News:

Buy things on Amazon? Please go to gracecentered.com/amazon FIRST and we'll earn a commission from your order!

Main Menu
+-+-

+-User

Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
 
 
 
Forgot your password?

+-Stats ezBlock

Members
Total Members: 89501
Latest: Reirric
New This Month: 0
New This Week: 0
New Today: 0
Stats
Total Posts: 898057
Total Topics: 90354
Most Online Today: 4569
Most Online Ever: 31148
(Tue Oct 13, 2026 - 23:44:57)
Users Online
Members: 1
Guests: 3618
Total: 3619
4WD
Google (2)

Catholics praying to people they think are in heaven.

Started by cs80918, Thu Jun 24, 2010 - 23:10:17

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Amo

QuoteI've debated more than my fair share of pretty smart SDAs and I know their positions pretty well. I know Mi-cha-el does in fact translate to "him who is like God" and there are singular texts that say there are none like unto God but that is a fair stretch to call the Son of God's "purest form in Heaven"( quote from an old debate a few years back) a mere archangel.

No SDA believes Christ to be just an angel, or even an angel at all.  If they did, and promulgated this view, they would be asked to disconnect themselves from the denomination.  I assure you, that the quotes from EGW above are taken out of context, or twisted in such a manner to make it appear she believed Christ was just an angel.  As soon as I have time I will prove it. 

Amo



Quote"SDA teaches that Jesus is Michael the Archangel, but Ellen G. White said He was Michael, so if they changed this, they'd need to reject her as "the spirit of prophecy" and they'd not be the remnant church!  So now they hold He's both God the Son, and Michael.  In fact, Ellen G. White DENIED the deity of Jesus, who in 1903 said, "The man Christ Jesus was not the Lord God Almighty

Amo

QuoteRecounting her vision of December, 1844, Ellen speaks of her and Jesus as "In a moment we were winging our way upward..." Seeing this, in the light of her calling Him "Michael the Archangel" (Desire of Ages pp. 99, 379; Spiritual Gifts Vol. 1, p. 158; Prophets & Kings p. 572) one is led to question if she did not, in fact, really view Him as just that—an angel! And if so, what of His deity and bodily resurrection?

To make these aberrant views appear as Biblical, the SDA's 1994 Clear Word Bible has changed the text to make Jesus Michael the Archangel in 1st Thessalonians 4:16; Revelation 12:7 and Jude 9; and to make Him to be a mighty angel in Revelation 10:1,5,8 & 10.  This is because in her comments on Revelation chapters 1, 8, and 10, Ellen White identified these angels in Revelation as also being Jesus Christ! (SDA Commentary VII, 971+978; ms15, 1897; ms 59).

Dr. Walter Martin, in his book The Kingdom of the Cults, wrongfully labels SDA's as a "Christian cult," on the assumption that they believe in Jesus' deity.  Clearly, something is very wrong with the SDA view of Jesus, and His deity.  By lowering Jesus to the level of Michael, an archangel, they have perverted Christ's deity.  It is clear that SDA's employ double-talk.  They talk-out-of-both-sides-of-their-mouth.  On one hand they promote Ellen G. White as the "Spirit of Prophecy," who openly denied that Jesus is Almighty God; but on the other hand they claim to believe in the deity of Christ.  It is important to understand that JW's also believe in the deity of Christ, i.e., that He is God, but they DENY that He is ALMIGHTY God.  In Revelation 1:8 Jesus claims to be "The Almighty."  In Isaiah 9:6 Jesus is called "The Mighty God" (King James Bible).  SDA's are liars, as was Ellen Gould White.  However, SDA's in contrast to JW's, do believe in the Godhead.  This fact confuses many people, misleading them to think that SDA's are Christians; BUT, they certainly are not.  The Jesus of SDA is Michael; the Jesus taught in the Scriptures is NOT!  To teach that Michael is Jesus clearly has negative IMPLICATIONS, and creates a host of doctrinal problems for SDA's to counter. "

The above is nothing bu the stretch of ones imagination, who is determined to make out EGW and the SDA Church to believe something we do not believe.  The following quotes from EGW, should be sufficient to settle the issue. 

Christ Man's Surety.—Not one of the angels could have become surety for the human race: their life is God's; they could not surrender it. The angels all wear the yoke of obedience. They are the appointed messengers of Him who is the Commander of all heaven. But Christ is equal with God, infinite and omnipotent. He could pay the ransom for man's freedom. He is the eternal self-existing Son, on whom no yoke had come; and when God asked, "Whom shall I send?

winsome

The following is taken from the theotokos.co.za web site:


The Seventh-day Adventist church was among these groups claiming spiritual allegiance with peculiar sects of the past, with their prophet making pronouncements on this matter as follows:

The gospel had been planted in Bohemia as early as the ninth century. The Bible was translated, and public worship was conducted, in the language of the people. ... Heaven had provided other agencies for the preservation of the church. Many of the Waldenses and Albigenses, driven by persecution from their homes in France and Italy, came to Bohemia. Though they dared not teach openly, they labored zealously in secret. Thus the true faith was preserved from century to century.
                    -- Ellen White, Great Controversy, Chapter 6, paragraph 1, p97.

Century after century the blood of the saints had been shed. While the Waldenses laid down their lives upon the mountains of Piedmont "for the word of God, and for the testimony of Jesus Christ," similar witness to the truth had been borne by their brethren, the Albigenses of France.
                    -- Ellen White, Great Controversy, Ch 15, p271.


Recently, the Adventist Review came out with a statement that is an indirect contradiction of those words, words which many Adventists believe to be inspired.  In an article by Ed Christian entitled "One Person's Heretic Is the Next Person's Martyr," there is a plain admission as to the beliefs and practices of the Albigensians.  He says:

I know people who, because of a few comments in Ellen White's book The Great Controversy, have a great fondness for the Albigensians (or Cathars), who were also considered heretics. Many were killed for their faith. These Cathars were very different from the Waldensians. They believed that Jesus was an angel, denied Jesus was really a man who died and was resurrected, and believed the Old Testament came from Satan. They discouraged marriage. They were in their day what David Koresh's Branch Davidians are in ours. Were they heretics or martyrs? Could they be both?
                    -- Adventist Review, Nov 20, 2003 - http://adventistreview.org/2003-1547/story4.html


It must be somewhat embarrassing to have a prophet who claims that people with such beliefs were the true Christians preserving the true faith.  What does that say about her theology?  And her status as prophet?

Amo

QuoteThe following is taken from the theotokos.co.za web site:


The Seventh-day Adventist church was among these groups claiming spiritual allegiance with peculiar sects of the past, with their prophet making pronouncements on this matter as follows:

The gospel had been planted in Bohemia as early as the ninth century. The Bible was translated, and public worship was conducted, in the language of the people. ... Heaven had provided other agencies for the preservation of the church. Many of the Waldenses and Albigenses, driven by persecution from their homes in France and Italy, came to Bohemia. Though they dared not teach openly, they labored zealously in secret. Thus the true faith was preserved from century to century.
                    -- Ellen White, Great Controversy, Chapter 6, paragraph 1, p97.

Century after century the blood of the saints had been shed. While the Waldenses laid down their lives upon the mountains of Piedmont "for the word of God, and for the testimony of Jesus Christ," similar witness to the truth had been borne by their brethren, the Albigenses of France.
                    -- Ellen White, Great Controversy, Ch 15, p271.

Recently, the Adventist Review came out with a statement that is an indirect contradiction of those words, words which many Adventists believe to be inspired.  In an article by Ed Christian entitled "One Person's Heretic Is the Next Person's Martyr," there is a plain admission as to the beliefs and practices of the Albigensians.  He says:

I know people who, because of a few comments in Ellen White's book The Great Controversy, have a great fondness for the Albigensians (or Cathars), who were also considered heretics. Many were killed for their faith. These Cathars were very different from the Waldensians. They believed that Jesus was an angel, denied Jesus was really a man who died and was resurrected, and believed the Old Testament came from Satan. They discouraged marriage. They were in their day what David Koresh's Branch Davidians are in ours. Were they heretics or martyrs? Could they be both?
                    -- Adventist Review, Nov 20, 2003 - http://adventistreview.org/2003-1547/story4.html

It must be somewhat embarrassing to have a prophet who claims that people with such beliefs were the true Christians preserving the true faith.  What does that say about her theology?  And her status as prophet?

Just because somebody wrote an article in the review, doesn't mean he knows what he is talking about.  I take odds with his conclusions.  He is not well read on the subject, and I intend to write a letter to the Review about it.  My next post has several quotes which contradict his statement.  The issue is as usual complicated by the many different versions of history existing between Roman Catholic, and Protestant historians, not to mention secular humanist ones as well.

Amo

MILLER'S CHURCH HISTORY
by Andrew Miller


VAUDOIS, ALBIGENSES, WALDENSES
4. The origin of the Western sectaries, so-called, under the common name
of Waldenses, has been the subject of much controversy. One class of
writers, favorable to Romanism, with the view of involving them in the
common charge of Manicheism, have endeavored to prove that their
opinions were of Eastern, or Paulician origin; while the opposite party
affirm that they were free from the Manicheart error, and that they have
been the inheritors and maintainers, from father to son, of a pure and
scriptural Christianity, from the time of Constantine, if not from the days
of the apostles.2
But as it is not so much our object at present to trace the history of these
ancient, simple, and devoted christian people, as to bring out another
feature of the papacy under Innocent, in its most fully expressed
blasphemy and cruelty; we will merely satisfy the reader as to who these
people were, and as to the scene of their slaughter. "The terms,

winsome

Quote from: Amo on Mon Jul 05, 2010 - 20:09:17
Just because somebody wrote an article in the review, doesn't mean he knows what he is talking about. 

Just remember that next time you quote some obscure Catholic or Catholic publication claiming it is the teaching of the Catholic Church.

Macrina

Quote from: Amo on Mon Jul 05, 2010 - 20:25:01
MILLER'S CHURCH HISTORY
by Andrew Miller


VAUDOIS, ALBIGENSES, WALDENSES
4. The origin of the Western sectaries, so-called, under the common name
of Waldenses, has been the subject of much controversy. One class of
writers, favorable to Romanism, with the view of involving them in the
common charge of Manicheism, have endeavored to prove that their
opinions were of Eastern, or Paulician origin; while the opposite party
affirm that they were free from the Manicheart error, and that they have
been the inheritors and maintainers, from father to son, of a pure and
scriptural Christianity, from the time of Constantine, if not from the days
of the apostles.2
But as it is not so much our object at present to trace the history of these
ancient, simple, and devoted christian people, as to bring out another
feature of the papacy under Innocent, in its most fully expressed
blasphemy and cruelty; we will merely satisfy the reader as to who these
people were, and as to the scene of their slaughter. "The terms,

winsome

Quote from: Macrina on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 11:42:09
What is that big block post about?

I'ts one of Amo's favourite ways of posting. He can't express his own thoughts so he posts great block of someone else's.

I'm not sure whether it is laziness, or he's trying to intimidate you, or he hopes to tie you up for hours trying to understand and reply to it.

Amo

QuoteI'ts one of Amo's favourite ways of posting. He can't express his own thoughts so he posts great block of someone else's.

I'm not sure whether it is laziness, or he's trying to intimidate you, or he hopes to tie you up for hours trying to understand and reply to it.

Winsome knows exactly what they are about.  He made a false statement regarding someones apparent ignorance relating to history.  The quotes I listed contradict that statement. 

LightHammer

Quote from: Amo on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 18:12:14
QuoteI'ts one of Amo's favourite ways of posting. He can't express his own thoughts so he posts great block of someone else's.

I'm not sure whether it is laziness, or he's trying to intimidate you, or he hopes to tie you up for hours trying to understand and reply to it.

Winsome knows exactly what they are about.  He made a false statement regarding someones apparent ignorance relating to history.  The quotes I listed contradict that statement. 

That maybe true but, without agreeing too much with the paranoid catholics, maybe you should try to condense your posts down to more specific piece. The way you do it makes it look like you're simply taking the ideas of others.

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 21:47:34
Quote from: Amo on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 18:12:14
QuoteI'ts one of Amo's favourite ways of posting. He can't express his own thoughts so he posts great block of someone else's.

I'm not sure whether it is laziness, or he's trying to intimidate you, or he hopes to tie you up for hours trying to understand and reply to it.

Winsome knows exactly what they are about.  He made a false statement regarding someones apparent ignorance relating to history.  The quotes I listed contradict that statement. 

That maybe true but, without agreeing too much with the paranoid catholics, maybe you should try to condense your posts down to more specific piece. The way you do it makes it look like you're simply taking the ideas of others.

What paranoid Catholics?  And what exactly is it that may be true? 

Selene

Quote from: Amo on Sun Jul 04, 2010 - 11:47:36
QuoteAnd this is coming from someone who believes that the Archangel Michael has the powers of resurrection.

QuoteAmo claims that Angels" have the power to resurrect and then complains that Catholics pray to the  Saints and Mary in heaven for their intercession!!!

I think no such thing. Unless of course God gives them that power.  Which power He gave also to some of the prophets of the old testament.  Of course it was God's power, not theirs.

1Thes 4:16 For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first:

Either the term archangel applies to Christ, or Christ gives this angel the power to resurrect the dead at His coming.  It was the archangel that raised the body of Moses also.  What do you think, God just wanted Moses' dead body?  No, but he was raised from the dead, and thus could appear alive to Christ and His apostles at the transfiguration.  Moses representing those who would be raised from the dead at Christ's coming, and Elijah representing those who would never see death.  

Angels are messengers, and no where in the Bible did God ever give an angel the power to resurrect the dead.  Christ is also not an Archangel.  He is God.  Just because He may have the voice of an Archangel does not mean that He is an Archangel.  Afterall, I have the voice of Whitney Houston, but I'm not Whitney Houston.   ::crackup::

Michael did not resurrect Moses.  He was protecting Moses' dead body from the devil.  The devil wanted to have sex with Moses' dead body.  There is NOTHING in the Bible that says that Michael resurrected Moses from the dead.  

As for Elijah, it doesn't matter that a whirlwind took him up, he never got to Heaven (God's kingdom) because Jesus said that no one went to Heaven.  The heaven that the Bible was referring to in regards to Elijah was the "sky."  You know.....the heaven that has the moon and the stars....that physical heaven.  Elijah died because as you go up further from the earth, the air gets thinner.  You pass out from lack of oxygen and then you die.  

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 21:54:52
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 21:47:34
Quote from: Amo on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 18:12:14
QuoteI'ts one of Amo's favourite ways of posting. He can't express his own thoughts so he posts great block of someone else's.

I'm not sure whether it is laziness, or he's trying to intimidate you, or he hopes to tie you up for hours trying to understand and reply to it.

Winsome knows exactly what they are about.  He made a false statement regarding someones apparent ignorance relating to history.  The quotes I listed contradict that statement. 

That maybe true but, without agreeing too much with the paranoid catholics, maybe you should try to condense your posts down to more specific piece. The way you do it makes it look like you're simply taking the ideas of others.

What paranoid Catholics?  And what exactly is it that may be true? 


I really need to just post certain things privately as it appears everything I post bears offense to at least someone.

Amo posted an obscenely large response in the defense of his beliefs. Honestly it kind of looked like he just copied and pasted something from someone else. Anyway. Macrina inquired on the meaning of the post and then Winsome made a comment implying that Amo was incapable of expressing his own thoughts and therefore uses the thoughts and ideals of others(which was very LightHammer-like in tone and persona). Amo then followed up by saying Winsome already knows the truth of the matter and has been corrected in the past on the falsehood of his posts. I then said that Amo may be right and Winsome may have been proven wrong but for the sake of us who were not apart of their older debates, he should shorten his position and be more specific.

By "paranoid catholics" I meant the ones who have bought into Avril's way of thinking and honestly believe I'm here to under mind their faith and not learn more about it. I'm sorry if that sparked a flame with you but in another thread Avril is insinuating that no one is responding because they believe as he does when it comes to my intentions.

So go ahead what did I say or do wrong this time?

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:06:31
Quote from: Amo on Sun Jul 04, 2010 - 11:47:36
QuoteAnd this is coming from someone who believes that the Archangel Michael has the powers of resurrection.

QuoteAmo claims that Angels" have the power to resurrect and then complains that Catholics pray to the  Saints and Mary in heaven for their intercession!!!

I think no such thing. Unless of course God gives them that power.  Which power He gave also to some of the prophets of the old testament.  Of course it was God's power, not theirs.

1Thes 4:16 For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first:

Either the term archangel applies to Christ, or Christ gives this angel the power to resurrect the dead at His coming.  It was the archangel that raised the body of Moses also.  What do you think, God just wanted Moses' dead body?  No, but he was raised from the dead, and thus could appear alive to Christ and His apostles at the transfiguration.  Moses representing those who would be raised from the dead at Christ's coming, and Elijah representing those who would never see death.  

Angels are messengers, and no where in the Bible did God ever give an angel the power to resurrect the dead.  Christ is also not an Archangel.  He is God.  Just because He may have the voice of an Archangel does not mean that He is an Archangel.  Afterall, I have the voice of Whitney Houston, but I'm not Whitney Houston.   ::crackup::

Michael did not resurrect Moses.  He was protecting Moses' dead body from the devil.  The devil wanted to have sex with Moses' dead body.  There is NOTHING in the Bible that says that Michael resurrected Moses from the dead.  

As for Elijah, it doesn't matter that a whirlwind took him up, he never got to Heaven (God's kingdom) because Jesus said that no one went to Heaven.  The heaven that the Bible was referring to in regards to Elijah was the "sky."  You know.....the heaven that has the moon and the stars....that physical heaven.  Elijah died because as you go up further from the earth, the air gets thinner.  You pass out from lack of oxygen and then you die.  


Whoa whoa there tiger.

Lets back track.

Lets skip the whole Christ being an archangel thing because you and me see eye to eye there.(Awkwardly enough)

But where did this idea of Elijah NOT ascending to the heaven of heavens come from?

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:09:05
I really need to just post certain things privately as it appears everything I post bears offense to at least someone.

Amo posted an obscenely large response in the defense of his beliefs. Honestly it kind of looked like he just copied and pasted something from someone else. Anyway. Macrina inquired on the meaning of the post and then Winsome made a comment implying that Amo was incapable of expressing his own thoughts and therefore uses the thoughts and ideals of others(which was very LightHammer-like in tone and persona). Amo then followed up by saying Winsome already knows the truth of the matter and has been corrected in the past on the falsehood of his posts. I then said that Amo may be right and Winsome may have been proven wrong but for the sake of us who were not apart of their older debates, he should shorten his position and be more specific.

By "paranoid catholics" I meant the ones who have bought into Avril's way of thinking and honestly believe I'm here to under mind their faith and not learn more about it. I'm sorry if that sparked a flame with you but in another thread Avril is insinuating that no one is responding because they believe as he does when it comes to my intentions.

So go ahead what did I say or do wrong this time?

There are many books written on Catholicsm if you are interested in learning about the Catholic religion.  You can read the book, and if you have any questions, then you can address them to a Catholic priest, a Catholic apologist, or on this forum board. 

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:16:27
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:09:05
I really need to just post certain things privately as it appears everything I post bears offense to at least someone.

Amo posted an obscenely large response in the defense of his beliefs. Honestly it kind of looked like he just copied and pasted something from someone else. Anyway. Macrina inquired on the meaning of the post and then Winsome made a comment implying that Amo was incapable of expressing his own thoughts and therefore uses the thoughts and ideals of others(which was very LightHammer-like in tone and persona). Amo then followed up by saying Winsome already knows the truth of the matter and has been corrected in the past on the falsehood of his posts. I then said that Amo may be right and Winsome may have been proven wrong but for the sake of us who were not apart of their older debates, he should shorten his position and be more specific.

By "paranoid catholics" I meant the ones who have bought into Avril's way of thinking and honestly believe I'm here to under mind their faith and not learn more about it. I'm sorry if that sparked a flame with you but in another thread Avril is insinuating that no one is responding because they believe as he does when it comes to my intentions.

So go ahead what did I say or do wrong this time?

There are many books written on Catholicsm if you are interested in learning about the Catholic religion.  You can read the book, and if you have any questions, then you can address them to a Catholic priest, a Catholic apologist, or on this forum board. 

Thank you. I had no clue there were publications over the Catholic faith.

I'm sorry but I prefer to converse with educated believers. I have found that you better understand a faith if you discuss with those who truly adhere to it in their everyday lives than in a book that is void of checks and balances to correct some of the errors that may have been made through the literature.

But once again thank you for your attempt.

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:12:06
But where did this idea of Elijah NOT ascending to the heaven of heavens come from?

John 3:13  And no man hath ascended into heaven, but he that descended from heaven, the Son of man who is in heaven.  

In 2 Kings 2:11, the word "heaven" in there is not meant to mean God's kingdom, because as Jesus said, no man has ascended into Heaven.  Elijah was taken up into the "visible" heaven....the sky.  

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:24:35
Thank you. I had no clue there were publications over the Catholic faith.

I'm sorry but I prefer to converse with educated believers. I have found that you better understand a faith if you discuss with those who truly adhere to it in their everyday lives than in a book that is void of checks and balances to correct some of the errors that may have been made through the literature.

But once again thank you for your attempt.

Our books are usually written by those practing the faith in their everyday lives.  There are books written by Catholic priests and Catholic theologians.

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:37:47
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:24:35
Thank you. I had no clue there were publications over the Catholic faith.

I'm sorry but I prefer to converse with educated believers. I have found that you better understand a faith if you discuss with those who truly adhere to it in their everyday lives than in a book that is void of checks and balances to correct some of the errors that may have been made through the literature.

But once again thank you for your attempt.

Our books are usually written by those practing the faith in their everyday lives.  There are books written by Catholic priests and Catholic theologians.

I understand Selene thank you but if its ok with you I would rather stick to learning from believers online and then comparing what they teach to the actual teachings that are written in the books I have here.

Thats kind of what I've been doing this whole time. All these topics I've started was a means to test something a catholic girl named Abby told me. "You will find that among the Catholic faith, we above any others are unified under not just one Name(Jesus Christ) but you official doctrine of that Name."

We met on a different site before it got shut down. I hate to admit it but she was literally the smartest Catholic I've ever debated next to that guy Ryan.

When I found this site I was still way too skeptical to catholicism so I stuck to the Theology Forum. But my ideology and unbiased positions, or as Avril would like to promote my "style", wasn't met with....lets just say open arms. So I was going to just leave the site when I saw an interesting on the Catholic Forum. Then I thought what the hey I might as well make it symmetrical. If the protestants are going to label me " a catholic in disguise" then I might as well post in the Catholic Forum until they label me "a hateful protestant". Then I can leave with a complete circle. 

LightHammer

#195
Quote from: Selene on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:37:47
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 22:24:35
Thank you. I had no clue there were publications over the Catholic faith.

I'm sorry but I prefer to converse with educated believers. I have found that you better understand a faith if you discuss with those who truly adhere to it in their everyday lives than in a book that is void of checks and balances to correct some of the errors that may have been made through the literature.

But once again thank you for your attempt.

Our books are usually written by those practing the faith in their everyday lives.  There are books written by Catholic priests and Catholic theologians.

I understand Selene thank you but if its ok with you I would rather stick to learning from believers online and then comparing what they teach to the actual teachings that are written in the books I have here.

Thats kind of what I've been doing this whole time. All these topics I've started was a means to test something a catholic girl named Abby told me. "You will find that among the Catholic faith, we above any others are unified under not just one Name(Jesus Christ) but of one official doctrine of that Name."

We met on a different site before it got shut down. I hate to admit it but she was literally the smartest Catholic I've ever debated next to that guy Ryan.

When I found this site I was still way too skeptical to catholicism so I stuck to the Theology Forum. But my ideology and unbiased positions, or as Avril would like to promote my "style", wasn't met with....lets just say open arms. So I was going to just leave the site when I saw an interesting on the Catholic Forum. Then I thought what the hey I might as well make it symmetrical. If the protestants are going to label me " a catholic in disguise" then I might as well post in the Catholic Forum until they label me "a hateful protestant". Then I can leave with a complete circle.  So I've been debating key topics and pricking at their ideology while comparing all of your responses to the books I have here and the online Catechism I was linked to.

I think that may be done with these people though. ::intherain::

Selene

Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 23:02:13
Thats kind of what I've been doing this whole time. All these topics I've started was a means to test something a catholic girl named Abby told me. "You will find that among the Catholic faith, we above any others are unified under not just one Name(Jesus Christ) but of one official doctrine of that Name."

That is true.  Our doctrines are in the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Canon Law of the Church.   A Catholic who goes against those doctrines is only putting himself/herself outside the Church.  Why would you want to test what Abby said?  Is your goal to learn the Catholic faith or is it to prove that Abby is wrong?  




stevehut

From my experience, most believers I meet (Cath and Prot alike) don't have a good understanding of the Bible or their own church doctrines.  Most Cath's I meet don't know the difference between the Immaculate Conception and the Virgin Birth, the former being one of the cornerstone doctrines of their religion.  So even when I happen to agree with them, it bothers me that they're blindly following a tradition they don't understand.

AvrilNYC

Quote from: stevehut on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:30:11
From my experience, most believers I meet (Cath and Prot alike) don't have a good understanding of the Bible or their own church doctrines.  Most Cath's I meet don't know the difference between the Immaculate Conception and the Virgin Birth, the former being one of the cornerstone doctrines of their religion.  So even when I happen to agree with them, it bothers me that they're blindly following a tradition they don't understand.

I don't think understanding the details of inter-denominational dogma differences is one of Jesus' commandments ::smile:: and it has nothing to do with Salvation.

What really makes the Catholic and Orthodox Churches different than Protentants is the faith in the Sacraments and Apostolic succession. The Eucharist (and the other sacraments) nourish us to help us grow in Christ within the Church.

As long as a Catholic (or Orthodox) has faith in (and participates in) the Sacraments and tries his/her best to keep Jesus' core commandemnts, he's a very good Catholic as far as I'm concerned

Josiah

Quote from: AvrilNYC on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:48:30


What really makes the Catholic and Orthodox Churches different than Protentants is the faith in the Sacraments and Apostolic succession. The Eucharist (and the other sacraments) nourish us to help us grow in Christ within the Church.

Of course, many Protestants are sacramental, too.   I'd invite you to not confuse the new, unique RCC embrace of the dogma of Transubstantiation with it now alone being sacramental; such is not the case.

I think your second comment is important.  What makes a Catholic "Catholic" is stated in the Catholic Catechism #87 (and foundational to nearly everything else there - including the book itself).   A good Catholic is one who accepts "with docility" whatever he/she is told to believe and do.   

QuoteAs long as a Catholic (or Orthodox) has faith in (and participates in) the Sacraments and tries his/her best to keep Jesus' core commandemnts, he's a very good Catholic as far as I'm concerned

Of course, this would have made Martin Luther a very good Catholic (I'm not sure I'd disagree).   But again, what makes one a "faithful" Catholic is that he/she exempts the RCC alone from any accountability or norming but rather, laying all that aside, just instead accepts whatever is taught/instrusted "with docility."   This was the point so much stressed to me in my Catholic days - docilic obedience and acceptance, exempting from norming, "just consider it right - and leave it at that" "just do it because the Church so says" as my Deacon once rather bluntly put it.  It's what makes a Catholic "good" or "faithful" Catholic.


Perhaps we could return to a discussion of the topic, however. 



Pax


- Josiah





.

winsome

Quote from: Josiah on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 10:03:35
I think your second comment is important.  What makes a Catholic "Catholic" is stated in the Catholic Catechism #87 (and foundational to nearly everything else there - including the book itself).   A good Catholic is one who accepts "with docility" whatever he/she is told to believe and do.  


Pax


- Josiah

.

Josiah,

You seem to have a problem with the Catechism #87:

Mindful of Christ's words to his apostles: "He who hears you, hears me", The faithful receive with docility the teachings and directives that their pastors give them in different forms.

I think your problem may lie in your understanding of what the Church means by docile here. You seem to be taking it as some sort of uncritical supineness. But I think this is not what the Church means.

Firstly the Catechism that you are quoting from is an English translation. The approved text is in Latin. In all translation there is a problem conveying the exact meaning across the languages. I'm not a Latin scholar so I shall have to rely on other sources for information. The word translated as docile is doliciter.

Firstly the Oxford English Dictionary says this about the origin of the word docile

C15 (in the sense 'apt or willing to learn'): from Latin docilis, from docere 'teach'.

So in the Latin has a meaning of being "willing to learn", "teachable."

I found this on a Latin to English Glossary of Church Latin
docilis -e, teachable, docile.  
Teachable means willing to learn as in the OED entymology.

Now if we change "docile" to "willingness to learn"  #87 reads
Mindful of Christ's words to his apostles: "He who hears you, hears me", The faithful receive with willingness to learn the teachings and directives that their pastors give them in different forms.

Do you have a problem with that?

LightHammer

Quote from: Selene on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:21:43
Quote from: LightHammer on Tue Jul 06, 2010 - 23:02:13
Thats kind of what I've been doing this whole time. All these topics I've started was a means to test something a catholic girl named Abby told me. "You will find that among the Catholic faith, we above any others are unified under not just one Name(Jesus Christ) but of one official doctrine of that Name."

That is true.  Our doctrines are in the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the Canon Law of the Church.   A Catholic who goes against those doctrines is only putting himself/herself outside the Church.  Why would you want to test what Abby said?  Is your goal to learn the Catholic faith or is it to prove that Abby is wrong?  





I'm not going to lie it was kind of both when she first told me this on the other site but after I went head to head with the chaos of every strange wind and doctrine found in the Theology Forum, I was hoping that it was true and that Christianity and the Truth was not subject to disorganization.

By the time I made my first response in the Catholic Forum I was hoping that what she said was fact and that there was a place where Truth was concrete and not just subject to the whims of every random believer who believes they have been given revelation that the rest f the world hasn't.

desertknight

Quote from: AvrilNYC on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:48:30
Quote from: stevehut on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:30:11
From my experience, most believers I meet (Cath and Prot alike) don't have a good understanding of the Bible or their own church doctrines.  Most Cath's I meet don't know the difference between the Immaculate Conception and the Virgin Birth, the former being one of the cornerstone doctrines of their religion.  So even when I happen to agree with them, it bothers me that they're blindly following a tradition they don't understand.

I don't think understanding the details of inter-denominational dogma differences is one of Jesus' commandments ::smile:: and it has nothing to do with Salvation.

What really makes the Catholic and Orthodox Churches different than Protentants is the faith in the Sacraments and Apostolic succession. The Eucharist (and the other sacraments) nourish us to help us grow in Christ within the Church.

As long as a Catholic (or Orthodox) has faith in (and participates in) the Sacraments and tries his/her best to keep Jesus' core commandemnts, he's a very good Catholic as far as I'm concerned

That is wise and quite true.  One does not need a degree in theology to be a good Catholic.  Recite the Apostles Creed with basic understanding and conviction, obey the commandments and honor proper authority, receive the graces of the sacraments, especially Holy Eucharist, and above all....Love God and your neighbour! 

stevehut

Quote from: AvrilNYC on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:48:30
1- I don't think understanding the details of inter-denominational dogma differences is one of Jesus' commandments

2- As long as a Catholic (or Orthodox) has faith in (and participates in) the Sacraments and tries his/her best to keep Jesus' core commandemnts, he's a very good Catholic as far as I'm concerned

1- I don't think so either.  My point was that most people don't really study their own religion.

2- Sounds like a very low standard to me.   ::lookaround::  Conformity is quite easy, but I don't think God is impressed when we just go through the motions.

stevehut

 ::lookaround::  Hmmm...

Too bad the apostles didn't have a Catechism.  Perhaps they could have been good saved Christians, too.

LightHammer

Quote from: stevehut on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 13:59:10
Quote from: AvrilNYC on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:48:30
1- I don't think understanding the details of inter-denominational dogma differences is one of Jesus' commandments

2- As long as a Catholic (or Orthodox) has faith in (and participates in) the Sacraments and tries his/her best to keep Jesus' core commandemnts, he's a very good Catholic as far as I'm concerned

1- I don't think so either.  My point was that most people don't really study their own religion.

2- Sounds like a very low standard to me.   ::lookaround::  Conformity is quite easy, but I don't think God is impressed when we just go through the motions.


Maybe you need to better understand the catholic position when it comes to the Sacraments. They don't view them as symbolic as most protestants do. They are at the core of their faith and practices.


QuoteLook around  Hmmm...

Too bad the apostles didn't have a Catechism.  Perhaps they could have been good saved Christians, too.

No catholic would ever claim what you're implying. If you're going to try and discredit someone's faith then at least do it on unbiased grounds. Don't imply that they believe something they don't.

stevehut

Quote from: LightHammer on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 14:36:44
1- They don't view them as symbolic as most protestants do. They are at the core of their faith and practices.

2- If you're going to try and discredit someone's faith then at least do it on unbiased grounds.

1- Of course.  As an ex-Catholic, I'm aware of that.

2- Not trying to discredit anyone or anything.  You can do or believe anything you want, it's a free country. I just believe the church's teachings are inconsistent.  The church teaches that genuine Christianity is defined by the Catechism, something the apostles didn't have.    They didn't teach seven sacraments, and they didn't pray the Rosary, etc.   

If this is the case (and it is), then I can only conclude that they weren't true Christians.  Or am I missing something...??

AvrilNYC

Quote from: stevehut on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 13:59:10
Quote from: AvrilNYC on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 09:48:30
1- I don't think understanding the details of inter-denominational dogma differences is one of Jesus' commandments

2- As long as a Catholic (or Orthodox) has faith in (and participates in) the Sacraments and tries his/her best to keep Jesus' core commandemnts, he's a very good Catholic as far as I'm concerned

1- I don't think so either.  My point was that most people don't really study their own religion.

2- Sounds like a very low standard to me.   ::lookaround::  Conformity is quite easy, but I don't think God is impressed when we just go through the motions.

keeping Jesus' commandments is a low standard?? Since when trying to keep our Lord'd commandments and actively participating in His body (the Church) "low"?? read my post again, either you did not understand it, or you just feel that you have to disagree at all costs

AvrilNYC

Quote from: stevehut on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 14:45:25
Quote from: LightHammer on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 14:36:44
1- They don't view them as symbolic as most protestants do. They are at the core of their faith and practices.

2- If you're going to try and discredit someone's faith then at least do it on unbiased grounds.

1- Of course.  As an ex-Catholic, I'm aware of that.

2- Not trying to discredit anyone or anything.  You can do or believe anything you want, it's a free country. I just believe the church's teachings are inconsistent.  The church teaches that genuine Christianity is defined by the Catechism, something the apostles didn't have.    They didn't teach seven sacraments, and they didn't pray the Rosary, etc.   

If this is the case (and it is), then I can only conclude that they weren't true Christians.  Or am I missing something...??

The Apostles and Jesus taught and practiced the 7 sacraments. All the sacraments were initiated by Jesus and the Apostles and there's scriptural proof for them. If you look at the theology forum, I just provided biblical support for the sacrament of baptism.

stevehut

Quote from: AvrilNYC on Wed Jul 07, 2010 - 14:45:39
keeping Jesus' commandments is a low standard?? Since when trying to keep our Lord'd commandments and actively participating in His body (the Church) "low"?? read my post again, either you did not understand it, or you just feel that you have to disagree at all costs

Look again, Avril, at the post that I responded to.   ::whistle::  You described a person who goes through the motions of religion.  No faith or virtue required there.

+-Recent Topics

Hebrews 12:11, Obedience by pppp
Today at 09:20:37

Proverbs 3:5-6, trust by pppp
Today at 08:33:20

Proverbs 4:23 by pppp
Yesterday at 14:42:57

John 20:22 by pppp
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 10:13:22

Roman politics by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:19:48

What does a Christian do concerning immigrants, and obeying the law of the land? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 07:10:32

American Socialism? by Amo
Mon Nov 16, 2026 - 06:53:38

1 Timothy 6:17 by pppp
Sun Nov 15, 2026 - 12:56:12

SDA Issues by Amo
Sat Nov 14, 2026 - 17:37:59

Creation scientists by Amo
Fri Nov 13, 2026 - 19:17:32

Powered by EzPortal