberal age where your 'benevolent' standing is granted. For now, anyway..

Look at the header of this thread and tell me how did this whole conquer thing work out?
How many of these nations taken in the name of Christ are Christian today?
All the crusades have contributed to is exactly the opposite of what it set out to achieve.

BlackSepulcher

#86
Quote from: AVZ on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 02:13:01
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 15:17:16
That's exactly what the holy lands were- under the possession of Christendom. You can make the difference between political and religious all you want, there was no difference then.

It's called the medieval ages. I know you don't want to accept that fact, it wouldn't have mattered if it was Catholicism, Protestantism, you or me- in those times, crusades were an inevitable part of the world.

Blaming the Church marks you as proverbially ignorant. That is another reason it upsets me- you all think you know everything, think you have it all figured out thinking you can point fingers at people. You live in a liberal age where your 'benevolent' standing is granted. For now, anyway..

Look at the header of this thread and tell me how did this whole conquer thing work out?
How many of these nations taken in the name of Christ are Christian today?
All the crusades have contributed to is exactly the opposite of what it set out to achieve.


The Church tamed the inevitable, nations were going to duke it out either way- if not for religion then prosperity. Which is another thing you are neglecting- just by the prevalent existence of Christianity itself, the Church has a responsibility that calls for tough and militant decisions. If you can't accept that then all I can say is too bad. No war, including a holy one, promises success.

I think that you need to get away from finding fault and instead look at it more realistically. The fact of the matter is that, whether you realize it or not, your criticism of the Church in this respect is nothing more then an entity conjured from your prejudice of her. 

FireSword

Black, are you in favour of the crusades or against? or are you conflicted, just accepting it as part of history.

BlackSepulcher

Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 08:54:18
Black, are you in favour of the crusades or against? or are you conflicted, just accepting it as part of history.


I am in favor of the crusades because it was necessary. It is far more reasonable then being opposed to them because of certain extremities that took place.



mclees8

#89
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 08:41:21
Quote from: AVZ on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 02:13:01
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Fri Sep 06, 2013 - 15:17:16
That's exactly what the holy lands were- under the possession of Christendom. You can make the difference between political and religious all you want, there was no difference then.

It's called the medieval ages. I know you don't want to accept that fact, it wouldn't have mattered if it was Catholicism, Protestantism, you or me- in those times, crusades were an inevitable part of the world.

Blaming the Church marks you as proverbially ignorant. That is another reason it upsets me- you all think you know everything, think you have it all figured out thinking you can point fingers at people. You live in a liberal age where your 'benevolent' standing is granted. For now, anyway..

Look at the header of this thread and tell me how did this whole conquer thing work out?
How many of these nations taken in the name of Christ are Christian today?
All the crusades have contributed to is exactly the opposite of what it set out to achieve.


The Church tamed the inevitable, nations were going to duke it out either way- if not for religion then prosperity. Which is another thing you are neglecting- just by the prevalent existence of Christianity itself, the Church has a responsibility that calls for tough and militant decisions. If you can't accept that then all I can say is too bad. No war, including a holy one, promises success.

I think that you need to get away from finding fault and instead look at it more realistically. The fact of the matter is that, whether you realize it or not, your criticism of the Church in this respect is nothing more then an entity conjured from your prejudice of her. 


Black you head is in the world and you think like it. You have never grasped Jesus Christ. Before Jesus went to cross the Jews were looking for the Messiah, How ever they wanted Him to be a poltical messiah. Even the apostles wanted this. They would have wanted him to be militant and deliver Israel from Roman control. Even Satan tempted Him saying I will give you the world if he would worship Him. Jesus could have been all that but that was not the purpose of the Father but that he should be crucified for the sins of the world. You now say the church had to be militant fighting with adversaries.   Since when? Did the Lord do that or even instruct His apostles to do that. I pray you go back and reread the gospels with careful prayer  that God would enlighten you that the church was about saving us from sin in our hearts not fighting  militant  adversaries. 


BlackSepulcher

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 11:43:27
You have never grasped Jesus Christ.


The histories of the OT are completely saturated with the Spirit. This includes much of God dishing out wrath through the hands of His people.


The Spirit commences from both the Father and Son, this is what makes the will of God so perfectly orchestrated by both the Old and New Testaments.
Christendom simply imitates the Spirit, that is why there are crusades to go along with peace and love.


See, not only do I grasp Jesus, I grasp the entire Godhead!

Amo

1 And after these things I saw another angel come down from heaven, having great power; and the earth was lightened with his glory. 2 And he cried mightily with a strong voice, saying, Babylon the great is fallen, is fallen, and is become the habitation of devils, and the hold of every foul spirit, and a cage of every unclean and hateful bird. 3 For all nations have drunk of the wine of the wrath of her fornication, and the kings of the earth have committed fornication with her, and the merchants of the earth are waxed rich through the abundance of her delicacies. 4 And I heard another voice from heaven, saying, Come out of her, my people, that ye be not partakers of her sins, and that ye receive not of her plagues. 5 For her sins have reached unto heaven, and God hath remembered her iniquities. 6 Reward her even as she rewarded you, and double unto her double according to her works: in the cup which she hath filled fill to her double. 7 How much she hath glorified herself, and lived deliciously, so much torment and sorrow give her: for she saith in her heart, I sit a queen, and am no widow, and shall see no sorrow. 8 Therefore shall her plagues come in one day, death, and mourning, and famine; and she shall be utterly burned with fire: for strong is the Lord God who judgeth her. 9 And the kings of the earth, who have committed fornication and lived deliciously with her, shall bewail her, and lament for her, when they shall see the smoke of her burning, 10 Standing afar off for the fear of her torment, saying, Alas, alas, that great city Babylon, that mighty city! for in one hour is thy judgment come. 11 And the merchants of the earth shall weep and mourn over her; for no man buyeth their merchandise any more: 12 The merchandise of gold, and silver, and precious stones, and of pearls, and fine linen, and purple, and silk, and scarlet, and all thyine wood, and all manner vessels of ivory, and all manner vessels of most precious wood, and of brass, and iron, and marble, 13 And cinnamon, and odours, and ointments, and frankincense, and wine, and oil, and fine flour, and wheat, and beasts, and sheep, and horses, and chariots, and slaves, and souls of men. 14 And the fruits that thy soul lusted after are departed from thee, and all things which were dainty and goodly are departed from thee, and thou shalt find them no more at all. 15 The merchants of these things, which were made rich by her, shall stand afar off for the fear of her torment, weeping and wailing, 16 And saying, Alas, alas, that great city, that was clothed in fine linen, and purple, and scarlet, and decked with gold, and precious stones, and pearls! 17 For in one hour so great riches is come to nought. And every shipmaster, and all the company in ships, and sailors, and as many as trade by sea, stood afar off, 18 And cried when they saw the smoke of her burning, saying, What city is like unto this great city! 19 And they cast dust on their heads, and cried, weeping and wailing, saying, Alas, alas, that great city, wherein were made rich all that had ships in the sea by reason of her costliness! for in one hour is she made desolate. 20 Rejoice over her, thou heaven, and ye holy apostles and prophets; for God hath avenged you on her. 21 And a mighty angel took up a stone like a great millstone, and cast it into the sea, saying, Thus with violence shall that great city Babylon be thrown down, and shall be found no more at all. 22 And the voice of harpers, and musicians, and of pipers, and trumpeters, shall be heard no more at all in thee; and no craftsman, of whatsoever craft he be, shall be found any more in thee; and the sound of a millstone shall be heard no more at all in thee; 23 And the light of a candle shall shine no more at all in thee; and the voice of the bridegroom and of the bride shall be heard no more at all in thee: for thy merchants were the great men of the earth; for by thy sorceries were all nations deceived. 24 And in her was found the blood of prophets, and of saints, and of all that were slain upon the earth. Rev 18:1-24 (KJV)

mclees8

#92
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 13:02:32
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 11:43:27
You have never grasped Jesus Christ.


The histories of the OT are completely saturated with the Spirit. This includes much of God dishing out wrath through the hands of His people.


The Spirit commences from both the Father and Son, this is what makes the will of God so perfectly orchestrated by both the Old and New Testaments.
Christendom simply imitates the Spirit, that is why there are crusades to go along with peace and love.


See, not only do I grasp Jesus, I grasp the entire Godhead!

No you don't because if you did you know that what I said is true. I'm not second guessing anything. Im not some babe just reading the word for first time without any understanding.


BlackSepulcher

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 20:20:46
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 13:02:32
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 11:43:27
You have never grasped Jesus Christ.


The histories of the OT are completely saturated with the Spirit. This includes much of God dishing out wrath through the hands of His people.


The Spirit commences from both the Father and Son, this is what makes the will of God so perfectly orchestrated by both the Old and New Testaments.
Christendom simply imitates the Spirit, that is why there are crusades to go along with peace and love.


See, not only do I grasp Jesus, I grasp the entire Godhead!

Do you even know what you are talking about. You make blind statements without substance and then say you have it all.  From reading what you just said I have to say more then ever,  No you don't. Please back up these statements because they are just personal assumptions. Especially your first statement. That one really blows with the wind.

My statements are not assumptions, it is a core belief of western Catholicism.

I've given you the keystone to understanding the Catholic philosophy, put so beautifully clear. Until you acknowledge it, you are never going to comprehend what drives the Church to do what it does and has done.

I'm pretty much over the back and forth between my reason and you all's ivory tower. You don't get to make a judgement call about an era you can't even begin to see yourself in, let alone actually have to be responsible for. The most detrimental thing among many Christians today is this new age, moral supremacy gambit. You are no different then an atheist who points at the Bible and calls out all the 'evil' things about God.

mclees8

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 20:44:30
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 20:20:46
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 13:02:32
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 11:43:27
You have never grasped Jesus Christ.

Try making what you said scriptural now.


The histories of the OT are completely saturated with the Spirit. This includes much of God dishing out wrath through the hands of His people.


The Spirit commences from both the Father and Son, this is what makes the will of God so perfectly orchestrated by both the Old and New Testaments.
Christendom simply imitates the Spirit, that is why there are crusades to go along with peace and love.


See, not only do I grasp Jesus, I grasp the entire Godhead!

Do you even know what you are talking about. You make blind statements without substance and then say you have it all.  From reading what you just said I have to say more then ever,  No you don't. Please back up these statements because they are just personal assumptions. Especially your first statement. That one really blows with the wind.

My statements are not assumptions, it is a core belief of western Catholicism.

I've given you the keystone to understanding the Catholic philosophy, put so beautifully clear. Until you acknowledge it, you are never going to comprehend what drives the Church to do what it does and has done.

I'm pretty much over the back and forth between my reason and you all's ivory tower. You don't get to make a judgement call about an era you can't even begin to see yourself in, let alone actually have to be responsible for. The most detrimental thing among many Christians today is this new age, moral supremacy gambit. You are no different then an atheist who points at the Bible and calls out all the 'evil' things about God.

mclees8

Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:26:03
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 20:44:30
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 20:20:46
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 13:02:32
Quote from: mclees8 on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 11:43:27
You have never grasped Jesus Christ.

Try making what you said scriptural now.


The histories of the OT are completely saturated with the Spirit. This includes much of God dishing out wrath through the hands of His people.


The Spirit commences from both the Father and Son, this is what makes the will of God so perfectly orchestrated by both the Old and New Testaments.
Christendom simply imitates the Spirit, that is why there are crusades to go along with peace and love.


See, not only do I grasp Jesus, I grasp the entire Godhead!

Do you even know what you are talking about. You make blind statements without substance and then say you have it all.  From reading what you just said I have to say more then ever,  No you don't. Please back up these statements because they are just personal assumptions. Especially your first statement. That one really blows with the wind.

My statements are not assumptions, it is a core belief of western Catholicism.

I've given you the keystone to understanding the Catholic philosophy, put so beautifully clear. Until you acknowledge it, you are never going to comprehend what drives the Church to do what it does and has done.

I'm pretty much over the back and forth between my reason and you all's ivory tower. You don't get to make a judgement call about an era you can't even begin to see yourself in, let alone actually have to be responsible for. The most detrimental thing among many Christians today is this new age, moral supremacy gambit. You are no different then an atheist who points at the Bible and calls out all the 'evil' things about God.

Try making what you said scriptural now.

FireSword

I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.




BlackSepulcher

Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

AVZ

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

The crusaders were not able to commit crimes.

mclees8

#99
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

Many innocent are caught up in wars. Look at the horror in Syria, And Christians have to fight in wars along side with fellow countrymen. But no Christian leader dictates war nor are generals of them under a Christian flag. The war believers are in we fight everyday are for our souls and against all the whiles of the Satan. We fight  this war on completely different terms.
For the weapons of our warfare are not carnal but mighty unto God to the pulling down of strongholds

FireSword

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

I thought the pope ordered the cathars execution.

BlackSepulcher

#101
Quote from: FireSword on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 10:50:48
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

I thought the pope ordered the cathars execution.

The Cathars were fantastically heretical. They were executed for the same exact reason as other heretics- to prevent thousands of denominations where death ends up occurring anyway.

If you are going to criticize the Church, why not Protestant founders and Puritans, or the whole Christian world before the 18th century for that matter?

Notice that death occurs anyway from dissension. If it's inevitable then one may as well try to maintain orthodoxy. That was the thinking of the medieval Church, your way is simply irresponsible.







FireSword

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 14:43:52
Quote from: FireSword on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 10:50:48
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

I thought the pope ordered the cathars execution.

The Cathars were fantastically heretical. They were executed for the same exact reason as other heretics- to prevent thousands of denominations where death ends up occurring anyway.

If you are going to criticize the Church, why not Protestant founders and Puritans, or the whole Christian world before the 18th century for that matter?

Notice that death occurs anyway from dissension. If it's inevitable then one may as well try to maintain orthodoxy. That was the thinking of the medieval Church, your way is simply irresponsible.

I tend to criticize various doctrines including Protestant, like we all do here.

We are supposed to convert unbelievers through good works etc, or as Paul said cursed is he that preacheth another gospel. So the correct scriptural position would be to reiterate Pauls words, so God can judge those who preach from another counterfeit book.

The executions It was irresponsible of the pope and it is actions like these that destroyed the credibility of the RCC, and even of the Christian faith, all those good works of charity, endurance and love marred by these type of murders.

I'm trying to figure out why did the RCC, now changed their policy and no longer executes those who preach a counterfeit gospel, did they believe the pope to be in error?





mclees8

Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 14:43:52
Quote from: FireSword on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 10:50:48
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

I thought the pope ordered the cathars execution.

The Cathars were fantastically heretical. They were executed for the same exact reason as other heretics- to prevent thousands of denominations where death ends up occurring anyway.

If you are going to criticize the Church, why not Protestant founders and Puritans, or the whole Christian world before the 18th century for that matter?

Notice that death occurs anyway from dissension. If it's inevitable then one may as well try to maintain orthodoxy. That was the thinking of the medieval Church, your way is simply irresponsible.








So the church goes from the executed to the executioner. Tell me did the early church fathers do that. Do you believe Jesus advocated being judge jury and executioner of anyone. Do you think that now. Thank God we don't have you as a pope.  God help us!

BlackSepulcher

#104
Quote from: FireSword on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 15:18:57
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 14:43:52
Quote from: FireSword on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 10:50:48
Quote from: BlackSepulcher on Sun Sep 08, 2013 - 07:48:57
Quote from: FireSword on Sat Sep 07, 2013 - 21:35:31
I'm not totally against crusades, but the targets they attacked were wrong. They went after believers, such as cathars, who were a weak force, not a threat.

There hasn't been a war in this wide world that has gone without those type of things happening. Even in the Iraqi War, soldiers had been known to shoot at mosques and kill people on mere suspicion.

There's nothing new under the sun, as Solomon said. The Church condemned the Templar Knights with war crimes- the crimes you put on the Church. At least they were willing to see error- I don't see any American troops in prison for their transgressions.

I thought the pope ordered the cathars execution.

The Cathars were fantastically heretical. They were executed for the same exact reason as other heretics- to prevent thousands of denominations where death ends up occurring anyway.

If you are going to criticize the Church, why not Protestant founders and Puritans, or the whole Christian world before the 18th century for that matter?

Notice that death occurs anyway from dissension. If it's inevitable then one may as well try to maintain orthodoxy. That was the thinking of the medieval Church, your way is simply irresponsible.

I tend to criticize various doctrines including Protestant, like we all do here.

We are supposed to convert unbelievers through good works etc, or as Paul said cursed is he that preacheth another gospel. So the correct scriptural position would be to reiterate Pauls words, so God can judge those who preach from another counterfeit book.

The executions It was irresponsible of the pope and it is actions like these that destroyed the credibility of the RCC, and even of the Christian faith, all those good works of charity, endurance and love marred by these type of murders.

I'm trying to figure out why did the RCC, now changed their policy and no longer executes those who preach a counterfeit gospel, did they believe the pope to be in error?

The Church tried to maintain orthodoxy, and it failed. What more can be said other then there's a first time for everything; they thought they could succeed. The problem with how non-Catholics go about it is that their argument is pretty much this:
"the Church is evil because of it's theology, and the Church is evil because she became violent against the dissent from such theology".

That's an attempt to mark a church for death as far as the archaic view goes. Literally, in fact- I've mentioned several times that it was a world ruled by religion, and there is no exaggeration in that period- it's just a fact.

And because it is a fact, the Church was tied to the same paradigm of getting things done. The reason the Church has changed today is because the world is no longer in that paradigm, it's as simple as a new key for a new lock.










+-Recent Topics

American Socialism? by 4WD
Today at 11:38:36

"Church Fathers" Scriptural or Not by pppp
Today at 11:12:21

John 6:50-71 , Living Bread by pppp
Today at 08:55:01

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Yesterday at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Yesterday at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Yesterday at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Tue Nov 17, 2026 - 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

Powered by EzPortal