News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898063
Total Topics: 90355
Most Online Today: 5032
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 2
Guests: 4270
Total: 4272

Catholics Do Not Worship Idols .

Started by Paulus, Sat Oct 25, 2014 - 08:39:43

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

kensington

As a person who was raised Catholic, but am a non-practicing Catholic now, it amazes me how some Protestants drum up this "Catholics worship statues" drama. As I have told a few, to me, having statues of Mary and Joseph and other figures from the Christian religion in church is no different than going to Washington, D.C. and seeing statues of our nations leaders and heros from the past.  During mass, Catholics occasionally glance at these statues, but nothing more.

Some Protestants simply enjoy being divisive, which certainly is going against the spirit of being Christ-like.


This is not true.  My sil is part of a group who worship Mary.  They have a statue of Mary in a 2ft glass case, and it travels each month to the home of a different member, and they meet once a week for prayer and worship.  They all get on their knees and pray before the statute together as a group.  They have the statue on an altar that the current host has prepared with a table, scarves, and candles.  They PRAY to that statue.

Also, when she got married, during the mass....  the priest stopped and informed the people that the couple were going to give a gift to Mary and seek her blessing to have children. They walked hand in hand over to a huge statue of Mary, laid roses at the feet, bowed their heads and prayed together to Mary for Children while we watched.

Occasional glance?  I think not.   ::frown::

Ladonia

Skeeter, so if you were raised Catholic then you know that no Catholic is EVER, EVER instructed to worship any statue as a deity. Never, ever, is this done and you darn well know it.

skeeter

Quote from: Ladonia on Tue Oct 28, 2014 - 18:35:21
Skeeter, so if you were raised Catholic then you know that no Catholic is EVER, EVER instructed to worship any statue as a deity. Never, ever, is this done and you darn well know it.
do you pray to Mary? the saints? light a candle before the statue? kneel before it?

do you consider Mary partly responsible for your salvation? (part Savior)

do you think she is sinless?  omnipotent?  ever virgin?

We were taught to pray to Mary and the saints - and to believe that they could answer our prayers.  A lot of time, prayer and singing revolved around Mary and the saints. 


kensington

My sil calls Mary "Co-Redeemer"... pure nonsense.

skeeter

Quote from: kensington on Tue Oct 28, 2014 - 22:45:58
My sil calls Mary "Co-Redeemer"... pure nonsense.

yep. I've read it on a number of Catholic sites.  That we weren't taught in school.  I was shocked to read what I have been recently - the way they talk about Mary - and the pope.  That belief in him and what he says (and Mary as co-redeemer) are required to be saved.  hogwash!  Most people know nothing about either of them when they get saved anyway.  I believe the pope exists, is a  human male and lives in Rome - not much else.   I put him to the side around jr-hi age and I was still Catholic then.   He doesn't get my time,  Jesus  does along with the word of God.  Jesus is our only connection to God.  He is the ONLY way.


kensington

yep. I've read it on a number of Catholic sites.  That we weren't taught in school.  I was shocked to read what I have been recently - the way they talk about Mary - and the pope.  That belief in him and what he says (and Mary as co-redeemer) are required to be saved.  hogwash!  Most people know nothing about either of them when they get saved anyway.  I believe the pope exists, is a  human male and lives in Rome - not much else.   I put him to the side around jr-hi age and I was still Catholic then.   He doesn't get my time,  Jesus  does along with the word of God.  Jesus is our only connection to God.  He is the ONLY way.

LOL, indeed.  When my sil told me Mary was "Co-Redeemer", part of the God head. Like 4th in the "Father, Son, Holy Spirit", seated with God in Heaven.  I said she wasn't,  That she was not Co-Redeemer with Jesus and that Jesus was seated at the right hand of the Father, and she declared I was speaking blasphemy.

I told her... "Get away from me girl, you're nuts"...

Paulus

Again I thank God that the few anti-Catholic Protestants who insult and scoff on here are not like the Protestants I know .

::announcment:: Anyone who reads this forum please do not take the anti-Catholicism you see here as being representative of Protestants .

Ladonia

#77
Skeeter: do you pray to Mary? the saints? light a candle before the statue? kneel before it?

Yes, I pray the rosary every once in a while which is a great meditation on the highlights of Jesus's ministerial life, fully 95% about Him, not her. As for statues, I am not really big on them. I have no problem with lighting a candle as part of prayer which symbolizes the light of the world that is Jesus Christ. And yes, when I pray I do kneel which shows my respect and subservience to God, our Father in heaven.

Skeeter: do you consider Mary partly responsible for your salvation?
(part Savior)


Definitely not part Savior, but she had a very important part in the salvation story.

Skeeter: do you think she is sinless?  omnipotent?  ever virgin?

Sinless? I accept the Church's teaching on this. Omnipotent? This is the first time I have ever heard the Blessed Mother called such. Ever virgin? Possible. I mean really, the Scriptures say she became impregnated not knowing man in the first place. But really, I do not have a big Marion devotion.

Skeeter: We were taught to pray to Mary and the saints - and to believe that they could answer our prayers.  A lot of time, prayer and singing revolved around Mary and the saints.

I believe the Church's teaching on the intercession of the saints. Funny how we have had such a different experience as to being Catholic. While Mary was definitely mentioned, most of my memories as a young lad are of Jesus, Jesus, Jesus.  Whether it was receiving him via the Holy Eucharist, his coming into the world as our Savior, his death and resurrection, or living out the sacramental life - it was, and still is mostly about Jesus.

Ladonia


Kensington said: Also, when she got married, during the mass....  the priest stopped and informed the people that the couple were going to give a gift to Mary and seek her blessing to have children. They walked hand in hand over to a huge statue of Mary, laid roses at the feet, bowed their heads and prayed together to Mary for Children while we watched.

Sometimes I think you are making things up. I have been Catholic all my life, been to countless Catholic weddings and have never heard or seen such a thing. I mean really, the priest stopping Mass and all that?

But if true, like in all things some people go overboard on certain aspects of things and yes, some Catholics do go overboard on Marion devotions. 

skeeter

Quote from: Paulus on Wed Oct 29, 2014 - 03:00:53
Again I thank God that the few anti-Catholic Protestants who insult and scoff on here are not like the Protestants I know .

::announcment:: Anyone who reads this forum please do not take the anti-Catholicism you see here as being representative of Protestants .
I think anyone reading here will note the Catholics anti-protestant view...
and that you don't know who IS a Protestant and who isn't.

skeeter

Quote from: Ladonia on Wed Oct 29, 2014 - 10:43:15

Kensington said: Also, when she got married, during the mass....  the priest stopped and informed the people that the couple were going to give a gift to Mary and seek her blessing to have children. They walked hand in hand over to a huge statue of Mary, laid roses at the feet, bowed their heads and prayed together to Mary for Children while we watched.

Sometimes I think you are making things up. I have been Catholic all my life, been to countless Catholic weddings and have never heard or seen such a thing. I mean really, the priest stopping Mass and all that?

But if true, like in all things some people go overboard on certain aspects of things and yes, some Catholics do go overboard on Marion devotions.
growing up I sang in the choir - that included weddings.  What Kensington posted does not surprise me one bit.

what does the CCC say about the Marion doctrine / dogma?  From what I've read it was a pope who claimed her as co-savior.


Ladonia

Skeeter said: growing up I sang in the choir - that included weddings.  What Kensington posted does not surprise me one bit.

Okay, so tell us, how many times did you see such a thing?

winsome

 Co-Redeemer

There is a group in the Catholic Church that is pushing to have Mary given the title Co-redemptrix (not Co-redeemer). This has not been accepted by the Vatican.

On another forum some years ago someone posted a reply from the Vatican on this issue and pointed them to an article (Declaration of the Theological Commission of the Pontifical International Marian Academy) in the English edition of L' Observatore Romano on 4 June 1997.

This is the extract from that article he typed out:

1. The titles, as proposed, are ambiguous, as they can be understood in very different ways. Furthermore, the theological direction taken by the Second Vatican Council, which did not wish to define any of these titles, should not be abandoned. The Second Vatican Council did not used the title "Coredemptrix" and uses "Mediatrix" and "Advocate" in a very moderate way (cf Lumen gentium, n. 62).... (snip) : In the first decades of this century the Holy See entrusted the possibility of its definition to three different commissions, the result of which was that the Holy See decided to set the question aside.

2. Even if the titles were assigned a content which could be accepted as belonging to the deposit of the faith, the definition of these titles, however, in the present situation would be lacking in theological clarity, as such titles and the doctrines inherent in them still require further study in a renewed Trinitarian, ecclesiastical and anthropological perspective. Finally, the theologians, especially the non-Catholics, were sensitive to the ecumenical difficulties which would be involved in such a definition.

 
In other words the Church has not given the title Co-redemptrix (much less co-redeemer) to Mary.

Paulus

Is this another one of those image-less , statue-less , icon-less , plain , simple and unadorned Protestant churches ?  ???

Well , not really . But it's a Protestant church .  ::crackup::

Beautiful Church Dome of Dresden Frauenkirche

Star of David

kensington, the Catholic church does not believe that Mary is a part of the Godhead.  They just give her the greatest honor of all of God's creatures.

Please do a little more careful checking of your facts.

kensington

#85
Sometimes I think you are making things up. I have been Catholic all my life, been to countless Catholic weddings and have never heard or seen such a thing. I mean really, the priest stopping Mass and all that?

Stop the mass/ceremony... whatever it was.  I've seen it twice.  But, that was the first time for sure.  No one in the crowd seems shocked by it. My husband did the reading of Corinthians on Love, it was right after that.  I was sitting on the second row.  I saw it.  I'd ask to borrow the picture out of the wedding album to show you, but considering what my motives would be, that wouldn't be right.

Why do Catholics even ask Mary to bless them with Children?  She can't do that. 

kensington

kensington, the Catholic church does not believe that Mary is a part of the Godhead.  They just give her the greatest honor of all of God's creatures.

Please do a little more careful checking of your facts.


LOL... I do not have to check the facts on what someone said directly to me in conversation.  Or on what I have seen with my own eyes. 


Star of David

kensington, the Catholic church does not believe that Mary is a part of the Godhead.  They just give her the greatest honor of all of God's creatures.

Please do a little more careful checking of your facts.

LOL... I do not have to check the facts on what someone said directly to me in conversation.  Or on what I have seen with my own eyes. 

           *******************************************************

My goodness, kensington, you are certainly thin-skinned.

To give serious thought to such a comment from someone is like accepting something that you read on the Internet.

Only consider what the Catholic church actually believes, not quoting some Catholic person who doesn't know what they're talking about.


Catholica

Quote from: kensington on Wed Oct 29, 2014 - 16:11:18
kensington, the Catholic church does not believe that Mary is a part of the Godhead.  They just give her the greatest honor of all of God's creatures.

Please do a little more careful checking of your facts.


LOL... I do not have to check the facts on what someone said directly to me in conversation.  Or on what I have seen with my own eyes.

What exactly did your sister in law say?  Did she say that Mary was Co-redemptrix, did she say that Mary was part of the Godhead, both, or did you just make the presumption that as Co-redemptrix someone must be part of the Godhead?  Only the part that Mary is Co-redemptrix was in quotes, so it seems that that is the only part that she actually said.

winsome


Star of David,

kensington is not interested in facts - just in giving her opinions.

Just look at her posts in this thread!

You'll get used to it.

Star of David

#90
Star of David,

kensington is not interested in facts - just in giving her opinions.

Just look at her posts in this thread!

You'll get used to it.

            **************************************

Yes, winsome, kensington and I got into quite a "tussle" long ago about the actual unfolding of the End Times (if my memory serves me correctly).  But expressing one's opinion is what these boards are all about.

I made the final conclusion back in 1992 that Christ's statements recorded in Luke 21:25a & Matthew 24:29-30a are effectively blacked out in the Bibles owned by Christian non-astronomers, whereas in the Bibles owned by Christian astronomers, particularly at this juncture in time, these same statements by Christ in Luke 21:25a & Matthew 24:29-30a are highlighted in bold type.



winsome

Star of David,

kensington is not interested in facts - just in giving her opinions.

Just look at her posts in this thread!

You'll get used to it.


            **************************************

Yes, winsome, kensington and I got into quite a "tussle" long ago about the actual unfolding of the End Times (if my memory serves me correctly).  But expressing one's opinion is what these boards are all about.

I made the final conclusion back in 1992 that Christ's statements recorded in Luke 21:25a & Matthew 24:29-30a are effectively blacked out in the Bibles owned by Christian non-astronomers, whereas in the Bibles owned by Christian astronomers, particularly at this juncture in time, these same statements by Christ in Luke 21:25a & Matthew 24:29-30a are highlighted in bold type.


Opinions are supposed to be backed up by evidence according to Forum Rule 1.3 if they involve negative opinions about a persons beliefs or religious organisation.

Star of David

Opinions are supposed to be backed up by evidence according to Forum Rule 1.3 if they involve negative opinions about a persons beliefs or religious organisation.

              ************************************************


Evidence?

That's a slippery slope when it comes to matters of religion and spirituality.

kensington can say that what she heard from her Catholic sister-in-law(?) about Mary being a part of the Godhead as being her "evidence" presented here.



kensington

#93
What exactly did your sister in law say?  Did she say that Mary was Co-redemptrix, did she say that Mary was part of the Godhead, both, or did you just make the presumption that as Co-redemptrix someone must be part of the Godhead?  Only the part that Mary is Co-redemptrix was in quotes, so it seems that that is the only part that she actually said.

She said Mary is "Co-redeemer" with Jesus Christ.  And that she is equal with Him in Heaven, seated next to God.  Co-Redeemer is the term she used.  I was not on any websites at the time, and I had no idea what she was talking about, but I do remember the conversation as it got very heated.  She claimed Mary equal to Jesus in Heaven seated on the throne with God as queen also. 

And when I said it was not true, Mary was NOT co-redeemer, nor was she equal with Christ or sitting on the throne with God as Queen, she got very upset, she took it personally, and accused me of "Blasphemy" just like I told you. 

She is devout Catholic, never misses mass, teaches the Catechism, baptism classes and music at the Catholic school.  I can only assume she believes Mary has done more for her than Christ.  As when you go into her home, there is a statue of Mary in every room... two in the living room.  And only one picture of Christ in the whole home. And it's a big house.  She now has my husband's cousin worshipping Mary, she is on pinterest every day pinning picture after picture of Mary. She sees her in the trees and believes that one statue she took a picture of had a living womb in it.  (she believes that the Holy Spirit is in the statue keeping Mary's womb alive) Because she saw a white dot on the screen when she took the picture.  It's nuts.

I'm not going to apologize for seeing what they say and do for what it is.  I have asked on here before,  if this is not what your religion is teaching, believing or doing..., WHY are you not speaking to those who are and calling them out of Mary worship? 

IF you think I am making it up... it's nothing to me.  I have more stories I could tell of my personal witness to this nonsense.  I've been married to my husband for almost 29 years. I've seen a lot of things Catholics do. 

kensington

BTW...  Last year, the cousin found some fabric with pictures of Mary all over it. I'm a quilter... and she sent me a picture and asked if I would make the two of them purses out of the Mary fabric.  I was polite, but I said no. 

skeeter

Quote from: Paulus on Wed Oct 29, 2014 - 12:34:22
Is this another one of those image-less , statue-less , icon-less , plain , simple and unadorned Protestant churches ? 

Well , not really . But it's a Protestant church . 
it's a Lutheran church in Germany.  That's in Europe...

does it rival St Peter's?

skeeter

Quote from: winsome on Wed Oct 29, 2014 - 16:50:37
Opinions are supposed to be backed up by evidence according to Forum Rule 1.3 if they involve negative opinions about a persons beliefs or religious organisation.

I've never seen any supporting 'evidence' posted when Catholics claim that there are anywhere from 20-50,000 different protestant  denominations...

kensington

I've never seen any supporting 'evidence' posted when Catholics claim that there are anywhere from 20-50,000 different protestant  denominations...


There have been a lot of things said about Protestant's by Catholics in these discussions that are not backed up by sources or facts.  ::juggle::





kensington

Another true story...  (if you have been here a while, you may have seen me post about this before)... 

When our son was born, the two of us being non Catholic, we do not infant baptize.  So, when our son was about a year old, my sil had a son.  After a few weeks she called to tell us, she had made arrangements with her priest to baptize our son during mass the week we would be home on vacation.

Oh yes she did, make arrangements with a priest to baptize our son without talking to us first.  I think that was the straw for my husband, he would not even discuss the CC with her again after that.  Not for decades.  And then, she started sending him "saint" medals.  I won't even get into that in this post.


skeeter

Quote from: Ladonia on Wed Oct 29, 2014 - 12:25:01
Skeeter said: growing up I sang in the choir - that included weddings.  What Kensington posted does not surprise me one bit.

Okay, so tell us, how many times did you see such a thing?

not to over guesstimate the #, I'd say a good half of them (at least). I was in the choir for 4 yrs, lots of weddings from April thru August - probably at least 1 a Saturday.  And there would be a sprinkling from Sept - March. 

The couple would make a trip to the right side of the altar (it was a bit 'out' from the regular altar (closer to the pews)), put flowers at the feet of 'Mary', light a candle in front of 'her' and kneel down in front of 'her' for a couple of minutes. 

I couldn't hear what they said while there but their heads were bowed.  The choir was in the balcony at the back of the church.  We looked down onto them.

Look-up

Just read through this thread and I like how the RCC seeks for evidence (well done) and when the Protestant supplies it we have "you don't know what your talking about".  Amo put up some great you-tubes showing clearly the RCC are entrenched in idolatry. 

Rachel stole the household idols and if any of you RCC members are anything like the homes I have been in their homes are full of idols.

The definition is a statue made with hands.

Does Catholicism have statues made with hands?

I liken it to angels needing wings!  But hey, if you are a Roman citizen you do whatever Caesar decrees.

Look-up

winsome

Opinions are supposed to be backed up by evidence according to Forum Rule 1.3 if they involve negative opinions about a persons beliefs or religious organisation.

              ************************************************


Evidence?

That's a slippery slope when it comes to matters of religion and spirituality.

kensington can say that what she heard from her Catholic sister-in-law(?) about Mary being a part of the Godhead as being her "evidence" presented here.




It's a forum  rule to provide evidence so it should be done.

The quality of evidence is another matter. When it comes to claims against the Catholic Church I would expect documentary evidence from authoritative sources not some tittle tattle and "a catholic said to me".

Sweeping statements are made in this forum by anti-catholics who seem to think that their opinions are evidence enough.

winsome

Just read through this thread and I like how the RCC seeks for evidence (well done) and when the Protestant supplies it we have "you don't know what your talking about".  Amo put up some great you-tubes showing clearly the RCC are entrenched in idolatry.

Amo put up a series of video and when I asked what the point was I got no reply from Amo.

They didn't show the Catholic Church was entrenched in idolatry



Rachel stole the household idols and if any of you RCC members are anything like the homes I have been in their homes are full of idols.

The definition is a statue made with hands.


No it is not.Idols are images that are worshipped.

idol
n    noun
1    an image or representation of a god used as an object of worship.

(Concise Oxford English Dictionary)

Do you notice I gave some evidence of my claim that idols are images that are worshipped. You just stated your opinion



Does Catholicism have statues made with hands?

Yes, but they are not idols. They are not worshipped



I liken it to angels needing wings!  But hey, if you are a Roman citizen you do whatever Caesar decrees.

Look-up

What is that supposed to mean? Anything?

AVZ

Quote from: winsome on Thu Oct 30, 2014 - 03:02:07
Opinions are supposed to be backed up by evidence according to Forum Rule 1.3 if they involve negative opinions about a persons beliefs or religious organisation.

              ************************************************


Evidence?

That's a slippery slope when it comes to matters of religion and spirituality.

kensington can say that what she heard from her Catholic sister-in-law(?) about Mary being a part of the Godhead as being her "evidence" presented here.




It's a forum  rule to provide evidence so it should be done.

The quality of evidence is another matter. When it comes to claims against the Catholic Church I would expect documentary evidence from authoritative sources not some tittle tattle and "a catholic said to me".

Sweeping statements are made in this forum by anti-catholics who seem to think that their opinions are evidence enough.

Would the Bible be enough authoritative for you?
Because up to now I have not seen any Catholic posting scripture that condones what you do.
All we have so far is "we can prostrate in front of a stature and pray to it because the church says so"

winsome

Would the Bible be enough authoritative for you?
Because up to now I have not seen any Catholic posting scripture that condones what you do.
All we have so far is "we can prostrate in front of a stature and pray to it because the church says so"


Then you haven't been reading the posts on this and the other thread discussing the same issue.

+-Recent Topics

American Socialism? by Texas Conservative
Today at 20:15:28

Lamentations 3:40 by pppp
Today at 13:24:52

Psalm 30:4 by pppp
Today at 13:09:23

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Today at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Today at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Yesterday at 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

Powered by EzPortal